Guest guest Posted May 30, 2003 Report Share Posted May 30, 2003 In a message dated 5/30/2003 12:54:59 PM US Mountain Standard Time, mglgm@... writes: > Am I wrong to second guess him on the DMSA challenge? I thought that when I > > went he would welcome my questions and thoughts but he didnt. He told me he > was > the doctor and basically to stop reading too much into this and trust him. Don't ever stop second guessing. This is when you get into trouble. You are right to question the reason to do a so called " challenge " . Jane Mama to 6 (ASD) and 3 (NT-although does have sensory and gut issues) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 30, 2003 Report Share Posted May 30, 2003 >>>>>>>>Am I wrong to second guess him on the DMSA challenge? I thought that when I went he would welcome my questions and thoughts but he didnt. He told me he was the doctor and basically to stop reading too much into this and trust him. What is the deal with these DAN doctors anyway?<<<<<<<< No, you are not wrong. You must first remove the amalgams. The deal with the DAN doctors? They are still doctors, and some doctors (many, well most) have big chips on their shoulders. God forbid you question a doctor..... In this case, you are the better educated one, so trust yourself, and if he doesn't support you, then do it yourself, or move on to a different doctor. a Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 30, 2003 Report Share Posted May 30, 2003 In a message dated 5/30/2003 7:46:38 PM Eastern Daylight Time, pjand3kids@... writes: > Andy is right. I met a great DAN doctor who was genuinely concerned for > his patients. He began focusing on autistic patients and totally believed in > the cause. Unfortunately, he worked in a general practice, and the other > doctors began to put the squeeze on him and his nurse, who was equally > knowledgeable and caring. The other doctors didn't like them thinking outside of the > box and not conforming to their " boys club " . They eventually had to leave the > practice, well the nurse was essentially fired. She had began to refuse to > vaccinate children, and thus....well you know. Any how, these types of > doctors and nurses are few and far between. If they don't conform to their > colleagues beliefs, they are singled out and essentially black balled. > > a > > I know what your saying and agree but this doctor is strictly a nutritional and wellness doctor. He used to practice regular medicine but now practices nutritional medicine and says he specializes in Autism???? His practice consists of a chelating room full of comfy recliners and people with IV's in their arms. He is very deceiving because his literature and practice are " outside of the box " . I thought I struck gold with him. Guess not. Lori Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 30, 2003 Report Share Posted May 30, 2003 WOuld you mind sharing the name of the DAN dr you saw? > Hi everyone, > > I went back to the DAN doc today to discuss test results. I was fortunate > enough to have Andy and interpret them as well before I went. While we > found on the list that the results are conclusive/consistent of mercury > poisoning the DAN doc wants to do a " DMSA challenge " as well. I informed him that I > was under the impression that he should not have any DMSA until his dental > fillings are removed and he said it didnt matter for a challenge? Is this correct? > Is it a matter of personal opinion or dosent DMSA draw out mercury in > fillings. Will this DMSA challenge be helpful in any way; we know he needs chelation > so why a " DMSA challenge " ? > > Also, I asked him if the low zinc, low magnesium and low molybedum were > consistent for mercury toxity and he said it could be caused by a million things! > I also asked him about the disordered mineral transport and thyroid issues > and asked whether these were consistent of mercury poison - he started getting > ticked off ( atleast it seemed to me) he told me I am on the internet too much > and am getting caught up in the latest rave. > > Besides his suggesting the " DMSA challenge " everything else he suggested was > consistent with what we discussed on the list though. > > Am I wrong to second guess him on the DMSA challenge? I thought that when I > went he would welcome my questions and thoughts but he didnt. He told me he was > the doctor and basically to stop reading too much into this and trust him. > What is the deal with these DAN doctors anyway? > > Again, any help is appreciated. > Lori > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 30, 2003 Report Share Posted May 30, 2003 > I went back to the DAN doc today to discuss test results. I was fortunate > enough to have Andy and interpret them as well before I went. While we > found on the list that the results are conclusive/consistent of mercury > poisoning the DAN doc wants to do a " DMSA challenge " as well. I informed him that I > was under the impression that he should not have any DMSA until his dental > fillings are removed and he said it didnt matter for a challenge? Is this correct? No. You should thank the doctor for conclusively proving he doesn't know anything at all about what he is doing and is very dangerous, then don't see him again. Challenge tests with filings in are dangerous. Challenge tests have no diagnostic utility anyway, there is no reason to do one. > Is it a matter of personal opinion Only among militant ignoramuses who don't know anything about medicine or pharmacology. E. g. some people do believe it is a matter of personal opinion whether the earth is round or flat, but it isn't. >or dosent DMSA draw out mercury in fillings. Yup. >Will this DMSA challenge be helpful in any way; No. > we know he needs chelation so why a " DMSA challenge " ? It lets the doctor go through some important scientific appearing ooga booga stuff and pretend that he made a diagnosis. > Also, I asked him if the low zinc, low magnesium and low molybedum were > consistent for mercury toxity and he said it could be caused by a million things! I see he also has no clinical experience with toxic kids. Is your kid his first patient, or does he just ignore the tests he orders? > I also asked him about the disordered mineral transport and thyroid issues > and asked whether these were consistent of mercury poison - he started getting > ticked off ( atleast it seemed to me) he told me I am on the internet too much > and am getting caught up in the latest rave. The pot calling the kettle black. He is following the latest fad, the stuff we are talking about has been around for many years. > Besides his suggesting the " DMSA challenge " everything else he suggested was > consistent with what we discussed on the list though. Good. > Am I wrong to second guess him on the DMSA challenge? No, you are right, he is wrong. >I thought that when I > went he would welcome my questions and thoughts but he didnt. Of course not! Answering questions is relatively hard even when you know what you are doing. > He told me he was > the doctor and basically to stop reading too much into this and trust him. Just like you trusted the doctor who poisoned your kids with mercury laced vaccines? That attitude alone makes him unable to help people and requires you dump him and do it yourself or find another doctor who isn't hard of listening if you want your kids to get better. > What is the deal with these DAN doctors anyway? They are MD's. The MD religion is very evil. Even the mostly good decent people who go to medical school to learn to help people eventually do get brainwashed and abused into acting this way. After a minimum of 8 years of brainwashing and emotional abuse they are finally turned loose on the world. You can't help them in an hour appointment, and you shouldn't have to pay to try. > Again, any help is appreciated. Dump this doctor. He can't help due to pe Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 30, 2003 Report Share Posted May 30, 2003 >>>>>>>>Even the mostly good decent people who go to medical school to learn to help people eventually do get brainwashed and abused into acting this way. After a minimum of 8 years of brainwashing and emotional abuse they are finally turned loose on the world. You can't help them in an hour appointment, and you shouldn't have to pay to try. >>>>>>>>> Andy is right. I met a great DAN doctor who was genuinely concerned for his patients. He began focusing on autistic patients and totally believed in the cause. Unfortunately, he worked in a general practice, and the other doctors began to put the squeeze on him and his nurse, who was equally knowledgeable and caring. The other doctors didn't like them thinking outside of the box and not conforming to their " boys club " . They eventually had to leave the practice, well the nurse was essentially fired. She had began to refuse to vaccinate children, and thus....well you know. Any how, these types of doctors and nurses are few and far between. If they don't conform to their colleagues beliefs, they are singled out and essentially black balled. a Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 30, 2003 Report Share Posted May 30, 2003 >>> The other doctors didn't like them thinking outside of the box and not conforming to their " boys club " ...If they don't conform to their colleagues beliefs, they are singled out and essentially black balled. Yes, but the dan club does the same exact thing to people who won't conform (or pay up) to what they want. So they do the same thing. . Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 30, 2003 Report Share Posted May 30, 2003 > > Yes, but the dan club does the same exact thing to people who won't > conform (or pay up) to what they want. So they do the same thing. > > . AMEN!!!!!!!! -Lissy Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 30, 2003 Report Share Posted May 30, 2003 Lori, Do NOT do the challenge while your son has amalgam fillings in place. This doc doesn't understand mercury poisoning or proper chelation. Consider doing chelation on your own with the help of this group. Even after the mercury fillings are out, a challenge is a bad idea unless you actually incorporate it into the first round using Andy's dosage and schedule. S <tt> Hi everyone, <BR> <BR> I went back to the DAN doc today to discuss test results. I was fortunate <BR> enough to have Andy and interpret them as well before I went.  While we <BR> found on the list that the results are conclusive/consistent of mercury <BR> poisoning the DAN doc wants to do a " DMSA challenge " as well. I informed him that I <BR> was under the impression that he should not have any DMSA until his dental <BR> fillings are removed and he said it didnt matter for a challenge? Is this correct? <BR> Is it a matter of personal opinion or dosent DMSA draw out mercury in <BR> fillings. Will this DMSA challenge be helpful in any way; we know he needs chelation <BR> so why a " DMSA challenge " ? <BR> <BR> Also, I asked him if the low zinc, low magnesium and low molybedum were <BR> consistent for mercury toxity and he said it could be caused by a million things! <BR> I also asked him about the disordered mineral transport and thyroid issues <BR> and asked whether these were consistent of mercury poison - he started getting <BR> ticked off ( atleast it seemed to me) he told me I am on the internet too much <BR> and am getting caught up in the latest rave. <BR> <BR> Besides his suggesting the " DMSA challenge " everything else he suggested was <BR> consistent with what we discussed on the list though. <BR> <BR> Am I wrong to second guess him on the DMSA challenge? I thought that when I <BR> went he would welcome my questions and thoughts but he didnt. He told me he was <BR> the doctor and basically to stop reading too much into this and trust him. <BR> What is the deal with these DAN doctors anyway?<BR> <BR> Again, any help is appreciated. <BR> Lori =======================================================<BR> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 31, 2003 Report Share Posted May 31, 2003 > In a message dated 5/30/2003 7:46:38 PM Eastern Daylight Time, > pjand3kids@j... writes: > > > Andy is right. I met a great DAN doctor who was genuinely concerned for > > his patients. He began focusing on autistic patients and totally believed in > > the cause. Unfortunately, he worked in a general practice, and the other > > doctors began to put the squeeze on him and his nurse, who was equally > > knowledgeable and caring. The other doctors didn't like them thinking outside of the > > box and not conforming to their " boys club " . They eventually had to leave the > > practice, well the nurse was essentially fired. She had began to refuse to > > vaccinate children, and thus....well you know. Any how, these types of > > doctors and nurses are few and far between. If they don't conform to their > > colleagues beliefs, they are singled out and essentially black balled. > > > > a > > > > > > I know what your saying and agree but this doctor is strictly a nutritional > and wellness doctor. Nope. Wrong. Error. He is an ACAM doctor. He does IV chelation for heart disease and similar things. >He used to practice regular medicine but now practices > nutritional medicine and says he specializes in Autism???? He says that to get business, it isn't so. If it was so he wouldn't have the room full of recliners. He specializes in EDTA chelation. > His practice consists > of a chelating room full of comfy recliners and people with IV's in their > arms. He is very deceiving because his literature and practice are " outside of the > box " . I thought I struck gold with him. Guess not. Nope. You just found a different sect of the MD religion. The ACAM church. Just like the AMA, but different dogma. > > Lori > > > [Non-text portions of this message ha Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 31, 2003 Report Share Posted May 31, 2003 --- In , " jornmatt " <defelice@t...> wrote: > >>> The other doctors didn't like them thinking outside of the box > and not conforming to their " boys club " ...If they don't conform to > their colleagues beliefs, they are singled out and essentially > black balled. > > Yes, but the dan club does the same exact thing to people who won't > conform (or pay up) to what they want. So they do the same thing. > > . Yup. AMA church. DAN! church. ACAM church. We don't need a sermon, we need medical care. But doctors don't do that any more, they preach and follow rituals. Andy . . . . . . . . . . Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 2, 2003 Report Share Posted June 2, 2003 Do yourself a favor and learn from my $10,000 mistake. DAN! doctors follow the chosen protocols (which may or may not be beneficial and even if they are, may or may not be relevant to your individual child) They also order zillions of tests to show them what you usually already know as a parent. Do yourself a favor and learn everything you can and make your own choices about what to do. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.