Guest guest Posted September 1, 2004 Report Share Posted September 1, 2004 > Well, I for one am totally confused about hormones. I had followed > Dr. Lee's advice, even using large amounts of progesterone to combat > my supposed estrogen dominance/endometriosis. In retrospect, for me > it caused a lot of depression, and I am not sure what else. I > recently had my testosterone, estrogen and progesterone tested, and > testosterone is definitely low, estrogen is questionable depending > on who you read and my progesterone is " normal " . I have read that > progesterone is a precursor to estrogen, testosterone is a precursor > to estrogen, and progesterone can take up the receptor sites for > testosterone. I experience " warm flashes " from using progesterone > cream, and from not using it. There are actually a lot of doctors > out there with very differing views on how to manage natural > hormones, perimenopause, etc (Reiss, Vliet, Schwarzbein) to name > others besides Lee). I am not sure anyone of them knows the > complete truth! And I am starting to feel like a guinea pig! > > R. One symptom of progesterone excess is low level depression and also fatigue...the thing is, women sometimes fail to realte it to progesteone when it has worked so remarkably for them for such a long time..but when you get to a place where your deficiency has been addressed, excess can happen with doses you have always used. It really is an individual thing. I used high doses of 10% progesteone cream non-stop for 3-1/2 years until I reached a point where such a large dose of it no longer gave me the benefits I had been getting (diuretic, energy, optimization of my thyroid meds, absence of " estrogen dominant " symptoms.) Now, at 55 and having been without a period since a little past age 53, I am now using progesterone 12 days per month, a low-level tri-est, every day (per Schwartzbein and some of the anti-aging doctors) and I'm getting a period again since June. I feel great. I think if a woman is going to take estrogen, she needs to allow a period to come and shed the uterine lining that builds up each month. I think it is an individual choice and depends on many factors, but especially how well you feel on natural HRT....which has been in use since the 60's and does not give a person the side effects that synthetic HRT is notorious for. It is a new area of research, for sure...and no one doctor has all the answers, as you mentioned. One think I have surmised by watching myself and my friends is that no one hormonal supplement works the same way in the same amounts we always used, forever - we are changing, and therefore our requirements and the amounts our bodies are producing are changing. We are all different as well, with how much our bodies make to begin with...Uzzi Reiss outlines the three types of hormonal profiles among women...we are different in what our bodies produce even in our primes..and so it makes sense we would not have the same requirments as every other woman out there when we attempt to replace what we are no longer producing. http://groups.yahoo.com/group/WmnsHormones Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 1, 2004 Report Share Posted September 1, 2004 > Well, I for one am totally confused about hormones. I had followed > Dr. Lee's advice, even using large amounts of progesterone to combat > my supposed estrogen dominance/endometriosis. In retrospect, for me > it caused a lot of depression, and I am not sure what else. I > recently had my testosterone, estrogen and progesterone tested, and > testosterone is definitely low, estrogen is questionable depending > on who you read and my progesterone is " normal " . I have read that > progesterone is a precursor to estrogen, testosterone is a precursor > to estrogen, and progesterone can take up the receptor sites for > testosterone. I experience " warm flashes " from using progesterone > cream, and from not using it. There are actually a lot of doctors > out there with very differing views on how to manage natural > hormones, perimenopause, etc (Reiss, Vliet, Schwarzbein) to name > others besides Lee). I am not sure anyone of them knows the > complete truth! And I am starting to feel like a guinea pig! > > R. One symptom of progesterone excess is low level depression and also fatigue...the thing is, women sometimes fail to realte it to progesteone when it has worked so remarkably for them for such a long time..but when you get to a place where your deficiency has been addressed, excess can happen with doses you have always used. It really is an individual thing. I used high doses of 10% progesteone cream non-stop for 3-1/2 years until I reached a point where such a large dose of it no longer gave me the benefits I had been getting (diuretic, energy, optimization of my thyroid meds, absence of " estrogen dominant " symptoms.) Now, at 55 and having been without a period since a little past age 53, I am now using progesterone 12 days per month, a low-level tri-est, every day (per Schwartzbein and some of the anti-aging doctors) and I'm getting a period again since June. I feel great. I think if a woman is going to take estrogen, she needs to allow a period to come and shed the uterine lining that builds up each month. I think it is an individual choice and depends on many factors, but especially how well you feel on natural HRT....which has been in use since the 60's and does not give a person the side effects that synthetic HRT is notorious for. It is a new area of research, for sure...and no one doctor has all the answers, as you mentioned. One think I have surmised by watching myself and my friends is that no one hormonal supplement works the same way in the same amounts we always used, forever - we are changing, and therefore our requirements and the amounts our bodies are producing are changing. We are all different as well, with how much our bodies make to begin with...Uzzi Reiss outlines the three types of hormonal profiles among women...we are different in what our bodies produce even in our primes..and so it makes sense we would not have the same requirments as every other woman out there when we attempt to replace what we are no longer producing. http://groups.yahoo.com/group/WmnsHormones Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 1, 2004 Report Share Posted September 1, 2004 > Well, I for one am totally confused about hormones. I had followed > Dr. Lee's advice, even using large amounts of progesterone to combat > my supposed estrogen dominance/endometriosis. In retrospect, for me > it caused a lot of depression, and I am not sure what else. I > recently had my testosterone, estrogen and progesterone tested, and > testosterone is definitely low, estrogen is questionable depending > on who you read and my progesterone is " normal " . I have read that > progesterone is a precursor to estrogen, testosterone is a precursor > to estrogen, and progesterone can take up the receptor sites for > testosterone. I experience " warm flashes " from using progesterone > cream, and from not using it. There are actually a lot of doctors > out there with very differing views on how to manage natural > hormones, perimenopause, etc (Reiss, Vliet, Schwarzbein) to name > others besides Lee). I am not sure anyone of them knows the > complete truth! And I am starting to feel like a guinea pig! > > R. One symptom of progesterone excess is low level depression and also fatigue...the thing is, women sometimes fail to realte it to progesteone when it has worked so remarkably for them for such a long time..but when you get to a place where your deficiency has been addressed, excess can happen with doses you have always used. It really is an individual thing. I used high doses of 10% progesteone cream non-stop for 3-1/2 years until I reached a point where such a large dose of it no longer gave me the benefits I had been getting (diuretic, energy, optimization of my thyroid meds, absence of " estrogen dominant " symptoms.) Now, at 55 and having been without a period since a little past age 53, I am now using progesterone 12 days per month, a low-level tri-est, every day (per Schwartzbein and some of the anti-aging doctors) and I'm getting a period again since June. I feel great. I think if a woman is going to take estrogen, she needs to allow a period to come and shed the uterine lining that builds up each month. I think it is an individual choice and depends on many factors, but especially how well you feel on natural HRT....which has been in use since the 60's and does not give a person the side effects that synthetic HRT is notorious for. It is a new area of research, for sure...and no one doctor has all the answers, as you mentioned. One think I have surmised by watching myself and my friends is that no one hormonal supplement works the same way in the same amounts we always used, forever - we are changing, and therefore our requirements and the amounts our bodies are producing are changing. We are all different as well, with how much our bodies make to begin with...Uzzi Reiss outlines the three types of hormonal profiles among women...we are different in what our bodies produce even in our primes..and so it makes sense we would not have the same requirments as every other woman out there when we attempt to replace what we are no longer producing. http://groups.yahoo.com/group/WmnsHormones Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 1, 2004 Report Share Posted September 1, 2004 >...when we attempt to replace what we are no longer producing. That part of the sentence presents a whole 'nother issue to the mix. Why do some of us even need to replace anything! My mother-in-law went through meno, never did a thing, and has never had bone issues or other dire warnings that go along with being meno. I am leaning the same direction, for the time being....though I am currently using a small amount of natural progesterone. Sometimes I am tempted to stop even that.....and see. But so far, I am impressed with what I read about progesterone in small amounts. So time will tell.... Janie Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 1, 2004 Report Share Posted September 1, 2004 > >...when we attempt to replace what we are no longer producing. > > That part of the sentence presents a whole 'nother issue to the mix. > Why do some of us even need to replace anything! My mother-in-law > went through meno, never did a thing, and has never had bone issues > or other dire warnings that go along with being meno. I am leaning > the same direction, for the time being....though I am currently using > a small amount of natural progesterone. Sometimes I am tempted to > stop even that.....and see. But so far, I am impressed with what I > read about progesterone in small amounts. So time will tell.... > > Janie No - we really do not have to replace anything...and I was doing fantastic on the progesterone alone for some years...it was really the atrophy of my vagina - - not only drying up, but losing length and elasticity in it that got me to try the estrogen..the flashes I think I could have lived with. At that point, and since i am married and had always had a good sex life, I made the decision for myself. and with the right amount of natural homrones, there are no side effects, like I did have so many years on the pill. I often said that if it weren't for being married, I would have just allowed myself to dry up. Especially those years before I needed anything else but the progesterone. The progesterone made such a fantastic difference in my energy and my feelings of good health. Actually, now thinking back - I was okay on the prog. alone until OVER a year after my period had stopped...age 54...age 53 was when I had my last one (of course, I didn't realize it then..lol) but women are living longer and healthier and I want to try it this way as long as I feel good doing it. The anti-aging specialists popping up are dealing with hormones this way for women who are interested. but I do have my reasons for doing this..not all women feel the same way or would even feel well on bio-identical HRT - my Mom did great with her menopause....but she also had no use for my father after that and it is in the fledgling stages of use now with our generation - so yes, a lot of unanswered questions. But i appreciate the fact that there is a choice (if you can find a doctor willing to work with you) and I also realize more and more as time goes on that women are not all the same - not in our primes and not in our requirements to feel well and live healthy lives later on - so cookie cutter answers are not practical. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.