Guest guest Posted April 13, 2010 Report Posted April 13, 2010 My orthopedic surgeon suggested getting a treking stick to use as a cane. He said most of his patients found it more palatable to use than a cane. So I went to REI to check them out and realized I know nothing about using a cane or treking stick. If my right hip is bad, which side do you use the cane on? Has anyone else used a treking stick? Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 Hi Judy, I like the treking stick. It folded down a little and was very lite. Also I can still use it now I don¹t need it because of my knees. Now I mostly use it to help open the drapes that I can¹t reach : ) Here is info about using a cane from the web site of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons at http://orthoinfo.aaos.org/topic.cfm?topic=a00181 > Canes > You may find it helpful to use a cane if you have a small problem with balance > or instability, some weakness in your leg or trunk, an injury, or pain. If you > are elderly, a single point cane may also help you to keep living > independently. > > Proper Positioning > The top of your cane should reach to the crease in your wrist when you stand > up straight. Your elbow should bend a bit when you hold your cane. Hold the > cane in the hand opposite the side that needs support. > > Walking > When you walk, the cane and your injured leg swing and strike the ground at > the same time. To start, position your cane about one small stride ahead and > step off on your injured leg. Finish the step with your normal leg. > > Stairs > To climb stairs, grasp the handrail (if possible) and step up on your good leg > first, with your cane in the hand opposite the injured leg. Then step up on > the injured leg. To come down stairs, put your cane on the step first, then > your injured leg, and finally the good leg, which carries your body weight. If you are seeing a physical therapist s/he will be able to show you and help as you practice. Peace, Jackie On 4/13/10 8:57 PM, " judypaca " <judypaca@...> wrote: > > > > > > My orthopedic surgeon suggested getting a treking stick to use as a cane. He > said most of his patients found it more palatable to use than a cane. So I > went to REI to check them out and realized I know nothing about using a cane > or treking stick. If my right hip is bad, which side do you use the cane on? > Has anyone else used a treking stick? > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 You use the cane stick on the opposite side, so if its your left hip or knee the problem then you use it on the right. x   mary.waspe@... OSA member since 04/2002 OSA SAM 01/2004 photo's at jessoph0309.myphotoalbum.com blog:- http://mary-museum.blogspot.com/ design for About Art Accents., -- cane or treking stick My orthopedic surgeon suggested getting a treking stick to use as a cane. He said most of his patients found it more palatable to use than a cane. So I went to REI to check them out and realized I know nothing about using a cane or treking stick. If my right hip is bad, which side do you use the cane on? Has anyone else used a treking stick? ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 opposite side for knee and for hip. Reen Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 I have been using a trekking stick. Â I find it more steadying than a cane. Â I use it on the same said as I would a cane, i.e. the opposite of the hip replacement. Â Have the person you buy it from help you adjust the height (assuming it is collapsible)...I would suggest one that collapses to the size of a suitcase in case you are traveling with it, as you cannot take it on board a plane. I have a Leki stick which has a shock absorber, and I use it with a rubber tip. Â The only problem I have with it is occasionally my wrists get achy because they bend at a slight angle when holding it, so I try to keep it as high as possible when walking. You WILL get comments... " how are the slopes? " etc...!!!! Helen From: judypaca <judypaca@...> Subject: cane or treking stick Joint Replacement Date: Tuesday, April 13, 2010, 11:57 PM Â My orthopedic surgeon suggested getting a treking stick to use as a cane. He said most of his patients found it more palatable to use than a cane. So I went to REI to check them out and realized I know nothing about using a cane or treking stick. If my right hip is bad, which side do you use the cane on? Has anyone else used a treking stick? Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 I use this for hiking in the UK. when going over rough terrain, it is invaluable! ________________________________ From: on <jackiett@...> Joint Replacement Sent: Wed, April 14, 2010 2:30:01 AM Subject: Re: cane or treking stick Hi Judy, I like the treking stick. It folded down a little and was very lite. Also I can still use it now I don¹t need it because of my knees. Now I mostly use it to help open the drapes that I can¹t reach : ) Here is info about using a cane from the web site of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons at http://orthoinfo. aaos.org/ topic.cfm? topic=a00181 > Canes > You may find it helpful to use a cane if you have a small problem with balance > or instability, some weakness in your leg or trunk, an injury, or pain. If you > are elderly, a single point cane may also help you to keep living > independently. > > Proper Positioning > The top of your cane should reach to the crease in your wrist when you stand > up straight. Your elbow should bend a bit when you hold your cane. Hold the > cane in the hand opposite the side that needs support. > > Walking > When you walk, the cane and your injured leg swing and strike the ground at > the same time. To start, position your cane about one small stride ahead and > step off on your injured leg. Finish the step with your normal leg. > > Stairs > To climb stairs, grasp the handrail (if possible) and step up on your good leg > first, with your cane in the hand opposite the injured leg. Then step up on > the injured leg. To come down stairs, put your cane on the step first, then > your injured leg, and finally the good leg, which carries your body weight. If you are seeing a physical therapist s/he will be able to show you and help as you practice. Peace, Jackie On 4/13/10 8:57 PM, " judypaca " <judypaca (DOT) com> wrote: > > > > > > My orthopedic surgeon suggested getting a treking stick to use as a cane. He > said most of his patients found it more palatable to use than a cane. So I > went to REI to check them out and realized I know nothing about using a cane > or treking stick. If my right hip is bad, which side do you use the cane on? > Has anyone else used a treking stick? > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 I use two treking sticks. My ortho said that two sticks maintain body balance and prevent favoring one side. I bought the lightest weight sticks which can be telescoped so I can carry it easily when I travel. REI has different styles, you should try them out to see which is most comfortable for you. The REI people are very helpful. Sandy On Tue, Apr 13, 2010 at 11:57 PM, judypaca <judypaca@...> wrote: > My orthopedic surgeon suggested getting a treking stick to use as a cane. > He said most of his patients found it more palatable to use than a cane. So > I went to REI to check them out and realized I know nothing about using a > cane or treking stick. If my right hip is bad, which side do you use the > cane on? Has anyone else used a treking stick? > > > > ------------------------------------ > > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 Judy, You use the stick or cane on the same side as your bad leg. cane or treking stick My orthopedic surgeon suggested getting a treking stick to use as a cane. He said most of his patients found it more palatable to use than a cane. So I went to REI to check them out and realized I know nothing about using a cane or treking stick. If my right hip is bad, which side do you use the cane on? Has anyone else used a treking stick? Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 I was told just the opposite of what you are saying. cane or treking stick My orthopedic surgeon suggested getting a treking stick to use as a cane. He said most of his patients found it more palatable to use than a cane. So I went to REI to check them out and realized I know nothing about using a cane or treking stick. If my right hip is bad, which side do you use the cane on? Has anyone else used a treking stick? ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 Now I am confused! My doctor told me specifically to use the cane on the same side as my bad knee. Is it the opposite for hip replacements????? cane or treking stick Joint Replacement Date: Tuesday, April 13, 2010, 11:57 PM My orthopedic surgeon suggested getting a treking stick to use as a cane. He said most of his patients found it more palatable to use than a cane. So I went to REI to check them out and realized I know nothing about using a cane or treking stick. If my right hip is bad, which side do you use the cane on? Has anyone else used a treking stick? Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 , That's incorrect. A cane is used on the opposite side and is the same regardless of procedure. I would check with the doctor again or your pt. Jeff ________________________________ From: Kohn <katiekohn@...> Joint Replacement Sent: Wed, April 14, 2010 9:14:56 AM Subject: Re: cane or treking stick Now I am confused! My doctor told me specifically to use the cane on the same side as my bad knee. Is it the opposite for hip replacements????? cane or treking stick Joint Replacement Date: Tuesday, April 13, 2010, 11:57 PM My orthopedic surgeon suggested getting a treking stick to use as a cane. He said most of his patients found it more palatable to use than a cane. So I went to REI to check them out and realized I know nothing about using a cane or treking stick. If my right hip is bad, which side do you use the cane on? Has anyone else used a treking stick? Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 Standard instructions for the use of a cane are to use on the OPPOSITE side of the bad leg. You have been advised to use in an uncommonly prescribed manner. If I were you, I would verify that you are understanding the instructions correctly and then ask your doctor why he has instructed you to use your cane in this manner. Perhaps he has a reason unique to your situation. I am not second guessing your doctor but I think everyone should ask questions of all their doctors especially when the advice given is not that which is generally given as with your instructions on the cane. On Apr 14, 2010, at 6:14 AM, Kohn wrote: > Now I am confused! My doctor told me specifically to use the cane on > the same side as my bad knee. Is it the opposite for hip > replacements????? > cane or treking stick > Joint Replacement > Date: Tuesday, April 13, 2010, 11:57 PM > > My orthopedic surgeon suggested getting a treking stick to use as a > cane. He said most of his patients found it more palatable to use > than a cane. So I went to REI to check them out and realized I know > nothing about using a cane or treking stick. If my right hip is bad, > which side do you use the cane on? Has anyone else used a treking > stick? > > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 When I had to use a cane (before knee replacement) I used it on the bad knee side...took pressure off the knee. No one suggested which side to use it on - it just felt best that way for me. Re: cane or treking stick You use the cane stick on the opposite side, so if its your left hip or knee the problem then you use it on the right. x   Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 , No doctor I ever heard of says this. Every time I see " House, M.D. " I cringe at the way he uses his cane on the side of the " bad " leg.. The natural way a person walks is left arm forward with right leg, right arm with left leg. That's the way our brains are wired. A very few people do it the other way--right arm + right leg, left arm + left leg. In the military, we called this " camel-humping " (pardon my French). It's unnatural and uncomfortable. (Not to mention that it's against military protocol:-) Take a few steps without thinking about it and look at people in the street walking naturally. You'll see what I mean very quickly. Why would any doctor or physiotherapist tell you to break your body's natural habits? It sounds like your stick is too long. Bending your wrist or elbow makes you tire quickly and ache. A cane should be just long enough to that the handle touches the heel of hour hand when you stand up straight and let your arm hang down over the cane. I've never used a trekking stick because you have to bend your arm too much, and it's tiring. The positioning of the hands is wrong for the kind of support you need post-op. It may be good for trekking, but not for support walking. The weight-bearing part of your hand should be parallel to the ground, the direction your hand hangs naturally when you walk unaided. Everyone I asked (surgeons and physiotherapists-- and if I had to choose between them, I'd rather listen to the physiotherapist--they know much more about post-op rehab issues than the surgeons do) recommended either a cane or a forearm crutch with the length described here. The problem with using a forearm crutch is that you have to buy a pair, while you can buy only one cane. D. RTHR: 2003; LTHR:2004 No trees were injured in the making of this e-mail, but a considerable number of electrons got very ticked off. _____ From: Joint Replacement [mailto:Joint Replacement ] On Behalf Of Scharff Sent: ã 14 àôøéì 2010 16:29 Joint Replacement Subject: Re: cane or treking stick , That's incorrect. A cane is used on the opposite side and is the same regardless of procedure. I would check with the doctor again or your pt. Jeff ________________________________ From: Kohn <katiekohnverizon (DOT) <mailto:katiekohn%40verizon.net> net> Total_Joint_ <mailto:Joint Replacement%40> Replacement Sent: Wed, April 14, 2010 9:14:56 AM Subject: Re: cane or treking stick Now I am confused! My doctor told me specifically to use the cane on the same side as my bad knee. Is it the opposite for hip replacements????? .. <http://geo./serv?s=97359714/grpId=7780446/grpspId=1705061104/msgId =35827/stime=1271252103/nc1=3848644/nc2=4025373/nc3=5191955> Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 My understanding is that by using a cane on the opposite site, one is better able to simulate a " normal " gait since the cane effectively provides an additional support to take the weight off when the affected limb is on the ground. Normally when one walks one foot is on the ground and the other is in motion -- thus at some point, all of the body weight is on one leg. The desire to avoid the pain when that happens causes many people to start walking (or more accurately MIS-walking LOL) in a very specific manner -- the Trendelenburg Gait. It is often used as a diagnostic tool since it is such a characteristic of someone with a bad hip -- someone with a bad knee just limps in a different manner to avoid putting weight on the foot. Also, prior to my hip replacement, I fell a few times because my " lurch " was making it more difficult for me to recover from normal " bumps " in the road so to speak as well as my inability to lift my foot as high as someone with a normal gait does - this caused me to " catch " my foot occasionally when my shoe didn't shuffle forward LOL. Perhaps one of the physical therapists can explain why use on the opposite side is recommended in more technical terms but if you try walking or observing those with a " normal " walk, you can see how a can on the opposite side would help one have a more normal walk as opposed to a limp or a lurch. On Apr 14, 2010, at 6:48 AM, Bentley wrote: > When I had to use a cane (before knee replacement) I used it on the > bad knee side...took pressure off the knee. No one suggested which > side to use it on - it just felt best that way for me. > > > Re: cane or treking stick > > You use the cane stick on the opposite side, so if its your left hip > or knee > the problem then you use it on the right. > x > >   > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 The sticks I have had are " telescoping " and can be height adjusted to use just like a cane. I find them very comfortable because they are so light. There are a lot of different styles so one would have to make sure the height adjustment is right. The one I still have (left my first one somewhere) also has a little bit of spring in it so it's gentler on my hand and arm. REI has a good online store and here are their trekking sticks and poles: http://www.rei.com/category/4500049 They also have an advice on selection section linked that page. There are lots of places on the internet that will give info on sizing the cane, complete with illustrations. If you are in PT, asking the therapist for help with sizing, use, and gait plus any suggestions specific to your sitiuation would perfect. I think 's comment on PTs versus docs on this type of thing is on the mark. They have different kinds of knowledge and experience. I wouldn't want my PT operating on me and I'd prefer to get rehab suggestions primarily from the PT. Peace, Jackie Ps I always chuckle at your sig, . Thanks for the smile this cloudy am in Oakland. -- Jackie on Jackiett@... R-TKR 3-19-09 L-TKR 9-1-09 Dr. Patch On 4/14/10 7:02 AM, " on " <mdavison@...> wrote: > , > <snip part of message> > > I've never used a trekking stick because you have to bend your arm too much, > and it's tiring. The positioning of the hands is wrong for the kind of > support you need post-op. It may be good for trekking, but not for support > walking. The weight-bearing part of your hand should be parallel to the > ground, the direction your hand hangs naturally when you walk unaided. > Everyone I asked (surgeons and physiotherapists-- and if I had to choose > between them, I'd rather listen to the physiotherapist--they know much more > about post-op rehab issues than the surgeons do) recommended either a cane > or a forearm crutch with the length described here. The problem with using > a forearm crutch is that you have to buy a pair, while you can buy only one > cane. > > D. RTHR: 2003; LTHR:2004 > > No trees were injured in the making of this e-mail, but a considerable > number of electrons got very ticked off. > > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 OK I really messed up on this one. I better go back to bed and get up again tomorrow! I did check and my doctor said that it is supposed to be opposite the bad leg. Sorry for all the confusion. WE all have that straight now!!! I only used the cane for a week or so. Hopefully it didn't set me back too much!! Re: cane or treking stick Now I am confused! My doctor told me specifically to use the cane on the same side as my bad knee. Is it the opposite for hip replacements????? .. <http://geo./serv?s=97359714/grpId=7780446/grpspId=1705061104/msgId =35827/stime=1271252103/nc1=3848644/nc2=4025373/nc3=5191955> Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 Hi Jackie, My trekking stick is the same. The " give " on the bottom of the stick makes for an easier weight on your arm, I think. I got mine in a walking store in the UK, but I'm sure you can get them from LLBean. All the best, Joan ________________________________ From: on <jackiett@...> Joint Replacement Sent: Wed, April 14, 2010 11:48:26 AM Subject: Re: cane or treking stick The sticks I have had are " telescoping " and can be height adjusted to use just like a cane. I find them very comfortable because they are so light. There are a lot of different styles so one would have to make sure the height adjustment is right. The one I still have (left my first one somewhere) also has a little bit of spring in it so it's gentler on my hand and arm. REI has a good online store and here are their trekking sticks and poles: http://www.rei. com/category/ 4500049 They also have an advice on selection section linked that page. There are lots of places on the internet that will give info on sizing the cane, complete with illustrations. If you are in PT, asking the therapist for help with sizing, use, and gait plus any suggestions specific to your sitiuation would perfect. I think 's comment on PTs versus docs on this type of thing is on the mark. They have different kinds of knowledge and experience. I wouldn't want my PT operating on me and I'd prefer to get rehab suggestions primarily from the PT. Peace, Jackie Ps I always chuckle at your sig, . Thanks for the smile this cloudy am in Oakland. -- Jackie on Jackiettatt (DOT) net R-TKR 3-19-09 L-TKR 9-1-09 Dr. Patch On 4/14/10 7:02 AM, " on " <mdavisonbezeqint (DOT) net> wrote: > , > <snip part of message> > > I've never used a trekking stick because you have to bend your arm too much, > and it's tiring. The positioning of the hands is wrong for the kind of > support you need post-op. It may be good for trekking, but not for support > walking. The weight-bearing part of your hand should be parallel to the > ground, the direction your hand hangs naturally when you walk unaided. > Everyone I asked (surgeons and physiotherapists- - and if I had to choose > between them, I'd rather listen to the physiotherapist- -they know much more > about post-op rehab issues than the surgeons do) recommended either a cane > or a forearm crutch with the length described here. The problem with using > a forearm crutch is that you have to buy a pair, while you can buy only one > cane. > > D. RTHR: 2003; LTHR:2004 > > No trees were injured in the making of this e-mail, but a considerable > number of electrons got very ticked off. > > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 That's wrong advice , always opposite for hips and knees. x   mary.waspe@... OSA member since 04/2002 OSA SAM 01/2004 photo's at jessoph0309.myphotoalbum.com blog:- http://mary-museum.blogspot.com/ design for About Art Accents., -- Re: cane or treking stick I was told just the opposite of what you are saying. cane or treking stick My orthopedic surgeon suggested getting a treking stick to use as a cane. He said most of his patients found it more palatable to use than a cane. So I went to REI to check them out and realized I know nothing about using a cane or treking stick. If my right hip is bad, which side do you use the cane on? Has anyone else used a treking stick? ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 Yep, check again. My doc says defintely the opposite from the injured side. Aussie Joint Replacement From: mary.waspe@... Date: Thu, 15 Apr 2010 08:01:02 +1000 Subject: Re: cane or treking stick That's wrong advice , always opposite for hips and knees. x   mary.waspe@... OSA member since 04/2002 OSA SAM 01/2004 photo's at jessoph0309.myphotoalbum.com blog:- http://mary-museum.blogspot.com/ design for About Art Accents., -- Re: cane or treking stick I was told just the opposite of what you are saying. cane or treking stick My orthopedic surgeon suggested getting a treking stick to use as a cane. He said most of his patients found it more palatable to use than a cane. So I went to REI to check them out and realized I know nothing about using a cane or treking stick. If my right hip is bad, which side do you use the cane on? Has anyone else used a treking stick? ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 The Leki poles have a spring to them, and you can can different kinds of attachments for the bottom. Helen > , > <snip part of message> > > I've never used a trekking stick because you have to bend your arm too much, > and it's tiring. The positioning of the hands is wrong for the kind of > support you need post-op. It may be good for trekking, but not for support > walking. The weight-bearing part of your hand should be parallel to the > ground, the direction your hand hangs naturally when you walk unaided. > Everyone I asked (surgeons and physiotherapists- - and if I had to choose > between them, I'd rather listen to the physiotherapist- -they know much more > about post-op rehab issues than the surgeons do) recommended either a cane > or a forearm crutch with the length described here. The problem with using > a forearm crutch is that you have to buy a pair, while you can buy only one > cane. > > D. RTHR: 2003; LTHR:2004 > > No trees were injured in the making of this e-mail, but a considerable > number of electrons got very ticked off. > > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 16, 2010 Report Posted April 16, 2010 I have been wondering what I will do when I have both knees replaced at the same time. Use two canes? I cannot imagine using crutches. Both knees will be bad, so I won't have a good leg to stand on. in PA Quote
Guest guest Posted April 16, 2010 Report Posted April 16, 2010 Do not know. Ditto on my bi-lateral hip replacements... Re: cane or treking stick I have been wondering what I will do when I have both knees replaced at the same time. Use two canes? I cannot imagine using crutches. Both knees will be bad, so I won't have a good leg to stand on. in PA Quote
Guest guest Posted April 16, 2010 Report Posted April 16, 2010 A friend had both knees done same time. He used a pair of those half-crutches that go around your arm - I don't know their exact name but they are quite common. And only sat in straight chairs with good arms. He worked on having good upper body strength before the op.. Did all his p/t and then some, after. He is now skiing again (1 year from op.), back-country telemark skiing. He is 65. So there is hope but you have to work it. ////OldClimber (age 70, L. TKR) Cfourhorses@... wrote: > > > > Do not know. Ditto on my bi-lateral hip replacements... > > Re: cane or treking stick > > I have been wondering what I will do when I have both knees replaced > at the same time. Use two canes? I cannot imagine using crutches. Both > knees will be bad, so I won't have a good leg to stand on. > > in PA > > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 16, 2010 Report Posted April 16, 2010 Use a walker until you get more mobile. I was given elbow crutches instead of the underarm ones, but never used them. But use the walker as long as you have to. All the best, Joan ________________________________ From: musician12858 <musician12858@...> Joint Replacement Sent: Fri, April 16, 2010 4:25:18 PM Subject: Re: cane or treking stick I have been wondering what I will do when I have both knees replaced at the same time. Use two canes? I cannot imagine using crutches. Both knees will be bad, so I won't have a good leg to stand on. in PA Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.