Guest guest Posted August 13, 2010 Report Posted August 13, 2010 I just joined due to recommendation from menieres.org site and have a few questions. I was diagnosed initially in 2004 with bilateral menieres.Late that year or early 2005 I had lost all hearing in my right ear. My doctor and I tried all the methods going from least destructive to finally going through with the Labyrinthectomy in May of 2008. I was symptom vertigo free for until this past May when it <menieres> reared its ugly head again. I have the BAHA on the right side which I received in March which I must say seems like a miracle after the loss of the right. With all that said I am faced with losing my remaining hearing in my left and without that ofcourse it is my understanding that the BAHA will cease to work as the left will not be able to interpet sound to send. Am I correct in this assumption or totally off? My next question is for anyone with similar situation. When I lose all hearing in the remaining ear is it still possible to be a candidate for the Cochlear or am I grasping at straws. I am on the fence waffling over what to do next and am looking for any information that I can glean as to if I can get the CI and get back to a normal life or something close to it. I apologize in advance for the wall of text. Quote
Guest guest Posted August 13, 2010 Report Posted August 13, 2010 I'm a bilateral Menieres dude who was completely deafened in 2003 in both ears. I do not know about the BAHA but I do not understand why losing hearing on one side would cause the other to cease to work. I'd sure talk to my doctor about that to set my mind at ease. I'm now bilaterally implanted with CI's and when I went totally deaf the decision was really easy to make--I had nothing to lose. If I'd had some usable hearing, I would have been less gung-ho for the operation. Please ask a doctor familiar with CI's your questions. My CI's are great--not perfect--just great. Is it possible? I just joined due to recommendation from menieres.org site and have a few questions. I was diagnosed initially in 2004 with bilateral menieres.Late that year or early 2005 I had lost all hearing in my right ear. My doctor and I tried all the methods going from least destructive to finally going through with the Labyrinthectomy in May of 2008. I was symptom vertigo free for until this past May when it <menieres> reared its ugly head again. I have the BAHA on the right side which I received in March which I must say seems like a miracle after the loss of the right. With all that said I am faced with losing my remaining hearing in my left and without that ofcourse it is my understanding that the BAHA will cease to work as the left will not be able to interpet sound to send. Am I correct in this assumption or totally off? My next question is for anyone with similar situation. When I lose all hearing in the remaining ear is it still possible to be a candidate for the Cochlear or am I grasping at straws. I am on the fence waffling over what to do next and am looking for any information that I can glean as to if I can get the CI and get back to a normal life or something close to it. I apologize in advance for the wall of text. Quote
Guest guest Posted August 13, 2010 Report Posted August 13, 2010 the BAHA is for people who have good single sided hearing and works on bone conduction from that good ear. That said, if the good ear looses it's hearing, the BAHA can no longer give the results. It works very differently from a CI whereas if the better ear goes, one can still hear on the implanted side. Happy Hearing! Carol Boca Raton, FL Cochlear America Nucleus 24C - left ear - Sprint 12/11/01 then 3G then upgraded to Freedom on 2/19/08 Cochlear America Freedom right ear -implanted 3/01/06 - activated 4/06/06 From: halfencer@... Sent: Friday, August 13, 2010 10:05 PM Subject: Re: Is it possible? I'm a bilateral Menieres dude who was completely deafened in 2003 in both ears. I do not know about the BAHA but I do not understand why losing hearing on one side would cause the other to cease to work. I'd sure talk to my doctor about that to set my mind at ease. I'm now bilaterally implanted with CI's and when I went totally deaf the decision was really easy to make--I had nothing to lose. If I'd had some usable hearing, I would have been less gung-ho for the operation. Please ask a doctor familiar with CI's your questions. My CI's are great--not perfect--just great. Is it possible? I just joined due to recommendation from menieres.org site and have a few questions. I was diagnosed initially in 2004 with bilateral menieres.Late that year or early 2005 I had lost all hearing in my right ear. My doctor and I tried all the methods going from least destructive to finally going through with the Labyrinthectomy in May of 2008. I was symptom vertigo free for until this past May when it <menieres> reared its ugly head again. I have the BAHA on the right side which I received in March which I must say seems like a miracle after the loss of the right. With all that said I am faced with losing my remaining hearing in my left and without that ofcourse it is my understanding that the BAHA will cease to work as the left will not be able to interpet sound to send. Am I correct in this assumption or totally off? My next question is for anyone with similar situation. When I lose all hearing in the remaining ear is it still possible to be a candidate for the Cochlear or am I grasping at straws. I am on the fence waffling over what to do next and am looking for any information that I can glean as to if I can get the CI and get back to a normal life or something close to it. I apologize in advance for the wall of text. Quote
Guest guest Posted August 14, 2010 Report Posted August 14, 2010 Thank you for the replies. I have/had 80% left in my left with total loss on right last audiology exam. I have experienced a noticeable drop on my good side though since the attacks have came back.I have an appointment with my Neurotologist on Monday so I guess I will be able to explore my options at that time. I am just anxious and wanted more knowledge from those that are familiar with or have similar experience. Thank you again. > > the BAHA is for people who have good single sided hearing and works on bone conduction from that good ear. That said, if the good ear looses it's hearing, the BAHA can no longer give the results. > It works very differently from a CI whereas if the better ear goes, one can still hear on the implanted side. > > Happy Hearing! > Carol > Boca Raton, FL > Cochlear America Nucleus 24C - left ear - Sprint 12/11/01 then 3G then upgraded to Freedom on 2/19/08 > Cochlear America Freedom right ear -implanted 3/01/06 - activated 4/06/06 > > > From: halfencer@... > Sent: Friday, August 13, 2010 10:05 PM > > Subject: Re: Is it possible? > > > > > I'm a bilateral Menieres dude who was completely deafened in 2003 in both ears. I do not know about the BAHA but I do not understand why losing hearing on one side would cause the other to cease to work. I'd sure talk to my doctor about that to set my mind at ease. I'm now bilaterally implanted with CI's and when I went totally deaf the decision was really easy to make--I had nothing to lose. If I'd had some usable hearing, I would have been less gung-ho for the operation. > > Please ask a doctor familiar with CI's your questions. My CI's are great--not perfect--just great. > > Is it possible? > > I just joined due to recommendation from menieres.org site and have a few questions. I was diagnosed initially in 2004 with bilateral menieres.Late that year or early 2005 I had lost all hearing in my right ear. My doctor and I tried all the methods going from least destructive to finally going through with the Labyrinthectomy in May of 2008. I was symptom vertigo free for until this past May when it <menieres> reared its ugly head again. I have the BAHA on the right side which I received in March which I must say seems like a miracle after the loss of the right. With all that said I am faced with losing my remaining hearing in my left and without that ofcourse it is my understanding that the BAHA will cease to work as the left will not be able to interpet sound to send. Am I correct in this assumption or totally off? > > My next question is for anyone with similar situation. When I lose all hearing in the remaining ear is it still possible to be a candidate for the Cochlear or am I grasping at straws. I am on the fence waffling over what to do next and am looking for any information that I can glean as to if I can get the CI and get back to a normal life or something close to it. I apologize in advance for the wall of text. > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 15, 2010 Report Posted August 15, 2010 Hi and welcome, I have bilateral Meniere's and bilateral cochlear implants (CIs). Both CIs work very well for me. As someone else mentioned, the BAHA works via bone conduction. If you Meniere's in that ear causes progressive hearing loss the BAHA may eventually not work for you. Assuming no other problems in that ear a CI should work. Also, I understand some surgeons are now doing a modified Labyrinthectomy where they don't remove the cochlea incase a CI is needed in the future. You should check with your surgeon and see if he left your cochlea intact. Best regards, Jim > > I just joined due to recommendation from menieres.org site and have a few questions. I was diagnosed initially in 2004 with bilateral menieres.Late that year or early 2005 I had lost all hearing in my right ear. My doctor and I tried all the methods going from least destructive to finally going through with the Labyrinthectomy in May of 2008. I was symptom vertigo free for until this past May when it <menieres> reared its ugly head again. I have the BAHA on the right side which I received in March which I must say seems like a miracle after the loss of the right. With all that said I am faced with losing my remaining hearing in my left and without that ofcourse it is my understanding that the BAHA will cease to work as the left will not be able to interpet sound to send. Am I correct in this assumption or totally off? > > My next question is for anyone with similar situation. When I lose all hearing in the remaining ear is it still possible to be a candidate for the Cochlear or am I grasping at straws. I am on the fence waffling over what to do next and am looking for any information that I can glean as to if I can get the CI and get back to a normal life or something close to it. I apologize in advance for the wall of text. > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.