Guest guest Posted October 28, 2001 Report Share Posted October 28, 2001 We have a three year old daughter who has been diagnosed PDD-NOS. We were finally able to see a developmental specialist who ordered a number of lab tests, to the exclusion of mercury. We will be persistent and will have her tested whether it is with this doctor or another. I need to know from those who have gone through this how many children have actually tested positive? How has chellation therapy gone? Has anybody seen improvements in their children? My daughter is nonverbal, but seems very open to learning sign language. She makes almost no attempt to verbally communicate, but seems to understand almost everything I tell her. What are the classic symptoms of mercury poisoning that would distinguish themselves from the regular PDD-NOS/Austism spectrum disorder characteristics? Please post your experiences. I know it may be redundant, but I need the help and expertise of you parents. Thank you, Aliza Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted October 28, 2001 Report Share Posted October 28, 2001 Dear Aliza, Hello and welcome to this group. Most of the info you are seeking can be perused at your liesure in the " Files " section. In particular, please read the FAQ for info about diagnostic testing, and the " Love_Letters " file for many families' accounts of their children's response chelation. My son with autism is four, has now had seven rounds of DMSA-only chelation, and has made very exciting progress. The symptoms of autism/PDD-NOS in fact very closely parallel those of mercury poisoning. http://www.autism.com/ari/mercurylong.html is a long scientific paper that explores this subject in detail. If you'll indulge me in a suggestion that is not what you asked about, go back to your doctor and ask for a written diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) for your daughter, not PDD-NOS. I say this because sometimes Regional Centers (the state agency that should be helping you with obtaining services for her) and school districts will quibble about whether PDD-NOS is really a " qualifying diagnosis " whereas autism always is. Your doctor probably said PDD-NOS because your daughter is smart (based on her good receptive language ability); or as a way to sugar the pill and spare you from having to hear the dreaded A-word. Think of the word " autism " not as a death sentence or even a reliable predictor of her future, but as a meal ticket that will help you get her the services she needs. You're in the right " place " and your daughter is young enough that tremendous things are possible for her. If you will post where you live, you will probably find other parents nearby who can help you with local resources. PS One more unsolicited suggestion... the book Facing Autism by Lynn Hamilton does not address chelation, but except for that I think it's the best all-around book for parents of new diagnosees. I particularly recommend her chapter about " Ten Things You Can Do Right Now " -- for example signing her up ASAP on waiting lists all over town, since all the good service agencies invariably have long waits, and videotaping her for future comparison purposes. > We have a three year old daughter who has been diagnosed PDD-NOS. We > were finally able to see a developmental specialist who ordered a > number of lab tests, to the exclusion of mercury. We will be > persistent and will have her tested whether it is with this doctor or > another. > > I need to know from those who have gone through this how many > children have actually tested positive? How has chellation therapy > gone? Has anybody seen improvements in their children? My daughter > is nonverbal, but seems very open to learning sign language. She > makes almost no attempt to verbally communicate, but seems to > understand almost everything I tell her. > > What are the classic symptoms of mercury poisoning that would > distinguish themselves from the regular PDD-NOS/Austism spectrum > disorder characteristics? > > Please post your experiences. I know it may be redundant, but I need > the help and expertise of you parents. > > Thank you, > Aliza Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted October 28, 2001 Report Share Posted October 28, 2001 Dear Aliza, Welcome. I am entering my comments in between parts of your text: >We have a three year old daughter who has been diagnosed PDD-NOS. We >were finally able to see a developmental specialist who ordered a >number of lab tests, to the exclusion of mercury. We will be >persistent and will have her tested whether it is with this doctor or >another. Does your comment here indicate that you realize the test which " excluded mercury " may be inaccurate? I hope it does. Not all tests are inaccurate, but for the most part the ones that are ordered seem to be ones that are useless. If my comments do not make sense, please read the " counting rules " file (in the FILES section on the website). >I need to know from those who have gone through this how many >children have actually tested positive? How has chellation therapy >gone? Has anybody seen improvements in their children? My daughter >is nonverbal, but seems very open to learning sign language. She >makes almost no attempt to verbally communicate, but seems to >understand almost everything I tell her. My impression is that almost all ASD kids have heavy metal poisoning. I think I have a couple of refernces somewhere to old posts where Dr. Amy Holmes talked about the hair test results she was seeing in ASD kids (which are her entire practice, I think). If you want I'll look for the post # for you. I think she said that most all kids she tested were toxic. Also, just from reading the comments on the list (which I've been doing for over a year), I'd say this seems true--- there are a few cases where a kid is not toxic, or where it is not clear-- but these seem to be the exception. I would say that most parents who are doing chelation are seeing improvements-- to varying degrees. The love letters file should provide reading material for several days. (Let me know if you don't find it right off). >What are the classic symptoms of mercury poisoning that would >distinguish themselves from the regular PDD-NOS/Austism spectrum >disorder characteristics? > >Please post your experiences. I know it may be redundant, but I need >the help and expertise of you parents. Just FYI, I have no kids. I'm the exception (here) as regards to that, please don't let it bug you. I think it would be fair to say I'm an ally. (I'm a mercury toxic adult, doing chelation on mySELF, and seeing progress-- slowly.) (I also post a lot on the list.) Moria Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted October 28, 2001 Report Share Posted October 28, 2001 Hi, ! I hate to disagree with you, but ASD is not a DSMIV diagnosis. ASD is a term that has developed in common language used by parents in discussing their children. People use it because Autism is a well known term, but PDD is not. However, it is getting to be with the rise is the number of children with these diagnoses. PDD-NOS is a DSMIV diagnosis under the Pervasive Developmental Disorders (p.65, check it out!). Autism is a different diagnosis than PDD-NOS. Although Aliza's daughter has received the PDD-NOS diagnosis, when she is older they may change her diagnosis to Autism. Because of her age, or because of her presenting overall picture, the doctor may have reasonably felt that PDD-NOS was the correct diagnosis. More to the point, has she been diagnosed additionally with Mental Retardation. My daughter is PDD-NOS with Mental Retardation, and my son is also PDD-NOS with average intelligence. Incidentally, when my son was being tested initially at the Yale Child Study Center I was told that he had scored the highest score of any child that had ever been tested at Yale in the block design test (99th percentile!). Cool! He'll be a world-class architect one day (he hopes)! School districts know the range, but the quality of programs may vary depending upon the district, the teachers, etc. That's why it is so important that parents know their children's educational rights and advocate strongly for their child. No one knows their child better than the parent, but I know both of my kids cooperate a whole lot better with other people than me. With me there are always the parent-child issues (yeah, just keep pushing my buttons to see when I'll put my foot down!). Cheers! [ ] Re: New to the group. Please provide some information Dear Aliza, Hello and welcome to this group. Most of the info you are seeking can be perused at your liesure in the " Files " section. In particular, please read the FAQ for info about diagnostic testing, and the " Love_Letters " file for many families' accounts of their children's response chelation. My son with autism is four, has now had seven rounds of DMSA-only chelation, and has made very exciting progress. The symptoms of autism/PDD-NOS in fact very closely parallel those of mercury poisoning. http://www.autism.com/ari/mercurylong.html is a long scientific paper that explores this subject in detail. If you'll indulge me in a suggestion that is not what you asked about, go back to your doctor and ask for a written diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) for your daughter, not PDD-NOS. I say this because sometimes Regional Centers (the state agency that should be helping you with obtaining services for her) and school districts will quibble about whether PDD-NOS is really a " qualifying diagnosis " whereas autism always is. Your doctor probably said PDD-NOS because your daughter is smart (based on her good receptive language ability); or as a way to sugar the pill and spare you from having to hear the dreaded A-word. Think of the word " autism " not as a death sentence or even a reliable predictor of her future, but as a meal ticket that will help you get her the services she needs. You're in the right " place " and your daughter is young enough that tremendous things are possible for her. If you will post where you live, you will probably find other parents nearby who can help you with local resources. PS One more unsolicited suggestion... the book Facing Autism by Lynn Hamilton does not address chelation, but except for that I think it's the best all-around book for parents of new diagnosees. I particularly recommend her chapter about " Ten Things You Can Do Right Now " -- for example signing her up ASAP on waiting lists all over town, since all the good service agencies invariably have long waits, and videotaping her for future comparison purposes. > We have a three year old daughter who has been diagnosed PDD-NOS. We > were finally able to see a developmental specialist who ordered a > number of lab tests, to the exclusion of mercury. We will be > persistent and will have her tested whether it is with this doctor or > another. > > I need to know from those who have gone through this how many > children have actually tested positive? How has chellation therapy > gone? Has anybody seen improvements in their children? My daughter > is nonverbal, but seems very open to learning sign language. She > makes almost no attempt to verbally communicate, but seems to > understand almost everything I tell her. > > What are the classic symptoms of mercury poisoning that would > distinguish themselves from the regular PDD-NOS/Austism spectrum > disorder characteristics? > > Please post your experiences. I know it may be redundant, but I need > the help and expertise of you parents. > > Thank you, > Aliza ======================================================= Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted October 28, 2001 Report Share Posted October 28, 2001 > We have a three year old daughter who has been diagnosed PDD-NOS. We > were finally able to see a developmental specialist who ordered a > number of lab tests, to the exclusion of mercury. We will be > persistent and will have her tested whether it is with this doctor or > another. Find anyone, including a chiropractor, optometrist, or whatever who will sign for a Hair Element Profile from Doctor's Data. This is a $42 test that is very helpful and you can interpret yourself using the information in the " counting rules " file. > I need to know from those who have gone through this how many > children have actually tested positive? Out of over 100 tests people on this list have been kind enough to post or share privately, 1 or maybe 2 appear to have some basis for their problem other than heavy metal intoxication. This is also what the physicians who practice in this area see - very few of the " genetic defect " cases, most cases respond to treatments that " aren't supposed to work " and " are a waste of your money " according to their mainstream colleagues. >How has chellation therapy gone? Marvelously. > Has anybody seen improvements in their children? Go through the " love letters " file and the multitudinous progress reports on this list. > My daughter > is nonverbal, but seems very open to learning sign language. She > makes almost no attempt to verbally communicate, but seems to > understand almost everything I tell her. > > What are the classic symptoms of mercury poisoning that would > distinguish themselves from the regular PDD-NOS/Austism spectrum > disorder characteristics? There are none, since PDD/NOS and autism ARE heavy metal intoxication. It isn't a distinct clinical entity, it is simply a misdiagnosis. Very few kids who have these diagnoses are NOT heavy metal toxic. > > Please post your experiences. I know it may be redundant, but I need > the help and expertise of you parents. > > Tha Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted October 29, 2001 Report Share Posted October 29, 2001 <<Andy said: >> >Find anyone, including a chiropractor, optometrist, or whatever who >will sign for a Hair Element Profile from Doctor's Data. This is a >$42 test that is very helpful and you can interpret yourself using the >information in the " counting rules " file. If you don't find someone to sign for the test, you can have DLS sign for it for you--- which costs -- um-- I think it is $79. (search in the archive on " DLS " -- i post this info regularly-- Ask if you don't find it & I'll post it again.) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.