Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

RE: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Pam,

With all due respect, I agree with Jan and Kathy.

Have you actually read the proposed health care bill ?

I have been reading through it (it's long, but easily accessible

on-line)...and there are major reasons to be concerned if it passes.

I am not against doing something for the uninsured. But I am totally

against the way it is being done.

You suggested that Kathy join the discussion " armed with correct

information " . Perhaps you should read the bill so that you will have the

correct

information.

Audley, M.S., R.D., L.D.

Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, Ohio

In a message dated 8/13/2009 2:18:39 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time,

pcharney@... writes:

Kathy,

With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

yet we have subpar results.

I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

becoming one of those individuals.

To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

" do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

get Congress to give up a perk or two.

How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

child in the U.S.?

Pam Charney PhD, RD

Clinical Coordinator

Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

Nutrition Sciences Program

School of Public Health and Community Medicine

Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

Affiliate Associate Professor

School of Pharmacy

MS Student

Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

School of Nursing

University of Washington

Seattle, WA

_charnepa@..._ (mailto:charnepa@...)

_http://www.linkedinhttp://www.linkeht_

(http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney)

" The person who says it can't be done should not

interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

> Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with the

> President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

> it

> works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

> overhaul

> the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

> not afford

> it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

> those who

> do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10 million

> working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not just

> address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

> realize there are many problems with our current system however we

> still do

> have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

> and it

> is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

> foreign

> country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

> is

> being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

> drop a

> couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

> frequent

> visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

> recently had

> the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

> anyone

> running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

>

> Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

> to the

> Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

>

> Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

>

> Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

>

> Natural Health Concepts

>

> Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

>

> Complementary & Alternative Medicine

>

> Bios Life Slim

>

> Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

>

> Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

>

> www.bioslifeslim/ www.biosl

>

> _____

>

> From: _rd-usa@...-_ (mailto:rd-usa )

[mailto:_rd-usa@...-_ (mailto:rd-usa ) ] On

> Behalf Of

> _Dineright4@..._ (mailto:Dineright4@...)

> Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

> To: _rd-usa@...-_ (mailto:rd-usa )

> Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>

> FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

>

> YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL) DURING

> THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

>

> " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

> CARE

> PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

> REST OF

> US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

>

> THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

> NOT TO

> ANSWER IT !!!...

>

> IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

> THERE

> RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

>

> AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

> HEALTH

> CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

> ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

>

> SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

> NOT

> GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...? GOOD ENOUGH FOR O

> PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

> TOTALLY

> WRONG

> !!!!!

>

> PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

> EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

> WASHINGTON

> " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

>

> IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

> OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

> POLITICIANS

> MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

>

> Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

> Director of Medical Nutrition

> Signet Diagnostic Corporation

>

> Fax:

> DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%mailto:Di> com

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pam,

With all due respect, I agree with Jan and Kathy.

Have you actually read the proposed health care bill ?

I have been reading through it (it's long, but easily accessible

on-line)...and there are major reasons to be concerned if it passes.

I am not against doing something for the uninsured. But I am totally

against the way it is being done.

You suggested that Kathy join the discussion " armed with correct

information " . Perhaps you should read the bill so that you will have the

correct

information.

Audley, M.S., R.D., L.D.

Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, Ohio

In a message dated 8/13/2009 2:18:39 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time,

pcharney@... writes:

Kathy,

With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

yet we have subpar results.

I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

becoming one of those individuals.

To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

" do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

get Congress to give up a perk or two.

How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

child in the U.S.?

Pam Charney PhD, RD

Clinical Coordinator

Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

Nutrition Sciences Program

School of Public Health and Community Medicine

Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

Affiliate Associate Professor

School of Pharmacy

MS Student

Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

School of Nursing

University of Washington

Seattle, WA

_charnepa@..._ (mailto:charnepa@...)

_http://www.linkedinhttp://www.linkeht_

(http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney)

" The person who says it can't be done should not

interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

> Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with the

> President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

> it

> works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

> overhaul

> the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

> not afford

> it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

> those who

> do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10 million

> working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not just

> address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

> realize there are many problems with our current system however we

> still do

> have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

> and it

> is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

> foreign

> country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

> is

> being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

> drop a

> couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

> frequent

> visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

> recently had

> the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

> anyone

> running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

>

> Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

> to the

> Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

>

> Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

>

> Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

>

> Natural Health Concepts

>

> Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

>

> Complementary & Alternative Medicine

>

> Bios Life Slim

>

> Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

>

> Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

>

> www.bioslifeslim/ www.biosl

>

> _____

>

> From: _rd-usa@...-_ (mailto:rd-usa )

[mailto:_rd-usa@...-_ (mailto:rd-usa ) ] On

> Behalf Of

> _Dineright4@..._ (mailto:Dineright4@...)

> Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

> To: _rd-usa@...-_ (mailto:rd-usa )

> Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>

> FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

>

> YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL) DURING

> THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

>

> " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

> CARE

> PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

> REST OF

> US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

>

> THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

> NOT TO

> ANSWER IT !!!...

>

> IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

> THERE

> RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

>

> AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

> HEALTH

> CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

> ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

>

> SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

> NOT

> GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...? GOOD ENOUGH FOR O

> PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

> TOTALLY

> WRONG

> !!!!!

>

> PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

> EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

> WASHINGTON

> " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

>

> IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

> OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

> POLITICIANS

> MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

>

> Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

> Director of Medical Nutrition

> Signet Diagnostic Corporation

>

> Fax:

> DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%mailto:Di> com

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with the

President should be placed on this new health care program first. If it

works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why overhaul

the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can not afford

it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and those who

do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10 million

working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not just

address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

realize there are many problems with our current system however we still do

have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country, and it

is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other foreign

country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone is

being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they drop a

couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a frequent

visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic recently had

the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see anyone

running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22 to the

Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

Natural Health Concepts

Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

Complementary & Alternative Medicine

Bios Life Slim

Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

_____

From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On Behalf Of

Dineright4@...

Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

To: rd-usa

Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL) DURING

THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

" MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH CARE

PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE REST OF

US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE NOT TO

ANSWER IT !!!...

IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND THERE

RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY HEALTH

CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS NOT

GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS TOTALLY

WRONG

!!!!!

PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE WASHINGTON

" ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING POLITICIANS

MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

Director of Medical Nutrition

Signet Diagnostic Corporation

Fax:

DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com> com

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with the

President should be placed on this new health care program first. If it

works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why overhaul

the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can not afford

it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and those who

do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10 million

working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not just

address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

realize there are many problems with our current system however we still do

have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country, and it

is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other foreign

country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone is

being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they drop a

couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a frequent

visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic recently had

the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see anyone

running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22 to the

Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

Natural Health Concepts

Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

Complementary & Alternative Medicine

Bios Life Slim

Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

_____

From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On Behalf Of

Dineright4@...

Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

To: rd-usa

Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL) DURING

THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

" MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH CARE

PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE REST OF

US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE NOT TO

ANSWER IT !!!...

IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND THERE

RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY HEALTH

CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS NOT

GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS TOTALLY

WRONG

!!!!!

PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE WASHINGTON

" ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING POLITICIANS

MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

Director of Medical Nutrition

Signet Diagnostic Corporation

Fax:

DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com> com

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kathy,

With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

yet we have subpar results.

I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

becoming one of those individuals.

To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

" do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

get Congress to give up a perk or two.

How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

child in the U.S.?

Pam Charney PhD, RD

Clinical Coordinator

Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

Nutrition Sciences Program

School of Public Health and Community Medicine

Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

Affiliate Associate Professor

School of Pharmacy

MS Student

Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

School of Nursing

University of Washington

Seattle, WA

charnepa@...

http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney

" The person who says it can't be done should not

interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

> Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with the

> President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

> it

> works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

> overhaul

> the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

> not afford

> it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

> those who

> do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10 million

> working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not just

> address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

> realize there are many problems with our current system however we

> still do

> have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

> and it

> is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

> foreign

> country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

> is

> being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

> drop a

> couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

> frequent

> visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

> recently had

> the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

> anyone

> running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

>

> Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

> to the

> Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

>

> Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

>

> Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

>

> Natural Health Concepts

>

> Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

>

> Complementary & Alternative Medicine

>

> Bios Life Slim

>

> Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

>

> Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

>

> www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

>

> _____

>

> From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On

> Behalf Of

> Dineright4@...

> Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

> To: rd-usa

> Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>

> FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

>

> YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL) DURING

> THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

>

> " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

> CARE

> PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

> REST OF

> US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

>

> THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

> NOT TO

> ANSWER IT !!!...

>

> IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

> THERE

> RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

>

> AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

> HEALTH

> CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

> ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

>

> SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

> NOT

> GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

> PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

> TOTALLY

> WRONG

> !!!!!

>

> PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

> EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

> WASHINGTON

> " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

>

> IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

> OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

> POLITICIANS

> MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

>

> Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

> Director of Medical Nutrition

> Signet Diagnostic Corporation

>

> Fax:

> DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com> com

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kathy,

With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

yet we have subpar results.

I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

becoming one of those individuals.

To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

" do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

get Congress to give up a perk or two.

How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

child in the U.S.?

Pam Charney PhD, RD

Clinical Coordinator

Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

Nutrition Sciences Program

School of Public Health and Community Medicine

Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

Affiliate Associate Professor

School of Pharmacy

MS Student

Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

School of Nursing

University of Washington

Seattle, WA

charnepa@...

http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney

" The person who says it can't be done should not

interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

> Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with the

> President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

> it

> works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

> overhaul

> the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

> not afford

> it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

> those who

> do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10 million

> working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not just

> address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

> realize there are many problems with our current system however we

> still do

> have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

> and it

> is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

> foreign

> country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

> is

> being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

> drop a

> couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

> frequent

> visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

> recently had

> the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

> anyone

> running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

>

> Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

> to the

> Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

>

> Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

>

> Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

>

> Natural Health Concepts

>

> Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

>

> Complementary & Alternative Medicine

>

> Bios Life Slim

>

> Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

>

> Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

>

> www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

>

> _____

>

> From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On

> Behalf Of

> Dineright4@...

> Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

> To: rd-usa

> Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>

> FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

>

> YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL) DURING

> THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

>

> " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

> CARE

> PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

> REST OF

> US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

>

> THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

> NOT TO

> ANSWER IT !!!...

>

> IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

> THERE

> RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

>

> AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

> HEALTH

> CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

> ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

>

> SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

> NOT

> GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

> PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

> TOTALLY

> WRONG

> !!!!!

>

> PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

> EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

> WASHINGTON

> " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

>

> IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

> OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

> POLITICIANS

> MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

>

> Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

> Director of Medical Nutrition

> Signet Diagnostic Corporation

>

> Fax:

> DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com> com

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kathy,

With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

yet we have subpar results.

I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

becoming one of those individuals.

To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

" do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

get Congress to give up a perk or two.

How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

child in the U.S.?

Pam Charney PhD, RD

Clinical Coordinator

Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

Nutrition Sciences Program

School of Public Health and Community Medicine

Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

Affiliate Associate Professor

School of Pharmacy

MS Student

Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

School of Nursing

University of Washington

Seattle, WA

charnepa@...

http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney

" The person who says it can't be done should not

interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

> Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with the

> President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

> it

> works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

> overhaul

> the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

> not afford

> it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

> those who

> do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10 million

> working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not just

> address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

> realize there are many problems with our current system however we

> still do

> have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

> and it

> is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

> foreign

> country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

> is

> being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

> drop a

> couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

> frequent

> visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

> recently had

> the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

> anyone

> running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

>

> Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

> to the

> Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

>

> Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

>

> Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

>

> Natural Health Concepts

>

> Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

>

> Complementary & Alternative Medicine

>

> Bios Life Slim

>

> Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

>

> Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

>

> www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

>

> _____

>

> From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On

> Behalf Of

> Dineright4@...

> Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

> To: rd-usa

> Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>

> FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

>

> YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL) DURING

> THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

>

> " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

> CARE

> PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

> REST OF

> US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

>

> THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

> NOT TO

> ANSWER IT !!!...

>

> IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

> THERE

> RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

>

> AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

> HEALTH

> CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

> ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

>

> SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

> NOT

> GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

> PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

> TOTALLY

> WRONG

> !!!!!

>

> PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

> EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

> WASHINGTON

> " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

>

> IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

> OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

> POLITICIANS

> MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

>

> Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

> Director of Medical Nutrition

> Signet Diagnostic Corporation

>

> Fax:

> DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com> com

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Very well said Pam.

I can't believe how many RD's who work in healthcare system honestly feel

that

our system is the best healthcare in the world? When did this country

become

" what's in it for me? "

I am lucky to be offered decent healthcare at my job. But I had to pay $100

more

dollars a month this year to keep it... my raise didn't even cover that.

But at least

I have health insurance.

It's truly sad that we live in a system where having healthcare depends on

you

needing to have a job. What about consultants, say RD's? Wouldn' t it be

nice if

we didn't have to worry about keeping FT employment to have health

benefits...think

about all the opportunities that would open up to us for doing different

things.

>

>

> Kathy,

>

> With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

> health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

> perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

> What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

> other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

> yet we have subpar results.

>

> I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

> uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

> current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

> becoming one of those individuals.

>

> To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

> the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

> and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

> Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

> neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

> " do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

> their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

> Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

> get Congress to give up a perk or two.

>

> How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

> a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

> child in the U.S.?

>

> Pam Charney PhD, RD

> Clinical Coordinator

> Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

> Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

> Nutrition Sciences Program

> School of Public Health and Community Medicine

> Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

>

> Affiliate Associate Professor

> School of Pharmacy

>

> MS Student

> Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

> School of Nursing

>

> University of Washington

> Seattle, WA

> charnepa@... <charnepa%40u.washington.edu>

> http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney

>

> " The person who says it can't be done should not

> interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

>

>

>

>

> > Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with the

> > President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

> > it

> > works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

> > overhaul

> > the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

> > not afford

> > it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

> > those who

> > do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10 million

> > working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not just

> > address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

> > realize there are many problems with our current system however we

> > still do

> > have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

> > and it

> > is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

> > foreign

> > country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

> > is

> > being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

> > drop a

> > couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

> > frequent

> > visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

> > recently had

> > the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

> > anyone

> > running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

> >

> > Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

> > to the

> > Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

> >

> > Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

> >

> > Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

> >

> > Natural Health Concepts

> >

> > Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

> >

> > Complementary & Alternative Medicine

> >

> > Bios Life Slim

> >

> > Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

> >

> > Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

> >

> > www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

> >

> > _____

> >

> > From: rd-usa <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> [mailto:

> rd-usa <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>] On

> > Behalf Of

> > Dineright4@... <Dineright4%40aol.com>

> > Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

> > To: rd-usa <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

> > Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

> >

> > FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

> >

> > YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL) DURING

> > THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

> >

> > " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

> > CARE

> > PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

> > REST OF

> > US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

> >

> > THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

> > NOT TO

> > ANSWER IT !!!...

> >

> > IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

> > THERE

> > RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

> >

> > AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

> > HEALTH

> > CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

> > ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

> >

> > SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

> > NOT

> > GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

> > PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

> > TOTALLY

> > WRONG

> > !!!!!

> >

> > PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

> > EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

> > WASHINGTON

> > " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

> >

> > IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

> > OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

> > POLITICIANS

> > MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

> >

> > Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

> > Director of Medical Nutrition

> > Signet Diagnostic Corporation

> >

> > Fax:

> > DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com <DineRight4%2540aol.com>>

> com

> >

> >

Link to comment
Share on other sites

,

Don't assume that I haven't.

It's over 1000 pages. I haven't gotten through it all, not by a long

shot. However, it is rather presumptuous on your part to assume that I

haven't read it or am somehow less informed than you might be. That's

the type of behavior that we need to avoid and engage in meaningful

discussion based on facts. There are parts of the bill that I don't

like. However, I'm not going to give up on reform just because I

personally don't like parts of the bill. That's the beauty of

Democracy. However, a true democracy requires that folks be ready to

compromise in order to ensure that basic needs of all are met.

Regards,

pam

Pam Charney PhD, RD

Clinical Coordinator

Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

Nutrition Sciences Program

School of Public Health and Community Medicine

Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

Affiliate Associate Professor

School of Pharmacy

MS Student

Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

School of Nursing

University of Washington

Seattle, WA

charnepa@...

http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney

" The person who says it can't be done should not

interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

> Pam,

>

> With all due respect, I agree with Jan and Kathy.

>

> Have you actually read the proposed health care bill ?

>

> I have been reading through it (it's long, but easily accessible

> on-line)...and there are major reasons to be concerned if it passes.

>

> I am not against doing something for the uninsured. But I am totally

> against the way it is being done.

>

> You suggested that Kathy join the discussion " armed with correct

> information " . Perhaps you should read the bill so that you will have

> the correct

> information.

>

> Audley, M.S., R.D., L.D.

> Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, Ohio

>

>

>

>

>

>

> In a message dated 8/13/2009 2:18:39 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time,

> pcharney@... writes:

>

> Kathy,

>

> With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

> health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

> perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

> What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

> other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

> yet we have subpar results.

>

> I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

> uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

> current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

> becoming one of those individuals.

>

> To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

> the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

> and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

> Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

> neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

> " do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

> their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

> Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

> get Congress to give up a perk or two.

>

> How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

> a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

> child in the U.S.?

>

> Pam Charney PhD, RD

> Clinical Coordinator

> Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

> Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

> Nutrition Sciences Program

> School of Public Health and Community Medicine

> Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

>

> Affiliate Associate Professor

> School of Pharmacy

>

> MS Student

> Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

> School of Nursing

>

> University of Washington

> Seattle, WA

> _charnepa@..._ (mailto:charnepa@...)

> _http://www.linkedinhttp://www.linkeht_

> (http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney)

>

> " The person who says it can't be done should not

> interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

>

>

>

> > Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with

> the

> > President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

> > it

> > works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

> > overhaul

> > the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

> > not afford

> > it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

> > those who

> > do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10

> million

> > working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not

> just

> > address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

> > realize there are many problems with our current system however we

> > still do

> > have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

> > and it

> > is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

> > foreign

> > country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

> > is

> > being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

> > drop a

> > couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

> > frequent

> > visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

> > recently had

> > the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

> > anyone

> > running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

> >

> > Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

> > to the

> > Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

> >

> > Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

> >

> > Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

> >

> > Natural Health Concepts

> >

> > Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

> >

> > Complementary & Alternative Medicine

> >

> > Bios Life Slim

> >

> > Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

> >

> > Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

> >

> > www.bioslifeslim/ www.biosl

> >

> > _____

> >

> > From: _rd-usa@...-_ (mailto:rd-usa )

> [mailto:_rd-usa@...-_ (mailto:rd-usa ) ] On

> > Behalf Of

> > _Dineright4@..._ (mailto:Dineright4@...)

> > Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

> > To: _rd-usa@...-_ (mailto:rd-usa )

> > Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

> >

> > FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

> >

> > YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL)

> DURING

> > THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

> >

> > " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

> > CARE

> > PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

> > REST OF

> > US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

> >

> > THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

> > NOT TO

> > ANSWER IT !!!...

> >

> > IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

> > THERE

> > RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

> >

> > AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

> > HEALTH

> > CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

> > ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

> >

> > SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

> > NOT

> > GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...? GOOD ENOUGH FOR O

> > PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

> > TOTALLY

> > WRONG

> > !!!!!

> >

> > PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

> > EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

> > WASHINGTON

> > " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

> >

> > IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

> > OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

> > POLITICIANS

> > MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

> >

> > Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

> > Director of Medical Nutrition

> > Signet Diagnostic Corporation

> >

> > Fax:

> > DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%mailto:Di> com

> >

> >

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If I could opt out of my State provided health care insurance and use the same

money for HSAs and catastrophic care, I would. We DO have the best healthcare in

the world. I don't see anyone leaving the country to get better care or faster

service. I see just the opposite. If we could get the government out of our

current health care, it would be dramatically better. What does government run

better than the private sector? Amtrak, postal service? Of course not. They

don't have to make a profit. That's why the private option will go away. They

won't be able to compete. The government can just take all the money they need

from the taxpayer to keep it going, poor service or not.

" If you think health care is expensive now, wait until you see what it costs

when it's free. " --P.J. O'Rourke

W. Rowell, RD, LN

Montana State Hospital, Warm Spring, MT

Consultant Dietitian, Long Term Care

Certified LEAP Therapist

________________________________

From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On Behalf Of Jen

Zingaro

Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 12:58 PM

To: rd-usa

Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

Very well said Pam.

I can't believe how many RD's who work in healthcare system honestly feel

that

our system is the best healthcare in the world? When did this country

become

" what's in it for me? "

I am lucky to be offered decent healthcare at my job. But I had to pay $100

more

dollars a month this year to keep it... my raise didn't even cover that.

But at least

I have health insurance.

It's truly sad that we live in a system where having healthcare depends on

you

needing to have a job. What about consultants, say RD's? Wouldn' t it be

nice if

we didn't have to worry about keeping FT employment to have health

benefits...think

about all the opportunities that would open up to us for doing different

things.

On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 2:14 PM, Pam Charney

<pcharney@...<mailto:pcharney%40mac.com>> wrote:

>

>

> Kathy,

>

> With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

> health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

> perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

> What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

> other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

> yet we have subpar results.

>

> I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

> uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

> current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

> becoming one of those individuals.

>

> To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

> the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

> and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

> Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

> neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

> " do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

> their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

> Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

> get Congress to give up a perk or two.

>

> How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

> a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

> child in the U.S.?

>

> Pam Charney PhD, RD

> Clinical Coordinator

> Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

> Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

> Nutrition Sciences Program

> School of Public Health and Community Medicine

> Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

>

> Affiliate Associate Professor

> School of Pharmacy

>

> MS Student

> Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

> School of Nursing

>

> University of Washington

> Seattle, WA

> charnepa@...<mailto:charnepa%40u.washington.edu>

<charnepa%40u.washington.edu>

> http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney

>

> " The person who says it can't be done should not

> interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

>

>

>

>

> > Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with the

> > President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

> > it

> > works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

> > overhaul

> > the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

> > not afford

> > it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

> > those who

> > do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10 million

> > working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not just

> > address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

> > realize there are many problems with our current system however we

> > still do

> > have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

> > and it

> > is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

> > foreign

> > country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

> > is

> > being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

> > drop a

> > couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

> > frequent

> > visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

> > recently had

> > the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

> > anyone

> > running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

> >

> > Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

> > to the

> > Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

> >

> > Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

> >

> > Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

> >

> > Natural Health Concepts

> >

> > Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

> >

> > Complementary & Alternative Medicine

> >

> > Bios Life Slim

> >

> > Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

> >

> > Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

> >

> > www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

> >

> > _____

> >

> > From: rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> [mailto:

> rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>] On

> > Behalf Of

> > Dineright4@...<mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com> <Dineright4%40aol.com>

> > Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

> > To: rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

> > Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

> >

> > FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

> >

> > YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL) DURING

> > THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

> >

> > " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

> > CARE

> > PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

> > REST OF

> > US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

> >

> > THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

> > NOT TO

> > ANSWER IT !!!...

> >

> > IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

> > THERE

> > RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

> >

> > AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

> > HEALTH

> > CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

> > ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

> >

> > SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

> > NOT

> > GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

> > PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

> > TOTALLY

> > WRONG

> > !!!!!

> >

> > PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

> > EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

> > WASHINGTON

> > " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

> >

> > IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

> > OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

> > POLITICIANS

> > MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

> >

> > Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

> > Director of Medical Nutrition

> > Signet Diagnostic Corporation

> >

> > Fax:

> > DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com <DineRight4%2540aol.com>>

> com

> >

> >

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oh, and I used to work for County government. It was the best healthcare

plan that I ever had.

> It's been said before then. Let those who need the public option have at

> it.

> If it's not competitive, it won't be popular and then health insurance

> companies don't

> have to worry about it. Why are we as a free market enterprise afraid of

> it. It's just

> another option for people to have. You don't have to have it. It's not

> going to be

> free for others, it's just another healthcare option?

>

> I don't know if you can really compare the post office and amtrak. It's

> sort of like apples

> and oranges. Fedex and UPS do just fine, and then there's the post office

> that you can use

> if you want to. I personally like the service at the post office. It's

> not for everyone but it's an option.

>

> I'm certain we'll all be using Medicare at some point? It's not a perfect

> system, but it's better than trying

> to find private insurance on your own when you are older and have

> preexisitng conditions.

>

>

>

>>

>>

>> If I could opt out of my State provided health care insurance and use the

>> same money for HSAs and catastrophic care, I would. We DO have the best

>> healthcare in the world. I don't see anyone leaving the country to get

>> better care or faster service. I see just the opposite. If we could get the

>> government out of our current health care, it would be dramatically better.

>> What does government run better than the private sector? Amtrak, postal

>> service? Of course not. They don't have to make a profit. That's why the

>> private option will go away. They won't be able to compete. The government

>> can just take all the money they need from the taxpayer to keep it going,

>> poor service or not.

>>

>> " If you think health care is expensive now, wait until you see what it

>> costs when it's free. " --P.J. O'Rourke

>>

>> W. Rowell, RD, LN

>> Montana State Hospital, Warm Spring, MT

>> Consultant Dietitian, Long Term Care

>> Certified LEAP Therapist

>>

>> ________________________________

>> From: rd-usa <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> [mailto:

>> rd-usa <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>] On Behalf Of Jen

>> Zingaro

>> Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 12:58 PM

>> To: rd-usa <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

>> Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>>

>> Very well said Pam.

>>

>> I can't believe how many RD's who work in healthcare system honestly feel

>> that

>> our system is the best healthcare in the world? When did this country

>> become

>> " what's in it for me? "

>>

>> I am lucky to be offered decent healthcare at my job. But I had to pay

>> $100

>> more

>> dollars a month this year to keep it... my raise didn't even cover that.

>> But at least

>> I have health insurance.

>>

>> It's truly sad that we live in a system where having healthcare depends on

>> you

>> needing to have a job. What about consultants, say RD's? Wouldn' t it be

>> nice if

>> we didn't have to worry about keeping FT employment to have health

>> benefits...think

>> about all the opportunities that would open up to us for doing different

>> things.

>>

>> On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 2:14 PM, Pam Charney

<pcharney@...<pcharney%40mac.com>

>> <mailto:pcharney%40mac.com <pcharney%2540mac.com>>> wrote:

>>

>> >

>> >

>> > Kathy,

>> >

>> > With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

>> > health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

>> > perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

>> > What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

>> > other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

>> > yet we have subpar results.

>> >

>> > I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

>> > uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

>> > current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

>> > becoming one of those individuals.

>> >

>> > To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

>> > the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

>> > and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

>> > Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

>> > neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

>> > " do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

>> > their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

>> > Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

>> > get Congress to give up a perk or two.

>> >

>> > How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

>> > a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

>> > child in the U.S.?

>> >

>> > Pam Charney PhD, RD

>> > Clinical Coordinator

>> > Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

>> > Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

>> > Nutrition Sciences Program

>> > School of Public Health and Community Medicine

>> > Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

>> >

>> > Affiliate Associate Professor

>> > School of Pharmacy

>> >

>> > MS Student

>> > Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

>> > School of Nursing

>> >

>> > University of Washington

>> > Seattle, WA

>> > charnepa@... <charnepa%40u.washington.edu><mailto:

>> charnepa%40u.washington.edu <charnepa%2540u.washington.edu>> <charnepa%

>> 40u.washington.edu>

>>

>> > http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney

>> >

>> > " The person who says it can't be done should not

>> > interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

>> >

>> >

>> >

>> >

>> > > Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with the

>> > > President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

>> > > it

>> > > works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

>> > > overhaul

>> > > the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

>> > > not afford

>> > > it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

>> > > those who

>> > > do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10 million

>> > > working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not just

>> > > address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

>> > > realize there are many problems with our current system however we

>> > > still do

>> > > have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

>> > > and it

>> > > is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

>> > > foreign

>> > > country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

>> > > is

>> > > being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

>> > > drop a

>> > > couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

>> > > frequent

>> > > visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

>> > > recently had

>> > > the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

>> > > anyone

>> > > running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

>> > >

>> > > Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

>> > > to the

>> > > Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

>> > >

>> > > Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

>> > >

>> > > Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

>> > >

>> > > Natural Health Concepts

>> > >

>> > > Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

>> > >

>> > > Complementary & Alternative Medicine

>> > >

>> > > Bios Life Slim

>> > >

>> > > Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

>> > >

>> > > Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

>> > >

>> > > www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

>> > >

>> > > _____

>> > >

>> > > From: rd-usa <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

>> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

>> 40yahoogroups.com> [mailto:

>> > rd-usa <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

>> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

>> 40yahoogroups.com>] On

>> > > Behalf Of

>> > > Dineright4@...

<Dineright4%40aol.com><mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com<Dineright4%2540aol.com>>

>> <Dineright4%40aol.com>

>> > > Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

>> > > To: rd-usa <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

>> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

>> 40yahoogroups.com>

>>

>> > > Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>> > >

>> > > FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

>> > >

>> > > YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL) DURING

>> > > THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

>> > >

>> > > " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

>> > > CARE

>> > > PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

>> > > REST OF

>> > > US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

>> > >

>> > > THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

>> > > NOT TO

>> > > ANSWER IT !!!...

>> > >

>> > > IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

>> > > THERE

>> > > RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

>> > >

>> > > AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

>> > > HEALTH

>> > > CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

>> > > ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

>> > >

>> > > SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

>> > > NOT

>> > > GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

>> > > PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

>> > > TOTALLY

>> > > WRONG

>> > > !!!!!

>> > >

>> > > PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

>> > > EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

>> > > WASHINGTON

>> > > " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

>> > >

>> > > IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

>> > > OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

>> > > POLITICIANS

>> > > MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

>> > >

>> > > Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

>> > > Director of Medical Nutrition

>> > > Signet Diagnostic Corporation

>> > >

>> > > Fax:

>> > > DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com

<DineRight4%2540aol.com><DineRight4%

>> 2540aol.com>>

>> > com

>> > >

>> > >

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's been said before then. Let those who need the public option have at

it.

If it's not competitive, it won't be popular and then health insurance

companies don't

have to worry about it. Why are we as a free market enterprise afraid of

it. It's just

another option for people to have. You don't have to have it. It's not

going to be

free for others, it's just another healthcare option?

I don't know if you can really compare the post office and amtrak. It's sort

of like apples

and oranges. Fedex and UPS do just fine, and then there's the post office

that you can use

if you want to. I personally like the service at the post office. It's not

for everyone but it's an option.

I'm certain we'll all be using Medicare at some point? It's not a perfect

system, but it's better than trying

to find private insurance on your own when you are older and have

preexisitng conditions.

>

>

> If I could opt out of my State provided health care insurance and use the

> same money for HSAs and catastrophic care, I would. We DO have the best

> healthcare in the world. I don't see anyone leaving the country to get

> better care or faster service. I see just the opposite. If we could get the

> government out of our current health care, it would be dramatically better.

> What does government run better than the private sector? Amtrak, postal

> service? Of course not. They don't have to make a profit. That's why the

> private option will go away. They won't be able to compete. The government

> can just take all the money they need from the taxpayer to keep it going,

> poor service or not.

>

> " If you think health care is expensive now, wait until you see what it

> costs when it's free. " --P.J. O'Rourke

>

> W. Rowell, RD, LN

> Montana State Hospital, Warm Spring, MT

> Consultant Dietitian, Long Term Care

> Certified LEAP Therapist

>

> ________________________________

> From: rd-usa <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> [mailto:

> rd-usa <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>] On Behalf Of Jen

> Zingaro

> Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 12:58 PM

> To: rd-usa <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

> Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>

> Very well said Pam.

>

> I can't believe how many RD's who work in healthcare system honestly feel

> that

> our system is the best healthcare in the world? When did this country

> become

> " what's in it for me? "

>

> I am lucky to be offered decent healthcare at my job. But I had to pay $100

> more

> dollars a month this year to keep it... my raise didn't even cover that.

> But at least

> I have health insurance.

>

> It's truly sad that we live in a system where having healthcare depends on

> you

> needing to have a job. What about consultants, say RD's? Wouldn' t it be

> nice if

> we didn't have to worry about keeping FT employment to have health

> benefits...think

> about all the opportunities that would open up to us for doing different

> things.

>

> On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 2:14 PM, Pam Charney

<pcharney@...<pcharney%40mac.com>

> <mailto:pcharney%40mac.com <pcharney%2540mac.com>>> wrote:

>

> >

> >

> > Kathy,

> >

> > With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

> > health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

> > perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

> > What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

> > other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

> > yet we have subpar results.

> >

> > I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

> > uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

> > current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

> > becoming one of those individuals.

> >

> > To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

> > the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

> > and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

> > Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

> > neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

> > " do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

> > their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

> > Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

> > get Congress to give up a perk or two.

> >

> > How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

> > a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

> > child in the U.S.?

> >

> > Pam Charney PhD, RD

> > Clinical Coordinator

> > Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

> > Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

> > Nutrition Sciences Program

> > School of Public Health and Community Medicine

> > Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

> >

> > Affiliate Associate Professor

> > School of Pharmacy

> >

> > MS Student

> > Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

> > School of Nursing

> >

> > University of Washington

> > Seattle, WA

> > charnepa@... <charnepa%40u.washington.edu><mailto:

> charnepa%40u.washington.edu <charnepa%2540u.washington.edu>> <charnepa%

> 40u.washington.edu>

>

> > http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney

> >

> > " The person who says it can't be done should not

> > interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > > Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with the

> > > President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

> > > it

> > > works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

> > > overhaul

> > > the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

> > > not afford

> > > it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

> > > those who

> > > do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10 million

> > > working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not just

> > > address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

> > > realize there are many problems with our current system however we

> > > still do

> > > have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

> > > and it

> > > is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

> > > foreign

> > > country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

> > > is

> > > being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

> > > drop a

> > > couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

> > > frequent

> > > visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

> > > recently had

> > > the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

> > > anyone

> > > running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

> > >

> > > Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

> > > to the

> > > Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

> > >

> > > Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

> > >

> > > Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

> > >

> > > Natural Health Concepts

> > >

> > > Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

> > >

> > > Complementary & Alternative Medicine

> > >

> > > Bios Life Slim

> > >

> > > Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

> > >

> > > Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

> > >

> > > www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

> > >

> > > _____

> > >

> > > From: rd-usa <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

> 40yahoogroups.com> [mailto:

> > rd-usa <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

> 40yahoogroups.com>] On

> > > Behalf Of

> > > Dineright4@...

<Dineright4%40aol.com><mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com<Dineright4%2540aol.com>>

> <Dineright4%40aol.com>

> > > Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

> > > To: rd-usa <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

> 40yahoogroups.com>

>

> > > Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

> > >

> > > FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

> > >

> > > YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL) DURING

> > > THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

> > >

> > > " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

> > > CARE

> > > PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

> > > REST OF

> > > US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

> > >

> > > THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

> > > NOT TO

> > > ANSWER IT !!!...

> > >

> > > IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

> > > THERE

> > > RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

> > >

> > > AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

> > > HEALTH

> > > CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

> > > ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

> > >

> > > SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

> > > NOT

> > > GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

> > > PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

> > > TOTALLY

> > > WRONG

> > > !!!!!

> > >

> > > PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

> > > EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

> > > WASHINGTON

> > > " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

> > >

> > > IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

> > > OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

> > > POLITICIANS

> > > MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

> > >

> > > Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

> > > Director of Medical Nutrition

> > > Signet Diagnostic Corporation

> > >

> > > Fax:

> > > DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com

<DineRight4%2540aol.com><DineRight4%

> 2540aol.com>>

> > com

> > >

> > >

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pam: I apologize in advance for the length of this reply - it could have

been much longer.

Where in the world can an individual get better care? I absolutely agree

with you that the cost of our health care is outrageous - twice that of any

other developed country. However, let's look at why. Do you think that

maybe malpractice and lawsuits are adding obscene amounts of money to our

care? There is no tort reform in the current proposal. WHY? That should

be number one on the list. What about fraud? It is so rampant in the

Medicare/Medicaid system it adds billions of dollars every year. How about

controlling that? The government currently runs Medicare and Medicaid and

does a pathetic job of controlling fraud. EX: a dentist in NY that billed

for 928 procedures in one day. I'd rather have a CZAR overseeing that than

making decisions for any of our citizens regarding personal health care.

Who wrote this bill - does anyone know? Politicians and God only knows who

else. Do you think that it might be more responsible for the government to

convene a task force of Health Care Professionals to identify the problems

with the current system and then make recommendations for improvement? Why

is this bunch ram roding this thru the Congress without giving the citizens

of the country time to READ IT( what a novel thought) and comment on it.

This is our health and our tax dollars NOT the government's. As far as our

members of Congress what have they done to deserve such health care? It is

hardly short sighted or childish to believe that ALL Americans are created

equally and deserve the same care. As far as outcomes the survival rates

for many forms of cancer and other diseases are much higher here in the US.

Statistics are very misleading and can be interpreted in many ways. As far

as the numbers go, I agree that more people are becoming uninsured due to

unemployment. However, I do not consider illegals part of the number - we

should not reward people for breaking US law. I also do not consider those

that are working and could have a policy but choose not to part of the

number. Personal responsibility has been totally lost. The government and

bankruptcy courts have contributed to MANY newly uninsured individuals by

making rulings that I believe are unlawful and unconstitutional. Let me

give you an example. My brother worked for GM for over 20 years and was

then spun of as Delphi. His pension and health care was guaranteed. Then

Delphi went into bankruptcy and the judge ruled against the salaried

employees. They have lost their pensions and their healthcare. The Union

employees did not. The governments " controlled bankruptcy's of the auto

company's have been unlawful and broken the law. They are paying back their

supporters at the detriment of those who should have been first in line. I

do not want the government becoming any more involved in the lives of US

citizens.

Now why not take some very successful US models and pattern reform after

them. The Mayo Clinic and the Cleveland Clinic are two of the top rated

facilities in the world - excellent outcomes with lower costs.

Or how about listening to Mr. Burd the CEO of Safeway, who by the way

has addressed our esteemed Senators regarding the Health Care Program he has

instituted at Safeway for his employees. Since 2005 with the new initiative

they have held their costs FLAT!!! While health care has increased at an

average of what maybe 40% over this time? Safeway promotes wellness and

prevention and recognizes that we need to insist on personal responsibility

since 70% of costs are behavior and lifestyle driven.

I agree that it is important to have correct information. I have yet to see

it come out of Washington. I do not want socialized medicine - that is the

eventual intent. My Father - A WWII Vet would be dead today in most

countries - esp. in Europe and Canada, and if this proposed plan had been

in effect the last 5 years. I do not want anyone in Washington dictating

his care.

I have been reading the actual bill. I also have been listening to the

philosophical opinions previously stated by those involved in this reform.

When you take into account all the information available, it is frightening

at best.

Lastly before taking anything as gospel from the White House consider the

" Stimulus " . I heard the President actually say last week - with a straight

face - that they passed a $787 billion dollar stimulus package with " NO PORK

OR EARMARKS " !!! Have you read that one??? Did anyone??? Just look at the

trash in that bill for Pelosi's district. I sure want them determining my

health care.

Thanks for the lively debate. Kathy

Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

Natural Health Concepts

Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

Complementary & Alternative Medicine

Bios Life Slim

Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

_____

From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On Behalf Of

Pam Charney

Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 1:14 PM

To: rd-usa

Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

Kathy,

With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

yet we have subpar results.

I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

becoming one of those individuals.

To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

" do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

get Congress to give up a perk or two.

How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

child in the U.S.?

Pam Charney PhD, RD

Clinical Coordinator

Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

Nutrition Sciences Program

School of Public Health and Community Medicine

Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

Affiliate Associate Professor

School of Pharmacy

MS Student

Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

School of Nursing

University of Washington

Seattle, WA

charnepa@... <mailto:charnepa%40u.washington.edu> on.edu

http://www.linkedin <http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney>

..com/in/pamcharney

" The person who says it can't be done should not

interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

> Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with the

> President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

> it

> works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

> overhaul

> the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

> not afford

> it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

> those who

> do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10 million

> working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not just

> address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

> realize there are many problems with our current system however we

> still do

> have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

> and it

> is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

> foreign

> country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

> is

> being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

> drop a

> couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

> frequent

> visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

> recently had

> the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

> anyone

> running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

>

> Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

> to the

> Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

>

> Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

>

> Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

>

> Natural Health Concepts

>

> Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

>

> Complementary & Alternative Medicine

>

> Bios Life Slim

>

> Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

>

> Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

>

> www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

>

> _____

>

> From: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

[mailto:rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com] On

> Behalf Of

> Dineright4aol (DOT) <mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com> com

> Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

> To: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

> Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>

> FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

>

> YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL) DURING

> THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

>

> " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

> CARE

> PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

> REST OF

> US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

>

> THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

> NOT TO

> ANSWER IT !!!...

>

> IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

> THERE

> RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

>

> AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

> HEALTH

> CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

> ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

>

> SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

> NOT

> GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

> PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

> TOTALLY

> WRONG

> !!!!!

>

> PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

> EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

> WASHINGTON

> " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

>

> IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

> OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

> POLITICIANS

> MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

>

> Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

> Director of Medical Nutrition

> Signet Diagnostic Corporation

>

> Fax:

> DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com> com

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pam: I apologize in advance for the length of this reply - it could have

been much longer.

Where in the world can an individual get better care? I absolutely agree

with you that the cost of our health care is outrageous - twice that of any

other developed country. However, let's look at why. Do you think that

maybe malpractice and lawsuits are adding obscene amounts of money to our

care? There is no tort reform in the current proposal. WHY? That should

be number one on the list. What about fraud? It is so rampant in the

Medicare/Medicaid system it adds billions of dollars every year. How about

controlling that? The government currently runs Medicare and Medicaid and

does a pathetic job of controlling fraud. EX: a dentist in NY that billed

for 928 procedures in one day. I'd rather have a CZAR overseeing that than

making decisions for any of our citizens regarding personal health care.

Who wrote this bill - does anyone know? Politicians and God only knows who

else. Do you think that it might be more responsible for the government to

convene a task force of Health Care Professionals to identify the problems

with the current system and then make recommendations for improvement? Why

is this bunch ram roding this thru the Congress without giving the citizens

of the country time to READ IT( what a novel thought) and comment on it.

This is our health and our tax dollars NOT the government's. As far as our

members of Congress what have they done to deserve such health care? It is

hardly short sighted or childish to believe that ALL Americans are created

equally and deserve the same care. As far as outcomes the survival rates

for many forms of cancer and other diseases are much higher here in the US.

Statistics are very misleading and can be interpreted in many ways. As far

as the numbers go, I agree that more people are becoming uninsured due to

unemployment. However, I do not consider illegals part of the number - we

should not reward people for breaking US law. I also do not consider those

that are working and could have a policy but choose not to part of the

number. Personal responsibility has been totally lost. The government and

bankruptcy courts have contributed to MANY newly uninsured individuals by

making rulings that I believe are unlawful and unconstitutional. Let me

give you an example. My brother worked for GM for over 20 years and was

then spun of as Delphi. His pension and health care was guaranteed. Then

Delphi went into bankruptcy and the judge ruled against the salaried

employees. They have lost their pensions and their healthcare. The Union

employees did not. The governments " controlled bankruptcy's of the auto

company's have been unlawful and broken the law. They are paying back their

supporters at the detriment of those who should have been first in line. I

do not want the government becoming any more involved in the lives of US

citizens.

Now why not take some very successful US models and pattern reform after

them. The Mayo Clinic and the Cleveland Clinic are two of the top rated

facilities in the world - excellent outcomes with lower costs.

Or how about listening to Mr. Burd the CEO of Safeway, who by the way

has addressed our esteemed Senators regarding the Health Care Program he has

instituted at Safeway for his employees. Since 2005 with the new initiative

they have held their costs FLAT!!! While health care has increased at an

average of what maybe 40% over this time? Safeway promotes wellness and

prevention and recognizes that we need to insist on personal responsibility

since 70% of costs are behavior and lifestyle driven.

I agree that it is important to have correct information. I have yet to see

it come out of Washington. I do not want socialized medicine - that is the

eventual intent. My Father - A WWII Vet would be dead today in most

countries - esp. in Europe and Canada, and if this proposed plan had been

in effect the last 5 years. I do not want anyone in Washington dictating

his care.

I have been reading the actual bill. I also have been listening to the

philosophical opinions previously stated by those involved in this reform.

When you take into account all the information available, it is frightening

at best.

Lastly before taking anything as gospel from the White House consider the

" Stimulus " . I heard the President actually say last week - with a straight

face - that they passed a $787 billion dollar stimulus package with " NO PORK

OR EARMARKS " !!! Have you read that one??? Did anyone??? Just look at the

trash in that bill for Pelosi's district. I sure want them determining my

health care.

Thanks for the lively debate. Kathy

Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

Natural Health Concepts

Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

Complementary & Alternative Medicine

Bios Life Slim

Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

_____

From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On Behalf Of

Pam Charney

Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 1:14 PM

To: rd-usa

Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

Kathy,

With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

yet we have subpar results.

I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

becoming one of those individuals.

To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

" do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

get Congress to give up a perk or two.

How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

child in the U.S.?

Pam Charney PhD, RD

Clinical Coordinator

Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

Nutrition Sciences Program

School of Public Health and Community Medicine

Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

Affiliate Associate Professor

School of Pharmacy

MS Student

Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

School of Nursing

University of Washington

Seattle, WA

charnepa@... <mailto:charnepa%40u.washington.edu> on.edu

http://www.linkedin <http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney>

..com/in/pamcharney

" The person who says it can't be done should not

interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

> Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with the

> President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

> it

> works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

> overhaul

> the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

> not afford

> it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

> those who

> do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10 million

> working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not just

> address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

> realize there are many problems with our current system however we

> still do

> have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

> and it

> is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

> foreign

> country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

> is

> being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

> drop a

> couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

> frequent

> visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

> recently had

> the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

> anyone

> running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

>

> Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

> to the

> Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

>

> Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

>

> Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

>

> Natural Health Concepts

>

> Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

>

> Complementary & Alternative Medicine

>

> Bios Life Slim

>

> Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

>

> Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

>

> www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

>

> _____

>

> From: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

[mailto:rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com] On

> Behalf Of

> Dineright4aol (DOT) <mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com> com

> Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

> To: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

> Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>

> FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

>

> YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL) DURING

> THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

>

> " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

> CARE

> PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

> REST OF

> US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

>

> THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

> NOT TO

> ANSWER IT !!!...

>

> IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

> THERE

> RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

>

> AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

> HEALTH

> CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

> ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

>

> SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

> NOT

> GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

> PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

> TOTALLY

> WRONG

> !!!!!

>

> PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

> EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

> WASHINGTON

> " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

>

> IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

> OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

> POLITICIANS

> MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

>

> Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

> Director of Medical Nutrition

> Signet Diagnostic Corporation

>

> Fax:

> DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com> com

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pam: I apologize in advance for the length of this reply - it could have

been much longer.

Where in the world can an individual get better care? I absolutely agree

with you that the cost of our health care is outrageous - twice that of any

other developed country. However, let's look at why. Do you think that

maybe malpractice and lawsuits are adding obscene amounts of money to our

care? There is no tort reform in the current proposal. WHY? That should

be number one on the list. What about fraud? It is so rampant in the

Medicare/Medicaid system it adds billions of dollars every year. How about

controlling that? The government currently runs Medicare and Medicaid and

does a pathetic job of controlling fraud. EX: a dentist in NY that billed

for 928 procedures in one day. I'd rather have a CZAR overseeing that than

making decisions for any of our citizens regarding personal health care.

Who wrote this bill - does anyone know? Politicians and God only knows who

else. Do you think that it might be more responsible for the government to

convene a task force of Health Care Professionals to identify the problems

with the current system and then make recommendations for improvement? Why

is this bunch ram roding this thru the Congress without giving the citizens

of the country time to READ IT( what a novel thought) and comment on it.

This is our health and our tax dollars NOT the government's. As far as our

members of Congress what have they done to deserve such health care? It is

hardly short sighted or childish to believe that ALL Americans are created

equally and deserve the same care. As far as outcomes the survival rates

for many forms of cancer and other diseases are much higher here in the US.

Statistics are very misleading and can be interpreted in many ways. As far

as the numbers go, I agree that more people are becoming uninsured due to

unemployment. However, I do not consider illegals part of the number - we

should not reward people for breaking US law. I also do not consider those

that are working and could have a policy but choose not to part of the

number. Personal responsibility has been totally lost. The government and

bankruptcy courts have contributed to MANY newly uninsured individuals by

making rulings that I believe are unlawful and unconstitutional. Let me

give you an example. My brother worked for GM for over 20 years and was

then spun of as Delphi. His pension and health care was guaranteed. Then

Delphi went into bankruptcy and the judge ruled against the salaried

employees. They have lost their pensions and their healthcare. The Union

employees did not. The governments " controlled bankruptcy's of the auto

company's have been unlawful and broken the law. They are paying back their

supporters at the detriment of those who should have been first in line. I

do not want the government becoming any more involved in the lives of US

citizens.

Now why not take some very successful US models and pattern reform after

them. The Mayo Clinic and the Cleveland Clinic are two of the top rated

facilities in the world - excellent outcomes with lower costs.

Or how about listening to Mr. Burd the CEO of Safeway, who by the way

has addressed our esteemed Senators regarding the Health Care Program he has

instituted at Safeway for his employees. Since 2005 with the new initiative

they have held their costs FLAT!!! While health care has increased at an

average of what maybe 40% over this time? Safeway promotes wellness and

prevention and recognizes that we need to insist on personal responsibility

since 70% of costs are behavior and lifestyle driven.

I agree that it is important to have correct information. I have yet to see

it come out of Washington. I do not want socialized medicine - that is the

eventual intent. My Father - A WWII Vet would be dead today in most

countries - esp. in Europe and Canada, and if this proposed plan had been

in effect the last 5 years. I do not want anyone in Washington dictating

his care.

I have been reading the actual bill. I also have been listening to the

philosophical opinions previously stated by those involved in this reform.

When you take into account all the information available, it is frightening

at best.

Lastly before taking anything as gospel from the White House consider the

" Stimulus " . I heard the President actually say last week - with a straight

face - that they passed a $787 billion dollar stimulus package with " NO PORK

OR EARMARKS " !!! Have you read that one??? Did anyone??? Just look at the

trash in that bill for Pelosi's district. I sure want them determining my

health care.

Thanks for the lively debate. Kathy

Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

Natural Health Concepts

Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

Complementary & Alternative Medicine

Bios Life Slim

Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

_____

From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On Behalf Of

Pam Charney

Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 1:14 PM

To: rd-usa

Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

Kathy,

With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

yet we have subpar results.

I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

becoming one of those individuals.

To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

" do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

get Congress to give up a perk or two.

How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

child in the U.S.?

Pam Charney PhD, RD

Clinical Coordinator

Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

Nutrition Sciences Program

School of Public Health and Community Medicine

Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

Affiliate Associate Professor

School of Pharmacy

MS Student

Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

School of Nursing

University of Washington

Seattle, WA

charnepa@... <mailto:charnepa%40u.washington.edu> on.edu

http://www.linkedin <http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney>

..com/in/pamcharney

" The person who says it can't be done should not

interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

> Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with the

> President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

> it

> works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

> overhaul

> the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

> not afford

> it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

> those who

> do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10 million

> working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not just

> address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

> realize there are many problems with our current system however we

> still do

> have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

> and it

> is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

> foreign

> country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

> is

> being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

> drop a

> couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

> frequent

> visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

> recently had

> the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

> anyone

> running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

>

> Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

> to the

> Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

>

> Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

>

> Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

>

> Natural Health Concepts

>

> Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

>

> Complementary & Alternative Medicine

>

> Bios Life Slim

>

> Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

>

> Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

>

> www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

>

> _____

>

> From: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

[mailto:rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com] On

> Behalf Of

> Dineright4aol (DOT) <mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com> com

> Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

> To: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

> Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>

> FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

>

> YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL) DURING

> THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

>

> " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

> CARE

> PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

> REST OF

> US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

>

> THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

> NOT TO

> ANSWER IT !!!...

>

> IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

> THERE

> RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

>

> AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

> HEALTH

> CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

> ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

>

> SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

> NOT

> GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

> PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

> TOTALLY

> WRONG

> !!!!!

>

> PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

> EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

> WASHINGTON

> " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

>

> IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

> OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

> POLITICIANS

> MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

>

> Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

> Director of Medical Nutrition

> Signet Diagnostic Corporation

>

> Fax:

> DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com> com

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The choice will go away because the private sector can't compete against a

government that doesn't have to compete. It will be a government monopoly. You

asked, " Why are we as a free market enterprise afraid of it. " Uh, because it

would no longer be " free market enterprise " . Government intrusion into the

market ends the " free market " . Free market by definition is free from government

intervention.

W. Rowell, RD, LN

Montana State Hospital, Warm Spring, MT

Consultant Dietitian, Long Term Care

Certified LEAP Therapist

________________________________

From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On Behalf Of Jen

Zingaro

Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 1:22 PM

To: rd-usa

Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

It's been said before then. Let those who need the public option have at

it.

If it's not competitive, it won't be popular and then health insurance

companies don't

have to worry about it. Why are we as a free market enterprise afraid of

it. It's just

another option for people to have. You don't have to have it. It's not

going to be

free for others, it's just another healthcare option?

I don't know if you can really compare the post office and amtrak. It's sort

of like apples

and oranges. Fedex and UPS do just fine, and then there's the post office

that you can use

if you want to. I personally like the service at the post office. It's not

for everyone but it's an option.

I'm certain we'll all be using Medicare at some point? It's not a perfect

system, but it's better than trying

to find private insurance on your own when you are older and have

preexisitng conditions.

On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 3:15 PM, Rowell,

<drowell@...<mailto:drowell%40mt.gov>> wrote:

>

>

> If I could opt out of my State provided health care insurance and use the

> same money for HSAs and catastrophic care, I would. We DO have the best

> healthcare in the world. I don't see anyone leaving the country to get

> better care or faster service. I see just the opposite. If we could get the

> government out of our current health care, it would be dramatically better.

> What does government run better than the private sector? Amtrak, postal

> service? Of course not. They don't have to make a profit. That's why the

> private option will go away. They won't be able to compete. The government

> can just take all the money they need from the taxpayer to keep it going,

> poor service or not.

>

> " If you think health care is expensive now, wait until you see what it

> costs when it's free. " --P.J. O'Rourke

>

> W. Rowell, RD, LN

> Montana State Hospital, Warm Spring, MT

> Consultant Dietitian, Long Term Care

> Certified LEAP Therapist

>

> ________________________________

> From: rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> [mailto:

> rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>] On Behalf Of Jen

> Zingaro

> Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 12:58 PM

> To: rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

> Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>

> Very well said Pam.

>

> I can't believe how many RD's who work in healthcare system honestly feel

> that

> our system is the best healthcare in the world? When did this country

> become

> " what's in it for me? "

>

> I am lucky to be offered decent healthcare at my job. But I had to pay $100

> more

> dollars a month this year to keep it... my raise didn't even cover that.

> But at least

> I have health insurance.

>

> It's truly sad that we live in a system where having healthcare depends on

> you

> needing to have a job. What about consultants, say RD's? Wouldn' t it be

> nice if

> we didn't have to worry about keeping FT employment to have health

> benefits...think

> about all the opportunities that would open up to us for doing different

> things.

>

> On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 2:14 PM, Pam Charney

<pcharney@...<mailto:pcharney%40mac.com><pcharney%40mac.com>

> <mailto:pcharney%40mac.com <pcharney%2540mac.com>>> wrote:

>

> >

> >

> > Kathy,

> >

> > With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

> > health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

> > perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

> > What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

> > other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

> > yet we have subpar results.

> >

> > I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

> > uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

> > current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

> > becoming one of those individuals.

> >

> > To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

> > the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

> > and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

> > Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

> > neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

> > " do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

> > their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

> > Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

> > get Congress to give up a perk or two.

> >

> > How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

> > a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

> > child in the U.S.?

> >

> > Pam Charney PhD, RD

> > Clinical Coordinator

> > Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

> > Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

> > Nutrition Sciences Program

> > School of Public Health and Community Medicine

> > Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

> >

> > Affiliate Associate Professor

> > School of Pharmacy

> >

> > MS Student

> > Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

> > School of Nursing

> >

> > University of Washington

> > Seattle, WA

> > charnepa@...<mailto:charnepa%40u.washington.edu>

<charnepa%40u.washington.edu><mailto:

> charnepa%40u.washington.edu <charnepa%2540u.washington.edu>> <charnepa%

> 40u.washington.edu>

>

> > http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney

> >

> > " The person who says it can't be done should not

> > interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > > Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with the

> > > President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

> > > it

> > > works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

> > > overhaul

> > > the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

> > > not afford

> > > it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

> > > those who

> > > do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10 million

> > > working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not just

> > > address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

> > > realize there are many problems with our current system however we

> > > still do

> > > have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

> > > and it

> > > is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

> > > foreign

> > > country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

> > > is

> > > being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

> > > drop a

> > > couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

> > > frequent

> > > visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

> > > recently had

> > > the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

> > > anyone

> > > running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

> > >

> > > Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

> > > to the

> > > Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

> > >

> > > Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

> > >

> > > Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

> > >

> > > Natural Health Concepts

> > >

> > > Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

> > >

> > > Complementary & Alternative Medicine

> > >

> > > Bios Life Slim

> > >

> > > Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

> > >

> > > Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

> > >

> > > www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

> > >

> > > _____

> > >

> > > From: rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

> 40yahoogroups.com> [mailto:

> > rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

> 40yahoogroups.com>] On

> > > Behalf Of

> > > Dineright4@...<mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com>

<Dineright4%40aol.com><mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com<Dineright4%2540aol.com>>

> <Dineright4%40aol.com>

> > > Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

> > > To: rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

> 40yahoogroups.com>

>

> > > Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

> > >

> > > FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

> > >

> > > YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL) DURING

> > > THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

> > >

> > > " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

> > > CARE

> > > PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

> > > REST OF

> > > US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

> > >

> > > THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

> > > NOT TO

> > > ANSWER IT !!!...

> > >

> > > IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

> > > THERE

> > > RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

> > >

> > > AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

> > > HEALTH

> > > CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

> > > ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

> > >

> > > SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

> > > NOT

> > > GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

> > > PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

> > > TOTALLY

> > > WRONG

> > > !!!!!

> > >

> > > PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

> > > EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

> > > WASHINGTON

> > > " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

> > >

> > > IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

> > > OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

> > > POLITICIANS

> > > MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

> > >

> > > Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

> > > Director of Medical Nutrition

> > > Signet Diagnostic Corporation

> > >

> > > Fax:

> > > DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com

<DineRight4%2540aol.com><DineRight4%

> 2540aol.com>>

> > com

> > >

> > >

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The choice will go away because the private sector can't compete against a

government that doesn't have to compete. It will be a government monopoly. You

asked, " Why are we as a free market enterprise afraid of it. " Uh, because it

would no longer be " free market enterprise " . Government intrusion into the

market ends the " free market " . Free market by definition is free from government

intervention.

W. Rowell, RD, LN

Montana State Hospital, Warm Spring, MT

Consultant Dietitian, Long Term Care

Certified LEAP Therapist

________________________________

From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On Behalf Of Jen

Zingaro

Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 1:22 PM

To: rd-usa

Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

It's been said before then. Let those who need the public option have at

it.

If it's not competitive, it won't be popular and then health insurance

companies don't

have to worry about it. Why are we as a free market enterprise afraid of

it. It's just

another option for people to have. You don't have to have it. It's not

going to be

free for others, it's just another healthcare option?

I don't know if you can really compare the post office and amtrak. It's sort

of like apples

and oranges. Fedex and UPS do just fine, and then there's the post office

that you can use

if you want to. I personally like the service at the post office. It's not

for everyone but it's an option.

I'm certain we'll all be using Medicare at some point? It's not a perfect

system, but it's better than trying

to find private insurance on your own when you are older and have

preexisitng conditions.

On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 3:15 PM, Rowell,

<drowell@...<mailto:drowell%40mt.gov>> wrote:

>

>

> If I could opt out of my State provided health care insurance and use the

> same money for HSAs and catastrophic care, I would. We DO have the best

> healthcare in the world. I don't see anyone leaving the country to get

> better care or faster service. I see just the opposite. If we could get the

> government out of our current health care, it would be dramatically better.

> What does government run better than the private sector? Amtrak, postal

> service? Of course not. They don't have to make a profit. That's why the

> private option will go away. They won't be able to compete. The government

> can just take all the money they need from the taxpayer to keep it going,

> poor service or not.

>

> " If you think health care is expensive now, wait until you see what it

> costs when it's free. " --P.J. O'Rourke

>

> W. Rowell, RD, LN

> Montana State Hospital, Warm Spring, MT

> Consultant Dietitian, Long Term Care

> Certified LEAP Therapist

>

> ________________________________

> From: rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> [mailto:

> rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>] On Behalf Of Jen

> Zingaro

> Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 12:58 PM

> To: rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

> Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>

> Very well said Pam.

>

> I can't believe how many RD's who work in healthcare system honestly feel

> that

> our system is the best healthcare in the world? When did this country

> become

> " what's in it for me? "

>

> I am lucky to be offered decent healthcare at my job. But I had to pay $100

> more

> dollars a month this year to keep it... my raise didn't even cover that.

> But at least

> I have health insurance.

>

> It's truly sad that we live in a system where having healthcare depends on

> you

> needing to have a job. What about consultants, say RD's? Wouldn' t it be

> nice if

> we didn't have to worry about keeping FT employment to have health

> benefits...think

> about all the opportunities that would open up to us for doing different

> things.

>

> On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 2:14 PM, Pam Charney

<pcharney@...<mailto:pcharney%40mac.com><pcharney%40mac.com>

> <mailto:pcharney%40mac.com <pcharney%2540mac.com>>> wrote:

>

> >

> >

> > Kathy,

> >

> > With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

> > health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

> > perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

> > What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

> > other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

> > yet we have subpar results.

> >

> > I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

> > uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

> > current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

> > becoming one of those individuals.

> >

> > To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

> > the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

> > and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

> > Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

> > neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

> > " do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

> > their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

> > Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

> > get Congress to give up a perk or two.

> >

> > How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

> > a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

> > child in the U.S.?

> >

> > Pam Charney PhD, RD

> > Clinical Coordinator

> > Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

> > Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

> > Nutrition Sciences Program

> > School of Public Health and Community Medicine

> > Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

> >

> > Affiliate Associate Professor

> > School of Pharmacy

> >

> > MS Student

> > Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

> > School of Nursing

> >

> > University of Washington

> > Seattle, WA

> > charnepa@...<mailto:charnepa%40u.washington.edu>

<charnepa%40u.washington.edu><mailto:

> charnepa%40u.washington.edu <charnepa%2540u.washington.edu>> <charnepa%

> 40u.washington.edu>

>

> > http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney

> >

> > " The person who says it can't be done should not

> > interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > > Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with the

> > > President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

> > > it

> > > works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

> > > overhaul

> > > the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

> > > not afford

> > > it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

> > > those who

> > > do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10 million

> > > working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not just

> > > address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

> > > realize there are many problems with our current system however we

> > > still do

> > > have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

> > > and it

> > > is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

> > > foreign

> > > country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

> > > is

> > > being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

> > > drop a

> > > couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

> > > frequent

> > > visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

> > > recently had

> > > the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

> > > anyone

> > > running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

> > >

> > > Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

> > > to the

> > > Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

> > >

> > > Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

> > >

> > > Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

> > >

> > > Natural Health Concepts

> > >

> > > Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

> > >

> > > Complementary & Alternative Medicine

> > >

> > > Bios Life Slim

> > >

> > > Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

> > >

> > > Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

> > >

> > > www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

> > >

> > > _____

> > >

> > > From: rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

> 40yahoogroups.com> [mailto:

> > rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

> 40yahoogroups.com>] On

> > > Behalf Of

> > > Dineright4@...<mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com>

<Dineright4%40aol.com><mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com<Dineright4%2540aol.com>>

> <Dineright4%40aol.com>

> > > Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

> > > To: rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

> 40yahoogroups.com>

>

> > > Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

> > >

> > > FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

> > >

> > > YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL) DURING

> > > THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

> > >

> > > " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

> > > CARE

> > > PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

> > > REST OF

> > > US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

> > >

> > > THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

> > > NOT TO

> > > ANSWER IT !!!...

> > >

> > > IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

> > > THERE

> > > RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

> > >

> > > AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

> > > HEALTH

> > > CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

> > > ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

> > >

> > > SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

> > > NOT

> > > GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

> > > PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

> > > TOTALLY

> > > WRONG

> > > !!!!!

> > >

> > > PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

> > > EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

> > > WASHINGTON

> > > " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

> > >

> > > IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

> > > OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

> > > POLITICIANS

> > > MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

> > >

> > > Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

> > > Director of Medical Nutrition

> > > Signet Diagnostic Corporation

> > >

> > > Fax:

> > > DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com

<DineRight4%2540aol.com><DineRight4%

> 2540aol.com>>

> > com

> > >

> > >

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The choice will go away because the private sector can't compete against a

government that doesn't have to compete. It will be a government monopoly. You

asked, " Why are we as a free market enterprise afraid of it. " Uh, because it

would no longer be " free market enterprise " . Government intrusion into the

market ends the " free market " . Free market by definition is free from government

intervention.

W. Rowell, RD, LN

Montana State Hospital, Warm Spring, MT

Consultant Dietitian, Long Term Care

Certified LEAP Therapist

________________________________

From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On Behalf Of Jen

Zingaro

Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 1:22 PM

To: rd-usa

Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

It's been said before then. Let those who need the public option have at

it.

If it's not competitive, it won't be popular and then health insurance

companies don't

have to worry about it. Why are we as a free market enterprise afraid of

it. It's just

another option for people to have. You don't have to have it. It's not

going to be

free for others, it's just another healthcare option?

I don't know if you can really compare the post office and amtrak. It's sort

of like apples

and oranges. Fedex and UPS do just fine, and then there's the post office

that you can use

if you want to. I personally like the service at the post office. It's not

for everyone but it's an option.

I'm certain we'll all be using Medicare at some point? It's not a perfect

system, but it's better than trying

to find private insurance on your own when you are older and have

preexisitng conditions.

On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 3:15 PM, Rowell,

<drowell@...<mailto:drowell%40mt.gov>> wrote:

>

>

> If I could opt out of my State provided health care insurance and use the

> same money for HSAs and catastrophic care, I would. We DO have the best

> healthcare in the world. I don't see anyone leaving the country to get

> better care or faster service. I see just the opposite. If we could get the

> government out of our current health care, it would be dramatically better.

> What does government run better than the private sector? Amtrak, postal

> service? Of course not. They don't have to make a profit. That's why the

> private option will go away. They won't be able to compete. The government

> can just take all the money they need from the taxpayer to keep it going,

> poor service or not.

>

> " If you think health care is expensive now, wait until you see what it

> costs when it's free. " --P.J. O'Rourke

>

> W. Rowell, RD, LN

> Montana State Hospital, Warm Spring, MT

> Consultant Dietitian, Long Term Care

> Certified LEAP Therapist

>

> ________________________________

> From: rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> [mailto:

> rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>] On Behalf Of Jen

> Zingaro

> Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 12:58 PM

> To: rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

> Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>

> Very well said Pam.

>

> I can't believe how many RD's who work in healthcare system honestly feel

> that

> our system is the best healthcare in the world? When did this country

> become

> " what's in it for me? "

>

> I am lucky to be offered decent healthcare at my job. But I had to pay $100

> more

> dollars a month this year to keep it... my raise didn't even cover that.

> But at least

> I have health insurance.

>

> It's truly sad that we live in a system where having healthcare depends on

> you

> needing to have a job. What about consultants, say RD's? Wouldn' t it be

> nice if

> we didn't have to worry about keeping FT employment to have health

> benefits...think

> about all the opportunities that would open up to us for doing different

> things.

>

> On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 2:14 PM, Pam Charney

<pcharney@...<mailto:pcharney%40mac.com><pcharney%40mac.com>

> <mailto:pcharney%40mac.com <pcharney%2540mac.com>>> wrote:

>

> >

> >

> > Kathy,

> >

> > With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

> > health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

> > perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

> > What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

> > other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

> > yet we have subpar results.

> >

> > I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

> > uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

> > current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

> > becoming one of those individuals.

> >

> > To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

> > the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

> > and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

> > Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

> > neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

> > " do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

> > their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

> > Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

> > get Congress to give up a perk or two.

> >

> > How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

> > a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

> > child in the U.S.?

> >

> > Pam Charney PhD, RD

> > Clinical Coordinator

> > Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

> > Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

> > Nutrition Sciences Program

> > School of Public Health and Community Medicine

> > Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

> >

> > Affiliate Associate Professor

> > School of Pharmacy

> >

> > MS Student

> > Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

> > School of Nursing

> >

> > University of Washington

> > Seattle, WA

> > charnepa@...<mailto:charnepa%40u.washington.edu>

<charnepa%40u.washington.edu><mailto:

> charnepa%40u.washington.edu <charnepa%2540u.washington.edu>> <charnepa%

> 40u.washington.edu>

>

> > http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney

> >

> > " The person who says it can't be done should not

> > interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > > Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with the

> > > President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

> > > it

> > > works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

> > > overhaul

> > > the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

> > > not afford

> > > it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

> > > those who

> > > do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10 million

> > > working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not just

> > > address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

> > > realize there are many problems with our current system however we

> > > still do

> > > have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

> > > and it

> > > is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

> > > foreign

> > > country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

> > > is

> > > being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

> > > drop a

> > > couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

> > > frequent

> > > visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

> > > recently had

> > > the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

> > > anyone

> > > running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

> > >

> > > Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

> > > to the

> > > Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

> > >

> > > Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

> > >

> > > Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

> > >

> > > Natural Health Concepts

> > >

> > > Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

> > >

> > > Complementary & Alternative Medicine

> > >

> > > Bios Life Slim

> > >

> > > Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

> > >

> > > Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

> > >

> > > www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

> > >

> > > _____

> > >

> > > From: rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

> 40yahoogroups.com> [mailto:

> > rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

> 40yahoogroups.com>] On

> > > Behalf Of

> > > Dineright4@...<mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com>

<Dineright4%40aol.com><mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com<Dineright4%2540aol.com>>

> <Dineright4%40aol.com>

> > > Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

> > > To: rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

> 40yahoogroups.com>

>

> > > Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

> > >

> > > FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

> > >

> > > YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL) DURING

> > > THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

> > >

> > > " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

> > > CARE

> > > PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

> > > REST OF

> > > US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

> > >

> > > THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

> > > NOT TO

> > > ANSWER IT !!!...

> > >

> > > IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

> > > THERE

> > > RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

> > >

> > > AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

> > > HEALTH

> > > CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

> > > ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

> > >

> > > SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

> > > NOT

> > > GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

> > > PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

> > > TOTALLY

> > > WRONG

> > > !!!!!

> > >

> > > PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

> > > EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

> > > WASHINGTON

> > > " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

> > >

> > > IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

> > > OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

> > > POLITICIANS

> > > MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

> > >

> > > Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

> > > Director of Medical Nutrition

> > > Signet Diagnostic Corporation

> > >

> > > Fax:

> > > DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com

<DineRight4%2540aol.com><DineRight4%

> 2540aol.com>>

> > com

> > >

> > >

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kathy,

I'm glad you have the time to respond in such detail. All I will say

is that if we had universal coverage your brother wouldn't be without

health insurance. If you are lacking health insurance, try to get an

appointment at the Cleveland Clinic or Mayo Clinic. I'm aware that

both provide charity care but that pot of money is shrinking rapidly

and very difficult to access if you happen to have a costly condition.

Unless we have meaningful discussion, none of the issues you raise

will be fixed. Would you rather continue as we are and thus have

fodder for ranting and raving or would you rather begin the arduous

process of improving care.

There are now over 20 nations that have better health outcomes than we

do. We are not even in the top 10 in infant mortality rates (meaning

that there are over 10 countries that have lower infant mortality than

we do). We rank lower than 15th in terms of other health outcomes.

Let's just look at one example; fewer than 50% of individuals who have

diabetes receive care at even what is considered minimal by health

standards.

Regards,

pam

Pam Charney

pcharney@...

" If all you ever do is all you've ever done, then all you'll ever get

is all you ever got " - Anonymous

> Pam: I apologize in advance for the length of this reply - it could

> have

> been much longer.

>

> Where in the world can an individual get better care? I absolutely

> agree

> with you that the cost of our health care is outrageous - twice that

> of any

> other developed country. However, let's look at why. Do you think that

> maybe malpractice and lawsuits are adding obscene amounts of money

> to our

> care? There is no tort reform in the current proposal. WHY? That

> should

> be number one on the list. What about fraud? It is so rampant in the

> Medicare/Medicaid system it adds billions of dollars every year. How

> about

> controlling that? The government currently runs Medicare and

> Medicaid and

> does a pathetic job of controlling fraud. EX: a dentist in NY that

> billed

> for 928 procedures in one day. I'd rather have a CZAR overseeing

> that than

> making decisions for any of our citizens regarding personal health

> care.

> Who wrote this bill - does anyone know? Politicians and God only

> knows who

> else. Do you think that it might be more responsible for the

> government to

> convene a task force of Health Care Professionals to identify the

> problems

> with the current system and then make recommendations for

> improvement? Why

> is this bunch ram roding this thru the Congress without giving the

> citizens

> of the country time to READ IT( what a novel thought) and comment on

> it.

> This is our health and our tax dollars NOT the government's. As far

> as our

> members of Congress what have they done to deserve such health care?

> It is

> hardly short sighted or childish to believe that ALL Americans are

> created

> equally and deserve the same care. As far as outcomes the survival

> rates

> for many forms of cancer and other diseases are much higher here in

> the US.

> Statistics are very misleading and can be interpreted in many ways.

> As far

> as the numbers go, I agree that more people are becoming uninsured

> due to

> unemployment. However, I do not consider illegals part of the number

> - we

> should not reward people for breaking US law. I also do not consider

> those

> that are working and could have a policy but choose not to part of the

> number. Personal responsibility has been totally lost. The

> government and

> bankruptcy courts have contributed to MANY newly uninsured

> individuals by

> making rulings that I believe are unlawful and unconstitutional. Let

> me

> give you an example. My brother worked for GM for over 20 years and

> was

> then spun of as Delphi. His pension and health care was guaranteed.

> Then

> Delphi went into bankruptcy and the judge ruled against the salaried

> employees. They have lost their pensions and their healthcare. The

> Union

> employees did not. The governments " controlled bankruptcy's of the

> auto

> company's have been unlawful and broken the law. They are paying

> back their

> supporters at the detriment of those who should have been first in

> line. I

> do not want the government becoming any more involved in the lives

> of US

> citizens.

>

> Now why not take some very successful US models and pattern reform

> after

> them. The Mayo Clinic and the Cleveland Clinic are two of the top

> rated

> facilities in the world - excellent outcomes with lower costs.

>

> Or how about listening to Mr. Burd the CEO of Safeway, who by

> the way

> has addressed our esteemed Senators regarding the Health Care

> Program he has

> instituted at Safeway for his employees. Since 2005 with the new

> initiative

> they have held their costs FLAT!!! While health care has increased

> at an

> average of what maybe 40% over this time? Safeway promotes wellness

> and

> prevention and recognizes that we need to insist on personal

> responsibility

> since 70% of costs are behavior and lifestyle driven.

>

> I agree that it is important to have correct information. I have yet

> to see

> it come out of Washington. I do not want socialized medicine - that

> is the

> eventual intent. My Father - A WWII Vet would be dead today in most

> countries - esp. in Europe and Canada, and if this proposed plan had

> been

> in effect the last 5 years. I do not want anyone in Washington

> dictating

> his care.

>

> I have been reading the actual bill. I also have been listening to the

> philosophical opinions previously stated by those involved in this

> reform.

> When you take into account all the information available, it is

> frightening

> at best.

>

> Lastly before taking anything as gospel from the White House

> consider the

> " Stimulus " . I heard the President actually say last week - with a

> straight

> face - that they passed a $787 billion dollar stimulus package with

> " NO PORK

> OR EARMARKS " !!! Have you read that one??? Did anyone??? Just look at

> the

> trash in that bill for Pelosi's district. I sure want them

> determining my

> health care.

>

> Thanks for the lively debate. Kathy

>

> Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

>

> Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

>

> Natural Health Concepts

>

> Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

>

> Complementary & Alternative Medicine

>

> Bios Life Slim

>

> Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

>

> Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

>

> www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

>

> _____

>

> From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On

> Behalf Of

> Pam Charney

> Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 1:14 PM

> To: rd-usa

> Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>

> Kathy,

>

> With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

> health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

> perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

> What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

> other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

> yet we have subpar results.

>

> I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

> uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

> current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

> becoming one of those individuals.

>

> To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

> the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

> and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

> Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

> neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

> " do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

> their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

> Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

> get Congress to give up a perk or two.

>

> How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

> a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

> child in the U.S.?

>

> Pam Charney PhD, RD

> Clinical Coordinator

> Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

> Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

> Nutrition Sciences Program

> School of Public Health and Community Medicine

> Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

>

> Affiliate Associate Professor

> School of Pharmacy

>

> MS Student

> Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

> School of Nursing

>

> University of Washington

> Seattle, WA

> charnepa@... <mailto:charnepa%40u.washington.edu> on.edu

> http://www.linkedin <http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney>

> .com/in/pamcharney

>

> " The person who says it can't be done should not

> interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

>

>

>

> > Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with

> the

> > President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

> > it

> > works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

> > overhaul

> > the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

> > not afford

> > it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

> > those who

> > do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10

> million

> > working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not

> just

> > address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

> > realize there are many problems with our current system however we

> > still do

> > have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

> > and it

> > is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

> > foreign

> > country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

> > is

> > being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

> > drop a

> > couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

> > frequent

> > visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

> > recently had

> > the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

> > anyone

> > running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

> >

> > Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

> > to the

> > Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

> >

> > Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

> >

> > Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

> >

> > Natural Health Concepts

> >

> > Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

> >

> > Complementary & Alternative Medicine

> >

> > Bios Life Slim

> >

> > Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

> >

> > Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

> >

> > www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

> >

> > _____

> >

> > From: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

> [mailto:rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com] On

> > Behalf Of

> > Dineright4aol (DOT) <mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com> com

> > Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

> > To: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

> > Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

> >

> > FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

> >

> > YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL)

> DURING

> > THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

> >

> > " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

> > CARE

> > PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

> > REST OF

> > US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

> >

> > THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

> > NOT TO

> > ANSWER IT !!!...

> >

> > IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

> > THERE

> > RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

> >

> > AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

> > HEALTH

> > CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

> > ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

> >

> > SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

> > NOT

> > GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

> > PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

> > TOTALLY

> > WRONG

> > !!!!!

> >

> > PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

> > EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

> > WASHINGTON

> > " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

> >

> > IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

> > OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

> > POLITICIANS

> > MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

> >

> > Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

> > Director of Medical Nutrition

> > Signet Diagnostic Corporation

> >

> > Fax:

> > DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com> com

> >

> >

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kathy,

I'm glad you have the time to respond in such detail. All I will say

is that if we had universal coverage your brother wouldn't be without

health insurance. If you are lacking health insurance, try to get an

appointment at the Cleveland Clinic or Mayo Clinic. I'm aware that

both provide charity care but that pot of money is shrinking rapidly

and very difficult to access if you happen to have a costly condition.

Unless we have meaningful discussion, none of the issues you raise

will be fixed. Would you rather continue as we are and thus have

fodder for ranting and raving or would you rather begin the arduous

process of improving care.

There are now over 20 nations that have better health outcomes than we

do. We are not even in the top 10 in infant mortality rates (meaning

that there are over 10 countries that have lower infant mortality than

we do). We rank lower than 15th in terms of other health outcomes.

Let's just look at one example; fewer than 50% of individuals who have

diabetes receive care at even what is considered minimal by health

standards.

Regards,

pam

Pam Charney

pcharney@...

" If all you ever do is all you've ever done, then all you'll ever get

is all you ever got " - Anonymous

> Pam: I apologize in advance for the length of this reply - it could

> have

> been much longer.

>

> Where in the world can an individual get better care? I absolutely

> agree

> with you that the cost of our health care is outrageous - twice that

> of any

> other developed country. However, let's look at why. Do you think that

> maybe malpractice and lawsuits are adding obscene amounts of money

> to our

> care? There is no tort reform in the current proposal. WHY? That

> should

> be number one on the list. What about fraud? It is so rampant in the

> Medicare/Medicaid system it adds billions of dollars every year. How

> about

> controlling that? The government currently runs Medicare and

> Medicaid and

> does a pathetic job of controlling fraud. EX: a dentist in NY that

> billed

> for 928 procedures in one day. I'd rather have a CZAR overseeing

> that than

> making decisions for any of our citizens regarding personal health

> care.

> Who wrote this bill - does anyone know? Politicians and God only

> knows who

> else. Do you think that it might be more responsible for the

> government to

> convene a task force of Health Care Professionals to identify the

> problems

> with the current system and then make recommendations for

> improvement? Why

> is this bunch ram roding this thru the Congress without giving the

> citizens

> of the country time to READ IT( what a novel thought) and comment on

> it.

> This is our health and our tax dollars NOT the government's. As far

> as our

> members of Congress what have they done to deserve such health care?

> It is

> hardly short sighted or childish to believe that ALL Americans are

> created

> equally and deserve the same care. As far as outcomes the survival

> rates

> for many forms of cancer and other diseases are much higher here in

> the US.

> Statistics are very misleading and can be interpreted in many ways.

> As far

> as the numbers go, I agree that more people are becoming uninsured

> due to

> unemployment. However, I do not consider illegals part of the number

> - we

> should not reward people for breaking US law. I also do not consider

> those

> that are working and could have a policy but choose not to part of the

> number. Personal responsibility has been totally lost. The

> government and

> bankruptcy courts have contributed to MANY newly uninsured

> individuals by

> making rulings that I believe are unlawful and unconstitutional. Let

> me

> give you an example. My brother worked for GM for over 20 years and

> was

> then spun of as Delphi. His pension and health care was guaranteed.

> Then

> Delphi went into bankruptcy and the judge ruled against the salaried

> employees. They have lost their pensions and their healthcare. The

> Union

> employees did not. The governments " controlled bankruptcy's of the

> auto

> company's have been unlawful and broken the law. They are paying

> back their

> supporters at the detriment of those who should have been first in

> line. I

> do not want the government becoming any more involved in the lives

> of US

> citizens.

>

> Now why not take some very successful US models and pattern reform

> after

> them. The Mayo Clinic and the Cleveland Clinic are two of the top

> rated

> facilities in the world - excellent outcomes with lower costs.

>

> Or how about listening to Mr. Burd the CEO of Safeway, who by

> the way

> has addressed our esteemed Senators regarding the Health Care

> Program he has

> instituted at Safeway for his employees. Since 2005 with the new

> initiative

> they have held their costs FLAT!!! While health care has increased

> at an

> average of what maybe 40% over this time? Safeway promotes wellness

> and

> prevention and recognizes that we need to insist on personal

> responsibility

> since 70% of costs are behavior and lifestyle driven.

>

> I agree that it is important to have correct information. I have yet

> to see

> it come out of Washington. I do not want socialized medicine - that

> is the

> eventual intent. My Father - A WWII Vet would be dead today in most

> countries - esp. in Europe and Canada, and if this proposed plan had

> been

> in effect the last 5 years. I do not want anyone in Washington

> dictating

> his care.

>

> I have been reading the actual bill. I also have been listening to the

> philosophical opinions previously stated by those involved in this

> reform.

> When you take into account all the information available, it is

> frightening

> at best.

>

> Lastly before taking anything as gospel from the White House

> consider the

> " Stimulus " . I heard the President actually say last week - with a

> straight

> face - that they passed a $787 billion dollar stimulus package with

> " NO PORK

> OR EARMARKS " !!! Have you read that one??? Did anyone??? Just look at

> the

> trash in that bill for Pelosi's district. I sure want them

> determining my

> health care.

>

> Thanks for the lively debate. Kathy

>

> Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

>

> Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

>

> Natural Health Concepts

>

> Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

>

> Complementary & Alternative Medicine

>

> Bios Life Slim

>

> Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

>

> Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

>

> www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

>

> _____

>

> From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On

> Behalf Of

> Pam Charney

> Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 1:14 PM

> To: rd-usa

> Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>

> Kathy,

>

> With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

> health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

> perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

> What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

> other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

> yet we have subpar results.

>

> I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

> uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

> current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

> becoming one of those individuals.

>

> To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

> the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

> and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

> Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

> neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

> " do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

> their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

> Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

> get Congress to give up a perk or two.

>

> How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

> a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

> child in the U.S.?

>

> Pam Charney PhD, RD

> Clinical Coordinator

> Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

> Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

> Nutrition Sciences Program

> School of Public Health and Community Medicine

> Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

>

> Affiliate Associate Professor

> School of Pharmacy

>

> MS Student

> Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

> School of Nursing

>

> University of Washington

> Seattle, WA

> charnepa@... <mailto:charnepa%40u.washington.edu> on.edu

> http://www.linkedin <http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney>

> .com/in/pamcharney

>

> " The person who says it can't be done should not

> interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

>

>

>

> > Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with

> the

> > President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

> > it

> > works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

> > overhaul

> > the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

> > not afford

> > it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

> > those who

> > do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10

> million

> > working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not

> just

> > address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

> > realize there are many problems with our current system however we

> > still do

> > have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

> > and it

> > is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

> > foreign

> > country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

> > is

> > being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

> > drop a

> > couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

> > frequent

> > visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

> > recently had

> > the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

> > anyone

> > running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

> >

> > Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

> > to the

> > Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

> >

> > Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

> >

> > Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

> >

> > Natural Health Concepts

> >

> > Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

> >

> > Complementary & Alternative Medicine

> >

> > Bios Life Slim

> >

> > Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

> >

> > Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

> >

> > www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

> >

> > _____

> >

> > From: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

> [mailto:rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com] On

> > Behalf Of

> > Dineright4aol (DOT) <mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com> com

> > Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

> > To: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

> > Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

> >

> > FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

> >

> > YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL)

> DURING

> > THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

> >

> > " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

> > CARE

> > PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

> > REST OF

> > US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

> >

> > THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

> > NOT TO

> > ANSWER IT !!!...

> >

> > IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

> > THERE

> > RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

> >

> > AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

> > HEALTH

> > CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

> > ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

> >

> > SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

> > NOT

> > GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

> > PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

> > TOTALLY

> > WRONG

> > !!!!!

> >

> > PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

> > EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

> > WASHINGTON

> > " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

> >

> > IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

> > OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

> > POLITICIANS

> > MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

> >

> > Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

> > Director of Medical Nutrition

> > Signet Diagnostic Corporation

> >

> > Fax:

> > DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com> com

> >

> >

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kathy,

I'm glad you have the time to respond in such detail. All I will say

is that if we had universal coverage your brother wouldn't be without

health insurance. If you are lacking health insurance, try to get an

appointment at the Cleveland Clinic or Mayo Clinic. I'm aware that

both provide charity care but that pot of money is shrinking rapidly

and very difficult to access if you happen to have a costly condition.

Unless we have meaningful discussion, none of the issues you raise

will be fixed. Would you rather continue as we are and thus have

fodder for ranting and raving or would you rather begin the arduous

process of improving care.

There are now over 20 nations that have better health outcomes than we

do. We are not even in the top 10 in infant mortality rates (meaning

that there are over 10 countries that have lower infant mortality than

we do). We rank lower than 15th in terms of other health outcomes.

Let's just look at one example; fewer than 50% of individuals who have

diabetes receive care at even what is considered minimal by health

standards.

Regards,

pam

Pam Charney

pcharney@...

" If all you ever do is all you've ever done, then all you'll ever get

is all you ever got " - Anonymous

> Pam: I apologize in advance for the length of this reply - it could

> have

> been much longer.

>

> Where in the world can an individual get better care? I absolutely

> agree

> with you that the cost of our health care is outrageous - twice that

> of any

> other developed country. However, let's look at why. Do you think that

> maybe malpractice and lawsuits are adding obscene amounts of money

> to our

> care? There is no tort reform in the current proposal. WHY? That

> should

> be number one on the list. What about fraud? It is so rampant in the

> Medicare/Medicaid system it adds billions of dollars every year. How

> about

> controlling that? The government currently runs Medicare and

> Medicaid and

> does a pathetic job of controlling fraud. EX: a dentist in NY that

> billed

> for 928 procedures in one day. I'd rather have a CZAR overseeing

> that than

> making decisions for any of our citizens regarding personal health

> care.

> Who wrote this bill - does anyone know? Politicians and God only

> knows who

> else. Do you think that it might be more responsible for the

> government to

> convene a task force of Health Care Professionals to identify the

> problems

> with the current system and then make recommendations for

> improvement? Why

> is this bunch ram roding this thru the Congress without giving the

> citizens

> of the country time to READ IT( what a novel thought) and comment on

> it.

> This is our health and our tax dollars NOT the government's. As far

> as our

> members of Congress what have they done to deserve such health care?

> It is

> hardly short sighted or childish to believe that ALL Americans are

> created

> equally and deserve the same care. As far as outcomes the survival

> rates

> for many forms of cancer and other diseases are much higher here in

> the US.

> Statistics are very misleading and can be interpreted in many ways.

> As far

> as the numbers go, I agree that more people are becoming uninsured

> due to

> unemployment. However, I do not consider illegals part of the number

> - we

> should not reward people for breaking US law. I also do not consider

> those

> that are working and could have a policy but choose not to part of the

> number. Personal responsibility has been totally lost. The

> government and

> bankruptcy courts have contributed to MANY newly uninsured

> individuals by

> making rulings that I believe are unlawful and unconstitutional. Let

> me

> give you an example. My brother worked for GM for over 20 years and

> was

> then spun of as Delphi. His pension and health care was guaranteed.

> Then

> Delphi went into bankruptcy and the judge ruled against the salaried

> employees. They have lost their pensions and their healthcare. The

> Union

> employees did not. The governments " controlled bankruptcy's of the

> auto

> company's have been unlawful and broken the law. They are paying

> back their

> supporters at the detriment of those who should have been first in

> line. I

> do not want the government becoming any more involved in the lives

> of US

> citizens.

>

> Now why not take some very successful US models and pattern reform

> after

> them. The Mayo Clinic and the Cleveland Clinic are two of the top

> rated

> facilities in the world - excellent outcomes with lower costs.

>

> Or how about listening to Mr. Burd the CEO of Safeway, who by

> the way

> has addressed our esteemed Senators regarding the Health Care

> Program he has

> instituted at Safeway for his employees. Since 2005 with the new

> initiative

> they have held their costs FLAT!!! While health care has increased

> at an

> average of what maybe 40% over this time? Safeway promotes wellness

> and

> prevention and recognizes that we need to insist on personal

> responsibility

> since 70% of costs are behavior and lifestyle driven.

>

> I agree that it is important to have correct information. I have yet

> to see

> it come out of Washington. I do not want socialized medicine - that

> is the

> eventual intent. My Father - A WWII Vet would be dead today in most

> countries - esp. in Europe and Canada, and if this proposed plan had

> been

> in effect the last 5 years. I do not want anyone in Washington

> dictating

> his care.

>

> I have been reading the actual bill. I also have been listening to the

> philosophical opinions previously stated by those involved in this

> reform.

> When you take into account all the information available, it is

> frightening

> at best.

>

> Lastly before taking anything as gospel from the White House

> consider the

> " Stimulus " . I heard the President actually say last week - with a

> straight

> face - that they passed a $787 billion dollar stimulus package with

> " NO PORK

> OR EARMARKS " !!! Have you read that one??? Did anyone??? Just look at

> the

> trash in that bill for Pelosi's district. I sure want them

> determining my

> health care.

>

> Thanks for the lively debate. Kathy

>

> Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

>

> Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

>

> Natural Health Concepts

>

> Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

>

> Complementary & Alternative Medicine

>

> Bios Life Slim

>

> Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

>

> Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

>

> www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

>

> _____

>

> From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On

> Behalf Of

> Pam Charney

> Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 1:14 PM

> To: rd-usa

> Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>

> Kathy,

>

> With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

> health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

> perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

> What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

> other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

> yet we have subpar results.

>

> I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

> uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

> current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

> becoming one of those individuals.

>

> To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

> the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

> and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

> Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

> neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

> " do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

> their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

> Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

> get Congress to give up a perk or two.

>

> How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

> a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

> child in the U.S.?

>

> Pam Charney PhD, RD

> Clinical Coordinator

> Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

> Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

> Nutrition Sciences Program

> School of Public Health and Community Medicine

> Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

>

> Affiliate Associate Professor

> School of Pharmacy

>

> MS Student

> Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

> School of Nursing

>

> University of Washington

> Seattle, WA

> charnepa@... <mailto:charnepa%40u.washington.edu> on.edu

> http://www.linkedin <http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney>

> .com/in/pamcharney

>

> " The person who says it can't be done should not

> interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

>

>

>

> > Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with

> the

> > President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

> > it

> > works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

> > overhaul

> > the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

> > not afford

> > it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

> > those who

> > do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10

> million

> > working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not

> just

> > address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

> > realize there are many problems with our current system however we

> > still do

> > have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

> > and it

> > is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

> > foreign

> > country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

> > is

> > being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

> > drop a

> > couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

> > frequent

> > visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

> > recently had

> > the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

> > anyone

> > running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

> >

> > Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

> > to the

> > Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

> >

> > Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

> >

> > Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

> >

> > Natural Health Concepts

> >

> > Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

> >

> > Complementary & Alternative Medicine

> >

> > Bios Life Slim

> >

> > Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

> >

> > Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

> >

> > www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

> >

> > _____

> >

> > From: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

> [mailto:rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com] On

> > Behalf Of

> > Dineright4aol (DOT) <mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com> com

> > Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

> > To: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

> > Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

> >

> > FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

> >

> > YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL)

> DURING

> > THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

> >

> > " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

> > CARE

> > PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

> > REST OF

> > US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

> >

> > THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

> > NOT TO

> > ANSWER IT !!!...

> >

> > IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

> > THERE

> > RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

> >

> > AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

> > HEALTH

> > CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

> > ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

> >

> > SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

> > NOT

> > GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

> > PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

> > TOTALLY

> > WRONG

> > !!!!!

> >

> > PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

> > EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

> > WASHINGTON

> > " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

> >

> > IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

> > OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

> > POLITICIANS

> > MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

> >

> > Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

> > Director of Medical Nutrition

> > Signet Diagnostic Corporation

> >

> > Fax:

> > DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com> com

> >

> >

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jen: The problem is that the government will have our tax dollars to

undercut the private plans and eventually run them out. That is not free

enterprise. Any time you get the government involved you smother free

enterprise. I also agree that there are significant issues with the

insurance companies. But government intervention is not the solution.

Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

Natural Health Concepts

Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

Complementary & Alternative Medicine

Bios Life Slim

Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

_____

From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On Behalf Of

Jen Zingaro

Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 2:23 PM

To: rd-usa

Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

Oh, and I used to work for County government. It was the best healthcare

plan that I ever had.

On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 3:22 PM, Jen Zingaro <jenzingarogmail (DOT)

<mailto:jenzingaro%40gmail.com> com> wrote:

> It's been said before then. Let those who need the public option have at

> it.

> If it's not competitive, it won't be popular and then health insurance

> companies don't

> have to worry about it. Why are we as a free market enterprise afraid of

> it. It's just

> another option for people to have. You don't have to have it. It's not

> going to be

> free for others, it's just another healthcare option?

>

> I don't know if you can really compare the post office and amtrak. It's

> sort of like apples

> and oranges. Fedex and UPS do just fine, and then there's the post office

> that you can use

> if you want to. I personally like the service at the post office. It's

> not for everyone but it's an option.

>

> I'm certain we'll all be using Medicare at some point? It's not a perfect

> system, but it's better than trying

> to find private insurance on your own when you are older and have

> preexisitng conditions.

>

> On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 3:15 PM, Rowell, <drowell@...

<mailto:drowell%40mt.gov> > wrote:

>

>>

>>

>> If I could opt out of my State provided health care insurance and use the

>> same money for HSAs and catastrophic care, I would. We DO have the best

>> healthcare in the world. I don't see anyone leaving the country to get

>> better care or faster service. I see just the opposite. If we could get

the

>> government out of our current health care, it would be dramatically

better.

>> What does government run better than the private sector? Amtrak, postal

>> service? Of course not. They don't have to make a profit. That's why the

>> private option will go away. They won't be able to compete. The

government

>> can just take all the money they need from the taxpayer to keep it going,

>> poor service or not.

>>

>> " If you think health care is expensive now, wait until you see what it

>> costs when it's free. " --P.J. O'Rourke

>>

>> W. Rowell, RD, LN

>> Montana State Hospital, Warm Spring, MT

>> Consultant Dietitian, Long Term Care

>> Certified LEAP Therapist

>>

>> ________________________________

>> From: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> [mailto:

>> rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>] On Behalf Of Jen

>> Zingaro

>> Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 12:58 PM

>> To: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

>> Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>>

>> Very well said Pam.

>>

>> I can't believe how many RD's who work in healthcare system honestly feel

>> that

>> our system is the best healthcare in the world? When did this country

>> become

>> " what's in it for me? "

>>

>> I am lucky to be offered decent healthcare at my job. But I had to pay

>> $100

>> more

>> dollars a month this year to keep it... my raise didn't even cover that.

>> But at least

>> I have health insurance.

>>

>> It's truly sad that we live in a system where having healthcare depends

on

>> you

>> needing to have a job. What about consultants, say RD's? Wouldn' t it be

>> nice if

>> we didn't have to worry about keeping FT employment to have health

>> benefits...think

>> about all the opportunities that would open up to us for doing different

>> things.

>>

>> On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 2:14 PM, Pam Charney <pcharneymac (DOT)

<mailto:pcharney%40mac.com> com<pcharney%40mac.com>

>> <mailto:pcharney%40mac.com <pcharney%2540mac.com>>> wrote:

>>

>> >

>> >

>> > Kathy,

>> >

>> > With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

>> > health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

>> > perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

>> > What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

>> > other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

>> > yet we have subpar results.

>> >

>> > I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

>> > uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

>> > current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

>> > becoming one of those individuals.

>> >

>> > To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

>> > the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

>> > and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

>> > Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

>> > neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

>> > " do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

>> > their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

>> > Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

>> > get Congress to give up a perk or two.

>> >

>> > How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

>> > a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

>> > child in the U.S.?

>> >

>> > Pam Charney PhD, RD

>> > Clinical Coordinator

>> > Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

>> > Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

>> > Nutrition Sciences Program

>> > School of Public Health and Community Medicine

>> > Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

>> >

>> > Affiliate Associate Professor

>> > School of Pharmacy

>> >

>> > MS Student

>> > Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

>> > School of Nursing

>> >

>> > University of Washington

>> > Seattle, WA

>> > charnepa@... <mailto:charnepa%40u.washington.edu> on.edu

<charnepa%40u.washington.edu><mailto:

>> charnepa%40u.washington.edu <charnepa%2540u.washington.edu>> <charnepa%

>> 40u.washington.edu>

>>

>> > http://www.linkedin <http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney>

..com/in/pamcharney

>> >

>> > " The person who says it can't be done should not

>> > interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

>> >

>> >

>> >

>> >

>> > > Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with

the

>> > > President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

>> > > it

>> > > works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

>> > > overhaul

>> > > the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

>> > > not afford

>> > > it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

>> > > those who

>> > > do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10

million

>> > > working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not

just

>> > > address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

>> > > realize there are many problems with our current system however we

>> > > still do

>> > > have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

>> > > and it

>> > > is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

>> > > foreign

>> > > country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

>> > > is

>> > > being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

>> > > drop a

>> > > couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

>> > > frequent

>> > > visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

>> > > recently had

>> > > the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

>> > > anyone

>> > > running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

>> > >

>> > > Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

>> > > to the

>> > > Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

>> > >

>> > > Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

>> > >

>> > > Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

>> > >

>> > > Natural Health Concepts

>> > >

>> > > Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

>> > >

>> > > Complementary & Alternative Medicine

>> > >

>> > > Bios Life Slim

>> > >

>> > > Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

>> > >

>> > > Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

>> > >

>> > > www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

>> > >

>> > > _____

>> > >

>> > > From: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

>> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

>> 40yahoogroups.com> [mailto:

>> > rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

>> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

>> 40yahoogroups.com>] On

>> > > Behalf Of

>> > > Dineright4aol (DOT) <mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com> com

<Dineright4%40aol.com><mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com<Dineright4%2540aol.com>>

>> <Dineright4%40aol.com>

>> > > Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

>> > > To: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

>> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

>> 40yahoogroups.com>

>>

>> > > Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>> > >

>> > > FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

>> > >

>> > > YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL)

DURING

>> > > THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

>> > >

>> > > " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

>> > > CARE

>> > > PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

>> > > REST OF

>> > > US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

>> > >

>> > > THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

>> > > NOT TO

>> > > ANSWER IT !!!...

>> > >

>> > > IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

>> > > THERE

>> > > RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

>> > >

>> > > AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

>> > > HEALTH

>> > > CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

>> > > ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

>> > >

>> > > SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

>> > > NOT

>> > > GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

>> > > PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

>> > > TOTALLY

>> > > WRONG

>> > > !!!!!

>> > >

>> > > PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

>> > > EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

>> > > WASHINGTON

>> > > " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

>> > >

>> > > IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

>> > > OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

>> > > POLITICIANS

>> > > MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

>> > >

>> > > Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

>> > > Director of Medical Nutrition

>> > > Signet Diagnostic Corporation

>> > >

>> > > Fax:

>> > > DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com

<DineRight4%2540aol.com><DineRight4%

>> 2540aol.com>>

>> > com

>> > >

>> > >

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jen: The problem is that the government will have our tax dollars to

undercut the private plans and eventually run them out. That is not free

enterprise. Any time you get the government involved you smother free

enterprise. I also agree that there are significant issues with the

insurance companies. But government intervention is not the solution.

Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

Natural Health Concepts

Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

Complementary & Alternative Medicine

Bios Life Slim

Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

_____

From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On Behalf Of

Jen Zingaro

Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 2:23 PM

To: rd-usa

Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

Oh, and I used to work for County government. It was the best healthcare

plan that I ever had.

On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 3:22 PM, Jen Zingaro <jenzingarogmail (DOT)

<mailto:jenzingaro%40gmail.com> com> wrote:

> It's been said before then. Let those who need the public option have at

> it.

> If it's not competitive, it won't be popular and then health insurance

> companies don't

> have to worry about it. Why are we as a free market enterprise afraid of

> it. It's just

> another option for people to have. You don't have to have it. It's not

> going to be

> free for others, it's just another healthcare option?

>

> I don't know if you can really compare the post office and amtrak. It's

> sort of like apples

> and oranges. Fedex and UPS do just fine, and then there's the post office

> that you can use

> if you want to. I personally like the service at the post office. It's

> not for everyone but it's an option.

>

> I'm certain we'll all be using Medicare at some point? It's not a perfect

> system, but it's better than trying

> to find private insurance on your own when you are older and have

> preexisitng conditions.

>

> On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 3:15 PM, Rowell, <drowell@...

<mailto:drowell%40mt.gov> > wrote:

>

>>

>>

>> If I could opt out of my State provided health care insurance and use the

>> same money for HSAs and catastrophic care, I would. We DO have the best

>> healthcare in the world. I don't see anyone leaving the country to get

>> better care or faster service. I see just the opposite. If we could get

the

>> government out of our current health care, it would be dramatically

better.

>> What does government run better than the private sector? Amtrak, postal

>> service? Of course not. They don't have to make a profit. That's why the

>> private option will go away. They won't be able to compete. The

government

>> can just take all the money they need from the taxpayer to keep it going,

>> poor service or not.

>>

>> " If you think health care is expensive now, wait until you see what it

>> costs when it's free. " --P.J. O'Rourke

>>

>> W. Rowell, RD, LN

>> Montana State Hospital, Warm Spring, MT

>> Consultant Dietitian, Long Term Care

>> Certified LEAP Therapist

>>

>> ________________________________

>> From: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> [mailto:

>> rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>] On Behalf Of Jen

>> Zingaro

>> Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 12:58 PM

>> To: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

>> Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>>

>> Very well said Pam.

>>

>> I can't believe how many RD's who work in healthcare system honestly feel

>> that

>> our system is the best healthcare in the world? When did this country

>> become

>> " what's in it for me? "

>>

>> I am lucky to be offered decent healthcare at my job. But I had to pay

>> $100

>> more

>> dollars a month this year to keep it... my raise didn't even cover that.

>> But at least

>> I have health insurance.

>>

>> It's truly sad that we live in a system where having healthcare depends

on

>> you

>> needing to have a job. What about consultants, say RD's? Wouldn' t it be

>> nice if

>> we didn't have to worry about keeping FT employment to have health

>> benefits...think

>> about all the opportunities that would open up to us for doing different

>> things.

>>

>> On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 2:14 PM, Pam Charney <pcharneymac (DOT)

<mailto:pcharney%40mac.com> com<pcharney%40mac.com>

>> <mailto:pcharney%40mac.com <pcharney%2540mac.com>>> wrote:

>>

>> >

>> >

>> > Kathy,

>> >

>> > With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

>> > health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

>> > perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

>> > What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

>> > other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

>> > yet we have subpar results.

>> >

>> > I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

>> > uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

>> > current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

>> > becoming one of those individuals.

>> >

>> > To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

>> > the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

>> > and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

>> > Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

>> > neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

>> > " do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

>> > their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

>> > Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

>> > get Congress to give up a perk or two.

>> >

>> > How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

>> > a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

>> > child in the U.S.?

>> >

>> > Pam Charney PhD, RD

>> > Clinical Coordinator

>> > Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

>> > Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

>> > Nutrition Sciences Program

>> > School of Public Health and Community Medicine

>> > Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

>> >

>> > Affiliate Associate Professor

>> > School of Pharmacy

>> >

>> > MS Student

>> > Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

>> > School of Nursing

>> >

>> > University of Washington

>> > Seattle, WA

>> > charnepa@... <mailto:charnepa%40u.washington.edu> on.edu

<charnepa%40u.washington.edu><mailto:

>> charnepa%40u.washington.edu <charnepa%2540u.washington.edu>> <charnepa%

>> 40u.washington.edu>

>>

>> > http://www.linkedin <http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney>

..com/in/pamcharney

>> >

>> > " The person who says it can't be done should not

>> > interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

>> >

>> >

>> >

>> >

>> > > Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with

the

>> > > President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

>> > > it

>> > > works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

>> > > overhaul

>> > > the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

>> > > not afford

>> > > it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

>> > > those who

>> > > do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10

million

>> > > working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not

just

>> > > address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

>> > > realize there are many problems with our current system however we

>> > > still do

>> > > have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

>> > > and it

>> > > is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

>> > > foreign

>> > > country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

>> > > is

>> > > being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

>> > > drop a

>> > > couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

>> > > frequent

>> > > visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

>> > > recently had

>> > > the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

>> > > anyone

>> > > running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

>> > >

>> > > Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

>> > > to the

>> > > Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

>> > >

>> > > Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

>> > >

>> > > Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

>> > >

>> > > Natural Health Concepts

>> > >

>> > > Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

>> > >

>> > > Complementary & Alternative Medicine

>> > >

>> > > Bios Life Slim

>> > >

>> > > Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

>> > >

>> > > Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

>> > >

>> > > www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

>> > >

>> > > _____

>> > >

>> > > From: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

>> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

>> 40yahoogroups.com> [mailto:

>> > rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

>> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

>> 40yahoogroups.com>] On

>> > > Behalf Of

>> > > Dineright4aol (DOT) <mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com> com

<Dineright4%40aol.com><mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com<Dineright4%2540aol.com>>

>> <Dineright4%40aol.com>

>> > > Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

>> > > To: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

<rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com><mailto:

>> rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com <rd-usa%2540yahoogroups.com>> <rd-usa%

>> 40yahoogroups.com>

>>

>> > > Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

>> > >

>> > > FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

>> > >

>> > > YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL)

DURING

>> > > THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

>> > >

>> > > " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

>> > > CARE

>> > > PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

>> > > REST OF

>> > > US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

>> > >

>> > > THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

>> > > NOT TO

>> > > ANSWER IT !!!...

>> > >

>> > > IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

>> > > THERE

>> > > RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

>> > >

>> > > AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

>> > > HEALTH

>> > > CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

>> > > ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

>> > >

>> > > SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

>> > > NOT

>> > > GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

>> > > PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

>> > > TOTALLY

>> > > WRONG

>> > > !!!!!

>> > >

>> > > PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

>> > > EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

>> > > WASHINGTON

>> > > " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

>> > >

>> > > IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

>> > > OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

>> > > POLITICIANS

>> > > MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

>> > >

>> > > Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

>> > > Director of Medical Nutrition

>> > > Signet Diagnostic Corporation

>> > >

>> > > Fax:

>> > > DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com

<DineRight4%2540aol.com><DineRight4%

>> 2540aol.com>>

>> > com

>> > >

>> > >

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Related to the comment that having healthcare depends on having a job.

Years ago people did not have health care insurance with their jobs. My

father had 4 kids and paid for it without insurance, all our illness, any

surgeries, etc. Before everyone jumps on this - I understand it cost much

less then, BUT salaries were much less also. He was a blue collar worker who

put the health and welfare of his family before all else. How many people

today who " can't afford healthcare " are buying things they really could live

without?? Cell phones, iPods, cigarettes, beer, etc. How about setting

priorities? We have become an out of control entitlement society. Over the

years such " benefits " as health care, vacation, holidays were used as

incentives to attract employees. I realize that this discussion includes

individuals of all ages - I suspect our perspective varies based on age.

Kathy

Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

Natural Health Concepts

Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

Complementary & Alternative Medicine

Bios Life Slim

Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

_____

From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On Behalf Of

Rowell,

Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 2:16 PM

To: 'rd-usa '

Subject: RE: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

If I could opt out of my State provided health care insurance and use the

same money for HSAs and catastrophic care, I would. We DO have the best

healthcare in the world. I don't see anyone leaving the country to get

better care or faster service. I see just the opposite. If we could get the

government out of our current health care, it would be dramatically better.

What does government run better than the private sector? Amtrak, postal

service? Of course not. They don't have to make a profit. That's why the

private option will go away. They won't be able to compete. The government

can just take all the money they need from the taxpayer to keep it going,

poor service or not.

" If you think health care is expensive now, wait until you see what it costs

when it's free. " --P.J. O'Rourke

W. Rowell, RD, LN

Montana State Hospital, Warm Spring, MT

Consultant Dietitian, Long Term Care

Certified LEAP Therapist

________________________________

From: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

[mailto:rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com] On Behalf

Of Jen Zingaro

Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 12:58 PM

To: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

Very well said Pam.

I can't believe how many RD's who work in healthcare system honestly feel

that

our system is the best healthcare in the world? When did this country

become

" what's in it for me? "

I am lucky to be offered decent healthcare at my job. But I had to pay $100

more

dollars a month this year to keep it... my raise didn't even cover that.

But at least

I have health insurance.

It's truly sad that we live in a system where having healthcare depends on

you

needing to have a job. What about consultants, say RD's? Wouldn' t it be

nice if

we didn't have to worry about keeping FT employment to have health

benefits...think

about all the opportunities that would open up to us for doing different

things.

On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 2:14 PM, Pam Charney <pcharneymac (DOT)

<mailto:pcharney%40mac.com> com<mailto:pcharney%40mac.com>> wrote:

>

>

> Kathy,

>

> With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

> health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

> perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

> What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

> other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

> yet we have subpar results.

>

> I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

> uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

> current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

> becoming one of those individuals.

>

> To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

> the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

> and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

> Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

> neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

> " do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

> their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

> Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

> get Congress to give up a perk or two.

>

> How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

> a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

> child in the U.S.?

>

> Pam Charney PhD, RD

> Clinical Coordinator

> Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

> Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

> Nutrition Sciences Program

> School of Public Health and Community Medicine

> Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

>

> Affiliate Associate Professor

> School of Pharmacy

>

> MS Student

> Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

> School of Nursing

>

> University of Washington

> Seattle, WA

> charnepa@... <mailto:charnepa%40u.washington.edu>

on.edu<mailto:charnepa%40u.washington.edu> <charnepa%40u.washington.edu>

> http://www.linkedin <http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney>

..com/in/pamcharney

>

> " The person who says it can't be done should not

> interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

>

>

>

>

> > Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with the

> > President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

> > it

> > works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

> > overhaul

> > the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

> > not afford

> > it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

> > those who

> > do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10 million

> > working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not just

> > address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

> > realize there are many problems with our current system however we

> > still do

> > have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

> > and it

> > is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

> > foreign

> > country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

> > is

> > being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

> > drop a

> > couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

> > frequent

> > visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

> > recently had

> > the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

> > anyone

> > running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

> >

> > Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

> > to the

> > Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

> >

> > Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

> >

> > Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

> >

> > Natural Health Concepts

> >

> > Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

> >

> > Complementary & Alternative Medicine

> >

> > Bios Life Slim

> >

> > Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

> >

> > Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

> >

> > www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

> >

> > _____

> >

> > From: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

com<mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> [mailto:

> rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

com<mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>] On

> > Behalf Of

> > Dineright4aol (DOT) <mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com>

com<mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com> <Dineright4%40aol.com>

> > Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

> > To: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

com<mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

> > Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

> >

> > FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

> >

> > YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL) DURING

> > THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

> >

> > " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

> > CARE

> > PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

> > REST OF

> > US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

> >

> > THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

> > NOT TO

> > ANSWER IT !!!...

> >

> > IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

> > THERE

> > RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

> >

> > AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

> > HEALTH

> > CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

> > ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

> >

> > SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

> > NOT

> > GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

> > PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

> > TOTALLY

> > WRONG

> > !!!!!

> >

> > PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

> > EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

> > WASHINGTON

> > " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

> >

> > IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

> > OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

> > POLITICIANS

> > MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

> >

> > Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

> > Director of Medical Nutrition

> > Signet Diagnostic Corporation

> >

> > Fax:

> > DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com <DineRight4%2540aol.com>>

> com

> >

> >

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Related to the comment that having healthcare depends on having a job.

Years ago people did not have health care insurance with their jobs. My

father had 4 kids and paid for it without insurance, all our illness, any

surgeries, etc. Before everyone jumps on this - I understand it cost much

less then, BUT salaries were much less also. He was a blue collar worker who

put the health and welfare of his family before all else. How many people

today who " can't afford healthcare " are buying things they really could live

without?? Cell phones, iPods, cigarettes, beer, etc. How about setting

priorities? We have become an out of control entitlement society. Over the

years such " benefits " as health care, vacation, holidays were used as

incentives to attract employees. I realize that this discussion includes

individuals of all ages - I suspect our perspective varies based on age.

Kathy

Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

Natural Health Concepts

Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

Complementary & Alternative Medicine

Bios Life Slim

Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

_____

From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On Behalf Of

Rowell,

Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 2:16 PM

To: 'rd-usa '

Subject: RE: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

If I could opt out of my State provided health care insurance and use the

same money for HSAs and catastrophic care, I would. We DO have the best

healthcare in the world. I don't see anyone leaving the country to get

better care or faster service. I see just the opposite. If we could get the

government out of our current health care, it would be dramatically better.

What does government run better than the private sector? Amtrak, postal

service? Of course not. They don't have to make a profit. That's why the

private option will go away. They won't be able to compete. The government

can just take all the money they need from the taxpayer to keep it going,

poor service or not.

" If you think health care is expensive now, wait until you see what it costs

when it's free. " --P.J. O'Rourke

W. Rowell, RD, LN

Montana State Hospital, Warm Spring, MT

Consultant Dietitian, Long Term Care

Certified LEAP Therapist

________________________________

From: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

[mailto:rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com] On Behalf

Of Jen Zingaro

Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 12:58 PM

To: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> com

Subject: Re: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

Very well said Pam.

I can't believe how many RD's who work in healthcare system honestly feel

that

our system is the best healthcare in the world? When did this country

become

" what's in it for me? "

I am lucky to be offered decent healthcare at my job. But I had to pay $100

more

dollars a month this year to keep it... my raise didn't even cover that.

But at least

I have health insurance.

It's truly sad that we live in a system where having healthcare depends on

you

needing to have a job. What about consultants, say RD's? Wouldn' t it be

nice if

we didn't have to worry about keeping FT employment to have health

benefits...think

about all the opportunities that would open up to us for doing different

things.

On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 2:14 PM, Pam Charney <pcharneymac (DOT)

<mailto:pcharney%40mac.com> com<mailto:pcharney%40mac.com>> wrote:

>

>

> Kathy,

>

> With all due respect, the U.S. most certainly does not have the best

> health care system in the world. We rank well below the top 10,

> perhaps even the top 20 in terms of outcomes of the care we provide.

> What we are number one for is the cost of that care. We outrank every

> other nation in the world in terms of what it costs to provide care,

> yet we have subpar results.

>

> I would also urge you to recheck your figures regarding the number of

> uninsured individuals. It is now over 47 million and growing in our

> current economic climate. We are all literally one job loss away from

> becoming one of those individuals.

>

> To advocate for trashing the entire proposal because you don't like

> the fact that Congress has a super duper health plan is short-sighted

> and childish at best. Am I happy with Congress's health insurance?

> Heck, no. I wish I had that coverage. But I also wish that my

> neighbors who are now unemployed did not have to make choices such as

> " do we pay the rent or do we go to the doctor? " I'll give Congress

> their pretty plan if it means I can also get my neighbors any plan.

> Hopefully through meaningful and respectful discussion we can maybe

> get Congress to give up a perk or two.

>

> How about joining the discussion armed with correct information and

> a desire to provide even basic health care for every man, woman, and

> child in the U.S.?

>

> Pam Charney PhD, RD

> Clinical Coordinator

> Graduate Coordinated Program in Dietetics

> Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology

> Nutrition Sciences Program

> School of Public Health and Community Medicine

> Box 353410, 306-C Raitt Hall

>

> Affiliate Associate Professor

> School of Pharmacy

>

> MS Student

> Clinical Informatics and Patient Centered Technology

> School of Nursing

>

> University of Washington

> Seattle, WA

> charnepa@... <mailto:charnepa%40u.washington.edu>

on.edu<mailto:charnepa%40u.washington.edu> <charnepa%40u.washington.edu>

> http://www.linkedin <http://www.linkedin.com/in/pamcharney>

..com/in/pamcharney

>

> " The person who says it can't be done should not

> interrupt the person doing it " - Ethel Kennedy

>

>

>

>

> > Jan: I could not agree with you more. Our government starting with the

> > President should be placed on this new health care program first. If

> > it

> > works, then they can sign the rest of us up!!! My question is why

> > overhaul

> > the entire system when a small number are truly uninsured and can

> > not afford

> > it. Remove the illegals, those who choose not to be insured and

> > those who

> > do not bother to sign up for benefits and an estimated 5 to 10 million

> > working poor are actually uninsured and require the help. Why not just

> > address these people?? Just another power grab by the government. I

> > realize there are many problems with our current system however we

> > still do

> > have the best health care in the world. I live here in Mayo country,

> > and it

> > is a common occurrence to have a 747 from Saudi Arabia or other

> > foreign

> > country sitting for several weeks at Rochester Airport while someone

> > is

> > being treated at the Clinic. In addition while they are here they

> > drop a

> > couple million in Rochester. Why ruin that?? King Hussein was a

> > frequent

> > visitor to the Mayo Clinic and died here. The Cleveland Clinic

> > recently had

> > the Prime Minister of Italy there for open heart surgery. Do you see

> > anyone

> > running to Canada or the UK for treatment???

> >

> > Have you attended any " Town Hall " meetings? I intend to go on Aug 22

> > to the

> > Rochester, MN meeting. Kathy

> >

> > Kathy C. Fielding, RD, LD

> >

> > Registered/Licensed Dietitian Nutritionist

> >

> > Natural Health Concepts

> >

> > Preventive Health Strategies & Wellness,

> >

> > Complementary & Alternative Medicine

> >

> > Bios Life Slim

> >

> > Lose Body Fat & Inches Naturally!

> >

> > Lower Cholesterol Naturally!

> >

> > www.bioslifeslim/kayceefielding

> >

> > _____

> >

> > From: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

com<mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> [mailto:

> rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

com<mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>] On

> > Behalf Of

> > Dineright4aol (DOT) <mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com>

com<mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com> <Dineright4%40aol.com>

> > Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 9:49 AM

> > To: rd-usayahoogroups (DOT) <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

com<mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> <rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com>

> > Subject: Re: FINALLY..... THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED.

> >

> > FINALLY...THE $64,000 QUESTION WAS ASKED...

> >

> > YESTERDAY ON " ABC-TV " (BETTER KNOWN AS THE ALL BARRACK CHANNEL) DURING

> > THE " NETWORK SPECIAL ON HEALTH CARE " .... OBAMA WAS ASKED:

> >

> > " MR. PRESIDENT WILL YOU AND YOUR FAMILY GIVE UP YOUR CURRENT HEALTH

> > CARE

> > PROGRAM AND JOIN THE NEW 'UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE PROGRAM' THAT THE

> > REST OF

> > US WILL BE ON ???? " ..... (BET YOU ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER)...

> >

> > THERE WAS A STONEY SILENCE AS OBAMA IGNORED THE QUESTION AND CHOSE

> > NOT TO

> > ANSWER IT !!!...

> >

> > IN ADDITION, A NUMBER OF SENATORS WERE ASKED T HE SAME QUESTION AND

> > THERE

> > RESPONSE WAS... " WE WILL THINK ABOUT IT. "

> >

> > AND THEY DID. IT WAS ANNOUNCED TODAY ON THE NEWS THAT THE " KENNEDY

> > HEALTH

> > CARE BILL " WAS WRITTEN INTO THE NEW HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE

> > ENSURING THAT CONGRESS WILL BE 100% EXEMPT !

> >

> > SO, THIS GREAT NEW HEALTH CARE PLAN THAT IS GOOD FOR YOU AND I... IS

> > NOT

> > GOOD ENOUGH FOR OBAMA, HIS FAMILY OR CONGRESS...?? WE (THE AMERICAN

> > PUBLIC) NEED TO STOP THIS PROPOSED DEBACLE ASAP !!!!... THIS IS

> > TOTALLY

> > WRONG

> > !!!!!

> >

> > PERSONALLY, I CAN ONLY ACCEPT A UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE OVERHAUL THAT

> > EXTENDS TO EVERYONE... NOT JUST US LOWLY CITIZENS... WHILE THE

> > WASHINGTON

> > " ELITE " KEEP RIGHT ON WITH THEIR GOLD-PLATED HEALTH CARE COVERAGES.

> >

> > IF YOU AGREE PLEASE PASS THIS O N ....IF NOT PLAN TO SUFFER WITH THE

> > OBAMA HEALTH CARE PLAN ...FOR FREE.... WHILE OUR SELF-SERVING

> > POLITICIANS

> > MAKE SURE THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF THEIR BUTTS AT OUR EXPENSE.

> >

> > Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT

> > Director of Medical Nutrition

> > Signet Diagnostic Corporation

> >

> > Fax:

> > DineRight4aol (DOT) <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com <DineRight4%2540aol.com>>

> com

> >

> >

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...