Fw: Don't call it hysteria ~ Some doctors assume that if they can't diagnose it, it doesn't exist ~ Fibromyalgia ~ National Post

[Guest guest]

From: " Ilena Rose " <ilena@...>

Sent: Thursday, June 21, 2001 11:47 AM

Subject: Don't call it hysteria ~ Some doctors assume that if they can't

diagnose it, it doesn't exist ~ Fibromyalgia ~ National Post

http://www.nationalpost.com/commentary/columnists/story.html?f=/stories/2001

0620

/596215.html

June 20, 2001

Don't call it hysteria

Some doctors assume that if they can't diagnose it, it doesn't exist

Norman Doidge

National Post

This newspaper ran a front-page story recently in which Professor

Shorter, a historian and the author of a book on the history of

psychiatry, asserted confidently that a number of conditions, such as

chronic fatigue, repetitive stress injury and hypoglycemia, are not real

physical illnesses but hysteria. He argued that no underlying organic

cause has been found, that the incidence of these conditions rises and

falls, and that they are mere " media-spread illness attributions. " He

says, " And if you have basically hysteria and you can dignify it with

something that makes it sound like you have a serious illness, then you

get more respect from people. "

I know hysteria exists: I treat it. But to point out, as Shorter does,

that a condition rises and falls at certain points in history or with

media attention, or that it lacks a known organic cause, is no proof of

hysteria. Once, AIDS didn't exist, then it did, and hopefully one day it

won't. In the period when the syndrome was being clarified, but before the

virus was discovered, many had their doubts that it was a single entity

because many different organ systems were affected. Similarly, being

unable to find an organic cause (as we couldn't for some time with AIDS)

is also no proof of hysteria.

Hysteria is never a diagnosis one should make just because one can't

figure out what is happening medically in a patient. The technical term

for this practice is " diagnosis by exclusion. " That means that one comes

to a diagnosis ( " It must be in the patient's head " ) only because one has

excluded every other possibility one can imagine.

Doctors approaching patients that way simply assume that " if it doesn't

show up on my lab test or physical exam, it doesn't exist. " But lab tests

and physical exams are only windows into known disease processes.

Sometimes they provide an excellent view, sometimes not.

I raise these concerns because there may have been an important medical

breakthrough in understanding one of the conditions that has often been

stigmatized as being nothing but hysteria. That condition is fibromyalgia,

and a new approach may in fact knit together the mystery of chronic

fatigue, hypoglycemia and some forms of muscle and tendon problems.

Fibromyalgia is a misnomer. It means " muscle pain " and is used because

many of these patients -- 85% of whom are women -- have bouts of muscle

aches and tender spots in muscles and tendons. They are often sore and

stiff. Most also can't get enough restorative sleep or have insomnia,

fatigue easily and experience a mental fog. (These symptoms are a lot like

those of chronic fatigue.)

But they are also prone to inflammatory bowel disease and -- as is less

well known -- bladder or vulvar pain, pain during intercourse, chronic

infections, brittle nails and excessive tartar on their teeth. A subset

suffer from hypoglycemia and weight gain. As the problem progresses, they

become increasingly immobilized and depressed; in later years, they often

develop osteoarthritis.

With so many different symptoms, they do the rounds with different kinds

of doctors, chiropractors and naturopaths and do poorly in treatment.

Rheumatologists now say fibromyalgia is the most common disorder they see.

Because anxiety and depression are prominent, these patients are often

treated as having psychiatric problems. Symptomatic treatment with

antidepressants and pain medications may help, but only a little. Many

lives are ruined.

But Dr. R. St. Amand, an internist and endocrinologist who has

treated more than 5,000 fibromyalgics, has figured out a new way of

helping, if not all fibromyalgics, at least a large subtype. In his model,

chronic fatigue and hypoglycemia may be different aspects of the same

condition.

Originally, St. Amand was treating gout patients. One day, one of his

patients showed him that he had a massive tartar buildup. St. Amand was

intrigued, so he studied the composition of tartar and found it was made

up of calcium and phosphate. Immersing himself in the study of gout, he

found that when it was originally described, some gout patients also had

chronic fatigue and muscle aches. Then he began to see a number of

patients who just had the fatigue and muscle aches. He decided to give

them gout medications, and, amazingly, they got better. When the term

fibromyalgia was introduced, he realized this was the same group of

patients.

Next, St. Amand came across a 1989 study in which the muscle and red blood

cells of fibromyalgics were studied and were shown to be low in a chemical

called adenosine triphosphate -- three phosphate molecules attached to

adenosine. All our cells use adenosine triphosphate to produce energy. St.

Amand's insight was to remember his patient who had excessive tartar

(calcium and, more importantly, phosphate). He recognized that some

fibromyalgics he treated also had heavy tartar. As well, some had brittle

nails (nail minerals are predominantly calcium and phosphate, and when

these are off-balance, crystals form and the nails get brittle).

According to St. Amand's theory, fibromyalgia is a genetic problem in

which the sufferer has difficulty getting rid of phosphates. Over a

lifetime, negatively charged phosphate builds up in the cells, interfering

with the functioning of adenosine triphosphate. This makes it hard for

cells, especially in the brain, muscles and immune system, to generate

energy. As well, calcium, which is positively charged, moves into the

cells to " buffer " -- or electrically neutralize -- the excess phosphate.

Because calcium normally turns on cellular and muscular activities, the

cells are put into overdrive, adding to the person's exhaustion. The

fibromyalgic's tender spots are produced because certain muscles can't

turn off and chronically contract.

The drug he uses, gaufenesin, is available over the counter. It was

discovered in 1543 and acts on the kidneys. When patients go on it, the

phosphates empty out of their cells into the bloodstream. Patients on

gaufenesin show a 65% increase in phosphate excretion into their urine.

They also lose the excess calcium, and the tender spots go away.

As the phosphate pours into the bloodstream, symptoms may get worse. But

when it is excreted, they feel better, often for the first time in years.

Patients cycle like this until their systems are consistently free of

symptoms.

There are two catches, though. First, gaufenesin doesn't work in the

presence of salicylates (which are in Aspirin, many cosmetics, aloe strips

in shavers and many herbs and plants), so one must vigilantly restrict

them; they block the site in the kidneys where gaufenesin acts. Second, a

subset of patients must be on a low-carbohydrate diet, because they have

carbohydrate intolerance and hypoglycemia. St. Amand shows how these are

related to fibromyalgia.

Dr. St. Amand's book for the general reader, What Your Doctor May Not Tell

You About Fibromyalgia, by Warner Books, is clear and interesting. The Web

site is at www.guaidoc.com.

Norman Doidge, M.D., is a research psychiatrist and psychoanalyst. His

column appears every other Wednesday.