Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: THR vs MOM

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Guest guest

My OS doesn't think running again is a good idea , Dr.

Gross says

you can start running 6 months after surgery .

how much running is ok ?? what surface ?? treadmill ??

could the high impact cause premature loosening or wear ??

any more details would be appreciated .

Dr. Goldberg C+ , 1/28/03

" Jim "

<jpuglisi@buffalo To:

surfacehippy

.k12.ny.us> cc:

Subject: THR vs

MOM

04/22/2003 10:22

AM

Please respond to

surfacehippy

I am now almost 6 weeks post-op from an MOM and feeling better

everyday.  I did extensive research on all types of hip replacement

before selecting the MOM.  The reasons were simple:

1. Does not cause leg lengthing, therefore reducing any chance of

   stress sheilding.

2. Maintains the bone structure.

3. Eliminates any chance of Osteolytis, therefore reducing the chance

   of revision.

4. Enables me to return to the lifestyle I enjoyed before arthritis

   stripped me of it. (i.e.  running which Dr. Mont said I can

                       resume in September)

I am just very pleased that I was a candidate for an MOM, I also

understand that not everyone is a candidate alot depends on age, bone

struture and density.  But to take a " Sour Grapes " attitude is very

immature.  The point of any Hip surgery is to get back a better

quality of life.  I agree with the Captain, there isn't anything that

Geoffery could say that should make any surface hippies think they

made a poor decision.  Now for my favorite part.

Pugman C+ 3/13/03 Dr. Mont

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

, at his point I have no idea. My plans are to start slow on a

running track. The surface is very soft compared to blacktop or

concrete. I plan on starting with 9 to 12 miles/week and seeing how

the hip reacts. I do not intend to run more than 20 miles/week

regardless.

>

> My OS doesn't think running again is a good

idea , Dr.

> Gross says

> you can start running 6 months after surgery .

>

> how much running is ok ?? what surface ?? treadmill ??

> could the high impact cause premature loosening or

wear ??

>

> any more details would be appreciated .

>

> Dr. Goldberg C+ , 1/28/03

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Thanks , Jim . Ill ask my doctor again next month @ my

3 month check up

" Jim "

<jpuglisi@buffalo To:

surfacehippy

.k12.ny.us> cc:

Subject: Re: THR

vs MOM

04/22/2003 10:43

AM

Please respond to

surfacehippy

, at his point I have no idea.  My plans are to start slow on a

running track.  The surface is very soft compared to blacktop or

concrete.  I plan on starting with 9 to 12 miles/week and seeing how

the hip reacts.  I do not intend to run more than 20 miles/week

regardless.

>

> My  OS    doesn't   think   running  again    is  a   good

idea ,   Dr.

> Gross   says

> you can   start   running    6  months  after   surgery .

>

> how  much  running  is  ok  ??    what  surface   ??   treadmill  ??

> could  the high  impact   cause  premature  loosening   or

wear  ??

>

> any   more  details   would  be  appreciated .

>

> Dr.  Goldberg    C+  ,  1/28/03

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

If you have 'soft bones' - possibly caused by lack of use of the leg for

months prior to surgery - your Doctor may advise no impact activities (eg

running) for up to a year following surgery.

If your bone stock is good - then running may be OK as soon as the soft

tissue and bone have actually healed.

george.sekulidis@... on 22/04/2003 16:01:59

To: surfacehippy

cc:

bcc:

From: george.sekulidis@..., 22 April 2003, 4:01 p.m.

Contact:

Contact:

Re: Re: THR vs MOM

Thanks , Jim . Ill ask my doctor again next month @ my

3 month check up

" Jim "

<jpuglisi@buffalo To:

surfacehippy

.k12.ny.us> cc:

Subject: Re:

THR vs MOM

04/22/2003 10:43

AM

Please respond to

surfacehippy

, at his point I have no idea.  My plans are to start slow on a

running track.  The surface is very soft compared to blacktop or

concrete.  I plan on starting with 9 to 12 miles/week and seeing how

the hip reacts.  I do not intend to run more than 20 miles/week

regardless.

>

> My  OS    doesn't   think   running  again    is  a   good

idea ,   Dr.

> Gross   says

> you can   start   running    6  months  after   surgery .

>

> how  much  running  is  ok  ??    what  surface   ??   treadmill  ??

> could  the high  impact   cause  premature  loosening   or

wear  ??

>

> any   more  details   would  be  appreciated .

>

> Dr.  Goldberg    C+  ,  1/28/03

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Actually , i was told my bone stock was excellent .......... i

had simple

OA , no AVN

i only had hip pain for 7 months prior to surgery and

was able to exercise pretty well prior to surgery .........

with some

pain , of course .

it just seems like running or other high impact exercise would

be much

more stressful on the components than other activities .

i was just curious what other OS have to say about running

after

surgery

" Isobel Hotten "

<isobel.hotten@yel To:

surfacehippy

lgroup.com> cc:

Subject: Re: Re:

THR vs MOM

04/22/2003 11:10

AM

Please respond to

surfacehippy

If you have 'soft bones' - possibly caused by lack of use of the leg for

months prior to surgery - your Doctor may advise no impact activities (eg

running) for up to a year following surgery.

If your bone stock is good - then running may be OK as soon as the soft

tissue and bone have actually healed.

george.sekulidis@... on 22/04/2003 16:01:59

To:        surfacehippy

cc:

bcc:

From:      george.sekulidis@..., 22 April 2003, 4:01 p.m.

Contact:

Contact:

Re: Re: THR vs MOM

Thanks , Jim .   Ill  ask  my   doctor  again   next   month   @  my

3  month  check  up

                      " Jim "

                      <jpuglisi@buffalo        To:

surfacehippy

                      .k12.ny.us>              cc:

                                               Subject:  Re:

THR vs MOM

                      04/22/2003 10:43

                      AM

                      Please respond to

                      surfacehippy

, at his point I have no idea.  My plans are to start slow on a

running track.  The surface is very soft compared to blacktop or

concrete.  I plan on starting with 9 to 12 miles/week and seeing how

the hip reacts.  I do not intend to run more than 20 miles/week

regardless.

>

> My  OS    doesn't   think   running  again    is  a   good

idea ,   Dr.

> Gross   says

> you can   start   running    6  months  after   surgery .

>

> how  much  running  is  ok  ??    what  surface   ??   treadmill  ??

> could  the high  impact   cause  premature  loosening   or

wear  ??

>

> any   more  details   would  be  appreciated .

>

> Dr.  Goldberg    C+  ,  1/28/03

>

                              

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

I've always taken it as Metal On Metal which can be true for THR as well as

resurfacing. As a generalisation the 3 major prosthesis for resurfacing are

MOM. McMinn, the surgeon who is responsible for modern day resurfacing (as was

Treacy), got the MOM idea from metal on metal THR as I understand it.

Rog

Re: THR vs MOM

Hi - Can you tell me -- what is a MOM? Is that hip resurface?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...