Guest guest Posted September 12, 2003 Report Posted September 12, 2003 Sue, That is an education for me. I never heard about Leptin. I have read about the " thrifty gene " . That sounds more like me. My weight problems started in high school when I started fad diets, fasting, and skipping meals to lose weight. Eventually I became ravenous and would binge eat. My thrifty body saved up every calorie from those binges and saved it for later, in case of fire, famine, or flood I suppose. doesn't have the thrifty gene. If he doesn't eat every 4 hours or so he gets irritable, lackluster and his eyes glass over a bit. (Then he wolfs down 3 bacon cheeseburgers with a Pepsi and he's fine.) I can easily go 7-8 hours without eating but after that--watch out! I heard one theory batted around that overfat may be related to a virus. That sort of died down. Last I heard they were developing some hormone shot. My question is this: if a medical cure for obesity were found, would our doctors administer it in the interest of our good health? Or would a medical cure be too devastating to industry? So many people get rich off of us. Everyone from the diet and exercise peddlers to the health care providers who replace our knees, graft our arteries, and monitor our blood sugars. Kim >From: " Sue in NJ " <susang@...> >Reply-100-plus > " ~~100-plus " <100-plus > >Subject: Always Hungry >Date: Thu, 11 Sep 2003 09:30:23 -0400 > _________________________________________________________________ Use custom emotions -- try MSN Messenger 6.0! http://www.msnmessenger-download.com/tracking/reach_emoticon > I think I hear you saying that when you eat on plan, you feel hungry all the > time for at least two months? She's not the only one. In fact, studies have found that people like me, hungry and overweight since birth, have always had this problem, that no matter how much we eat - whether it's 10 cups of leafy vegetables or 4 cups of ice cream - we're physically hungry, with the same growling stomach and cramps as if we hadn't eaten in hours, and the only time we stop eating is when we eat so much we feel like we're about to burst. Last year that amazing protein in our genes leptin was discovered responsible for this, and that adding leptin to a mouse's food made them stop eating after a small amount. Unfortunately, this didn't work in human studies. It turns out we have enough of it, 4 times as much as we need, in fact, but it just doesn't work right, like people with insulin resistance have enough insulin, the body just doesn't use it the right way. http://www.weight.com/Leptin.html If scientists *could* formulate that " magic pill " that will let our bodies know when it's had enough to eat, that would be the end of obesity. Unfortunately, that seems to be a long way off. So in the meantime, we go on calorie restricted, portion controlled diets, go against evolution and tell our bodies it *can't* have the food it craves, and hope our bodies don't rebel by going into starvation mode. And we stay hungry. > Have you tried increasing fiber? Those six > servings of vegetables and four servings of fruit are quite bulky and I > think help with the hunger. 6 servings is only 3 cups cooked or one big salad. I don't know about Ann, but I can do *double* that in one meal! The cooked veggies AND the salad. AND a cup or 2 of nice and fiber-filled brown rice to go with it. And still be hungry when I'm finished eating. > That would be extremely difficult for me--hunger pangs for weeks and weeks. You and 95% of all the dieters out there, which is why there's such a high failure rate in all weight loss plans. > How do you know you are getting *enough* food? How, indeed. Any " food plan " already goes against a person's natural appetite and instincts. One that greatly restricts the amount of food we eat just messes up out natural instincts, our natural hunger drive. We no longer *know* what our real needs are. If we want to lose weight, we have to follow a strict eating plan that is suitable for us, never veering, and staying hungry. tells us what calorie card to use; Sugar Busters says to eat only foods that fit the program and fit on one plate. Other plans have other restrictions. One thing the McDougall plans promise is that we can eat all we want, eat to satisfaction, and still lose weight. Well, I'm one of many who have proved the good doctor wrong. Even on his Maximum Weight Loss Plan, the one that has not only the vegan foods & fat restrictions of his regular plan but also doesn't allow any higher fat or processed foods, such as tofu, nuts, bread, pasta, olives, etc., so about the only things that *can* be eaten are whole grains, beans & legumes (only a cup a day), and most vegetables. For many of us, we *still* have to restrict the amounts of potatoes and brown rice if we want to lose weight, something that Dr. McDougall says *not* to do because we need those foods to feel full, for the fiber and bulk they provide. If we *don't* eat those foods " to satisfaction " we'll fail because we'll still be hungry. And, on a plan that allows us to " eat to full, eat to satisfaction, " we do go hungry if we want to lose weight. What was the point of all this? For many of us, it's this: If you want to lose weight, you have to go against your instinct, ignore the signals your body is giving you, and go hungry. And hope you don't lose your mind before you lose the pounds. To unsubscribe DO NOT send a message to the list.Please click on this link and unsubscribe: 100-plus/join Quote
Guest guest Posted February 28, 2006 Report Posted February 28, 2006 Were you doing BFL while nursing? If so it makes sense you were hungry! It takes a lot of energy, so you would have to eat bigger portions. I know the book says not to count and weigh and stuff, but if you are not able to find a balance right off maybe you should make use of a food tracker like fit day. Set yourself a reasonable calorie goal, and I don't know your stats, but if you go to hussman.com you can use his formula to figure up your base rate. Split those calories 40/40/20 between carb/protein/fat. After a while you will start to be able to guage the portions. You should not " always be hungry " on BFL, so the odds are that you were cutting yourself too low. Did that help or did I just confuse you more? I'm sleepy...off to finsish some homework then go to sleep. Barbara Quote
Guest guest Posted February 28, 2006 Report Posted February 28, 2006 It's just a matter of making your portions a little bigger or choosing more calorie dense foods when you're hungrier. For example a cup of pasta and a cup of strawberries are both authorized and both roughly the size of a fist, but there's 220 calories in the pasta and only 46 calories in the berries. A chicken breast, a serving of pasta, and a big salad will leave you satisfied for hours, but a couple of turkey slices and a few grapes might have you looking for another meal an hour later. If you really look at the bread and the tuna, the portion is probably fine. If you grab the bread slices and squash them into a ball (either literally or just visually), I'm sure it's fist-sized or smaller. And if you dump the tuna out on a plate and shape it, I'll bet it's about the size of your palm. :-) Remember, steak, potatoes, pasta, beans, oats, six egg white omelets, and GIANT salads are filling. Berries, seafood, rice cakes, shakes and bars - not so much. You should not be starving this plan. It's normal to start feeling a little hungry 2-3 hours after your last meal, and as soon as you feel hungry you should eat. If you're ravenous an hour after a meal, you know you need to make the portions bigger or choose more satisfying foods. If you're still not hungry 4 hours after a meal, then you know you made it too big. You should never feel really hungry or really full on BFL. Most of the time you should walk around feeling just right. Also, make sure you're getting enough healthy fat in your diet, maybe even supplement with flax oil or Udo's. Fat really helps you to feel satisfied and to reduce hunger and cravings. A little avocado here and a few nuts there make a big difference. If you drop your fat intake too low, you'll be starving. On 2/27/06, jennicamama <jennicamama@...> wrote: > Hi! I am Jennica and going to start body for life next week!! I am > feeling a little overwhelmed and nervous about sticking to the diet > part. I have done Body for Life 2 times before--once after each > child--and the first time I did it right and got right back into > shape, but was hungry the whole time. The second time I gave up > because I was even hungrier the whole time. I am just finishing > weaning my third baby and I am committed to doing it right. Any > thoughts on how to keep from being hungry? I get so confused because > he says to use your palm and fist as portion sizes and yet 2 slices of > bread and a can of tuna (for example) are way bigger than my palm and > fist--but I can't imagine eating less than that!!! > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 28, 2006 Report Posted February 28, 2006 I agree. Oatmeal is very filling. I love the chocolate oatmeal in the EFL cookbook. I also like oatmeal w/ cottage cheese. The EFL pancakes are very good too. Make sure your portions are big enough and that you are eating every 2 1/2 to 3 hours. The shakes are filling and so is cottage cheese and an apple. Laurie Marrelli <laurie@...> wrote: Hi Jennica, One thing I do is start off my day with something like oatmeal with protein or egg whites in it. If I do that I almost have to make myself eat because it¹s so filling. I¹ve even reduced my oatmeal to 1/4 cup because I was full too long. Sometimes I¹ll start off with something more lunch like such as a turkey sandwich on light whole wheat bread. If I start off hungry I feel like it¹s hard to catch up and I have this feeling that I want to shovel food into my mouth which is very counter-productive Hope that helps, Laurie & shy; San Diego On 2/27/06 6:28 PM, " jennicamama " <jennicamama@...> wrote: > Hi! I am Jennica and going to start body for life next week!! I am > feeling a little overwhelmed and nervous about sticking to the diet > part. I have done Body for Life 2 times before--once after each > child--and the first time I did it right and got right back into > shape, but was hungry the whole time. The second time I gave up > because I was even hungrier the whole time. I am just finishing > weaning my third baby and I am committed to doing it right. Any > thoughts on how to keep from being hungry? I get so confused because > he says to use your palm and fist as portion sizes and yet 2 slices of > bread and a can of tuna (for example) are way bigger than my palm and > fist--but I can't imagine eating less than that!!! > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 19, 2006 Report Posted March 19, 2006 Etana, thanks for the concern. I don't think I was clear. I am not " always hungry " in an unsatisfied way. I've been doing BFL for almost 2-years and I've had a lot of success and I have never felt deprived. Believe me, I eat more than enough to keep up with my intense workouts. I learned a long time ago that in order to work out like a maniac, you have to eat a lot of good food. I just meant that, even if I have just eaten a great, well balanced meal, I could still eat more. I'm just a bottomless pit. I truly eat like a football player. I wrote my post to address the diet soda issue. Simply put, I'm less likely to eat snacky stuff at work or eat out of boredom if I drink diet soda. Thanks though. > > To " Ruth " <FairyDogmother@...> > > >I have never found that they stimulate my appetite. But then, I'm > always hungry... I wish I could blame diet soda, > > I don't think you should " always be hungry " on this food plan. Could > you let us know how much protein you are eating; perhaps a sample food > day? I found as soon as I added protein to each meal, instead of living > on processed flour and vegies, my hunger completely was satisfied, > unless it's past meal time. > > Etana > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 20, 2006 Report Posted March 20, 2006 I'm kind of like that too. I could always eat more. The portion sizes are small with BFL. I don't even like the feeling of stomach fullness any more. If we go to a restaurant I'll stop eating way before I feel full. But I could always eat more. It's the whole idea of eating deliberately instead of incidentally(or recreationally) that keeps it all in check. Stasia > > > > To " Ruth " <FairyDogmother@> > > > > >I have never found that they stimulate my appetite. But then, I'm > > always hungry... I wish I could blame diet soda, > > > > I don't think you should " always be hungry " on this food plan. > Could > > you let us know how much protein you are eating; perhaps a sample > food > > day? I found as soon as I added protein to each meal, instead of > living > > on processed flour and vegies, my hunger completely was satisfied, > > unless it's past meal time. > > > > Etana > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 3, 2010 Report Posted April 3, 2010 It will go away--its called "head hunger" I am 2 years out this May 21 and sometimes still get it but it doesnt last--Good Luck--From: kiheisurfs <t_y_kahn@...>Subject: Always Hungry Date: Friday, April 2, 2010, 5:33 PM I had my sleeve done last Friday and I am constantly hungry? I am getting the right amount of protein and water. Has anyone else experianced this? Does it go away? I thought that the hunger would diminish with this surgery. I have 2 protein shakes a day and broth..Sometimes some sugar free jello. Quote
Guest guest Posted April 3, 2010 Report Posted April 3, 2010 It may also be acid!MarilouDr. AcevesVSG~February 5, 2010 On Apr 3, 2010, at 8:46 AM, Ron Waggoner wrote:It will go away--its called "head hunger" I am 2 years out this May 21 and sometimes still get it but it doesnt last--Good Luck--From: kiheisurfs <t_y_kahn >Subject: Always Hungry Date: Friday, April 2, 2010, 5:33 PM I had my sleeve done last Friday and I am constantly hungry? I am getting the right amount of protein and water. Has anyone else experianced this? Does it go away? I thought that the hunger would diminish with this surgery. I have 2 protein shakes a day and broth..Sometimes some sugar free jello. Quote
Guest guest Posted April 3, 2010 Report Posted April 3, 2010 Thanks! I have heard of that but I did not know you could feel it in your stomach. Mine constantly grumbles just like it used to do when I was hungry but now it goes all day. I take my Nexium everyday so I doubt it is that. Good to hear it will go away because it is driving me crazy. Quote
Guest guest Posted April 3, 2010 Report Posted April 3, 2010 You aren't feeling real hunger--It is what we call "head hunger" You think you are hungry, and it has to do with emotional feeling not actual hunger. So you have to learn to talk to yourself through this and work your way around it. Drink some water or water with crystal light in it. Decaf Tea or coffee. We all have the "head hunger" thing. I just use to have to ask my self, am I really hungry or do I just think I am and so I want to eat because of how I use to always graze. If you are a grazer, then steam some veggies and have them around and when you THINK you are hungry then have them. This is one of the hardest things to learn to recognize. I hope that helps. Others will tell you we deal with head hunger all the time! I now have to remind myself to eat if I am busy doing something. It does get better, but you have to be in control of this feelings. Suzanne In a message dated 4/2/2010 11:25:04 P.M. Pacific Daylight Time, t_y_kahn@... writes: I had my sleeve done last Friday and I am constantly hungry? I am getting the right amount of protein and water. Has anyone else experianced this? Does it go away? I thought that the hunger would diminish with this surgery. I have 2 protein shakes a day and broth..Sometimes some sugar free jello. Quote
Guest guest Posted April 3, 2010 Report Posted April 3, 2010 For me I found that the Nexium really didn't work that well. So if you feel like it is acid reflux you may want to try OTC Prilosec. That worked much better for me. And because I have insurance, my doctor prescribes it for me and I get the generic Prilosec and it only cost me $5.00 per month with a prescription and not OTC. Just a thought. Suzanne In a message dated 4/3/2010 10:31:08 A.M. Pacific Daylight Time, t_y_kahn@... writes: Thanks! I have heard of that but I did not know you could feel it in your stomach. Mine constantly grumbles just like it used to do when I was hungry but now it goes all day. I take my Nexium everyday so I doubt it is that. Good to hear it will go away because it is driving me crazy. Quote
Guest guest Posted April 3, 2010 Report Posted April 3, 2010 Doesn't sound like head hunger to me. Head hunger is when you just think you're hungry, but it's all in your head. Real hunger IS when your stomach is grumbling and you feel weak from no food. Not sure what you're experiencing, but it doesn't sound like it's just in your head. > > Thanks! I have heard of that but I did not know you could feel it in your stomach. Mine constantly grumbles just like it used to do when I was hungry but now it goes all day. I take my Nexium everyday so I doubt it is that. Good to hear it will go away because it is driving me crazy. > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 3, 2010 Report Posted April 3, 2010 I'm with everyone else, my vote is head hunger and it's a buggar.On Sat, Apr 3, 2010 at 1:28 PM, extraordinarybags <april.white@...> wrote: Doesn't sound like head hunger to me. Head hunger is when you just think you're hungry, but it's all in your head. Real hunger IS when your stomach is grumbling and you feel weak from no food. Not sure what you're experiencing, but it doesn't sound like it's just in your head. > > Thanks! I have heard of that but I did not know you could feel it in your stomach. Mine constantly grumbles just like it used to do when I was hungry but now it goes all day. I take my Nexium everyday so I doubt it is that. Good to hear it will go away because it is driving me crazy. > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 3, 2010 Report Posted April 3, 2010 for me head hunger is when I wanna EEEEAT~ and real hunger is when I feel empty and kind of weak. for what it's worth. j Re: Always Hungry Doesn't sound like head hunger to me. Head hunger is when you just think you're hungry, but it's all in your head. Real hunger IS when your stomach is grumbling and you feel weak from no food. Not sure what you're experiencing, but it doesn't sound like it's just in your head.>> Thanks! I have heard of that but I did not know you could feel it in your stomach. Mine constantly grumbles just like it used to do when I was hungry but now it goes all day. I take my Nexium everyday so I doubt it is that. Good to hear it will go away because it is driving me crazy.> Quote
Guest guest Posted April 3, 2010 Report Posted April 3, 2010 Thanks everyone for taking the time to answer my question. I just talked to one of the women that had surgery with me the same day last week and she is feeling the same thing. She has researched and found that once we can start on cream soups and such that it should go away. I am also suspecting that is might be the Nexum like Suzanne mentioned. I will try prilosec tomm. I appreciate all the posts! Sleeve 3/26/2010 Quote
Guest guest Posted April 4, 2010 Report Posted April 4, 2010 The steamed veggies are a good idea but not until you are in the soft food stage! I have been lucky and haven't been hungry, maybe once or twice during the first 10 days. Just drink some hot tea. Celestial Seasonings has all kinds of different flavored tea, ones with chamomile may calm your stomach down. I think it probably is head hunger. It will go away. Peace, Kay Quote
Guest guest Posted April 4, 2010 Report Posted April 4, 2010 Hey, That is what we are here for, I am glad that you got a lot of answers. So I will keep good thoughts going for you. Remember we have said that the 1st 30 days is the most difficult, after that life starts to look a lot better. My biggest thing I had to learn was taking small bites and learning to chew and chew. You may experience this once you start eating solid food. Take care, Suzanne In a message dated 4/4/2010 10:16:29 A.M. Pacific Daylight Time, t_y_kahn@... writes: Thanks everyone for taking the time to answer my question. I just talked to one of the women that had surgery with me the same day last week and she is feeling the same thing. She has researched and found that once we can start on cream soups and such that it should go away. I am also suspecting that is might be the Nexum like Suzanne mentioned. I will try prilosec tomm. I appreciate all the posts!Sleeve 3/26/2010 Quote
Guest guest Posted April 4, 2010 Report Posted April 4, 2010 Yeah, for me it was my answer and I knew that this was the medication that made me feel a whole lot better. And it cost a lot less too! Suzanne In a message dated 4/4/2010 11:42:51 A.M. Pacific Daylight Time, t_y_kahn@... writes: I switched to Prilosec today and that seems to helping! Quote
Guest guest Posted April 4, 2010 Report Posted April 4, 2010 I switched to Prilosec today and that seems to helping! Quote
Guest guest Posted April 4, 2010 Report Posted April 4, 2010 Glad to hear it; I didn't think it was all in your head. Glad you're feeling better now. > > I switched to Prilosec today and that seems to helping! > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 4, 2010 Report Posted April 4, 2010 Hi Marilou, I didn't wait, I knew someone who took Nexium and gave them mine. I felt my good health was well worth buying the Prilosec OTC. I also then found out that since I had insurance that my doctor could prescribe the generic Prilosec and my insurance would pay for it and my co-pay was only $5.00. I understand that not everyone has that good of insurance, but if you do ask your doctor to prescribe it for you. Take care, Suzanne In a message dated 4/4/2010 6:24:41 P.M. Pacific Daylight Time, terriertamer@... writes: I'm switching as soon as the Nexium is gone. I don't think it works as well as it could. Marilou Dr. Aceves VSG~February 5, 2010 On Apr 4, 2010, at 2:25 PM, SuzanneSHaol wrote: Yeah, for me it was my answer and I knew that this was the medication that made me feel a whole lot better. And it cost a lot less too! / div> Suzanne In a message dated 4/4/2010 11:42:51 A.M. Pacific Daylight Time, t_y_kahn writes: I switched to Prilosec today and that seems to helping! Quote
Guest guest Posted April 4, 2010 Report Posted April 4, 2010 This is not a silly question. I think it took me about 6 weeks before I could swallow pills, and then I had to do them one at a time--not all at one time. Vitamins have always been an issue for me, and so now I do the adult chewable vitamins. I use to mash the pills up and put them in a little applesauce with equal. That worked for me until I could take them with a glass of water. Suzanne In a message dated 4/4/2010 7:35:34 P.M. Pacific Daylight Time, ishoot42@... writes: This may be a silly question but when can we swallow whole pills again?On Sun Apr s, 2010 6:19 PM PDT Marilou stone wrote:>I'm switching as soon as the Nexium is gone. I don't think it works as well as it could.>>Marilou>Dr. Aceves>VSG~February 5, 2010>>>>On Apr 4, 2010, at 2:25 PM, SuzanneSHaol wrote:>>> >> Yeah, for me it was my answer and I knew that this was the medication that made me feel a whole lot better. And it cost a lot less too!>> >> Suzanne>> >> In a message dated 4/4/2010 11:42:51 A.M. Pacific Daylight Time, t_y_kahn writes:>> >> >> I switched to Prilosec today and that seems to helping!>> >> >> >> > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 4, 2010 Report Posted April 4, 2010 I'm switching as soon as the Nexium is gone. I don't think it works as well as it could. MarilouDr. AcevesVSG~February 5, 2010 On Apr 4, 2010, at 2:25 PM, SuzanneSH@... wrote:Yeah, for me it was my answer and I knew that this was the medication that made me feel a whole lot better. And it cost a lot less too! Suzanne In a message dated 4/4/2010 11:42:51 A.M. Pacific Daylight Time, t_y_kahn writes: I switched to Prilosec today and that seems to helping! Quote
Guest guest Posted April 4, 2010 Report Posted April 4, 2010 This may be a silly question but when can we swallow whole pills again? On Sun Apr 4th, 2010 6:19 PM PDT Marilou stone wrote: >I'm switching as soon as the Nexium is gone. I don't think it works as well as it could. > >Marilou >Dr. Aceves >VSG~February 5, 2010 > > > >On Apr 4, 2010, at 2:25 PM, SuzanneSH@... wrote: > >> >> Yeah, for me it was my answer and I knew that this was the medication that made me feel a whole lot better. And it cost a lot less too! >> >> Suzanne >> >> In a message dated 4/4/2010 11:42:51 A.M. Pacific Daylight Time, t_y_kahn@... writes: >> >> >> I switched to Prilosec today and that seems to helping! >> >> >> >> > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 4, 2010 Report Posted April 4, 2010 I want to try the Prilosec before I go to the doc. Then I can see which works better and get a script for that one. I am far better than I was. In the beginning I had to take 2 Nexiums a day. Now I'm back down to one in the morning. MarilouDr. AcevesVSG~February 5, 2010 On Apr 4, 2010, at 6:45 PM, SuzanneSH@... wrote:Hi Marilou, I didn't wait, I knew someone who took Nexium and gave them mine. I felt my good health was well worth buying the Prilosec OTC. I also then found out that since I had insurance that my doctor could prescribe the generic Prilosec and my insurance would pay for it and my co-pay was only $5.00. I understand that not everyone has that good of insurance, but if you do ask your doctor to prescribe it for you. Take care,Suzanne In a message dated 4/4/2010 6:24:41 P.M. Pacific Daylight Time, terriertamermac writes: I'm switching as soon as the Nexium is gone. I don't think it works as well as it could. MarilouDr. AcevesVSG~February 5, 2010 On Apr 4, 2010, at 2:25 PM, SuzanneSHaol wrote:Yeah, for me it was my answer and I knew that this was the medication that made me feel a whole lot better. And it cost a lot less too! / div>Suzanne In a message dated 4/4/2010 11:42:51 A.M. Pacific Daylight Time, t_y_kahn writes: I switched to Prilosec today and that seems to helping! Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.