Guest guest Posted December 14, 2001 Report Share Posted December 14, 2001 Aletta, Remember that there are a lot of people running around these days with someone else's heart, liver, kidney, cornea and blood in them. These are not attempts to make people live forever, only to an age they should have lived to. Both of Charlotte's parents lived into their 80's, but Charlotte's mother outlived one of her daughter's (who smoked and died of lung cancer). Charlotte was only 62. No, medicine today MUST be a science. To many people today just make statements about some " natural supplement " helping them, yet when a scientific study is done 20 people are hurt for every person that is helped in some cases. Or you are saved from a headache, and die of an irregular heartbeat. You mention that you think medicine should be plant-based but that goes against what you say about " I am completely uncomfortable with the concept of having the DNA God designed for one individual life put in my body " . If you were vaccinated, you have foreign DNA in your body. Did you ever have a flu shot? I am an engineer and know the development process for a new instrument or device. It is often long and slow with many detours AND compromises. Polio took many, many years to beat - yet it is almost extinct in the USA due to someone sticking modified DNA into people. Some cancers are already being cured by sticking modified DNA into you. Now they have cured mice of paralysis by sticking human cells into the vertebrae. Seems to me that people have been getting human cells from other people for a hunderd years or so - it's called blood transfusion. I've had a blood transfusion and glad they could do it. Take care, Bill Werre aletta mes wrote: Nonetheless I prefer medicine as an art rather than a science. As an art it is creative and aspires to the best in man. As a science it becomes a matter of proving theory, being right is more important than being kind. My two cents on cloning (and transplants for that matter): I am completely uncomfortable with the concept of having the DNA God designed for one individual life put in my body, that was God's work - don't muck with it. I feel better about engineering artificial body parts and synthetic and plant-based pharmaceutical (my X has had two implanted lense since his early 30'S which work beautifully). When did this society become so arrogant as to assume we have an entitlement to a long and healthy life? Glad to see the artificial heart shows promise, pacemakers work well (could someone explain the stomach pacemaker Anne had implanted?) Science is good at exploration, engineers are problem solvers, doctors apply their knowledge of both for their patient's benefit. OK three cents worth. Have lovely day all. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.