Guest guest Posted July 2, 2010 Report Posted July 2, 2010 My layman's understanding is there is no difference between hard/soft @ mod.1.5 chamber you can get oxygen toxicity from either. It is the amount of time being spent in that chamber that is the cuplit, just like the asprin effect if 2 asprin is good then 4 asprin is GREAT... not so... there is a reason for the protocol, 40 treatments then 5 week break then 40 treatments...and if you are doing it 2x a day then make sure you leave 4 hours break before doing the second treatment in that day... Quote
Guest guest Posted July 2, 2010 Report Posted July 2, 2010 Thank you so much for posting this. By the way you would not believe the people that have contacted me that have chambers that have been outfitted to 1.5 and who actually sold it to them. Some of our worst critics.. I will forward you them later today ...I have to get my but in Bed I just got off work... Â From: <jessienjustin@...> Subject: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? medicaid Date: Thursday, July 1, 2010, 10:34 PM Â Here is a link to the paper pucblished by Dr. Harch. http://www.healing-arts.org/children/Hyperbaric_Oxygen_Therapy_in_Chronic_Brain_\ Injury.pdf Below is a 'cut and paste' of the conclusion of the paper... In conclusion, oxygen toxicity at 1.5 and 1.75 ATA in chronic neurologically injured patients is a certainty. Acute toxicity seems to occur more frequently at 1.75 ATA than 1.5 ATA. Chronic oxygen toxicity occurs earlier in the treatment course at 1.75 ATA than 1.5 ATA and more frequently after prolonged uninterrupted courses of HBOT or escalation of pressure from 1.5 to 1.75 or 2.0 ATA. Finally, a third syndrome is described of an acute withdrawal effect from HBOT after prolonged courses at 1.75 ATA that responds to additional HBOT at lower pressures. All three of these syndromes may have long-term detrimental effects. > > I would love to have the link to Dr. Harch's published paper about oxygen toxicity at 1.5 100 oxygen that Darin mentions in his post below. Does anyone have that link? > > Also, if anyone could explain how that would relate to mbot at 1.3 or 1.5 with an oxygen concentrator, I would very much appreciate the advice. > > Thanks, > Jinger > > > > From: Darin > Sent: Thursday, July 01, 2010 5:07 AM > Medicaidforhbot > Subject: [ ] Help..... > > > > Below is an one of many emails I have recieved from parents. I took the name off for protection of the parents and the child. But this is the kind of stuff that performance has caused. Cleary if you will read no Dangers has ever been shared with her. No one has told her the effects of Oxygen toxicity etc. No one has told her about the paper Dr Harch published about O2 toxicity at 1.5 100 oxygen.. I'm ashamed at some of the people on this list as well clinics etc that helped these people get these portable chambers. YOU PEOPLE SIT ON THIS LIST AND ACTED ALL HIGH AND MIGHTY ETC.. WHILE YOU HAVE BEEN ADVOCATING AND HELPING FOLKS OBTAIN THESE OUT YORU BACK DOOR.. THEN YOU WANNA TALK. I COULD RELEASE THE EMAILS WITH THE NAMES OF CLINICS AND DR.S AND PEOPLE ON THIS GROUP AND ALL OF YOU WOULD HAVE SOME LIABILITY IN THIS 12 Million lawsuit.. Pityfull...... > > I have over a dozen people that have emailed me gave the names of whom helped them purchase etc. I'm just shocked at some of you.. You people would sell you soul to the Devil for a quick Buck. > > Hi Darin, > > I wanted to email you privately. I am an owner of the > > double bag chamber by Performance Hyperbarics. I purchased > > it last year for my 5 year old son w/ autism through a > > doctor and it was outfitted to 1.5 ata. I am confused as to > > what to do. We have done over 300 hrs and my son will only > > wear the mask for 20 min each session. We have seen some > > small improvements mostly in the beginning but > > unfortunately, due to logistics of being a single mom of 2, > > we are only able to go in for 1 to 2 dives per week b/c I > > have no one to watch my 3 year old daughter. > > > > My question is, should I be requesting a refund? I still > > want to continue mHBOT and the only center in (where I > > live) has Hard chambers that are 1.5ATA but are $250 an hour > > but it may be worth it if he is exposed to 100% oxygen for > > the entire hour as opposed to the % he egst in our mhbot > > chamber when he's wearing the mask (the other time I'm > > holding the tube up to his nose) . What are the dangers of > > using 1.5ata in our chamber? > > > > Thanks for any information you can provide me to make the > > best decision for my son. > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 3, 2010 Report Posted July 3, 2010 Diane you said that well from a fromer Real Estate Agent with no Medical background. OH I FORGOT YOU DO HAVE A CRAKER JACK DR, THAT GIVES YOU ADVISE...  Once again you were sued by Oxyhealth go to http://www.iptoday.com/search-results.asp?cx=partner-pub-3423154585508958%3Apy7k\ buxzzx4 & cof=FORID%3A10 & ie=ISO-8859-1 & q=%22oxy-health%22 & sa=Search & siteurl=www.ip\ today.com%2F and just look at the documents. This will explain why she is bashing Oxyhealth , my God she was sued by them and lost the Law suit . Most of the court documents are titled " Oxy-Health, LLC v. Spencer Feldman et al " or " Oxy-Health LLC v. Diane Pechenick et al " . Oxyhealth sued Performance Hyperbarics and both Spencer Feldman and Diane Pechenick individually. Anyway this is another round of her babbleing when she has no Idea what she is talking about. This is one case where if Diane was  injured Hyperbaric's should not be used it would be a waste of Good Oxygen...    Darin  > > > > Thank you so much for posting this. By the way you would not believe the people that have contacted me that have chambers that have been outfitted to 1.5 and who actually sold it to them. Some of our worst critics.. I will forward you them later today ...I have to get my but in Bed I just got off work... Quote
Guest guest Posted July 4, 2010 Report Posted July 4, 2010 But Diane your a Liar.. I mean how can you defend yourself. You were caught on tape talking about it etc. You were also caught on tape sending me to that Craker Jack Dr. that asked for a little something Something. Come on Diane lets not forget that.. Your hair looks brwon in the picture but I'm starting to wonder if it is not blonde. Darin 4312 Rains County Rd 1495Emory Texas 75440 From: hbotforhealth <diane@...> Subject: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? medicaid Date: Sunday, July 4, 2010, 12:42 PM Â Anyone can sue anyone for anything. Just because you have been sued does not make you guilty of anything. I am currently defending myself against the lawsuit from Oxyealth, unlike all of the other people who were sued by Oxyhealth for using their keywords on google. It's too bad that no one has sued Oxyhealth for all of their unethical behavior over the years. Maybe one day, their time will come. Diane > > > > > > > > Thank you so much for posting this. By the way you would not > believe the people that have contacted me that have chambers that have > been outfitted to 1.5 and who actually sold it to them. Some of our > worst critics.. I will forward you them later today ...I have to get my > but in Bed I just got off work... > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 4, 2010 Report Posted July 4, 2010 Can you please start your bickering on your own post -- whether valid or not, is not the issue. I asked a question and can't seem to get answers without several of the posts positioning and jabbing each other. I don't want to keep clicking on my oxygen toxicity post to read valid responses to my question, just to have to read more bickering. It has gotten very old to me. From: Darin Sent: Sunday, July 04, 2010 1:53 PM medicaid Subject: Re: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? But Diane your a Liar.. I mean how can you defend yourself. You were caught on tape talking about it etc. You were also caught on tape sending me to that Craker Jack Dr. that asked for a little something Something. Come on Diane lets not forget that.. Your hair looks brwon in the picture but I'm starting to wonder if it is not blonde. Darin 4312 Rains County Rd 1495Emory Texas 75440 From: hbotforhealth <diane@...> Subject: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? medicaid Date: Sunday, July 4, 2010, 12:42 PM Anyone can sue anyone for anything. Just because you have been sued does not make you guilty of anything. I am currently defending myself against the lawsuit from Oxyealth, unlike all of the other people who were sued by Oxyhealth for using their keywords on google. It's too bad that no one has sued Oxyhealth for all of their unethical behavior over the years. Maybe one day, their time will come. Diane > > > > > > > > Thank you so much for posting this. By the way you would not > believe the people that have contacted me that have chambers that have > been outfitted to 1.5 and who actually sold it to them. Some of our > worst critics.. I will forward you them later today ...I have to get my > but in Bed I just got off work... > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 5, 2010 Report Posted July 5, 2010 HOLD UP WAIT A MINUTE NOW DIANE STARTED THIS AND I WILL AND HAVE TO REMIND EVERYONE OF WHO SHE IS... IF DAVID THE MODERATOR OF THIS GROUP WANTS TO MODERATE HER THEN OK....IF NOT BE PREPARED FOR ME TO RESPOND TO HER LIES AND PROTECT THE WELL BEING OF PEOPLE ON THIS GROUP.. Â I'M SORRY IF IT OFFENDS YOU BUT SHE COULD END UP CAUSING A PERSON TO GET HURT WITH HER CRAP... Â Â NOT ON MY WATCH BABY JUST HIT DELETE THAT IS WHAT IT IS FOR....... Â Â From: hbotforhealth <diane@...> Subject: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? medicaid Date: Sunday, July 4, 2010, 12:42 PM Anyone can sue anyone for anything. Just because you have been sued does not make you guilty of anything. I am currently defending myself against the lawsuit from Oxyealth, unlike all of the other people who were sued by Oxyhealth for using their keywords on google. It's too bad that no one has sued Oxyhealth for all of their unethical behavior over the years. Maybe one day, their time will come. Diane > > > > > > > > Thank you so much for posting this. By the way you would not > believe the people that have contacted me that have chambers that have > been outfitted to 1.5 and who actually sold it to them. Some of our > worst critics.. I will forward you them later today ...I have to get my > but in Bed I just got off work... > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 5, 2010 Report Posted July 5, 2010 Also by the way I do think I brought this subject up and that is why you posted your post to begin with... Darin From: hbotforhealth <diane@...> Subject: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? medicaid Date: Sunday, July 4, 2010, 12:42 PM Anyone can sue anyone for anything. Just because you have been sued does not make you guilty of anything. I am currently defending myself against the lawsuit from Oxyealth, unlike all of the other people who were sued by Oxyhealth for using their keywords on google. It's too bad that no one has sued Oxyhealth for all of their unethical behavior over the years. Maybe one day, their time will come. Diane > > > > > > > > Thank you so much for posting this. By the way you would not > believe the people that have contacted me that have chambers that have > been outfitted to 1.5 and who actually sold it to them. Some of our > worst critics.. I will forward you them later today ...I have to get my > but in Bed I just got off work... > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 5, 2010 Report Posted July 5, 2010 1.5 ATA is safe to do in the home...   Everything was correct in your statement but the above mentioned. 1.5 is not exactly safe to do in a home settting speaking as a parent that had a child with O2 toxicity at 1.5 at home use I think it is fair for me to speak on this subject. I spoke to Dr. Harch and he told me what was wrong we followed his advise and the symptoms went away. Diane I ask you to not speak on something like this wothout the medical knowledge. This mother is asking about O2 Toxicity don't make her learn the hard way as I did. You could be responsible for her loved one going throught this without having to.. STOP THIS...  I wish Dr. Harch would get online and speak to this person and everyone on the group about this subject. can you get him to do so. Someone before Diane get's this lady's loved one in trouble. I don't think a former Real Estate Agent has the authority to speak on this subject.  Darin     From: hbotforhealth <diane@...> Subject: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? medicaid Date: Monday, July 5, 2010, 11:01 AM  Oxygen toxicity can happen at any pressure if the proper protocols are not followed. It does not matter if you are using a 1.3 ATA chamber domestically or a 1.5 ATA chamber internationally, or if you are going to a clinic for treatments. The key is to follow the proper protocols. That being said, the risk of oxygen toxicity is greater at higher pressures than at lower pressures. That is why mild HBOT at 1.3 ATA - 1.5 ATA is safe to do in the home, whereas higher pressure treatments are typically done in a clinical setting. Diane Quote
Guest guest Posted July 6, 2010 Report Posted July 6, 2010 I would never attack you I have no reason to. You are intitled to your veiw. I think it is very wise of you to stand up for and Diane afterall they are your allies as they helped you obtain your portable maybe. I have no Idea.  I think you have missed the last few weeks of disscusion. Diane was caught on a phone recorded conversation lyeing. If you will read corrrectly I told her most of her statements last time were correct but one. The one I was reffering to was 1.5 being a safe protocol for home use. That is incorrect.  Regarding this..DIane's past as a Real Estate Agent makes her unworthy to speak on oxygen toxicity.  Diane has no clue she is in it for the money and further more yes she sells houses and chambers has no clue as to what O2 toxcity is she proably never has even spoke to anyone that does.  Anyway your a sweet person I can tell that so No I'm not going to attack you. I think it was great of you to post the information you have. Now we know who's in bed with who on this chamber selling etc. I just never thought a clinic would support portables but you made it clear without saying it they do.. THANK'S  However I allready knew and have know for sometime. I just never said anything.. Darin 4312 Rains County Rd 1495Emory Texas 75440 From: S <rmcmillen@...> Subject: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? medicaid Date: Tuesday, July 6, 2010, 8:52 AM  Hello- I am going to come out of the woodwork to comment on this one. I've sat back while this ridiculous and often slanderous banter has gone on. I don't know any of you, except at Rapid Recovery where I went years ago. I know her well enough to know she doesn't participate in this " discussion " . She has better things to do, like healing people! A professional. And as far as Diane goes, say what you will, she has stayed above board while being attacked and attacked. Which for outsiders, like myself, speaks well of her. I AM going to take issue with your comment, Darin, that DIane's past as a Real Estate Agent makes her unworthy to speak on oxygen toxicity. That's absolutely ridiculous.. So, only a doctor should post on such issues in this group? Well, I'm an optometrist, granted a retired one, and I can assure you that Diane and probably most of you in this group are more knowlegeable about oxygen toxicity than me. Being a doctor isn't an immediate qualifier of anything. I think most of us could attest to that. I agree with the other poster about how one would assume that this group was set up for information. Yet it has become a platform for a couple people to attack one other, over and over. What is worrisome about it is both seem to be enjoying their " role " . Which makes one wonder. Again, that is a perspective from an outsider who has no axe to grind. That's it,,,now you can attack me. Maybe it will deflect a bit of it off DIane. Why she puts up with it, I don't know. But this forum certainly doesn't reflect well on the hyperbaric community. Strange Cheeseville And as far as why I am in this group, I do own a small hard chamber that for reasons to long to go into has been in storage for close to ten years. I'd hoped to just kind of " absorb " information on HBO again. Whew. Not in this group. > > > From: hbotforhealth <diane@...> > Subject: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? > medicaid > Date: Monday, July 5, 2010, 11:01 AM > > >  > > > > > Oxygen toxicity can happen at any pressure if the proper protocols are > not followed. It does not matter if you are using a 1.3 ATA chamber > domestically or a 1.5 ATA chamber internationally, or if you are going > to a clinic for treatments. The key is to follow the proper protocols. > That being said, the risk of oxygen toxicity is greater at higher > pressures than at lower pressures. That is why mild HBOT at 1.3 ATA - > 1.5 ATA is safe to do in the home, whereas higher pressure treatments > are typically done in a clinical setting. > > Diane > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 8, 2010 Report Posted July 8, 2010 >People have died from oxygen toxicity at pressures in excess of 1.5 ATA. Diane, Please reference. Thank you. Freels 2948 Windfield Circle Tucker, GA 30084-6714 770-491-6776 (phone) 404-725-4520 (cell) 815-366-7962 (fax) http://www.davidfreels.com mailto:david@... [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? > > >If you develop oxygen toxicity at 1.3 ATA or 1.5 ATA, taking a break >from HBOT will often cause the symptoms to reverse. If you develop >oxygen toxicity at higher pressures, the situation is much more serious. >People have died from oxygen toxicity at pressures in excess of 1.5 ATA. > >Diane > > >> >> Hello- >> >> I am going to come out of the woodwork to comment on this one. I've >sat back while this ridiculous and often slanderous banter has gone on. >I don't know any of you, except at Rapid Recovery where I went >years ago. I know her well enough to know she doesn't participate in >this " discussion " . She has better things to do, like healing people! A >professional. And as far as Diane goes, say what you will, she has >stayed above board while being attacked and attacked. Which for >outsiders, like myself, speaks well of her. >> >> I AM going to take issue with your comment, Darin, that DIane's past >as a Real Estate Agent makes her unworthy to speak on oxygen toxicity. >That's absolutely ridiculous.. So, only a doctor should post on such >issues in this group? Well, I'm an optometrist, granted a retired one, >and I can assure you that Diane and probably most of you in this group >are more knowlegeable about oxygen toxicity than me. Being a doctor >isn't an immediate qualifier of anything. I think most of us could >attest to that. >> >> I agree with the other poster about how one would assume that this >group was set up for information. Yet it has become a platform for a >couple people to attack one other, over and over. What is worrisome >about it is both seem to be enjoying their " role " . Which makes one >wonder. Again, that is a perspective from an outsider who has no axe to >grind. >> >> That's it,,,now you can attack me. Maybe it will deflect a bit of it >off DIane. Why she puts up with it, I don't know. But this forum >certainly doesn't reflect well on the hyperbaric community. >> >> Strange >> >> Cheeseville >> >> And as far as why I am in this group, I do own a small hard chamber >that for reasons to long to go into has been in storage for close to ten >years. I'd hoped to just >> kind of " absorb " information on HBO again. Whew. Not in this group. > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 8, 2010 Report Posted July 8, 2010 Diane do you ever reference anything. SO do you... From: hbotforhealth <diane@...> Subject: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? medicaid Date: Thursday, July 8, 2010, 7:14 AM Â If you develop oxygen toxicity at 1.3 ATA or 1.5 ATA, taking a break from HBOT will often cause the symptoms to reverse. If you develop oxygen toxicity at higher pressures, the situation is much more serious. People have died from oxygen toxicity at pressures in excess of 1.5 ATA. Diane > > Hello- > > I am going to come out of the woodwork to comment on this one. I've sat back while this ridiculous and often slanderous banter has gone on. I don't know any of you, except at Rapid Recovery where I went years ago. I know her well enough to know she doesn't participate in this " discussion " . She has better things to do, like healing people! A professional. And as far as Diane goes, say what you will, she has stayed above board while being attacked and attacked. Which for outsiders, like myself, speaks well of her. > > I AM going to take issue with your comment, Darin, that DIane's past as a Real Estate Agent makes her unworthy to speak on oxygen toxicity. That's absolutely ridiculous.. So, only a doctor should post on such issues in this group? Well, I'm an optometrist, granted a retired one, and I can assure you that Diane and probably most of you in this group are more knowlegeable about oxygen toxicity than me. Being a doctor isn't an immediate qualifier of anything. I think most of us could attest to that. > > I agree with the other poster about how one would assume that this group was set up for information. Yet it has become a platform for a couple people to attack one other, over and over. What is worrisome about it is both seem to be enjoying their " role " . Which makes one wonder. Again, that is a perspective from an outsider who has no axe to grind. > > That's it,,,now you can attack me. Maybe it will deflect a bit of it off DIane. Why she puts up with it, I don't know. But this forum certainly doesn't reflect well on the hyperbaric community. > > Strange > > Cheeseville > > And as far as why I am in this group, I do own a small hard chamber that for reasons to long to go into has been in storage for close to ten years. I'd hoped to just > kind of " absorb " information on HBO again. Whew. Not in this group. Quote
Guest guest Posted July 8, 2010 Report Posted July 8, 2010 These comments on the site by Diane recently have been aggravating in the extreme, shed no light on anything, and are offered by a woman who has, to my knowledge, no medical training. My opinion, the more I know about hyperbaric oxygen, is that it should be done under a physician's supervision, by prescription. I don't mean that a physician needs to necessarily be on-site. But the range of medical problems that people can have, with contra-indications for hyperbaric oxygen, are such that in my opinion, it is practicing medicine without a license to treat with hyperbaric oxygen without a physician's evaluation and appropriate supervision, as may be needed. I'm not trying to scare anyone away from hyperbaric medicine. I've seen it used with positive results on people with TBI, autism, stroke, anoxic brain injury, and diabetic non-healing wounds, without complication. I just would like to see the discussion assume a more rational and helpful course. I've now had two sets of hyperbaric oxygen treatment at 1.5 atm with 100 percent oxygen, twice daily M-F; the first was two years ago at Integrative Hyperbarics, in Madison, WI, which was very professional and I was very pleased with my treatment. The second 40 treatments were not done until March and April of this year, as cost was prohibitive to pay for it out of pocket before then. I got the second set of treatments, with the same protocol as was used in my first treatment, from Dr. Zant in Destin, Florida. He uses Seachrist chambers, whereas the Integrative Hyperbarics used Oxyhealth Baby Blue chambers. That was the main difference between the two treatments. Dr. Zant is taking part in the NBIRR study, a military protocol for returning GIs with TBI, and had access to the ANAM testing, which I got before and after treatment. Even as early as immediately after treatment, 3 of 5 cognitive funtions that were initially abnormal showed normalization; the other two were unchanged. However, I have continued to see improvement over time following my first treatment, and expect and hope that will be the case in this instance too. I've had to pay for all of my treatment out of pocket, and in the latest instance, had some help from a family member, and put the remainder on a line of credit, which I will have to pay off as I am able. I'm looking forward to the day when these treatments, which everyone who knows me will say have brought about tremendous improvement in my case, will be reimbursed for people with similar problems, by medicare and Tricare, and other insurance. My cost, for treatment, and room and board out of town, has been approximately $6,500 each time. I'm sure other people have had to pay more, as the average cost at most centers for people paying on their own is about $200/treatment. I have been fortunate to get discounts in each case. I will go into retirement in a few years with no savings other than a small annuity, and social security. I can ill afford these medical expenses, but I chose to do it in hopes of being able to live a more normal life, and I am glad I made that decision. , MD TBI survivor ________________________________ From: Freels <dfreels@...> medicaid Sent: Thu, July 8, 2010 10:13:18 AM Subject: Re: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? >People have died from oxygen toxicity at pressures in excess of 1.5 ATA. Diane, Please reference. Thank you. Freels 2948 Windfield Circle Tucker, GA 30084-6714 770-491-6776 (phone) 404-725-4520 (cell) 815-366-7962 (fax) http://www.davidfreels.com mailto:david@... [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? > > >If you develop oxygen toxicity at 1.3 ATA or 1.5 ATA, taking a break >from HBOT will often cause the symptoms to reverse. If you develop >oxygen toxicity at higher pressures, the situation is much more serious. >People have died from oxygen toxicity at pressures in excess of 1.5 ATA. > >Diane > > >> >> Hello- >> >> I am going to come out of the woodwork to comment on this one. I've >sat back while this ridiculous and often slanderous banter has gone on. >I don't know any of you, except at Rapid Recovery where I went >years ago. I know her well enough to know she doesn't participate in >this " discussion " . She has better things to do, like healing people! A >professional. And as far as Diane goes, say what you will, she has >stayed above board while being attacked and attacked. Which for >outsiders, like myself, speaks well of her. >> >> I AM going to take issue with your comment, Darin, that DIane's past >as a Real Estate Agent makes her unworthy to speak on oxygen toxicity. >That's absolutely ridiculous.. So, only a doctor should post on such >issues in this group? Well, I'm an optometrist, granted a retired one, >and I can assure you that Diane and probably most of you in this group >are more knowlegeable about oxygen toxicity than me. Being a doctor >isn't an immediate qualifier of anything. I think most of us could >attest to that. >> >> I agree with the other poster about how one would assume that this >group was set up for information. Yet it has become a platform for a >couple people to attack one other, over and over. What is worrisome >about it is both seem to be enjoying their " role " . Which makes one >wonder. Again, that is a perspective from an outsider who has no axe to >grind. >> >> That's it,,,now you can attack me. Maybe it will deflect a bit of it >off DIane. Why she puts up with it, I don't know. But this forum >certainly doesn't reflect well on the hyperbaric community. >> >> Strange >> >> Cheeseville >> >> And as far as why I am in this group, I do own a small hard chamber >that for reasons to long to go into has been in storage for close to ten >years. I'd hoped to just >> kind of " absorb " information on HBO again. Whew. Not in this group. > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 9, 2010 Report Posted July 9, 2010 Diane, This is unacceptable. This is not a reference at all, but a hearsay statement that you assert came from a physician. This means nothing. Do you have anything in writing from Dr. Whitaker? Do you have any kind of documentation to substantiate your claims? Let me explain this to you. You are seen as a dishonest person because you repeatedly make unsubstantiated claims about Hyperbaric Medicine. You might remember that I suspended your ability to post unmoderated on this list a year or 2 ago. I was so concerned then about statements you were making that I personally contacted the FDA to bring you to their attention. A few weeks later three people with FDA email addresses joined the group, and it was my assumption they joined so as to document your statements. That's when I changed your status back to unmoderated. I wanted you to say things to incriminate yourself, which you've done. I have a vested interest in hyperbarics. HBOT has permanently improved my son's quality of life. I believe that a cure for brain-injury might be discovered if adequate research dollars were invested, but I also know there is no one who has those resources in the private sector, which is why I started this group. So far 23 of 50 states have covered HBOT for pediatric brain-injury via the EPSDT statute. Once we reach 25 or 26 states, the US Congress will have a legal obligation to invest in that research. At the same time, I also follow what other so-called professionals say about HBOT. Specifically, orthopedic surgeons and pediatric neurologists and also the UHMS membership. All three of these groups have a vested interest in maintaining the status quo. For example, children like my son generate millions of dollars worth of surgeries by the time they reach adulthood. My son has never been under the knife, thanks to HBOT. This fact can be repeated by thousands of other brain-injured children who've been fortunate enough to receive HBOT. This threatens the status quo. At the same time, the status quo would love nothing better than to have a legal excuse to ban the use of HBOT--in any form--for brain-injured children. Should such a ban occur, which is very possible under the current government, the opportunity for investment into discovering the full potential of HBOT will be lost, and that means my son's opportunity will be lost. Therefore Diane, what you do, what you say, and how you say it--this all has a direct impact on my son's quality of life and the lives of all brain-injured children whose parents are members of the listserv. I realized this a year or two ago, and that's why I removed all moderation from your posts. I wanted you to say and do things so that you would hang yourself. I believe you will eventually go to jail for what you have done. I have allowed you to do this because I believe it is the best way for me to protect my son's interests. Let me give you a couple of examples of documentation that prove my claims about you, and this is the level of documentation members of this group expect you to produce every time you make a statement or claim--without anyone having to then follow-up on your statements with a request for you to document your statements. You should document each and every claim automatically. Your inherent dishonesty in the way you choose to do business has now rendered a Federal court decision against you in a lawsuit where you are now at least partially liable for a $12,000,000 judgement that you must pay to Oxyhealth. See HBOTruth.com. Further, your inherent dishonesty in the way you sell/market portable chambers in direct violation of FDA law is documented and published on the web at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e-9wn3BNa-Y & hd=1 Lastly, your pseudo-quote of n Whitaker is of no value and is probably false--which means you are probably also guilty of slander and/or libel. At the 6th HBOT Symposium in 2008, Dr. Whitaker spoke in an after-dinner lecture I believe on the second night. His topic was theoretically increasing the use of CO2 during hyperbaric treatment so as to induce dilation of the capillaries and then theoretically increase the amount of oxygen actually delivered under pressure. A fairly raucous discussion ensued followed by an intense debate. It was obvious that Dr. Whitaker really didn't understand Hyperbaric Medicine because what he was actually proposing was the introduction of a new variable into the equation that would not only be impossible to moderate or control but would also most likely result in oxygen toxicity for the patient. Whitaker's response? He was unfamiliar with oxygen toxicity. DF [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? > > >I spoke to Dr. n Whitaker about HBOT earlier this year, and he told >me about several patients who had died from oxygen toxicity in hard >chambers. I've never heard of any deaths from oxygen toxicity in >portable chambers, presumably because the lower pressures are much >safer. > >Diane > > >> >> >> >> Hello- >> >> >> >> I am going to come out of the woodwork to comment on this one. I've >> >sat back while this ridiculous and often slanderous banter has gone >on. >> >I don't know any of you, except at Rapid Recovery where I went >> >years ago. I know her well enough to know she doesn't participate in >> >this " discussion " . She has better things to do, like healing people! >A >> >professional. And as far as Diane goes, say what you will, she has >> >stayed above board while being attacked and attacked. Which for >> >outsiders, like myself, speaks well of her. >> >> >> >> I AM going to take issue with your comment, Darin, that DIane's >past >> >as a Real Estate Agent makes her unworthy to speak on oxygen >toxicity. >> >That's absolutely ridiculous.. So, only a doctor should post on such >> >issues in this group? Well, I'm an optometrist, granted a retired >one, >> >and I can assure you that Diane and probably most of you in this >group >> >are more knowlegeable about oxygen toxicity than me. Being a doctor >> >isn't an immediate qualifier of anything. I think most of us could >> >attest to that. >> >> >> >> I agree with the other poster about how one would assume that this >> >group was set up for information. Yet it has become a platform for a >> >couple people to attack one other, over and over. What is worrisome >> >about it is both seem to be enjoying their " role " . Which makes one >> >wonder. Again, that is a perspective from an outsider who has no axe >to >> >grind. >> >> >> >> That's it,,,now you can attack me. Maybe it will deflect a bit of >it >> >off DIane. Why she puts up with it, I don't know. But this forum >> >certainly doesn't reflect well on the hyperbaric community. >> >> >> >> Strange >> >> >> >> Cheeseville >> >> >> >> And as far as why I am in this group, I do own a small hard chamber >> >that for reasons to long to go into has been in storage for close to >ten >> >years. I'd hoped to just >> >> kind of " absorb " information on HBO again. Whew. Not in this group. >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 10, 2010 Report Posted July 10, 2010 Diane your digging yourself a deeper hole.. I'm not going anywhere.. Funny thing is these people may not vare that your killing people by selling altered unapproved devices to them but I do. I care about there loved ones etc. I may be laughed at talked about or even made fun of called names etc. But I'm fighting.... Â I have seen O2 toxicity first hand. I seen what a medical device can do if not properly maintained we all have.. Florida Fire. Kenitz reported the problems way before the fire and no one een cared they made fun of her etc. Well today there is a mother without a child and a mother today her child was burnt up in that chamber allong with the childs grandmother. IF someone had listened to s complaints those peopel woudl be alive today. Â Now your sellling up approved devices etc. IT is clear that it is against the law the lawsuit states that. So now how long will it take for someone to be killed in one of you un approved devices or hurt. Will they say then I should have listed to Darin. I'm documenting everything when it happens I'm flying to that location and boy I'm having a Media feild day of I told you so.... Â Darin From: hbotforhealth <diane@...> Subject: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? medicaid Date: Saturday, July 10, 2010, 3:29 AM Â Wisconsin Integrative Hyperbarics is owned by Oxyheath. Of course they use Oxyhealth chambers at their own clinic. They also use their own chambers at the other clinic that they own, California Integrative Hyperbarics. Diane > > These comments on the site by Diane recently have been aggravating in the > extreme, shed no light on anything, and are offered by a woman who has, to my > knowledge, no medical training. > > My opinion, the more I know about hyperbaric oxygen, is that it should be done > under a physician's supervision, by prescription. I don't mean that a physician > needs to necessarily be on-site. But the range of medical problems that people > can have, with contra-indications for hyperbaric oxygen, are such that in my > opinion, it is practicing medicine without a license to treat with hyperbaric > oxygen without a physician's evaluation and appropriate supervision, as may be > needed. > > I'm not trying to scare anyone away from hyperbaric medicine. I've seen it used > with positive results on people with TBI, autism, stroke, anoxic brain injury, > and diabetic non-healing wounds, without complication. I just would like to see > the discussion assume a more rational and helpful course. > > I've now had two sets of hyperbaric oxygen treatment at 1.5 atm with 100 percent > oxygen, twice daily M-F; the first was two years ago at Integrative Hyperbarics, > in Madison, WI, which was very professional and I was very pleased with my > treatment. The second 40 treatments were not done until March and April of this > year, as cost was prohibitive to pay for it out of pocket before then. I got the > second set of treatments, with the same protocol as was used in my first > treatment, from Dr. Zant in Destin, Florida. He uses Seachrist chambers, whereas > the Integrative Hyperbarics used Oxyhealth Baby Blue chambers. That was the main > difference between the two treatments. > > Dr. Zant is taking part in the NBIRR study, a military protocol for returning > GIs with TBI, and had access to the ANAM testing, which I got before and after > treatment. Even as early as immediately after treatment, 3 of 5 cognitive > funtions that were initially abnormal showed normalization; the other two were > unchanged. However, I have continued to see improvement over time following my > first treatment, and expect and hope that will be the case in this instance too. > I've had to pay for all of my treatment out of pocket, and in the latest > instance, had some help from a family member, and put the remainder on a line of > credit, which I will have to pay off as I am able. > > I'm looking forward to the day when these treatments, which everyone who knows > me will say have brought about tremendous improvement in my case, will be > reimbursed for people with similar problems, by medicare and Tricare, and other > insurance. My cost, for treatment, and room and board out of town, has been > approximately $6,500 each time. I'm sure other people have had to pay more, as > the average cost at most centers for people paying on their own is about > $200/treatment. I have been fortunate to get discounts in each case. I will go > into retirement in a few years with no savings other than a small annuity, and > social security. I can ill afford these medical expenses, but I chose to do it > in hopes of being able to live a more normal life, and I am glad I made that > decision. > > , MD > TBI survivor Quote
Guest guest Posted July 11, 2010 Report Posted July 11, 2010 This message is to Diane regarding  Wisconsin Integrative Hyperbarics is owned by Oxyheath. Of course they > use Oxyhealth chambers at their own clinic. They also use their own > chambers at the other clinic that they own, California Integrative > Hyperbarics. > > Diane  Why would they not use there chambers they are approved and not altered. YOur's on the other hand were done illegal. You have a law suit against you that say's so. I think that in itself speaks volume. Darin From: Crystal <cmjaczzy@...> Subject: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? medicaid Date: Saturday, July 10, 2010, 8:40 PM  THANK YOU RACHEL! This has been the best post on this site. I have RSD and have just finished my first 10 dives. I also have to pay. > > > > These comments on the site by Diane recently have been aggravating in > the > > extreme, shed no light on anything, and are offered by a woman who > has, to my > > knowledge, no medical training. > > > > My opinion, the more I know about hyperbaric oxygen, is that it should > be done > > under a physician's supervision, by prescription. I don't mean that a > physician > > needs to necessarily be on-site. But the range of medical problems > that people > > can have, with contra-indications for hyperbaric oxygen, are such that > in my > > opinion, it is practicing medicine without a license to treat with > hyperbaric > > oxygen without a physician's evaluation and appropriate supervision, > as may be > > needed. > > > > I'm not trying to scare anyone away from hyperbaric medicine. I've > seen it used > > with positive results on people with TBI, autism, stroke, anoxic brain > injury, > > and diabetic non-healing wounds, without complication. I just would > like to see > > the discussion assume a more rational and helpful course. > > > > I've now had two sets of hyperbaric oxygen treatment at 1.5 atm with > 100 percent > > oxygen, twice daily M-F; the first was two years ago at Integrative > Hyperbarics, > > in Madison, WI, which was very professional and I was very pleased > with my > > treatment. The second 40 treatments were not done until March and > April of this > > year, as cost was prohibitive to pay for it out of pocket before then. > I got the > > second set of treatments, with the same protocol as was used in my > first > > treatment, from Dr. Zant in Destin, Florida. He uses Seachrist > chambers, whereas > > the Integrative Hyperbarics used Oxyhealth Baby Blue chambers. That > was the main > > difference between the two treatments. > > > > Dr. Zant is taking part in the NBIRR study, a military protocol for > returning > > GIs with TBI, and had access to the ANAM testing, which I got before > and after > > treatment. Even as early as immediately after treatment, 3 of 5 > cognitive > > funtions that were initially abnormal showed normalization; the other > two were > > unchanged. However, I have continued to see improvement over time > following my > > first treatment, and expect and hope that will be the case in this > instance too. > > I've had to pay for all of my treatment out of pocket, and in the > latest > > instance, had some help from a family member, and put the remainder on > a line of > > credit, which I will have to pay off as I am able. > > > > I'm looking forward to the day when these treatments, which everyone > who knows > > me will say have brought about tremendous improvement in my case, will > be > > reimbursed for people with similar problems, by medicare and Tricare, > and other > > insurance. My cost, for treatment, and room and board out of town, has > been > > approximately $6,500 each time. I'm sure other people have had to pay > more, as > > the average cost at most centers for people paying on their own is > about > > $200/treatment. I have been fortunate to get discounts in each case. I > will go > > into retirement in a few years with no savings other than a small > annuity, and > > social security. I can ill afford these medical expenses, but I chose > to do it > > in hopes of being able to live a more normal life, and I am glad I > made that > > decision. > > > > , MD > > TBI survivor > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 11, 2010 Report Posted July 11, 2010 Diane I agree witht he following. Now that I have answered yoru question do you think you can answer mine or 's? You seem to want to ask questions but never answer them.    Quamvis™ 270 and Quamvis™ 320  Our new and improved portable hyperbaric chamber was designed and manufactured to meet the rigorous PVHO guidelines in order to provide the most durable soft chamber on the market. Designed to be tough and durable, these chambers provide added reinforcement while maintaining their practicality and comfort. Available with either a 27 " or 32 " diameter the Quamvis is all about giving the best flexibility in pressure protocols in a portable design. Meets stringent PVHO Non-Mandatory Appendix ultimate strength requirement 4 psi portable mild hyperbaric chamber Pressure tested beyond 24 psi to exceed PVHO-1 safety requirements 44 oz urethane bladder with proprietary “SteelWeld†seams Extreme performance reinforcing ballistic nylon jacket with Lexan® mix viewing windows External “SafeSet†buckling system for additional secure enclosure support Designed for improved airflow throughout chamber Rigid frame maintains form when deflated Medical pass-through—facilitates external device hookup Clean air compressor—double head, oil-less, dual intake filters High efficiency in-line filtration system—filters to 0.01 microns Bolster set—cradles and stabilizes chamber when inflated Custom mattress—contoured to fit inside the chamber Chamber carry From: hbotforhealth <diane@...> Subject: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? medicaid Date: Sunday, July 11, 2010, 6:18 AM  Do you think that it is safe to use a Quamvis chamber at 1.5 ATA? Diane > > > > > > These comments on the site by Diane recently have been aggravating in > > the > > > extreme, shed no light on anything, and are offered by a woman who > > has, to my > > > knowledge, no medical training. > > > > > > My opinion, the more I know about hyperbaric oxygen, is that it should > > be done > > > under a physician's supervision, by prescription. I don't mean that a > > physician > > > needs to necessarily be on-site. But the range of medical problems > > that people > > > can have, with contra-indications for hyperbaric oxygen, are such that > > in my > > > opinion, it is practicing medicine without a license to treat with > > hyperbaric > > > oxygen without a physician's evaluation and appropriate supervision, > > as may be > > > needed. > > > > > > I'm not trying to scare anyone away from hyperbaric medicine. I've > > seen it used > > > with positive results on people with TBI, autism, stroke, anoxic brain > > injury, > > > and diabetic non-healing wounds, without complication. I just would > > like to see > > > the discussion assume a more rational and helpful course. > > > > > > I've now had two sets of hyperbaric oxygen treatment at 1.5 atm with > > 100 percent > > > oxygen, twice daily M-F; the first was two years ago at Integrative > > Hyperbarics, > > > in Madison, WI, which was very professional and I was very pleased > > with my > > > treatment. The second 40 treatments were not done until March and > > April of this > > > year, as cost was prohibitive to pay for it out of pocket before then. > > I got the > > > second set of treatments, with the same protocol as was used in my > > first > > > treatment, from Dr. Zant in Destin, Florida. He uses Seachrist > > chambers, whereas > > > the Integrative Hyperbarics used Oxyhealth Baby Blue chambers. That > > was the main > > > difference between the two treatments. > > > > > > Dr. Zant is taking part in the NBIRR study, a military protocol for > > returning > > > GIs with TBI, and had access to the ANAM testing, which I got before > > and after > > > treatment. Even as early as immediately after treatment, 3 of 5 > > cognitive > > > funtions that were initially abnormal showed normalization; the other > > two were > > > unchanged. However, I have continued to see improvement over time > > following my > > > first treatment, and expect and hope that will be the case in this > > instance too. > > > I've had to pay for all of my treatment out of pocket, and in the > > latest > > > instance, had some help from a family member, and put the remainder on > > a line of > > > credit, which I will have to pay off as I am able. > > > > > > I'm looking forward to the day when these treatments, which everyone > > who knows > > > me will say have brought about tremendous improvement in my case, will > > be > > > reimbursed for people with similar problems, by medicare and Tricare, > > and other > > > insurance. My cost, for treatment, and room and board out of town, has > > been > > > approximately $6,500 each time. I'm sure other people have had to pay > > more, as > > > the average cost at most centers for people paying on their own is > > about > > > $200/treatment. I have been fortunate to get discounts in each case. I > > will go > > > into retirement in a few years with no savings other than a small > > annuity, and > > > social security. I can ill afford these medical expenses, but I chose > > to do it > > > in hopes of being able to live a more normal life, and I am glad I > > made that > > > decision. > > > > > > , MD > > > TBI survivor > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 11, 2010 Report Posted July 11, 2010 Diane I do notr work for Oxyhealth they are just good freinds of mine but regarding your answer if you were implying that I or Oxyhealth agree with altering a Chamber you may want to visit there web page and see it is published to the world at http://www.oxyhealth.com/fda-legality.html  However since your having a hard time finding it and you can never get to resoruces and must not be able to do a google search because you can never provide references so that must mean your not able to look them up or your to lazy. So here is what I have done for you I have posted the page for you please read the following.  The Illegal Modification of a Chamber  The recent increase in number of calls to our staff at OxyHealth, LLC, regarding the modification of chambers is a great cause of alarm to our company. With over ten years of experience building hyperbaric chambers and having over 7000 chambers in circulation, OxyHealth, LLC is universally recognized as the authority in the field of soft-chamber portable hyperbarics. Our acknowledged experience is the reason why many Doctors, Chiropractors, and other medical practitioners have brought their concerns to us regarding certain modifications to soft hyperbaric chambers that have been advanced on the internet.  Modifying Your Chamber is both illegal and potentially harmful.  A portable hyperbaric chamber is a prescriptive device regulated by the FDA. OxyHealth, LLC facilities have been audited by the FDA and our procedures meet their stringent requirements. Our commitment to safety has helped us to produce a chamber that has been well over-built. Even still, we would NEVER encourage any modification that would increase the amount of pressure beyond that approved by the FDA. When a chamber is modified, the FDA considers it “adultered†and it immediately loses its 510K clearance (the FDA’s safety compliance approval for medical devices). After spending time and money to purchase an FDA regulated quality chamber, all those assurances are stripped away and your investment is completely compromised. It would be like purchasing a medical grade oxygen concentrator, then swapping it for a welder’s concentrator – the assurance for human consumption is gone and any use of the product would be suspect.  To continue to use an adultered prescriptive device is illegal.  If a practice is found to be using a modified chamber, it can be shut down and the person(s) found using that chamber may be prosecuted as well as held personally liable. It is perceived by the “law†that you have combined two items in an illegal manner – similar to the drunk driver that mixes excess alcohol consumption with driving. The car manufacturer or distillery is not arrested - just the driver. Because a chamber is a physical device, some people falsely believe that there is no real harm in making a modification to it. However, this modification is viewed by the FDA as being just as illegal as modifying Sudafed to produce crystal meth. You may get instructions and an adaptation kit over the internet from someone working out of a rented garage, but please think twice. If you have an issue with the FDA or a patient, those people who provided the adaptation equipment would be the first to disappear, taking no accountability for the problem they created. The risk to yourself and your patients are just not worth it.  Why at OxyHealth, LLC do we care what people do after they purchase a chamber?  We care because our friends and families use our chambers. We care because we have built long-term relationships with the professional and personal communities that rely on our chambers on a daily basis. After ten years in this industry, we have built a reputation for quality, safety, and customer care that we are proud to maintain. At OxyHealth, LLC, a team of over 50 “care†professionals stands behind every chamber. It is important to the physicians who rely on OxyHealth chambers for their practices and medical research, as well as to the very patients who use OxyHealth chambers. We have worked diligently over the past 10 years and have delivered over 1.5 million treatments annually in OxyHealth chambers to confidently present to our customers their chamber at optimum operational condition From: hbotforhealth <diane@...> Subject: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? medicaid Date: Sunday, July 11, 2010, 6:18 AM  Do you think that it is safe to use a Quamvis chamber at 1.5 ATA? Diane > > > > > > These comments on the site by Diane recently have been aggravating in > > the > > > extreme, shed no light on anything, and are offered by a woman who > > has, to my > > > knowledge, no medical training. > > > > > > My opinion, the more I know about hyperbaric oxygen, is that it should > > be done > > > under a physician's supervision, by prescription. I don't mean that a > > physician > > > needs to necessarily be on-site. But the range of medical problems > > that people > > > can have, with contra-indications for hyperbaric oxygen, are such that > > in my > > > opinion, it is practicing medicine without a license to treat with > > hyperbaric > > > oxygen without a physician's evaluation and appropriate supervision, > > as may be > > > needed. > > > > > > I'm not trying to scare anyone away from hyperbaric medicine. I've > > seen it used > > > with positive results on people with TBI, autism, stroke, anoxic brain > > injury, > > > and diabetic non-healing wounds, without complication. I just would > > like to see > > > the discussion assume a more rational and helpful course. > > > > > > I've now had two sets of hyperbaric oxygen treatment at 1.5 atm with > > 100 percent > > > oxygen, twice daily M-F; the first was two years ago at Integrative > > Hyperbarics, > > > in Madison, WI, which was very professional and I was very pleased > > with my > > > treatment. The second 40 treatments were not done until March and > > April of this > > > year, as cost was prohibitive to pay for it out of pocket before then. > > I got the > > > second set of treatments, with the same protocol as was used in my > > first > > > treatment, from Dr. Zant in Destin, Florida. He uses Seachrist > > chambers, whereas > > > the Integrative Hyperbarics used Oxyhealth Baby Blue chambers. That > > was the main > > > difference between the two treatments. > > > > > > Dr. Zant is taking part in the NBIRR study, a military protocol for > > returning > > > GIs with TBI, and had access to the ANAM testing, which I got before > > and after > > > treatment. Even as early as immediately after treatment, 3 of 5 > > cognitive > > > funtions that were initially abnormal showed normalization; the other > > two were > > > unchanged. However, I have continued to see improvement over time > > following my > > > first treatment, and expect and hope that will be the case in this > > instance too. > > > I've had to pay for all of my treatment out of pocket, and in the > > latest > > > instance, had some help from a family member, and put the remainder on > > a line of > > > credit, which I will have to pay off as I am able. > > > > > > I'm looking forward to the day when these treatments, which everyone > > who knows > > > me will say have brought about tremendous improvement in my case, will > > be > > > reimbursed for people with similar problems, by medicare and Tricare, > > and other > > > insurance. My cost, for treatment, and room and board out of town, has > > been > > > approximately $6,500 each time. I'm sure other people have had to pay > > more, as > > > the average cost at most centers for people paying on their own is > > about > > > $200/treatment. I have been fortunate to get discounts in each case. I > > will go > > > into retirement in a few years with no savings other than a small > > annuity, and > > > social security. I can ill afford these medical expenses, but I chose > > to do it > > > in hopes of being able to live a more normal life, and I am glad I > > made that > > > decision. > > > > > > , MD > > > TBI survivor > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 11, 2010 Report Posted July 11, 2010 Diane, First, they do not use Quamvis chambers in either clinic. Second, it is irrelevant. This is not a debate on manufacturers but is a debate regarding the safety of home chambers at 1.5 ata. With that being said, the issue of 1.5 ata is not the safety issue. The use of 1.5 ata with supplemental oxygen is a safety concern. Using 1.5 ata without the use of supplemental oxygen will not create oxygen toxicity problems. It may become a problem when supplemental oxygen is introduced. Due to there being a chance of oxygen toxicity, regardless of how small of a chance it is, one must consider it a safety factor. Also, since many people will introduce supplemental oxygen regardless of being told not to, all 1.5 chambers should be considered a safety issue. Therefore, the use of 1.5 ata chambers in a home setting should not be allowed. The bigger issue is that the sale of 1.5 ata chambers, along this the export of these chambers, is illegal.  It does not matter who manufactures them. What is illegal is illegal. Let's not try to divert the conversations in order to avoid the subject. Brett From: hbotforhealth <diane@...> Subject: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? medicaid Date: Sunday, July 11, 2010, 6:18 AM  Do you think that it is safe to use a Quamvis chamber at 1.5 ATA? Diane > > > > > > These comments on the site by Diane recently have been aggravating in > > the > > > extreme, shed no light on anything, and are offered by a woman who > > has, to my > > > knowledge, no medical training. > > > > > > My opinion, the more I know about hyperbaric oxygen, is that it should > > be done > > > under a physician's supervision, by prescription. I don't mean that a > > physician > > > needs to necessarily be on-site. But the range of medical problems > > that people > > > can have, with contra-indications for hyperbaric oxygen, are such that > > in my > > > opinion, it is practicing medicine without a license to treat with > > hyperbaric > > > oxygen without a physician's evaluation and appropriate supervision, > > as may be > > > needed. > > > > > > I'm not trying to scare anyone away from hyperbaric medicine. I've > > seen it used > > > with positive results on people with TBI, autism, stroke, anoxic brain > > injury, > > > and diabetic non-healing wounds, without complication. I just would > > like to see > > > the discussion assume a more rational and helpful course. > > > > > > I've now had two sets of hyperbaric oxygen treatment at 1.5 atm with > > 100 percent > > > oxygen, twice daily M-F; the first was two years ago at Integrative > > Hyperbarics, > > > in Madison, WI, which was very professional and I was very pleased > > with my > > > treatment. The second 40 treatments were not done until March and > > April of this > > > year, as cost was prohibitive to pay for it out of pocket before then. > > I got the > > > second set of treatments, with the same protocol as was used in my > > first > > > treatment, from Dr. Zant in Destin, Florida. He uses Seachrist > > chambers, whereas > > > the Integrative Hyperbarics used Oxyhealth Baby Blue chambers. That > > was the main > > > difference between the two treatments. > > > > > > Dr. Zant is taking part in the NBIRR study, a military protocol for > > returning > > > GIs with TBI, and had access to the ANAM testing, which I got before > > and after > > > treatment. Even as early as immediately after treatment, 3 of 5 > > cognitive > > > funtions that were initially abnormal showed normalization; the other > > two were > > > unchanged. However, I have continued to see improvement over time > > following my > > > first treatment, and expect and hope that will be the case in this > > instance too. > > > I've had to pay for all of my treatment out of pocket, and in the > > latest > > > instance, had some help from a family member, and put the remainder on > > a line of > > > credit, which I will have to pay off as I am able. > > > > > > I'm looking forward to the day when these treatments, which everyone > > who knows > > > me will say have brought about tremendous improvement in my case, will > > be > > > reimbursed for people with similar problems, by medicare and Tricare, > > and other > > > insurance. My cost, for treatment, and room and board out of town, has > > been > > > approximately $6,500 each time. I'm sure other people have had to pay > > more, as > > > the average cost at most centers for people paying on their own is > > about > > > $200/treatment. I have been fortunate to get discounts in each case. I > > will go > > > into retirement in a few years with no savings other than a small > > annuity, and > > > social security. I can ill afford these medical expenses, but I chose > > to do it > > > in hopes of being able to live a more normal life, and I am glad I > > made that > > > decision. > > > > > > , MD > > > TBI survivor > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 11, 2010 Report Posted July 11, 2010 Brett, I don't think I agree with the logic that since many people will abuse the chambers, it should be illegal. People abuse LOTS of things, but that doesn't mean they should be illegal. People abuse junk food, but there is nothing on the horizon outlawing Big Macs. Believe me, a LOT more people are dying of complications of abusing food (of any kind) than I think will ever CONSIDER risking oxygen toxicity. I think the level of risk is the concern, and I don't have numbers on that and am not aware that there is a specific amount of exposure that creates toxicity for everyone. I have known of children who reacted poorly to 100% O2 and others who don't respond to anything less than 100% O2. What is toxic for one creates healing for another. So it should be illegal for everyone? Not trying to be contentious, I just want to err on the side of people being free to make their own choices once they are informed of risk. Once freedom of choice is available, there WILL BE people who make bad choices and hurt themselves/loved ones. It is the price of free choice. On Sun, Jul 11, 2010 at 9:42 PM, brett szymonski <szymonski@...>wrote: > > > Diane, > > First, they do not use Quamvis chambers in either clinic. Second, it is > irrelevant. This is not a debate on manufacturers but is a debate regarding > the safety of home chambers at 1.5 ata. > > With that being said, the issue of 1.5 ata is not the safety issue. The > use of 1.5 ata with supplemental oxygen is a safety concern. Using 1.5 ata > without the use of supplemental oxygen will not create oxygen toxicity > problems. It may become a problem when supplemental oxygen is introduced. > Due to there being a chance of oxygen toxicity, regardless of how small of a > chance it is, one must consider it a safety factor. Also, since many people > will introduce supplemental oxygen regardless of being told not to, all 1.5 > chambers should be considered a safety issue. Therefore, the use of 1.5 ata > chambers in a home setting should not be allowed. > > The bigger issue is that the sale of 1.5 ata chambers, along this the > export of these chambers, is illegal. It does not matter who manufactures > them. What is illegal is illegal. Let's not try to divert the > conversations in order to avoid the subject. > > Brett > > > > From: hbotforhealth <diane@... <diane%40healingdives.com>> > Subject: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? > medicaid <medicaid%40> > Date: Sunday, July 11, 2010, 6:18 AM > > > > Do you think that it is safe to use a Quamvis chamber at 1.5 ATA? > > Diane > > > > > > > > > > > > These comments on the site by Diane recently have been aggravating > > in > > > > the > > > > > extreme, shed no light on anything, and are offered by a woman who > > > > has, to my > > > > > knowledge, no medical training. > > > > > > > > > > My opinion, the more I know about hyperbaric oxygen, is that it > > should > > > > be done > > > > > under a physician's supervision, by prescription. I don't mean > > that a > > > > physician > > > > > needs to necessarily be on-site. But the range of medical problems > > > > that people > > > > > can have, with contra-indications for hyperbaric oxygen, are such > > that > > > > in my > > > > > opinion, it is practicing medicine without a license to treat with > > > > hyperbaric > > > > > oxygen without a physician's evaluation and appropriate > > supervision, > > > > as may be > > > > > needed. > > > > > > > > > > I'm not trying to scare anyone away from hyperbaric medicine. I've > > > > seen it used > > > > > with positive results on people with TBI, autism, stroke, anoxic > > brain > > > > injury, > > > > > and diabetic non-healing wounds, without complication. I just > > would > > > > like to see > > > > > the discussion assume a more rational and helpful course. > > > > > > > > > > I've now had two sets of hyperbaric oxygen treatment at 1.5 atm > > with > > > > 100 percent > > > > > oxygen, twice daily M-F; the first was two years ago at > > Integrative > > > > Hyperbarics, > > > > > in Madison, WI, which was very professional and I was very pleased > > > > with my > > > > > treatment. The second 40 treatments were not done until March and > > > > April of this > > > > > year, as cost was prohibitive to pay for it out of pocket before > > then. > > > > I got the > > > > > second set of treatments, with the same protocol as was used in my > > > > first > > > > > treatment, from Dr. Zant in Destin, Florida. He uses Seachrist > > > > chambers, whereas > > > > > the Integrative Hyperbarics used Oxyhealth Baby Blue chambers. > > That > > > > was the main > > > > > difference between the two treatments. > > > > > > > > > > Dr. Zant is taking part in the NBIRR study, a military protocol > > for > > > > returning > > > > > GIs with TBI, and had access to the ANAM testing, which I got > > before > > > > and after > > > > > treatment. Even as early as immediately after treatment, 3 of 5 > > > > cognitive > > > > > funtions that were initially abnormal showed normalization; the > > other > > > > two were > > > > > unchanged. However, I have continued to see improvement over time > > > > following my > > > > > first treatment, and expect and hope that will be the case in this > > > > instance too. > > > > > I've had to pay for all of my treatment out of pocket, and in the > > > > latest > > > > > instance, had some help from a family member, and put the > > remainder on > > > > a line of > > > > > credit, which I will have to pay off as I am able. > > > > > > > > > > I'm looking forward to the day when these treatments, which > > everyone > > > > who knows > > > > > me will say have brought about tremendous improvement in my case, > > will > > > > be > > > > > reimbursed for people with similar problems, by medicare and > > Tricare, > > > > and other > > > > > insurance. My cost, for treatment, and room and board out of town, > > has > > > > been > > > > > approximately $6,500 each time. I'm sure other people have had to > > pay > > > > more, as > > > > > the average cost at most centers for people paying on their own is > > > > about > > > > > $200/treatment. I have been fortunate to get discounts in each > > case. I > > > > will go > > > > > into retirement in a few years with no savings other than a small > > > > annuity, and > > > > > social security. I can ill afford these medical expenses, but I > > chose > > > > to do it > > > > > in hopes of being able to live a more normal life, and I am glad I > > > > made that > > > > > decision. > > > > > > > > > > , MD > > > > > TBI survivor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 11, 2010 Report Posted July 11, 2010 Well written, Brett. Thanks. Diane stated in an earlier email that Integrative Hyperbarics in Madison, WI, is owned by Oxyhealth; that's news to me. This was not the impression I had during the month I was treated there. Nor do I find any evidence on either Oxyhealth's site or Integrative Hyperbarics' site that this is the case. I'm going to check it out tomorrow, out of curiosity. Of course, whether it is or isn't, and whether it uses Oxyhealth chambers or those of another reputable company seems irrelevant to anything under discussion, as Brett has pointed out. Sincerely, , MD TBI survivor ________________________________ From: brett szymonski <szymonski@...> medicaid Sent: Sun, July 11, 2010 9:42:35 PM Subject: Re: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? Diane, First, they do not use Quamvis chambers in either clinic. Second, it is irrelevant. This is not a debate on manufacturers but is a debate regarding the safety of home chambers at 1.5 ata. With that being said, the issue of 1.5 ata is not the safety issue. The use of 1.5 ata with supplemental oxygen is a safety concern. Using 1.5 ata without the use of supplemental oxygen will not create oxygen toxicity problems. It may become a problem when supplemental oxygen is introduced. Due to there being a chance of oxygen toxicity, regardless of how small of a chance it is, one must consider it a safety factor. Also, since many people will introduce supplemental oxygen regardless of being told not to, all 1.5 chambers should be considered a safety issue. Therefore, the use of 1.5 ata chambers in a home setting should not be allowed. The bigger issue is that the sale of 1.5 ata chambers, along this the export of these chambers, is illegal. It does not matter who manufactures them. What is illegal is illegal. Let's not try to divert the conversations in order to avoid the subject. Brett From: hbotforhealth <diane@...> Subject: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? medicaid Date: Sunday, July 11, 2010, 6:18 AM Do you think that it is safe to use a Quamvis chamber at 1.5 ATA? Diane > > > > > > These comments on the site by Diane recently have been aggravating in > > the > > > extreme, shed no light on anything, and are offered by a woman who > > has, to my > > > knowledge, no medical training. > > > > > > My opinion, the more I know about hyperbaric oxygen, is that it should > > be done > > > under a physician's supervision, by prescription. I don't mean that a > > physician > > > needs to necessarily be on-site. But the range of medical problems > > that people > > > can have, with contra-indications for hyperbaric oxygen, are such that > > in my > > > opinion, it is practicing medicine without a license to treat with > > hyperbaric > > > oxygen without a physician's evaluation and appropriate supervision, > > as may be > > > needed. > > > > > > I'm not trying to scare anyone away from hyperbaric medicine. I've > > seen it used > > > with positive results on people with TBI, autism, stroke, anoxic brain > > injury, > > > and diabetic non-healing wounds, without complication. I just would > > like to see > > > the discussion assume a more rational and helpful course. > > > > > > I've now had two sets of hyperbaric oxygen treatment at 1.5 atm with > > 100 percent > > > oxygen, twice daily M-F; the first was two years ago at Integrative > > Hyperbarics, > > > in Madison, WI, which was very professional and I was very pleased > > with my > > > treatment. The second 40 treatments were not done until March and > > April of this > > > year, as cost was prohibitive to pay for it out of pocket before then. > > I got the > > > second set of treatments, with the same protocol as was used in my > > first > > > treatment, from Dr. Zant in Destin, Florida. He uses Seachrist > > chambers, whereas > > > the Integrative Hyperbarics used Oxyhealth Baby Blue chambers. That > > was the main > > > difference between the two treatments. > > > > > > Dr. Zant is taking part in the NBIRR study, a military protocol for > > returning > > > GIs with TBI, and had access to the ANAM testing, which I got before > > and after > > > treatment. Even as early as immediately after treatment, 3 of 5 > > cognitive > > > funtions that were initially abnormal showed normalization; the other > > two were > > > unchanged. However, I have continued to see improvement over time > > following my > > > first treatment, and expect and hope that will be the case in this > > instance too. > > > I've had to pay for all of my treatment out of pocket, and in the > > latest > > > instance, had some help from a family member, and put the remainder on > > a line of > > > credit, which I will have to pay off as I am able. > > > > > > I'm looking forward to the day when these treatments, which everyone > > who knows > > > me will say have brought about tremendous improvement in my case, will > > be > > > reimbursed for people with similar problems, by medicare and Tricare, > > and other > > > insurance. My cost, for treatment, and room and board out of town, has > > been > > > approximately $6,500 each time. I'm sure other people have had to pay > > more, as > > > the average cost at most centers for people paying on their own is > > about > > > $200/treatment. I have been fortunate to get discounts in each case. I > > will go > > > into retirement in a few years with no savings other than a small > > annuity, and > > > social security. I can ill afford these medical expenses, but I chose > > to do it > > > in hopes of being able to live a more normal life, and I am glad I > > made that > > > decision. > > > > > > , MD > > > TBI survivor > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 12, 2010 Report Posted July 12, 2010 , It is owned by Oxyhealth and they use their chambers. However, it matters not. Brett Re: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? Diane, First, they do not use Quamvis chambers in either clinic. Second, it is irrelevant. This is not a debate on manufacturers but is a debate regarding the safety of home chambers at 1.5 ata. With that being said, the issue of 1.5 ata is not the safety issue. The use of 1.5 ata with supplemental oxygen is a safety concern. Using 1.5 ata without the use of supplemental oxygen will not create oxygen toxicity problems. It may b [The entire original message is not included] Quote
Guest guest Posted July 12, 2010 Report Posted July 12, 2010 Donna, I did not say they should be illegal. I said that using them in a home setting should not be allowed. The illegal portion is just how it is, like it or not. The problem is that somewhere, sometime, someone will use a 1.5 ATA chamber at home, with supplemental oxygen, and they will get hurt, or worse yet, die. This will result in huge lawsuits and a bad image for HBOT in general. Therefore, using 1.5 ata chambers in a home setting is not a good idea. Brett > > From: hbotforhealth <diane@... <diane%40healingdives.com>> > Subject: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? > medicaid <medicaid%40> > Date: Sunday, July 11, 2010, 6:18 AM > > > > Do you think that it is safe to use a Quamvis chamber at 1.5 ATA? > > Diane > > > > > > > > > > > > These comments on the site by Diane recently have been aggravating > > in > > > > the > > > > > extreme, shed no light on anything, and are offered by a woman who > > > > has, to my > > > > > knowledge, no medical training. > > > > > > > > > > My opinion, the more I know about hyperbaric oxygen, is that it > > should > > > > be done > > > > > under a physician's supervision, by prescription. I don't mean > > that a > > > > physician > > > > > needs to necessarily be on-site. But the range of medical problems > > > > that people > > > > > can have, with contra-indications for hyperbaric oxygen, are such > > that > > > > in my > > > > > opinion, it is practicing medicine without a license to treat with > > > > hyperbaric > > > > > oxygen without a physician's evaluation and appropriate > > supervision, > > > > as may be > > > > > needed. > > > > > > > > > > I'm not trying to scare anyone away from hyperbaric medicine. I've > > > > seen it used > > > > > with positive results on people with TBI, autism, stroke, anoxic > > brain > > > > injury, > > > > > and diabetic non-healing wounds, without complication. I just > > would > > > > like to see > > > > > the discussion assume a more rational and helpful course. > > > > > > > > > > I've now had two sets of hyperbaric oxygen treatment at 1.5 atm > > with > > > > 100 percent > > > > > oxygen, twice daily M-F; the first was two years ago at > > Integrative > > > > Hyperbarics, > > > > > in Madison, WI, which was very professional and I was very pleased > > > > with my > > > > > treatment. The second 40 treatments were not done until March and > > > > April of this > > > > > year, as cost was prohibitive to pay for it out of pocket before > > then. > > > > I got the > > > > > second set of treatments, with the same protocol as was used in my > > > > first > > > > > treatment, from Dr. Zant in Destin, Florida. He uses Seachrist > > > > chambers, whereas > > > > > the Integrative Hyperbarics used Oxyhealth Baby Blue chambers. > > That > > > > was the main > > > > > difference between the two treatments. > > > > > > > > > > Dr. Zant is taking part in the NBIRR study, a military protocol > > for > > > > returning > > > > > GIs with TBI, and had access to the ANAM testing, which I got > > before > > > > and after > > > > > treatment. Even as early as immediately after treatment, 3 of 5 > > > > cognitive > > > > > funtions that were initially abnormal showed normalization; the > > other > > > > two were > > > > > unchanged. However, I have continued to see improvement over time > > > > following my > > > > > first treatment, and expect and hope that will be the case in this > > > > instance too. > > > > > I've had to pay for all of my treatment out of pocket, and in the > > > > latest > > > > > instance, had some help from a family member, and put the > > remainder on > > > > a line of > > > > > credit, which I will have to pay off as I am able. > > > > > > > > > > I'm looking forward to the day when these treatments, which > > everyone > > > > who knows > > > > > me will say have brought about tremendous improvement in my case, > > will > > > > be > > > > > reimbursed for people with similar problems, by medicare and > > Tricare, > > > > and other > > > > > insurance. My cost, for treatment, and room and board out of town, > > has > > > > been > > > > > approximately $6,500 each time. I'm sure other people have had to > > pay > > > > more, as > > > > > the average cost at most centers for people paying on their own is > > > > about > > > > > $200/treatment. I have been fortunate to get discounts in each > > case. I > > > > will go > > > > > into retirement in a few years with no savings other than a small > > > > annuity, and > > > > > social security. I can ill afford these medical expenses, but I > > chose > > > > to do it > > > > > in hopes of being able to live a more normal life, and I am glad I > > > > made that > > > > > decision. > > > > > > > > > > , MD > > > > > TBI survivor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 12, 2010 Report Posted July 12, 2010 But using that logic, so should ALL over the counter meds. On Mon, Jul 12, 2010 at 6:55 PM, brett szymonski <szymonski@...>wrote: > > > Donna, > > I did not say they should be illegal. I said that using them in a home > setting should not be allowed. The illegal portion is just how it is, like > it or not. > > The problem is that somewhere, sometime, someone will use a 1.5 ATA chamber > at home, with supplemental oxygen, and they will get hurt, or worse yet, > die. This will result in huge lawsuits and a bad image for HBOT in general. > > Therefore, using 1.5 ata chambers in a home setting is not a good idea. > > Brett > > > > > > From: hbotforhealth <diane@... <diane%40healingdives.com><diane% > 40healingdives.com>> > > Subject: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? > > medicaid <medicaid%40><medicaid% > 40> > > Date: Sunday, July 11, 2010, 6:18 AM > > > > > > > > Do you think that it is safe to use a Quamvis chamber at 1.5 ATA? > > > > Diane > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > These comments on the site by Diane recently have been aggravating > > > > in > > > > > > the > > > > > > > extreme, shed no light on anything, and are offered by a woman who > > > > > > has, to my > > > > > > > knowledge, no medical training. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > My opinion, the more I know about hyperbaric oxygen, is that it > > > > should > > > > > > be done > > > > > > > under a physician's supervision, by prescription. I don't mean > > > > that a > > > > > > physician > > > > > > > needs to necessarily be on-site. But the range of medical problems > > > > > > that people > > > > > > > can have, with contra-indications for hyperbaric oxygen, are such > > > > that > > > > > > in my > > > > > > > opinion, it is practicing medicine without a license to treat with > > > > > > hyperbaric > > > > > > > oxygen without a physician's evaluation and appropriate > > > > supervision, > > > > > > as may be > > > > > > > needed. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I'm not trying to scare anyone away from hyperbaric medicine. I've > > > > > > seen it used > > > > > > > with positive results on people with TBI, autism, stroke, anoxic > > > > brain > > > > > > injury, > > > > > > > and diabetic non-healing wounds, without complication. I just > > > > would > > > > > > like to see > > > > > > > the discussion assume a more rational and helpful course. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I've now had two sets of hyperbaric oxygen treatment at 1.5 atm > > > > with > > > > > > 100 percent > > > > > > > oxygen, twice daily M-F; the first was two years ago at > > > > Integrative > > > > > > Hyperbarics, > > > > > > > in Madison, WI, which was very professional and I was very pleased > > > > > > with my > > > > > > > treatment. The second 40 treatments were not done until March and > > > > > > April of this > > > > > > > year, as cost was prohibitive to pay for it out of pocket before > > > > then. > > > > > > I got the > > > > > > > second set of treatments, with the same protocol as was used in my > > > > > > first > > > > > > > treatment, from Dr. Zant in Destin, Florida. He uses Seachrist > > > > > > chambers, whereas > > > > > > > the Integrative Hyperbarics used Oxyhealth Baby Blue chambers. > > > > That > > > > > > was the main > > > > > > > difference between the two treatments. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Dr. Zant is taking part in the NBIRR study, a military protocol > > > > for > > > > > > returning > > > > > > > GIs with TBI, and had access to the ANAM testing, which I got > > > > before > > > > > > and after > > > > > > > treatment. Even as early as immediately after treatment, 3 of 5 > > > > > > cognitive > > > > > > > funtions that were initially abnormal showed normalization; the > > > > other > > > > > > two were > > > > > > > unchanged. However, I have continued to see improvement over time > > > > > > following my > > > > > > > first treatment, and expect and hope that will be the case in this > > > > > > instance too. > > > > > > > I've had to pay for all of my treatment out of pocket, and in the > > > > > > latest > > > > > > > instance, had some help from a family member, and put the > > > > remainder on > > > > > > a line of > > > > > > > credit, which I will have to pay off as I am able. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I'm looking forward to the day when these treatments, which > > > > everyone > > > > > > who knows > > > > > > > me will say have brought about tremendous improvement in my case, > > > > will > > > > > > be > > > > > > > reimbursed for people with similar problems, by medicare and > > > > Tricare, > > > > > > and other > > > > > > > insurance. My cost, for treatment, and room and board out of town, > > > > has > > > > > > been > > > > > > > approximately $6,500 each time. I'm sure other people have had to > > > > pay > > > > > > more, as > > > > > > > the average cost at most centers for people paying on their own is > > > > > > about > > > > > > > $200/treatment. I have been fortunate to get discounts in each > > > > case. I > > > > > > will go > > > > > > > into retirement in a few years with no savings other than a small > > > > > > annuity, and > > > > > > > social security. I can ill afford these medical expenses, but I > > > > chose > > > > > > to do it > > > > > > > in hopes of being able to live a more normal life, and I am glad I > > > > > > made that > > > > > > > decision. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > , MD > > > > > > > TBI survivor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 12, 2010 Report Posted July 12, 2010 There is a HUGE difference here Donna. Oxygen is a prescription drug, not an over the counter med. Regardless, why do you think all those warnings are on the back of over the counter meds? Secondly, the issue still remains that using a portable chamber that goes to 1.5 ATA in a home setting, with supplemental oxygen, is not legal. Okay, let me backup. The sale of 1.5 portable chambers is not legal, and the use of supplemental oxygen is only legal if done so by prescription. The sale of over the counter meds is legal. Like it or not, that is the way it is. Failure to follow laws and regulations is not the way to advance HBOT. The point is that if we want to eventually get HBOT into mainstream medicine, we must do it as safely as possible. By allowing illegal activities or unsafe practices, HBOT will never make it into mainstream. This means little, if any, Medicare/Medicaid payments for its use. Not to mention private insurance. The fact is that many people cannot afford paying for treatments out of pocket. Therefore, millions of people that could greatly benefit from HBOT will never receive treatments. We need to push for HBOT to become part of traditional medicine. However, we must do this correctly. Allowing unsafe practices will eventually sink the ship, so to speak. All it takes is one incident, and it will be the beginning of the end for HBOT. Understand that I believe, in most cases, that using a portable chamber that is capable of 1.5 ATA and supplemental oxygen in a home setting will not result in any problems. However, that is MOST cases. It only takes one case to end it all. Therefore, one must err on the side of caution. It is for the greater good of all those that really need HBOT. One thing that we must keep in mind: Many people believe that if a little medicine is good, that more must be better. I have seen it many, many times. With oxygen, people often believe that it is safe and that " overdosing " cannot occur. In the case of HBOT, if a person sees positive results with an hour a day, they may be tempted to increase the " dosage " . As we all know, this can lead to serious problems, including oxygen toxicity. Brett > > > > From: hbotforhealth <diane@... <diane%40healingdives.com><diane% > 40healingdives.com>> > > Subject: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? > > medicaid <medicaid%40><medicaid% > 40> > > Date: Sunday, July 11, 2010, 6:18 AM > > > > > > > > Do you think that it is safe to use a Quamvis chamber at 1.5 ATA? > > > > Diane > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > These comments on the site by Diane recently have been aggravating > > > > in > > > > > > the > > > > > > > extreme, shed no light on anything, and are offered by a woman who > > > > > > has, to my > > > > > > > knowledge, no medical training. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > My opinion, the more I know about hyperbaric oxygen, is that it > > > > should > > > > > > be done > > > > > > > under a physician's supervision, by prescription. I don't mean > > > > that a > > > > > > physician > > > > > > > needs to necessarily be on-site. But the range of medical problems > > > > > > that people > > > > > > > can have, with contra-indications for hyperbaric oxygen, are such > > > > that > > > > > > in my > > > > > > > opinion, it is practicing medicine without a license to treat with > > > > > > hyperbaric > > > > > > > oxygen without a physician's evaluation and appropriate > > > > supervision, > > > > > > as may be > > > > > > > needed. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I'm not trying to scare anyone away from hyperbaric medicine. I've > > > > > > seen it used > > > > > > > with positive results on people with TBI, autism, stroke, anoxic > > > > brain > > > > > > injury, > > > > > > > and diabetic non-healing wounds, without complication. I just > > > > would > > > > > > like to see > > > > > > > the discussion assume a more rational and helpful course. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I've now had two sets of hyperbaric oxygen treatment at 1.5 atm > > > > with > > > > > > 100 percent > > > > > > > oxygen, twice daily M-F; the first was two years ago at > > > > Integrative > > > > > > Hyperbarics, > > > > > > > in Madison, WI, which was very professional and I was very pleased > > > > > > with my > > > > > > > treatment. The second 40 treatments were not done until March and > > > > > > April of this > > > > > > > year, as cost was prohibitive to pay for it out of pocket before > > > > then. > > > > > > I got the > > > > > > > second set of treatments, with the same protocol as was used in my > > > > > > first > > > > > > > treatment, from Dr. Zant in Destin, Florida. He uses Seachrist > > > > > > chambers, whereas > > > > > > > the Integrative Hyperbarics used Oxyhealth Baby Blue chambers. > > > > That > > > > > > was the main > > > > > > > difference between the two treatments. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Dr. Zant is taking part in the NBIRR study, a military protocol > > > > for > > > > > > returning > > > > > > > GIs with TBI, and had access to the ANAM testing, which I got > > > > before > > > > > > and after > > > > > > > treatment. Even as early as immediately after treatment, 3 of 5 > > > > > > cognitive > > > > > > > funtions that were initially abnormal showed normalization; the > > > > other > > > > > > two were > > > > > > > unchanged. However, I have continued to see improvement over time > > > > > > following my > > > > > > > first treatment, and expect and hope that will be the case in this > > > > > > instance too. > > > > > > > I've had to pay for all of my treatment out of pocket, and in the > > > > > > latest > > > > > > > instance, had some help from a family member, and put the > > > > remainder on > > > > > > a line of > > > > > > > credit, which I will have to pay off as I am able. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I'm looking forward to the day when these treatments, which > > > > everyone > > > > > > who knows > > > > > > > me will say have brought about tremendous improvement in my case, > > > > will > > > > > > be > > > > > > > reimbursed for people with similar problems, by medicare and > > > > Tricare, > > > > > > and other > > > > > > > insurance. My cost, for treatment, and room and board out of town, > > > > has > > > > > > been > > > > > > > approximately $6,500 each time. I'm sure other people have had to > > > > pay > > > > > > more, as > > > > > > > the average cost at most centers for people paying on their own is > > > > > > about > > > > > > > $200/treatment. I have been fortunate to get discounts in each > > > > case. I > > > > > > will go > > > > > > > into retirement in a few years with no savings other than a small > > > > > > annuity, and > > > > > > > social security. I can ill afford these medical expenses, but I > > > > chose > > > > > > to do it > > > > > > > in hopes of being able to live a more normal life, and I am glad I > > > > > > made that > > > > > > > decision. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > , MD > > > > > > > TBI survivor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 12, 2010 Report Posted July 12, 2010 Donna, Brett I understand both of your point's but from a parent that lost a child. I know and worked with may children and families so they would not have to use the illegal chambers. I got out of it about a year ago. It was to hard on me. I missed my child. As a parent that still has their kid I see Donna's point wanting to do everyting to get their child treated. HOWEVER... I would never risk my child's life with a unaproved device. NOT ONE CHANCE... I think the fact that I'm still here and still fighting for you and your kid's even after mine has passed away should speak volumes on the subject. If I feel that strongly about this subject to fight for your loved ones as I as a former parent of a disabled child know how you judgement can get clouded when you are a parent of a disabled child. The point is the law is the law regardless if we like it or not it is the law without it the world would be even more crazy than it is now. We should abide by it.....If Diane wants to sell a portable then go by the law others have done it and now are sucessfull they can do it to. That is the bottom line. PERIOD... I will not speak on the subject again. As I have a child now here her name is Kylie and she loves me why should I waste my time on the people on the list that don't care. I will continue to fight to shut people like this down but just not respond on it. Darin > > > > > > From: hbotforhealth <diane@... > <diane%40healingdives.com><diane% > > 40healingdives.com>> > > > Subject: [ ] Re: oxygen toxicity? > > > medicaid > <medicaid%40><medicaid% > > 40> > > > Date: Sunday, July 11, 2010, 6:18 AM > > > > > > > > > > > > Do you think that it is safe to use a Quamvis > chamber at 1.5 ATA? > > > > > > Diane > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > These comments on the site by > Diane recently have been aggravating > > > > > > in > > > > > > > > the > > > > > > > > > extreme, shed no light on > anything, and are offered by a woman who > > > > > > > > has, to my > > > > > > > > > knowledge, no medical training. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > My opinion, the more I know about > hyperbaric oxygen, is that it > > > > > > should > > > > > > > > be done > > > > > > > > > under a physician's supervision, > by prescription. I don't mean > > > > > > that a > > > > > > > > physician > > > > > > > > > needs to necessarily be on-site. > But the range of medical problems > > > > > > > > that people > > > > > > > > > can have, with contra-indications > for hyperbaric oxygen, are such > > > > > > that > > > > > > > > in my > > > > > > > > > opinion, it is practicing medicine > without a license to treat with > > > > > > > > hyperbaric > > > > > > > > > oxygen without a physician's > evaluation and appropriate > > > > > > supervision, > > > > > > > > as may be > > > > > > > > > needed. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I'm not trying to scare anyone > away from hyperbaric medicine. I've > > > > > > > > seen it used > > > > > > > > > with positive results on people > with TBI, autism, stroke, anoxic > > > > > > brain > > > > > > > > injury, > > > > > > > > > and diabetic non-healing wounds, > without complication. I just > > > > > > would > > > > > > > > like to see > > > > > > > > > the discussion assume a more > rational and helpful course. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I've now had two sets of > hyperbaric oxygen treatment at 1.5 atm > > > > > > with > > > > > > > > 100 percent > > > > > > > > > oxygen, twice daily M-F; the first > was two years ago at > > > > > > Integrative > > > > > > > > Hyperbarics, > > > > > > > > > in Madison, WI, which was very > professional and I was very pleased > > > > > > > > with my > > > > > > > > > treatment. The second 40 > treatments were not done until March and > > > > > > > > April of this > > > > > > > > > year, as cost was prohibitive to > pay for it out of pocket before > > > > > > then. > > > > > > > > I got the > > > > > > > > > second set of treatments, with the > same protocol as was used in my > > > > > > > > first > > > > > > > > > treatment, from Dr. Zant in > Destin, Florida. He uses Seachrist > > > > > > > > chambers, whereas > > > > > > > > > the Integrative Hyperbarics used > Oxyhealth Baby Blue chambers. > > > > > > That > > > > > > > > was the main > > > > > > > > > difference between the two > treatments. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Dr. Zant is taking part in the > NBIRR study, a military protocol > > > > > > for > > > > > > > > returning > > > > > > > > > GIs with TBI, and had access to > the ANAM testing, which I got > > > > > > before > > > > > > > > and after > > > > > > > > > treatment. Even as early as > immediately after treatment, 3 of 5 > > > > > > > > cognitive > > > > > > > > > funtions that were initially > abnormal showed normalization; the > > > > > > other > > > > > > > > two were > > > > > > > > > unchanged. However, I have > continued to see improvement over time > > > > > > > > following my > > > > > > > > > first treatment, and expect and > hope that will be the case in this > > > > > > > > instance too. > > > > > > > > > I've had to pay for all of my > treatment out of pocket, and in the > > > > > > > > latest > > > > > > > > > instance, had some help from a > family member, and put the > > > > > > remainder on > > > > > > > > a line of > > > > > > > > > credit, which I will have to pay > off as I am able. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I'm looking forward to the day > when these treatments, which > > > > > > everyone > > > > > > > > who knows > > > > > > > > > me will say have brought about > tremendous improvement in my case, > > > > > > will > > > > > > > > be > > > > > > > > > reimbursed for people with similar > problems, by medicare and > > > > > > Tricare, > > > > > > > > and other > > > > > > > > > insurance. My cost, for treatment, > and room and board out of town, > > > > > > has > > > > > > > > been > > > > > > > > > approximately $6,500 each time. > I'm sure other people have had to > > > > > > pay > > > > > > > > more, as > > > > > > > > > the average cost at most centers > for people paying on their own is > > > > > > > > about > > > > > > > > > $200/treatment. I have been > fortunate to get discounts in each > > > > > > case. I > > > > > > > > will go > > > > > > > > > into retirement in a few years > with no savings other than a small > > > > > > > > annuity, and > > > > > > > > > social security. I can ill afford > these medical expenses, but I > > > > > > chose > > > > > > > > to do it > > > > > > > > > in hopes of being able to live a > more normal life, and I am glad I > > > > > > > > made that > > > > > > > > > decision. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > , MD > > > > > > > > > TBI survivor > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > [Non-text portions of this message have > been removed] > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > [Non-text portions of this message have been > removed] > > > > > > > > > > > > > [Non-text portions of this message have been > removed] > > > > > > [Non-text portions of this message have been > removed] > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > Donna Bateman > > Neurodevelopmental Specialist > > www.parentswithpurpose.com > > Check out my blog: www.parentswithpurpose.blog.com > > Natural Moms Talk Radio Interview Podcast: http://is.gd/4Wwib > > Mom to 25, Katy Kartchner 23 (just married) , > Preston 21 (serving a > > full-time mission in Mendoza, Argentina), Annie 19, > Kent 17, Callie 14 > > (cured from dyslexia), Carson 12, Dawson 10 (brain > injured--was severe now > > mild!) > > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.