OT: A news item never to be discussed over thanksgiving dinner . . .

[Guest guest]

Heavier women seen prone to personality disorders

Last Updated: 2009-01-06 15:23:16 -0400 (Reuters Health)

By Anne Harding

NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Overweight and obese women are more likely

to have antisocial personality disorder, paranoid personality disorder

and extreme social phobia than their leaner peers, new research

published in Psychosomatic Medicine shows.

On the other hand, for men, extra pounds seem to actually reduce their

risk for paranoid personality disorder.

Dr. Jitender Sareen of the University of Manitoba in Winnipeg and his

colleagues suggest in their report that antisocial and paranoid

disorders could conceivably cause overweight and obesity in women, or

vice versa -- or both.

People who are overweight or obese are known to be at higher risk of

so-called Axis I psychiatric disorders, which include major

depression, anxiety disorders, and substance abuse, Sareen told

Reuters Health. However, the association between body weight and

personality disorders (classified as Axis II disorders) is not as clear.

People are believed to develop personality disorders relatively early

in life, before age 18. These disorders are considered to be fairly

resistant to treatment, although evidence is mounting that certain

types of personality disorder can indeed get better with the right

kind of therapy.

Sareen and his colleagues looked at data from a 2001-2002 national

survey on 43,093 US residents 18 and older. Study participants had

been assessed for all seven different types of personality disorder.

Once the researchers accounted for Axis I disorders, socioeconomic and

demographic characteristics, health problems, and other relevant

factors, they found that the overweight and obese women were at

greater risk of antisocial, paranoid, and avoidant personality disorder.

People with avoidant personality disorder are extremely shy and

fearful of rejection, and avoid social interaction. Antisocial

personality disorder, on the other hand, is characterized by disregard

for the rights of other people.

The Canadian team also found that schizoid personality disorder, a

relatively rare condition in which a person is not interested in

social relationships and prefers to live a solitary, secretive life,

was more common among underweight women. Overweight men were less

likely to have paranoid personality disorder.

Women with avoidant or paranoid personalities may lead more sedentary

lifestyles, making them more likely to gain weight, while the

stigmatization overweight women may experience could itself lead to

personality problems, the researchers say.

It's also possible that a shared underlying biological problem, such

as abnormalities in the " reward hormone " dopamine, could contribute to

personality disorder risk and the likelihood of being overweight.

" Lots of people get psychotherapy for Axis II disorders and over time

they do change, " Sareen noted, even though the benefits of

psychodynamic therapy for these individuals has been " controversial. "

In the future, he added, it will be important to investigate whether

treating such disorders may make it easier for people to maintain a

healthy weight.

SOURCE: Psychosomatic Medicine, November/December 2008.