Guest guest Posted April 12, 2006 Report Share Posted April 12, 2006 the chelation mantra. Proper chelation: ALA every 3-4 hours or more often, DMSA every 4 hours or more often, DMPS every 8 hours or more often, EDTA every 8 hours or more often, Route of adminstration doesn't matter. Anything else is wrong, wrong, wrong. Dangerous, harmful, and wrong. Doesn't matter how it goes in, doesn't matter where it is supposed to come out. Gotta do it right. TTFD, chlorella, glutathione, MSM, and a lot of other things called chelators actually are not. Andy Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 12, 2006 Report Share Posted April 12, 2006 > > ALA every 3-4 hours or more often, > What do you mean by more often ? Will giving it more often pull more mercury ? How often ? I am using ALA only, he is tolerating it well at your dosage (1/2 mg pound) every 3 hours, finished round 3, starting round 4 friday. Cheryl Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 12, 2006 Report Share Posted April 12, 2006 Cheryl, ALA dosing time is a no brainer. It needs to be dosed every three hours or sooner during the waking hours. At the outside time it can be dosed at every 4 hours during sleep, meaning wake up to do it. The dosing schedule is probably the MOST asked question, just do it. Sorry I am short tonight be it is important to dose correctly. Lee [ ] Re: Please chant along with me... > > ALA every 3-4 hours or more often, > What do you mean by more often ? Will giving it more often pull more mercury ? How often ? I am using ALA only, he is tolerating it well at your dosage (1/2 mg pound) every 3 hours, finished round 3, starting round 4 friday. Cheryl ======================================================= Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 12, 2006 Report Share Posted April 12, 2006 then you might want to actually read someting before responding and trying to make me feel stupid , i was asking andy what he meant by MORE OFTEN ! > > > > > > ALA every 3-4 hours or more often, > > > What do you mean by more often ? Will giving it more often pull more > mercury ? How often ? > > I am using ALA only, he is tolerating it well at your dosage (1/2 mg > pound) every 3 hours, finished round 3, starting round 4 friday. > > Cheryl > > > > > > ======================================================= > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 12, 2006 Report Share Posted April 12, 2006 Well, if the protocol calls for a certain level of chelator to be given at a certain time to be safe I think giving it more often would require some division of a three-hour dose, or require giving, for example, a three-hour 25mg dose of chelator more often. I certainly see your consternation. If you are supposed to give a 25mg dose of chelator every three hours and you are being told this is the safe way to do things, giving the same more often might add up to a 3-hour 50mg ( more often meaning every hour and a half), or even a 3-hour 75mg (more often meaning every hour) load of chelator. Well, that's a lot of chelator over a three-hour period. A lot more than what Andy's safe protocol calls for. I don't see how this does not also lead to a significant chelator drop-off when you reach the end of the round. Is this really the appropriate thing to do? We ran into a similar problem trying to figure out dosing for using DMPS and ALA in combination. DMPS is supposed to be given at eight hour intervals and, of course, ALA is supposed to be given at three-hour intervals. Keeping the dosing separate over the course of three days and nights obviously can get out of hand. I think we ended up dividing the eight-hour DMPS dose in half then gave it with the regular three-hour ALA dose for a few rounds before we went back to DMSA and ALA on a three-hour schedule. Some people report moving a regular three-hour dose to every two-hours during the day then returning to even three hours at night is better. To me, this sort of logic is paralleled by people with a fancy for betting only on red just before the roulette wheel whirls around. Honestly in both cases you are simply guessing on the unknown. Particularly with autistic-like children, who more often then not can not express what is going on inside them, unless you have a mobile DDI lab parked in the driveway with a pipe connected to your child running a zillion dollar's worth of monitoring tests you don't know what's happening. My opinion on all this " tweaking " is just like betting only red, you have a fifty-fifty chance that what modifications to the safe protocol being made might not become the dreaded " harmful and inappropriate " . In reality, it probably not that dramatic to change things around, but it doesn't stop it from feeling that way. Oral chelation is a long journey. Be safe and take your time. [ ] Re: Please chant along with me... then you might want to actually read someting before responding and trying to make me feel stupid , i was asking andy what he meant by MORE OFTEN ! > > > > > > ALA every 3-4 hours or more often, > > > What do you mean by more often ? Will giving it more often pull more > mercury ? How often ? > > I am using ALA only, he is tolerating it well at your dosage (1/2 mg > pound) every 3 hours, finished round 3, starting round 4 friday. > > Cheryl > > > > > > ======================================================= > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 12, 2006 Report Share Posted April 12, 2006 By " more often " I simply mean that you can give it more frequently than the listed time, e. g. 8 hours for DMPS, and it is OK. For DMPS every 6, or 4, or 2 or 1 or every 10 minutes would be fine. I usually say 3-4 hours for ALA since some people are OK on 4 hours for that, some not, but most do OK with 3 during the day and 4 at night. Andy > > then you might want to actually read someting before responding and > trying to make me feel stupid , i was asking andy what he meant by > MORE OFTEN ! > > > > ALA every 3-4 hours or more often, > > > > > What do you mean by more often ? Will giving it more often pull > more > > mercury ? Probably not, but it won't slam any of it deep into his brain and liver, which inadequately frequent dosing does. > > How often ? > > > > I am using ALA only, he is tolerating it well at your dosage (1/2 > mg > > pound) every 3 hours, finished round 3, starting round 4 friday. > > > > Cheryl > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 13, 2006 Report Share Posted April 13, 2006 > Doesn't matter how it goes in, doesn't matter where > it is supposed to come out. Does the dosage matter on how it goes in(TD, Oral etc)? __________________________________________________ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 13, 2006 Report Share Posted April 13, 2006 > > > > > > ALA every 3-4 hours or more often, > > > What do you mean by more often ? He means that it is also okay to use ALA, say, every 2 hours, or every 1 hour. It is a problem if it is LESS often. It is fine if it is MORE often. > Will giving it more often pull more > mercury ? no, it won't. It's dose that does that. good wishes, Moria http://home.earthlink.net/~moriam/ Mercury Detox: Information, Tools, and Resources Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 13, 2006 Report Share Posted April 13, 2006 There are some people who need it at 21/2 hours just because their metabolism is faster. But in general, the three to four hours is fine. Barb [ ] Re: Please chant along with me... > >> >> ALA every 3-4 hours or more often, >> > What do you mean by more often ? Will giving it more often pull more > mercury ? How often ? > > I am using ALA only, he is tolerating it well at your dosage (1/2 mg > pound) every 3 hours, finished round 3, starting round 4 friday. > > Cheryl > > > > > > ======================================================= > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 13, 2006 Report Share Posted April 13, 2006 ALA is taken every 3 hours or sooner during the day and every 4 hours or less during the night. The reason for this dosing schedule is ALA's half life. You want to keep ALA in the system at an steady level, same as if you were taking antibiotics. Chelating doesn't work if you dose haphazardly. Talking the night time doses at every four hours is for two reasons: 1. During sleep the body functions slow and 2. It allows you to get more sleep. If you want to get up every three hours during the night that is your choice. " More often " means it is better to take a dose a bit earlier than to go over the 3 hours. When you are chelating for days at a time it is difficult to get every dose at exactly EVERY 3 hours so taking it earlier is a safeguard against going over 3 hours. You might want to invest in Andy's book Amalgam Illness as it explains these things in detail. You might also want to read the files section. Lee [ ] Re: Please chant along with me... then you might want to actually read someting before responding and trying to make me feel stupid , i was asking andy what he meant by MORE OFTEN ! > > > > > > ALA every 3-4 hours or more often, > > > What do you mean by more often ? Will giving it more often pull more > mercury ? How often ? > > I am using ALA only, he is tolerating it well at your dosage (1/2 mg > pound) every 3 hours, finished round 3, starting round 4 friday. > > Cheryl > > > > > > ======================================================= > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 13, 2006 Report Share Posted April 13, 2006 Lee, you might want to stop assuming things and trying to make a person feel bad about asking questions, thats not really helpful, especially to new people that need extra help. If you had actually read my post you would have seen that I am giving the ALA per Andys protocol, on a 3 hour dosing schedule. That right there should have given you insight that I have read a few things around here, like files and posts.... I didnt ask for a " lesson " on ALA , i simply asked for clarification of " more often " . My question was logical and warranted to get clarification if " more often " would pull more mercury, what wasnt necessary were the 2 attempts to belittle my asking the question. I actually did check the archives prior to posting but this wasnt addressed except in reference to needing to do a dosage early for other reasons. Thanks Andy, Moria, and Kerbob, for understanding my question and answering without trying to make me feel bad for asking it.... Cheryl Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 13, 2006 Report Share Posted April 13, 2006 I haven't run the numbers, but I think that assuming a half-life of ALA of three hours, and assuming no variation for metabolism speed, dosing more often than 3 hours would cause a higher level of chelator in the blood, thus perhaps increasing metal pull by effectively increasing dosage. Anne > > Lee, you might want to stop assuming things and trying to make a > person feel bad about asking questions, thats not really helpful, > especially to new people that need extra help. If you had actually > read my post you would have seen that I am giving the ALA per Andys > protocol, on a 3 hour dosing schedule. That right there should have > given you insight that I have read a few things around here, like > files and posts.... I didnt ask for a " lesson " on ALA , i simply > asked for clarification of " more often " . My question was logical and > warranted to get clarification if " more often " would pull more > mercury, what wasnt necessary were the 2 attempts to belittle my > asking the question. I actually did check the archives prior to > posting but this wasnt addressed except in reference to needing to do > a dosage early for other reasons. > > Thanks Andy, Moria, and Kerbob, for understanding my question > and answering without trying to make me feel bad for asking it.... > > Cheryl > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 13, 2006 Report Share Posted April 13, 2006 Anne, The " half life " I mentioned is not my theory. I believe I read this in one of Andy's books but I could be wrong. I must read upwards of 1,000 emails a day and of course not everything is correct so thanks for bringing this to my attention. Currently I have been up since 2AM so pardon if I make mistakes. Guess I should stay off the computer when I haven't had any rest. I did not mean to offend anyone. Sorry if my intent was not clear. I will crawl back in my hole... Lee [ ] Re: Please chant along with me... I haven't run the numbers, but I think that assuming a half-life of ALA of three hours, and assuming no variation for metabolism speed, dosing more often than 3 hours would cause a higher level of chelator in the blood, thus perhaps increasing metal pull by effectively increasing dosage. Anne > > Lee, you might want to stop assuming things and trying to make a > person feel bad about asking questions, thats not really helpful, > especially to new people that need extra help. If you had actually > read my post you would have seen that I am giving the ALA per Andys > protocol, on a 3 hour dosing schedule. That right there should have > given you insight that I have read a few things around here, like > files and posts.... I didnt ask for a " lesson " on ALA , i simply > asked for clarification of " more often " . My question was logical and > warranted to get clarification if " more often " would pull more > mercury, what wasnt necessary were the 2 attempts to belittle my > asking the question. I actually did check the archives prior to > posting but this wasnt addressed except in reference to needing to do > a dosage early for other reasons. > > Thanks Andy, Moria, and Kerbob, for understanding my question > and answering without trying to make me feel bad for asking it.... > > Cheryl > ======================================================= Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 13, 2006 Report Share Posted April 13, 2006 I'm sorry if you misinterpreted my answer as an attempt to belittle. That was not my intent. I was hoping to help but obviously I only caused grief/anger. Please accept an apology. You are right that I missed part of the post. I also missed the answer you received...I may be having a problem with . I receive individual posts off the list server and am not seeing them in a reasonable order today. Lee [ ] Re: Please chant along with me... Lee, you might want to stop assuming things and trying to make a person feel bad about asking questions, thats not really helpful, especially to new people that need extra help. If you had actually read my post you would have seen that I am giving the ALA per Andys protocol, on a 3 hour dosing schedule. That right there should have given you insight that I have read a few things around here, like files and posts.... I didnt ask for a " lesson " on ALA , i simply asked for clarification of " more often " . My question was logical and warranted to get clarification if " more often " would pull more mercury, what wasnt necessary were the 2 attempts to belittle my asking the question. I actually did check the archives prior to posting but this wasnt addressed except in reference to needing to do a dosage early for other reasons. Thanks Andy, Moria, and Kerbob, for understanding my question and answering without trying to make me feel bad for asking it.... Cheryl ======================================================= Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 13, 2006 Report Share Posted April 13, 2006 Lee, I was not implying that the half-life of ALA was your theory. I was just saying that if you run the numbers using the 3 hour half-life and not taking into account fast or slow metabolism (which could effectively change the 1/2 life, I guess), it seems to me that if you dose more often than every three hours, you would have a higher blood concentration of ALA, and thus, all systems a go, be pulling more out. But I may be wrong. Anne > > > > Lee, you might want to stop assuming things and trying to make a > > person feel bad about asking questions, thats not really helpful, > > especially to new people that need extra help. If you had actually > > read my post you would have seen that I am giving the ALA per > Andys > > protocol, on a 3 hour dosing schedule. That right there should > have > > given you insight that I have read a few things around here, like > > files and posts.... I didnt ask for a " lesson " on ALA , i simply > > asked for clarification of " more often " . My question was logical > and > > warranted to get clarification if " more often " would pull more > > mercury, what wasnt necessary were the 2 attempts to belittle my > > asking the question. I actually did check the archives prior to > > posting but this wasnt addressed except in reference to needing to > do > > a dosage early for other reasons. > > > > Thanks Andy, Moria, and Kerbob, for understanding my > question > > and answering without trying to make me feel bad for asking it.... > > > > Cheryl > > > > > > > > > ======================================================= > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 13, 2006 Report Share Posted April 13, 2006 Someone did do the math on this subject a few weeks back but they did not taking into consideration a fast or slow metabolizer. I'm not sure which forum it was posted on but the person did use 3 hours as the half life, meaning that at 6 hours most of the ALA is used up in some way. So, if one accepts that 3 hours is roughly the half life then yes if you dose every two hours you will have more blood concentration. Does more ALA in the blood mean that more mercury is processed? Hum, Andy says to chelate with low doses so it may be that the body can only handle so much circulating mercury at once. Wouldn't that be the reason not to do a challenge test?--because the body can't remove the mercury fast enough so it redistributes? I'm just thinking out loud here. I have such a headache. I hope I am making some sense. Lee [ ] Re: Please chant along with me... Lee, I was not implying that the half-life of ALA was your theory. I was just saying that if you run the numbers using the 3 hour half-life and not taking into account fast or slow metabolism (which could effectively change the 1/2 life, I guess), it seems to me that if you dose more often than every three hours, you would have a higher blood concentration of ALA, and thus, all systems a go, be pulling more out. But I may be wrong. Anne > > > > Lee, you might want to stop assuming things and trying to make a > > person feel bad about asking questions, thats not really helpful, > > especially to new people that need extra help. If you had actually > > read my post you would have seen that I am giving the ALA per > Andys > > protocol, on a 3 hour dosing schedule. That right there should > have > > given you insight that I have read a few things around here, like > > files and posts.... I didnt ask for a " lesson " on ALA , i simply > > asked for clarification of " more often " . My question was logical > and > > warranted to get clarification if " more often " would pull more > > mercury, what wasnt necessary were the 2 attempts to belittle my > > asking the question. I actually did check the archives prior to > > posting but this wasnt addressed except in reference to needing to > do > > a dosage early for other reasons. > > > > Thanks Andy, Moria, and Kerbob, for understanding my > question > > and answering without trying to make me feel bad for asking it.... > > > > Cheryl > > > > > > > > > ======================================================= > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 13, 2006 Report Share Posted April 13, 2006 > > > > > > Lee, you might want to stop assuming things and trying to make > a > > > person feel bad about asking questions, thats not really > helpful, > > > especially to new people that need extra help. If you had > actually > > > read my post you would have seen that I am giving the ALA per > > Andys > > > protocol, on a 3 hour dosing schedule. That right there should > > have > > > given you insight that I have read a few things around here, > like > > > files and posts.... I didnt ask for a " lesson " on ALA , i > simply > > > asked for clarification of " more often " . My question was > logical > > and > > > warranted to get clarification if " more often " would pull more > > > mercury, what wasnt necessary were the 2 attempts to belittle > my > > > asking the question. I actually did check the archives prior > to > > > posting but this wasnt addressed except in reference to > needing to > > do > > > a dosage early for other reasons. > > > > > > Thanks Andy, Moria, and Kerbob, for understanding my > > question > > > and answering without trying to make me feel bad for asking > it.... > > > > > > Cheryl > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > ======================================================= > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 13, 2006 Report Share Posted April 13, 2006 [ ] Re: Please chant along with me... >By " more often " I simply mean that you can give it more frequently >than the listed time, e. g. 8 hours for DMPS, and it is OK. For DMPS >every 6, or 4, or 2 or 1 or every 10 minutes would be fine. Am I correct that DMPS may be given as often as every ten minutes at the eight hour volume, or is one supposed to sub-divide the eight hour volume into 48 ten minute doses? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.