Guest guest Posted June 4, 2004 Report Share Posted June 4, 2004 GREETINGS -- This is a posting I made elsewhere and thought it might be helpful to revisit it here. You are probably frustrated by the various ways diets, especially carb loadings, are established. The following piece will hopefully provide some insights wambo I ended up choosing from among three approaches to develop my strategy for managing the blood glucose produced from the metabolosim of the food I consume. I ended up taking bits and pieces from all three. The first approach involves an exchange system that has been well covered in the literature and has been in use for some time (one exchange of carbs equals 15 grams). The second is carb counting which is gaining converts as low carb diets are gaining in popularity. The third is TAG (Total Available Glucose) that is based on an assumption that 100% of carbohydrate, 58% of protein, and 10% of fat is broken down in the body to glucose. The closer you want to control your blood sugars the more important it is to cover all sources of glucose. In my case, however, I factor in glucose from carbs and from protein. You need to adopt an approach where you feel comfortable. The ratios of carbs, protein, and fat that make up your diet is another decision you need to make. Two powerful non-profits in the US (American Heart Association and American Diabetes Association) have been backing a diet for years that limits protein and fat content – emphasizing carbs by promoting a diet that includes up to 65% (up from 45% initially) of the calories a diabetic consumes (and 10-20% protein and 25% fat). On the other hand Drs. Atkins and Bernstein have been promoting Low Carb diets (30 grams of carbohydrate). But that don't factor in a person's size. Because of my size (6 " 4 " and 235 lbs) I tend to use percentages – 10-15% of calories as carbs in lieu of a number of grams or ounces, and a variable split between protein and fat. It seems to work for me. As an adult, moderately active, person weighing 140 pounds (my assumption), it would take approximately 1900 calories per day to maintain that weight. The possible carb volumes range from 30 grams (Bernstein) to 230 grams (ADA/AHA) per day. The possible protein volumes range from 3 oz. (10%) (ADA/AHA) to 15 oz. (50%) (Bernstein). The glucose volume (and thus the medication requirement) will be the highest if the ADA/AHA carb/protein/fat configuration is adopted. In my case I use 10-15% carbs, 50% protein, and the remainder fats – although I don't factor fat in my insulin calculations. I live a very sedentary lifestyle for now and am still in the weight loss mode. More to follow, wambo1941 PS. For those not familiar with my background I am an insulin- dependent Type II (10 years) who has finally been able to normalize both my blood sugars and my insulin dosages and am currently reaping the benefits of that effort. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.