Guest guest Posted February 18, 2010 Report Posted February 18, 2010 Sheila, You wrote: > > Your problem is that you fail to follow up your statements by > citing references.... What unmitigated hypocrisy. The entire reason I recently left your TPA list is because you would not ALLOW me to post citations, even when they were in support of a position you took. Apparently ' offense was that he dared to question your received wisdom on thyroid products from which all active ingredients had been removed, ergo expensive hamburger. In fact, I think is being unnecessarily forgiving about the way he was treated by your list. I repeatedly asked you for citations in support of your advice on adrenals, to which you never once replied. Not one citation. My impression is that your so-called " support " list is nothing but a thinly disguised front for a doctor who had his license revoked for his unorthodox treatment methods involving hypoT. I have never experienced a list with a more repressive level of censorship. In contrast, this Group is billed as both a discussion and support list. Thus, unlike your tightly controlled propagandistic forum, dissent is accepted here. That gives every right to be interested and to be here. It also explains how he can be so forgiving about being booted off your list. I don't consider it much of a loss, either. As to the immediate issue, there are nine major studies in the last decade alone that show no measurable advantage of T3 combinations over T4 only medications, except in one study in which a majority of patients expressed a preference for T3 combinations, even though there was no discernible physiological difference. I personally think there are still situations where T3 combinations are warranted, but the currently accepted practices are based on many studies, not just opinion, as you patently and dishonestly asserted. Since we long ago discussed these nine studies on your list, I know you are aware of them. Thus, your claim that support for their conclusions is nothing but opinion, is more than an accidental prevarication but another deliberate attempt to mislead. Here are a few of the citations and abstracts: Treatment of Hypothyroidism with Combinations of Levothyroxine plus Liothyronine Héctor F. Escobar-Morreale, José I. Botella-Carretero, Francisco Escobar del Rey and la Morreale de Escobar, ANN INTERN MED 2005;142:412-424. Nine controlled clinical trials were identified that compared treatment with levothyroxine alone and treatment with combinations of levothyroxine plus liothyronine and included a sufficient number of adult hypothyroid patients to yield meaningful results. In only one study did the combined therapy appear to have beneficial effects on the mood, quality of life, and psychometric performance of the patients over levothyroxine alone. These results have not been confirmed by later studies using either T3 substitution protocols or approaches with fixed combinations of levothyroxine plus liothyronine, including those based on the physiological proportion in which T3 and T4 are secreted by the human thyroid. However, in some of these studies the patients preferred levothyroxine plus liothyronine combinations, for reasons not explained by changes in the psychological and psychometric tests employed. Yet patients’ preference should be balanced against the possibility of adverse events resulting from the addition of liothyronine to levothyroxine, even in the small doses used in these studies. Conclusions: Until clear advantages of levothyroxine plus liothyronine are demonstrated, the administration of levothyroxine alone should remain the treatment of choice for replacement therapy of hypothyroidism. Same authors, ls of Int. Med., 2005: " In summary, treatment with L-thyroxine–liothyronine combinations that replicate the ratio of thyroxine to triiodothyronine in human thyroid secretion does not offer any objective advantage over treatment with L-thyroxine alone, although patients prefer combination treatment. However, the addition of even minimally excessive liothyronine doses to L-thyroxine may have undesirable effects. Until clear advantages of L-thyroxine–liothyronine combinations are demonstrated, L-thyroxine alone should remain the drug of choice for hypothyroid replacement therapy. " Combined Levothyroxine Plus Liothyronine Compared With Levothyroxine Alone in Primary Hypothyroidism: A Randomized Controlled Trial W. Clyde, Amir E. Harari, J. Getka, and K. M. Mohamed Shakir, JAMA. 2003;290(22):2952-2958. Treatment of Clinical Hypothyroidism With Thyroxine and Triiodothyronine: A Literature Review and Metaanalysis Joffe et al., Psychosomatics 2007;48:379-384. Thyroxine is the standard replacement therapy for patients with clinical hypothyroidism. However, there has been recent interest in examining the potential advantages of combined thyroxine and triiodothyronine treatment for the treatment of hypothyroidism. The authors review the nine studies to-date and conclude that the variability and limitations in study design make definitive and clinically useful recommendations difficult. They therefore conducted a metaanalysis of the nine controlled studies examining the impact of combined thyroxine-plus-triiodothyronine versus thyroxine alone, with measures of psychiatric symptoms as the primary outcome. Their analysis reveals no significant difference in treatment effect on psychiatric symptoms in the nine controlled studies to date. Bunévicius R, Kazanavicius G, Zalinkevicius R, Prange AJ. Effects of thyroxine as compared with thyroxine plus triiodothyronine in patients with hypothyroidism. N Engl J Med 340(6):424-429, 1999. Treatment of Hypothyroidism with Combinations of Levothyroxine plus Liothyronine Escobar-Morreale et al. J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab. 2005;90:4946-4954. Combined T3/T4 for Hypothyroidism -- Again, No Better Than T4 Psychiatry 2004;2004:8-8. Gastroenterology 2004;2004:10-10. Here is a table from a 2005 Slone Survey on patterns of medication use. http://128.197.26.3/slone/SloneSurvey/AnnualRpt/SloneSurveyWebReport2005.pdf Table 2. Thirty Most Commonly Used Prescription and Over-the-Counter Drugs Taken by U.S. Adults in 2005 According to Sex and Age Males 18-44 45-64 65+ Females 18-44 45-64 65+ Total (n=366) (n=423)(n=277) (n=450)(n=672)(n=496) (n=2684) No. (%)* No. (%)* No.(%)* No. (%)* No. (%)* No.(%)*No.(%)** Acetaminophen 65 (19) 45 (13) 47 (17) 97 (23) 156 (24) 119 (25) 529 (20) Aspirin 24 (6.7) 111 (26) 112 (40) 27 (5.3) 148 (22) 173 (36) 595 (17) Ibuprofen 55 (17) 39 (9.8) 18 (6.9) 111 (25) 109 (16) 41 (9.5) 373 (16) Atorvastatin 8 (1.6) 46 (11) 38 (14) 4 (0.4) 58 (9.4) 70 (14) 224 (6.2) Levothyroxine 9 (2.4) 9 (2.0) 12 (4.8) 23 (5.1) 69 (10) 75 (15) 197(5.6) Hydrochlorothiaz 4 (1.5) 30 (6.0) 28 (10) 9 (1.9) 66 (9.1)68(14)205(5.3) Pseudoephedrine 27 (6.2) 18 (4.2) 4 (1.4) 31 (6.5) 45(6.6)8(1.6)133(5.3) Naproxen 11 (3.2) 13 (3.0) 14 (4.1) 22 (4.9) 43 (6.6) 14 (2.5) 117 (4.3) Metoprolol 4 (1.1) 20 (4.7) 37 (13) 5 (1.1) 33 (5.1) 61 (12) 160 (4.2) Lisinopril 5 (1.2) 25 (5.4) 33 (15) 5 (0.7) 40 (5.5) 46 (10) 154 (4.0) Simvastatin 3 (0.8) 29 (5.9) 35 (13) 1 (0.3) 27 (4.1) 35 (7.3) 130 (3.4) Fluticasone 6 (2.0) 16 (3.5) 13 (5.2) 14 (2.8) 28 (3.9) 23 (4.5)100(3.2) Atenolol 3 (0.5) 23 (4.5) 20 (10) 2 (0.4) 23 (3.1) 55 (11) 126 (3.1) Amlodipine 4 (0.6) 19 (4.3) 28 (8.8) 2 (0.2) 33 (4.7) 37 (7.8) 123 (3.1) Diphenhydramine 3 (0.7) 6 (1.3) 5 (1.8) 25 (5.4) 34 (4.8) 25(4.3)98(3.1) Albuterol 7 (1.9) 9 (1.4) 10 (3.2) 15 (3.1) 31 (4.2) 22 (3.9) 94 (3.0) Metformin 2 (0.2) 16 (3.6) 16 (6.0) 8 (1.5) 37 (5.4) 27 (5.7) 106 (2.8) Esomeprazole 5 (1.6) 9 (3.0) 14 (4.6) 6 (1.2) 28 (4.1) 21 (4.4) 83 (2.6) Furosemide 1 (0.1) 8 (1.8) 28 (9.0) 2 (0.1) 21 (2.9) 45 (9.7) 105 (2.5) Valsartan 2 (0.7) 10 (2.5) 13 (5.4) 3 (0.7) 17 (2.8) 30 (6.2) 75 (2.2) Fexofenadine 6 (1.9) 13 (2.9) 4 (1.6) 13 (2.5) 15 (2.1) 8 (1.6) 59 (2.1) Warfarin 3 (1.0) 6 (1.3) 26 (9.1) 0 -- 11 (1.4) 36 (6.9)82(2.0) Omeprazole 6 (1.6) 10 (2.7) 12 (4.8) 4 (0.7) 14 (2.1) 18 (4.0) 64 (2.0) Salmeterol 4 (1.4) 12 (2.5) 11 (4.6) 7 (1.4) 15 (2.1) 15 (2.9) 64 (2.0) Loratadine 2 (0.6) 11 (2.8) 5 (1.8) 14 (2.6) 20 (2.8) 7 (1.9) 59 (2.0) Clopidogrel 1 (0.1) 11 (2.4) 26 (8.5) 0 (--) 11 (1.6) 26 (5.8) 75 (1.8) Sertraline 2 (0.5) 7 (1.5) 5 (1.4) 7 (1.8) 19 (2.5) 18 (4.2) 58 (1.8) Lansoprazole 1 (0.1) 8 (1.7) 7 (3.2) 4 (0.7) 27 (3.0) 16 (3.2) 63 (1.5) Triamterene 0 (--) 6 (1.6) 7 (2.2) 2 (0.4) 18 (2.5) 26 (5.6) 59 (1.5) Alendronate 1 (0.1) 2 (0.4) 3 (1.0) 0 (--) 23 (2.9) 38 (7.0) 67 (1.3) *Weighted according to household size **Weighted according to household size and adjusted to US 2005 population (ref). Note that Armour and other dessicated forms are not even listed. et al. BMC Public Health 2009 9:132 doi:10.1186/1471-2458-9-132 NHS statistics for 2007: http://www.ic.nhs.uk/webfiles/publications/PCA%20publication/PCA%202007%20comple\ te%20V2.pdf show that T4 only medications had a total of 18,736,400 prescriptions in the U.K. In the same year, Armour had a _total_ of 1,500 prescriptions and T3 forms had 48,100 prescriptions. In costs, that is 41,013,300 versus 68,900 and 557,300. Either way, the total of all alternatives to T4 only was less than 0.1%. Armour prescriptions in the U.K. are less than four order of magnitude less than T4 only. Lest you think this neglects too many non-prescription sales, the entire volume of Forest Laboratories sales from ALL their products was less than 10% of this total last year. Chuck Quote
Guest guest Posted February 18, 2010 Report Posted February 18, 2010 Hi Chuck > > Sheila, > > You wrote: > > > > Your problem is that you fail to follow up your statements by > > citing references.... > > What unmitigated hypocrisy. > > The entire reason I recently left your TPA list is because you would not > ALLOW me to post citations, even when they were in support of a position > you took. You are yet again twisting facts to suit your agenda. FACT: I run two – both under the heading Thyroid Patient Advocacy-UK. The main one is for campaigning and for support of those folk suffering with thyroid disease. The second, (named `LABGAB') I opened specifically for those who were interested in the legal aspects of campaigning issues and a place to discuss topics for the more scientifically minded, as not all members want their Inbox filled up with information they neither want nor understand. At that time my forum was receiving over 2600 messages a month, and it was felt necessary to split the forum into groups. Part of the message on the LABGAB Home Page Message reads : " This forum is dedicated solely to discussions and debates about purely scientific aspects regarding the diagnosis and treatment of thyroid disease. You insisted on posting `purely scientific' discussions with long lists of citations (as you have done here) on to the main support forum. I asked you on many occasions to repost them onto LABGAB . I received notification from that there was a message waiting to be approved on the main forum from you. After reading it, I rejected it and asked you to resend to LABGAB as you completely ignored my request previously. You said you were not going to do that and with that, you unsubscribed. Your assertion that I refused you to post citations is quite untrue. >Apparently ' offense was that he dared to question your > received wisdom on thyroid products from which all active ingredients > had been removed, ergo expensive hamburger. > In fact, I think is being unnecessarily forgiving about the way he > was treated by your list. was removed from our list because my moderators and some members had asked for him to be removed because of his constant negative remarks and belittling of our recommendations for treatment using a specific thyroid supplement we recommend. This supplement is called Nutri Thyroid. Both you and continually argued that we were recommending an " expensive hamburgher " because it contained NO active ingredients. Even today you still maintain we are recommending an " expensive hamburgher " , though I suspect this is something you originally said, and copied it. You say this because you believe that Nutri Thyroid has had all thyroid hormone removed. Go to the Nutri site and read up about this product. They do say that their product is completely " thyroxine-free " –it does not say " thyroid hormone free " . This product is equivalent to Nutri-Meds. Nutri Meds is described as " dietary desiccated thyroid " and is sold over the counter in the US. Both products are described as " glandulars " . Each tablet contains 130mg of desiccated thyroid powder from animals in New Zealand (pigs for Nutri Thyroid and cows and pigs for Nutri Meds). Agreed - both are thyroxine (T4) free because the FDA would remove them from the market if they were not thyroxine free. The assumption is, then that as ONLY thyroxine was removed, the tablets still contains T3, T2, T1 as these hormones are natural to thyroid gland tissue. So they are not the " expensive hamburgher " you would have others believe. I run my forum to offer support and help others get the confidence and information they will need if the time ever comes when they need to take their thyroid health into their own hands. My members are my first consideration.I will fight tooth and nail if others, through bullying tactics, try to undermine the work that I am doing, or try to undermine any of the products we recommend without them having a very good reason. Both and yourself gave your `opinion' only about the adrenal and thyroid glandulars we recommend. was always treated courteously by all, including me, and so were you. I repeatedly asked you for citations in > support of your advice on adrenals, to which you never once replied. Not > one citation. My impression is that your so-called " support " list is > nothing but a thinly disguised front for a doctor who had his license > revoked for his unorthodox treatment methods involving hypoT. I have > never experienced a list with a more repressive level of censorship. You were not given citations because I am not sure there are any when it comes to treating low adrenal reserve as opposed to primary adrenal insufficiency. I am not sure whether any studies have been done. Certainly no studies have ever been done to show that synthetic thyroxine is superior to any other thyroid hormone replacements. My support list has five medical advisers, all of whom are highly respected by the hundreds, if not thousands, of patients who have regained their normal health under their guidance and care. These doctors were chosen deliberately because they dare to diagnose and treat outside mainstream guidelines and get their patients well. The one doctor, to whom you refer,was trained at the Broda Foundation, and has given back normal health to hundreds of US citizens as well as thousands UK citizens – and we know not how many world-wide who have read his books.You do him a great disservice by your remarks. Your opinion about his license being revoked is wrong. His license was suspended while on-going investigations were being made. At that time, and because he had reached retirement age, he decided to call it a day and open his Metabolic Clinics so he could continue to diagnose and treat in the way he knew worked - so gave up his registration voluntarily. > > In contrast, this Group is billed as both a discussion and support > list. Thus, unlike your tightly controlled propagandistic forum, dissent > is accepted here. That gives every right to be interested and to > be here. It also explains how he can be so forgiving about being booted > off your list. I don't consider it much of a loss, either. You have made it very clear that you do not like forums that are moderated – hence your antagonism. If you believe that a moderated group means we run " a tightly controlled propagandistic forum where dissent is not allowed " - you couldn't be further from the truth. We are a well established organisation and will continue to provide support and help to those who need it, and ask for it.If you seek to change TPA-s constitution, you are wasting your time. > > As to the immediate issue, there are nine major studies in the last > decade alone that show no measurable advantage of T3 combinations over > T4 only medications, except in one study in which a majority of patients > expressed a preference for T3 combinations, even though there was no > discernible physiological difference. I personally think there are still > situations where T3 combinations are warranted, but the currently > accepted practices are based on many studies, not just opinion, as you > patently and dishonestly asserted. > We know through the thousands of counterexamples to the levothyroxine-only therapy that `accepted practices' have been reached through invalid conclusions of the studies you quote. This is not just my opinion. These counterexamples are those suffering symptoms of hypothyroidism that were not alleviated or eliminated on T4-only therapy, yet who regained their normal health when a T3 product was prescribed. I would suggest that you read Dr Lowe's rebuttal to the British Thyroid Association's Statement on natural thyroid extract and synthetic T4/T3 combination therapy if you have not already done so regarding the studies you quote. http://www.thyroidscience.com/Criticism/lowe.3.16.09/lowe.bta.rebuttal.3\ ..16.09.pdf <http://www.thyroidscience.com/Criticism/lowe.3.16.09/lowe.bta.rebuttal.\ 3.16.09.pdf> - there's many other such critiques that I am sure you have already read. Sheila Quote
Guest guest Posted February 19, 2010 Report Posted February 19, 2010 I appreciate the support, Chuck; it really means a lot to me. Regards, .. .. > > Posted by: " Chuck B " gumboyaya@... > <mailto:gumboyaya@...?Subject=%20Re%3ACites%20and%20Stats> > gumbo482001 <gumbo482001> > > > Wed Feb 17, 2010 4:43 pm (PST) > > > > Sheila, > > You wrote: > > > > Your problem is that you fail to follow up your statements by > > citing references.. > .. > > What unmitigated hypocrisy. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 20, 2010 Report Posted February 20, 2010 Sheila is fantastic. I'm sorry her wisdom and knowledge are being attacked as they are. I'm honored to know her through her forum. I have had, I believe, one small disagreement with her, but just about always I have found her to be right on the money. Sheesh. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 20, 2010 Report Posted February 20, 2010 I heartily agree with you. I did myself a disservice when I listened to the opinions of Chuck and in respect of thyroid and adrenal glandulars ...supplementing with them has been extremely beneficial to me as a part of t4 only treatment. I am feeling the best I have ever since I started taking them. Everyone makes mistakes though Trish > > Sheila is fantastic. I'm sorry her wisdom and knowledge are being attacked > as they are. I'm honored to know her through her forum. I have had, I > believe, one small disagreement with her, but just about always I have found > her to be right on the money. > > > > Sheesh. > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 21, 2010 Report Posted February 21, 2010 Trish, You wrote: > > I did myself a disservice when I listened to the opinions of Chuck and > in respect of thyroid and adrenal glandulars ... Exactly when did either of us talk about adrenal glandulars? For most people, the removed active ingredient for these is adrenaline. There is a small amount of hydrocortisone left in, under the prescription guidelines. So, that might be an alternative to the otc skin creams, for people who are convinced they need that support. However, I am still waiting for credible research that affirms efficacy of physiologic doses of glucocorticoids when tests do not detect adrenal insufficiency. Chuck Quote
Guest guest Posted February 21, 2010 Report Posted February 21, 2010 The ACTH tests check for adrenal insufficiency only Chuck, at least in the UK. Either you are shown to have 's disease or you are shown to have Cushing's syndrome, but for the majority, any shades of grey between the two, showing low adrenal reserve, do not show up, so the patient is told they have normal adrenal function. If you can't find the credible research then probably none has been done. The only test that shows low adrenal reserve is the 24 hour salivary adrenal profile that checks the level of DHEA and cortisol at four specific times during the day. Sheila > > However, I am still waiting for credible research that affirms efficacy > of physiologic doses of glucocorticoids when tests do not detect adrenal > insufficiency. > > Chuck > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 21, 2010 Report Posted February 21, 2010 We didn't talk directly ....for a very long time I read all there was to read .... " expensive hamburger " was the clear message from you and . Trish > > > > I did myself a disservice when I listened to the opinions of Chuck and > > in respect of thyroid and adrenal glandulars ... > > Exactly when did either of us talk about adrenal glandulars? > > For most people, the removed active ingredient for these is adrenaline. > There is a small amount of hydrocortisone left in, under the > prescription guidelines. So, that might be an alternative to the otc > skin creams, for people who are convinced they need that support. > > However, I am still waiting for credible research that affirms efficacy > of physiologic doses of glucocorticoids when tests do not detect adrenal > insufficiency. > > Chuck > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 21, 2010 Report Posted February 21, 2010 I'd like to pose another question to this whole adrenal issue? WHY are the doctors both here and in the UK so reluctant to address this issue? If someone has some " inside " people that they could speak with privately to find out what is REALLY going on, it might benefit us all. <>Roni Immortality exists! It's called knowledge! Just because something isn't seen doesn't mean it's not there<> From: SheilaT <sheilaturner@...> Subject: Re:Cites and Stats hypothyroidism Date: Sunday, February 21, 2010, 11:53 AM The ACTH tests check for adrenal insufficiency only Chuck, at least in the UK. Either you are shown to have 's disease or you are shown to have Cushing's syndrome, but for the majority, any shades of grey between the two, showing low adrenal reserve, do not show up, so the patient is told they have normal adrenal function. If you can't find the credible research then probably none has been done. The only test that shows low adrenal reserve is the 24 hour salivary adrenal profile that checks the level of DHEA and cortisol at four specific times during the day. Sheila > > However, I am still waiting for credible research that affirms efficacy > of physiologic doses of glucocorticoids when tests do not detect adrenal > insufficiency. > > Chuck > ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted February 21, 2010 Report Posted February 21, 2010 Expensive hamburger is a metaphor for something not terribly efficacious as hormone therapy. Getting lost in the minutia destroys the ability for all to put forth their points of view so that everyone can examine them and decide for themselves what they want to do. <>Roni Immortality exists! It's called knowledge! Just because something isn't seen doesn't mean it's not there<> From: Trish <fielddot@...> Subject: Re:Cites and Stats hypothyroidism Date: Sunday, February 21, 2010, 12:11 PM We didn't talk directly ....for a very long time I read all there was to read .... " expensive hamburger " was the clear message from you and . Trish > > > > I did myself a disservice when I listened to the opinions of Chuck and > > in respect of thyroid and adrenal glandulars ... > > Exactly when did either of us talk about adrenal glandulars? > > For most people, the removed active ingredient for these is adrenaline. > There is a small amount of hydrocortisone left in, under the > prescription guidelines. So, that might be an alternative to the otc > skin creams, for people who are convinced they need that support. > > However, I am still waiting for credible research that affirms efficacy > of physiologic doses of glucocorticoids when tests do not detect adrenal > insufficiency. > > Chuck > ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted February 21, 2010 Report Posted February 21, 2010 Sheila, You wrote: > > The ACTH tests check for adrenal insufficiency only Chuck, at least in > the UK. Either you are shown to have 's disease or you are shown > to have Cushing's syndrome, ... I just went through these tests with my son. The ACTH detects adrenal failure or Cushings, as you said. He passed that test. No 's, either. So, they gave him a 24 hour urine test, which they said would detect even subclinical adrenal insufficiency. This was at a university medical center, where the endos are also professors. Chuck Quote
Guest guest Posted February 22, 2010 Report Posted February 22, 2010 I believe the reason is that there is no recognized disease called " adrenal fatigue " . There are no professionaly recognized symptoms; there are no professionally recognized tests and there are no professionally recognized treatments. This from the Mayo Clinic: .. .. > *Adrenal* *fatigue* is a term applied to a collection of nonspecific > symptoms, such as body aches, *fatigue*, nervousness, sleep > disturbances and digestive problems. The term often shows up in > popular health books and on alternative medicine Web sites, but it > isn't an accepted medical diagnosis. .. .. It's rather difficult to treat a group of nonspecific symptoms with no credible tests available and no established treatment. PS: I believe I've posted the same [or similar] before. Perhaps this is where the idea that I've addressed adrenal glandulars comes from??? .. .. > Posted by: " Roni Molin " matchermaam@... > <mailto:matchermaam@...?Subject=%20Re%3A%20Cites%20and%20Stats> > matchermaam <matchermaam> > > > Sun Feb 21, 2010 12:16 pm (PST) > > > > I'd like to pose another question to this whole adrenal issue? WHY are > the doctors both here and in the UK so reluctant to address this > issue? If someone has some " inside " people that they could speak with > privately to find out what is REALLY going on, it might benefit us all. > > <>Roni Quote
Guest guest Posted February 22, 2010 Report Posted February 22, 2010 It is that; but in this case it's more. Here it is literally the flesh of a pig [or cow in some cases] from which the hormones have been removed. With a pig we really should say " expensive sausage " I guess! [ggg] .. .. > > Posted by: " Roni Molin " matchermaam@... > <mailto:matchermaam@...?Subject=%20Re%3A%20Cites%20and%20Stats> > matchermaam <matchermaam> > > > Sun Feb 21, 2010 12:21 pm (PST) > > > > Expensive hamburger is a metaphor for something not terribly > efficacious as hormone therapy. Getting lost in the minutia destroys > the ability for all to put forth their points of view so that everyone > can examine them and decide for themselves what they want to do. > > <>Roni > Immortality exists! > It's called knowledge! > > Just because something isn't seen > doesn't mean it's not there<> > > > > From: Trish <fielddot@... <mailto:fielddot%40gmail.com>> > Subject: Re:Cites and Stats > hypothyroidism > <mailto:hypothyroidism%40> > Date: Sunday, February 21, 2010, 12:11 PM > > We didn't talk directly ....for a very long time I read all there was > to read ... " expensive hamburger " was the clear message from you and . > > Trish Quote
Guest guest Posted February 22, 2010 Report Posted February 22, 2010 That may be so, but for me, the achiles heel of allopathic treatment is that they wait until you are very sick before they start giving you treatments that may or may not help you, and in many cases actually do harm or exacerbate the condition for which you are being treated. I found this out when I was doing research for atrial fibrillation, and ended up not taking anything on a daily basis. Instead I opted for medication on what they call pill-in-the-pocket basis which means when I get an episode, I take the medication. When it stops, that's it. So far so good. Most of the medications have really bad short and long term side effects. Thyroid hormones do not. The only problems come into play due to dosage. However, if your body does not metabolize T4 like it's " supposed " to do, you are not going to feel well. The allopathic doctors for the most part are totally stubborn in insisting that it's the only way to treat hypoTs. As for RT3, they don't even want to test for it, and I've had doctors tell me they are not interested in it. It's very difficult to say the least, but a supplement is not going to give you the thyroid hormone you need, and a patient who needs thyroid will get sicker without it, and eventually die. <>Roni Immortality exists! It's called knowledge! Just because something isn't seen doesn't mean it's not there<> From: <res075oh@...> Subject: Re: Cites and Stats hypothyroidism Date: Sunday, February 21, 2010, 6:52 PM I believe the reason is that there is no recognized disease called " adrenal fatigue " . There are no professionaly recognized symptoms; there are no professionally recognized tests and there are no professionally recognized treatments. This from the Mayo Clinic: .. .. > *Adrenal* *fatigue* is a term applied to a collection of nonspecific > symptoms, such as body aches, *fatigue*, nervousness, sleep > disturbances and digestive problems. The term often shows up in > popular health books and on alternative medicine Web sites, but it > isn't an accepted medical diagnosis. .. .. It's rather difficult to treat a group of nonspecific symptoms with no credible tests available and no established treatment. PS: I believe I've posted the same [or similar] before. Perhaps this is where the idea that I've addressed adrenal glandulars comes from??? .. .. > Posted by: " Roni Molin " matchermaam@... > <mailto:matchermaam@...?Subject=%20Re%3A%20Cites%20and%20Stats> > matchermaam <matchermaam> > > > Sun Feb 21, 2010 12:16 pm (PST) > > > > I'd like to pose another question to this whole adrenal issue? WHY are > the doctors both here and in the UK so reluctant to address this > issue? If someone has some " inside " people that they could speak with > privately to find out what is REALLY going on, it might benefit us all. > > <>Roni ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted February 22, 2010 Report Posted February 22, 2010 You are lucky in the US that such a test would be done as a matter of course. Rarely would an NHS doctor offer a 24 hour urine test if the ACTH test showed negative results for either Cushing's or s. Good to know that your son does not have an adrenal problem. Sheila > > I just went through these tests with my son. The ACTH detects adrenal > failure or Cushings, as you said. He passed that test. No 's, > either. So, they gave him a 24 hour urine test, which they said would > detect even subclinical adrenal insufficiency. This was at a university > medical center, where the endos are also professors. > > Chuck > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 22, 2010 Report Posted February 22, 2010 The 24-hour urine test is useless in cases of beginning adrenal insufficiency. I took that, and it showed me to be fine. The 24-hour salivary cortisol test is much better. The urine test gathers all the cortisol output for the entire 24-hour period and presents this total number. In the early stages of adrenal insufficiency, output may be good at some times of the day and not so good at others. It may even be too high at some and too low at others. The adrenals begin to splutter and be uneven in their cortisol output as they lose strength. (Cortisol output WILL be uneven, as it follows a circadian rhythm; but there are expected ranges for each 6-hour time period which take this into account; and for someone in early-state adrenal insufficiency, results will be out of this range - either high, or low - for at least one of these time periods.) The 24-hour salivary test measures cortisol output every 6 hours during the 24-hour period, so we can see at which time of day the adrenals may be faltering, if they are. Total cortisol output for the 24-hour period is as useless as a Total T4 test or a Total T3 test. Different reason, same useless result. Total output for 24 hours may be completely adequate; yet, if this output was uneven, the amounts per time of day may be completely inadequate. Once I was tested on the salivary test, we could identify that I had an adrenal problem, and I was treated for it with great success. Cherwyn Quote
Guest guest Posted February 22, 2010 Report Posted February 22, 2010 Great information, thanks. What did you use to treat the adrenals? Trish > > The 24-hour urine test is useless in cases of beginning adrenal > insufficiency. I took that, and it showed me to be fine. The 24-hour > salivary cortisol test is much better. > > > > The urine test gathers all the cortisol output for the entire 24-hour period > and presents this total number. > > > > In the early stages of adrenal insufficiency, output may be good at some > times of the day and not so good at others. It may even be too high at some > and too low at others. The adrenals begin to splutter and be uneven in their > cortisol output as they lose strength. (Cortisol output WILL be uneven, as > it follows a circadian rhythm; but there are expected ranges for each 6-hour > time period which take this into account; and for someone in early-state > adrenal insufficiency, results will be out of this range - either high, or > low - for at least one of these time periods.) > > > > The 24-hour salivary test measures cortisol output every 6 hours during the > 24-hour period, so we can see at which time of day the adrenals may be > faltering, if they are. > > > > Total cortisol output for the 24-hour period is as useless as a Total T4 > test or a Total T3 test. Different reason, same useless result. Total output > for 24 hours may be completely adequate; yet, if this output was uneven, the > amounts per time of day may be completely inadequate. > > > > Once I was tested on the salivary test, we could identify that I had an > adrenal problem, and I was treated for it with great success. > > > > Cherwyn > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 22, 2010 Report Posted February 22, 2010 I'm sorry you are not so keen on detail Roni but sometimes it is very important. The reason I continued to talk with in another thread about how to slice the " types of medicine pie " was because he was not acknowledging that the pie should be sliced three ways rather than two, to wit Traditional Medicine, Allopathic Medicine, Alternative Medicine. As I pointed out at the time, it is ignorant to lump Traditional and Alternative medicine together. I have said before that I am a follower of Traditional Medicine ...actually I follow Ayurveda as a system and one of the most beautiful things about it is that it doesn't count anything out. It is inclusive rather than narrow and rigid like the allopathic model. In Ayurveda you would never get a physician telling you that you are fine because that is what your blood tests show despite your signs and symptoms clearly demonstrating that you are hypothyroid (for example). Ayurveda takes the best from everything that is available, it is inclusive. In the other thread, you are quite correct that " roughly " is the same as " about " ....that wasn't my point, Chuck first of all said half a pound of beef equals 1 kg ...I told him it did not, and he came back with: " I said " roughly " to simplify the calculation. When was the last time you ate exactly 1/2 pound of beef? The nearest steak house to me has a minimum size order of 12 ounces, which is 50% more than what we were considering. " and Chuck added this little gem: 1 pound = 2.2 kg. So, 1/2 pound = 1.1 kg, roughly 1 kg. and also asked which planet I was from! I find it interesting that his response to being told 1/2 pound was not equal to 1 kilo involved asking me when I last ate exactly 1/2 pound of beef! LOL (If someone questioned my conversion of something, the first thing I would do would be to check it out, I would not assume I was right because we can all make mistakes). I was surprised also that did not immediately swoop in regarding Chuck's erroneous conversion....afterall, it could be possible that some badly educated or exceedingly stupid person could take what Chuck had said as truth and then used his conversion for some reason or another and suffered damage. Regarding your suggestion about perhaps trying some T3 I have to say that I before I tried the glandulars I was thinking along those lines. However, as I am finding the glandulars to be so very helpful, I don't think I need to go the T3 route. (I am not in the UK and T3 is not at all easily available). Thank you for your suggestion though. Trish > > >��� > > > I did myself a disservice when I listened to the opinions of Chuck and > > > in respect of thyroid and adrenal glandulars ... > > > > Exactly when did either of us talk about adrenal glandulars? > > > > For most people, the removed active ingredient for these is adrenaline. > > There is a small amount of hydrocortisone left in, under the > > prescription guidelines. So, that might be an alternative to the otc > > skin creams, for people who are convinced they need that support. > > > > However, I am still waiting for credible research that affirms efficacy > > of physiologic doses of glucocorticoids when tests do not detect adrenal > > insufficiency. > > > > Chuck > > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 22, 2010 Report Posted February 22, 2010 I don't understand what you are talking about. I'm not keen on details? No, it's that I'm not keen on going on and on with a minute point that is really not the core issue. The supplement in question either has the active thyroid ingredients in it or it does not. That is the point of contention, not whether it is equal to 1/2 pound of rare or well done hamburger or not. It was a metaphor used for illustration. You are making too much out of it. Let it go and move on. However, if you have more information on what the ingredients actually are in that product, by all means please post it. <>Roni Immortality exists! It's called knowledge! Just because something isn't seen doesn't mean it's not there<> From: Trish <fielddot@...> Subject: Re:Cites and Stats hypothyroidism Date: Monday, February 22, 2010, 12:13 PM I'm sorry you are not so keen on detail Roni but sometimes it is very important. The reason I continued to talk with in another thread about how to slice the " types of medicine pie " was because he was not acknowledging that the pie should be sliced three ways rather than two, to wit Traditional Medicine, Allopathic Medicine, Alternative Medicine. As I pointed out at the time, it is ignorant to lump Traditional and Alternative medicine together. I have said before that I am a follower of Traditional Medicine ...actually I follow Ayurveda as a system and one of the most beautiful things about it is that it doesn't count anything out. It is inclusive rather than narrow and rigid like the allopathic model. In Ayurveda you would never get a physician telling you that you are fine because that is what your blood tests show despite your signs and symptoms clearly demonstrating that you are hypothyroid (for example). Ayurveda takes the best from everything that is available, it is inclusive. In the other thread, you are quite correct that " roughly " is the same as " about " ....that wasn't my point, Chuck first of all said half a pound of beef equals 1 kg ...I told him it did not, and he came back with: " I said " roughly " to simplify the calculation. When was the last time you ate exactly 1/2 pound of beef? The nearest steak house to me has a minimum size order of 12 ounces, which is 50% more than what we were considering. " and Chuck added this little gem: 1 pound = 2.2 kg. So, 1/2 pound = 1.1 kg, roughly 1 kg. and also asked which planet I was from! I find it interesting that his response to being told 1/2 pound was not equal to 1 kilo involved asking me when I last ate exactly 1/2 pound of beef! LOL (If someone questioned my conversion of something, the first thing I would do would be to check it out, I would not assume I was right because we can all make mistakes). I was surprised also that did not immediately swoop in regarding Chuck's erroneous conversion....afterall, it could be possible that some badly educated or exceedingly stupid person could take what Chuck had said as truth and then used his conversion for some reason or another and suffered damage. Regarding your suggestion about perhaps trying some T3 I have to say that I before I tried the glandulars I was thinking along those lines. However, as I am finding the glandulars to be so very helpful, I don't think I need to go the T3 route. (I am not in the UK and T3 is not at all easily available). Thank you for your suggestion though. Trish > > >��� > > > I did myself a disservice when I listened to the opinions of Chuck and > > > in respect of thyroid and adrenal glandulars ... > > > > Exactly when did either of us talk about adrenal glandulars? > > > > For most people, the removed active ingredient for these is adrenaline. > > There is a small amount of hydrocortisone left in, under the > > prescription guidelines. So, that might be an alternative to the otc > > skin creams, for people who are convinced they need that support. > > > > However, I am still waiting for credible research that affirms efficacy > > of physiologic doses of glucocorticoids when tests do not detect adrenal > > insufficiency. > > > > Chuck > > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 Every time I read something like that I want to exclaim: " Why the #e!! do you put up with it? " And then I realize that almost half the people in the US, including virtually 100% of the present Democrat ruling party seems to think it's a good idea for us too. And, IMHO will at some point inflict it upon us. So if anybody ever thought we in the US were smarter than you in the UK here's pretty convincing proof that it ain't so. You just had a few hundred years head start on us. .. .. > > Posted by: " SheilaT " sheilaturner@... > <mailto:sheilaturner@...?Subject=%20Re%3ACites%20and%20Stats> > campaigner77 <campaigner77> > > > Mon Feb 22, 2010 12:54 am (PST) > > > > > You are lucky in the US that such a test would be done as a matter of > course. Rarely would an NHS doctor offer a 24 hour urine test if the > ACTH test showed negative results for either Cushing's or s. Good > to know that your son does not have an adrenal problem. > > Sheila Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 Since the half life of T4 is about a week you aren't going to observe any benefit from testing at 6 hour intervals. .. .. > > Posted by: " Cherwyn Ambuter " cherwyn@... > <mailto:cherwyn@...?Subject=%20Re%3A%20Cites%20and%20Stats> > atmosphere1823 <atmosphere1823> > > > Mon Feb 22, 2010 4:44 am (PST) > > > > [...] > > Total cortisol output for the 24-hour period is as useless as a Total T4 > test or a Total T3 test. Different reason, same useless result. Total > output > for 24 hours may be completely adequate; yet, if this output was > uneven, the > amounts per time of day may be completely inadequate. > > [...] > Cherwyn Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 Sheila, You wrote: > > You are lucky in the US that such a test would be done as a matter of > course..... Well, he did have some Cushingoid indicators, but I think it is all from his goiter, which we will be removing in a few more weeks. I should emphasize they said they were looking for adrenal " insufficiency " rather than adrenal fatigue. I'm not sure where the boundary would be. Chuck Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 Cherwyn, You wrote: > > ... The urine test gathers all the cortisol output for the entire 24-hour period > and presents this total number.... That wasn't what they did. They showed us output as a function of time. We had to carefully segregate output by time and store it. Chuck Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 , I was talking about cortisol...Not T4. I was lumping both tests together as useless " but for different reasons. " Please read people's posts more carefully before announcing they have wrong reasoning. Thank you most sincerely, Cherwyn > > Since the half life of T4 is about a week you aren't going to observe > any benefit from testing at 6 hour intervals. > > > . > . > > > > > Posted by: " Cherwyn Ambuter " cherwyn@... > > <mailto:cherwyn@...?Subject=%20Re%3A%20Cites%20and%20Stats> > > atmosphere1823 <atmosphere1823> > > > > > > Mon Feb 22, 2010 4:44 am (PST) > > > > > > > > [...] > > > > Total cortisol output for the 24-hour period is as useless as a Total T4 > > test or a Total T3 test. Different reason, same useless result. Total > > output > > for 24 hours may be completely adequate; yet, if this output was > > uneven, the > > amounts per time of day may be completely inadequate. > > > > [...] > > Cherwyn > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 Hi, Chuck, thanks for elucidating. I was administered the 24-hour urine free cortisol test seven years ago, and at the time, it was structured as I described. Apparently, the test has been improved with this subdivision into 4 separate time periods for assessment, and I'm truly so thrilled to hear this. It makes me almost have a little tiny bit of hope for the traditional medical establishment, as far as their understanding of the adrenal/cortisol cycle and assessing it. I still don't know whether the test is as sensitive as is the salivary test, but it may be. It would be wonderful to see a side-by-side study and whether the results for the two tests correlated with one another. But, of course, that is never going to happen, as the traditional medical establishment is quite smug about even acknowledging the possibilities that the alternative medicine movement may have developed any kinds of worthwhile tests! But as I said, I remain thrilled that the medical community is gradually learning about how to design a good test. Now if we could only get the ranges right, and the treatments right! Good luck to your son - I sincerely wish him all the very best and hope that his health will be fully restored with the procedure he is about to have. All of my kids are hypothyroid and at one time, battled low adrenal function. (On top of two of them having gluten-intolerance.) So, I know what it's like to have one's child suffer, and how long the road to a diagnosis can be. I hope this is the end of all your special pursuits for health for your son. Very sincerely, Cherwyn > > > > ... The urine test gathers all the cortisol output for the entire 24-hour period > > and presents this total number.... > > That wasn't what they did. They showed us output as a function of time. > We had to carefully segregate output by time and store it. > > Chuck > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.