Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

calcium supplements

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Guest guest
Posted

Dear Hilda,

I'm interested in hearing what others have to say on this subject, as well. It

is my understanding that the source of the calcium, as well as a proper calcium

to magnesium ratio makes all the difference in the world. Magnesium is

necessary to process the calcium, and certain calcium formulas are not as

readily absorbed by the body as others, thereby creating calcium deposits which

sometimes end up in the kidneys, and other times on the skeletal structure.

This is a good question!

Best wishes,

Carrol

Hilda Vosloo <hildavosloo@...> wrote: I heard a disturbing thing last

week. My sister went to hospital to have her bladder checked out. In the same

room was a woman with kidney stones that got admitted in a big hurry. The

urologist asked her whether she was taking calcium supplements, to which she

said yes. He told her to stop it immediately, as this is the main cause of

kidney stones. Could this indeed be the case? What to do now? How to we fight

osteo if we don't take dairy, and we can't have calcium supplements?

Hilda Vosloo

email: hildavosloo@...

cell: 0829229136

Guest guest
Posted

In a message dated 6/5/2002 3:09:25 PM Eastern Daylight Time,

hildavosloo@... writes:

> He told her to stop it immediately, as this is the main cause of kidney

> stones. Could this indeed be the case?

No, it is my understanding that this isn't true. I had a kidney stone when I

was 25 and my doctor told me it was from not drinking enough. I am now 59

and haven't had one since and I have taken calcium for years.

Sharon (Ontario) Canada

Guest guest
Posted

I've been " preaching " this for many many years. Bs should not take calcium

at all in tablet form. Only from food. I always suggest twice as much

magnesium as calcium.

" " " " " " " " " " " " " " How to we fight osteo if we don't take dairy, and we can't

have calcium supplements? " " " " " " " " " '

Buy not eating dairy, but lots of exercise and protein. Take magnesium 600

to 1000 mg daily. That should do it.

Calcium Supplements

I heard a disturbing thing last week. My sister went to hospital to have

her bladder checked out. In the same room was a woman with kidney stones

that got admitted in a big hurry. The urologist asked her whether she was

taking calcium supplements, to which she said yes. He told her to stop it

immediately, as this is the main cause of kidney stones. Could this indeed

be the case? What to do now? How to we fight osteo if we don't take dairy,

and we can't have calcium supplements?

Hilda Vosloo

email: hildavosloo@...

cell: 0829229136

Guest guest
Posted

stones are calcium " deposits "

Re: Calcium Supplements

In a message dated 6/5/2002 3:09:25 PM Eastern Daylight Time,

hildavosloo@... writes:

> He told her to stop it immediately, as this is the main cause of kidney

> stones. Could this indeed be the case?

No, it is my understanding that this isn't true. I had a kidney stone

when I

was 25 and my doctor told me it was from not drinking enough. I am now 59

and haven't had one since and I have taken calcium for years.

Sharon (Ontario) Canada

Guest guest
Posted

, just to make sure I understand correctly. By eating the normal O way, I

can take magnesium supplements only? I don't have to take calcium?

Buy not eating dairy, but lots of exercise and protein. Take magnesium 600

to 1000 mg daily. That should do it.

Guest guest
Posted

Assuming that you do vigorous exercise 5 to 6 days, high protein, low starch

then maybe once a week taking calcium is ok. Everyone is different however.

Magnesium is necessary daily.

Re: Calcium Supplements

, just to make sure I understand correctly. By eating the normal O

way, I can take magnesium supplements only? I don't have to take calcium?

Buy not eating dairy, but lots of exercise and protein. Take magnesium

600

to 1000 mg daily. That should do it.

  • 1 year later...
Guest guest
Posted

We are recommending a powdered calcium citrate that provides 700 mgs per

teaspoon. Check out www.nowfoods.com. It costs $7.99 for 75 servings and

there is a list of retail outlets on the website.

Shirley R. , RD, MS, CD

Registered Dietitian

Dean East Clinic, 1821 S. Stoughton Rd

Madison, WI 53716

Ph: (608) 260-6524

fax : (608) 260-6521

shirley.shelley@...

" anne_marquart "

<anne_marquart@yah

oo.com> cc:

Subject:

Calcium supplements

04/08/2004 10:03

AM

Please respond to

BariatricNutrition

Dietitians

Hello Everyone!

I have several patients complaining about calcium pills. Our program

is relatively new (the first surgery was in Feb) and I have not been

able to come up with a calcium supplement that patients can take

without cringing. I have recommended 1200-1500 mg of calcium citrate

daily, taken in divided doses. Most patients are crushing Citracal

tablets or a crushing calcium citrate tablets from GNC. Our surgeons

have not allowed tablets to be swallowed whole, and many patients are

too scared to swallow large pills, even if allowed. Patients are

complaining of bitter taste, gagging, etc. Every patient has asked me

about chewing Viactiv instead of taking these bitter tablets...what

fo y'all think? Has anyone found a chewable or liquid calcium citrate?

Thank you!

Anne Marquart, MS, RD, LD

Northwest Medical Center

Bariatric Program

Guest guest
Posted

Bariatric Advantage has a chewable Calcium Citrate. IT's chocolate & we

have lots of pts. taht tolerate it well.

> Hello Everyone!

>

> I have several patients complaining about calcium pills. Our program

> is relatively new (the first surgery was in Feb) and I have not been

> able to come up with a calcium supplement that patients can take

> without cringing. I have recommended 1200-1500 mg of calcium citrate

> daily, taken in divided doses. Most patients are crushing Citracal

> tablets or a crushing calcium citrate tablets from GNC. Our surgeons

> have not allowed tablets to be swallowed whole, and many patients are

> too scared to swallow large pills, even if allowed. Patients are

> complaining of bitter taste, gagging, etc. Every patient has asked me

> about chewing Viactiv instead of taking these bitter tablets...what

> fo y'all think? Has anyone found a chewable or liquid calcium citrate?

>

> Thank you!

> Anne Marquart, MS, RD, LD

> Northwest Medical Center

> Bariatric Program

>

>

>

>

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

We let our pts have Viactiv and they like it.

Buttrey, RD

Area Medical Center

>>> anne_marquart@... 04/08/04 11:03AM >>>

Hello Everyone!

I have several patients complaining about calcium pills. Our program

is relatively new (the first surgery was in Feb) and I have not been

able to come up with a calcium supplement that patients can take

without cringing. I have recommended 1200-1500 mg of calcium citrate

daily, taken in divided doses. Most patients are crushing Citracal

tablets or a crushing calcium citrate tablets from GNC. Our surgeons

have not allowed tablets to be swallowed whole, and many patients are

too scared to swallow large pills, even if allowed. Patients are

complaining of bitter taste, gagging, etc. Every patient has asked me

about chewing Viactiv instead of taking these bitter tablets...what

fo y'all think? Has anyone found a chewable or liquid calcium citrate?

Thank you!

Anne Marquart, MS, RD, LD

Northwest Medical Center

Bariatric Program

Guest guest
Posted

Isn't there a file as part of our group that has a handout on different sources of calcium?

Also, some of the pts that I've seen told me that they have asked the pharmacist and he/she will often have chewable behind the counter (citrate).

Is anyone concerned about viativ causing a stenosis, since it is so chewy, especially immediately post op?

Randi Belhumeur

-----Original Message-----From: anne_marquart [mailto:anne_marquart@...]Sent: Thursday, April 08, 2004 11:04 AM Subject: Calcium supplementsHello Everyone!I have several patients complaining about calcium pills. Our program is relatively new (the first surgery was in Feb) and I have not been able to come up with a calcium supplement that patients can take without cringing. I have recommended 1200-1500 mg of calcium citrate daily, taken in divided doses. Most patients are crushing Citracal tablets or a crushing calcium citrate tablets from GNC. Our surgeons have not allowed tablets to be swallowed whole, and many patients are too scared to swallow large pills, even if allowed. Patients are complaining of bitter taste, gagging, etc. Every patient has asked me about chewing Viactiv instead of taking these bitter tablets...what fo y'all think? Has anyone found a chewable or liquid calcium citrate?Thank you!Anne Marquart, MS, RD, LDNorthwest Medical CenterBariatric Program

  • 4 weeks later...
Guest guest
Posted

I contacted Novartis and while it is not posted on their website, they faxed me their FAQ on Optisource, their chewable calcium carbonate supplement formulated for bariatric patients. The references included 2 that were unavailable one a personal communication and one cited an ADA presentation, but these two references below were also included, so I am passing them along to the list for your review. I have also left a message with their staff dietitian to see if he or she can elucidate those other references more clearly.

What I found interesting about the first abstract below is the part I bolded: Administration of calcium carbonate as part of a normal breakfast resulted in completely normal absorption in the achlorhydric subjects.

Whereas the authors added that: These results indicate that calcium absorption from carbonate is impaired in achlorhydria under fasting conditions.

My interpretation would be to simply recommend the inexpensive, more concentrated, and equally well absorbed carbonate form with meals to elderly patients or those with achlorydia ( ? bariatric patients).

The second study is also very interesting re: the role of acid in calcium carbonate absorption.

I am interested in others interpretation and references

N Engl J Med. 1985 Jul 11;313(2):70-3. Calcium absorption and achlorhydria. Recker RR.

Defective absorption of calcium has been thought to exist in patients with achlorhydria. I compared absorption of calcium in its carbonate form with that in a pH-adjusted citrate form in a group of 11 fasting patients with achlorhydria and in 9 fasting normal subjects. Fractional calcium absorption was measured by a modified double-isotope procedure with 0.25 g of calcium used as the carrier. Mean calcium absorption (+/- S.D.) in the patients with achlorhydria was 0.452 +/- 0.125 for citrate and 0.042 +/- 0.021 for carbonate (P less than 0.0001). Fractional calcium absorption in the normal subjects was 0.243 +/- 0.049 for citrate and 0.225 +/- 0.108 for carbonate (not significant). Absorption of calcium from carbonate in patients with achlorhydria was significantly lower than in the normal subjects and was lower than absorption from citrate in either group; absorption from citrate in those with achlorhydria was significantly higher than in the normal subjects, as well as higher than absorption from carbonate in either group. Administration of calcium carbonate as part of a normal breakfast resulted in completely normal absorption in the achlorhydric subjects.

These results indicate that calcium absorption from carbonate is impaired in achlorhydria under fasting conditions. Since achlorhydria is common in older persons, calcium carbonate may not be the ideal dietary supplement.

J Clin Invest. 1984 Mar;73(3):640-7. An evaluation of the importance of gastric acid secretion in the absorption of dietary calcium.

Bo-Linn GW, GR, Buddrus DJ, Morawski SG, Santa Ana C, Fordtran JS.

Since calcium solubility is a prerequisite to calcium absorption, and since solubility of calcium is highly pH-dependent, it has been generally assumed that gastric acid secretion and gastric acidity play an important role in the intestinal absorption of calcium from ingested food or calcium salts such as CaCO3. To evaluate this hypothesis, we developed a method wherein net gastrointestinal absorption of calcium can be measured after ingestion of a single meal. A large dose of cimetidine, which markedly reduced gastric acid secretion, had no effect on calcium absorption in normal subjects, and an achlorhydric patient with pernicious anemia absorbed calcium normally. This was true regardless of the major source of dietary calcium (i.e., milk, insoluble calcium carbonate, or soluble calcium citrate). Moreover, calcium absorption after CaCO3 ingestion was the same when intragastric contents were maintained at pH 7.4 (by in vivo titration) as when intragastric pH was 3.0. On the basis of these results, we conclude that gastric acid secretion and gastric acidity do not normally play a role in the absorption of dietary calcium. Other possible mechanisms by which the gastrointestinal tract might solubilize ingested calcium complexes and salts are discussed.

Saucier Choate, M.S., R.D., L.D.

Food and Nutrition Educator

The Co-op Food Stores

Hanover and Lebanon, NH

(603) 643-2667 ext.3406

 

The Opposite of Fad Diets: Better Eating for Life, A Step-by-Step Guide to Healthier Choices

<http://www.coopfoodstore.com/news/arch_bettereat.html>

Calcium supplements

04/08/2004 10:03

AM

Please respond to

BariatricNutrition

Dietitians

Hello Everyone!

I have several patients complaining about calcium pills. Our program

is relatively new (the first surgery was in Feb) and I have not been

able to come up with a calcium supplement that patients can take

without cringing. I have recommended 1200-1500 mg of calcium citrate

daily, taken in divided doses. Most patients are crushing Citracal

tablets or a crushing calcium citrate tablets from GNC. Our surgeons

have not allowed tablets to be swallowed whole, and many patients are

too scared to swallow large pills, even if allowed. Patients are

complaining of bitter taste, gagging, etc. Every patient has asked me

about chewing Viactiv instead of taking these bitter tablets...what

fo y'all think? Has anyone found a chewable or liquid calcium citrate?

Thank you!

Anne Marquart, MS, RD, LD

Northwest Medical Center

Bariatric Program

Guest guest
Posted

I do not believe we can extrapolate the results of calcium absorption studies in patients with achlorhydria to patients who have their duodenum and in some cases the majority of their jejunum bypassed, which, with the exception of lap bands and VBGs, include all other bariatric operations. We do not know where calcium is being absorbed after these operations, is it in the digestive limb prior to mixing with the alkaline contents of the enzymatic limb, or is absorption taking place in the distal jejunum or perhaps even the ileum secondary to adaptation of the G.I. tract? Adaptation is known to take place in the case of protein following a BPB, in that the majority is absorbed in the colon, so why not a change in calcium absorption also. We know some absorption must be taking place, somewhere, or 100% of these patients should develop calcium malnutrition. Our knowledge is really quite limited. Jeannie Blankenship, I know you said you have had problems posting on the lists, if you would give permission, perhaps I can post your lecture on calcium that you sent me for others to read. I think it is valuable. This entire subject is currently up for grabs, especially the appropriate follow-up evaluations, etc. If anyone would like to hear more about the controversies, I can offer more questions for thought, but few answers.

Calcium supplements 04/08/2004 10:03 AM Please respond to BariatricNutrition Dietitians

Hello Everyone!

I have several patients complaining about calcium pills. Our program is relatively new (the first surgery was in Feb) and I have not been able to come up with a calcium supplement that patients can take without cringing. I have recommended 1200-1500 mg of calcium citrate daily, taken in divided doses. Most patients are crushing Citracal tablets or a crushing calcium citrate tablets from GNC. Our surgeons have not allowed tablets to be swallowed whole, and many patients are too scared to swallow large pills, even if allowed. Patients are complaining of bitter taste, gagging, etc. Every patient has asked me about chewing Viactiv instead of taking these bitter tablets...what fo y'all think? Has anyone found a chewable or liquid calcium citrate?

Thank you! Anne Marquart, MS, RD, LD Northwest Medical Center Bariatric Program

  • 11 months later...
Guest guest
Posted

--- You wrote:

Do any of you now of any form of Calcium carbonate that is absorbed in the post

op bariatric patient? We have a person in our support group who sells coral

calcium, which is a liquid form of calcium carbonate. Is anyone familiar with

this product and now if it is really absorbed because it is in the liquid form.

The persons spoke to the company and they of course said it is absorbed. Alot of

our patients are buying it.

--- end of quote ---

I discourage the use of coral calcium. The reports I've read state that it is

actually the worst absorbed form of calcium and it can contain heavy metals

(i.e. lead). Is coral calcium a form of calcium carbonate? I'm not sure that

it is. If pts take calcium carbonate, I suggest they take it close to meal

times.

Letendre, MS,RD,LD

Bariatric Surgery Program

Section of General Surgery

(603)650-8810

Guest guest
Posted

Thanks Amy, that would be great!!!!

Maskrey, RD

Chapman Medical Center__________________________________________________

Guest guest
Posted

Abbe, which part is false, that coral calcium in liquid form is not really absorbed any better or that it contains lead and other harmful metals?

RE: Calcium supplements

Thanks Amy, that would be great!!!!

Maskrey, RD

Chapman Medical Center

__________________________________________________

  • 1 year later...
Posted

Sandy,

Thank you for this info. When I saw that irregular heart beat is a

side effect I got concerned. I have been having " flutters " for the

past week or so. I can feel my heart skipping or having a series of

many beats at once. I'm wondering if it is my thyroid meds or the

fact that I have been popping the Mylanta/Tums a lot lately. I have

burning in my stomach when it is empty and also when I eat anything

remotely spicy and sometimes for no reason at all. I will be seeing

my band doc next week and endocrinologist after that, so hopefully I

will be able to get some answers. Thanks again.

Carol

>

> This is very important for all of us to know:

>

> (We have to be careful with all supplements! We can't just be

popping

> stuff we read or hear about.)

>

> re CALCIUM: women under 50 yrs of age, and all men, need about

1200

> mg a day. Women over 50 need 1500 mg a day, UNLESS they are on

> estrogen, then they need only 800 mg a day.

>

> Too much is dangerous - and too much is about 2000 mg a day. It's

> not hard to get this much!!

>

> We do NOT need supplements if we are using dairy products! Are you

> getting NO calcium from milk, cheese, yogurt, cottage cheese, etc?

If

> you ARE, then you could easily go over 2000 mg a day and get into

> trouble- severe constipation, kidney stones, and more.

>

> you have to see how much you're already getting from the calcium-

rich

> foods you're eating, and then see if you need more.

>

> Here is a list of the calcium content of common foods:

> http://ag.arizona.edu/maricopa/fcs/bb/highCalciumFds.html

> Calcium overdoses are serious enough to be listed in " poison

control "

> manuals. Here is the listing in mine:

>

>

> Poisonous Ingredient Calcium

>

> Where Found

>

> Calcium carbonate

>

> Some antacids (Tums, Chooz)

> Some mineral supplements

> Some vitamin and mineral supplements

> Some hand lotions

> Note: This list may not be all inclusive.

>

> Symptoms

>

> Muscles, bones, and joints

> Bone pain

> Gastrointestinal

> Abdominal pain

> Nausea and vomiting

> Severe Constipation

> Severe Diarrhea

> Heart and blood

> Irregular heartbeat, sometimes fatal

> Nervous system:

> Confusion, dementia

> Depression

> Coma

> Headache

>

>

> Also, the supplements come in 600 mg tabs and chews for a very

good

> reason - the body cannot absorb any more than this is one sitting.

>

> So, if you do need a supplement, it must be taken in divided

doses,

> not all at once.

>

> Always look up EVERYthing you consider taking, to learn of the

side-

> effects, risks, benefits, interactions with other meds, etc. Herbs

> and supplements can be just as dangerous as medictions!

>

> One mor thing about the Viactiv -or similar chews - they look and

> taste like candy! Don't be tempted to eat several of them - only 4

> gets you into the overdose area. A friend who was hungry for candy

> had about 10 and was in the ICU for a week with heart and kidney

> problems. and a child eating them accidentally like candy can die

> from the OD. (grandparents and people with little kids around -

treat

> them like medications and lock them up.)

>

> Calcium supplements are just FINE - ** IF ** we need them! They

are

> one of the few things that are just as effective as REAL FOOD.

>

> I bet most of us are getting enough calcium from foods so that we

> need only one or NO calcium supplements a day.

>

> Sandy R

> at goal

>

Posted

I have been having " flutters " for the past week or so. I can feel my heart

skipping or having a series of many beats at once. I'm wondering if it is my

thyroid meds

~~~~~~~~~~

Carol,

It sounds as though your thyroid meds could be too high. It is generally

understood that thyroid requirements can decrease as one loses weight, I have

also found that thyroid meds seem to need to be decreased in the hot, brighter,

summer months, and increased in the darker, colder months. How are your Ferritin

levels? low levels can cause the thyroid meds to be less well utilized by the

cells, and cause increased levels in the blood stream (unused....just running

around and causing symptoms such as heart palps.) How are your adrenal glands?

Been under any unusual stress or ongoing heavy stress lately?! Again, low

levels of cortisol can cause thyroid meds to appear too high....when they are

just not being used properly by the body.

Glad you are seeing your PCP and an endo. Hopefully they will run a TSH, FT4

and a FT3....that is what will *really* tell you where you are in regard to

thyroid meds/function. Perhaps you could get the blood work orders a head of

time (faxed to lab or you could pick up), so when you DO see your doc's, you

will be able to discuss them and possible protocol.

HTH and feel free to write to me personally, if you wish.

ginger207/agr8nthrngal

---------------------------------

All-new - Fire up a more powerful email and get things done faster.

Posted

Are you pre or post menopausal? I have those heart palpitations when my

estrogen is low.

Re: Calcium supplements

I have been having " flutters " for the past week or so. I can feel my heart

skipping or having a series of many beats at once. I'm wondering if it is my

thyroid meds

~~~~~~~~~~

Carol,

It sounds as though your thyroid meds could be too high. It is generally

understood that thyroid requirements can decrease as one loses weight, I have

also found that thyroid meds seem to need to be decreased in the hot, brighter,

summer months, and increased in the darker, colder months. How are your Ferritin

levels? low levels can cause the thyroid meds to be less well utilized by the

cells, and cause increased levels in the blood stream (unused....just running

around and causing symptoms such as heart palps.) How are your adrenal glands?

Been under any unusual stress or ongoing heavy stress lately?! Again, low levels

of cortisol can cause thyroid meds to appear too high....when they are just not

being used properly by the body.

Glad you are seeing your PCP and an endo. Hopefully they will run a TSH, FT4 and

a FT3....that is what will *really* tell you where you are in regard to thyroid

meds/function. Perhaps you could get the blood work orders a head of time (faxed

to lab or you could pick up), so when you DO see your doc's, you will be able to

discuss them and possible protocol.

HTH and feel free to write to me personally, if you wish.

ginger207/agr8nthrngal

---------------------------------

All-new - Fire up a more powerful email and get things done faster.

Posted

Ginger,

So nice to meet up with someone who is also on thyroid meds and

knows lots more than me. I have bloodwork done every 6 mos and

lately the endo is telling me that the TSH is on the higher end, but

other hormones indicate that I don't need to decrease Synthroid. I

never paid attention to exactly what hormones, but I'll ask about

the Ferritin? I'll be in her office on 9/5. I'm actually a little

hesitant to decrease meds because I'm afraid I'll lose even slower,

but I guess being at risk with my heart is not a good idea. My PCP

had done some bloodwork months ago and advised me to just stop

taking the Synthroid alltogether. Does this sound right? I didn't

take his advise, because I figured the endo knows a lot more than

he. I've never heard about the hot months vs. cold, very

interesting. As far as stress goes, its constant for me, but I did

notice that my heart palps started just around the time that I was

getting ready to come home to New Jersey from a month's stay with my

older son in California.....just coincidence?

Thanks so much for your help

Carol

>

> I have been having " flutters " for the past week or so. I can feel

my heart skipping or having a series of many beats at once. I'm

wondering if it is my thyroid meds

>

> ~~~~~~~~~~

> Carol,

> It sounds as though your thyroid meds could be too high. It is

generally understood that thyroid requirements can decrease as one

loses weight, I have also found that thyroid meds seem to need to be

decreased in the hot, brighter, summer months, and increased in the

darker, colder months. How are your Ferritin levels? low levels can

cause the thyroid meds to be less well utilized by the cells, and

cause increased levels in the blood stream (unused....just running

around and causing symptoms such as heart palps.) How are your

adrenal glands? Been under any unusual stress or ongoing heavy

stress lately?! Again, low levels of cortisol can cause thyroid

meds to appear too high....when they are just not being used

properly by the body.

>

> Glad you are seeing your PCP and an endo. Hopefully they will

run a TSH, FT4 and a FT3....that is what will *really* tell you

where you are in regard to thyroid meds/function. Perhaps you could

get the blood work orders a head of time (faxed to lab or you could

pick up), so when you DO see your doc's, you will be able to discuss

them and possible protocol.

>

> HTH and feel free to write to me personally, if you wish.

>

> ginger207/agr8nthrngal

>

>

> ---------------------------------

> All-new - Fire up a more powerful email and get

things done faster.

>

>

Posted

Amen, .

(Misinformation can be deadly. )

Marley

- who quoted the SAME section in an earlier post

>Posted by: " juliewmson " jwmson1@... juliewmson >Tue Aug 29, 2006

4:58 am (PST) >You might want to re-think that " as needed basis " ... this is a

quote

>from the CLOS website in the section concerning postop meds...

>

> " Tums can be started soon after the surgery and because of the risk

>of poor calcium absorption after the Mini-Gastric Bypass; you should

>consider taking some form of calcium supplement for the rest of your

>life. "

>

>I personally don't want osteoporosis or other bone related

>problems... I will be taking my Tums daily for the rest of my life or

>some other form of calcium. A very small price to pay!

>

> in GA

>

> I take 6 per day and will only take it for 4 months like the

manual said.

> Then it's on a as needed basis.

>

> Hugs,

---------------------------------

All-new - Fire up a more powerful email and get things done faster.

Posted

I'm pre. Any advice on natural supplements? I don't want ERT at

all and have heard of the St. 's Wort, etc., but haven't tried

it. Just thankful that the band has gottem me into a good vitamin

regimen including B-Complex which I know has helped tremendously.

>

> Are you pre or post menopausal? I have those heart palpitations

when my estrogen is low.

>

>

> Re: Calcium supplements

>

>

> I have been having " flutters " for the past week or so. I can feel

my heart skipping or having a series of many beats at once. I'm

wondering if it is my thyroid meds

>

> ~~~~~~~~~~

> Carol,

> It sounds as though your thyroid meds could be too high. It is

generally understood that thyroid requirements can decrease as one

loses weight, I have also found that thyroid meds seem to need to be

decreased in the hot, brighter, summer months, and increased in the

darker, colder months. How are your Ferritin levels? low levels can

cause the thyroid meds to be less well utilized by the cells, and

cause increased levels in the blood stream (unused....just running

around and causing symptoms such as heart palps.) How are your

adrenal glands? Been under any unusual stress or ongoing heavy

stress lately?! Again, low levels of cortisol can cause thyroid meds

to appear too high....when they are just not being used properly by

the body.

>

> Glad you are seeing your PCP and an endo. Hopefully they will run

a TSH, FT4 and a FT3....that is what will *really* tell you where

you are in regard to thyroid meds/function. Perhaps you could get

the blood work orders a head of time (faxed to lab or you could pick

up), so when you DO see your doc's, you will be able to discuss them

and possible protocol.

>

> HTH and feel free to write to me personally, if you wish.

>

> ginger207/agr8nthrngal

>

>

> ---------------------------------

> All-new - Fire up a more powerful email and get things

done faster.

>

>

  • 1 year later...
Guest guest
Posted

Beth, I'm Canadian (Ontario) and hear you about the wonderful weather. We're buried in snow at the moment. If you blink you miss fall and spring and summer doesn't seem to last long enough. I don't mind the cold, if only it was drier.

I'm not familiar with citracal petites.. but I find taking calcium/magnesium/vitamin D capsules works fairly well. You can probably buy them most places in the states. We need the magnesium and it helps to get the calcium into our systems. I've read that taking magnesium along with calcium helps to prevent calcium deposits also. Not sure if that's true or not.

ine

> dominie > From: bethmrmn@...> Date: Fri, 14 Mar 2008 15:34:39 +0000> Subject: calcium supplements> > Hi everyone! I am recovering from a flare that has happened since we> have had ice and snow storms here in Ohio. I believe my flares happen> when the cold and snow flares-in Ohio, we have 8 months of winter(in> my opinion) lol! Also, I KNOW that any stressful event causes them for me.> Anyway, at my last visit to my PCP, I was given Lyrica- it has> helped me somewhat. I know others aren't able to take because of the> side effects. I am on a low dose 50mg twice a day. I also take Elavil> at night and Lunesta for sleep. Anyway, I am in the throes of> menopause which does not help ANYTHING!!! I asked my dr. about calcium> supplements- she said chew some Tums. I do not drink milk and get very> little sunshine here in Ohio. I bought some Citracal Petites- I am> wondering how many I should take a day. The label say 1-2 tablets> twice a day.Is that enough? Each tablet has 400 IU Vitamin D and 400mg> of calcium. Any advice???> Thanks so much, Beth > > > ------------------------------------> >

Guest guest
Posted

Thanks for the info ine:)Beth MoormanFrom: pauline <foggynanny@...>Subject: RE: calcium supplementsdominie Date: Friday, March 14, 2008, 12:04 PM

Beth, I'm Canadian (Ontario) and hear you about the wonderful weather. We're buried in snow at the moment. If you blink you miss fall and spring and summer doesn't seem to last long enough. I don't mind the cold, if only it was drier.

I'm not familiar with citracal petites.. but I find taking calcium/magnesium/vitamin D capsules works fairly well. You can probably buy them most places in the states. We need the magnesium and it helps to get the calcium into our systems. I've read that taking magnesium along with calcium helps to prevent calcium deposits also. Not sure if that's true or not.

ine

> dominie > From: bethmrmn@...> Date: Fri, 14 Mar 2008 15:34:39 +0000> Subject: calcium supplements> > Hi everyone! I am recovering from a flare that has happened since we> have had ice and snow storms here in Ohio. I believe my flares happen> when the cold and snow flares-in Ohio, we have 8 months of winter(in> my opinion) lol! Also, I KNOW that any stressful event causes them for me.> Anyway, at my last visit to my PCP, I was given Lyrica- it has> helped me somewhat. I know others aren't able to take because of the> side effects. I am on a low dose 50mg twice a day. I also take Elavil> at night and Lunesta for sleep. Anyway, I am in the throes of> menopause which does not help ANYTHING!!! I asked my dr. about calcium> supplements- she said chew some Tums. I do not drink milk and get very> little sunshine here in

Ohio. I bought some Citracal Petites- I am> wondering how many I should take a day. The label say 1-2 tablets> twice a day.Is that enough? Each tablet has 400 IU Vitamin D and 400mg> of calcium. Any advice???> Thanks so much, Beth > > > ------------------------------------> >

Guest guest
Posted

>

I am post menopausal :) no HRT nopr could I take it due to heart

problems I use to take the generic version of vivactive in the wallmart

brand for chewables. But my PCP and ENDOCRINE Dr told me we need

Vitamin D3 so I now take a citracal calium pill twice a day I have more

bone loss in my hips than in my spine too due to years of taking

thyroid hormones. But you can get them in the petite too,. hope this

helps some. hugs heidi

> Hi everyone! I am recovering from a flare that has happened since we

> have had ice and snow storms here in Ohio. I believe my flares happen

> when the cold and snow flares-in Ohio, we have 8 months of winter(in

> my opinion) lol! Also, I KNOW that any stressful event causes them

for me.

> Anyway, at my last visit to my PCP, I was given Lyrica- it has

> helped me somewhat. I know others aren't able to take because of the

> side effects. I am on a low dose 50mg twice a day. I also take Elavil

> at night and Lunesta for sleep. Anyway, I am in the throes of

> menopause which does not help ANYTHING!!! I asked my dr. about calcium

> supplements- she said chew some Tums. I do not drink milk and get very

> little sunshine here in Ohio. I bought some Citracal Petites- I am

> wondering how many I should take a day. The label say 1-2 tablets

> twice a day.Is that enough? Each tablet has 400 IU Vitamin D and 400mg

> of calcium. Any advice???

> Thanks so much, Beth

>

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...