Guest guest Posted March 7, 2006 Report Share Posted March 7, 2006 Some doctors always do the antibiotic challenge as it can draw the spirochetes out of the cells into the blood. Many do a course of abx, and then a week off and then test. I am not sure if my daughter has had the test you are speaking of but I know many who have. On the IgG it could be an old infection or one that has been lying dormant and is now flaring again. Anyone, isn't that right? I think the fact that your doctor is concerned about what to do for future insurance questions shows that they are truly in the loop about how to deal with these frustrating issues. Dr. J has done the same thing with my daughter ordering tests just in case we need the documentation to prove a need for treatment. (BTW-Dr. J never takes my daughter off the abx when he does repeat WB. We asked him and he said in his experience it did not make that big a difference. I have always wondered though if hers would be MORE positive if we did this...) [ ] antibiotic challenge to force IgM? and IgeneX LDA Test Hi, My daughter's new doctor said that the 10 Quest positive IgG bands doesn't indicated " active " lyme and has said the next step is to do an antibiotic challenge with biaxin and amox for five days, and do the IgeneX Lyme Dot Blot Assay (a urine) test. If that is positive, it would be followed by a reverse western blot on the antigens found in the urine. Does anyone have experience with this IgeneX test? I wondered if anyone else did this or if the IgG reactivity was sufficient for an " active " lyme diagnosis in your child's case? My daughter isn't highly symptomatic, but, my fear is that she has had this since birth (she's six) and it is hiding in her...she has some cognitive impairment, but no major physical symptoms NOW (but has in the past - we didn't know it was lyme then.) He said he would treat her now, but,he thought we should get some sort of documentation of IgM response so future insurance, etc. wouldn't question it. Anyone? Thanks. For up to date information about Lyme disease and the known co-infections delivered to your email address see: Robynns_Lyme_List/ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 8, 2006 Report Share Posted March 8, 2006 I have had the LUA (Lyme Urine Antigen) thru Igenex many many times...and so has my son. Basically its collections of morning urines ( 3-5 depending upon Dr) and at a certain point after starting abx (again this varies according to theory). the urine is then poured into a test tube and frozen, packed then fed-exed directly to California...the kit is self explanatory and fed-ex has always been wonderful!!! door to door!!! The idea is that IF the meds are promoting the body to shed pieces of bacteria, theyll be in the urine. (antigen = pcs of organism, antibody is the protein the body makes in response to having been exposed to an antigen). and if the person's immune system is for whatever reason not recognizing the bacteria ( and therefore giving a neg blot or ELISA)...then maybe they can look for actual bacterial matter. BUT as with all tests, its again a case of the 'ol fishing hole. ( my own personal theory that even if the lake has just been well -stocked with fish, there's still no guarantee of catching a fish...)i.e. you can very well have spirochetes ( or other bacteria) but if that 'catch' ( blood or urine or spinal fluid) just happens to not catch any,,,well you get the drift. Its certainly worth the test ( tho very expensive) as its non-invasive...and it may just correllate with a herx ( which will also be a positive confirmation of infection), but a 'neg' wont prove absence of disease; yet an insurance company may try to use that ( and any other 'neg') to deny treatment!! good luck Finette [ ] antibiotic challenge to force IgM? and IgeneX LDA Test Hi, My daughter's new doctor said that the 10 Quest positive IgG bands doesn't indicated " active " lyme and has said the next step is to do an antibiotic challenge with biaxin and amox for five days, and do the IgeneX Lyme Dot Blot Assay (a urine) test. If that is positive, it would be followed by a reverse western blot on the antigens found in the urine. Does anyone have experience with this IgeneX test? I wondered if anyone else did this or if the IgG reactivity was sufficient for an " active " lyme diagnosis in your child's case? My daughter isn't highly symptomatic, but, my fear is that she has had this since birth (she's six) and it is hiding in her...she has some cognitive impairment, but no major physical symptoms NOW (but has in the past - we didn't know it was lyme then.) He said he would treat her now, but,he thought we should get some sort of documentation of IgM response so future insurance, etc. wouldn't question it. Anyone? Thanks. For up to date information about Lyme disease and the known co-infections delivered to your email address see: Robynns_Lyme_List/ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 8, 2006 Report Share Posted March 8, 2006 Dear Finette, I loved your analogy of the well stocked lake with fish, but it doesn't mean you will catch one. When I try to explain the PCR testing that is a good on e to use. I have likened it to a few peas in our swimming pool. If you draw up a test tube of water without a pea, it doesn't mean there isn't one there. Thanks!! Also the links you sent were good as well. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 25, 2006 Report Share Posted March 25, 2006 I truly believe that my Jake got Lyme from me, in utero and through breastmilk. However, he did not have any symptoms (ie. Bell's Palsey) as an infant. He has been healthy until last May, at which time, he did have a rash with a puncture mark (no tick seen). I believe it remained dormant in him, until he was re-infected again. I have heard of attempting to " time " the assays, which is what it sounds like your doctor is trying to do. In my mind, a positive is a positive...and there just isn't an absolute definitive test for Lyme. I've heard of people getting a CDC positive (to quote Dr. J... " the CDC's standards are stupid " ) AND still insurance refuses to pay. Truly it is all tightly wound ball of red tape! And, unfortunately, it is the patients & families that suffer in many ways! Oh, how I hate LD. (TN) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.