Guest guest Posted September 24, 2000 Report Share Posted September 24, 2000 Bridged, I am scheduled for a surgery 10-10-2000. I was scheduled in August for the RNY, saw the truth for me, cancelled the operation & found a DS surgeon. I heard all the same things you talked about & almost went with the RNY because of all the " stinky " press I read about the DS. Then found a few DS post-ps on the AMOS site & read every post those few had ever written ( thank you , Fran & Heidi). From that informaion, I found the Duodenal Switch site & did my own research. For me, the only choice is DS. There are no gauranties as far as 20 years post op goes but I can tell you where I will be in 10 shold I forgo the DS, dead. Also, I wouldn't trade even 5 years of quality life for the 20 of misery. Another thought, I asked my surgeon about long term complications and he said the biggest thing they worry about is liver trouble due to protein malabsorption. So, you must be willing to eat the prescribed amount of protein daily for the rest of your life, I am willing to do that to save my own life. Also he said that if I am doing the regular blood work that is required for postop we coud catch the problem long before it gets to the pint of liver damage. Hope this helps a bit, t Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 25, 2000 Report Share Posted September 25, 2000 Brigid.... hi and welcome! As we all know, this is a big and scary step. It does get confusing. All I can say is that for me, it was the DS or nothing. This surgery has enabled me to live a normal life and make normal food choices and has left my body functioning as normally as possible. For my mother (age 54) and daughter (age 17), the decision was the same. No DS, no surgery. I believe in this surgery so much, Birgid and I do hope you an find the answers you are looking for. If you have any specific questions, just let us know. kris ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Aniceto Baltasar, MD Alcoy, SPAIN July 23, 1999 - self pay Open BPD/DS 60.35 inches gone 140+ lbs gone to the wind La vita e bella! See my pics: http://www.duodenalswitch.com/Patients/Kris/kris.html newbie & needing info on post-op problems > > > Hello Everyone, > I have also been watching and reading from afar. I am having > difficulty deciding betweeen the RNY and the " switch " . I feel like I > need to know more about the bad things(Bruce if you're reading please > respond to everyones cry for facts). I know it is thrilling to lose > the weight. I know you can live a normal life again. > What I don't know is the negative side. What about your > health in 20- 30 years? what about getting enough nutrients to live > and be healthy 20 years from now? What about everything I hear about > gas/diarrhea or rectal problems? > These are what I hear every where else..the DS gives you > terrible gas/ diarrhea from that. Then when I am reading everyone's > post no body has it or at least I haven't seen it yet. I know I > probably sound negative, but I really truly am not I am just very > frustrated with my resources for facts. Every sight I go to whether > it's for RNY or DS claims to bethe best and no one ever has any of > these problems. Then when I read the medical side it's beware of the > gas, diarrhea, rectal problems. I am scared to do this one because of > this alone. > O.k. on a " lighter " side I really appreciate having this available > to me. I really appreciate all of you who have put your selfs out > there for us to learn and grow from. I can't tell you how happy I am > that I have a choice. I just don't want to regret the choice to have > the DS. I really want to have this procedure the most, but I am > terrified I will end up with more problems than I started with. > I hope someone who has had this procedure will respond. I am not > as " crabby " as I probably came across here, but just getting a little > desperate for info. > Thanking you in anticipation!! > Brigid > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 25, 2000 Report Share Posted September 25, 2000 Brigid.... hi and welcome! As we all know, this is a big and scary step. It does get confusing. All I can say is that for me, it was the DS or nothing. This surgery has enabled me to live a normal life and make normal food choices and has left my body functioning as normally as possible. For my mother (age 54) and daughter (age 17), the decision was the same. No DS, no surgery. I believe in this surgery so much, Birgid and I do hope you an find the answers you are looking for. If you have any specific questions, just let us know. kris ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Aniceto Baltasar, MD Alcoy, SPAIN July 23, 1999 - self pay Open BPD/DS 60.35 inches gone 140+ lbs gone to the wind La vita e bella! See my pics: http://www.duodenalswitch.com/Patients/Kris/kris.html newbie & needing info on post-op problems > > > Hello Everyone, > I have also been watching and reading from afar. I am having > difficulty deciding betweeen the RNY and the " switch " . I feel like I > need to know more about the bad things(Bruce if you're reading please > respond to everyones cry for facts). I know it is thrilling to lose > the weight. I know you can live a normal life again. > What I don't know is the negative side. What about your > health in 20- 30 years? what about getting enough nutrients to live > and be healthy 20 years from now? What about everything I hear about > gas/diarrhea or rectal problems? > These are what I hear every where else..the DS gives you > terrible gas/ diarrhea from that. Then when I am reading everyone's > post no body has it or at least I haven't seen it yet. I know I > probably sound negative, but I really truly am not I am just very > frustrated with my resources for facts. Every sight I go to whether > it's for RNY or DS claims to bethe best and no one ever has any of > these problems. Then when I read the medical side it's beware of the > gas, diarrhea, rectal problems. I am scared to do this one because of > this alone. > O.k. on a " lighter " side I really appreciate having this available > to me. I really appreciate all of you who have put your selfs out > there for us to learn and grow from. I can't tell you how happy I am > that I have a choice. I just don't want to regret the choice to have > the DS. I really want to have this procedure the most, but I am > terrified I will end up with more problems than I started with. > I hope someone who has had this procedure will respond. I am not > as " crabby " as I probably came across here, but just getting a little > desperate for info. > Thanking you in anticipation!! > Brigid > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 25, 2000 Report Share Posted September 25, 2000 Hi Jenn.... please let us know if you need any specific questions answered. We all want you to make the best decision for you. You should make your decision on what you can live with. Good luck! kris ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Aniceto Baltasar, MD Alcoy, SPAIN July 23, 1999 - self pay Open BPD/DS 60.35 inches gone 140+ lbs gone to the wind La vita e bella! See my pics: http://www.duodenalswitch.com/Patients/Kris/kris.html Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 25, 2000 Report Share Posted September 25, 2000 Hi Jenn.... please let us know if you need any specific questions answered. We all want you to make the best decision for you. You should make your decision on what you can live with. Good luck! kris ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Aniceto Baltasar, MD Alcoy, SPAIN July 23, 1999 - self pay Open BPD/DS 60.35 inches gone 140+ lbs gone to the wind La vita e bella! See my pics: http://www.duodenalswitch.com/Patients/Kris/kris.html Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 25, 2000 Report Share Posted September 25, 2000 jennmich473@... wrote: > > I TOO AM HAVING A HARD TIME DECIDING BETWEEN THE TWO SURGERIES, NO > MATTER WHICH SITE YOU GO TO, THEY THINK THAT THIER SURGERY IS THE > BEST. <soft chuckle> This is true. However, having once had a similar operation to the RNY, losing some weight, gaining it back, as well as being a member of RNY and pouch lists for over a year, I must say I have seen a *majority* of posts regarding how to just *live* with their new insides. They have to essentially learn how to eat again, and it can be *very,* very frustrating. Do not take this warning lightly, as a " preference " issue. It is the absolute truth, from one who has been there and one who has seen many, MANY others go through the same thing, and still many others who regain their weight because the pouch or reduced stomach *does* stretch or for other reasons. BTW, I have seen much much more impartiality on this DS list (leaving it up to the individual as to the decision to make on a personal basis) than on any of the other WLS sites I have participated in. Everyone has to weigh the pros and cons before coming to the decision that is right for them, but I consider the people here more experienced and knowledgeable, and many are being or have been revised from other WLS procedures before this one, and this is their last. I personally would not choose a RNY as a revision because I don't think it would be very successful for very long. I need a permanent solution. Learning all of the facts and logistics of the two surgeries and the aftercare, I have found the DS to appear to be more logical in taking care of my long-term goals. JMOHO, once again ;-) Robin Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 25, 2000 Report Share Posted September 25, 2000 , Well said. I think I love you. LOL Robin F Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.