Guest guest Posted July 21, 2008 Report Share Posted July 21, 2008 I believe that my mil is BPD or NPD, she's never been diagnosed, but her behavior fits the descriptions of both disorders. I really don't care too much about the label. I just want to deal with her behavior. I tended to put myself in the middle to try to keep her out of our lives as much as possible, and this played into her hand nicely. She never had to face the fractured relationship she had with her adult son, when she could blame it on his b*%chy wife. Now, I deal with her as little as possible, and leave it up to my husband to maintain whatever level of contact he's comfortable with. At the present time, that is very limited contact, and that's alright with me! Best of luck. It can be hard to deal with these people when you haven't been raised by them to service their endless emotional demands. It can be especially difficult when your spouse is ambivalent about the situation, and you feel stuck in the middle. Let me know if there is anything more specific that you would find helpful. > > Does anyone out there have a mother-in-law with BPD? I have just > read " Stop Walking on Eggshells " (Mason/Kreger), " Surviving a > Borderline Parent " (Roth/Friedman), and " Toxic In-laws " (Forward). > This is my first post. > > Thank you for any insight! > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 21, 2008 Report Share Posted July 21, 2008 i find this thread interesting. My aunt, I suspect is BPD or Narc. She always spoke to me in a horrible tone of voice - taking the piss and trying to make me look small when I was a child. She used to then send me birthday cards and presents and expect me to be grateful. Did anyone else experience this? > > > > Does anyone out there have a mother-in-law with BPD? I have just > > read " Stop Walking on Eggshells " (Mason/Kreger) , > " Surviving a > > Borderline Parent " (Roth/Friedman) , and " Toxic In-laws " > (Forward). > > This is my first post. > > > > Thank you for any insight! > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 21, 2008 Report Share Posted July 21, 2008 oh heck yeah. nada expected me to be grateful for everything,...down to the powdered milk she so generously provided to me. nada demanded ultimate servitude in return for the barest essentials but she will tell you that she was the world's greatest mother. Mercy > > > > , > > Oh yeah,...I've seen the hurt, about-to-cry look on my 8 year old > one too many times. My 17 year old has been told that he no longer > needs to hold his tongue with it,...he can say or do whatever. > (He's a good kid, mind you.) I've taken too many pains with my boys > to not break their spirits as mine was as a child. I absolutely > refuse to have a b & %ch of a SIL tear them down. (Forgive me.) > Thanks for your advice. I still feel sometimes that it's my > fault,....weird huh? Like your closing sentence,....ya have a mean > streak in ya, dontcha? (wink wink) > > Hugs, > > Mercy > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 22, 2008 Report Share Posted July 22, 2008 How can they be so abusive to children? I have felt that they are just transfering the abusive way they've been with me over the years, pinning all the families problems on me and setting me up as some sort of scapegoat...onto my innocent child. For no other reason that he is mine. That's when it's best to just remove your child from these people's lives. They are not supportive, and building the child's self esteem, providing a positive nurturing support system...They are destroying his self worth and setting him up to develop the same self hate that we all deal with. Because, he can't do anything right. No matter how hard he tries. Some times it's better to be alone, than with those who hurt you. That's what I've done with my son too. I don't allow him near my nephew, or narc sister and brother anymore. After the extremely hurtful things they were doing to him. It's not worth it. We are working to build other relationships and supports instead. > > > > Does anyone out there have a mother-in-law with BPD? I have just > > read " Stop Walking on Eggshells " (Mason/Kreger) , " Surviving a > > Borderline Parent " (Roth/Friedman) , and " Toxic In-laws " (Forward). > > This is my first post. > > > > Thank you for any insight! > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 23, 2008 Report Share Posted July 23, 2008 I feel the same way... it is hard for me. My husband is still tied up with my MIL emotionally. For the first time in fourteen years I am no longer consumed with trying to please her, and trying to please my husband (non-BPD). The IL's live within a half hour from us and the kids. I have no contact with my own Father due to abusive situation, and I feel like my husband continues to trumpet the tune, " Our kids aren't going to end up like you and your Dad, not having a relationship with their grandmother " . I have not wanted that either, and so I am trying to crawl out of this hole I feel like I have helped dig. (And now beating myself up for not seeing earlier!) It all came to a head this when for the first time I insisted we (the four of us - two grandparents and us parents) sit down and discuss boundaries for the kids when they go over to the Grandparent's house. We're all adults right? Why would my hubby be so against this? There has been mounting issues around this for years, they have been going for visits once or twice a week. (The IL's are starting to insist their house/their rules.) My husband and I discussed the boundaries ahead of time, he said it might be better on paper, I typed them up. It took three weeks for them to finally agree to a meeting - only to have my MIL begin the meeting with " wipe that smurck off your face, I didn't come here to be laughed at by you. " What smurck ?@#?!? It went down hill from there. My husband was able to stand up to his Mom and Dad regarding the kids and boundaries (you may not pop our 1 1/2 year old, or any of the other kids for that matter, you may not call our 7 year old a 'crybaby', We will decide what is appropriate for the kids to watch on TV, no family secrets - do not tell the kids, " don't tell your mom. . . " , etc.) But I am still feeling resentful and hurt, he would not stand up for me. He allowed her to treat me without regard or respect. For the first time in fourteen years, when she stood up and pointed down at me, blaming me and laying into me, I STOOD UP AND POINTED BACK! Is it possible to be embarrassed and proud at the same time? My husband now blames me. He says I blew it by stooping to her level. He said this was why he wants to handle his Mom instead of doing it together. He said I am a Christian and need to act like one, etc. I am tired of being shamed and feeling like I have to be perfect to be accepted within this family. How embarrassing!!! I'm the mother in this family!!! My husband does not see how emeshed with his BP Mom emotionally he is. She relies and depends on him (daily phone calls, etc), and FIL likes it that way - he doesn't have to deal with MIL. FIL does not to stand up to MIL. It finally ended that my husband will be taking the kids over for an evening visit tonight without me, chaperoned by him. I trust him with the kids - and honestly don't mind him going and taking them. Am I wrong in wanting him to say, " Hey Mom, I love my wife. This is our family. If YOU want to be a part of US, then you will have to respect her and treat her as if she is a part of me. " I am determined to enjoy my evening; but I am torn between feeling relieved at not having to go, and upset that I am the one being left out. Any words of wisdom? WTOAdultChildren1 , " friendsofcam " wrote: > > How can they be so abusive to children? I have felt that they are > just transfering the abusive way they've been with me over the > years, pinning all the families problems on me and setting me up as > some sort of scapegoat...onto my innocent child. For no other reason > that he is mine. That's when it's best to just remove your child > from these people's lives. They are not supportive, and building > the child's self esteem, providing a positive nurturing support > system...They are destroying his self worth and setting him up to > develop the same self hate that we all deal with. Because, he can't > do anything right. No matter how hard he tries. Some times it's > better to be alone, than with those who hurt you. That's what I've > done with my son too. I don't allow him near my nephew, or narc > sister and brother anymore. After the extremely hurtful things they > were doing to him. It's not worth it. We are working to build other > relationships and supports instead. > > > > > > > > > Does anyone out there have a mother-in-law with BPD? I have just > > > read " Stop Walking on Eggshells " (Mason/Kreger) , " Surviving a > > > Borderline Parent " (Roth/Friedman) , and " Toxic In-laws " > (Forward). > > > This is my first post. > > > > > > Thank you for any insight! > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 23, 2008 Report Share Posted July 23, 2008 Oooh, I have such a hard time when someone uses the reasoning that if you're a Christian you need to be someone's doormat. From the info you gave in your post, it does not sound like you are asking anything unreasonable in the way of treatment of your kids. I see a parent asking for respect of her rules. As far as the happenings with you and your husband,...um, I'm just going to say that imho he needs to take a more proactive stance in your favor. My husband doesn't tolerate his mother verbally abusing me or his sister yelling at my kids. Kindest regards, Mercy > > I feel the same way... it is hard for me. My husband is still tied > up with my MIL emotionally. For the first time in fourteen years I > am no longer consumed with trying to please her, and trying to > please my husband (non-BPD). The IL's live within a half hour from > us and the kids. I have no contact with my own Father due to > abusive situation, and I feel like my husband continues to trumpet > the tune, " Our kids aren't going to end up like you and your Dad, > not having a relationship with their grandmother " . I have not > wanted that either, and so I am trying to crawl out of this hole I > feel like I have helped dig. (And now beating myself up for not > seeing earlier!) It all came to a head this when for the first time > I insisted we (the four of us - two grandparents and us parents) sit > down and discuss boundaries for the kids when they go over to the > Grandparent's house. We're all adults right? Why would my hubby be > so against this? There has been mounting issues around this for > years, they have been going for visits once or twice a week. (The > IL's are starting to insist their house/their rules.) My husband > and I discussed the boundaries ahead of time, he said it might be > better on paper, I typed them up. It took three weeks for them to > finally agree to a meeting - only to have my MIL begin the meeting > with " wipe that smurck off your face, I didn't come here to be > laughed at by you. " What smurck ?@#?!? It went down hill from > there. My husband was able to stand up to his Mom and Dad regarding > the kids and boundaries (you may not pop our 1 1/2 year old, or any > of the other kids for that matter, you may not call our 7 year old > a 'crybaby', We will decide what is appropriate for the kids to > watch on TV, no family secrets - do not tell the kids, " don't tell > your mom. . . " , etc.) But I am still feeling resentful and hurt, he > would not stand up for me. He allowed her to treat me without regard > or respect. For the first time in fourteen years, when she stood up > and pointed down at me, blaming me and laying into me, I STOOD UP > AND POINTED BACK! Is it possible to be embarrassed and proud at the > same time? My husband now blames me. He says I blew it by stooping > to her level. He said this was why he wants to handle his Mom > instead of doing it together. He said I am a Christian and need to > act like one, etc. I am tired of being shamed and feeling like I > have to be perfect to be accepted within this family. How > embarrassing!!! I'm the mother in this family!!! My husband does > not see how emeshed with his BP Mom emotionally he is. She relies > and depends on him (daily phone calls, etc), and FIL likes it that > way - he doesn't have to deal with MIL. FIL does not to stand up to > MIL. It finally ended that my husband will be taking the kids over > for an evening visit tonight without me, chaperoned by him. I trust > him with the kids - and honestly don't mind him going and taking > them. Am I wrong in wanting him to say, " Hey Mom, I love my wife. > This is our family. If YOU want to be a part of US, then you will > have to respect her and treat her as if she is a part of me. " I am > determined to enjoy my evening; but I am torn between feeling > relieved at not having to go, and upset that I am the one being left > out. > > Any words of wisdom? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 23, 2008 Report Share Posted July 23, 2008 Thank you for writing. Believe it or not, I live life in tougher skin - and appreciate you being straight forward. Sometimes I feel like I can see everyone elses issues and somehow get lost in the fog on mine. You have basically written my argument to him. My MIL has had success. And you're right. . .he doesn't see it that way. He sees it as keeping the peace in the family, which would be part of the problem. He is the 'chosen' child. His older brother is the one who could do no right - still can't according to MIL. My BIL is the only one in their immediate family who dares to address her straight on and it infuriates her. I see my husband still trying to play the chosen child role, only I don't think he can see it. She cannot form and keep friendships, she makes a friend and as long as she is in control, all goes well. When the friendship goes south (usually a couple of months when they come up for air) she does mean things on purpose pretending not to, and even has a name for this - she calls it giving someone a " nice-nasty " . She phones and gives my hubby all the details, poor poor me, I've been pooped on again - gaining his sympathy. (And a LOT of his emotional energy.) She cries when she doesn't get her way, doing her " it's not fair " number, sharing way too much with my husband. MIL and FIL followed us when we moved from one end of the state to the other, and bought a second house 3 miles from our last one (we moved last year) while I was pregnant. She said I would need help with all the kids - and then gave me the silent treatment for several months when I asked my Mom to help after delivery. Why didn't I tell her then? I kept waiting for my husband to do that. I just can't wait for him any longer to take the lead here. I waited too long, trying to please and now trying not to beat myself up for it. My hubby is strong in so many ways - a man's man really. Mountain bikes, hikes, runs, basketball, insightful, reads Elderidge's every word sometimes twice. Even likes to give me foot rubs! His mom is his achilles heel. I am not trying to make excuses, he has hurt me horribly over all of this - but I am not convienced he sees it. Oh I pray the Lord will open his eyes. We agreed to re-group later this evening and discuss their visit. I think your idea is great to have them over here. That ought to put a damper on the visits for a while, and some regained control over our family. I am proud of myself in sending them off tonight. No lectures, no pineing; a smile and a kiss. Thank you for your straightforward honesty. I need it! > > > > > > > > Does anyone out there have a mother-in-law with BPD? I have > just > > > > read " Stop Walking on Eggshells " (Mason/Kreger) , " Surviving a > > > > Borderline Parent " (Roth/Friedman) , and " Toxic In-laws " > > (Forward). > > > > This is my first post. > > > > > > > > Thank you for any insight! > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 23, 2008 Report Share Posted July 23, 2008 Thanks JaneSoul - I want to be healthy! > > > > > > > > Does anyone out there have a mother-in-law with BPD? I have > just > > > > read " Stop Walking on Eggshells " (Mason/Kreger) , " Surviving a > > > > Borderline Parent " (Roth/Friedman) , and " Toxic In-laws " > > (Forward). > > > > This is my first post. > > > > > > > > Thank you for any insight! > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 23, 2008 Report Share Posted July 23, 2008 Thank you Mercy. Do you mind if I ask, how did your husband come to the realization that his Mom was BPD? My hubby reads a lot but is unwilling to read my 'boarderline' and " Toxic Inlaws " books. I have asked him to. It was as if he and my FIL knew what to expect, with her spewing when we tried to talk, the four of us. I am guessing that if this happened with my hubby growing up, then he has been both emotionally and verbally abused? But maybe not, since he was the 'chosen' child? I was emotionally and verbally abused growing up by my Dad. My parents divorced, my mother is happily remarried, I have a wonderful step-father, but my biological father and I have no relationship or contact. To my husband, this is the worst thing that could ever happen in a family. When I push too hard (what is too hard? I'm not sure I know - when I start to feel like Edith Bunker,) he will say, " My Mom and I are not going to end up like you and your Dad. " It cuts me to the core. Is there a way to open his eyes to the possibility of him being 'abused'? Thank you for writing, finallystanding > > > > I feel the same way... it is hard for me. My husband is still tied > > up with my MIL emotionally. For the first time in fourteen years I > > am no longer consumed with trying to please her, and trying to > > please my husband (non-BPD). The IL's live within a half hour from > > us and the kids. I have no contact with my own Father due to > > abusive situation, and I feel like my husband continues to trumpet > > the tune, " Our kids aren't going to end up like you and your Dad, > > not having a relationship with their grandmother " . I have not > > wanted that either, and so I am trying to crawl out of this hole I > > feel like I have helped dig. (And now beating myself up for not > > seeing earlier!) It all came to a head this when for the first > time > > I insisted we (the four of us - two grandparents and us parents) > sit > > down and discuss boundaries for the kids when they go over to the > > Grandparent's house. We're all adults right? Why would my hubby > be > > so against this? There has been mounting issues around this for > > years, they have been going for visits once or twice a week. (The > > IL's are starting to insist their house/their rules.) My husband > > and I discussed the boundaries ahead of time, he said it might be > > better on paper, I typed them up. It took three weeks for them to > > finally agree to a meeting - only to have my MIL begin the meeting > > with " wipe that smurck off your face, I didn't come here to be > > laughed at by you. " What smurck ?@#?!? It went down hill from > > there. My husband was able to stand up to his Mom and Dad > regarding > > the kids and boundaries (you may not pop our 1 1/2 year old, or any > > of the other kids for that matter, you may not call our 7 year old > > a 'crybaby', We will decide what is appropriate for the kids to > > watch on TV, no family secrets - do not tell the kids, " don't tell > > your mom. . . " , etc.) But I am still feeling resentful and hurt, > he > > would not stand up for me. He allowed her to treat me without > regard > > or respect. For the first time in fourteen years, when she stood > up > > and pointed down at me, blaming me and laying into me, I STOOD UP > > AND POINTED BACK! Is it possible to be embarrassed and proud at > the > > same time? My husband now blames me. He says I blew it by > stooping > > to her level. He said this was why he wants to handle his Mom > > instead of doing it together. He said I am a Christian and need to > > act like one, etc. I am tired of being shamed and feeling like I > > have to be perfect to be accepted within this family. How > > embarrassing!!! I'm the mother in this family!!! My husband does > > not see how emeshed with his BP Mom emotionally he is. She relies > > and depends on him (daily phone calls, etc), and FIL likes it that > > way - he doesn't have to deal with MIL. FIL does not to stand up > to > > MIL. It finally ended that my husband will be taking the kids over > > for an evening visit tonight without me, chaperoned by him. I > trust > > him with the kids - and honestly don't mind him going and taking > > them. Am I wrong in wanting him to say, " Hey Mom, I love my wife. > > This is our family. If YOU want to be a part of US, then you will > > have to respect her and treat her as if she is a part of me. " I am > > determined to enjoy my evening; but I am torn between feeling > > relieved at not having to go, and upset that I am the one being > left > > out. > > > > Any words of wisdom? > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 23, 2008 Report Share Posted July 23, 2008 Me again. I believe that the chances your hubby was emotionally and verbally abused is around 90%, if he can see it for what it is. Just because they are the 'chosen' one does not make them immune to the abuse. Like most of us however the possibility that we are being abused in such a manner by our parent may take some time and serioius mental work of our own. It is literally too scary for words. That your hubby seems to have fear of his nada should be a great big red flag for you. Keeping the peace means that your hubby is sacrificing himself to please his nada and keep her from going 'nuclear' on him in an emotional way. She absolutly will. As I suggest in another posting, you may get further if you address the tactic of invalidation with your hubby rather than labeling it as abuse. That may be too much for him at this point. Otherwise you may need to let things run their course and wait for his eventual " blacklisting " that will come from her as the two of you continue to push back with respect to the parenting of your children. At that point, if you can recognize it, you might be able to reach him. Be strong > > > > > > I feel the same way... it is hard for me. My husband is still > tied > > > up with my MIL emotionally. For the first time in fourteen > years I > > > am no longer consumed with trying to please her, and trying to > > > please my husband (non-BPD). The IL's live within a half hour > from > > > us and the kids. I have no contact with my own Father due to > > > abusive situation, and I feel like my husband continues to > trumpet > > > the tune, " Our kids aren't going to end up like you and your > Dad, > > > not having a relationship with their grandmother " . I have not > > > wanted that either, and so I am trying to crawl out of this hole > I > > > feel like I have helped dig. (And now beating myself up for not > > > seeing earlier!) It all came to a head this when for the first > > time > > > I insisted we (the four of us - two grandparents and us parents) > > sit > > > down and discuss boundaries for the kids when they go over to > the > > > Grandparent's house. We're all adults right? Why would my > hubby > > be > > > so against this? There has been mounting issues around this for > > > years, they have been going for visits once or twice a week. > (The > > > IL's are starting to insist their house/their rules.) My > husband > > > and I discussed the boundaries ahead of time, he said it might > be > > > better on paper, I typed them up. It took three weeks for them > to > > > finally agree to a meeting - only to have my MIL begin the > meeting > > > with " wipe that smurck off your face, I didn't come here to be > > > laughed at by you. " What smurck ?@#?!? It went down hill from > > > there. My husband was able to stand up to his Mom and Dad > > regarding > > > the kids and boundaries (you may not pop our 1 1/2 year old, or > any > > > of the other kids for that matter, you may not call our 7 year > old > > > a 'crybaby', We will decide what is appropriate for the kids to > > > watch on TV, no family secrets - do not tell the kids, " don't > tell > > > your mom. . . " , etc.) But I am still feeling resentful and > hurt, > > he > > > would not stand up for me. He allowed her to treat me without > > regard > > > or respect. For the first time in fourteen years, when she > stood > > up > > > and pointed down at me, blaming me and laying into me, I STOOD > UP > > > AND POINTED BACK! Is it possible to be embarrassed and proud at > > the > > > same time? My husband now blames me. He says I blew it by > > stooping > > > to her level. He said this was why he wants to handle his Mom > > > instead of doing it together. He said I am a Christian and need > to > > > act like one, etc. I am tired of being shamed and feeling like > I > > > have to be perfect to be accepted within this family. How > > > embarrassing!!! I'm the mother in this family!!! My husband > does > > > not see how emeshed with his BP Mom emotionally he is. She > relies > > > and depends on him (daily phone calls, etc), and FIL likes it > that > > > way - he doesn't have to deal with MIL. FIL does not to stand > up > > to > > > MIL. It finally ended that my husband will be taking the kids > over > > > for an evening visit tonight without me, chaperoned by him. I > > trust > > > him with the kids - and honestly don't mind him going and taking > > > them. Am I wrong in wanting him to say, " Hey Mom, I love my > wife. > > > This is our family. If YOU want to be a part of US, then you > will > > > have to respect her and treat her as if she is a part of me. " I > am > > > determined to enjoy my evening; but I am torn between feeling > > > relieved at not having to go, and upset that I am the one being > > left > > > out. > > > > > > Any words of wisdom? > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 23, 2008 Report Share Posted July 23, 2008 Dearest Finally, Hmm,...we're not exactly sure that MIL is BPD. We just know that jacked up stuff is going on with MIL and SIL. MIL has some mild traits like my Nada and I think we hopped on the boundary bandwagon after my husband witnessed how my Nada treated me and how I reacted; he knew limits had to be set with his MIL. We haven't quite put a finger on what's really going on but we both know that our kids have been hurt emotionally and we're not going to stand for it. My MIL really blew it with my husband though when she ranted at me and took sides with irrational SIL. That was a breaking point for him and she blew the deal. I doubt their relationship will ever be the same. Kindest regards, Mercy > > > > Oooh, I have such a hard time when someone uses the reasoning that > if > > you're a Christian you need to be someone's doormat. From the > info > > you gave in your post, it does not sound like you are asking > anything > > unreasonable in the way of treatment of your kids. I see a parent > > asking for respect of her rules. > > > > As far as the happenings with you and your husband,...um, I'm just > > going to say that imho he needs to take a more proactive stance in > > your favor. My husband doesn't tolerate his mother verbally > abusing > > me or his sister yelling at my kids. > > > > Kindest regards, > > Mercy Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 23, 2008 Report Share Posted July 23, 2008 If he wants to get all on you about Christianity, then maybe he should take a look at some of these verses: Genesis 2:24 This explains why a man leaves his father and mother and is joined to his wife, and the two are united into one. Ephesians 5:25-28: For husbands, this means love your wives, just as Christ loved the church. He gave up his life for her to make her holy and clean, washed by the cleansing of God's word. He did this to present her to himself as a glorious church without a spot or wrinkle or any other blemish. Instead, she will be holy and without fault.In the same way, husbands ought to love their wives as they love their own bodies. For a man who loves his wife actually shows love for himself. I'm just sayin... > > > > > > > > Does anyone out there have a mother-in-law with BPD? I have > just > > > > read " Stop Walking on Eggshells " (Mason/Kreger) , " Surviving a > > > > Borderline Parent " (Roth/Friedman) , and " Toxic In-laws " > > (Forward). > > > > This is my first post. > > > > > > > > Thank you for any insight! > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 24, 2008 Report Share Posted July 24, 2008 Thank you for posting the FULL text of that often-abused commandment. I hate when BPDs cherry-pick to suit themselves, conveniently ignoring anything that THEY are responsible for. My dad loves to berate me behind my back for not " honoring thy father and mother like the commandment says. I wish she'd get out that Bible of hers....etc.....etc.... " He loves to trash me on that one. You rock! [hugs] Kyla > > > > > > > > > > Does anyone out there have a mother-in-law with BPD? I have > > just > > > > > read " Stop Walking on Eggshells " (Mason/Kreger) , " Surviving > a > > > > > Borderline Parent " (Roth/Friedman) , and " Toxic In-laws " > > > (Forward). > > > > > This is my first post. > > > > > > > > > > Thank you for any insight! > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 24, 2008 Report Share Posted July 24, 2008 YEAH!! now that's what I'm talkin' about. you ALL rock! Kindest regards, Mercy > > > > Rock on, Daisy. It is amazing to me how the good name of Christ > gets trotted out to justify all sorts of bad behavior. Somewhere I > read that the Honor thy mother and father is only part of the > commandment. > > Here is the full text, which I find qutie revealing: > > " Children, obey your parents in the Lord: for this is right. Honor > thy father and thy mother; which is the first commandment with > promise; That it may be well with thee, and thou mayest live long on > the earth. And, ye fathers, provoke not your children to wrath: but > bring them up in the nurture and admonition of the Lord, " Ephesians > 6:1-4. > > * > > " Children, obey your parents in all things: for this is well > pleasing unto the Lord. Fathers, provoke not your children to anger, > lest they be discouraged, " Colossians 3:20-21. > > Makes you think that BPD has been around a long, long time. > > Be strong > > > > > > > > Re: BPD mother-in-law? > > > > > > If he wants to get all on you about Christianity, then maybe he > > should take a look at some of these verses: > > > > Genesis 2:24 > > This explains why a man leaves his father and mother and is joined > to > > his wife, and the two are united into one. > > > > Ephesians 5:25-28: > > For husbands, this means love your wives, just as Christ loved the > > church. He gave up his life for her to make her holy and clean, > > washed by the cleansing of God's word. He did this to present her > to > > himself as a glorious church without a spot or wrinkle or any > other > > blemish. Instead, she will be holy and without fault.In the same > way, > > husbands ought to love their wives as they love their own bodies. > For > > a man who loves his wife actually shows love for himself. > > > > I'm just sayin... > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 30, 2008 Report Share Posted July 30, 2008 Just curious, do you two have children? Do they go with your husband to see your MIL? I would love some feedback from anyone on this. I have said a strong " no " to allowing the children to go over there without him (was that MY voice I heard saying no?!?) MIL is out of town visiting her painted black child now that her painted white child relationship has been 'tarnished' by me, the DIL. This is new territory and I am not sure what my expectations should be - or what is fair in the situation. I want to be ready when they return from out of town, I know they will be expecting a visit (from everyone else but me). I don't want to prevent the kids from having a relationship with MIL and FIL, but I also want to be careful in that relationship, seeing as she is becoming more abusive and selective. Or am I just becoming more intolerant, getting wiser? I also struggle a bit with feeling like I am the one left out of the family here, and she is the one with BPD. How did THAT happen? Thanks rinkled! Finally standing > > > > Does anyone out there have a mother-in-law with BPD? I have just > > read " Stop Walking on Eggshells " (Mason/Kreger), " Surviving a > > Borderline Parent " (Roth/Friedman), and " Toxic In-laws " (Forward). > > This is my first post. > > > > Thank you for any insight! > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 30, 2008 Report Share Posted July 30, 2008 Hello finallystanding, I have two children. They are 18 and 16 years old now. We rarely visit my mil, but my husband has never taken them to see his parents (his father died last June) without me. Taking the kids to visit his parents without me was actually a " line in the sand " moment for me and my husband. It happened in 1994. Here's how it went down: One Saturday in December, my inlaws stopped in for an unexpected visit. I happened to be out of the house when they arrived. When I walked in the house, my husband, 4 year old son, 2 year old daughter, and my inlaws were sitting in the living room. My fil immediately stood up from his seat and said " let's go, Peg " , as he pushed passed me without saying hello or making eye contact. My mil, waif that she is, stood there looking confused and worried. I may have mentioned before that all the issues between us were my fault as far as the inlaws are concerned. For instance things like requesting that they refrain from dropping in uninvited was a huge insult to them. From their point of view, I was keeping their son (and THEIR grandchildren) away from them. From my point of view it was an invasion of our privacy and an intrusion on our limited family time on weekends. Anyway, after the fil walked passed me, I said, this is my house, you don't get to be rude to me here. Maybe I should have bit my tongue in front of the kids, but I didn't. And my fil went off. Hurling insults and cursing and etc. And my kids started crying, so I took the two of them upstairs, and told my husband to " get rid of them. " This occurred the weekend before Christmas. We were planning to go visit them at their home about 2 hours away on the day after Christmas. I told my husband, unless things change drastically between now and then, we are not going. My husband, said, you don't have to go. NO, NO, NO! They don't get to be rude, disrespectful and horrible to me. They don't get to act as though I am a nonperson, and then get unfettered access to MY children without the " burden " of my presence. We had a huge fight. One of the worst ever. And then I guess he realized at some point that his parents were not kind or loving towards me. That he had to stop appeasing them and letting them " get away with it " in order to keep them quiet and off his back. Because it didn't realy keep them off his back, they just expected more and more and more. We went NC with them for three glorious years. My fil sent me a letter a couple weeks later. He apolgized that my feelings were hurt because I take things the wrong way, and other non- apologetic excuses for his behavior. I was instructed to let bygones be bygones. The kicker? He spelled my name wrong! On the one hand, it seems easier all around to stay home when your husband takes them to see his parents. But I found the exculsion unacceptable and it felt as if my husband was validating that " I " was the problem if he did that. It hurts. Have you read " Toxic Inlaws " by Forward? Also, " Understanding the Borderline Mother " , by Lawson? Gave me a lot of insight into the situation with my husband. But he had to be ready, willing. Head in the sand is so much more comfortable in this instance. It is very frustrating if they choose to stay there when you are ready to pull their heads out, and force them to look at the sky. We've been married for 21 years now, and we are still handling the fallout. (((((finallystanding))))) > > > > > > Does anyone out there have a mother-in-law with BPD? I have > just > > > read " Stop Walking on Eggshells " (Mason/Kreger), " Surviving a > > > Borderline Parent " (Roth/Friedman), and " Toxic In-laws " > (Forward). > > > This is my first post. > > > > > > Thank you for any insight! > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 31, 2008 Report Share Posted July 31, 2008 Rinkled, I sooo appreciate you sharing - very timely too, as sure enough, the MIL called my husband last night, wanting " visitation with the grandkids " . She just got back from visiting her other son (split black), and told my husband she felt the need to discuss the situation at length with him. He lives 10 hours away!!! Reading this yesterday helped me to stay strong today in a heated 'discussion' (with husband). My husband wants to allow the kids to go over there and spend the night Friday. I stuck to my guns and said no. . . though this was hard. Nothing has been resolved. He said they now know our boundaries. I disagreed. They didn't agree to any of them and she treated me horribly when we sat down to try to discuss things. My husband keeps saying it is an ongoing problem between she and I. This is the first time I have embarrassingly EVER stood up to her, trying to set boundaries for the kids and then had to take up for myself when my husband wouldn't. I told him I felt like it is an ongoing problem between she and him, and he and I (what a GREAT triangle!!) Boy is it hard not to just go along. He said what he has learned is that the longer things go unresolved, the harder it is to resolve them. I said that is what he has experienced with his mother. I have asked him to go with me to see a marriage counselor. He is not real hip on the idea. Thank you again - especially " They don't get to be rude, disrespectful and horrible to me. They don't get to act as though I am a nonperson, and then get unfettered access to MY children without the " burden " of my presence. " I LOVE this! This is how I feel. My husband has had a phone interview with a company about two hours from here - an INCREDIBLE thing, he hates the company he is with now but he hasn't wanted to move again (MIL said several months ago, " Honey, if you move again, we WON'T be going with you. " ) She meant it as a threat. I am silently singing the halleluiah chorus! Any other ideas or words of wisdom are welcomed. Thanks again, Finally Standing > In WTOAdultChildren1 , " rinkled " wrote: > > Hello finallystanding, > I have two children. They are 18 and 16 years old now. We rarely > visit my mil, but my husband has never taken them to see his parents > (his father died last June) without me. Taking the kids to visit his > parents without me was actually a " line in the sand " moment for me > and my husband. It happened in 1994. > > Here's how it went down: > One Saturday in December, my inlaws stopped in for an unexpected > visit. I happened to be out of the house when they arrived. When I > walked in the house, my husband, 4 year old son, 2 year old daughter, > and my inlaws were sitting in the living room. My fil immediately > stood up from his seat and said " let's go, Peg " , as he pushed passed > me without saying hello or making eye contact. My mil, waif that she > is, stood there looking confused and worried. > > I may have mentioned before that all the issues between us were my > fault as far as the inlaws are concerned. For instance things like > requesting that they refrain from dropping in uninvited was a huge > insult to them. From their point of view, I was keeping their son > (and THEIR grandchildren) away from them. From my point of view it > was an invasion of our privacy and an intrusion on our limited family > time on weekends. > > Anyway, after the fil walked passed me, I said, this is my house, you > don't get to be rude to me here. Maybe I should have bit my tongue > in front of the kids, but I didn't. And my fil went off. Hurling > insults and cursing and etc. And my kids started crying, so I took > the two of them upstairs, and told my husband to " get rid of them. " > > This occurred the weekend before Christmas. We were planning to go > visit them at their home about 2 hours away on the day after > Christmas. I told my husband, unless things change drastically > between now and then, we are not going. > > My husband, said, you don't have to go. > > NO, NO, NO! > > They don't get to be rude, disrespectful and horrible to me. They > don't get to act as though I am a nonperson, and then get unfettered > access to MY children without the " burden " of my presence. > > We had a huge fight. One of the worst ever. And then I guess he > realized at some point that his parents were not kind or loving > towards me. That he had to stop appeasing them and letting them " get > away with it " in order to keep them quiet and off his back. Because > it didn't realy keep them off his back, they just expected more and > more and more. We went NC with them for three glorious years. > > My fil sent me a letter a couple weeks later. He apolgized that my > feelings were hurt because I take things the wrong way, and other non- > apologetic excuses for his behavior. I was instructed to let bygones > be bygones. The kicker? He spelled my name wrong! > > On the one hand, it seems easier all around to stay home when your > husband takes them to see his parents. But I found the exculsion > unacceptable and it felt as if my husband was validating that " I " was > the problem if he did that. It hurts. > > Have you read " Toxic Inlaws " by Forward? Also, " Understanding > the Borderline Mother " , by Lawson? Gave me a lot of > insight into the situation with my husband. But he had to be ready, > willing. Head in the sand is so much more comfortable in this > instance. It is very frustrating if they choose to stay there when > you are ready to pull their heads out, and force them to look at the > sky. We've been married for 21 years now, and we are still handling > the fallout. > > (((((finallystanding))))) > > > > > > > > > > Does anyone out there have a mother-in-law with BPD? I have > > just > > > > read " Stop Walking on Eggshells " (Mason/Kreger), " Surviving a > > > > Borderline Parent " (Roth/Friedman), and " Toxic In-laws " > > (Forward). > > > > This is my first post. > > > > > > > > Thank you for any insight! > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 31, 2008 Report Share Posted July 31, 2008 Thanks , I hadn't thought of that. Any ideas of best communicating that to a husband, whom I truely love dearly, but doesn't yet know his head is still in the sand where his Nada is concerned? I'd love a guy's perspective on this (I am assuming you are a guy with the name , if not, I will just have to eat my pen. ;-) Finally Standing > > > He said they now know our boundaries. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 31, 2008 Report Share Posted July 31, 2008 Thanks JaneSoul, I agree, it may come down to the dreaded choice. My fear has been for years that he would choose her. Truely to his benefit, he loves me and adores the kids - a great father. . . but still an entangled and emeshed son. Somehow, I have felt there are parts of him emotionally that I don't have access to. Like he sits on the fence, trying to go between us - his two female obligations. I think what the kicker has been for me is that over ten years ago, I went NC with my father (NP). When I bring up my MIL or an issue and my frustration, he says, " Well, we aren't going to end up like you and your dad, not talking to each other. " I don't wish that on him either, but that has been enough to shut me up in the past. I see disengaged and emeshed as being two opposite polars, with 'healthy' somewhere in the middle. I am still afraid of his choice (or series of choices maybe?), and sometimes I wonder if he will resent and blame me if in the end he does choose me, because my MIL will do all she can to make him regret that decision, including spewing her 'reality' of the situation to his extended family. I just know that I truely think the kid's emotional (and physical, for the baby) well-being is at stake, and I feel like I am fighting for that. For me too, but honestly, I would probably still be swallowing MIL behavior and attitude if it were just me in the picture. That's hard to admit to myself sometimes. It just sounds pathetic, even as I write it. Thanks again, Finally Standing > > > > > > > > > > Does anyone out there have a mother-in-law with BPD? I have > > > just > > > > > read " Stop Walking on Eggshells " (Mason/Kreger) , " Surviving > a > > > > > Borderline Parent " (Roth/Friedman) , and " Toxic In-laws " > > > (Forward). > > > > > This is my first post. > > > > > > > > > > Thank you for any insight! > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 31, 2008 Report Share Posted July 31, 2008 I think my husband and his mother used me as the problem in the middle. I took the heat for him, because I was the one arguing, and she didn't have to face that her son avoids her at all costs! I understand why I allowed myself to get stuck in the middle like that, because I felt that he wouldn't (couldn't?) stand up to her. In most intimate relationships, there are going to be problems, misunderstandings or disagreements. I learned to examine my own behavior, and how it might be making the situation worse. And if you are involved with a sane and rational person, they'll probably examine their own part too. As far as my mil is concerned, I finally realized that I'm dealing with a personality disorder, no amount of arguing or discussion is going to do anything but make me dizzy. And feed her disorder. It is impossible to " fix " things with her, unless she decides to fix herself, and I don't see that ever happening. > > > > > > > > > > Does anyone out there have a mother-in-law with BPD? I have > > > just > > > > > read " Stop Walking on Eggshells " (Mason/Kreger) , " Surviving > a > > > > > Borderline Parent " (Roth/Friedman) , and " Toxic In-laws " > > > (Forward). > > > > > This is my first post. > > > > > > > > > > Thank you for any insight! > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 31, 2008 Report Share Posted July 31, 2008 --- I think you need some outside help on this. He really doesn't get it, and he's fighting to maintain the status quo, as you want to change it. Sounds like he's fearing the wrath of nada. It bothers me that he throws up your situation with your father. That sounds manipulative to me. As if you aren't credible or something, b/c of this, when really, it is irrelevant to the situation with his M. I think a therapist could help him to see the triangulating, his role, etc... Will he at least read the books? Joanna In WTOAdultChildren1 , " finallystanding " wrote: > > Thanks JaneSoul, I agree, it may come down to the dreaded choice. > My fear has been for years that he would choose her. Truely to his > benefit, he loves me and adores the kids - a great father. . . but > still an entangled and emeshed son. Somehow, I have felt there are > parts of him emotionally that I don't have access to. Like he sits > on the fence, trying to go between us - his two female obligations. > I think what the kicker has been for me is that over ten years ago, > I went NC with my father (NP). When I bring up my MIL or an issue > and my frustration, he says, " Well, we aren't going to end up like > you and your dad, not talking to each other. " I don't wish that on > him either, but that has been enough to shut me up in the past. I > see disengaged and emeshed as being two opposite polars, > with 'healthy' somewhere in the middle. I am still afraid of his > choice (or series of choices maybe?), and sometimes I wonder if he > will resent and blame me if in the end he does choose me, because my > MIL will do all she can to make him regret that decision, including > spewing her 'reality' of the situation to his extended family. I > just know that I truely think the kid's emotional (and physical, for > the baby) well-being is at stake, and I feel like I am fighting for > that. For me too, but honestly, I would probably still be > swallowing MIL behavior and attitude if it were just me in the > picture. That's hard to admit to myself sometimes. It just sounds > pathetic, even as I write it. > > Thanks again, > > Finally Standing > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Does anyone out there have a mother-in-law with BPD? I > have > > > > just > > > > > > read " Stop Walking on Eggshells " > (Mason/Kreger) , " Surviving > > a > > > > > > Borderline Parent " (Roth/Friedman) , and " Toxic In-laws " > > > > (Forward). > > > > > > This is my first post. > > > > > > > > > > > > Thank you for any insight! > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 31, 2008 Report Share Posted July 31, 2008 Thanks joanna, yes, I think he does fear the wrath of his Nada - he has seen it first hand for years, and avoided it for just as long. You really think it is manipulative when he mentions my situation with my father? I think I have taken the 'fear factor' I felt growing up with my Father (NP), and put it onto my husband - who is NOT NP, but I think in trying to be perfect and working hard to live up to expectations and trying to please (all of which are me, me, and me trying to somehow be good enough). I think I have put (transfered?) this on him and my MIL. I think in the beginning, I thought that if I could be a wonderful wife and wonderful DIL, that I could be a part of a close-knit family - not like my FOO, not close at all. After all, I am married to the chosen child. . . I have lived with the fear of not measuring up, or if the 'real' me stood up, everyone would leave the room. So, now I am beginning to wonder, who is the 'real' me? Am I in here somewhere? Do my thoughts count? I think I might be scared of having original thoughts. And then I beat myself up for digging this hole. Isn't this some kind of sick inside-out version of self-absorption? Maybe that is why I haven't seen his words as manipulation. I have asked him to read the books. Incidently, I have: Toxic Inlaws, Walking on Eggshells, and Surviving the Borderline Parent. The titles immediately put him on guard, but he has asked me to read some to him. Like last night, I read to him the 'sponging' concept, and told him I know I do this and it is a factor contributing to my GAD. I also try to leave the books in the bathroom, hoping he might be picking them up when I'm not looking. I see signs that he might be realizing his mother has some deep-seeded issues, but I don't know if he has yet made the jump to 'Borderline'. I am trying not to talk about it too much, hoping he will cook some thoughts on his own. Thanks again, Finally Standing > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Does anyone out there have a mother-in-law with BPD? I > > have > > > > > just > > > > > > > read " Stop Walking on Eggshells " > > (Mason/Kreger) , " Surviving > > > a > > > > > > > Borderline Parent " (Roth/Friedman) , and " Toxic In- laws " > > > > > (Forward). > > > > > > > This is my first post. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Thank you for any insight! > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 31, 2008 Report Share Posted July 31, 2008 --- well, I think it's manipulative in that it stops you in your tracks and distracts you from the issue at hand...it also makes me think that he is afraid NC is the only other option re: his nada. he's playing his part in maintaining the status quo. i can't imagine being the chosen child, but i'm thinking it's a role that you have to embrace fully to maintain - never looking closely at problems, lest you fall off your pedestal... have you gone to a therapist on your own? it would probably help to get things sorted out. as you start to look at things, everyone is going to dig in their heels... it sounds like you've done very well, coming from such a family. of course you wanted a close relationship with in-laws. it sounds like if just took you a while to realize how whacked it is. Joanna In WTOAdultChildren1 , " finallystanding " wrote: > > Thanks joanna, yes, I think he does fear the wrath of his Nada - he > has seen it first hand for years, and avoided it for just as long. > You really think it is manipulative when he mentions my situation > with my father? I think I have taken the 'fear factor' I felt > growing up with my Father (NP), and put it onto my husband - who is > NOT NP, but I think in trying to be perfect and working hard to live > up to expectations and trying to please (all of which are me, me, > and me trying to somehow be good enough). I think I have put > (transfered?) this on him and my MIL. I think in the beginning, I > thought that if I could be a wonderful wife and wonderful DIL, that > I could be a part of a close-knit family - not like my FOO, not > close at all. After all, I am married to the chosen child. . . I > have lived with the fear of not measuring up, or if the 'real' me > stood up, everyone would leave the room. So, now I am beginning to > wonder, who is the 'real' me? Am I in here somewhere? Do my > thoughts count? I think I might be scared of having original > thoughts. And then I beat myself up for digging this hole. Isn't > this some kind of sick inside-out version of self-absorption? Maybe > that is why I haven't seen his words as manipulation. I have asked > him to read the books. Incidently, I have: Toxic Inlaws, Walking on > Eggshells, and Surviving the Borderline Parent. The titles > immediately put him on guard, but he has asked me to read some to > him. Like last night, I read to him the 'sponging' concept, and > told him I know I do this and it is a factor contributing to my > GAD. I also try to leave the books in the bathroom, hoping he might > be picking them up when I'm not looking. I see signs that he might > be realizing his mother has some deep-seeded issues, but I don't > know if he has yet made the jump to 'Borderline'. I am trying not > to talk about it too much, hoping he will cook some thoughts on his > own. > > Thanks again, > > Finally Standing > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Does anyone out there have a mother-in-law with BPD? I > > > have > > > > > > just > > > > > > > > read " Stop Walking on Eggshells " > > > (Mason/Kreger) , " Surviving > > > > a > > > > > > > > Borderline Parent " (Roth/Friedman) , and " Toxic In- > laws " > > > > > > (Forward). > > > > > > > > This is my first post. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Thank you for any insight! > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 31, 2008 Report Share Posted July 31, 2008 Thanks Joanna - It does stop me in my tracks when he says that, and it does tend to shut me right up. Hummm. I asked him to go with me to a therapist again this morning. He didn't say no this time, but not a yes either. The first time I asked was a week or so ago. If he doesn't agree by the end of the weekend, I will go ahead and make myself an appointment. I appreciate your honesty. . . I am afraid there is no easy fix, and probably will get bumpier before it gets any better. Finally Standing > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Does anyone out there have a mother-in-law with BPD? > I > > > > have > > > > > > > just > > > > > > > > > read " Stop Walking on Eggshells " > > > > (Mason/Kreger) , " Surviving > > > > > a > > > > > > > > > Borderline Parent " (Roth/Friedman) , and " Toxic In- > > laws " > > > > > > > (Forward). > > > > > > > > > This is my first post. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Thank you for any insight! > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 1, 2008 Report Share Posted August 1, 2008 Thanks ! Bad news - HUGE fight last night. Good news - we are going to see a counselor, together. He wanted to take the kids tonight to MIL's house to stay the night. (After having transmission problems and asking his parents to borrow one of their four cars, driving it home from work. Am I not his wife? Could he not have called me to come and pick him up? Why does he continue to call Mom to bail him out? And who knows what they talked about?!? Is it petty that I would be bothered by what they talked about?) I stood my ground and said, " absolutely not " . It got bad. He asked me to leave, then changed his mind when I started to go upstairs and help the kids pack. No way I was leaving them behind! The counselor also specializes in Marriage and Family, so I am hoping he will be insightful. Thanks to all who have written. I am so grateful and re-read these posts over and over. It helps me remember I'm not the one who is crazy. A co-dependant textbook, maybe, but not crazy. Finally Standing > > > > > > > > > > Does anyone out there have a mother-in-law with BPD? I have > > > just > > > > > read " Stop Walking on Eggshells " (Mason/Kreger) , " Surviving > a > > > > > Borderline Parent " (Roth/Friedman) , and " Toxic In-laws " > > > (Forward). > > > > > This is my first post. > > > > > > > > > > Thank you for any insight! > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.