Guest guest Posted December 26, 2010 Report Posted December 26, 2010 > > Hi Bee, > > I've been reading a few articles indicating a connection between long term low carb diets and serious health risks, I'm interested to know your opinion: > http://perfecthealthdiet.com/?p=1032 > http://perfecthealthdiet.com/?cat=82 > http://perfecthealthdiet.com/?p=1139 > http://perfecthealthdiet.com/?p=1077 > http://www.webmd.com/diet/news/20100907/meat-protein-risky-in-low-carb-diets > http://180degreehealth.blogspot.com/2010/02/is-low-carb-diet-counterproductive.h\ tml > http://www.em-consulte.com/article/79912 +++You are Adam, right? I don't have time to read those articles and I wouldn't anyway, since the claim that you must have carbs to be healthy is totally false. You should do your own reading so you aren't swayed by such information. Of course there is no health risks at all on low-carb or even no-carb diets. Any glucose requirements are easily met by meats, eggs and good fats. That is because 58% of protein and 10% of good fats can be changed into glucose in our liver as needed, and we need very little. Also the brain, heart and nervous system are healthier running on ketones (the energy from fats) rather than glucose. See these articles: Carbohydrates Are Not Needed for Energy: http://www.healingnaturallybybee.com/articles/foods11.php Scientific Proof They Carbohydrates Cause Disease: http://www.healingnaturallybybee.com/articles/foods12.php Also the healthiest people Dr. Weston A. Price studied were the Eskimos and Masai people in Africa, and they had ate all meat and fat diets - see Eskimos Prove An All Meat Diet Provides Excellent Health: http://www.biblelife.org/stefansson1.htm In fact the article above includes a study done in a US hospital on 2 men - there's 3 parts to this article so I suggest you read them all. All the best, Bee Quote
Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 Hi (Adam?) I did read these articles, and if you spend some time really comparing what they are talking about, vs what we do on this diet, you can see... there is no comparison. A) Except for the last article, which talked about giving rats some kind of powdered food with various constituents of protein, fat and carbs, the article don't really discuss what it means to have a high percentage of fats like we do with Bee's diet. VERY IMPORTANT ASPECT OF THIS DIET!! They get into scury, etc... WE TAKE VITAMIN C! Also, aboriginal peoples ate more organ meats, like liver, which have a high concentration of Vit C. If you only talk about " high protein " and don't discuss what KIND of protein (meat/muscle vs. organ meats vs plant protein) then information is being left out of these studies and conclusions. C) They keep repaeting they are on " low to no carb diets " , then talk about how many vegetables they were eating, which seemed like a lot, without discussing whether they were eating cooked, or raw, etc. THAT is NOT a low to no carb diet. They refer to this " low carb diet " as being low carb because the intenstinal bacteria consume the veggie carbs. Bee's articles discuss how intestinal bacteria increase in order to deal with consumption of carbs to help your body deal with them, and that a high level of probiotics is not necessarily a sign of health. See this article: http://www.healingnaturallybybee.com/articles/probiotic1.php#p2 I have very personal history with such " low carb diets " and they were not only not helpful in healing my health issues, I had many of the same problems refered to in the articles of intestinal distress etc(sans kindey stones). I was hungray ALL the time, unsatisfied, tired, grouchy, gassy and feeling very stuck in all of it. When I came across Bee's diet the first time, I rejected it for those reasons - " I already did that and it didn't work " . The second time, I looked closer and noticed the emphasis on fats, and the deemphasis on carbs. Something in me clicked, I went for it, and you know what? It has been the most transformative thing I have ever done for my health in 25 years of trying to figure out my health. It is the fats, which protect the gut, and facilitate better absorbtion and assimilation of nutrients. This is key, and except for the rat article none of the article cover it (rats fed powdered crap does not make a good comaprison with humans eating real food). Also, these " low carb " diets where people are eating ALOT of veggies (which I did in my other diets) is harsh on the intestines, which I can attest to personally. I used to LOVE my salads - and would have the worst bloating and gas afterward. I could never figure it out - " isn't raw vegetable fiber good for me? " . No - especially when you have a seriously compromised gut like I have. The leading raw fooder Viktorinas Kulvinskas (? can't remember how to spell his name) - his wife died at the tender age of 50 or in her 50's.... of stomach cancer. Those people in your articles are consuming alot of veggies, and in fact the Optimal diet, which they cite as having a high GI cancer rate, requires that one eat at least 50 g of carbs a day (not off from what we do here if eating carbs), AND includes wheat, etc in their diet - using breadcrumbs, and sponge cake etc. Having been a raw fooder, and on " candida diets " that allowed grains, I can tell you from experience that they do not work. That is why Bee's diet is so great - she takes the best of all of these diets, and gets us closer to what our bodies have evolved to thrive on. Too many veggies are not so good, grains are a recent human foodstuff (within the scope of human evolution 10,000 years of agriculture of grains vs. hundres of thousands to millions of years of a paleolithic diet) and our bodies thrive on high fats and a good amount of protein. Moderators - hope that covers it all properly, and Adam - hope that answers your questions brought up by those articles. Blessings, all and Happy New Year!! - Lilithe > > Hi Bee, > > I've been reading a few articles indicating a connection between long term low carb diets and serious health risks, I'm interested to know your opinion: > http://perfecthealthdiet.com/?p=1032 > http://perfecthealthdiet.com/?cat=82 > http://perfecthealthdiet.com/?p=1139 > http://perfecthealthdiet.com/?p=1077 > http://www.webmd.com/diet/news/20100907/meat-protein-risky-in-low-carb-diets > http://180degreehealth.blogspot.com/2010/02/is-low-carb-diet-counterproductive.h\ tml > http://www.em-consulte.com/article/79912 > > Thank you for your time. > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 > > Hi (Adam?) > > I did read these articles, and if you spend some time really comparing what they are talking about, vs what we do on this diet, you can see... there is no comparison. > > A) Except for the last article, which talked about giving rats some kind of powdered food with various constituents of protein, fat and carbs, the article don't really discuss what it means to have a high percentage of fats like we do with Bee's diet. VERY IMPORTANT ASPECT OF THIS DIET!! > > They get into scury, etc... WE TAKE VITAMIN C! Also, aboriginal peoples ate more organ meats, like liver, which have a high concentration of Vit C. If you only talk about " high protein " and don't discuss what KIND of protein (meat/muscle vs. organ meats vs plant protein) then information is being left out of these studies and conclusions. > > C) They keep repeating they are on " low to no carb diets " , then talk about how many vegetables they were eating, which seemed like a lot, without discussing whether they were eating cooked, or raw, etc. THAT is NOT a low to no carb diet. They refer to this " low carb diet " as being low carb because the intenstinal bacteria consume the veggie carbs. Bee's articles discuss how intestinal bacteria increase in order to deal with consumption of carbs to help your body deal with them, and that a high level of probiotics is not necessarily a sign of health. See this article: > > http://www.healingnaturallybybee.com/articles/probiotic1.php#p2 > > I have very personal history with such " low carb diets " and they were not only not helpful in healing my health issues, I had many of the same problems refered to in the articles of intestinal distress etc(sans kindey stones). I was hungray ALL the time, unsatisfied, tired, grouchy, gassy and feeling very stuck in all of it. When I came across Bee's diet the first time, I rejected it for those reasons - " I already did that and it didn't work " . The second time, I looked closer and noticed the emphasis on fats, and the deemphasis on carbs. Something in me clicked, I went for it, and you know what? It has been the most transformative thing I have ever done for my health in 25 years of trying to figure out my health. > > It is the fats, which protect the gut, and facilitate better absorbtion and assimilation of nutrients. This is key, and except for the rat article none of the article cover it (rats fed powdered crap does not make a good comaprison with humans eating real food). Also, these " low carb " diets where people are eating ALOT of veggies (which I did in my other diets) is harsh on the intestines, which I can attest to personally. I used to LOVE my salads - and would have the worst bloating and gas afterward. I could never figure it out - " isn't raw vegetable fiber good for me? " . No - especially when you have a seriously compromised gut like I have. > > The leading raw fooder Viktorinas Kulvinskas (? can't remember how to spell his name) - his wife died at the tender age of 50 or in her 50's.... of stomach cancer. Those people in your articles are consuming alot of veggies, and in fact the Optimal diet, which they cite as having a high GI cancer rate, requires that one eat at least 50 g of carbs a day (not off from what we do here if eating carbs), AND includes wheat, etc in their diet - using breadcrumbs, and sponge cake etc. > > Having been a raw fooder, and on " candida diets " that allowed grains, I can tell you from experience that they do not work. That is why Bee's diet is so great - she takes the best of all of these diets, and gets us closer to what our bodies have evolved to thrive on. Too many veggies are not so good, grains are a recent human foodstuff (within the scope of human evolution 10,000 years of agriculture of grains vs. hundres of thousands to millions of years of a paleolithic diet) and our bodies thrive on high fats and a good amount of protein. > > Moderators - hope that covers it all properly, and Adam - hope that answers your questions brought up by those articles. > > Blessings, all and Happy New Year!! - Lilithe @@ Snip @@ Hi Adam & Lilithe, Lilithe you did a fantastic job ! Adam, I too had a chance to review a few of the links provided. I found type of ketogenic diet that seemed to be the focus, was the one used similar for epilepsy. Which is a high protein & low - zero carb diet. This type can have issues if not properly monitored, yes. However, very little if much, is referred/mentioned in compensating by increasing good fats. Which is the type of ketogenic diet our group is utilizing. Lastly, I noticed, the gentleman ( Jaminet )of these articles of " Perfect Health Diet- Dangers of Low Carb " actually states " Some infections, esp. fungal infections, get worse on a zero-carb diet because the immune response to them is so glucose dependent. " I have to chuckle, sorry. Is he serious, really? Well, for starts fungal infections i.e Cancer are carb/sugar addictive. Therefore the Cancer industry will love this guy. Second, if his synopsis was correct nobody would be getting better here. Since their health issues stems from Candida/fungus in the gut and they are using low carbs. Yet, they are getting better .. hmmm... Jaminet also responds to a post, stating his theories are speculative. Well that one I agree, and not a good one either. Lilithe, already addressed the remaining links, I may have missed , thus I'm certain you got the gist of it. Keep researching & reading Adam and thanks for the links, but while fascinating they lack consistency in the facts tainted with confusion of the type of ketogenic diet. Best in Health, Ed group moderator Quote
Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 I would add to your comment too Lilithe, that those cultures that tend to eat a lot of vegetables, probably not only have gut bacteria that is adapted to deal with them, but they don't eat the copious quantity of processed carbs and sugars, or are given the medical drugs like antibiotics that would throw the gut flora off balance in the first place. Ali. > > > > Hi Bee, > > > > I've been reading a few articles indicating a connection between long term low carb diets and serious health risks, I'm interested to know your opinion: > > http://perfecthealthdiet.com/?p=1032 > > http://perfecthealthdiet.com/?cat=82 > > http://perfecthealthdiet.com/?p=1139 > > http://perfecthealthdiet.com/?p=1077 > > http://www.webmd.com/diet/news/20100907/meat-protein-risky-in-low-carb-diets > > http://180degreehealth.blogspot.com/2010/02/is-low-carb-diet-counterproductive.h\ tml > > http://www.em-consulte.com/article/79912 > > > > Thank you for your time. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 > > I have very personal history with such " low carb diets " and they were not only not helpful in healing my health issues, I had many of the same problems refered to in the articles of intestinal distress etc(sans kindey stones). I was hungray ALL the time, unsatisfied, tired, grouchy, gassy and feeling very stuck in all of it. When I came across Bee's diet the first time, I rejected it for those reasons - " I already did that and it didn't work " . The second time, I looked closer and noticed the emphasis on fats, and the deemphasis on carbs. Something in me clicked, I went for it, and you know what? It has been the most transformative thing I have ever done for my health in 25 years of trying to figure out my health. > > It is the fats, which protect the gut, and facilitate better absorbtion and assimilation of nutrients. This is key, and except for the rat article none of the article cover it (rats fed powdered crap does not make a good comaprison with humans eating real food). Also, these " low carb " diets where people are eating ALOT of veggies (which I did in my other diets) is harsh on the intestines, which I can attest to personally. I used to LOVE my salads - and would have the worst bloating and gas afterward. I could never figure it out - " isn't raw vegetable fiber good for me? " . No - especially when you have a seriously compromised gut like I have. ++++ Hi, your testimoniance is very interesting! I'm on Bee's program for 8+ months and I don't see any positive gain, I feel fatigued, I'm constipated and my digestion is worse than before. I calcolated my carb intake (75g) and to reach it I eat a lot of vegetables. However I was never able to reach more than 50g carbs. Can I ask you what kind and what quantity of vegetables do you eat? How much carbs do you eat a day? > The leading raw fooder Viktorinas Kulvinskas (? can't remember how to spell his name) - his wife died at the tender age of 50 or in her 50's.... of stomach cancer. Those people in your articles are consuming alot of veggies, and in fact the Optimal diet, which they cite as having a high GI cancer rate, requires that one eat at least 50 g of carbs a day (not off from what we do here if eating carbs), AND includes wheat, etc in their diet - using breadcrumbs, and sponge cake etc. > Optimal dieters eat less wheat, cakes etc than standard dieters, so they should have less cancer rate. Fabio Quote
Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 > > ++++ Hi, your testimoniance is very interesting! > I'm on Bee's program for 8+ months and I don't see any positive gain, I feel fatigued, I'm constipated and my digestion is worse than before. > > I calcolated my carb intake (75g) and to reach it I eat a lot of vegetables. However I was never able to reach more than 50g carbs. > > Can I ask you what kind and what quantity of vegetables do you eat? > How much carbs do you eat a day? +++Hi Fabio, Each person's calculation of protein, fat and carb intake is different, which is according to their height, so you can't go by quantities someone else is having. Everyone on my program only has the kinds of carbs I recommend, which are on this food list: http://www.healingnaturallybybee.com/articles/foodslist.php So I assume you are entering the foods you eat into www.fitday.com to see the amount of grams so you can adjust your food intake accordingly? First, calculate ratios here: http://www.healingnaturallybybee.com/articles/foods8.php Second, follow the instructions for entering foods into fitday.com: http://www.healingnaturallybybee.com/articles/foods9.php If my program were a problem no one would be getting healthy like they are - see these Success Stories: http://www.healingnaturallybybee.com/success/index.php Of course while your body is healing it is going to " retrace " all past issues you've had with digestion or any other kinds of health issues - see this: http://www.healingnaturallybybee.com/articles/heal10.php Of course you also must only have well-cooked carbs (vegetables) as explained in this article: http://www.healingnaturallybybee.com/articles/veg3.php Since you are having digestive problems you need to do my 9-Day Program: http://www.healingnaturallybybee.com/articles/dig6.php However, you may need to stay on liquid and pureed foods much longer than 2 days, so only do the enemas for 9 days total and after that do them every 4-5 days. I've known people with digestive issues that needed 1 year in order to heal properly. Bee Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.