Guest guest Posted August 11, 2005 Report Share Posted August 11, 2005 --- In , Idol <Idol@c...> wrote: > - > > >Oh, I would try them if I were you. > > Maybe you could explain something for me, then. Homeopathy isn't something > I've looked into that much, but isn't the idea supposed to be that water > has a memory, and that if you put a substance into some water and then > dilute it many, many times over, the water will still " remember " the > substance and will yield similar results? I have read that. I think it does make sense. Since nutrition and biochemistry has a lot to do with how molecules fit together in a 3D manner, if you can create a substance that contains a " hole " for something that is needed, and the structure has enough " handles " for it to fit into places where the critical substance is needed, perhaps that's all that's needed to get things working together again. > How does that square with little > solid pellets made of lactose and sucrose? I don't know how the little pellets implement the " shaped hole " concept! It doesn't seem like it would work, does it? > Or is the liquid dilution thing > just one type of homeopathic remedy, completely distinct from the pellets? > > > - I had greater success with the liquid remedy. It was alcohol-based and you used it by placing it under your tongue. The whole concept of homeopathy is to try to get the body working properly to heal itself, rather than forcing symptoms to subside using chemicals that affect your hydration level, or whatever. The only time I've ever had enough discomfort to wish I had an Instant Remedy was the one time I had a bladder infection. But the remedy that was recommended by my MD was to drink cranberry juice! I guess that's one reason I'm so friendly towards homeopathic remedies. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2005 Report Share Posted August 12, 2005 - >Anti-spasmodic, expectorant and very good bronchial dilator. It also >one of those herbs you can use when nothing else you are doing seems >to be working. Great. It seems like it'd be a really choice thing for me to have on hand with all my lung problems. Any idea where I can get some, now that Schulze has discontinued it? - Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2005 Report Share Posted August 12, 2005 - >Here is a great source of quality medicinal herbs: >www.pacificbotanicals.com. I think they even have fresh ginger but you >might want to keep some powdered ginger on hand. They sell in bulk. Thanks. I think I will order some powdered ginger for emergencies like this one and maybe to beef up ginger juice as suggested. > > Looks interesting except for the fennel. Why's that in there? > >Like ginger it is a carminative, helpful with digestion, gas, etc. I'm pretty sure I once read that fennel is a powerful phytoestrogen (recommended for women, of course, ho ho) but then again I suppose an occasional dose wouldn't do any harm. >Tincture poured on burns and powder packed in wounds greatly >accelerates the healing process. I prefer honey myself. Doesn't cayenne applied to wounds and burns hurt like the dickens? I've never actually tried honey either, as I'd be afraid of not having honey of a high enough quality for the bad effects of the sugar to be suppressed, but cayenne? I have to say, it sounds brutal. - Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2005 Report Share Posted August 12, 2005 > - > > >Here is a great source of quality medicinal herbs: > >www.pacificbotanicals.com. I think they even have fresh ginger but you > >might want to keep some powdered ginger on hand. They sell in bulk. > > Thanks. I think I will order some powdered ginger for emergencies like > this one and maybe to beef up ginger juice as suggested. > > > > Looks interesting except for the fennel. Why's that in there? > > > >Like ginger it is a carminative, helpful with digestion, gas, etc. > > I'm pretty sure I once read that fennel is a powerful phytoestrogen > (recommended for women, of course, ho ho) but then again I suppose an > occasional dose wouldn't do any harm. > > >Tincture poured on burns and powder packed in wounds greatly > >accelerates the healing process. I prefer honey myself. > > Doesn't cayenne applied to wounds and burns hurt like the dickens? I've > never actually tried honey either, as I'd be afraid of not having honey of > a high enough quality for the bad effects of the sugar to be suppressed, > but cayenne? I have to say, it sounds brutal. , Here's a link-y to some of Dr. Schulze's formulas with instructions for use and further links on how to make yourself. Pretty cool. http://healingtools.tripod.com/thns14.html You might want to add on to your herbal order, just sayin'. Cayenne does sound brutal--but effective. Hopefully no one will have occasion to try it. B. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2005 Report Share Posted August 12, 2005 On 8/11/05, Idol <Idol@...> wrote: > Naomi- > > >Hope you are doing better by now. If not, have you tried any > >homeopathic remedies? > > I confess that skepticism has kept me from ever trying any homeopathic > remedies. > > I understand your skepticism—I had the same misgivings when I was trying it out 15-odd years ago. I used to suffer from recurrent bladder infections in my early 20s, and was going to the doctor a lot for antibiotics and meds. Homeopathy put an end to that cycle. It's helped me recover from surgery quickly, I've given it to my cats, and my daughter gets dosed with Arnica frequently for her bumps and bruises (which it prevents in injuries if given soon enough). If I didn't give it to her, she would be black and blue all over! Nutrition helps 98% of the problems that homeopathy cures, but sometimes I need that immune system boost quickly, and the remedies work even quicker than regular herbs in a lot of cases. Not only that, it's more convenient than schlepping a bunch of herbal tinctures when you're out and about. Someday science will advance enough to explain why and how it works, but probably not soon since it's cheap and not patentable. Naomi Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2005 Report Share Posted August 12, 2005 On 8/11/05, <toyotaokiec@...> wrote: > From what I have seen, therefore, they shouldn't hurt you if you > don't need them, and they can really help if you do need them. Of > course, the choice of remedy can determine whether you see an > improvement or not. > The quickest and best improvement comes when you take a single remedy for your problem; for some problems, you have to see a homeopath. For allergies, my ex-husband found that the bioAllers brand, which is a combination of remedies, worked the best. The first time he took it regularly, he had to take it every day for a few months (during a particularly bad hay fever season). The following spring, he had only a few allergy episodes. Then the following few years, he had no symptoms at all. And this is someone who was allergic to everything. I was tempted to get him a HazMat suit, I swear! Naomi Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2005 Report Share Posted August 12, 2005 On 8/11/05, Idol <Idol@...> wrote: > > Homeopathy isn't something > I've looked into that much, but isn't the idea supposed to be that water > has a memory, and that if you put a substance into some water and then > dilute it many, many times over, the water will still " remember " the > substance and will yield similar results? Something like that. An herbal tincture is mixed with alcohol, and shaken up a number of times. Then some of this liquid is mixed again with more alcohol, and shaken up some more. The more diluted it is, paradoxically the more powerful it becomes. > How does that square with little > solid pellets made of lactose and sucrose? Or is the liquid dilution thing > just one type of homeopathic remedy, completely distinct from the pellets? The liquid is mixed with lactose to make the pellets. There's also homeopathic ointments, creams, and sprays (Arnica spray is great for bruises and muscle soreness). Here's a good article on how they're made: http://www.healthynewage.com/what-is-homeopathy.htm Naomi Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2005 Report Share Posted August 12, 2005 Naomi- >Something like that. An herbal tincture is mixed with alcohol, and >shaken up a number of times. Then some of this liquid is mixed again >with more alcohol, and shaken up some more. The more diluted it is, >paradoxically the more powerful it becomes. Well, I hope you'll forgive my skepticism, but they _say_ it becomes more powerful with dilution. It sounds more than a bit questionable to me. Has anyone ever done any real animal testing? I know the selection of homeopathic medications is supposed to be a highly individual thing, meaning that a whole cohort of animals with problem X treated with homeopathy remedy Y wouldn't necessarily resemble the real-world applications of the discipline, but surely homeopathic vets could be found to administer such studies, no? - Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2005 Report Share Posted August 12, 2005 > > The only time I've ever had enough discomfort to wish I had an > Instant Remedy was the one time I had a bladder infection. But the > remedy that was recommended by my MD was to drink cranberry juice! Cranberry juice helps, but it has to be pure cranberry juice, which is quite expensive. The unsweetened kind is not very palatable, but I've never tried mixing it with stevia. For bladder infections, I used to use Cantharis. It cured my cystitis, and offered instant relief of symptoms (it even works on my cats†" one of them is very prone to get bladder infections, to the point of bleeding). However, I think there are a few other remedies for it, so it depends on your symptoms. The single remedies, when they're the right ones, often work instantly. Naomi Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2005 Report Share Posted August 12, 2005 --- In , Idol <Idol@c...> , > Well, I hope you'll forgive my skepticism, but they _say_ it becomes more > powerful with dilution. It sounds more than a bit questionable to me. Has > anyone ever done any real animal testing? I know the selection of > homeopathic medications is supposed to be a highly individual thing, > meaning that a whole cohort of animals with problem X treated with > homeopathy remedy Y wouldn't necessarily resemble the real-world > applications of the discipline, but surely homeopathic vets could be found > to administer such studies, no? > > There have been a lot of studies done on people *and* animals, but I don't know if they're good enough to prove the efficacy of homeopathy to those who are skeptical. I tried doing a Google search, but my dd is either hanging all over me like a monkey or running amok getting into my books and papers, making it impossible to concentrate. I've been writing this one message for about 30 minutes! One of the difficulties in setting up a study is that problem X, say a cold, is experienced differently for people. For example, one person will get a cold and feel very feverish and headache-y, while another's cold manifests as frequent sneezing with chills. These would require different remedies, even if they both have the " same " problem. In one of my homeopathy book, there's 14 remedies listed for a cold, all depending on the symptoms. BTW, hope you are feeling better. Naomi Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2005 Report Share Posted August 12, 2005 Naomi- >One of the difficulties in setting up a study is that problem X, say >a cold, is experienced differently for people. For example, one person >will get a cold and feel very feverish and headache-y, while >another's cold manifests as frequent sneezing with chills. These would >require different remedies, even if they both have the " same " problem. >In one of my homeopathy book, there's 14 remedies listed for a cold, >all depending on the symptoms. Yeah, that's why I suggested that animal studies would have to be done with homeopathic vets who'd treat animals in the treatment cohort accordingly. I guess that would require a much larger study, in order get enough animals getting each kind of treatment, and very specific information would have to be kept about symptoms, but I don't see why it couldn't be done. >BTW, hope you are feeling better. Thanks! Whether it's coincidence (or the power of suggestion) or Dr. Schulze's Echinacea Plus is really as powerful as says, I'm feeling like a whole new person. Still tired (as if I could be otherwise at this point), but my throat is so much less sore that swallowing food was merely an irritation, not a trial by fire, and full of energy despite the exhaustion. I've been running around doing things nonstop for the first time since Monday, and I might even be able to go to the farmers market tomorrow, which would be good, as an unexplained absence on my part would kind of suck for people I can't get in touch with who are saving things for me. Everything that was troubling me seems to have gotten a lot better, though nothing's entirely gone yet. For anyone who's interested, I took half a bottle of E+ over the course of, I don't know, maybe half an hour, and then I stopped. I got to thinking that if I DO go to the market tomorrow (which might be a terrible idea, but I'll have to see how I feel in the morning) I might need more afterwards to keep me from backsliding, though of course it's hard to know whether I'm playing things worse by having less today than by keeping some for tomorrow. I had been mending slightly before taking it, but the temporal connection between starting to use it and starting to feel really dramatically better is so tight that it's hard for me to believe it's coincidence. I wonder how effective it would've been if taken at the very worst I've been over the past few days, though. At any rate, when I got up this morning I felt like there was no end in sight. Now I almost feel like I'm there. - Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2005 Report Share Posted August 12, 2005 On 8/12/05, Idol <Idol@...> wrote: > - > > >Anti-spasmodic, expectorant and very good bronchial dilator. It also > >one of those herbs you can use when nothing else you are doing seems > >to be working. > > Great. It seems like it'd be a really choice thing for me to have on hand > with all my lung problems. Any idea where I can get some, now that Schulze > has discontinued it? I will check around but I think you might be out of luck. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 13, 2005 Report Share Posted August 13, 2005 - >I will check around but I think you might be out of luck. Nertz. Maybe I'll order one of his lung formula tinctures then. It's not listed on the site, but the guy I spoke to on the phone mentioned it. IIRC it has lobelia in it along with a bunch of other stuff. BTW, as I mentioned yesterday, the E+ helped a lot, but it wasn't quite the miracle I initially thought it was. Awhile after I took half a bottle, I backslid appreciably. My throat started hurting a lot more, though not nearly as much as it had, and in general I felt a lot more run down. The burst of energy I'd had deserted me entirely. So I drank the rest of the bottle, figuring I'd let today take care of itself, and I did recover some of the lost ground, but again, much of those gains were temporary. I'm wondering whether some of it was just the anaesthetizing effect of alcohol, though that certainly wouldn't account for a burst of energy. It did make me regret not getting a second bottle to take the full dose you recommended. Anyway, despite the disappointment, I got my first decent night's sleep since Monday, waking up only once or twice and getting back to sleep easily instead of waking every couple minutes and often being unable to get to sleep at all for long stretches at a time. So I am a convert, but his stuff doesn't seem to have quite the miraculous powers I'd at first hoped -- though to be fair I didn't take the full dose you recommended, either. - Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 13, 2005 Report Share Posted August 13, 2005 - >Here is a great source of quality medicinal herbs: >www.pacificbotanicals.com. I think they even have fresh ginger but you >might want to keep some powdered ginger on hand. They sell in bulk. Turns out they have lobelia in their current catalog. They have the dried herb in seed stage, though I don't know whether that means the whole plant, they have whole seeds, and during the summer they may have fresh plants. Which do you recommend and in what quantity to make a tincture? - Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 13, 2005 Report Share Posted August 13, 2005 , Stossel did a segment where they tested homeopathic remedies. I don't remember whether it was animal or human or what it was, but I do remember that they had on video a bunch of homeopaths who certified that the study had been set up appropriately, and then at the end when they found no efficacy, the homeopaths were saying the study was flawed. It made them look pretty stupid. On the other hand, it's pretty easy to manipulate someone's message through editing. Personally, my skepticism prevents me from spending money on them, but if they're around the house and I didn't pay for them, I generally find them to be moderately effective for myself. Chris -- Want the other side of the cholesterol story? Find out what your doctor isn't telling you: http://www.cholesterol-and-health.com Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 14, 2005 Report Share Posted August 14, 2005 On 8/12/05, wrote: I've been running around doing things nonstop for the first time since Monday, On 8/13/05, wrote: > > > > BTW, as I mentioned yesterday, the E+ helped a lot, but it wasn't quite > the > miracle I initially thought it was. Awhile after I took half a bottle, I > backslid appreciably. My throat started hurting a lot more, though not > nearly as much as it had, and in general I felt a lot more run down. The > burst of energy I'd had deserted me entirely. Jeez, , I hope you've had a chance to relax a bit! Give the Echinacea a chance to work, for goodness sakes. Naomi Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 14, 2005 Report Share Posted August 14, 2005 On 8/13/05, Masterjohn <chrismasterjohn@...> wrote: > > > > Stossel did a segment where they tested homeopathic remedies. I > don't remember whether it was animal or human or what it was, but I do > remember that they had on video a bunch of homeopaths who certified > that the study had been set up appropriately, and then at the end when > they found no efficacy, the homeopaths were saying the study was > flawed. > > It made them look pretty stupid. On the other hand, it's pretty easy > to manipulate someone's message through editing. Well, it didn't work because instead of replicating the earlier positive studies like they were supposed to, they used ammonium chloride, which destroys basophils (the white blood cell that was under study), which wasn't used in the original ones, among other problems. http://www.townsendletter.com/July2004/shorts0704.ht " Stossel Takes on Homeopathy " http://www.homeopathic.com/articles/media/2020_response_critique.php " Stossel and 20/20's Program on Homeopathy: Junk Science Creates Junk Journalism When TV Science Creates Science Fiction " This is a thorough review of that segment, and includes the pros and cons of the facts presented. The references show some positive studies on homeopathy. One of the latest from RHEUMATOLOGY is " Improved clinical status in fibromyalgia patients treated with individualized homeopathic remedies versus placebo. " I thought this was a good point: " 20/20 didn't acknowledge that although we don't know precisely how homeopathic medicines work, we also do not presently know how many common drugs work, including many used for anesthesia in surgery. " Isn't this true for a lot of herbs, too? Personally, my skepticism prevents me from spending money on them, but > if they're around the house and I didn't pay for them, I generally > find them to be moderately effective for myself. What, you just have a bunch of bottles of homeopathic tablets lying around? Lucky! This may increase your skepticism, but be sure they're not sitting next to bottles of perfume or essential oils, as this can compromise quality. It also helps to take them with a clean mouth, which means 15 minutes before or after you eat or drink something (other than water). And you do know that you shouldn't touch them with your hands, right? Okay, is that enough information, LOL? Naomi Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 16, 2005 Report Share Posted August 16, 2005 Chris- > Stossel did a segment where they tested homeopathic remedies. I >don't remember whether it was animal or human or what it was, but I do >remember that they had on video a bunch of homeopaths who certified >that the study had been set up appropriately, and then at the end when >they found no efficacy, the homeopaths were saying the study was >flawed. > >It made them look pretty stupid. On the other hand, it's pretty easy >to manipulate someone's message through editing. Editing can accomplish a lot, but still, if they signed off on the study and then changed their tune, that's not very encouraging. - Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 16, 2005 Report Share Posted August 16, 2005 >> Stossel did a segment where they tested homeopathic remedies. I >> don't remember whether it was animal or human or what it was, but I do >> remember that they had on video a bunch of homeopaths who certified >> that the study had been set up appropriately, and then at the end when >> they found no efficacy, the homeopaths were saying the study was >> flawed. >> >> It made them look pretty stupid. On the other hand, it's pretty easy >> to manipulate someone's message through editing. > > Editing can accomplish a lot, but still, if they signed off on the > study > and then changed their tune, that's not very encouraging. The thing is, though, I wouldn't trust Stossel to tell me what time it is. Lynn S. ------ Lynn Siprelle * web developer, writer, mama, fiber junky http://www.siprelle.com * http://www.thenewhomemaker.com http://www.deanspeaksforme.com * http://www.knitting911.net Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 16, 2005 Report Share Posted August 16, 2005 Lynn- >The thing is, though, I wouldn't trust Stossel to tell me what >time it is. Me neither, but he wasn't the one signing off on the experiment. - Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 18, 2005 Report Share Posted August 18, 2005 On 8/13/05, Idol <Idol@...> wrote: > - > > >Here is a great source of quality medicinal herbs: > >www.pacificbotanicals.com. I think they even have fresh ginger but you > >might want to keep some powdered ginger on hand. They sell in bulk. > > Turns out they have lobelia in their current catalog. They have the dried > herb in seed stage, though I don't know whether that means the whole plant, > they have whole seeds, and during the summer they may have fresh > plants. Which do you recommend and in what quantity to make a tincture? , I think gave a very good answer to this. If you didn't see it I will paste and copy. The only thing I would add is to do the procedure twice, unless you are in a real hurry. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.