SCD and/or HVV?

[Guest guest]

Greetings all,

In doing research on IBS, I've noticed some startling

contradictory plans between SCD and a high soluble fiber diet like the one

described by Van Vorous, at helpforibs.com and in her book, IBS: the

First Year. HVV appears to endorse lots of things BTVC makes illegal (starches,

In particular) and argue against some staple of BTVC, such as fat, red meat,

dairy, etc. I was surprised, and a bit dismayed, there could be that much

disagreement. Is IBS different enough from UC or CD that it would warrant such a different approach?

In the BTVC foreward, Dr Hoffman seems to reject such a difference, but I'm curious if anyone

else has tried the HVV diet?

thanks!

Tom