Guest guest Posted December 23, 2010 Report Posted December 23, 2010 http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/charting-the-depths/201012/how-does-depressi\ on-start Blogs Charting the Depths Reflections on the Science of Depression by Rottenberg, Ph.D. How does depression start? A revealing gap in our knowledge about depression Published on December 23, 2010 For all the vast research we have on depression, with millions spent on genotyping, brain scans, and intervention studies, I have discovered a massive and most embarrassing hole in our knowledge. Usually when we want to understand a serious problem, say, an airline accident, we start at the beginning. An investigator will want to inspect maintenance records and analyze data from the flight recorder. He or she will establish a detailed timeline. A critical mark on this timeline is the first sign of something unusual. Often the eventual outcome --the plane slamming into a mountainside-- comes at the end of a chain of unfortunate events (i.e., the weather is bad, the pilots are unfamiliar with new traffic control rules, the tower miscommunicates at a critical moment in the flight). To understand what happened, one needs to go to the beginning of the chain. Quote
Guest guest Posted December 23, 2010 Report Posted December 23, 2010 http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/charting-the-depths/201012/how-does-depressi\ on-start Blogs Charting the Depths Reflections on the Science of Depression by Rottenberg, Ph.D. How does depression start? A revealing gap in our knowledge about depression Published on December 23, 2010 For all the vast research we have on depression, with millions spent on genotyping, brain scans, and intervention studies, I have discovered a massive and most embarrassing hole in our knowledge. Usually when we want to understand a serious problem, say, an airline accident, we start at the beginning. An investigator will want to inspect maintenance records and analyze data from the flight recorder. He or she will establish a detailed timeline. A critical mark on this timeline is the first sign of something unusual. Often the eventual outcome --the plane slamming into a mountainside-- comes at the end of a chain of unfortunate events (i.e., the weather is bad, the pilots are unfamiliar with new traffic control rules, the tower miscommunicates at a critical moment in the flight). To understand what happened, one needs to go to the beginning of the chain. Quote
Guest guest Posted December 23, 2010 Report Posted December 23, 2010 http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/charting-the-depths/201012/how-does-depressi\ on-start Blogs Charting the Depths Reflections on the Science of Depression by Rottenberg, Ph.D. How does depression start? A revealing gap in our knowledge about depression Published on December 23, 2010 For all the vast research we have on depression, with millions spent on genotyping, brain scans, and intervention studies, I have discovered a massive and most embarrassing hole in our knowledge. Usually when we want to understand a serious problem, say, an airline accident, we start at the beginning. An investigator will want to inspect maintenance records and analyze data from the flight recorder. He or she will establish a detailed timeline. A critical mark on this timeline is the first sign of something unusual. Often the eventual outcome --the plane slamming into a mountainside-- comes at the end of a chain of unfortunate events (i.e., the weather is bad, the pilots are unfamiliar with new traffic control rules, the tower miscommunicates at a critical moment in the flight). To understand what happened, one needs to go to the beginning of the chain. Quote
Guest guest Posted December 23, 2010 Report Posted December 23, 2010 http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/charting-the-depths/201012/how-does-depressi\ on-start Blogs Charting the Depths Reflections on the Science of Depression by Rottenberg, Ph.D. How does depression start? A revealing gap in our knowledge about depression Published on December 23, 2010 For all the vast research we have on depression, with millions spent on genotyping, brain scans, and intervention studies, I have discovered a massive and most embarrassing hole in our knowledge. Usually when we want to understand a serious problem, say, an airline accident, we start at the beginning. An investigator will want to inspect maintenance records and analyze data from the flight recorder. He or she will establish a detailed timeline. A critical mark on this timeline is the first sign of something unusual. Often the eventual outcome --the plane slamming into a mountainside-- comes at the end of a chain of unfortunate events (i.e., the weather is bad, the pilots are unfamiliar with new traffic control rules, the tower miscommunicates at a critical moment in the flight). To understand what happened, one needs to go to the beginning of the chain. Quote
Guest guest Posted December 24, 2010 Report Posted December 24, 2010 << http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/charting-the-depths/201012/how-does-depressi\ on-start > by Rottenberg, Ph.D. > > How does depression start? > > A revealing gap in our knowledge about depression > > Published on December 23, 2010 > > For all the vast research we have on depression, with millions spent on genotyping, brain scans, and intervention studies, I have discovered a massive and most embarrassing hole in our knowledge. > > Usually when we want to understand a serious problem, say, an airline accident, we start at the beginning. An investigator will want to inspect maintenance records and analyze data from the flight recorder. He or she will establish a detailed timeline. A critical mark on this timeline is the first sign of something unusual. Often the eventual outcome --the plane slamming into a mountainside-- comes at the end of a chain of unfortunate events (i.e., the weather is bad, the pilots are unfamiliar with new traffic control rules, the tower miscommunicates at a critical moment in the flight). To understand what happened, one needs to go to the beginning of the chain. > It seems reasonable to apply the methods of accident investigation to depression. How does it start? What are its warning signs and first symptoms? A fancy research word to capture the idea of first symptoms is a prodrome...? > > It turns out that we know almost nothing about the depressive prodrome. The amount of research is paltry, and nearly all of it is retrospective, meaning it asks people who have already become depressed to reflect on what they can remember about what was going wrong before they got depressed. This is a poor method for the task at hand because human memory obviously lacks the fidelity of a flight data recorder. Memory is a fallible record at best and depression only makes it more so!>> ** This is an attempt to cause fear in people by making the origin of depression seem mysterious, complicated and elusive. The more frightened people are, the more willing they will be to take antidepressants (drugs that have fallen out of favor in the US, Canada, and the UK lately). Imo, it is perfectly normal to have 2-3 periods of feeling depressed throughout one's life. In most people, this happens the 1st time in adolescence. Depression give a person time to be introspective, usually in time for a period of major life changes. People do get depressed usually for three other reasons. The first, that happens far more than most even suspect, is because of poor nutrition. The younger a person is when they become depressed (or get slapped with another label), the most likely it is that they didn't receive the proper nutrition in utero. If the mother was not properly nourished, the fetus did not get what was needed for proper development. The second is learned behavior from being in an environment where a parent exhibited depression. The third reason is because people cling to a picture they have in their minds of what life should be while resisting engaging in life now because it is not meeting their expectations. Basically, it's based on a huge temper tantrum. In all the time I've been doing this, I've NEVER seen depression that is " genetic " other than for the reasons above which could be called genetic but doesn't fit the definition medicine uses for this. Regards, Quote
Guest guest Posted December 24, 2010 Report Posted December 24, 2010 << http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/charting-the-depths/201012/how-does-depressi\ on-start > by Rottenberg, Ph.D. > > How does depression start? > > A revealing gap in our knowledge about depression > > Published on December 23, 2010 > > For all the vast research we have on depression, with millions spent on genotyping, brain scans, and intervention studies, I have discovered a massive and most embarrassing hole in our knowledge. > > Usually when we want to understand a serious problem, say, an airline accident, we start at the beginning. An investigator will want to inspect maintenance records and analyze data from the flight recorder. He or she will establish a detailed timeline. A critical mark on this timeline is the first sign of something unusual. Often the eventual outcome --the plane slamming into a mountainside-- comes at the end of a chain of unfortunate events (i.e., the weather is bad, the pilots are unfamiliar with new traffic control rules, the tower miscommunicates at a critical moment in the flight). To understand what happened, one needs to go to the beginning of the chain. > It seems reasonable to apply the methods of accident investigation to depression. How does it start? What are its warning signs and first symptoms? A fancy research word to capture the idea of first symptoms is a prodrome...? > > It turns out that we know almost nothing about the depressive prodrome. The amount of research is paltry, and nearly all of it is retrospective, meaning it asks people who have already become depressed to reflect on what they can remember about what was going wrong before they got depressed. This is a poor method for the task at hand because human memory obviously lacks the fidelity of a flight data recorder. Memory is a fallible record at best and depression only makes it more so!>> ** This is an attempt to cause fear in people by making the origin of depression seem mysterious, complicated and elusive. The more frightened people are, the more willing they will be to take antidepressants (drugs that have fallen out of favor in the US, Canada, and the UK lately). Imo, it is perfectly normal to have 2-3 periods of feeling depressed throughout one's life. In most people, this happens the 1st time in adolescence. Depression give a person time to be introspective, usually in time for a period of major life changes. People do get depressed usually for three other reasons. The first, that happens far more than most even suspect, is because of poor nutrition. The younger a person is when they become depressed (or get slapped with another label), the most likely it is that they didn't receive the proper nutrition in utero. If the mother was not properly nourished, the fetus did not get what was needed for proper development. The second is learned behavior from being in an environment where a parent exhibited depression. The third reason is because people cling to a picture they have in their minds of what life should be while resisting engaging in life now because it is not meeting their expectations. Basically, it's based on a huge temper tantrum. In all the time I've been doing this, I've NEVER seen depression that is " genetic " other than for the reasons above which could be called genetic but doesn't fit the definition medicine uses for this. Regards, Quote
Guest guest Posted December 24, 2010 Report Posted December 24, 2010 << http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/charting-the-depths/201012/how-does-depressi\ on-start > by Rottenberg, Ph.D. > > How does depression start? > > A revealing gap in our knowledge about depression > > Published on December 23, 2010 > > For all the vast research we have on depression, with millions spent on genotyping, brain scans, and intervention studies, I have discovered a massive and most embarrassing hole in our knowledge. > > Usually when we want to understand a serious problem, say, an airline accident, we start at the beginning. An investigator will want to inspect maintenance records and analyze data from the flight recorder. He or she will establish a detailed timeline. A critical mark on this timeline is the first sign of something unusual. Often the eventual outcome --the plane slamming into a mountainside-- comes at the end of a chain of unfortunate events (i.e., the weather is bad, the pilots are unfamiliar with new traffic control rules, the tower miscommunicates at a critical moment in the flight). To understand what happened, one needs to go to the beginning of the chain. > It seems reasonable to apply the methods of accident investigation to depression. How does it start? What are its warning signs and first symptoms? A fancy research word to capture the idea of first symptoms is a prodrome...? > > It turns out that we know almost nothing about the depressive prodrome. The amount of research is paltry, and nearly all of it is retrospective, meaning it asks people who have already become depressed to reflect on what they can remember about what was going wrong before they got depressed. This is a poor method for the task at hand because human memory obviously lacks the fidelity of a flight data recorder. Memory is a fallible record at best and depression only makes it more so!>> ** This is an attempt to cause fear in people by making the origin of depression seem mysterious, complicated and elusive. The more frightened people are, the more willing they will be to take antidepressants (drugs that have fallen out of favor in the US, Canada, and the UK lately). Imo, it is perfectly normal to have 2-3 periods of feeling depressed throughout one's life. In most people, this happens the 1st time in adolescence. Depression give a person time to be introspective, usually in time for a period of major life changes. People do get depressed usually for three other reasons. The first, that happens far more than most even suspect, is because of poor nutrition. The younger a person is when they become depressed (or get slapped with another label), the most likely it is that they didn't receive the proper nutrition in utero. If the mother was not properly nourished, the fetus did not get what was needed for proper development. The second is learned behavior from being in an environment where a parent exhibited depression. The third reason is because people cling to a picture they have in their minds of what life should be while resisting engaging in life now because it is not meeting their expectations. Basically, it's based on a huge temper tantrum. In all the time I've been doing this, I've NEVER seen depression that is " genetic " other than for the reasons above which could be called genetic but doesn't fit the definition medicine uses for this. Regards, Quote
Guest guest Posted December 24, 2010 Report Posted December 24, 2010 << http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/charting-the-depths/201012/how-does-depressi\ on-start > by Rottenberg, Ph.D. > > How does depression start? > > A revealing gap in our knowledge about depression > > Published on December 23, 2010 > > For all the vast research we have on depression, with millions spent on genotyping, brain scans, and intervention studies, I have discovered a massive and most embarrassing hole in our knowledge. > > Usually when we want to understand a serious problem, say, an airline accident, we start at the beginning. An investigator will want to inspect maintenance records and analyze data from the flight recorder. He or she will establish a detailed timeline. A critical mark on this timeline is the first sign of something unusual. Often the eventual outcome --the plane slamming into a mountainside-- comes at the end of a chain of unfortunate events (i.e., the weather is bad, the pilots are unfamiliar with new traffic control rules, the tower miscommunicates at a critical moment in the flight). To understand what happened, one needs to go to the beginning of the chain. > It seems reasonable to apply the methods of accident investigation to depression. How does it start? What are its warning signs and first symptoms? A fancy research word to capture the idea of first symptoms is a prodrome...? > > It turns out that we know almost nothing about the depressive prodrome. The amount of research is paltry, and nearly all of it is retrospective, meaning it asks people who have already become depressed to reflect on what they can remember about what was going wrong before they got depressed. This is a poor method for the task at hand because human memory obviously lacks the fidelity of a flight data recorder. Memory is a fallible record at best and depression only makes it more so!>> ** This is an attempt to cause fear in people by making the origin of depression seem mysterious, complicated and elusive. The more frightened people are, the more willing they will be to take antidepressants (drugs that have fallen out of favor in the US, Canada, and the UK lately). Imo, it is perfectly normal to have 2-3 periods of feeling depressed throughout one's life. In most people, this happens the 1st time in adolescence. Depression give a person time to be introspective, usually in time for a period of major life changes. People do get depressed usually for three other reasons. The first, that happens far more than most even suspect, is because of poor nutrition. The younger a person is when they become depressed (or get slapped with another label), the most likely it is that they didn't receive the proper nutrition in utero. If the mother was not properly nourished, the fetus did not get what was needed for proper development. The second is learned behavior from being in an environment where a parent exhibited depression. The third reason is because people cling to a picture they have in their minds of what life should be while resisting engaging in life now because it is not meeting their expectations. Basically, it's based on a huge temper tantrum. In all the time I've been doing this, I've NEVER seen depression that is " genetic " other than for the reasons above which could be called genetic but doesn't fit the definition medicine uses for this. Regards, Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.