[Fwd: Re: Re: Homeopathy - Andy, please join the discussion]

[Guest guest]

--- Re: [ ] Re: Homeopathy - Andy, please join the

discussion

Date: Thu, 18 Jun 2009 21:40:24 +1000

From: Fran Sheffield <FranSheffield@...>

Fran Sheffield <fransheffield@...>

References: <gvgbpj+pgnoeGroups>

Hi Andy,

I have interspersed some comments below. I am rarely on this forum

lately so if you would like me to respond, please reply directly to me

as well.

andrewhallcutler wrote:

>

>

> > > ===>Andy can clarify, but I don't think he is distinguishing between

> > > various types of homeopathy when he says " don't use it for detox " and

> > > warns that homeopathy causes " more brain symptoms " . He means all

> > > homeopathy, regardless of what you call it or how you separate it.

>

> I am distinguishing just fine.

>

>

> Do NOT EVER use anything held out or intended as 'homeopathic detox.'

> That in itself distinguishes it as not 'classical' homeopathy, where

> someone is just matched to a remedy without cause and effect reasoning.

>

> Also do not ever use any mercurius, argentum, arsenicum, plumbum, etc.

> remedies with a toxic person even if prescribed because they are an

> exact match.

>

Why not? If indicated by, and prescribed according to the symptoms

experienced by the person, these remedies will achieve wonderful results

for them.

>

> I've seen multitudinous instances of both these causing severely

> exacerbated brain and sometimes liver symptoms that can last for years

> on end (at least).

>

Provide some examples and cases please. I am assuming that use these

remedies far more than you but I have never seen these results when they

are prescribed appropriately. On the contrary, the short and long-term

improvements have been heart-warming.

Now, if you are talking about remedies prescribed when they are not

indicated but only according to some lab report, then I might agree with

you. You will still have to give me verifiable accounts and records

though and believe me, I will be more than happy to go in to bat for you

on this one. Without something a little more substantial, it just sounds

like scare-mongering ....

>

> > > It is only the use of potentised substances (potentised being the way

> > > homeopaths prepare their medicines) being prescribed outside

> > > homeopathy's guiding principles.

>

> I don't think it is appropriate to turn homeopathy into a religious

> cult any more than it is OK with allopathic medicine.

>

> Things work, or they don't. " guiding principles " isn't what makes them

> work, those are just shorthand to make it possible for human beings to

> practice homeopathy without having to memorize 500,000 pages of provings.

>

I'm not completely sure what you are talking about here but you can't

have it both ways. You cannot expouse 'guiding principles' in relation

to chelation and deny others the same right for other therapies. If

homeopathy is not applied according to certain principles one can be in

for a very bumpy ride and will not obtain good results.

>

> Most of what I am saying is that the general principles of 'old

> fashoined' homeopathy do seem to work OK for toxic people. Drainage

> remedies do too, and they are very much not according to these principles.

>

> Homeopathic remedies are just ones diluted and usually succused. E. g.

> Optique eyedrops, very commonly prescribed by MD's who don't realize

> they're homeopathic because they work. Allergy shots are also homeopathic.

>

Andy, I have to say that you are talking outside your area of expertise

and don't seem to know a lot about homeopathy. When you make statements

such as some of those above it very misleading to those who could be

very much helped by homeopathy.

Rather than take my word on homeopthy why don't you spend a little time

on some specialist homeopathic forums and ask or say the above things

there - you would find some very helpful homeopaths who would point you

in the right direction and fill in some of the gaps in your knowledge.

--

Kind regards,

Fran Sheffield

Homeopathy Plus! (Tutorials - Remedies - Immunisation)

http://www.homeopathyplus.com.au

Do No Harm Initiative (Free Information on Homeopathic Immunisation)

http://www.d-n-h.org

Homeopathy for Autism (Guidelines for Treatment - Search for Practitioners)

http://www.homeopathy4autism.com

>

> Andy

>

> www.noamalgam.com

>

> www.noamalgam.com/hairtestbook.html

>

>

--

Kind regards,

Fran Sheffield

Homeopathy Plus! (Tutorials - Remedies - Immunisation)

http://www.homeopathyplus.com.au

Do No Harm Initiative (Free Information on Homeopathic Immunisation)

http://www.d-n-h.org

Homeopathy for Autism (Guidelines for Treatment - Search for Practitioners)

http://www.homeopathy4autism.com