Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: My experience with 4S

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Sure. I grew up with my mom, dad and slightly older brother. We ate dinner together every night. There was no yelling or abuse. My very early memories was that I was a picky eater, lots of foods I didn't like. Sometimes I didn't get dessert if I refused to eat anything but it was not done out of anger and most times as long as I choked something down I got what I wanted. We were told to be polite in all that we did including meal times, no elbows on table, chew with mouths closed, don't grab people's food. Typical 1960's manners. Nothing was drilled into us and no punishments were rendered My mom would only politely and gently asked us to comply. Don't think my dad cared one way or another. It was the same throughout all aspects of our lives, we were expected to say please and thank you, open doors for older women, just be polite, loving members of society The only "issue" I can possible muster up was that I was so picky that sometimes I just couldn't decide what to eat in restaurants and could not make a choice and my dad would get pissed off at me for failing to choose and would tell me if I couldn't decide then I'd get nothing. But that had nothing to so with the way we ate, chewed or made noises. And we did to go out to eat muchLet me know if you have any questions. HeidiSent from my iPhone

Heidi,I originally formed an hypothesis that 4S was often provoked by different situations during family mealtimes. This was proved true by quite a few people I interviewed.Would you consider telling me a bit about family mealtimes when you were growing up?With thanks,TaraLet your email find you with BlackBerry from Vodafone

Sender: Soundsensitivity

Date: Mon, 31 Jan 2011 11:03:52 -0800To: Soundsensitivity <Soundsensitivity >ReplyTo: Soundsensitivity

Subject: Re: My experience with 4S

Welcome mark,I am so very sorry to hear your childhood experience. I am of the belief that this condition is not psychological brought on by an event but rather physiological. I say that as lay person with no medical training, obviously. However, many people here were not treated poorly at the table at all and yet have 4S. Given what so many people have shared here it seems unlikely you have this condition due to your abusive father (which he obviously was). It's much more likely he had 4S and that was how he was dealing with it and you, sadly, inherited it, like most of us. My aunt has it and we certainly didn't grow up in the same house. In that same vein I don't think your wife can catch it but she probably has become more sensitive and is getting weary of being glared at etc. Many have reported sound immersion does not work. I think we can do things to keep down our stress so that how we respond is made more bearable, especially for others In our life. We can use yoga, exercise, mediation, therapy, good nutrition to help. But so far I don't think we can eliminate our 4S. I try to keep myself in a good place physically and emotionally so that I can cope better when sounds bother me and not take my issue out on other people. And of course I use my earplugs and iPod when necessary. Sadly there doesn't seem to be a fix yet. But certainly addressing what you went through in childhood through therapy could probably help with your responses/reactions. Good luck and welcome again,HeidiSent from my iPhone

Hi Everyone,I'm new to the group and joined specifically to save my marriage. I'm pretty sure I know why I have this condition. And now it seems that my wife is beginning to "catch" it.Background: As a child (I'm 45), my siblings and I would be punished for making "avoidable" noises at the dinner table (e.g., scraping teeth with a fork, humming, chewing with our mouths open, snorting, scraping knives sideways on a plate, etc.) The first infraction during a meal would result in an icy stare from my father and tension in the room for the rest of the meal. A second infraction would result in punishment. The punishment was pretty standard - go to bed for the rest of the day - without finishing the

meal. No TV, books, newspapers, magazines, radio, etc. Pretty much just go sit in silence and we'll see you tomorrow. If we cried, he'd come upstairs and "give us something to cry about" - usually a beating with his belt.I'm not looking for sympathy, nor do I want to appear as one of the "it's all my father's fault" people. I'm just laying out the facts as I believe they are related to my 4S.What I "learned" was that making unnecessary sounds would result in punishment; and even if I wasn't the one being punished, I still had to sit through the remainder of the meal - which was punishment in itself. What started out as a nice dinner could end with tension, fear, and anxiety. Over time, everyone at the table would shoot an icy stare at the offender. We all were taking on my father's aversion to everyday sounds. Maybe he had 4S? Sound irritation moved from the dinner table to

the house in general (playing too loudly, creaking the stairs, popping bubble gum, etc), to school, to work, to my own home. The list of sounds that I just can't ignore now includes everything mentioned above plus chewing hard candy, fussing with candy wrappers and plastic bags, chewing ice, playing with coins in a pocket, newscasters with speech impediments, mispronounced words like "shtreet" (instead of "street"), incessant clicking of a pen, typing, lip smacking at the beginning of every sentence, word repetition (i.e. same word being used multiple times in a sentence), feet thudding across the floor above me, chair legs screeching when dragged across a floor, etc, etc.These sounds don't make me fearful or fill me with rage, they irritate and aggravate. My reaction to these sounds can be staring, mimicking the sound, talking loudly enough to drown out the sound, turning up the volume of the tv/radio, leaving the room,

etc. I used to say something about it, but people weren't very sympathetic. They'd make more noise just to bug me. Being forced to deal with irritating sounds without vocalizing displeasure caused me to be more passive in my responses.A worst-case scenario for me is when I'm in a meeting or seminar and there are bowls of hard candy at every table. There's always someone that will eat a whole bowl of them - and refill at every break. It may take a minute or so of fussing with the wrapper to get the candy open. Then they crunch the candy rather than letting it dissolve slowly. While doing this, they mindlessly fold the wrapper into the tiniest square possible. Then they begin unwrapping another piece as the final bits of the previous piece are being chomped. This is worst-case for me because I can't focus on the topic being discussed and I can't tune out what I'm hearing. I just sit there

stewing - waiting for someone to tell them to SHUT UP; wondering how everyone else can tune it out while I can't; wondering how someone can deliberately be so rude and inconsiderate of others; and looking around the room trying to make eye contact with others that are annoyed but finding no one. Once that person does take a break, someone else picks up where he left off. Eventually, I have to join in as it's the only way to make enough noise to drown out what I'm hearing. The session ends, I've learned nothing, and I've eaten a bunch of candy. During breaks, I've asked other people "Could that guy make more of a racket with the candy?" and the response is always "What guy? I didn't hear anything." Basically they're saying that I have issues.Recently, my wife told me that she's tired of walking on eggshells around me. I was surprised because I just passively and subtly leave the room, turn up the radio,

talk, etc when she makes a sound that annoys me. I realize that it's my problem and deal with it the best I can - without directing anger toward her. But she's no dummy. She sees the icy stare out of the corner of her eye; she realizes I'm leaving the room because I don't want to hear her crunch cereal; she knows that using her emory board on her nails will cause me to take the dog out; etc. When she drops a piece of silverware, she now experiences all the feelings I experienced 40 years ago. She becomes tense, waiting for my reaction, knowing I'm completely irritated. I don't want her feeling that way around me. I have to change.As far as I'm concerned, my 4S is a behavioral issue caused by events that occurred an early age and allowed to grow unchecked for decades. Now I need to fix it. I don't think medicines or vitamins are the answer. For me, I think it's "unlearning" the

behavior. My guess is that either hypnosis or completely immersing myself in sounds I hate will be the cure for me. Maybe I should make a recording of the sounds and play them loudly during my commute. If I can tolerate them for an hour straight, I should be able to tolerate the occasional instance.Out of curiosity, have any of you had an early experience similar to mine where punishment may have caused the symptoms of 4S? Or did most people have a relatively normal childhood and feel that 4S is more genetic than environmental? Has anyone tried hypnotism or "sound immersion"?Thanks for listening.MarkPS - I'm not a fan of receiving long emails so I apologize for sending one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mine started at the mall when I was around 8 to10. I would cry as we would enter because the lights hurt my ears so badly. Eventually the noises at the dinner table became unbearable as well but nothing negative happened there to "cause" my 4S it just happens to be where all the mouth sounds I hate existed. Sent from my iPhone

Tara and Heidi, Hi there, I was just reading it and I realized that this is exactly how my 4s has started- during family meals. My patents and brother are loud eaters, smackers and slurpers, you name it. Even thinking of it now aggravates me, I can hear and see them.. Ugh, I am already mad. My mother has a habit if constant eating and snacking, her favorites are apples!!!! She loves tasting the food she s making and nothing seems to go to waste including bones and their inside. Disgusting. And so much f...noise. I ate with them once a year- christmas eve supper. Of course with earplugs in. She s my biggest trigger. I moved out if the house 5 years ago because I couldn't stand it. She is a noisy person in general, door slamming, loud talking, loud walking, and nail clipping wherever she feels like it. I do hate her for that. She always got mad when I yelled at everybody because I couldn't stand it. I think my family made it worse. I am very sensitive to trigger sounds now. KateSent from my iPhone

Heidi,I originally formed an hypothesis that 4S was often provoked by different situations during family mealtimes. This was proved true by quite a few people I interviewed.Would you consider telling me a bit about family mealtimes when you were growing up?With thanks,TaraLet your email find you with BlackBerry from Vodafone

Sender: Soundsensitivity

Date: Mon, 31 Jan 2011 11:03:52 -0800To: Soundsensitivity <Soundsensitivity >ReplyTo: Soundsensitivity

Subject: Re: My experience with 4S

Welcome mark,I am so very sorry to hear your childhood experience. I am of the belief that this condition is not psychological brought on by an event but rather physiological. I say that as lay person with no medical training, obviously. However, many people here were not treated poorly at the table at all and yet have 4S. Given what so many people have shared here it seems unlikely you have this condition due to your abusive father (which he obviously was). It's much more likely he had 4S and that was how he was dealing with it and you, sadly, inherited it, like most of us. My aunt has it and we certainly didn't grow up in the same house. In that same vein I don't think your wife can catch it but she probably has become more sensitive and is getting weary of being glared at etc. Many have reported sound immersion does not work. I think we can do things to keep down our stress so that how we respond is made more bearable, especially for others In our life. We can use yoga, exercise, mediation, therapy, good nutrition to help. But so far I don't think we can eliminate our 4S. I try to keep myself in a good place physically and emotionally so that I can cope better when sounds bother me and not take my issue out on other people. And of course I use my earplugs and iPod when necessary. Sadly there doesn't seem to be a fix yet. But certainly addressing what you went through in childhood through therapy could probably help with your responses/reactions. Good luck and welcome again,HeidiSent from my iPhone

Hi Everyone,I'm new to the group and joined specifically to save my marriage. I'm pretty sure I know why I have this condition. And now it seems that my wife is beginning to "catch" it.Background: As a child (I'm 45), my siblings and I would be punished for making "avoidable" noises at the dinner table (e.g., scraping teeth with a fork, humming, chewing with our mouths open, snorting, scraping knives sideways on a plate, etc.) The first infraction during a meal would result in an icy stare from my father and tension in the room for the rest of the meal. A second infraction would result in punishment. The punishment was pretty standard - go to bed for the rest of the day - without finishing the

meal. No TV, books, newspapers, magazines, radio, etc. Pretty much just go sit in silence and we'll see you tomorrow. If we cried, he'd come upstairs and "give us something to cry about" - usually a beating with his belt.I'm not looking for sympathy, nor do I want to appear as one of the "it's all my father's fault" people. I'm just laying out the facts as I believe they are related to my 4S.What I "learned" was that making unnecessary sounds would result in punishment; and even if I wasn't the one being punished, I still had to sit through the remainder of the meal - which was punishment in itself. What started out as a nice dinner could end with tension, fear, and anxiety. Over time, everyone at the table would shoot an icy stare at the offender. We all were taking on my father's aversion to everyday sounds. Maybe he had 4S? Sound irritation moved from the dinner table to

the house in general (playing too loudly, creaking the stairs, popping bubble gum, etc), to school, to work, to my own home. The list of sounds that I just can't ignore now includes everything mentioned above plus chewing hard candy, fussing with candy wrappers and plastic bags, chewing ice, playing with coins in a pocket, newscasters with speech impediments, mispronounced words like "shtreet" (instead of "street"), incessant clicking of a pen, typing, lip smacking at the beginning of every sentence, word repetition (i.e. same word being used multiple times in a sentence), feet thudding across the floor above me, chair legs screeching when dragged across a floor, etc, etc.These sounds don't make me fearful or fill me with rage, they irritate and aggravate. My reaction to these sounds can be staring, mimicking the sound, talking loudly enough to drown out the sound, turning up the volume of the tv/radio, leaving the room,

etc. I used to say something about it, but people weren't very sympathetic. They'd make more noise just to bug me. Being forced to deal with irritating sounds without vocalizing displeasure caused me to be more passive in my responses.A worst-case scenario for me is when I'm in a meeting or seminar and there are bowls of hard candy at every table. There's always someone that will eat a whole bowl of them - and refill at every break. It may take a minute or so of fussing with the wrapper to get the candy open. Then they crunch the candy rather than letting it dissolve slowly. While doing this, they mindlessly fold the wrapper into the tiniest square possible. Then they begin unwrapping another piece as the final bits of the previous piece are being chomped. This is worst-case for me because I can't focus on the topic being discussed and I can't tune out what I'm hearing. I just sit there

stewing - waiting for someone to tell them to SHUT UP; wondering how everyone else can tune it out while I can't; wondering how someone can deliberately be so rude and inconsiderate of others; and looking around the room trying to make eye contact with others that are annoyed but finding no one. Once that person does take a break, someone else picks up where he left off. Eventually, I have to join in as it's the only way to make enough noise to drown out what I'm hearing. The session ends, I've learned nothing, and I've eaten a bunch of candy. During breaks, I've asked other people "Could that guy make more of a racket with the candy?" and the response is always "What guy? I didn't hear anything." Basically they're saying that I have issues.Recently, my wife told me that she's tired of walking on eggshells around me. I was surprised because I just passively and subtly leave the room, turn up the radio,

talk, etc when she makes a sound that annoys me. I realize that it's my problem and deal with it the best I can - without directing anger toward her. But she's no dummy. She sees the icy stare out of the corner of her eye; she realizes I'm leaving the room because I don't want to hear her crunch cereal; she knows that using her emory board on her nails will cause me to take the dog out; etc. When she drops a piece of silverware, she now experiences all the feelings I experienced 40 years ago. She becomes tense, waiting for my reaction, knowing I'm completely irritated. I don't want her feeling that way around me. I have to change.As far as I'm concerned, my 4S is a behavioral issue caused by events that occurred an early age and allowed to grow unchecked for decades. Now I need to fix it. I don't think medicines or vitamins are the answer. For me, I think it's "unlearning" the

behavior. My guess is that either hypnosis or completely immersing myself in sounds I hate will be the cure for me. Maybe I should make a recording of the sounds and play them loudly during my commute. If I can tolerate them for an hour straight, I should be able to tolerate the occasional instance.Out of curiosity, have any of you had an early experience similar to mine where punishment may have caused the symptoms of 4S? Or did most people have a relatively normal childhood and feel that 4S is more genetic than environmental? Has anyone tried hypnotism or "sound immersion"?Thanks for listening.MarkPS - I'm not a fan of receiving long emails so I apologize for sending one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mine started at the mall when I was around 8 to10. I would cry as we would enter because the lights hurt my ears so badly. Eventually the noises at the dinner table became unbearable as well but nothing negative happened there to "cause" my 4S it just happens to be where all the mouth sounds I hate existed. Sent from my iPhone

Tara and Heidi, Hi there, I was just reading it and I realized that this is exactly how my 4s has started- during family meals. My patents and brother are loud eaters, smackers and slurpers, you name it. Even thinking of it now aggravates me, I can hear and see them.. Ugh, I am already mad. My mother has a habit if constant eating and snacking, her favorites are apples!!!! She loves tasting the food she s making and nothing seems to go to waste including bones and their inside. Disgusting. And so much f...noise. I ate with them once a year- christmas eve supper. Of course with earplugs in. She s my biggest trigger. I moved out if the house 5 years ago because I couldn't stand it. She is a noisy person in general, door slamming, loud talking, loud walking, and nail clipping wherever she feels like it. I do hate her for that. She always got mad when I yelled at everybody because I couldn't stand it. I think my family made it worse. I am very sensitive to trigger sounds now. KateSent from my iPhone

Heidi,I originally formed an hypothesis that 4S was often provoked by different situations during family mealtimes. This was proved true by quite a few people I interviewed.Would you consider telling me a bit about family mealtimes when you were growing up?With thanks,TaraLet your email find you with BlackBerry from Vodafone

Sender: Soundsensitivity

Date: Mon, 31 Jan 2011 11:03:52 -0800To: Soundsensitivity <Soundsensitivity >ReplyTo: Soundsensitivity

Subject: Re: My experience with 4S

Welcome mark,I am so very sorry to hear your childhood experience. I am of the belief that this condition is not psychological brought on by an event but rather physiological. I say that as lay person with no medical training, obviously. However, many people here were not treated poorly at the table at all and yet have 4S. Given what so many people have shared here it seems unlikely you have this condition due to your abusive father (which he obviously was). It's much more likely he had 4S and that was how he was dealing with it and you, sadly, inherited it, like most of us. My aunt has it and we certainly didn't grow up in the same house. In that same vein I don't think your wife can catch it but she probably has become more sensitive and is getting weary of being glared at etc. Many have reported sound immersion does not work. I think we can do things to keep down our stress so that how we respond is made more bearable, especially for others In our life. We can use yoga, exercise, mediation, therapy, good nutrition to help. But so far I don't think we can eliminate our 4S. I try to keep myself in a good place physically and emotionally so that I can cope better when sounds bother me and not take my issue out on other people. And of course I use my earplugs and iPod when necessary. Sadly there doesn't seem to be a fix yet. But certainly addressing what you went through in childhood through therapy could probably help with your responses/reactions. Good luck and welcome again,HeidiSent from my iPhone

Hi Everyone,I'm new to the group and joined specifically to save my marriage. I'm pretty sure I know why I have this condition. And now it seems that my wife is beginning to "catch" it.Background: As a child (I'm 45), my siblings and I would be punished for making "avoidable" noises at the dinner table (e.g., scraping teeth with a fork, humming, chewing with our mouths open, snorting, scraping knives sideways on a plate, etc.) The first infraction during a meal would result in an icy stare from my father and tension in the room for the rest of the meal. A second infraction would result in punishment. The punishment was pretty standard - go to bed for the rest of the day - without finishing the

meal. No TV, books, newspapers, magazines, radio, etc. Pretty much just go sit in silence and we'll see you tomorrow. If we cried, he'd come upstairs and "give us something to cry about" - usually a beating with his belt.I'm not looking for sympathy, nor do I want to appear as one of the "it's all my father's fault" people. I'm just laying out the facts as I believe they are related to my 4S.What I "learned" was that making unnecessary sounds would result in punishment; and even if I wasn't the one being punished, I still had to sit through the remainder of the meal - which was punishment in itself. What started out as a nice dinner could end with tension, fear, and anxiety. Over time, everyone at the table would shoot an icy stare at the offender. We all were taking on my father's aversion to everyday sounds. Maybe he had 4S? Sound irritation moved from the dinner table to

the house in general (playing too loudly, creaking the stairs, popping bubble gum, etc), to school, to work, to my own home. The list of sounds that I just can't ignore now includes everything mentioned above plus chewing hard candy, fussing with candy wrappers and plastic bags, chewing ice, playing with coins in a pocket, newscasters with speech impediments, mispronounced words like "shtreet" (instead of "street"), incessant clicking of a pen, typing, lip smacking at the beginning of every sentence, word repetition (i.e. same word being used multiple times in a sentence), feet thudding across the floor above me, chair legs screeching when dragged across a floor, etc, etc.These sounds don't make me fearful or fill me with rage, they irritate and aggravate. My reaction to these sounds can be staring, mimicking the sound, talking loudly enough to drown out the sound, turning up the volume of the tv/radio, leaving the room,

etc. I used to say something about it, but people weren't very sympathetic. They'd make more noise just to bug me. Being forced to deal with irritating sounds without vocalizing displeasure caused me to be more passive in my responses.A worst-case scenario for me is when I'm in a meeting or seminar and there are bowls of hard candy at every table. There's always someone that will eat a whole bowl of them - and refill at every break. It may take a minute or so of fussing with the wrapper to get the candy open. Then they crunch the candy rather than letting it dissolve slowly. While doing this, they mindlessly fold the wrapper into the tiniest square possible. Then they begin unwrapping another piece as the final bits of the previous piece are being chomped. This is worst-case for me because I can't focus on the topic being discussed and I can't tune out what I'm hearing. I just sit there

stewing - waiting for someone to tell them to SHUT UP; wondering how everyone else can tune it out while I can't; wondering how someone can deliberately be so rude and inconsiderate of others; and looking around the room trying to make eye contact with others that are annoyed but finding no one. Once that person does take a break, someone else picks up where he left off. Eventually, I have to join in as it's the only way to make enough noise to drown out what I'm hearing. The session ends, I've learned nothing, and I've eaten a bunch of candy. During breaks, I've asked other people "Could that guy make more of a racket with the candy?" and the response is always "What guy? I didn't hear anything." Basically they're saying that I have issues.Recently, my wife told me that she's tired of walking on eggshells around me. I was surprised because I just passively and subtly leave the room, turn up the radio,

talk, etc when she makes a sound that annoys me. I realize that it's my problem and deal with it the best I can - without directing anger toward her. But she's no dummy. She sees the icy stare out of the corner of her eye; she realizes I'm leaving the room because I don't want to hear her crunch cereal; she knows that using her emory board on her nails will cause me to take the dog out; etc. When she drops a piece of silverware, she now experiences all the feelings I experienced 40 years ago. She becomes tense, waiting for my reaction, knowing I'm completely irritated. I don't want her feeling that way around me. I have to change.As far as I'm concerned, my 4S is a behavioral issue caused by events that occurred an early age and allowed to grow unchecked for decades. Now I need to fix it. I don't think medicines or vitamins are the answer. For me, I think it's "unlearning" the

behavior. My guess is that either hypnosis or completely immersing myself in sounds I hate will be the cure for me. Maybe I should make a recording of the sounds and play them loudly during my commute. If I can tolerate them for an hour straight, I should be able to tolerate the occasional instance.Out of curiosity, have any of you had an early experience similar to mine where punishment may have caused the symptoms of 4S? Or did most people have a relatively normal childhood and feel that 4S is more genetic than environmental? Has anyone tried hypnotism or "sound immersion"?Thanks for listening.MarkPS - I'm not a fan of receiving long emails so I apologize for sending one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Heidi, I totally agree with your assessment of 4s and it origination. From: Soundsensitivity [mailto:Soundsensitivity ] On Behalf Of Heidi SalernoSent: Monday, January 31, 2011 2:04 PMTo: Soundsensitivity Subject: Re: My experience with 4S Welcome mark,I am so very sorry to hear your childhood experience. I am of the belief that this condition is not psychological brought on by an event but rather physiological. I say that as lay person with no medical training, obviously. However, many people here were not treated poorly at the table at all and yet have 4S. Given what so many people have shared here it seems unlikely you have this condition due to your abusive father (which he obviously was). It's much more likely he had 4S and that was how he was dealing with it and you, sadly, inherited it, like most of us. My aunt has it and we certainly didn't grow up in the same house. In that same vein I don't think your wife can catch it but she probably has become more sensitive and is getting weary of being glared at etc. Many have reported sound immersion does not work. I think we can do things to keep down our stress so that how we respond is made more bearable, especially for others In our life. We can use yoga, exercise, mediation, therapy, good nutrition to help. But so far I don't think we can eliminate our 4S. I try to keep myself in a good place physically and emotionally so that I can cope better when sounds bother me and not take my issue out on other people. And of course I use my earplugs and iPod when necessary. Sadly there doesn't seem to be a fix yet. But certainly addressing what you went through in childhood through therapy could probably help with your responses/reactions. Good luck and welcome again, HeidiSent from my iPhone Hi Everyone,I'm new to the group and joined specifically to save my marriage. I'm pretty sure I know why I have this condition. And now it seems that my wife is beginning to " catch " it.Background: As a child (I'm 45), my siblings and I would be punished for making " avoidable " noises at the dinner table (e.g., scraping teeth with a fork, humming, chewing with our mouths open, snorting, scraping knives sideways on a plate, etc.) The first infraction during a meal would result in an icy stare from my father and tension in the room for the rest of the meal. A second infraction would result in punishment. The punishment was pretty standard - go to bed for the rest of the day - without finishing the meal. No TV, books, newspapers, magazines, radio, etc. Pretty much just go sit in silence and we'll see you tomorrow. If we cried, he'd come upstairs and " give us something to cry about " - usually a beating with his belt.I'm not looking for sympathy, nor do I want to appear as one of the " it's all my father's fault " people. I'm just laying out the facts as I believe they are related to my 4S.What I " learned " was that making unnecessary sounds would result in punishment; and even if I wasn't the one being punished, I still had to sit through the remainder of the meal - which was punishment in itself. What started out as a nice dinner could end with tension, fear, and anxiety. Over time, everyone at the table would shoot an icy stare at the offender. We all were taking on my father's aversion to everyday sounds. Maybe he had 4S? Sound irritation moved from the dinner table to the house in general (playing too loudly, creaking the stairs, popping bubble gum, etc), to school, to work, to my own home. The list of sounds that I just can't ignore now includes everything mentioned above plus chewing hard candy, fussing with candy wrappers and plastic bags, chewing ice, playing with coins in a pocket, newscasters with speech impediments, mispronounced words like " shtreet " (instead of " street " ), incessant clicking of a pen, typing, lip smacking at the beginning of every sentence, word repetition (i.e. same word being used multiple times in a sentence), feet thudding across the floor above me, chair legs screeching when dragged across a floor, etc, etc.These sounds don't make me fearful or fill me with rage, they irritate and aggravate. My reaction to these sounds can be staring, mimicking the sound, talking loudly enough to drown out the sound, turning up the volume of the tv/radio, leaving the room, etc. I used to say something about it, but people weren't very sympathetic. They'd make more noise just to bug me. Being forced to deal with irritating sounds without vocalizing displeasure caused me to be more passive in my responses.A worst-case scenario for me is when I'm in a meeting or seminar and there are bowls of hard candy at every table. There's always someone that will eat a whole bowl of them - and refill at every break. It may take a minute or so of fussing with the wrapper to get the candy open. Then they crunch the candy rather than letting it dissolve slowly. While doing this, they mindlessly fold the wrapper into the tiniest square possible. Then they begin unwrapping another piece as the final bits of the previous piece are being chomped. This is worst-case for me because I can't focus on the topic being discussed and I can't tune out what I'm hearing. I just sit there stewing - waiting for someone to tell them to SHUT UP; wondering how everyone else can tune it out while I can't; wondering how someone can deliberately be so rude and inconsiderate of others; and looking around the room trying to make eye contact with others that are annoyed but finding no one. Once that person does take a break, someone else picks up where he left off. Eventually, I have to join in as it's the only way to make enough noise to drown out what I'm hearing. The session ends, I've learned nothing, and I've eaten a bunch of candy. During breaks, I've asked other people " Could that guy make more of a racket with the candy? " and the response is always " What guy? I didn't hear anything. " Basically they're saying that I have issues.Recently, my wife told me that she's tired of walking on eggshells around me. I was surprised because I just passively and subtly leave the room, turn up the radio, talk, etc when she makes a sound that annoys me. I realize that it's my problem and deal with it the best I can - without directing anger toward her. But she's no dummy. She sees the icy stare out of the corner of her eye; she realizes I'm leaving the room because I don't want to hear her crunch cereal; she knows that using her emory board on her nails will cause me to take the dog out; etc. When she drops a piece of silverware, she now experiences all the feelings I experienced 40 years ago. She becomes tense, waiting for my reaction, knowing I'm completely irritated. I don't want her feeling that way around me. I have to change.As far as I'm concerned, my 4S is a behavioral issue caused by events that occurred an early age and allowed to grow unchecked for decades. Now I need to fix it. I don't think medicines or vitamins are the answer. For me, I think it's " unlearning " the behavior. My guess is that either hypnosis or completely immersing myself in sounds I hate will be the cure for me. Maybe I should make a recording of the sounds and play them loudly during my commute. If I can tolerate them for an hour straight, I should be able to tolerate the occasional instance.Out of curiosity, have any of you had an early experience similar to mine where punishment may have caused the symptoms of 4S? Or did most people have a relatively normal childhood and feel that 4S is more genetic than environmental? Has anyone tried hypnotism or " sound immersion " ?Thanks for listening.MarkPS - I'm not a fan of receiving long emails so I apologize for sending one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Mark,I too had an abusive step-father who would hit me upside my head when he heard me smack at the table. At that time, I was not even aware of the sounds I made or sounds like these that others made. But from that time (almost 50 years now) I have struggled with this syndrome. At the start it was just the eating sounds that drove me crazy, but as time has moved on, additional sounds drive crazy. I could make a very long list of these sounds now!JRSent from my iPad

Hi Everyone,I'm new to the group and joined specifically to save my marriage. I'm pretty sure I know why I have this condition. And now it seems that my wife is beginning to "catch" it.Background: As a child (I'm 45), my siblings and I would be punished for making "avoidable" noises at the dinner table (e.g., scraping teeth with a fork, humming, chewing with our mouths open, snorting, scraping knives sideways on a plate, etc.) The first infraction during a meal would result in an icy stare from my father and tension in the room for the rest of the meal. A second infraction would result in punishment. The punishment was pretty standard - go to bed for the rest of the day - without finishing the

meal. No TV, books, newspapers, magazines, radio, etc. Pretty much just go sit in silence and we'll see you tomorrow. If we cried, he'd come upstairs and "give us something to cry about" - usually a beating with his belt.I'm not looking for sympathy, nor do I want to appear as one of the "it's all my father's fault" people. I'm just laying out the facts as I believe they are related to my 4S.What I "learned" was that making unnecessary sounds would result in punishment; and even if I wasn't the one being punished, I still had to sit through the remainder of the meal - which was punishment in itself. What started out as a nice dinner could end with tension, fear, and anxiety. Over time, everyone at the table would shoot an icy stare at the offender. We all were taking on my father's aversion to everyday sounds. Maybe he had 4S? Sound irritation moved from the dinner table to

the house in general (playing too loudly, creaking the stairs, popping bubble gum, etc), to school, to work, to my own home. The list of sounds that I just can't ignore now includes everything mentioned above plus chewing hard candy, fussing with candy wrappers and plastic bags, chewing ice, playing with coins in a pocket, newscasters with speech impediments, mispronounced words like "shtreet" (instead of "street"), incessant clicking of a pen, typing, lip smacking at the beginning of every sentence, word repetition (i.e. same word being used multiple times in a sentence), feet thudding across the floor above me, chair legs screeching when dragged across a floor, etc, etc.These sounds don't make me fearful or fill me with rage, they irritate and aggravate. My reaction to these sounds can be staring, mimicking the sound, talking loudly enough to drown out the sound, turning up the volume of the tv/radio, leaving the room,

etc. I used to say something about it, but people weren't very sympathetic. They'd make more noise just to bug me. Being forced to deal with irritating sounds without vocalizing displeasure caused me to be more passive in my responses.A worst-case scenario for me is when I'm in a meeting or seminar and there are bowls of hard candy at every table. There's always someone that will eat a whole bowl of them - and refill at every break. It may take a minute or so of fussing with the wrapper to get the candy open. Then they crunch the candy rather than letting it dissolve slowly. While doing this, they mindlessly fold the wrapper into the tiniest square possible. Then they begin unwrapping another piece as the final bits of the previous piece are being chomped. This is worst-case for me because I can't focus on the topic being discussed and I can't tune out what I'm hearing. I just sit there

stewing - waiting for someone to tell them to SHUT UP; wondering how everyone else can tune it out while I can't; wondering how someone can deliberately be so rude and inconsiderate of others; and looking around the room trying to make eye contact with others that are annoyed but finding no one. Once that person does take a break, someone else picks up where he left off. Eventually, I have to join in as it's the only way to make enough noise to drown out what I'm hearing. The session ends, I've learned nothing, and I've eaten a bunch of candy. During breaks, I've asked other people "Could that guy make more of a racket with the candy?" and the response is always "What guy? I didn't hear anything." Basically they're saying that I have issues.Recently, my wife told me that she's tired of walking on eggshells around me. I was surprised because I just passively and subtly leave the room, turn up the radio,

talk, etc when she makes a sound that annoys me. I realize that it's my problem and deal with it the best I can - without directing anger toward her. But she's no dummy. She sees the icy stare out of the corner of her eye; she realizes I'm leaving the room because I don't want to hear her crunch cereal; she knows that using her emory board on her nails will cause me to take the dog out; etc. When she drops a piece of silverware, she now experiences all the feelings I experienced 40 years ago. She becomes tense, waiting for my reaction, knowing I'm completely irritated. I don't want her feeling that way around me. I have to change.As far as I'm concerned, my 4S is a behavioral issue caused by events that occurred an early age and allowed to grow unchecked for decades. Now I need to fix it. I don't think medicines or vitamins are the answer. For me, I think it's "unlearning" the

behavior. My guess is that either hypnosis or completely immersing myself in sounds I hate will be the cure for me. Maybe I should make a recording of the sounds and play them loudly during my commute. If I can tolerate them for an hour straight, I should be able to tolerate the occasional instance.Out of curiosity, have any of you had an early experience similar to mine where punishment may have caused the symptoms of 4S? Or did most people have a relatively normal childhood and feel that 4S is more genetic than environmental? Has anyone tried hypnotism or "sound immersion"?Thanks for listening.MarkPS - I'm not a fan of receiving long emails so I apologize for sending one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Mark,I too had an abusive step-father who would hit me upside my head when he heard me smack at the table. At that time, I was not even aware of the sounds I made or sounds like these that others made. But from that time (almost 50 years now) I have struggled with this syndrome. At the start it was just the eating sounds that drove me crazy, but as time has moved on, additional sounds drive crazy. I could make a very long list of these sounds now!JRSent from my iPad

Hi Everyone,I'm new to the group and joined specifically to save my marriage. I'm pretty sure I know why I have this condition. And now it seems that my wife is beginning to "catch" it.Background: As a child (I'm 45), my siblings and I would be punished for making "avoidable" noises at the dinner table (e.g., scraping teeth with a fork, humming, chewing with our mouths open, snorting, scraping knives sideways on a plate, etc.) The first infraction during a meal would result in an icy stare from my father and tension in the room for the rest of the meal. A second infraction would result in punishment. The punishment was pretty standard - go to bed for the rest of the day - without finishing the

meal. No TV, books, newspapers, magazines, radio, etc. Pretty much just go sit in silence and we'll see you tomorrow. If we cried, he'd come upstairs and "give us something to cry about" - usually a beating with his belt.I'm not looking for sympathy, nor do I want to appear as one of the "it's all my father's fault" people. I'm just laying out the facts as I believe they are related to my 4S.What I "learned" was that making unnecessary sounds would result in punishment; and even if I wasn't the one being punished, I still had to sit through the remainder of the meal - which was punishment in itself. What started out as a nice dinner could end with tension, fear, and anxiety. Over time, everyone at the table would shoot an icy stare at the offender. We all were taking on my father's aversion to everyday sounds. Maybe he had 4S? Sound irritation moved from the dinner table to

the house in general (playing too loudly, creaking the stairs, popping bubble gum, etc), to school, to work, to my own home. The list of sounds that I just can't ignore now includes everything mentioned above plus chewing hard candy, fussing with candy wrappers and plastic bags, chewing ice, playing with coins in a pocket, newscasters with speech impediments, mispronounced words like "shtreet" (instead of "street"), incessant clicking of a pen, typing, lip smacking at the beginning of every sentence, word repetition (i.e. same word being used multiple times in a sentence), feet thudding across the floor above me, chair legs screeching when dragged across a floor, etc, etc.These sounds don't make me fearful or fill me with rage, they irritate and aggravate. My reaction to these sounds can be staring, mimicking the sound, talking loudly enough to drown out the sound, turning up the volume of the tv/radio, leaving the room,

etc. I used to say something about it, but people weren't very sympathetic. They'd make more noise just to bug me. Being forced to deal with irritating sounds without vocalizing displeasure caused me to be more passive in my responses.A worst-case scenario for me is when I'm in a meeting or seminar and there are bowls of hard candy at every table. There's always someone that will eat a whole bowl of them - and refill at every break. It may take a minute or so of fussing with the wrapper to get the candy open. Then they crunch the candy rather than letting it dissolve slowly. While doing this, they mindlessly fold the wrapper into the tiniest square possible. Then they begin unwrapping another piece as the final bits of the previous piece are being chomped. This is worst-case for me because I can't focus on the topic being discussed and I can't tune out what I'm hearing. I just sit there

stewing - waiting for someone to tell them to SHUT UP; wondering how everyone else can tune it out while I can't; wondering how someone can deliberately be so rude and inconsiderate of others; and looking around the room trying to make eye contact with others that are annoyed but finding no one. Once that person does take a break, someone else picks up where he left off. Eventually, I have to join in as it's the only way to make enough noise to drown out what I'm hearing. The session ends, I've learned nothing, and I've eaten a bunch of candy. During breaks, I've asked other people "Could that guy make more of a racket with the candy?" and the response is always "What guy? I didn't hear anything." Basically they're saying that I have issues.Recently, my wife told me that she's tired of walking on eggshells around me. I was surprised because I just passively and subtly leave the room, turn up the radio,

talk, etc when she makes a sound that annoys me. I realize that it's my problem and deal with it the best I can - without directing anger toward her. But she's no dummy. She sees the icy stare out of the corner of her eye; she realizes I'm leaving the room because I don't want to hear her crunch cereal; she knows that using her emory board on her nails will cause me to take the dog out; etc. When she drops a piece of silverware, she now experiences all the feelings I experienced 40 years ago. She becomes tense, waiting for my reaction, knowing I'm completely irritated. I don't want her feeling that way around me. I have to change.As far as I'm concerned, my 4S is a behavioral issue caused by events that occurred an early age and allowed to grow unchecked for decades. Now I need to fix it. I don't think medicines or vitamins are the answer. For me, I think it's "unlearning" the

behavior. My guess is that either hypnosis or completely immersing myself in sounds I hate will be the cure for me. Maybe I should make a recording of the sounds and play them loudly during my commute. If I can tolerate them for an hour straight, I should be able to tolerate the occasional instance.Out of curiosity, have any of you had an early experience similar to mine where punishment may have caused the symptoms of 4S? Or did most people have a relatively normal childhood and feel that 4S is more genetic than environmental? Has anyone tried hypnotism or "sound immersion"?Thanks for listening.MarkPS - I'm not a fan of receiving long emails so I apologize for sending one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My mother who had 4S told me that she was frightened of her father and was bothered by her fathers eating noises when at the table. I was driven nuts at the table and was always upset when eating. A friend from therapy told me her father would sexually molest her then sit at the dinner table and being so upset , focus on his eating which was so upsetting to her. Eating together as a family is a very intimate experience. It can be wonderful , but being intimate can be too close for comfort when there are problems and negative feelings.

But I think there is something more to it than that . A predisposition, maybe genetic maybe learned. I just don't know.

ML.

Hi Everyone,I'm new to the group and joined specifically to save my marriage. I'm pretty sure I know why I have this condition. And now it seems that my wife is beginning to "catch" it.Background: As a child (I'm 45), my siblings and I would be punished for making "avoidable" noises at the dinner table (e.g., scraping teeth with a fork, humming, chewing with our mouths open, snorting, scraping knives sideways on a plate, etc.) The first infraction during a meal would result in an icy stare from my father and tension in the room for the rest of the meal. A second infraction would result in punishment. The punishment was pretty standard - go to bed for the rest of the day - without finishing the meal. No TV, books, newspapers, magazines, radio, etc. Pretty much just

go sit in silence and we'll see you tomorrow. If we cried, he'd come upstairs and "give us something to cry about" - usually a beating with his belt.I'm not looking for sympathy, nor do I want to appear as one of the "it's all my father's fault" people. I'm just laying out the facts as I believe they are related to my 4S.What I "learned" was that making unnecessary sounds would result in punishment; and even if I wasn't the one being punished, I still had to sit through the remainder of the meal - which was punishment in itself. What started out as a nice dinner could end with tension, fear, and anxiety. Over time, everyone at the table would shoot an icy stare at the offender. We all were taking on my father's aversion to everyday sounds. Maybe he had 4S? Sound irritation moved from the dinner table to the house in general (playing too loudly, creaking the stairs, popping bubble gum,

etc), to school, to work, to my own home. The list of sounds that I just can't ignore now includes everything mentioned above plus chewing hard candy, fussing with candy wrappers and plastic bags, chewing ice, playing with coins in a pocket, newscasters with speech impediments, mispronounced words like "shtreet" (instead of "street"), incessant clicking of a pen, typing, lip smacking at the beginning of every sentence, word repetition (i.e. same word being used multiple times in a sentence), feet thudding across the floor above me, chair legs screeching when dragged across a floor, etc, etc.These sounds don't make me fearful or fill me with rage, they irritate and aggravate. My reaction to these sounds can be staring, mimicking the sound, talking loudly enough to drown out the sound, turning up the volume of the tv/radio, leaving the room, etc. I used to say something about it, but people weren't very sympathetic.

They'd make more noise just to bug me. Being forced to deal with irritating sounds without vocalizing displeasure caused me to be more passive in my responses.A worst-case scenario for me is when I'm in a meeting or seminar and there are bowls of hard candy at every table. There's always someone that will eat a whole bowl of them - and refill at every break. It may take a minute or so of fussing with the wrapper to get the candy open. Then they crunch the candy rather than letting it dissolve slowly. While doing this, they mindlessly fold the wrapper into the tiniest square possible. Then they begin unwrapping another piece as the final bits of the previous piece are being chomped. This is worst-case for me because I can't focus on the topic being discussed and I can't tune out what I'm hearing. I just sit there stewing - waiting for someone to tell them to SHUT UP; wondering how everyone else can

tune it out while I can't; wondering how someone can deliberately be so rude and inconsiderate of others; and looking around the room trying to make eye contact with others that are annoyed but finding no one. Once that person does take a break, someone else picks up where he left off. Eventually, I have to join in as it's the only way to make enough noise to drown out what I'm hearing. The session ends, I've learned nothing, and I've eaten a bunch of candy. During breaks, I've asked other people "Could that guy make more of a racket with the candy?" and the response is always "What guy? I didn't hear anything." Basically they're saying that I have issues.Recently, my wife told me that she's tired of walking on eggshells around me. I was surprised because I just passively and subtly leave the room, turn up the radio, talk, etc when she makes a sound that annoys me. I realize that it's my problem

and deal with it the best I can - without directing anger toward her. But she's no dummy. She sees the icy stare out of the corner of her eye; she realizes I'm leaving the room because I don't want to hear her crunch cereal; she knows that using her emory board on her nails will cause me to take the dog out; etc. When she drops a piece of silverware, she now experiences all the feelings I experienced 40 years ago. She becomes tense, waiting for my reaction, knowing I'm completely irritated. I don't want her feeling that way around me. I have to change.As far as I'm concerned, my 4S is a behavioral issue caused by events that occurred an early age and allowed to grow unchecked for decades. Now I need to fix it. I don't think medicines or vitamins are the answer. For me, I think it's "unlearning" the behavior. My guess is that either hypnosis or completely immersing myself in sounds I

hate will be the cure for me. Maybe I should make a recording of the sounds and play them loudly during my commute. If I can tolerate them for an hour straight, I should be able to tolerate the occasional instance.Out of curiosity, have any of you had an early experience similar to mine where punishment may have caused the symptoms of 4S? Or did most people have a relatively normal childhood and feel that 4S is more genetic than environmental? Has anyone tried hypnotism or "sound immersion"?Thanks for listening.MarkPS - I'm not a fan of receiving long emails so I apologize for sending one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My mother who had 4S told me that she was frightened of her father and was bothered by her fathers eating noises when at the table. I was driven nuts at the table and was always upset when eating. A friend from therapy told me her father would sexually molest her then sit at the dinner table and being so upset , focus on his eating which was so upsetting to her. Eating together as a family is a very intimate experience. It can be wonderful , but being intimate can be too close for comfort when there are problems and negative feelings.

But I think there is something more to it than that . A predisposition, maybe genetic maybe learned. I just don't know.

ML.

Hi Everyone,I'm new to the group and joined specifically to save my marriage. I'm pretty sure I know why I have this condition. And now it seems that my wife is beginning to "catch" it.Background: As a child (I'm 45), my siblings and I would be punished for making "avoidable" noises at the dinner table (e.g., scraping teeth with a fork, humming, chewing with our mouths open, snorting, scraping knives sideways on a plate, etc.) The first infraction during a meal would result in an icy stare from my father and tension in the room for the rest of the meal. A second infraction would result in punishment. The punishment was pretty standard - go to bed for the rest of the day - without finishing the meal. No TV, books, newspapers, magazines, radio, etc. Pretty much just

go sit in silence and we'll see you tomorrow. If we cried, he'd come upstairs and "give us something to cry about" - usually a beating with his belt.I'm not looking for sympathy, nor do I want to appear as one of the "it's all my father's fault" people. I'm just laying out the facts as I believe they are related to my 4S.What I "learned" was that making unnecessary sounds would result in punishment; and even if I wasn't the one being punished, I still had to sit through the remainder of the meal - which was punishment in itself. What started out as a nice dinner could end with tension, fear, and anxiety. Over time, everyone at the table would shoot an icy stare at the offender. We all were taking on my father's aversion to everyday sounds. Maybe he had 4S? Sound irritation moved from the dinner table to the house in general (playing too loudly, creaking the stairs, popping bubble gum,

etc), to school, to work, to my own home. The list of sounds that I just can't ignore now includes everything mentioned above plus chewing hard candy, fussing with candy wrappers and plastic bags, chewing ice, playing with coins in a pocket, newscasters with speech impediments, mispronounced words like "shtreet" (instead of "street"), incessant clicking of a pen, typing, lip smacking at the beginning of every sentence, word repetition (i.e. same word being used multiple times in a sentence), feet thudding across the floor above me, chair legs screeching when dragged across a floor, etc, etc.These sounds don't make me fearful or fill me with rage, they irritate and aggravate. My reaction to these sounds can be staring, mimicking the sound, talking loudly enough to drown out the sound, turning up the volume of the tv/radio, leaving the room, etc. I used to say something about it, but people weren't very sympathetic.

They'd make more noise just to bug me. Being forced to deal with irritating sounds without vocalizing displeasure caused me to be more passive in my responses.A worst-case scenario for me is when I'm in a meeting or seminar and there are bowls of hard candy at every table. There's always someone that will eat a whole bowl of them - and refill at every break. It may take a minute or so of fussing with the wrapper to get the candy open. Then they crunch the candy rather than letting it dissolve slowly. While doing this, they mindlessly fold the wrapper into the tiniest square possible. Then they begin unwrapping another piece as the final bits of the previous piece are being chomped. This is worst-case for me because I can't focus on the topic being discussed and I can't tune out what I'm hearing. I just sit there stewing - waiting for someone to tell them to SHUT UP; wondering how everyone else can

tune it out while I can't; wondering how someone can deliberately be so rude and inconsiderate of others; and looking around the room trying to make eye contact with others that are annoyed but finding no one. Once that person does take a break, someone else picks up where he left off. Eventually, I have to join in as it's the only way to make enough noise to drown out what I'm hearing. The session ends, I've learned nothing, and I've eaten a bunch of candy. During breaks, I've asked other people "Could that guy make more of a racket with the candy?" and the response is always "What guy? I didn't hear anything." Basically they're saying that I have issues.Recently, my wife told me that she's tired of walking on eggshells around me. I was surprised because I just passively and subtly leave the room, turn up the radio, talk, etc when she makes a sound that annoys me. I realize that it's my problem

and deal with it the best I can - without directing anger toward her. But she's no dummy. She sees the icy stare out of the corner of her eye; she realizes I'm leaving the room because I don't want to hear her crunch cereal; she knows that using her emory board on her nails will cause me to take the dog out; etc. When she drops a piece of silverware, she now experiences all the feelings I experienced 40 years ago. She becomes tense, waiting for my reaction, knowing I'm completely irritated. I don't want her feeling that way around me. I have to change.As far as I'm concerned, my 4S is a behavioral issue caused by events that occurred an early age and allowed to grow unchecked for decades. Now I need to fix it. I don't think medicines or vitamins are the answer. For me, I think it's "unlearning" the behavior. My guess is that either hypnosis or completely immersing myself in sounds I

hate will be the cure for me. Maybe I should make a recording of the sounds and play them loudly during my commute. If I can tolerate them for an hour straight, I should be able to tolerate the occasional instance.Out of curiosity, have any of you had an early experience similar to mine where punishment may have caused the symptoms of 4S? Or did most people have a relatively normal childhood and feel that 4S is more genetic than environmental? Has anyone tried hypnotism or "sound immersion"?Thanks for listening.MarkPS - I'm not a fan of receiving long emails so I apologize for sending one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My mother who had 4S told me that she was frightened of her father and was bothered by her fathers eating noises when at the table. I was driven nuts at the table and was always upset when eating. A friend from therapy told me her father would sexually molest her then sit at the dinner table and being so upset , focus on his eating which was so upsetting to her. Eating together as a family is a very intimate experience. It can be wonderful , but being intimate can be too close for comfort when there are problems and negative feelings.

But I think there is something more to it than that . A predisposition, maybe genetic maybe learned. I just don't know.

ML.

Hi Everyone,I'm new to the group and joined specifically to save my marriage. I'm pretty sure I know why I have this condition. And now it seems that my wife is beginning to "catch" it.Background: As a child (I'm 45), my siblings and I would be punished for making "avoidable" noises at the dinner table (e.g., scraping teeth with a fork, humming, chewing with our mouths open, snorting, scraping knives sideways on a plate, etc.) The first infraction during a meal would result in an icy stare from my father and tension in the room for the rest of the meal. A second infraction would result in punishment. The punishment was pretty standard - go to bed for the rest of the day - without finishing the meal. No TV, books, newspapers, magazines, radio, etc. Pretty much just

go sit in silence and we'll see you tomorrow. If we cried, he'd come upstairs and "give us something to cry about" - usually a beating with his belt.I'm not looking for sympathy, nor do I want to appear as one of the "it's all my father's fault" people. I'm just laying out the facts as I believe they are related to my 4S.What I "learned" was that making unnecessary sounds would result in punishment; and even if I wasn't the one being punished, I still had to sit through the remainder of the meal - which was punishment in itself. What started out as a nice dinner could end with tension, fear, and anxiety. Over time, everyone at the table would shoot an icy stare at the offender. We all were taking on my father's aversion to everyday sounds. Maybe he had 4S? Sound irritation moved from the dinner table to the house in general (playing too loudly, creaking the stairs, popping bubble gum,

etc), to school, to work, to my own home. The list of sounds that I just can't ignore now includes everything mentioned above plus chewing hard candy, fussing with candy wrappers and plastic bags, chewing ice, playing with coins in a pocket, newscasters with speech impediments, mispronounced words like "shtreet" (instead of "street"), incessant clicking of a pen, typing, lip smacking at the beginning of every sentence, word repetition (i.e. same word being used multiple times in a sentence), feet thudding across the floor above me, chair legs screeching when dragged across a floor, etc, etc.These sounds don't make me fearful or fill me with rage, they irritate and aggravate. My reaction to these sounds can be staring, mimicking the sound, talking loudly enough to drown out the sound, turning up the volume of the tv/radio, leaving the room, etc. I used to say something about it, but people weren't very sympathetic.

They'd make more noise just to bug me. Being forced to deal with irritating sounds without vocalizing displeasure caused me to be more passive in my responses.A worst-case scenario for me is when I'm in a meeting or seminar and there are bowls of hard candy at every table. There's always someone that will eat a whole bowl of them - and refill at every break. It may take a minute or so of fussing with the wrapper to get the candy open. Then they crunch the candy rather than letting it dissolve slowly. While doing this, they mindlessly fold the wrapper into the tiniest square possible. Then they begin unwrapping another piece as the final bits of the previous piece are being chomped. This is worst-case for me because I can't focus on the topic being discussed and I can't tune out what I'm hearing. I just sit there stewing - waiting for someone to tell them to SHUT UP; wondering how everyone else can

tune it out while I can't; wondering how someone can deliberately be so rude and inconsiderate of others; and looking around the room trying to make eye contact with others that are annoyed but finding no one. Once that person does take a break, someone else picks up where he left off. Eventually, I have to join in as it's the only way to make enough noise to drown out what I'm hearing. The session ends, I've learned nothing, and I've eaten a bunch of candy. During breaks, I've asked other people "Could that guy make more of a racket with the candy?" and the response is always "What guy? I didn't hear anything." Basically they're saying that I have issues.Recently, my wife told me that she's tired of walking on eggshells around me. I was surprised because I just passively and subtly leave the room, turn up the radio, talk, etc when she makes a sound that annoys me. I realize that it's my problem

and deal with it the best I can - without directing anger toward her. But she's no dummy. She sees the icy stare out of the corner of her eye; she realizes I'm leaving the room because I don't want to hear her crunch cereal; she knows that using her emory board on her nails will cause me to take the dog out; etc. When she drops a piece of silverware, she now experiences all the feelings I experienced 40 years ago. She becomes tense, waiting for my reaction, knowing I'm completely irritated. I don't want her feeling that way around me. I have to change.As far as I'm concerned, my 4S is a behavioral issue caused by events that occurred an early age and allowed to grow unchecked for decades. Now I need to fix it. I don't think medicines or vitamins are the answer. For me, I think it's "unlearning" the behavior. My guess is that either hypnosis or completely immersing myself in sounds I

hate will be the cure for me. Maybe I should make a recording of the sounds and play them loudly during my commute. If I can tolerate them for an hour straight, I should be able to tolerate the occasional instance.Out of curiosity, have any of you had an early experience similar to mine where punishment may have caused the symptoms of 4S? Or did most people have a relatively normal childhood and feel that 4S is more genetic than environmental? Has anyone tried hypnotism or "sound immersion"?Thanks for listening.MarkPS - I'm not a fan of receiving long emails so I apologize for sending one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mine did onset at the age of 11 or so but there was certainly no abuse in my family. My father is bothered by visual cues such as a tapping foot in his peripheral vision while he is watching tv or a person he is trying to talk to fidgeting (as well as talking too fast) but no abuse, just irritation. I believe with every fiber of my being that it is not psychological. I have been on numerous medications since that age, tried immersing myself, learning to "deal" and viewing it as something that I "must learn to control" but nothing worked. I think others perhaps react to in a way that makes sense to them (ie they think to themselves 'when something annoys me I just tune it out or ignore it, why can't YOU do that!') because they do not suffer physically from it and their reactions are not a complex mix of emotional and

physiological. I often tell my partner that if I had a switch to control it I would have learned to turn it off long ago instead of suffering through years and years of ruined dinners, dates, special occasions, etc.

A world of madeis not a world of born--pity poor fleshand trees,poor stars and stones,but never thisfine specimen of hypermagicalultraomnipotence. We doctors knowa hopeless case if--listen:there's a hellof a good universe next door;let's go-E.E Cummings

Subject: Re: My experience with 4STo: Soundsensitivity Date: Monday, January 31, 2011, 8:47 PM

Mark's story TODAY sounds a lot like mine. The only difference is onset. My problems did not start as a child. Those who say that everyone with 4S must have had a bad experience at the dinner table have to be crazy when so many have said that they did not. If it's all or nothing, and so many say they did not have that experience, then it throws that theory right out of the water.I'm not saying that some cases could not have been brought on by that, but certainly not all. My 4s (or whatever it is called) did not start until I was 23 years old.> > > Hi Everyone,> > > > I'm new to the group and joined specifically to save my marriage. I'm pretty sure I know why I have this condition. And now it seems that my wife is beginning to "catch" it.> > > > Background: As a child (I'm 45), my siblings and I

would be punished for making "avoidable" noises at the dinner table (e.g., scraping teeth with a fork, humming, chewing with our mouths open, snorting, scraping knives sideways on a plate, etc.) The first infraction during a meal would result in an icy stare from my father and tension in the room for the rest of the meal. A second infraction would result in punishment. The punishment was pretty standard - go to bed for the rest of the day - without finishing the meal. No TV, books, newspapers, magazines, radio, etc. Pretty much just go sit in silence and we'll see you tomorrow. If we cried, he'd come upstairs and "give us something to cry about" - usually a beating with his belt.> > > > I'm not looking for sympathy, nor do I want to appear as one of the "it's all my father's fault" people. I'm just laying out the facts as I believe they are related to my 4S.> > > > What I "learned" was that making unnecessary

sounds would result in punishment; and even if I wasn't the one being punished, I still had to sit through the remainder of the meal - which was punishment in itself. What started out as a nice dinner could end with tension, fear, and anxiety. Over time, everyone at the table would shoot an icy stare at the offender. We all were taking on my father's aversion to everyday sounds. Maybe he had 4S? > > > > Sound irritation moved from the dinner table to the house in general (playing too loudly, creaking the stairs, popping bubble gum, etc), to school, to work, to my own home. The list of sounds that I just can't ignore now includes everything mentioned above plus chewing hard candy, fussing with candy wrappers and plastic bags, chewing ice, playing with coins in a pocket, newscasters with speech impediments, mispronounced words like "shtreet" (instead of "street"), incessant clicking of a pen, typing, lip smacking at the beginning of

every sentence, word repetition (i.e. same word being used multiple times in a sentence), feet thudding across the floor above me, chair legs screeching when dragged across a floor, etc, etc.> > > > These sounds don't make me fearful or fill me with rage, they irritate and aggravate. > > > > My reaction to these sounds can be staring, mimicking the sound, talking loudly enough to drown out the sound, turning up the volume of the tv/radio, leaving the room, etc. I used to say something about it, but people weren't very sympathetic. They'd make more noise just to bug me. Being forced to deal with irritating sounds without vocalizing displeasure caused me to be more passive in my responses.> > > > A worst-case scenario for me is when I'm in a meeting or seminar and there are bowls of hard candy at every table. There's always someone that will eat a whole bowl of them - and refill at every break.

It may take a minute or so of fussing with the wrapper to get the candy open. Then they crunch the candy rather than letting it dissolve slowly. While doing this, they mindlessly fold the wrapper into the tiniest square possible. Then they begin unwrapping another piece as the final bits of the previous piece are being chomped. This is worst-case for me because I can't focus on the topic being discussed and I can't tune out what I'm hearing. I just sit there stewing - waiting for someone to tell them to SHUT UP; wondering how everyone else can tune it out while I can't; wondering how someone can deliberately be so rude and inconsiderate of others; and looking around the room trying to make eye contact with others that are annoyed but finding no one. Once that person does take a break, someone else picks up where he left off. Eventually, I have to join in as it's the only way to make enough noise to drown out what I'm hearing. The session ends, I've

learned nothing, and I've eaten a bunch of candy. During breaks, I've asked other people "Could that guy make more of a racket with the candy?" and the response is always "What guy? I didn't hear anything." Basically they're saying that I have issues.> > > > Recently, my wife told me that she's tired of walking on eggshells around me. I was surprised because I just passively and subtly leave the room, turn up the radio, talk, etc when she makes a sound that annoys me. I realize that it's my problem and deal with it the best I can - without directing anger toward her. But she's no dummy. She sees the icy stare out of the corner of her eye; she realizes I'm leaving the room because I don't want to hear her crunch cereal; she knows that using her emory board on her nails will cause me to take the dog out; etc. When she drops a piece of silverware, she now experiences all the feelings I experienced 40 years ago. She becomes tense,

waiting for my reaction, knowing I'm completely irritated. I don't want her feeling that way around me. I have to change.> > > > As far as I'm concerned, my 4S is a behavioral issue caused by events that occurred an early age and allowed to grow unchecked for decades. Now I need to fix it. I don't think medicines or vitamins are the answer. For me, I think it's "unlearning" the behavior. My guess is that either hypnosis or completely immersing myself in sounds I hate will be the cure for me. Maybe I should make a recording of the sounds and play them loudly during my commute. If I can tolerate them for an hour straight, I should be able to tolerate the occasional instance.> > > > Out of curiosity, have any of you had an early experience similar to mine where punishment may have caused the symptoms of 4S? Or did most people have a relatively normal childhood and feel that 4S is more genetic than environmental? Has

anyone tried hypnotism or "sound immersion"?> > > > Thanks for listening.> > Mark> > > > PS - I'm not a fan of receiving long emails so I apologize for sending one.> > > > > > > >>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mine did onset at the age of 11 or so but there was certainly no abuse in my family. My father is bothered by visual cues such as a tapping foot in his peripheral vision while he is watching tv or a person he is trying to talk to fidgeting (as well as talking too fast) but no abuse, just irritation. I believe with every fiber of my being that it is not psychological. I have been on numerous medications since that age, tried immersing myself, learning to "deal" and viewing it as something that I "must learn to control" but nothing worked. I think others perhaps react to in a way that makes sense to them (ie they think to themselves 'when something annoys me I just tune it out or ignore it, why can't YOU do that!') because they do not suffer physically from it and their reactions are not a complex mix of emotional and

physiological. I often tell my partner that if I had a switch to control it I would have learned to turn it off long ago instead of suffering through years and years of ruined dinners, dates, special occasions, etc.

A world of madeis not a world of born--pity poor fleshand trees,poor stars and stones,but never thisfine specimen of hypermagicalultraomnipotence. We doctors knowa hopeless case if--listen:there's a hellof a good universe next door;let's go-E.E Cummings

Subject: Re: My experience with 4STo: Soundsensitivity Date: Monday, January 31, 2011, 8:47 PM

Mark's story TODAY sounds a lot like mine. The only difference is onset. My problems did not start as a child. Those who say that everyone with 4S must have had a bad experience at the dinner table have to be crazy when so many have said that they did not. If it's all or nothing, and so many say they did not have that experience, then it throws that theory right out of the water.I'm not saying that some cases could not have been brought on by that, but certainly not all. My 4s (or whatever it is called) did not start until I was 23 years old.> > > Hi Everyone,> > > > I'm new to the group and joined specifically to save my marriage. I'm pretty sure I know why I have this condition. And now it seems that my wife is beginning to "catch" it.> > > > Background: As a child (I'm 45), my siblings and I

would be punished for making "avoidable" noises at the dinner table (e.g., scraping teeth with a fork, humming, chewing with our mouths open, snorting, scraping knives sideways on a plate, etc.) The first infraction during a meal would result in an icy stare from my father and tension in the room for the rest of the meal. A second infraction would result in punishment. The punishment was pretty standard - go to bed for the rest of the day - without finishing the meal. No TV, books, newspapers, magazines, radio, etc. Pretty much just go sit in silence and we'll see you tomorrow. If we cried, he'd come upstairs and "give us something to cry about" - usually a beating with his belt.> > > > I'm not looking for sympathy, nor do I want to appear as one of the "it's all my father's fault" people. I'm just laying out the facts as I believe they are related to my 4S.> > > > What I "learned" was that making unnecessary

sounds would result in punishment; and even if I wasn't the one being punished, I still had to sit through the remainder of the meal - which was punishment in itself. What started out as a nice dinner could end with tension, fear, and anxiety. Over time, everyone at the table would shoot an icy stare at the offender. We all were taking on my father's aversion to everyday sounds. Maybe he had 4S? > > > > Sound irritation moved from the dinner table to the house in general (playing too loudly, creaking the stairs, popping bubble gum, etc), to school, to work, to my own home. The list of sounds that I just can't ignore now includes everything mentioned above plus chewing hard candy, fussing with candy wrappers and plastic bags, chewing ice, playing with coins in a pocket, newscasters with speech impediments, mispronounced words like "shtreet" (instead of "street"), incessant clicking of a pen, typing, lip smacking at the beginning of

every sentence, word repetition (i.e. same word being used multiple times in a sentence), feet thudding across the floor above me, chair legs screeching when dragged across a floor, etc, etc.> > > > These sounds don't make me fearful or fill me with rage, they irritate and aggravate. > > > > My reaction to these sounds can be staring, mimicking the sound, talking loudly enough to drown out the sound, turning up the volume of the tv/radio, leaving the room, etc. I used to say something about it, but people weren't very sympathetic. They'd make more noise just to bug me. Being forced to deal with irritating sounds without vocalizing displeasure caused me to be more passive in my responses.> > > > A worst-case scenario for me is when I'm in a meeting or seminar and there are bowls of hard candy at every table. There's always someone that will eat a whole bowl of them - and refill at every break.

It may take a minute or so of fussing with the wrapper to get the candy open. Then they crunch the candy rather than letting it dissolve slowly. While doing this, they mindlessly fold the wrapper into the tiniest square possible. Then they begin unwrapping another piece as the final bits of the previous piece are being chomped. This is worst-case for me because I can't focus on the topic being discussed and I can't tune out what I'm hearing. I just sit there stewing - waiting for someone to tell them to SHUT UP; wondering how everyone else can tune it out while I can't; wondering how someone can deliberately be so rude and inconsiderate of others; and looking around the room trying to make eye contact with others that are annoyed but finding no one. Once that person does take a break, someone else picks up where he left off. Eventually, I have to join in as it's the only way to make enough noise to drown out what I'm hearing. The session ends, I've

learned nothing, and I've eaten a bunch of candy. During breaks, I've asked other people "Could that guy make more of a racket with the candy?" and the response is always "What guy? I didn't hear anything." Basically they're saying that I have issues.> > > > Recently, my wife told me that she's tired of walking on eggshells around me. I was surprised because I just passively and subtly leave the room, turn up the radio, talk, etc when she makes a sound that annoys me. I realize that it's my problem and deal with it the best I can - without directing anger toward her. But she's no dummy. She sees the icy stare out of the corner of her eye; she realizes I'm leaving the room because I don't want to hear her crunch cereal; she knows that using her emory board on her nails will cause me to take the dog out; etc. When she drops a piece of silverware, she now experiences all the feelings I experienced 40 years ago. She becomes tense,

waiting for my reaction, knowing I'm completely irritated. I don't want her feeling that way around me. I have to change.> > > > As far as I'm concerned, my 4S is a behavioral issue caused by events that occurred an early age and allowed to grow unchecked for decades. Now I need to fix it. I don't think medicines or vitamins are the answer. For me, I think it's "unlearning" the behavior. My guess is that either hypnosis or completely immersing myself in sounds I hate will be the cure for me. Maybe I should make a recording of the sounds and play them loudly during my commute. If I can tolerate them for an hour straight, I should be able to tolerate the occasional instance.> > > > Out of curiosity, have any of you had an early experience similar to mine where punishment may have caused the symptoms of 4S? Or did most people have a relatively normal childhood and feel that 4S is more genetic than environmental? Has

anyone tried hypnotism or "sound immersion"?> > > > Thanks for listening.> > Mark> > > > PS - I'm not a fan of receiving long emails so I apologize for sending one.> > > > > > > >>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mine did onset at the age of 11 or so but there was certainly no abuse in my family. My father is bothered by visual cues such as a tapping foot in his peripheral vision while he is watching tv or a person he is trying to talk to fidgeting (as well as talking too fast) but no abuse, just irritation. I believe with every fiber of my being that it is not psychological. I have been on numerous medications since that age, tried immersing myself, learning to "deal" and viewing it as something that I "must learn to control" but nothing worked. I think others perhaps react to in a way that makes sense to them (ie they think to themselves 'when something annoys me I just tune it out or ignore it, why can't YOU do that!') because they do not suffer physically from it and their reactions are not a complex mix of emotional and

physiological. I often tell my partner that if I had a switch to control it I would have learned to turn it off long ago instead of suffering through years and years of ruined dinners, dates, special occasions, etc.

A world of madeis not a world of born--pity poor fleshand trees,poor stars and stones,but never thisfine specimen of hypermagicalultraomnipotence. We doctors knowa hopeless case if--listen:there's a hellof a good universe next door;let's go-E.E Cummings

Subject: Re: My experience with 4STo: Soundsensitivity Date: Monday, January 31, 2011, 8:47 PM

Mark's story TODAY sounds a lot like mine. The only difference is onset. My problems did not start as a child. Those who say that everyone with 4S must have had a bad experience at the dinner table have to be crazy when so many have said that they did not. If it's all or nothing, and so many say they did not have that experience, then it throws that theory right out of the water.I'm not saying that some cases could not have been brought on by that, but certainly not all. My 4s (or whatever it is called) did not start until I was 23 years old.> > > Hi Everyone,> > > > I'm new to the group and joined specifically to save my marriage. I'm pretty sure I know why I have this condition. And now it seems that my wife is beginning to "catch" it.> > > > Background: As a child (I'm 45), my siblings and I

would be punished for making "avoidable" noises at the dinner table (e.g., scraping teeth with a fork, humming, chewing with our mouths open, snorting, scraping knives sideways on a plate, etc.) The first infraction during a meal would result in an icy stare from my father and tension in the room for the rest of the meal. A second infraction would result in punishment. The punishment was pretty standard - go to bed for the rest of the day - without finishing the meal. No TV, books, newspapers, magazines, radio, etc. Pretty much just go sit in silence and we'll see you tomorrow. If we cried, he'd come upstairs and "give us something to cry about" - usually a beating with his belt.> > > > I'm not looking for sympathy, nor do I want to appear as one of the "it's all my father's fault" people. I'm just laying out the facts as I believe they are related to my 4S.> > > > What I "learned" was that making unnecessary

sounds would result in punishment; and even if I wasn't the one being punished, I still had to sit through the remainder of the meal - which was punishment in itself. What started out as a nice dinner could end with tension, fear, and anxiety. Over time, everyone at the table would shoot an icy stare at the offender. We all were taking on my father's aversion to everyday sounds. Maybe he had 4S? > > > > Sound irritation moved from the dinner table to the house in general (playing too loudly, creaking the stairs, popping bubble gum, etc), to school, to work, to my own home. The list of sounds that I just can't ignore now includes everything mentioned above plus chewing hard candy, fussing with candy wrappers and plastic bags, chewing ice, playing with coins in a pocket, newscasters with speech impediments, mispronounced words like "shtreet" (instead of "street"), incessant clicking of a pen, typing, lip smacking at the beginning of

every sentence, word repetition (i.e. same word being used multiple times in a sentence), feet thudding across the floor above me, chair legs screeching when dragged across a floor, etc, etc.> > > > These sounds don't make me fearful or fill me with rage, they irritate and aggravate. > > > > My reaction to these sounds can be staring, mimicking the sound, talking loudly enough to drown out the sound, turning up the volume of the tv/radio, leaving the room, etc. I used to say something about it, but people weren't very sympathetic. They'd make more noise just to bug me. Being forced to deal with irritating sounds without vocalizing displeasure caused me to be more passive in my responses.> > > > A worst-case scenario for me is when I'm in a meeting or seminar and there are bowls of hard candy at every table. There's always someone that will eat a whole bowl of them - and refill at every break.

It may take a minute or so of fussing with the wrapper to get the candy open. Then they crunch the candy rather than letting it dissolve slowly. While doing this, they mindlessly fold the wrapper into the tiniest square possible. Then they begin unwrapping another piece as the final bits of the previous piece are being chomped. This is worst-case for me because I can't focus on the topic being discussed and I can't tune out what I'm hearing. I just sit there stewing - waiting for someone to tell them to SHUT UP; wondering how everyone else can tune it out while I can't; wondering how someone can deliberately be so rude and inconsiderate of others; and looking around the room trying to make eye contact with others that are annoyed but finding no one. Once that person does take a break, someone else picks up where he left off. Eventually, I have to join in as it's the only way to make enough noise to drown out what I'm hearing. The session ends, I've

learned nothing, and I've eaten a bunch of candy. During breaks, I've asked other people "Could that guy make more of a racket with the candy?" and the response is always "What guy? I didn't hear anything." Basically they're saying that I have issues.> > > > Recently, my wife told me that she's tired of walking on eggshells around me. I was surprised because I just passively and subtly leave the room, turn up the radio, talk, etc when she makes a sound that annoys me. I realize that it's my problem and deal with it the best I can - without directing anger toward her. But she's no dummy. She sees the icy stare out of the corner of her eye; she realizes I'm leaving the room because I don't want to hear her crunch cereal; she knows that using her emory board on her nails will cause me to take the dog out; etc. When she drops a piece of silverware, she now experiences all the feelings I experienced 40 years ago. She becomes tense,

waiting for my reaction, knowing I'm completely irritated. I don't want her feeling that way around me. I have to change.> > > > As far as I'm concerned, my 4S is a behavioral issue caused by events that occurred an early age and allowed to grow unchecked for decades. Now I need to fix it. I don't think medicines or vitamins are the answer. For me, I think it's "unlearning" the behavior. My guess is that either hypnosis or completely immersing myself in sounds I hate will be the cure for me. Maybe I should make a recording of the sounds and play them loudly during my commute. If I can tolerate them for an hour straight, I should be able to tolerate the occasional instance.> > > > Out of curiosity, have any of you had an early experience similar to mine where punishment may have caused the symptoms of 4S? Or did most people have a relatively normal childhood and feel that 4S is more genetic than environmental? Has

anyone tried hypnotism or "sound immersion"?> > > > Thanks for listening.> > Mark> > > > PS - I'm not a fan of receiving long emails so I apologize for sending one.> > > > > > > >>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There were other noises besides the dinner table noises that started roughly at the same time for me, brother tipping stool (not at dinner table), brother chewing fingernails (not at dinner table), best friend clearing throat (not at dinner table), dog howling next store (nadt), kids sniffling at school, father inhaling pipe smoke, kids shrieking on playground, kids bouncing balls etc etc. I have a rather extensive list of irritating sounds from my childhood, not quite to the degree that I have now but spread out among different people and places. Family was the worst of course, but I was around them the most, so it makes sense that that is why. And dinner was the one time of day we were altogether on a daily basis, so of course it would stand out in memory.To: Soundsensitivity Sent: Mon, January 31, 2011 8:47:34 PMSubject: Re: My experience with 4S

Mark's story TODAY sounds a lot like mine. The only difference is onset. My problems did not start as a child. Those who say that everyone with 4S must have had a bad experience at the dinner table have to be crazy when so many have said that they did not. If it's all or nothing, and so many say they did not have that experience, then it throws that theory right out of the water.

I'm not saying that some cases could not have been brought on by that, but certainly not all. My 4s (or whatever it is called) did not start until I was 23 years old.

>

> > Hi Everyone,

> >

> > I'm new to the group and joined specifically to save my marriage. I'm pretty sure I know why I have this condition. And now it seems that my wife is beginning to "catch" it.

> >

> > Background: As a child (I'm 45), my siblings and I would be punished for making "avoidable" noises at the dinner table (e.g., scraping teeth with a fork, humming, chewing with our mouths open, snorting, scraping knives sideways on a plate, etc.) The first infraction during a meal would result in an icy stare from my father and tension in the room for the rest of the meal. A second infraction would result in punishment. The punishment was pretty standard - go to bed for the rest of the day - without finishing the meal. No TV, books, newspapers, magazines, radio, etc. Pretty much just go sit in silence and we'll see you tomorrow. If we cried, he'd come upstairs and "give us something to cry about" - usually a beating with his belt.

> >

> > I'm not looking for sympathy, nor do I want to appear as one of the "it's all my father's fault" people. I'm just laying out the facts as I believe they are related to my 4S.

> >

> > What I "learned" was that making unnecessary sounds would result in punishment; and even if I wasn't the one being punished, I still had to sit through the remainder of the meal - which was punishment in itself. What started out as a nice dinner could end with tension, fear, and anxiety. Over time, everyone at the table would shoot an icy stare at the offender. We all were taking on my father's aversion to everyday sounds. Maybe he had 4S?

> >

> > Sound irritation moved from the dinner table to the house in general (playing too loudly, creaking the stairs, popping bubble gum, etc), to school, to work, to my own home. The list of sounds that I just can't ignore now includes everything mentioned above plus chewing hard candy, fussing with candy wrappers and plastic bags, chewing ice, playing with coins in a pocket, newscasters with speech impediments, mispronounced words like "shtreet" (instead of "street"), incessant clicking of a pen, typing, lip smacking at the beginning of every sentence, word repetition (i.e. same word being used multiple times in a sentence), feet thudding across the floor above me, chair legs screeching when dragged across a floor, etc, etc.

> >

> > These sounds don't make me fearful or fill me with rage, they irritate and aggravate.

> >

> > My reaction to these sounds can be staring, mimicking the sound, talking loudly enough to drown out the sound, turning up the volume of the tv/radio, leaving the room, etc. I used to say something about it, but people weren't very sympathetic. They'd make more noise just to bug me. Being forced to deal with irritating sounds without vocalizing displeasure caused me to be more passive in my responses.

> >

> > A worst-case scenario for me is when I'm in a meeting or seminar and there are bowls of hard candy at every table. There's always someone that will eat a whole bowl of them - and refill at every break. It may take a minute or so of fussing with the wrapper to get the candy open. Then they crunch the candy rather than letting it dissolve slowly. While doing this, they mindlessly fold the wrapper into the tiniest square possible. Then they begin unwrapping another piece as the final bits of the previous piece are being chomped. This is worst-case for me because I can't focus on the topic being discussed and I can't tune out what I'm hearing. I just sit there stewing - waiting for someone to tell them to SHUT UP; wondering how everyone else can tune it out while I can't; wondering how someone can deliberately be so rude and inconsiderate of others; and looking around the room trying to make eye contact with others that are annoyed but

finding no one. Once that person does take a break, someone else picks up where he left off. Eventually, I have to join in as it's the only way to make enough noise to drown out what I'm hearing. The session ends, I've learned nothing, and I've eaten a bunch of candy. During breaks, I've asked other people "Could that guy make more of a racket with the candy?" and the response is always "What guy? I didn't hear anything." Basically they're saying that I have issues.

> >

> > Recently, my wife told me that she's tired of walking on eggshells around me. I was surprised because I just passively and subtly leave the room, turn up the radio, talk, etc when she makes a sound that annoys me. I realize that it's my problem and deal with it the best I can - without directing anger toward her. But she's no dummy. She sees the icy stare out of the corner of her eye; she realizes I'm leaving the room because I don't want to hear her crunch cereal; she knows that using her emory board on her nails will cause me to take the dog out; etc. When she drops a piece of silverware, she now experiences all the feelings I experienced 40 years ago. She becomes tense, waiting for my reaction, knowing I'm completely irritated. I don't want her feeling that way around me. I have to change.

> >

> > As far as I'm concerned, my 4S is a behavioral issue caused by events that occurred an early age and allowed to grow unchecked for decades. Now I need to fix it. I don't think medicines or vitamins are the answer. For me, I think it's "unlearning" the behavior. My guess is that either hypnosis or completely immersing myself in sounds I hate will be the cure for me. Maybe I should make a recording of the sounds and play them loudly during my commute. If I can tolerate them for an hour straight, I should be able to tolerate the occasional instance.

> >

> > Out of curiosity, have any of you had an early experience similar to mine where punishment may have caused the symptoms of 4S? Or did most people have a relatively normal childhood and feel that 4S is more genetic than environmental? Has anyone tried hypnotism or "sound immersion"?

> >

> > Thanks for listening.

> > Mark

> >

> > PS - I'm not a fan of receiving long emails so I apologize for sending one.

> >

> >

> >

> >

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There were other noises besides the dinner table noises that started roughly at the same time for me, brother tipping stool (not at dinner table), brother chewing fingernails (not at dinner table), best friend clearing throat (not at dinner table), dog howling next store (nadt), kids sniffling at school, father inhaling pipe smoke, kids shrieking on playground, kids bouncing balls etc etc. I have a rather extensive list of irritating sounds from my childhood, not quite to the degree that I have now but spread out among different people and places. Family was the worst of course, but I was around them the most, so it makes sense that that is why. And dinner was the one time of day we were altogether on a daily basis, so of course it would stand out in memory.To: Soundsensitivity Sent: Mon, January 31, 2011 8:47:34 PMSubject: Re: My experience with 4S

Mark's story TODAY sounds a lot like mine. The only difference is onset. My problems did not start as a child. Those who say that everyone with 4S must have had a bad experience at the dinner table have to be crazy when so many have said that they did not. If it's all or nothing, and so many say they did not have that experience, then it throws that theory right out of the water.

I'm not saying that some cases could not have been brought on by that, but certainly not all. My 4s (or whatever it is called) did not start until I was 23 years old.

>

> > Hi Everyone,

> >

> > I'm new to the group and joined specifically to save my marriage. I'm pretty sure I know why I have this condition. And now it seems that my wife is beginning to "catch" it.

> >

> > Background: As a child (I'm 45), my siblings and I would be punished for making "avoidable" noises at the dinner table (e.g., scraping teeth with a fork, humming, chewing with our mouths open, snorting, scraping knives sideways on a plate, etc.) The first infraction during a meal would result in an icy stare from my father and tension in the room for the rest of the meal. A second infraction would result in punishment. The punishment was pretty standard - go to bed for the rest of the day - without finishing the meal. No TV, books, newspapers, magazines, radio, etc. Pretty much just go sit in silence and we'll see you tomorrow. If we cried, he'd come upstairs and "give us something to cry about" - usually a beating with his belt.

> >

> > I'm not looking for sympathy, nor do I want to appear as one of the "it's all my father's fault" people. I'm just laying out the facts as I believe they are related to my 4S.

> >

> > What I "learned" was that making unnecessary sounds would result in punishment; and even if I wasn't the one being punished, I still had to sit through the remainder of the meal - which was punishment in itself. What started out as a nice dinner could end with tension, fear, and anxiety. Over time, everyone at the table would shoot an icy stare at the offender. We all were taking on my father's aversion to everyday sounds. Maybe he had 4S?

> >

> > Sound irritation moved from the dinner table to the house in general (playing too loudly, creaking the stairs, popping bubble gum, etc), to school, to work, to my own home. The list of sounds that I just can't ignore now includes everything mentioned above plus chewing hard candy, fussing with candy wrappers and plastic bags, chewing ice, playing with coins in a pocket, newscasters with speech impediments, mispronounced words like "shtreet" (instead of "street"), incessant clicking of a pen, typing, lip smacking at the beginning of every sentence, word repetition (i.e. same word being used multiple times in a sentence), feet thudding across the floor above me, chair legs screeching when dragged across a floor, etc, etc.

> >

> > These sounds don't make me fearful or fill me with rage, they irritate and aggravate.

> >

> > My reaction to these sounds can be staring, mimicking the sound, talking loudly enough to drown out the sound, turning up the volume of the tv/radio, leaving the room, etc. I used to say something about it, but people weren't very sympathetic. They'd make more noise just to bug me. Being forced to deal with irritating sounds without vocalizing displeasure caused me to be more passive in my responses.

> >

> > A worst-case scenario for me is when I'm in a meeting or seminar and there are bowls of hard candy at every table. There's always someone that will eat a whole bowl of them - and refill at every break. It may take a minute or so of fussing with the wrapper to get the candy open. Then they crunch the candy rather than letting it dissolve slowly. While doing this, they mindlessly fold the wrapper into the tiniest square possible. Then they begin unwrapping another piece as the final bits of the previous piece are being chomped. This is worst-case for me because I can't focus on the topic being discussed and I can't tune out what I'm hearing. I just sit there stewing - waiting for someone to tell them to SHUT UP; wondering how everyone else can tune it out while I can't; wondering how someone can deliberately be so rude and inconsiderate of others; and looking around the room trying to make eye contact with others that are annoyed but

finding no one. Once that person does take a break, someone else picks up where he left off. Eventually, I have to join in as it's the only way to make enough noise to drown out what I'm hearing. The session ends, I've learned nothing, and I've eaten a bunch of candy. During breaks, I've asked other people "Could that guy make more of a racket with the candy?" and the response is always "What guy? I didn't hear anything." Basically they're saying that I have issues.

> >

> > Recently, my wife told me that she's tired of walking on eggshells around me. I was surprised because I just passively and subtly leave the room, turn up the radio, talk, etc when she makes a sound that annoys me. I realize that it's my problem and deal with it the best I can - without directing anger toward her. But she's no dummy. She sees the icy stare out of the corner of her eye; she realizes I'm leaving the room because I don't want to hear her crunch cereal; she knows that using her emory board on her nails will cause me to take the dog out; etc. When she drops a piece of silverware, she now experiences all the feelings I experienced 40 years ago. She becomes tense, waiting for my reaction, knowing I'm completely irritated. I don't want her feeling that way around me. I have to change.

> >

> > As far as I'm concerned, my 4S is a behavioral issue caused by events that occurred an early age and allowed to grow unchecked for decades. Now I need to fix it. I don't think medicines or vitamins are the answer. For me, I think it's "unlearning" the behavior. My guess is that either hypnosis or completely immersing myself in sounds I hate will be the cure for me. Maybe I should make a recording of the sounds and play them loudly during my commute. If I can tolerate them for an hour straight, I should be able to tolerate the occasional instance.

> >

> > Out of curiosity, have any of you had an early experience similar to mine where punishment may have caused the symptoms of 4S? Or did most people have a relatively normal childhood and feel that 4S is more genetic than environmental? Has anyone tried hypnotism or "sound immersion"?

> >

> > Thanks for listening.

> > Mark

> >

> > PS - I'm not a fan of receiving long emails so I apologize for sending one.

> >

> >

> >

> >

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There were other noises besides the dinner table noises that started roughly at the same time for me, brother tipping stool (not at dinner table), brother chewing fingernails (not at dinner table), best friend clearing throat (not at dinner table), dog howling next store (nadt), kids sniffling at school, father inhaling pipe smoke, kids shrieking on playground, kids bouncing balls etc etc. I have a rather extensive list of irritating sounds from my childhood, not quite to the degree that I have now but spread out among different people and places. Family was the worst of course, but I was around them the most, so it makes sense that that is why. And dinner was the one time of day we were altogether on a daily basis, so of course it would stand out in memory.To: Soundsensitivity Sent: Mon, January 31, 2011 8:47:34 PMSubject: Re: My experience with 4S

Mark's story TODAY sounds a lot like mine. The only difference is onset. My problems did not start as a child. Those who say that everyone with 4S must have had a bad experience at the dinner table have to be crazy when so many have said that they did not. If it's all or nothing, and so many say they did not have that experience, then it throws that theory right out of the water.

I'm not saying that some cases could not have been brought on by that, but certainly not all. My 4s (or whatever it is called) did not start until I was 23 years old.

>

> > Hi Everyone,

> >

> > I'm new to the group and joined specifically to save my marriage. I'm pretty sure I know why I have this condition. And now it seems that my wife is beginning to "catch" it.

> >

> > Background: As a child (I'm 45), my siblings and I would be punished for making "avoidable" noises at the dinner table (e.g., scraping teeth with a fork, humming, chewing with our mouths open, snorting, scraping knives sideways on a plate, etc.) The first infraction during a meal would result in an icy stare from my father and tension in the room for the rest of the meal. A second infraction would result in punishment. The punishment was pretty standard - go to bed for the rest of the day - without finishing the meal. No TV, books, newspapers, magazines, radio, etc. Pretty much just go sit in silence and we'll see you tomorrow. If we cried, he'd come upstairs and "give us something to cry about" - usually a beating with his belt.

> >

> > I'm not looking for sympathy, nor do I want to appear as one of the "it's all my father's fault" people. I'm just laying out the facts as I believe they are related to my 4S.

> >

> > What I "learned" was that making unnecessary sounds would result in punishment; and even if I wasn't the one being punished, I still had to sit through the remainder of the meal - which was punishment in itself. What started out as a nice dinner could end with tension, fear, and anxiety. Over time, everyone at the table would shoot an icy stare at the offender. We all were taking on my father's aversion to everyday sounds. Maybe he had 4S?

> >

> > Sound irritation moved from the dinner table to the house in general (playing too loudly, creaking the stairs, popping bubble gum, etc), to school, to work, to my own home. The list of sounds that I just can't ignore now includes everything mentioned above plus chewing hard candy, fussing with candy wrappers and plastic bags, chewing ice, playing with coins in a pocket, newscasters with speech impediments, mispronounced words like "shtreet" (instead of "street"), incessant clicking of a pen, typing, lip smacking at the beginning of every sentence, word repetition (i.e. same word being used multiple times in a sentence), feet thudding across the floor above me, chair legs screeching when dragged across a floor, etc, etc.

> >

> > These sounds don't make me fearful or fill me with rage, they irritate and aggravate.

> >

> > My reaction to these sounds can be staring, mimicking the sound, talking loudly enough to drown out the sound, turning up the volume of the tv/radio, leaving the room, etc. I used to say something about it, but people weren't very sympathetic. They'd make more noise just to bug me. Being forced to deal with irritating sounds without vocalizing displeasure caused me to be more passive in my responses.

> >

> > A worst-case scenario for me is when I'm in a meeting or seminar and there are bowls of hard candy at every table. There's always someone that will eat a whole bowl of them - and refill at every break. It may take a minute or so of fussing with the wrapper to get the candy open. Then they crunch the candy rather than letting it dissolve slowly. While doing this, they mindlessly fold the wrapper into the tiniest square possible. Then they begin unwrapping another piece as the final bits of the previous piece are being chomped. This is worst-case for me because I can't focus on the topic being discussed and I can't tune out what I'm hearing. I just sit there stewing - waiting for someone to tell them to SHUT UP; wondering how everyone else can tune it out while I can't; wondering how someone can deliberately be so rude and inconsiderate of others; and looking around the room trying to make eye contact with others that are annoyed but

finding no one. Once that person does take a break, someone else picks up where he left off. Eventually, I have to join in as it's the only way to make enough noise to drown out what I'm hearing. The session ends, I've learned nothing, and I've eaten a bunch of candy. During breaks, I've asked other people "Could that guy make more of a racket with the candy?" and the response is always "What guy? I didn't hear anything." Basically they're saying that I have issues.

> >

> > Recently, my wife told me that she's tired of walking on eggshells around me. I was surprised because I just passively and subtly leave the room, turn up the radio, talk, etc when she makes a sound that annoys me. I realize that it's my problem and deal with it the best I can - without directing anger toward her. But she's no dummy. She sees the icy stare out of the corner of her eye; she realizes I'm leaving the room because I don't want to hear her crunch cereal; she knows that using her emory board on her nails will cause me to take the dog out; etc. When she drops a piece of silverware, she now experiences all the feelings I experienced 40 years ago. She becomes tense, waiting for my reaction, knowing I'm completely irritated. I don't want her feeling that way around me. I have to change.

> >

> > As far as I'm concerned, my 4S is a behavioral issue caused by events that occurred an early age and allowed to grow unchecked for decades. Now I need to fix it. I don't think medicines or vitamins are the answer. For me, I think it's "unlearning" the behavior. My guess is that either hypnosis or completely immersing myself in sounds I hate will be the cure for me. Maybe I should make a recording of the sounds and play them loudly during my commute. If I can tolerate them for an hour straight, I should be able to tolerate the occasional instance.

> >

> > Out of curiosity, have any of you had an early experience similar to mine where punishment may have caused the symptoms of 4S? Or did most people have a relatively normal childhood and feel that 4S is more genetic than environmental? Has anyone tried hypnotism or "sound immersion"?

> >

> > Thanks for listening.

> > Mark

> >

> > PS - I'm not a fan of receiving long emails so I apologize for sending one.

> >

> >

> >

> >

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wow ! You avoided the whole preteen - teen 4S. I know 4s sucks no matter the age but I have to say those were the hardest cuz so I often I could not take control like I can more often (albeit nit always) as an adult. That coupled with all the angst of new hormones I think just makes that time with 4S horrible. Somehow its fascinating to me that it was delayed so long for you. Can't wait for this to be studied and answers to be uncovered as it's very interesting to me. HeidiSent from my iPhone

Mark's story TODAY sounds a lot like mine. The only difference is onset. My problems did not start as a child. Those who say that everyone with 4S must have had a bad experience at the dinner table have to be crazy when so many have said that they did not. If it's all or nothing, and so many say they did not have that experience, then it throws that theory right out of the water.

I'm not saying that some cases could not have been brought on by that, but certainly not all. My 4s (or whatever it is called) did not start until I was 23 years old.

>

> > Hi Everyone,

> >

> > I'm new to the group and joined specifically to save my marriage. I'm pretty sure I know why I have this condition. And now it seems that my wife is beginning to "catch" it.

> >

> > Background: As a child (I'm 45), my siblings and I would be punished for making "avoidable" noises at the dinner table (e.g., scraping teeth with a fork, humming, chewing with our mouths open, snorting, scraping knives sideways on a plate, etc.) The first infraction during a meal would result in an icy stare from my father and tension in the room for the rest of the meal. A second infraction would result in punishment. The punishment was pretty standard - go to bed for the rest of the day - without finishing the meal. No TV, books, newspapers, magazines, radio, etc. Pretty much just go sit in silence and we'll see you tomorrow. If we cried, he'd come upstairs and "give us something to cry about" - usually a beating with his belt.

> >

> > I'm not looking for sympathy, nor do I want to appear as one of the "it's all my father's fault" people. I'm just laying out the facts as I believe they are related to my 4S.

> >

> > What I "learned" was that making unnecessary sounds would result in punishment; and even if I wasn't the one being punished, I still had to sit through the remainder of the meal - which was punishment in itself. What started out as a nice dinner could end with tension, fear, and anxiety. Over time, everyone at the table would shoot an icy stare at the offender. We all were taking on my father's aversion to everyday sounds. Maybe he had 4S?

> >

> > Sound irritation moved from the dinner table to the house in general (playing too loudly, creaking the stairs, popping bubble gum, etc), to school, to work, to my own home. The list of sounds that I just can't ignore now includes everything mentioned above plus chewing hard candy, fussing with candy wrappers and plastic bags, chewing ice, playing with coins in a pocket, newscasters with speech impediments, mispronounced words like "shtreet" (instead of "street"), incessant clicking of a pen, typing, lip smacking at the beginning of every sentence, word repetition (i.e. same word being used multiple times in a sentence), feet thudding across the floor above me, chair legs screeching when dragged across a floor, etc, etc.

> >

> > These sounds don't make me fearful or fill me with rage, they irritate and aggravate.

> >

> > My reaction to these sounds can be staring, mimicking the sound, talking loudly enough to drown out the sound, turning up the volume of the tv/radio, leaving the room, etc. I used to say something about it, but people weren't very sympathetic. They'd make more noise just to bug me. Being forced to deal with irritating sounds without vocalizing displeasure caused me to be more passive in my responses.

> >

> > A worst-case scenario for me is when I'm in a meeting or seminar and there are bowls of hard candy at every table. There's always someone that will eat a whole bowl of them - and refill at every break. It may take a minute or so of fussing with the wrapper to get the candy open. Then they crunch the candy rather than letting it dissolve slowly. While doing this, they mindlessly fold the wrapper into the tiniest square possible. Then they begin unwrapping another piece as the final bits of the previous piece are being chomped. This is worst-case for me because I can't focus on the topic being discussed and I can't tune out what I'm hearing. I just sit there stewing - waiting for someone to tell them to SHUT UP; wondering how everyone else can tune it out while I can't; wondering how someone can deliberately be so rude and inconsiderate of others; and looking around the room trying to make eye contact with others that are annoyed but finding no one. Once that person does take a break, someone else picks up where he left off. Eventually, I have to join in as it's the only way to make enough noise to drown out what I'm hearing. The session ends, I've learned nothing, and I've eaten a bunch of candy. During breaks, I've asked other people "Could that guy make more of a racket with the candy?" and the response is always "What guy? I didn't hear anything." Basically they're saying that I have issues.

> >

> > Recently, my wife told me that she's tired of walking on eggshells around me. I was surprised because I just passively and subtly leave the room, turn up the radio, talk, etc when she makes a sound that annoys me. I realize that it's my problem and deal with it the best I can - without directing anger toward her. But she's no dummy. She sees the icy stare out of the corner of her eye; she realizes I'm leaving the room because I don't want to hear her crunch cereal; she knows that using her emory board on her nails will cause me to take the dog out; etc. When she drops a piece of silverware, she now experiences all the feelings I experienced 40 years ago. She becomes tense, waiting for my reaction, knowing I'm completely irritated. I don't want her feeling that way around me. I have to change.

> >

> > As far as I'm concerned, my 4S is a behavioral issue caused by events that occurred an early age and allowed to grow unchecked for decades. Now I need to fix it. I don't think medicines or vitamins are the answer. For me, I think it's "unlearning" the behavior. My guess is that either hypnosis or completely immersing myself in sounds I hate will be the cure for me. Maybe I should make a recording of the sounds and play them loudly during my commute. If I can tolerate them for an hour straight, I should be able to tolerate the occasional instance.

> >

> > Out of curiosity, have any of you had an early experience similar to mine where punishment may have caused the symptoms of 4S? Or did most people have a relatively normal childhood and feel that 4S is more genetic than environmental? Has anyone tried hypnotism or "sound immersion"?

> >

> > Thanks for listening.

> > Mark

> >

> > PS - I'm not a fan of receiving long emails so I apologize for sending one.

> >

> >

> >

> >

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wow ! You avoided the whole preteen - teen 4S. I know 4s sucks no matter the age but I have to say those were the hardest cuz so I often I could not take control like I can more often (albeit nit always) as an adult. That coupled with all the angst of new hormones I think just makes that time with 4S horrible. Somehow its fascinating to me that it was delayed so long for you. Can't wait for this to be studied and answers to be uncovered as it's very interesting to me. HeidiSent from my iPhone

Mark's story TODAY sounds a lot like mine. The only difference is onset. My problems did not start as a child. Those who say that everyone with 4S must have had a bad experience at the dinner table have to be crazy when so many have said that they did not. If it's all or nothing, and so many say they did not have that experience, then it throws that theory right out of the water.

I'm not saying that some cases could not have been brought on by that, but certainly not all. My 4s (or whatever it is called) did not start until I was 23 years old.

>

> > Hi Everyone,

> >

> > I'm new to the group and joined specifically to save my marriage. I'm pretty sure I know why I have this condition. And now it seems that my wife is beginning to "catch" it.

> >

> > Background: As a child (I'm 45), my siblings and I would be punished for making "avoidable" noises at the dinner table (e.g., scraping teeth with a fork, humming, chewing with our mouths open, snorting, scraping knives sideways on a plate, etc.) The first infraction during a meal would result in an icy stare from my father and tension in the room for the rest of the meal. A second infraction would result in punishment. The punishment was pretty standard - go to bed for the rest of the day - without finishing the meal. No TV, books, newspapers, magazines, radio, etc. Pretty much just go sit in silence and we'll see you tomorrow. If we cried, he'd come upstairs and "give us something to cry about" - usually a beating with his belt.

> >

> > I'm not looking for sympathy, nor do I want to appear as one of the "it's all my father's fault" people. I'm just laying out the facts as I believe they are related to my 4S.

> >

> > What I "learned" was that making unnecessary sounds would result in punishment; and even if I wasn't the one being punished, I still had to sit through the remainder of the meal - which was punishment in itself. What started out as a nice dinner could end with tension, fear, and anxiety. Over time, everyone at the table would shoot an icy stare at the offender. We all were taking on my father's aversion to everyday sounds. Maybe he had 4S?

> >

> > Sound irritation moved from the dinner table to the house in general (playing too loudly, creaking the stairs, popping bubble gum, etc), to school, to work, to my own home. The list of sounds that I just can't ignore now includes everything mentioned above plus chewing hard candy, fussing with candy wrappers and plastic bags, chewing ice, playing with coins in a pocket, newscasters with speech impediments, mispronounced words like "shtreet" (instead of "street"), incessant clicking of a pen, typing, lip smacking at the beginning of every sentence, word repetition (i.e. same word being used multiple times in a sentence), feet thudding across the floor above me, chair legs screeching when dragged across a floor, etc, etc.

> >

> > These sounds don't make me fearful or fill me with rage, they irritate and aggravate.

> >

> > My reaction to these sounds can be staring, mimicking the sound, talking loudly enough to drown out the sound, turning up the volume of the tv/radio, leaving the room, etc. I used to say something about it, but people weren't very sympathetic. They'd make more noise just to bug me. Being forced to deal with irritating sounds without vocalizing displeasure caused me to be more passive in my responses.

> >

> > A worst-case scenario for me is when I'm in a meeting or seminar and there are bowls of hard candy at every table. There's always someone that will eat a whole bowl of them - and refill at every break. It may take a minute or so of fussing with the wrapper to get the candy open. Then they crunch the candy rather than letting it dissolve slowly. While doing this, they mindlessly fold the wrapper into the tiniest square possible. Then they begin unwrapping another piece as the final bits of the previous piece are being chomped. This is worst-case for me because I can't focus on the topic being discussed and I can't tune out what I'm hearing. I just sit there stewing - waiting for someone to tell them to SHUT UP; wondering how everyone else can tune it out while I can't; wondering how someone can deliberately be so rude and inconsiderate of others; and looking around the room trying to make eye contact with others that are annoyed but finding no one. Once that person does take a break, someone else picks up where he left off. Eventually, I have to join in as it's the only way to make enough noise to drown out what I'm hearing. The session ends, I've learned nothing, and I've eaten a bunch of candy. During breaks, I've asked other people "Could that guy make more of a racket with the candy?" and the response is always "What guy? I didn't hear anything." Basically they're saying that I have issues.

> >

> > Recently, my wife told me that she's tired of walking on eggshells around me. I was surprised because I just passively and subtly leave the room, turn up the radio, talk, etc when she makes a sound that annoys me. I realize that it's my problem and deal with it the best I can - without directing anger toward her. But she's no dummy. She sees the icy stare out of the corner of her eye; she realizes I'm leaving the room because I don't want to hear her crunch cereal; she knows that using her emory board on her nails will cause me to take the dog out; etc. When she drops a piece of silverware, she now experiences all the feelings I experienced 40 years ago. She becomes tense, waiting for my reaction, knowing I'm completely irritated. I don't want her feeling that way around me. I have to change.

> >

> > As far as I'm concerned, my 4S is a behavioral issue caused by events that occurred an early age and allowed to grow unchecked for decades. Now I need to fix it. I don't think medicines or vitamins are the answer. For me, I think it's "unlearning" the behavior. My guess is that either hypnosis or completely immersing myself in sounds I hate will be the cure for me. Maybe I should make a recording of the sounds and play them loudly during my commute. If I can tolerate them for an hour straight, I should be able to tolerate the occasional instance.

> >

> > Out of curiosity, have any of you had an early experience similar to mine where punishment may have caused the symptoms of 4S? Or did most people have a relatively normal childhood and feel that 4S is more genetic than environmental? Has anyone tried hypnotism or "sound immersion"?

> >

> > Thanks for listening.

> > Mark

> >

> > PS - I'm not a fan of receiving long emails so I apologize for sending one.

> >

> >

> >

> >

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wow ! You avoided the whole preteen - teen 4S. I know 4s sucks no matter the age but I have to say those were the hardest cuz so I often I could not take control like I can more often (albeit nit always) as an adult. That coupled with all the angst of new hormones I think just makes that time with 4S horrible. Somehow its fascinating to me that it was delayed so long for you. Can't wait for this to be studied and answers to be uncovered as it's very interesting to me. HeidiSent from my iPhone

Mark's story TODAY sounds a lot like mine. The only difference is onset. My problems did not start as a child. Those who say that everyone with 4S must have had a bad experience at the dinner table have to be crazy when so many have said that they did not. If it's all or nothing, and so many say they did not have that experience, then it throws that theory right out of the water.

I'm not saying that some cases could not have been brought on by that, but certainly not all. My 4s (or whatever it is called) did not start until I was 23 years old.

>

> > Hi Everyone,

> >

> > I'm new to the group and joined specifically to save my marriage. I'm pretty sure I know why I have this condition. And now it seems that my wife is beginning to "catch" it.

> >

> > Background: As a child (I'm 45), my siblings and I would be punished for making "avoidable" noises at the dinner table (e.g., scraping teeth with a fork, humming, chewing with our mouths open, snorting, scraping knives sideways on a plate, etc.) The first infraction during a meal would result in an icy stare from my father and tension in the room for the rest of the meal. A second infraction would result in punishment. The punishment was pretty standard - go to bed for the rest of the day - without finishing the meal. No TV, books, newspapers, magazines, radio, etc. Pretty much just go sit in silence and we'll see you tomorrow. If we cried, he'd come upstairs and "give us something to cry about" - usually a beating with his belt.

> >

> > I'm not looking for sympathy, nor do I want to appear as one of the "it's all my father's fault" people. I'm just laying out the facts as I believe they are related to my 4S.

> >

> > What I "learned" was that making unnecessary sounds would result in punishment; and even if I wasn't the one being punished, I still had to sit through the remainder of the meal - which was punishment in itself. What started out as a nice dinner could end with tension, fear, and anxiety. Over time, everyone at the table would shoot an icy stare at the offender. We all were taking on my father's aversion to everyday sounds. Maybe he had 4S?

> >

> > Sound irritation moved from the dinner table to the house in general (playing too loudly, creaking the stairs, popping bubble gum, etc), to school, to work, to my own home. The list of sounds that I just can't ignore now includes everything mentioned above plus chewing hard candy, fussing with candy wrappers and plastic bags, chewing ice, playing with coins in a pocket, newscasters with speech impediments, mispronounced words like "shtreet" (instead of "street"), incessant clicking of a pen, typing, lip smacking at the beginning of every sentence, word repetition (i.e. same word being used multiple times in a sentence), feet thudding across the floor above me, chair legs screeching when dragged across a floor, etc, etc.

> >

> > These sounds don't make me fearful or fill me with rage, they irritate and aggravate.

> >

> > My reaction to these sounds can be staring, mimicking the sound, talking loudly enough to drown out the sound, turning up the volume of the tv/radio, leaving the room, etc. I used to say something about it, but people weren't very sympathetic. They'd make more noise just to bug me. Being forced to deal with irritating sounds without vocalizing displeasure caused me to be more passive in my responses.

> >

> > A worst-case scenario for me is when I'm in a meeting or seminar and there are bowls of hard candy at every table. There's always someone that will eat a whole bowl of them - and refill at every break. It may take a minute or so of fussing with the wrapper to get the candy open. Then they crunch the candy rather than letting it dissolve slowly. While doing this, they mindlessly fold the wrapper into the tiniest square possible. Then they begin unwrapping another piece as the final bits of the previous piece are being chomped. This is worst-case for me because I can't focus on the topic being discussed and I can't tune out what I'm hearing. I just sit there stewing - waiting for someone to tell them to SHUT UP; wondering how everyone else can tune it out while I can't; wondering how someone can deliberately be so rude and inconsiderate of others; and looking around the room trying to make eye contact with others that are annoyed but finding no one. Once that person does take a break, someone else picks up where he left off. Eventually, I have to join in as it's the only way to make enough noise to drown out what I'm hearing. The session ends, I've learned nothing, and I've eaten a bunch of candy. During breaks, I've asked other people "Could that guy make more of a racket with the candy?" and the response is always "What guy? I didn't hear anything." Basically they're saying that I have issues.

> >

> > Recently, my wife told me that she's tired of walking on eggshells around me. I was surprised because I just passively and subtly leave the room, turn up the radio, talk, etc when she makes a sound that annoys me. I realize that it's my problem and deal with it the best I can - without directing anger toward her. But she's no dummy. She sees the icy stare out of the corner of her eye; she realizes I'm leaving the room because I don't want to hear her crunch cereal; she knows that using her emory board on her nails will cause me to take the dog out; etc. When she drops a piece of silverware, she now experiences all the feelings I experienced 40 years ago. She becomes tense, waiting for my reaction, knowing I'm completely irritated. I don't want her feeling that way around me. I have to change.

> >

> > As far as I'm concerned, my 4S is a behavioral issue caused by events that occurred an early age and allowed to grow unchecked for decades. Now I need to fix it. I don't think medicines or vitamins are the answer. For me, I think it's "unlearning" the behavior. My guess is that either hypnosis or completely immersing myself in sounds I hate will be the cure for me. Maybe I should make a recording of the sounds and play them loudly during my commute. If I can tolerate them for an hour straight, I should be able to tolerate the occasional instance.

> >

> > Out of curiosity, have any of you had an early experience similar to mine where punishment may have caused the symptoms of 4S? Or did most people have a relatively normal childhood and feel that 4S is more genetic than environmental? Has anyone tried hypnotism or "sound immersion"?

> >

> > Thanks for listening.

> > Mark

> >

> > PS - I'm not a fan of receiving long emails so I apologize for sending one.

> >

> >

> >

> >

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah. I did avoid it, but believe me, I had my share of problems. I would have

taken 4S those years over the medical problems I was dealing with! Now I get it

all!

Mine started last year right around the time I was diagnosed with two other

conditions... but they had started months earlier--so it wasn't that it came

right when they did...

> > >

> > > > Hi Everyone,

> > > >

> > > > I'm new to the group and joined specifically to save my marriage. I'm

pretty sure I know why I have this condition. And now it seems that my wife is

beginning to " catch " it.

> > > >

> > > > Background: As a child (I'm 45), my siblings and I would be punished for

making " avoidable " noises at the dinner table (e.g., scraping teeth with a fork,

humming, chewing with our mouths open, snorting, scraping knives sideways on a

plate, etc.) The first infraction during a meal would result in an icy stare

from my father and tension in the room for the rest of the meal. A second

infraction would result in punishment. The punishment was pretty standard - go

to bed for the rest of the day - without finishing the meal. No TV, books,

newspapers, magazines, radio, etc. Pretty much just go sit in silence and we'll

see you tomorrow. If we cried, he'd come upstairs and " give us something to cry

about " - usually a beating with his belt.

> > > >

> > > > I'm not looking for sympathy, nor do I want to appear as one of the

" it's all my father's fault " people. I'm just laying out the facts as I believe

they are related to my 4S.

> > > >

> > > > What I " learned " was that making unnecessary sounds would result in

punishment; and even if I wasn't the one being punished, I still had to sit

through the remainder of the meal - which was punishment in itself. What started

out as a nice dinner could end with tension, fear, and anxiety. Over time,

everyone at the table would shoot an icy stare at the offender. We all were

taking on my father's aversion to everyday sounds. Maybe he had 4S?

> > > >

> > > > Sound irritation moved from the dinner table to the house in general

(playing too loudly, creaking the stairs, popping bubble gum, etc), to school,

to work, to my own home. The list of sounds that I just can't ignore now

includes everything mentioned above plus chewing hard candy, fussing with candy

wrappers and plastic bags, chewing ice, playing with coins in a pocket,

newscasters with speech impediments, mispronounced words like " shtreet " (instead

of " street " ), incessant clicking of a pen, typing, lip smacking at the beginning

of every sentence, word repetition (i.e. same word being used multiple times in

a sentence), feet thudding across the floor above me, chair legs screeching when

dragged across a floor, etc, etc.

> > > >

> > > > These sounds don't make me fearful or fill me with rage, they irritate

and aggravate.

> > > >

> > > > My reaction to these sounds can be staring, mimicking the sound, talking

loudly enough to drown out the sound, turning up the volume of the tv/radio,

leaving the room, etc. I used to say something about it, but people weren't very

sympathetic. They'd make more noise just to bug me. Being forced to deal with

irritating sounds without vocalizing displeasure caused me to be more passive in

my responses.

> > > >

> > > > A worst-case scenario for me is when I'm in a meeting or seminar and

there are bowls of hard candy at every table. There's always someone that will

eat a whole bowl of them - and refill at every break. It may take a minute or so

of fussing with the wrapper to get the candy open. Then they crunch the candy

rather than letting it dissolve slowly. While doing this, they mindlessly fold

the wrapper into the tiniest square possible. Then they begin unwrapping another

piece as the final bits of the previous piece are being chomped. This is

worst-case for me because I can't focus on the topic being discussed and I can't

tune out what I'm hearing. I just sit there stewing - waiting for someone to

tell them to SHUT UP; wondering how everyone else can tune it out while I can't;

wondering how someone can deliberately be so rude and inconsiderate of others;

and looking around the room trying to make eye contact with others that are

annoyed but finding no one. Once that person does take a break, someone else

picks up where he left off. Eventually, I have to join in as it's the only way

to make enough noise to drown out what I'm hearing. The session ends, I've

learned nothing, and I've eaten a bunch of candy. During breaks, I've asked

other people " Could that guy make more of a racket with the candy? " and the

response is always " What guy? I didn't hear anything. " Basically they're saying

that I have issues.

> > > >

> > > > Recently, my wife told me that she's tired of walking on eggshells

around me. I was surprised because I just passively and subtly leave the room,

turn up the radio, talk, etc when she makes a sound that annoys me. I realize

that it's my problem and deal with it the best I can - without directing anger

toward her. But she's no dummy. She sees the icy stare out of the corner of her

eye; she realizes I'm leaving the room because I don't want to hear her crunch

cereal; she knows that using her emory board on her nails will cause me to take

the dog out; etc. When she drops a piece of silverware, she now experiences all

the feelings I experienced 40 years ago. She becomes tense, waiting for my

reaction, knowing I'm completely irritated. I don't want her feeling that way

around me. I have to change.

> > > >

> > > > As far as I'm concerned, my 4S is a behavioral issue caused by events

that occurred an early age and allowed to grow unchecked for decades. Now I need

to fix it. I don't think medicines or vitamins are the answer. For me, I think

it's " unlearning " the behavior. My guess is that either hypnosis or completely

immersing myself in sounds I hate will be the cure for me. Maybe I should make a

recording of the sounds and play them loudly during my commute. If I can

tolerate them for an hour straight, I should be able to tolerate the occasional

instance.

> > > >

> > > > Out of curiosity, have any of you had an early experience similar to

mine where punishment may have caused the symptoms of 4S? Or did most people

have a relatively normal childhood and feel that 4S is more genetic than

environmental? Has anyone tried hypnotism or " sound immersion " ?

> > > >

> > > > Thanks for listening.

> > > > Mark

> > > >

> > > > PS - I'm not a fan of receiving long emails so I apologize for sending

one.

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > >

> >

> >

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not sure if I replied to group or just to Tara but my first trigger was florescent lights. Heidi Sent from my iPhone

Tara, I realize you were addressing Heidi with this message so I hope you'll excuse my replying :) I was wondering if in your interviews you'd spoken with anyone whose first trigger was not related to eating? I first started having 4S symptoms triggered by my brother's cracking his knuckles- eating noises came later.

>

> Heidi,

> I originally formed an hypothesis that 4S was often provoked by different situations during family mealtimes. This was proved true by quite a few people I interviewed.

> Would you consider telling me a bit about family mealtimes when you were growing up?

> With thanks,

> Tara

> Let your email find you with BlackBerry from Vodafone

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thank you for your input! Hypothese are there to be tested, and All information important.So far you are the first one to directly say to me that it did not start from occurrences at family meals. In my interviews it was it was not necessarily abuse at the dining table. Several women had selective eating/ swallowing/ food dislike problems. Others reacted to repetitive insistence on manners, or "just another bite", or pressure to converse nicely, or even the way a sibling looked at them across the table.So my next question is whether you recall if your brother cracked his knuckles at the table?Let your email find you with BlackBerry from VodafoneSender: Soundsensitivity Date: Tue, 01 Feb 2011 17:02:08 -0000To: <Soundsensitivity >ReplyTo: Soundsensitivity Subject: Re: My experience with 4S Tara, I realize you were addressing Heidi with this message so I hope you'll excuse my replying :) I was wondering if in your interviews you'd spoken with anyone whose first trigger was not related to eating? I first started having 4S symptoms triggered by my brother's cracking his knuckles- eating noises came later.>> Heidi,> I originally formed an hypothesis that 4S was often provoked by different situations during family mealtimes. This was proved true by quite a few people I interviewed.> Would you consider telling me a bit about family mealtimes when you were growing up?> With thanks,> Tara> Let your email find you with BlackBerry from Vodafone

Link to comment
Share on other sites

my first trigger was not eating noises either..it was foot tapping and pencil tapping in school.

Subject: Re: Re: My experience with 4STo: Soundsensitivity Date: Tuesday, February 1, 2011, 12:24 PM

Thank you for your input! Hypothese are there to be tested, and All information important.So far you are the first one to directly say to me that it did not start from occurrences at family meals. In my interviews it was it was not necessarily abuse at the dining table. Several women had selective eating/ swallowing/ food dislike problems. Others reacted to repetitive insistence on manners, or "just another bite", or pressure to converse nicely, or even the way a sibling looked at them across the table.So my next question is whether you recall if your brother cracked his knuckles at the table?

Let your email find you with BlackBerry from Vodafone

Sender: Soundsensitivity

Date: Tue, 01 Feb 2011 17:02:08 -0000

To: <Soundsensitivity >

ReplyTo: Soundsensitivity

Subject: Re: My experience with 4S

Tara, I realize you were addressing Heidi with this message so I hope you'll excuse my replying :) I was wondering if in your interviews you'd spoken with anyone whose first trigger was not related to eating? I first started having 4S symptoms triggered by my brother's cracking his knuckles- eating noises came later.>> Heidi,> I originally formed an hypothesis that 4S was often provoked by different situations during family mealtimes. This was proved true by quite a few people I interviewed.> Would you consider telling me a bit about family mealtimes when you were growing up?> With thanks,> Tara> Let your email find you with BlackBerry from

Vodafone

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mine was finger pointing by my grandmother at maybe 5 years old. Sent from my BlackBerry® wireless deviceSender: Soundsensitivity Date: Tue, 1 Feb 2011 08:26:23 -0800 (PST)To: <Soundsensitivity >ReplyTo: Soundsensitivity Subject: Re: My experience with 4S I think that having the problem brought to ones attention is a big contributing factor with 4S, however I feel there must be a predisposition for it. Maybe even genetic. My mother was always talking about how much the sounds bothered her and correcting everyones eating noises ( and manners) , but I picked it up, not my brother or sister. I'm a lot like her in other ways too including allergies. I had two children. My youngest daughter, who is my clone in so many ways, is the one who picked it up. Not my other daughter(thank God!). I just don't have the answer, but that is my observation.ML.Subject: My experience with 4STo: Soundsensitivity Date: Monday, January 31, 2011, 4:12 PM Hi Everyone,I'm new to the group and joined specifically to save my marriage. I'm pretty sure I know why I have this condition. And now it seems that my wife is beginning to "catch" it.Background: As a child (I'm 45), my siblings and I would be punished for making "avoidable" noises at the dinner table (e.g., scraping teeth with a fork, humming, chewing with our mouths open, snorting, scraping knives sideways on a plate, etc.) The first infraction during a meal would result in an icy stare from my father and tension in the room for the rest of the meal. A second infraction would result in punishment. The punishment was pretty standard - go to bed for the rest of the day - without finishing the meal. No TV, books, newspapers, magazines, radio, etc. Pretty much justgo sit in silence and we'll see you tomorrow. If we cried, he'd come upstairs and "give us something to cry about" - usually a beating with his belt.I'm not looking for sympathy, nor do I want to appear as one of the "it's all my father's fault" people. I'm just laying out the facts as I believe they are related to my 4S.What I "learned" was that making unnecessary sounds would result in punishment; and even if I wasn't the one being punished, I still had to sit through the remainder of the meal - which was punishment in itself. What started out as a nice dinner could end with tension, fear, and anxiety. Over time, everyone at the table would shoot an icy stare at the offender. We all were taking on my father's aversion to everyday sounds. Maybe he had 4S? Sound irritation moved from the dinner table to the house in general (playing too loudly, creaking the stairs, popping bubble gum,etc), to school, to work, to my own home. The list of sounds that I just can't ignore now includes everything mentioned above plus chewing hard candy, fussing with candy wrappers and plastic bags, chewing ice, playing with coins in a pocket, newscasters with speech impediments, mispronounced words like "shtreet" (instead of "street"), incessant clicking of a pen, typing, lip smacking at the beginning of every sentence, word repetition (i.e. same word being used multiple times in a sentence), feet thudding across the floor above me, chair legs screeching when dragged across a floor, etc, etc.These sounds don't make me fearful or fill me with rage, they irritate and aggravate. My reaction to these sounds can be staring, mimicking the sound, talking loudly enough to drown out the sound, turning up the volume of the tv/radio, leaving the room, etc. I used to say something about it, but people weren't verysympathetic. They'd make more noise just to bug me. Being forced to deal with irritating sounds without vocalizing displeasure caused me to be more passive in my responses.A worst-case scenario for me is when I'm in a meeting or seminar and there are bowls of hard candy at every table. There's always someone that will eat a whole bowl of them - and refill at every break. It may take a minute or so of fussing with the wrapper to get the candy open. Then they crunch the candy rather than letting it dissolve slowly. While doing this, they mindlessly fold the wrapper into the tiniest square possible. Then they begin unwrapping another piece as the final bits of the previous piece are being chomped. This is worst-case for me because I can't focus on the topic being discussed and I can't tune out what I'm hearing. I just sit there stewing - waiting for someone to tell them to SHUT UP; wondering howeveryone else can tune it out while I can't; wondering how someone can deliberately be so rude and inconsiderate of others; and looking around the room trying to make eye contact with others that are annoyed but finding no one. Once that person does take a break, someone else picks up where he left off. Eventually, I have to join in as it's the only way to make enough noise to drown out what I'm hearing. The session ends, I've learned nothing, and I've eaten a bunch of candy. During breaks, I've asked other people "Could that guy make more of a racket with the candy?" and the response is always "What guy? I didn't hear anything." Basically they're saying that I have issues.Recently, my wife told me that she's tired of walking on eggshells around me. I was surprised because I just passively and subtly leave the room, turn up the radio, talk, etc when she makes a sound that annoys me. I realize thatit's my problem and deal with it the best I can - without directing anger toward her. But she's no dummy. She sees the icy stare out of the corner of her eye; she realizes I'm leaving the room because I don't want to hear her crunch cereal; she knows that using her emory board on her nails will cause me to take the dog out; etc. When she drops a piece of silverware, she now experiences all the feelings I experienced 40 years ago. She becomes tense, waiting for my reaction, knowing I'm completely irritated. I don't want her feeling that way around me. I have to change.As far as I'm concerned, my 4S is a behavioral issue caused by events that occurred an early age and allowed to grow unchecked for decades. Now I need to fix it. I don't think medicines or vitamins are the answer. For me, I think it's "unlearning" the behavior. My guess is that either hypnosis or completely immersing myselfin sounds I hate will be the cure for me. Maybe I should make a recording of the sounds and play them loudly during my commute. If I can tolerate them for an hour straight, I should be able to tolerate the occasional instance.Out of curiosity, have any of you had an early experience similar to mine where punishment may have caused the symptoms of 4S? Or did most people have a relatively normal childhood and feel that 4S is more genetic than environmental? Has anyone tried hypnotism or "sound immersion"?Thanks for listening.MarkPS - I'm not a fan of receiving long emails so I apologize for sending one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No. No one in my family cracks their knuckles. Thankfully ;). No glaring, etc. I can't imagine how "one more bite" could cause 4S. I simply could not tolerate the sounds. I found out just 2 years ago that my aunt is the exact same way. Had no idea and we did not grow up together and I never heard her complaints so I didn't learn it from her. But I'll betcha a billion dollars we have a gene in common that causes it. And there's been several people who have posted here including mothers of kids with it who have stated no dinner table problems but 4S exists in any event. And that food wasn't first trigger. Sent from my iPhone

Thank you for your input! Hypothese are there to be tested, and All information important.So far you are the first one to directly say to me that it did not start from occurrences at family meals. In my interviews it was it was not necessarily abuse at the dining table. Several women had selective eating/ swallowing/ food dislike problems. Others reacted to repetitive insistence on manners, or "just another bite", or pressure to converse nicely, or even the way a sibling looked at them across the table.So my next question is whether you recall if your brother cracked his knuckles at the table?Let your email find you with BlackBerry from Vodafone

Sender: Soundsensitivity

Date: Tue, 01 Feb 2011 17:02:08 -0000To: <Soundsensitivity >ReplyTo: Soundsensitivity

Subject: Re: My experience with 4S

Tara, I realize you were addressing Heidi with this message so I hope you'll excuse my replying :) I was wondering if in your interviews you'd spoken with anyone whose first trigger was not related to eating? I first started having 4S symptoms triggered by my brother's cracking his knuckles- eating noises came later.

>

> Heidi,

> I originally formed an hypothesis that 4S was often provoked by different situations during family mealtimes. This was proved true by quite a few people I interviewed.

> Would you consider telling me a bit about family mealtimes when you were growing up?

> With thanks,

> Tara

> Let your email find you with BlackBerry from Vodafone

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks to all for contibuting their first triggers!Let your email find you with BlackBerry from VodafoneSender: Soundsensitivity Date: Tue, 1 Feb 2011 11:05:45 -0800To: Soundsensitivity <Soundsensitivity >ReplyTo: Soundsensitivity Subject: Re: Re: My experience with 4S No. No one in my family cracks their knuckles. Thankfully ;). No glaring, etc. I can't imagine how "one more bite" could cause 4S. I simply could not tolerate the sounds. I found out just 2 years ago that my aunt is the exact same way. Had no idea and we did not grow up together and I never heard her complaints so I didn't learn it from her. But I'll betcha a billion dollars we have a gene in common that causes it. And there's been several people who have posted here including mothers of kids with it who have stated no dinner table problems but 4S exists in any event. And that food wasn't first trigger. Sent from my iPhone Thank you for your input! Hypothese are there to be tested, and All information important.So far you are the first one to directly say to me that it did not start from occurrences at family meals. In my interviews it was it was not necessarily abuse at the dining table. Several women had selective eating/ swallowing/ food dislike problems. Others reacted to repetitive insistence on manners, or "just another bite", or pressure to converse nicely, or even the way a sibling looked at them across the table.So my next question is whether you recall if your brother cracked his knuckles at the table?Let your email find you with BlackBerry from VodafoneSender: Soundsensitivity Date: Tue, 01 Feb 2011 17:02:08 -0000To: <Soundsensitivity >ReplyTo: Soundsensitivity Subject: Re: My experience with 4S Tara, I realize you were addressing Heidi with this message so I hope you'll excuse my replying :) I was wondering if in your interviews you'd spoken with anyone whose first trigger was not related to eating? I first started having 4S symptoms triggered by my brother's cracking his knuckles- eating noises came later.>> Heidi,> I originally formed an hypothesis that 4S was often provoked by different situations during family mealtimes. This was proved true by quite a few people I interviewed.> Would you consider telling me a bit about family mealtimes when you were growing up?> With thanks,> Tara> Let your email find you with BlackBerry from Vodafone

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...