Guest guest Posted March 3, 2005 Report Share Posted March 3, 2005 For most of my career I was in Silicon Valley where I was surrounded by venture capitalists, many of whom I knew to one or degree or another. Many of the people I worked with went on to start companies and get rich. I've had ideas and seen others think of them later on and do something about it. You're right about the existential problem if that's the right term. To do this you have to have some " fire in the belly, " a strong desire either to make a lot of money or to make a name for yourself. I have no strong desire in either category. If someone gives me an assignment, I can go off and do it happily and feel motivated. But when it comes to originating something, I don't feel highly motivated. Maybe it's connected with the ego issue we were talking about earlier. I don't know. Another problem is that I'm very good at finding problems with ideas, and I often convince myself something wouldn't work out for one reasons or another. Maybe that's because I really know the kind of effort and exposure involved, and I know it would probably be too stressful for me. In any event, I feel from your post that I'm in the same boat as you are. I'd really like to get a much clearer understanding of why I am not more ambitious. Ken > > Both when I've talked to Tom and now at the latest Aspie meeting, it > has transpired that many of us are actually sitting on really great > ideas. Ideas that are very innovative and could be a real commercial > hit. But most of us don't bother to do anything about them. Usually > for the the following reasons: > > 1. Not knowing how to go about it. > 2. Lack of funding and help to create a prototype, get it patented > etc. > 3. Well-founded fear of getting ripped off. > 4. Lack of ambition; a feeling that it might be too much of a hassle > to be worth the trouble. > 5. Not wanting to help create or sell more products in this world if > it is something unnecessary. > 6. Realizing that the change of it getting anywhere is microscopic if > it is something truly beneficial to mankind and/or the planet. > > I've had several rather cool ideas myself, that I never bothered > doing anything about. And some years later someone else got the same > idea and actually created something similar (though not quite as > good, beautiful and logical as mine would have been of course). ;-) > > Has that happened to anyone else here? (If you have a great idea that > you haven't patented yet, you may want to still keep it a bit private > though.) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2005 Report Share Posted March 4, 2005 Ken wrote: > For most of my career I was in Silicon Valley where I was surrounded > by venture capitalists, many of whom I knew to one or degree or > another. Many of the people I worked with went on to start companies > and get rich. I've had ideas and seen others think of them later on > and do something about it. Bit annoying that, isn't it? > You're right about the existential problem if that's the right term. > To do this you have to have some " fire in the belly, " a strong desire either to make a lot of money or to make a name for yourself. I have no strong desire in either category. Same here. I cherish my privacy and even though I wouldn't mind just a little bit more money, a lot more would only cause trouble and worries and pull me back into a sort of accountant sphere of thinking that I'm so relieved to have left behind. I can't stand anything to do with money, figures, taxes and boring paperwork! > If someone gives me an assignment, I can go off and do it happily and feel motivated. But when it comes to originating something, I don't feel highly motivated. Maybe it's connected with the ego issue we were talking about earlier. I don't know. I suspect that it is. I'm sort of the same; I too most easily get motivated by being asked. Or if I perceive a real need for something, then I may do it. > Another problem is that I'm very good at finding problems with ideas, and I often convince myself something wouldn't work out for one reasons or another. Maybe that's because I really know the kind of effort and exposure involved, and I know it would probably be too stressful for me. Right. That's another thing other Aspies have said too; they see all the possible problems right away and that's often enough to deter one who does not have a passionate desire for the fame and fortune you mentioned. > In any event, I feel from your post that I'm in the same boat as you are. I'd really like to get a much clearer understanding of why I am not more ambitious. I think it has to do with our purpose for being here. Are we here to use our receptiveness to ideas to help raise consciousness on this planet or are we here to help improve the material Aspect of it? I can only speak for myself, of course, and ideally I'd like to do both. But the former actually seems to be what is on my path while the latter continually turns into dead ends if I try to go down that road. Very annoying since I know I could add so much improvement to the material world if only given a chance. BUt I'm definitely not willing or able to do what it takes to get into that race. It makes me wonder though... if the majority of the population were Aspies, we would probably have a lot less wars, pollution etc. But would we actually get anything done at all? Inger Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2005 Report Share Posted March 4, 2005 Oooh, you're so right. Thanks for reminding me about our greater purpose. I know that, but I keep forgetting and getting caught up in the day to day. I've been taking a writing class where we write whatever we want and read it to each other and critique it. I've felt for some time that my mission is to write a book that attempts to reconcile science and spirituality (the objective and the subjective; the rational and the transrational). I've been especially inspired by the work of Ken Wilber. I write little bits here and there, and I'm also doing a lot of reading and filling in gaps in my knowledge. I had an astrology reading the other day with a man who's been pretty accurate for me in the past. Without my even telling him about this project, he told me that it would be good for me if I wrote the kind of book I described. He said I need to kick back here until summer, then find someone professional to talk to in a kind of Castaneda-style recapitulation to recapture some power lost in my youth, and then move back up to the Silicon Valley where the energy level is higher for this kind of project. It sounds right to me and we'll see how it develops. Ken > > I think it has to do with our purpose for being here. Are we here to use our receptiveness to ideas to help raise consciousness on this planet or are we here to help improve the material Aspect of it? I can only speak for myself, of course, and ideally I'd like to do both. But the former actually seems to be what is on my path while the latter continually turns into dead ends if I try to go down that road. Very annoying since I know I could add so much improvement to the material world if only given a chance. BUt I'm definitely not willing or able to do what it takes to get into that race. It makes me wonder though... if the majority of the population were Aspies, we would probably have a lot less wars, pollution etc. But would we actually get anything done at all? Inger Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2005 Report Share Posted March 4, 2005 That's cool, Ken. Sounds exactly like what some of us are here to do. Ken Wilber has done an enormous job of trying to make a synthesis of it all. (Just a bit too academic language for my personal taste. But then it's not written for people like me but for those who use that kind of lingo.) I hope you will take that suggestion seriously and really write that book. I very strongly belive that we ARE here to try and make a differnece, and with enough of us doing our best to do so, it HAS to have an effect. And the time is very advantageous for that sort of project as there is a greater openimindedness now than perhaps ever before. So, go for it! Inger > > > > I think it has to do with our purpose for being here. Are we here to > use our receptiveness to ideas to help raise consciousness on this > planet or are we here to help improve the material Aspect of it? I > can only speak for myself, of course, and ideally I'd like to do > both. But the former actually seems to be what is on my path while > the latter continually turns into dead ends if I try to go down that > road. Very annoying since I know I could add so much improvement to > the material world if only given a chance. BUt I'm definitely not > willing or able to do what it takes to get into that race. > > It makes me wonder though... if the majority of the population were > Aspies, we would probably have a lot less wars, pollution etc. But > would we actually get anything done at all? > > Inger Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2005 Report Share Posted March 4, 2005 That's cool, Ken. Sounds exactly like what some of us are here to do. Ken Wilber has done an enormous job of trying to make a synthesis of it all. (Just a bit too academic language for my personal taste. But then it's not written for people like me but for those who use that kind of lingo.) I hope you will take that suggestion seriously and really write that book. I very strongly belive that we ARE here to try and make a differnece, and with enough of us doing our best to do so, it HAS to have an effect. And the time is very advantageous for that sort of project as there is a greater openimindedness now than perhaps ever before. So, go for it! Inger > > > > I think it has to do with our purpose for being here. Are we here to > use our receptiveness to ideas to help raise consciousness on this > planet or are we here to help improve the material Aspect of it? I > can only speak for myself, of course, and ideally I'd like to do > both. But the former actually seems to be what is on my path while > the latter continually turns into dead ends if I try to go down that > road. Very annoying since I know I could add so much improvement to > the material world if only given a chance. BUt I'm definitely not > willing or able to do what it takes to get into that race. > > It makes me wonder though... if the majority of the population were > Aspies, we would probably have a lot less wars, pollution etc. But > would we actually get anything done at all? > > Inger Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2005 Report Share Posted March 4, 2005 The other observation I can make is that I've never been able to avoid things that I was really supposed to do. It's like there's a big finger coming down from the sky pointing in a particular direction. The ones I'm really supposed to do just won't go away even if I try to ignore them. Ken > > > > > > I think it has to do with our purpose for being here. Are we here > to > > use our receptiveness to ideas to help raise consciousness on this > > planet or are we here to help improve the material Aspect of it? I > > can only speak for myself, of course, and ideally I'd like to do > > both. But the former actually seems to be what is on my path while > > the latter continually turns into dead ends if I try to go down that > > road. Very annoying since I know I could add so much improvement to > > the material world if only given a chance. BUt I'm definitely not > > willing or able to do what it takes to get into that race. > > > > It makes me wonder though... if the majority of the population were > > Aspies, we would probably have a lot less wars, pollution etc. But > > would we actually get anything done at all? > > > > Inger Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2005 Report Share Posted March 4, 2005 The other observation I can make is that I've never been able to avoid things that I was really supposed to do. It's like there's a big finger coming down from the sky pointing in a particular direction. The ones I'm really supposed to do just won't go away even if I try to ignore them. Ken > > > > > > I think it has to do with our purpose for being here. Are we here > to > > use our receptiveness to ideas to help raise consciousness on this > > planet or are we here to help improve the material Aspect of it? I > > can only speak for myself, of course, and ideally I'd like to do > > both. But the former actually seems to be what is on my path while > > the latter continually turns into dead ends if I try to go down that > > road. Very annoying since I know I could add so much improvement to > > the material world if only given a chance. BUt I'm definitely not > > willing or able to do what it takes to get into that race. > > > > It makes me wonder though... if the majority of the population were > > Aspies, we would probably have a lot less wars, pollution etc. But > > would we actually get anything done at all? > > > > Inger Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2005 Report Share Posted March 4, 2005 Yes, it's been that way for me too. Some things I just know that I have to do, and even if it can be a bit of a challenge, I still have a drive to do them and won't be able to relax until I'm done. I've therefore stopped worrying about anything and just go with the flow. Inger > > > > > > > > I think it has to do with our purpose for being here. Are we here > > to > > > use our receptiveness to ideas to help raise consciousness on this > > > planet or are we here to help improve the material Aspect of it? I > > > can only speak for myself, of course, and ideally I'd like to do > > > both. But the former actually seems to be what is on my path while > > > the latter continually turns into dead ends if I try to go down that > > > road. Very annoying since I know I could add so much improvement to > > > the material world if only given a chance. BUt I'm definitely not > > > willing or able to do what it takes to get into that race. > > > > > > It makes me wonder though... if the majority of the population were > > > Aspies, we would probably have a lot less wars, pollution etc. But > > > would we actually get anything done at all? > > > > > > Inger Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2005 Report Share Posted March 4, 2005 Yes, it's been that way for me too. Some things I just know that I have to do, and even if it can be a bit of a challenge, I still have a drive to do them and won't be able to relax until I'm done. I've therefore stopped worrying about anything and just go with the flow. Inger > > > > > > > > I think it has to do with our purpose for being here. Are we here > > to > > > use our receptiveness to ideas to help raise consciousness on this > > > planet or are we here to help improve the material Aspect of it? I > > > can only speak for myself, of course, and ideally I'd like to do > > > both. But the former actually seems to be what is on my path while > > > the latter continually turns into dead ends if I try to go down that > > > road. Very annoying since I know I could add so much improvement to > > > the material world if only given a chance. BUt I'm definitely not > > > willing or able to do what it takes to get into that race. > > > > > > It makes me wonder though... if the majority of the population were > > > Aspies, we would probably have a lot less wars, pollution etc. But > > > would we actually get anything done at all? > > > > > > Inger Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2005 Report Share Posted March 4, 2005 Inger, This has happened to me more than once and continues to happen. I had a really great ideal at work and I know it would be a major benefit but still cannot even think of who to ask to help me make it a reality so I just dropped it. I told someone this about scrapbooking and how 9 years ago I began doing it but there were little or no supplies out there and now they are every where. Ever hear of a "round tuit" my friend made me one over 26 years ago. I think it would be great if we could make an online Autism/ Aspergers individual data base so that we could all write about us and what we can do professionally and personally speaking and then we could connect together with others to actually get some things done. It is like the post we had about a book here. It may seem slow but I am actually working on that. But my problem is what to do with it once it is done? If I look too far I won't ever do it so I will concentrate on that later RuthInger wrote: Both when I've talked to Tom and now at the latest Aspie meeting, it has transpired that many of us are actually sitting on really great ideas. Ideas that are very innovative and could be a real commercial hit. But most of us don't bother to do anything about them. Usually for the the following reasons:1. Not knowing how to go about it.2. Lack of funding and help to create a prototype, get it patented etc.3. Well-founded fear of getting ripped off.4. Lack of ambition; a feeling that it might be too much of a hassle to be worth the trouble. 5. Not wanting to help create or sell more products in this world if it is something unnecessary.6. Realizing that the change of it getting anywhere is microscopic if it is something truly beneficial to mankind and/or the planet. I've had several rather cool ideas myself, that I never bothered doing anything about. And some years later someone else got the same idea and actually created something similar (though not quite as good, beautiful and logical as mine would have been of course). ;-)Has that happened to anyone else here? (If you have a great idea that you haven't patented yet, you may want to still keep it a bit private though.) FAM Secret Society is a community based on respect, friendship, support and acceptance. Everyone is valued. Celebrate Yahoo!'s 10th Birthday! Yahoo! Netrospective: 100 Moments of the Web Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2005 Report Share Posted March 4, 2005 Inger, This has happened to me more than once and continues to happen. I had a really great ideal at work and I know it would be a major benefit but still cannot even think of who to ask to help me make it a reality so I just dropped it. I told someone this about scrapbooking and how 9 years ago I began doing it but there were little or no supplies out there and now they are every where. Ever hear of a "round tuit" my friend made me one over 26 years ago. I think it would be great if we could make an online Autism/ Aspergers individual data base so that we could all write about us and what we can do professionally and personally speaking and then we could connect together with others to actually get some things done. It is like the post we had about a book here. It may seem slow but I am actually working on that. But my problem is what to do with it once it is done? If I look too far I won't ever do it so I will concentrate on that later RuthInger wrote: Both when I've talked to Tom and now at the latest Aspie meeting, it has transpired that many of us are actually sitting on really great ideas. Ideas that are very innovative and could be a real commercial hit. But most of us don't bother to do anything about them. Usually for the the following reasons:1. Not knowing how to go about it.2. Lack of funding and help to create a prototype, get it patented etc.3. Well-founded fear of getting ripped off.4. Lack of ambition; a feeling that it might be too much of a hassle to be worth the trouble. 5. Not wanting to help create or sell more products in this world if it is something unnecessary.6. Realizing that the change of it getting anywhere is microscopic if it is something truly beneficial to mankind and/or the planet. I've had several rather cool ideas myself, that I never bothered doing anything about. And some years later someone else got the same idea and actually created something similar (though not quite as good, beautiful and logical as mine would have been of course). ;-)Has that happened to anyone else here? (If you have a great idea that you haven't patented yet, you may want to still keep it a bit private though.) FAM Secret Society is a community based on respect, friendship, support and acceptance. Everyone is valued. Celebrate Yahoo!'s 10th Birthday! Yahoo! Netrospective: 100 Moments of the Web Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2005 Report Share Posted March 5, 2005 > > Both when I've talked to Tom and now at the latest Aspie meeting, it > has transpired that many of us are actually sitting on really great > ideas. Ideas that are very innovative and could be a real commercial > hit. (snip) > Has that happened to anyone else here? (If you have a great idea that > you haven't patented yet, you may want to still keep it a bit private > though.) I have a lot of good ideas. The problem is actually getting the capital to do something with them. Here are some of them (I don't fear being " ripped off " since I've been in business and know that a " good idea " is about 10% of what you need to make a business): Buffet style restaurants that feature top quality food (like those found at casinos-- but not at casinos). I think there is already a restaurant like this at LAX. Exercise machines that double as video game controllers (the first ones are on the market now-- but the market is still open). A business that buys and provides service and support for " abandoned " specialized, industry specific software. And so on... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2005 Report Share Posted March 5, 2005 > > Both when I've talked to Tom and now at the latest Aspie meeting, it > has transpired that many of us are actually sitting on really great > ideas. Ideas that are very innovative and could be a real commercial > hit. (snip) > Has that happened to anyone else here? (If you have a great idea that > you haven't patented yet, you may want to still keep it a bit private > though.) I have a lot of good ideas. The problem is actually getting the capital to do something with them. Here are some of them (I don't fear being " ripped off " since I've been in business and know that a " good idea " is about 10% of what you need to make a business): Buffet style restaurants that feature top quality food (like those found at casinos-- but not at casinos). I think there is already a restaurant like this at LAX. Exercise machines that double as video game controllers (the first ones are on the market now-- but the market is still open). A business that buys and provides service and support for " abandoned " specialized, industry specific software. And so on... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2005 Report Share Posted March 5, 2005 > > Both when I've talked to Tom and now at the latest Aspie meeting, it > has transpired that many of us are actually sitting on really great > ideas. Ideas that are very innovative and could be a real commercial > hit. (snip) > Has that happened to anyone else here? (If you have a great idea that > you haven't patented yet, you may want to still keep it a bit private > though.) I have a lot of good ideas. The problem is actually getting the capital to do something with them. Here are some of them (I don't fear being " ripped off " since I've been in business and know that a " good idea " is about 10% of what you need to make a business): Buffet style restaurants that feature top quality food (like those found at casinos-- but not at casinos). I think there is already a restaurant like this at LAX. Exercise machines that double as video game controllers (the first ones are on the market now-- but the market is still open). A business that buys and provides service and support for " abandoned " specialized, industry specific software. And so on... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2005 Report Share Posted March 5, 2005 If you were in the Silicon Valley, it would be pretty easy to meet venture capitalists and present your business plan. There are also angel groups for small amounts of financing. And they're used to Aspies of which there are many in the Valley. Closer to you there's also a smaller scale venture capital community around Montgomery Country, MD. Not that helps you where you live. Ken > > > > Both when I've talked to Tom and now at the latest Aspie meeting, it > > has transpired that many of us are actually sitting on really great > > ideas. Ideas that are very innovative and could be a real commercial > > hit. > (snip) > > Has that happened to anyone else here? (If you have a great idea that > > you haven't patented yet, you may want to still keep it a bit private > > though.) > > I have a lot of good ideas. The problem is actually getting the > capital to do something with them. Here are some of them (I don't > fear being " ripped off " since I've been in business and know that a > " good idea " is about 10% of what you need to make a business): > > Buffet style restaurants that feature top quality food (like those > found at casinos-- but not at casinos). I think there is already a > restaurant like this at LAX. > > Exercise machines that double as video game controllers (the first > ones are on the market now-- but the market is still open). > > A business that buys and provides service and support for " abandoned " > specialized, industry specific software. > > And so on... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 8, 2005 Report Share Posted March 8, 2005 > it has transpired that many of us are actually sitting on really > great ideas. That doesn't surprise me. I've heard the comment that if it weren't for people on The Spectrum, the entire inventive activity of humanity would consist of: - beer - darts - and a few weapons. As a patent lawyer, I don't really see that but that's because patents are generally obtained to protect commercial activity of some sort. Most of what's patented is, " something cute (from an engineering viewpoint) that makes something work. " It is extremely rare for an independent inventor to develop an idea and be able to benefit from a patent. I know one person who did it (relating to a tool used to pull wires through a building). For an idea to make it commercially, one must be able to have it produced and in the market to an extent sufficient to prove its marketability. Whether it's a good idea is irrelevant. > But most of us don't bother to do anything about > them. Usually for the the following reasons: > ... > 4. Lack of ambition; a feeling that it might be too much of > a hassle to be worth the trouble. Well, from a commercial standpoint. Also, it's extremely difficult to gain commercial recognition. For example, I could propose a low flicker fluorescent light system, but I'd have to find someone who is already trying to address that problem on a commercial level. Obtaining patent protection is a bit easy for me, although the patent would have to be for the controller. But it's still not likely to be accepted. At that point, I can publish it, and hope that people use it on their own. Most people have the hurdle of convincing a business that one has the technical credibility to have any idea accepted. Simultaneously, in many cases the business wants patent protection. > 5. Not wanting to help create or sell more > products in this world if it is something unnecessary. Probably not an issue for most products as conceived by the inventor. The inventor usually considers the particular idea worth the environmental cost. > I've had several rather cool ideas myself, that I never bothered > doing anything about. For the most part, ideas are developed because of a desire for the product. > Has that happened to anyone else here? (If you have a great idea > that you haven't patented yet, you may want to still keep it a > bit private though.) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 8, 2005 Report Share Posted March 8, 2005 > it has transpired that many of us are actually sitting on really > great ideas. That doesn't surprise me. I've heard the comment that if it weren't for people on The Spectrum, the entire inventive activity of humanity would consist of: - beer - darts - and a few weapons. As a patent lawyer, I don't really see that but that's because patents are generally obtained to protect commercial activity of some sort. Most of what's patented is, " something cute (from an engineering viewpoint) that makes something work. " It is extremely rare for an independent inventor to develop an idea and be able to benefit from a patent. I know one person who did it (relating to a tool used to pull wires through a building). For an idea to make it commercially, one must be able to have it produced and in the market to an extent sufficient to prove its marketability. Whether it's a good idea is irrelevant. > But most of us don't bother to do anything about > them. Usually for the the following reasons: > ... > 4. Lack of ambition; a feeling that it might be too much of > a hassle to be worth the trouble. Well, from a commercial standpoint. Also, it's extremely difficult to gain commercial recognition. For example, I could propose a low flicker fluorescent light system, but I'd have to find someone who is already trying to address that problem on a commercial level. Obtaining patent protection is a bit easy for me, although the patent would have to be for the controller. But it's still not likely to be accepted. At that point, I can publish it, and hope that people use it on their own. Most people have the hurdle of convincing a business that one has the technical credibility to have any idea accepted. Simultaneously, in many cases the business wants patent protection. > 5. Not wanting to help create or sell more > products in this world if it is something unnecessary. Probably not an issue for most products as conceived by the inventor. The inventor usually considers the particular idea worth the environmental cost. > I've had several rather cool ideas myself, that I never bothered > doing anything about. For the most part, ideas are developed because of a desire for the product. > Has that happened to anyone else here? (If you have a great idea > that you haven't patented yet, you may want to still keep it a > bit private though.) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 8, 2005 Report Share Posted March 8, 2005 From: Inger wrote: > it has transpired that many of us are actually sitting on really great ideas. Stan: > That doesn't surprise me. I've heard the comment that if it weren't for people on The Spectrum, the entire inventive activity of humanity would consist of: - beer - darts - and a few weapons.¨ LOL! > As a patent lawyer, I don't really see that but that's because patents are generally obtained to protect commercial activity of some sort. Most of what's patented is, " something cute (from an engineering viewpoint) that makes something work. " > It is extremely rare for an independent inventor to develop an idea and be able to benefit from a patent. I know one person who did it (relating to a tool used to pull wires through a building). I know an inventor too that was successful. He was rather atypical as well. > For an idea to make it commercially, one must be able to have it produced and in the market to an extent sufficient to prove its marketability. Whether it's a good idea is irrelevant. Right. That's the tiresome bit. :-( >> But most of us don't bother to do anything about >> them. Usually for the the following reasons: >> 4. Lack of ambition; a feeling that it might be too >> much of a hassle to be worth the trouble. > > Well, from a commercial standpoint. Also, it's extremely difficult to gain commercial recognition. For example, I could propose a low flicker fluorescent light system, but I'd have to find someone who is already trying to address that problem on a commercial level. Well, there already is a low flicker FL light system, and someone must have invented that? > Obtaining patent protection is a bit easy for me, although the patent would have to be for the controller. Controller? > But it's still not likely to be accepted. By whom? > At that point, I can publish it, and hope that people use it on their own. If they do, do they have to pay you if you have the patent? > Most people have the hurdle of convincing a business that one has the technical credibility to have any idea accepted. That's very difficult, isn't it? > Simultaneously, in many cases the business wants patent protection. What do you do if you have a really great and revolutionary idea, say something that could replace the keyboard for your computer, or a new soft drink taste that no one has ever thought of before. How would you go about selling the idea without someone snatching it? And to whom? Would you have to be able to construct a prototype and exact recipe respectively in order to sell it, or could you just sell the idea itself and get sort of a royalty on it or something? >> 5. Not wanting to help create or sell more > products in this world if it is something unnecessary. > Probably not an issue for most products as conceived by the inventor. The inventor usually considers the particular idea worth the environmental cost. I guess I'm atypical, then. :-) >> I've had several rather cool ideas myself, that I never bothered > doing anything about. > > For the most part, ideas are developed because of a desire for the product. That's the problem. I sometimes get ideas for products that I wouldn't want myself. Or if I do, no one else does. :-( Inger Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 8, 2005 Report Share Posted March 8, 2005 From: Inger wrote: > it has transpired that many of us are actually sitting on really great ideas. Stan: > That doesn't surprise me. I've heard the comment that if it weren't for people on The Spectrum, the entire inventive activity of humanity would consist of: - beer - darts - and a few weapons.¨ LOL! > As a patent lawyer, I don't really see that but that's because patents are generally obtained to protect commercial activity of some sort. Most of what's patented is, " something cute (from an engineering viewpoint) that makes something work. " > It is extremely rare for an independent inventor to develop an idea and be able to benefit from a patent. I know one person who did it (relating to a tool used to pull wires through a building). I know an inventor too that was successful. He was rather atypical as well. > For an idea to make it commercially, one must be able to have it produced and in the market to an extent sufficient to prove its marketability. Whether it's a good idea is irrelevant. Right. That's the tiresome bit. :-( >> But most of us don't bother to do anything about >> them. Usually for the the following reasons: >> 4. Lack of ambition; a feeling that it might be too >> much of a hassle to be worth the trouble. > > Well, from a commercial standpoint. Also, it's extremely difficult to gain commercial recognition. For example, I could propose a low flicker fluorescent light system, but I'd have to find someone who is already trying to address that problem on a commercial level. Well, there already is a low flicker FL light system, and someone must have invented that? > Obtaining patent protection is a bit easy for me, although the patent would have to be for the controller. Controller? > But it's still not likely to be accepted. By whom? > At that point, I can publish it, and hope that people use it on their own. If they do, do they have to pay you if you have the patent? > Most people have the hurdle of convincing a business that one has the technical credibility to have any idea accepted. That's very difficult, isn't it? > Simultaneously, in many cases the business wants patent protection. What do you do if you have a really great and revolutionary idea, say something that could replace the keyboard for your computer, or a new soft drink taste that no one has ever thought of before. How would you go about selling the idea without someone snatching it? And to whom? Would you have to be able to construct a prototype and exact recipe respectively in order to sell it, or could you just sell the idea itself and get sort of a royalty on it or something? >> 5. Not wanting to help create or sell more > products in this world if it is something unnecessary. > Probably not an issue for most products as conceived by the inventor. The inventor usually considers the particular idea worth the environmental cost. I guess I'm atypical, then. :-) >> I've had several rather cool ideas myself, that I never bothered > doing anything about. > > For the most part, ideas are developed because of a desire for the product. That's the problem. I sometimes get ideas for products that I wouldn't want myself. Or if I do, no one else does. :-( Inger Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 9, 2005 Report Share Posted March 9, 2005 > > At that point, I can publish it, and hope that people use it on > > their own. > > If they do, do they have to pay you if you have the patent? If I patent it and they use the system as defined by the patent. Sometimes that's straightforward, meaning the idea and the patented system or method are the same. There are some cases where the basic idea (e.g., a mathematical formula or some techniques) are either unpatentable or the patent cannot be enforced. > > Most people have the hurdle of convincing a business that > one has the technical credibility to have any idea accepted. > > That's very difficult, isn't it? Yes. > > Simultaneously, in many cases the business wants patent > protection. > > What do you do if you have a really great and revolutionary idea ... > How would you go about selling the idea without someone snatching > it? That's what the patent is for. The idea is to get someone to produce it, either under license or not. The problem is that the patent is costly, and it's very difficult to get someone to produce it. The way to go about it is to obtain patent protection and have the product produced. If it is marginally successful, then perhaps someone in the business may expect to make a profit and wish to produce it. > Would you have to be able to construct a > prototype and exact recipe respectively in order to sell it, or > could you just sell the idea itself and get sort of a royalty on > it or something? The difficult part is to sell the idea. Business don't buy ideas from the outside. So you'd have to get it produced and demonstrate its marketability. > > Probably not an issue for most products as conceived by the > inventor. The inventor usually considers the particular idea > worth the environmental cost. > > I guess I'm atypical, then. :-) I guess I could conceive of some products that would be wasteful, but I don't think I'd be interested in develop them. > That's the problem. I sometimes get ideas for products that I > wouldn't want myself. Or if I do, no one else does. :-( More likely, you're talking about the disconnect between engineering and marketing. What seems like a good idea from the engineering standpoint is often not marketable. (Sounds like the AS/NT thing.) - s Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 9, 2005 Report Share Posted March 9, 2005 > > At that point, I can publish it, and hope that people use it on > > their own. > > If they do, do they have to pay you if you have the patent? If I patent it and they use the system as defined by the patent. Sometimes that's straightforward, meaning the idea and the patented system or method are the same. There are some cases where the basic idea (e.g., a mathematical formula or some techniques) are either unpatentable or the patent cannot be enforced. > > Most people have the hurdle of convincing a business that > one has the technical credibility to have any idea accepted. > > That's very difficult, isn't it? Yes. > > Simultaneously, in many cases the business wants patent > protection. > > What do you do if you have a really great and revolutionary idea ... > How would you go about selling the idea without someone snatching > it? That's what the patent is for. The idea is to get someone to produce it, either under license or not. The problem is that the patent is costly, and it's very difficult to get someone to produce it. The way to go about it is to obtain patent protection and have the product produced. If it is marginally successful, then perhaps someone in the business may expect to make a profit and wish to produce it. > Would you have to be able to construct a > prototype and exact recipe respectively in order to sell it, or > could you just sell the idea itself and get sort of a royalty on > it or something? The difficult part is to sell the idea. Business don't buy ideas from the outside. So you'd have to get it produced and demonstrate its marketability. > > Probably not an issue for most products as conceived by the > inventor. The inventor usually considers the particular idea > worth the environmental cost. > > I guess I'm atypical, then. :-) I guess I could conceive of some products that would be wasteful, but I don't think I'd be interested in develop them. > That's the problem. I sometimes get ideas for products that I > wouldn't want myself. Or if I do, no one else does. :-( More likely, you're talking about the disconnect between engineering and marketing. What seems like a good idea from the engineering standpoint is often not marketable. (Sounds like the AS/NT thing.) - s Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 9, 2005 Report Share Posted March 9, 2005 > > At that point, I can publish it, and hope that people use it on > > their own. > > If they do, do they have to pay you if you have the patent? If I patent it and they use the system as defined by the patent. Sometimes that's straightforward, meaning the idea and the patented system or method are the same. There are some cases where the basic idea (e.g., a mathematical formula or some techniques) are either unpatentable or the patent cannot be enforced. > > Most people have the hurdle of convincing a business that > one has the technical credibility to have any idea accepted. > > That's very difficult, isn't it? Yes. > > Simultaneously, in many cases the business wants patent > protection. > > What do you do if you have a really great and revolutionary idea ... > How would you go about selling the idea without someone snatching > it? That's what the patent is for. The idea is to get someone to produce it, either under license or not. The problem is that the patent is costly, and it's very difficult to get someone to produce it. The way to go about it is to obtain patent protection and have the product produced. If it is marginally successful, then perhaps someone in the business may expect to make a profit and wish to produce it. > Would you have to be able to construct a > prototype and exact recipe respectively in order to sell it, or > could you just sell the idea itself and get sort of a royalty on > it or something? The difficult part is to sell the idea. Business don't buy ideas from the outside. So you'd have to get it produced and demonstrate its marketability. > > Probably not an issue for most products as conceived by the > inventor. The inventor usually considers the particular idea > worth the environmental cost. > > I guess I'm atypical, then. :-) I guess I could conceive of some products that would be wasteful, but I don't think I'd be interested in develop them. > That's the problem. I sometimes get ideas for products that I > wouldn't want myself. Or if I do, no one else does. :-( More likely, you're talking about the disconnect between engineering and marketing. What seems like a good idea from the engineering standpoint is often not marketable. (Sounds like the AS/NT thing.) - s Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 9, 2005 Report Share Posted March 9, 2005 Stan, thanks for this info. Now, if someone was really smart - and rich - they could find Aspies from all over the world, not focus overly on their official credentials, just on their great ideas, and offer the help to produce, patent and market these ideas and then share the profits. It could actually be like an Aspie co-op where the inventors were also shareholders. Wouldn't that be cool? Inger - dreaming up more unrealistic ideas as usual... *sigh* Re: Re: Aspie inventiveness? > > At that point, I can publish it, and hope that people use it on > > their own. > > If they do, do they have to pay you if you have the patent? If I patent it and they use the system as defined by the patent. Sometimes that's straightforward, meaning the idea and the patented system or method are the same. There are some cases where the basic idea (e.g., a mathematical formula or some techniques) are either unpatentable or the patent cannot be enforced. > > Most people have the hurdle of convincing a business that > one has the technical credibility to have any idea accepted. > > That's very difficult, isn't it? Yes. > > Simultaneously, in many cases the business wants patent > protection. > > What do you do if you have a really great and revolutionary idea ... > How would you go about selling the idea without someone snatching > it? That's what the patent is for. The idea is to get someone to produce it, either under license or not. The problem is that the patent is costly, and it's very difficult to get someone to produce it. The way to go about it is to obtain patent protection and have the product produced. If it is marginally successful, then perhaps someone in the business may expect to make a profit and wish to produce it. > Would you have to be able to construct a > prototype and exact recipe respectively in order to sell it, or > could you just sell the idea itself and get sort of a royalty on > it or something? The difficult part is to sell the idea. Business don't buy ideas from the outside. So you'd have to get it produced and demonstrate its marketability. > > Probably not an issue for most products as conceived by the > inventor. The inventor usually considers the particular idea > worth the environmental cost. > > I guess I'm atypical, then. :-) I guess I could conceive of some products that would be wasteful, but I don't think I'd be interested in develop them. > That's the problem. I sometimes get ideas for products that I > wouldn't want myself. Or if I do, no one else does. :-( More likely, you're talking about the disconnect between engineering and marketing. What seems like a good idea from the engineering standpoint is often not marketable. (Sounds like the AS/NT thing.) - s FAM Secret Society is a community based on respect, friendship, support and acceptance. Everyone is valued. Don't forget, all female members of FAM Secret Society may join FAM Ladies' Lodge http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/FAMLadiesLodge/ and all males from Secret Society may join FAM Gentlemen's Guild http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/FAMGentlemensGuild/. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 9, 2005 Report Share Posted March 9, 2005 Stan, thanks for this info. Now, if someone was really smart - and rich - they could find Aspies from all over the world, not focus overly on their official credentials, just on their great ideas, and offer the help to produce, patent and market these ideas and then share the profits. It could actually be like an Aspie co-op where the inventors were also shareholders. Wouldn't that be cool? Inger - dreaming up more unrealistic ideas as usual... *sigh* Re: Re: Aspie inventiveness? > > At that point, I can publish it, and hope that people use it on > > their own. > > If they do, do they have to pay you if you have the patent? If I patent it and they use the system as defined by the patent. Sometimes that's straightforward, meaning the idea and the patented system or method are the same. There are some cases where the basic idea (e.g., a mathematical formula or some techniques) are either unpatentable or the patent cannot be enforced. > > Most people have the hurdle of convincing a business that > one has the technical credibility to have any idea accepted. > > That's very difficult, isn't it? Yes. > > Simultaneously, in many cases the business wants patent > protection. > > What do you do if you have a really great and revolutionary idea ... > How would you go about selling the idea without someone snatching > it? That's what the patent is for. The idea is to get someone to produce it, either under license or not. The problem is that the patent is costly, and it's very difficult to get someone to produce it. The way to go about it is to obtain patent protection and have the product produced. If it is marginally successful, then perhaps someone in the business may expect to make a profit and wish to produce it. > Would you have to be able to construct a > prototype and exact recipe respectively in order to sell it, or > could you just sell the idea itself and get sort of a royalty on > it or something? The difficult part is to sell the idea. Business don't buy ideas from the outside. So you'd have to get it produced and demonstrate its marketability. > > Probably not an issue for most products as conceived by the > inventor. The inventor usually considers the particular idea > worth the environmental cost. > > I guess I'm atypical, then. :-) I guess I could conceive of some products that would be wasteful, but I don't think I'd be interested in develop them. > That's the problem. I sometimes get ideas for products that I > wouldn't want myself. Or if I do, no one else does. :-( More likely, you're talking about the disconnect between engineering and marketing. What seems like a good idea from the engineering standpoint is often not marketable. (Sounds like the AS/NT thing.) - s FAM Secret Society is a community based on respect, friendship, support and acceptance. Everyone is valued. Don't forget, all female members of FAM Secret Society may join FAM Ladies' Lodge http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/FAMLadiesLodge/ and all males from Secret Society may join FAM Gentlemen's Guild http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/FAMGentlemensGuild/. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 9, 2005 Report Share Posted March 9, 2005 Stan, thanks for this info. Now, if someone was really smart - and rich - they could find Aspies from all over the world, not focus overly on their official credentials, just on their great ideas, and offer the help to produce, patent and market these ideas and then share the profits. It could actually be like an Aspie co-op where the inventors were also shareholders. Wouldn't that be cool? Inger - dreaming up more unrealistic ideas as usual... *sigh* Re: Re: Aspie inventiveness? > > At that point, I can publish it, and hope that people use it on > > their own. > > If they do, do they have to pay you if you have the patent? If I patent it and they use the system as defined by the patent. Sometimes that's straightforward, meaning the idea and the patented system or method are the same. There are some cases where the basic idea (e.g., a mathematical formula or some techniques) are either unpatentable or the patent cannot be enforced. > > Most people have the hurdle of convincing a business that > one has the technical credibility to have any idea accepted. > > That's very difficult, isn't it? Yes. > > Simultaneously, in many cases the business wants patent > protection. > > What do you do if you have a really great and revolutionary idea ... > How would you go about selling the idea without someone snatching > it? That's what the patent is for. The idea is to get someone to produce it, either under license or not. The problem is that the patent is costly, and it's very difficult to get someone to produce it. The way to go about it is to obtain patent protection and have the product produced. If it is marginally successful, then perhaps someone in the business may expect to make a profit and wish to produce it. > Would you have to be able to construct a > prototype and exact recipe respectively in order to sell it, or > could you just sell the idea itself and get sort of a royalty on > it or something? The difficult part is to sell the idea. Business don't buy ideas from the outside. So you'd have to get it produced and demonstrate its marketability. > > Probably not an issue for most products as conceived by the > inventor. The inventor usually considers the particular idea > worth the environmental cost. > > I guess I'm atypical, then. :-) I guess I could conceive of some products that would be wasteful, but I don't think I'd be interested in develop them. > That's the problem. I sometimes get ideas for products that I > wouldn't want myself. Or if I do, no one else does. :-( More likely, you're talking about the disconnect between engineering and marketing. What seems like a good idea from the engineering standpoint is often not marketable. (Sounds like the AS/NT thing.) - s FAM Secret Society is a community based on respect, friendship, support and acceptance. Everyone is valued. Don't forget, all female members of FAM Secret Society may join FAM Ladies' Lodge http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/FAMLadiesLodge/ and all males from Secret Society may join FAM Gentlemen's Guild http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/FAMGentlemensGuild/. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.