Guest guest Posted May 22, 2006 Report Share Posted May 22, 2006 My Doc just changed his mind about the DSMA. apperntly he went to a seminar from Kane who has a different approach to detoxification of heavy metals. Detoxification in short words: Detoxification includes: 1. goat whey 2. oil schedule 3. diet: low carbohydrates, many proteins (amino acids are needed for transportation of mercury). When diet is changed and minerals are supplemented, detoxification can start. 4. Basis of detoxification is the combination of Chlorella, bear's garlic and Chinese parsley. It is important to say, that strict vegetarians, who don't eat eggs, will get difficulties at detoxification. Does anybody have a opinion. I was so sure we would do the DSMA but our doc is very excited about Kanes work. I know Iam the parent who decides, still Iam cofused what to do? Bea Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2006 Report Share Posted May 22, 2006 It sounds like your Doc may not have much experience (no offense!). How can he just change his mind on something like this? If he doesn't have a track record of treating people, then perhaps he's not the right person to be making the call. I've read that Chlorella isn't safe (don't recall where, though I think in Cutler's writings), parsley is unmeasurable (how much and how frequent?), garlic has it's benefits like with yeast, dont' know about detox. Protein diet sounds ok, certainly. DMSA is definately a more proven & safe method. HTH, > > My Doc just changed his mind about the DSMA. apperntly he went to a > seminar from Kane who has a different approach to > detoxification of heavy metals. > Detoxification in short words: > Detoxification includes: > > 1. goat whey > 2. oil schedule > 3. diet: low carbohydrates, many proteins (amino acids are needed for > transportation of mercury). When diet is changed and minerals are > supplemented, detoxification can start. > 4. Basis of detoxification is the combination of Chlorella, bear's > garlic and Chinese parsley. > It is important to say, that strict vegetarians, who don't eat eggs, > will get difficulties at detoxification. > > Does anybody have a opinion. I was so sure we would do the DSMA but > our doc is very excited about Kanes work. I know Iam the parent who > decides, still Iam cofused what to do? > Bea > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2006 Report Share Posted May 22, 2006 I have no personal experience with her but I have heard, from MANY parents over MANY years, than Kane (who is not a doctor, and has a questionable degree from a diploma mill) is disreputable, that she " spies " on parents on lists such as this one (pretending to be a parent and retaliating against her detractors in very nasty ways), that she has no credibility with her peers, and that she's just generally very bad news. It might be helpful to do some searches going back at least 6-7 years and see what people have to say. Like I said, just passing along what I've heard - sorry. -------------- Original message -------------- From: " schwarzbeatrix " <schwarzbeatrix@...> My Doc just changed his mind about the DSMA. apperntly he went to a seminar from Kane who has a different approach to detoxification of heavy metals. Detoxification in short words: Detoxification includes: 1. goat whey 2. oil schedule 3. diet: low carbohydrates, many proteins (amino acids are needed for transportation of mercury). When diet is changed and minerals are supplemented, detoxification can start. 4. Basis of detoxification is the combination of Chlorella, bear's garlic and Chinese parsley. It is important to say, that strict vegetarians, who don't eat eggs, will get difficulties at detoxification. Does anybody have a opinion. I was so sure we would do the DSMA but our doc is very excited about Kanes work. I know Iam the parent who decides, still Iam cofused what to do? Bea ======================================================= Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2006 Report Share Posted May 22, 2006 is right, I would be wary of a doctor who can change his mind this quickly. -- goat whey is high cysteine, so will be problematic for some people. If this is whey *powder*, then you're also dealing with a lot of free glutamic acid (the active part of MSG). Casein also may or may not be a problem, depending on one's sensitivities. -- amino acids are not chelators to my knowledge. They do other helpful things, but they will not transport mercury out of the body. -- chlorella and chinese parsley (cilantro) do move mercury around, but because no one knows how to use them safely (what is the active ingredient? What is the half life? How do you make standardized formulas of the active ingredient if you don't know what it is?) they are probably best avoided. You can look up many many warning posts in the archives by Andy re: chlorella and cilantro, and Moria has collected posts by people who have used these things too. These posts are in the FAQ section, I think. -- garlic is another food that some people will have problems with if they are high sulphur. Also, it only has one thiol group, so not a chelator. -- I don't know much about Kane except that people are absolutely forbidden to mention her on the ABMD list. You might want to email the owner of that list to find out why. Sorry about all of this, Bea. It gets confulsing, doesn't it? take care René > > My Doc just changed his mind about the DSMA. apperntly he went to a > seminar from Kane who has a different approach to > detoxification of heavy metals. > Does anybody have a opinion. I was so sure we would do the DSMA but > our doc is very excited about Kanes work. I know Iam the parent who > decides, still Iam cofused what to do? > Bea > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2006 Report Share Posted May 22, 2006 hi, WHAT DOES THE GOAT WHEY DO THAT'S DIFFERENT FROM THE GOAT'S YOGURT IN THE SPECIFIC CARBOHYDRATE DIET/? COULD YOU PLEASE EXPLAIN THE DIFFERENCE, THIS IS VERY INTERESTING..... THANKS SO MUCH...... CORINNE [ ] Very confused: Kane? My Doc just changed his mind about the DSMA. apperntly he went to a seminar from Kane who has a different approach to detoxification of heavy metals. Detoxification in short words: Detoxification includes: 1. goat whey 2. oil schedule 3. diet: low carbohydrates, many proteins (amino acids are needed for transportation of mercury). When diet is changed and minerals are supplemented, detoxification can start. 4. Basis of detoxification is the combination of Chlorella, bear's garlic and Chinese parsley. It is important to say, that strict vegetarians, who don't eat eggs, will get difficulties at detoxification. Does anybody have a opinion. I was so sure we would do the DSMA but our doc is very excited about Kanes work. I know Iam the parent who decides, still Iam cofused what to do? Bea ======================================================= Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2006 Report Share Posted May 22, 2006 Your doc needs to go to seminars of real medical professionals. As someone who researches amino acids for a living that women has no knowledge about what she talks about as they are not chelators of mercury at all. Her knowledge of essential fatty acids is contrary to the world's research. Protect yourself and see a real doctor who knows what they're doing. Mark Schauss www.markschauss.com [ ] Very confused: Kane? My Doc just changed his mind about the DSMA. apperntly he went to a seminar from Kane who has a different approach to detoxification of heavy metals. Detoxification in short words: Detoxification includes: 1. goat whey 2. oil schedule 3. diet: low carbohydrates, many proteins (amino acids are needed for transportation of mercury). When diet is changed and minerals are supplemented, detoxification can start. 4. Basis of detoxification is the combination of Chlorella, bear's garlic and Chinese parsley. It is important to say, that strict vegetarians, who don't eat eggs, will get difficulties at detoxification. Does anybody have a opinion. I was so sure we would do the DSMA but our doc is very excited about Kanes work. I know Iam the parent who decides, still Iam cofused what to do? Bea ======================================================= Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2006 Report Share Posted May 22, 2006 I cant describe how thankful i am for this group.THANK YOU. Its 1am in the morning I am still researching.I called my doc left a message that I like to stick with the oral DSMA.If he doesnt like it I have to move on. Well. I was really scared what people had to say about clorella.Really crazy. Thanks again, you are so great!!!!! Bea > > > > My Doc just changed his mind about the DSMA. apperntly he went to a > > seminar from Kane who has a different approach to > > detoxification of heavy metals. > > Does anybody have a opinion. I was so sure we would do the DSMA but > > our doc is very excited about Kanes work. I know Iam the parent who > > decides, still Iam cofused what to do? > > Bea > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2006 Report Share Posted May 23, 2006 Dr. Kane has to my knowledge never revealed which higher institution awarded her a PhD. [ ] Very confused: Kane? My Doc just changed his mind about the DSMA. apperntly he went to a seminar from Kane who has a different approach to detoxification of heavy metals. Detoxification in short words: Detoxification includes: 1. goat whey 2. oil schedule 3. diet: low carbohydrates, many proteins (amino acids are needed for transportation of mercury). When diet is changed and minerals are supplemented, detoxification can start. 4. Basis of detoxification is the combination of Chlorella, bear's garlic and Chinese parsley. It is important to say, that strict vegetarians, who don't eat eggs, will get difficulties at detoxification. Does anybody have a opinion. I was so sure we would do the DSMA but our doc is very excited about Kanes work. I know Iam the parent who decides, still Iam cofused what to do? Bea ======================================================= Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2006 Report Share Posted May 23, 2006 My guess is this doctor of yours will attend another conference a year from now and change his mind again... probably has little understanding of the biology of Autism (and perhaps the body in general!). Not uncommon, but perhaps not the leader you are looking for. I think it is great that doctors continue to try to educate themselves, but dumping a proven chelation method after hearing one good speech is a little scary. Chlorella is considered a very unwise method of chelation by many who follow the low/slow method of detox. I've never looked in to it, but the archives are probably jammed packed with horror stories and debates. Pam > > My Doc just changed his mind about the DSMA. apperntly he went to a > seminar from Kane who has a different approach to > detoxification of heavy metals. > Detoxification in short words: > Detoxification includes: > > 1. goat whey > 2. oil schedule > 3. diet: low carbohydrates, many proteins (amino acids are needed for > transportation of mercury). When diet is changed and minerals are > supplemented, detoxification can start. > 4. Basis of detoxification is the combination of Chlorella, bear's > garlic and Chinese parsley. > It is important to say, that strict vegetarians, who don't eat eggs, > will get difficulties at detoxification. > > Does anybody have a opinion. I was so sure we would do the DSMA but > our doc is very excited about Kanes work. I know Iam the parent who > decides, still Iam cofused what to do? > Bea > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2006 Report Share Posted May 23, 2006 Let me see--how shall I put this? Years ago, her qualifications were called into question??? Barb [ ] Very confused: Kane? > My Doc just changed his mind about the DSMA. apperntly he went to a > seminar from Kane who has a different approach to > detoxification of heavy metals. > Detoxification in short words: > Detoxification includes: > > 1. goat whey > 2. oil schedule > 3. diet: low carbohydrates, many proteins (amino acids are needed for > transportation of mercury). When diet is changed and minerals are > supplemented, detoxification can start. > 4. Basis of detoxification is the combination of Chlorella, bear's > garlic and Chinese parsley. > It is important to say, that strict vegetarians, who don't eat eggs, > will get difficulties at detoxification. > > Does anybody have a opinion. I was so sure we would do the DSMA but > our doc is very excited about Kanes work. I know Iam the parent who > decides, still Iam cofused what to do? > Bea > > > > > > > > ======================================================= > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2006 Report Share Posted May 23, 2006 I would do what others have done and succeeded -- chelation using DMSA or DMPS with the AC protocal. I experiment and try other things when the standard way fails. jromkema <jromkema@...> wrote: Let me see--how shall I put this? Years ago, her qualifications were called into question??? Barb [ ] Very confused: Kane? > My Doc just changed his mind about the DSMA. apperntly he went to a > seminar from Kane who has a different approach to > detoxification of heavy metals. > Detoxification in short words: > Detoxification includes: > > 1. goat whey > 2. oil schedule > 3. diet: low carbohydrates, many proteins (amino acids are needed for > transportation of mercury). When diet is changed and minerals are > supplemented, detoxification can start. > 4. Basis of detoxification is the combination of Chlorella, bear's > garlic and Chinese parsley. > It is important to say, that strict vegetarians, who don't eat eggs, > will get difficulties at detoxification. > > Does anybody have a opinion. I was so sure we would do the DSMA but > our doc is very excited about Kanes work. I know Iam the parent who > decides, still Iam cofused what to do? > Bea > > > > > > > > ======================================================= > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.