Guest guest Posted December 23, 2010 Report Posted December 23, 2010 Ear and Hearing - February, 2011 Source, order full text: http://tinyurl.com/2c2q7zk " no significant difference between bimodal and bilateral cochlear implant users " -------------------------- Comparison of Bimodal and Bilateral Cochlear Implant Users on Speech Recognition With Competing Talker, Music Perception, Affective Prosody Discrimination, and Talker Identification Cullington, Helen E.; Zeng, Fan-Gang Abstract Objectives: Despite excellent performance in speech recognition in quiet, most cochlear implant users have great difficulty with speech recognition in noise, music perception, identifying tone of voice, and discriminating different talkers. This may be partly due to the pitch coding in cochlear implant speech processing. Most current speech processing strategies use only the envelope information; the temporal fine structure is discarded. One way to improve electric pitch perception is to use residual acoustic hearing via a hearing aid on the nonimplanted ear (bimodal hearing). This study aimed to test the hypothesis that bimodal users would perform better than bilateral cochlear implant users on tasks requiring good pitch perception. Design: Four pitch-related tasks were used. 1. Hearing in Noise Test (HINT) sentences spoken by a male talker with a competing female, male, or child talker. 2. Montreal Battery of Evaluation of Amusia. This is a music test with six subtests examining pitch, rhythm and timing perception, and musical memory. 3. Aprosodia Battery. This has five subtests evaluating aspects of affective prosody and recognition of sarcasm. 4. Talker identification using vowels spoken by 10 different talkers (three men, three women, two boys, and two girls). Bilateral cochlear implant users were chosen as the comparison group. Thirteen bimodal and 13 bilateral adult cochlear implant users were recruited; all had good speech perception in quiet. Results: There were no significant differences between the mean scores of the bimodal and bilateral groups on any of the tests, although the bimodal group did perform better than the bilateral group on almost all tests. Performance on the different pitch-related tasks was not correlated, meaning that if a subject performed one task well they would not necessarily perform well on another. The correlation between the bimodal users' hearing threshold levels in the aided ear and their performance on these tasks was weak. Conclusions: Although the bimodal cochlear implant group performed better than the bilateral group on most parts of the four pitch-related tests, the differences were not statistically significant. The lack of correlation between test results shows that the tasks used are not simply providing a measure of pitch ability. Even if the bimodal users have better pitch perception, the real-world tasks used are reflecting more diverse skills than pitch. This research adds to the existing speech perception, language, and localization studies that show no significant difference between bimodal and bilateral cochlear implant users. Quote
Guest guest Posted December 24, 2010 Report Posted December 24, 2010 So, I am bimodal, with poor hearing in the aid ear, as are most of us with an implant. I doubt this study would apply to most of us! My aid ear is about 24% speech recognition. Bob Sent from my iPad Sent from my iPad Quote
Guest guest Posted December 24, 2010 Report Posted December 24, 2010 I also wear an implant and a hearing aid and a CI. My speech recognition is 18% in understanding words with the hearing aid. > > So, I am bimodal, with poor hearing in the aid ear, as are most of us with an implant. I doubt this study would apply to most of us! My aid ear is about 24% speech recognition. > Bob > > Sent from my iPad > > Sent from my iPad > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 Thats an interesting study BOB and it adds to what I have always thought as stupid and short sighted advice given by the audiologists that ask implantees NOT to use their hearing aid in their other ear. I've always thought that it was terrible advice and these tests seem to support the facts that using a hearing aid in the non implanted ear, is of great benefit. Thank goodness that the wisdom today, is seeing more and more audiologists advise use of the hearing aid in the other ear. My other ear with just the hearing aid is pretty much useless on its own, but it is a tremendous help when coupled with my Freedom processor. Ted F. > > Ear and Hearing - February, 2011 > > Source, order full text: http://tinyurl.com/2c2q7zk > > " no significant difference between bimodal and bilateral cochlear implant > users " > > -------------------------- > > Comparison of Bimodal and Bilateral Cochlear Implant Users on Speech > Recognition With Competing Talker, Music Perception, Affective Prosody > Discrimination, and Talker Identification > > Cullington, Helen E.; Zeng, Fan-Gang > > > Abstract > > > Objectives: Despite excellent performance in speech recognition in quiet, > most cochlear implant users have great difficulty with speech recognition in > noise, music perception, identifying tone of voice, and discriminating > different talkers. This may be partly due to the pitch coding in cochlear > implant speech processing. Most current speech processing strategies use > only the envelope information; the temporal fine structure is discarded. One > way to improve electric pitch perception is to use residual acoustic hearing > via a hearing aid on the nonimplanted ear (bimodal hearing). This study > aimed to test the hypothesis that bimodal users would perform better than > bilateral cochlear implant users on tasks requiring good pitch perception. > > Design: Four pitch-related tasks were used. > > 1. Hearing in Noise Test (HINT) sentences spoken by a male talker with a > competing female, male, or child talker. > > 2. Montreal Battery of Evaluation of Amusia. This is a music test with six > subtests examining pitch, rhythm and timing perception, and musical memory. > > 3. Aprosodia Battery. This has five subtests evaluating aspects of affective > prosody and recognition of sarcasm. > > 4. Talker identification using vowels spoken by 10 different talkers (three > men, three women, two boys, and two girls). > > Bilateral cochlear implant users were chosen as the comparison group. > Thirteen bimodal and 13 bilateral adult cochlear implant users were > recruited; all had good speech perception in quiet. > > Results: There were no significant differences between the mean scores of > the bimodal and bilateral groups on any of the tests, although the bimodal > group did perform better than the bilateral group on almost all tests. > Performance on the different pitch-related tasks was not correlated, meaning > that if a subject performed one task well they would not necessarily perform > well on another. The correlation between the bimodal users' hearing > threshold levels in the aided ear and their performance on these tasks was > weak. > > Conclusions: Although the bimodal cochlear implant group performed better > than the bilateral group on most parts of the four pitch-related tests, the > differences were not statistically significant. The lack of correlation > between test results shows that the tasks used are not simply providing a > measure of pitch ability. Even if the bimodal users have better pitch > perception, the real-world tasks used are reflecting more diverse skills > than pitch. This research adds to the existing speech perception, language, > and localization studies that show no significant difference between bimodal > and bilateral cochlear implant users. > > > > > > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.