Guest guest Posted November 6, 2005 Report Share Posted November 6, 2005 In a message dated 11/5/2005 10:32:30 P.M. Central Standard Time, mwaybright@... writes: I have a question about DMG. I've been thinking about trying it, but a friend of mine thought she remembered reading that it was best to try this later in the protocol. What do you all know about this? I have not read anywhere that DMG should be tried later according to a specific protocol (not sure which one you're referring to). In the book, Biological Treatments for Autism & PDD by Shaw, in chapter 9 which is written by Bernard Rimland of the Autism Research Institute, Dr. Rimland doesn't say when the best time to start he just writes that for a pre-school aged child he would start with 1/2 of a 125 mg tablet a day with breakfast for a few days. Then gradually increase to 1 to 4 tablets a day. We only did 1 tablet per day the entire time my son was on it. Dr. Rimland suggests if you are just starting out, to give DMG for 2-3 weeks then add B6/magnesium. He says to write to ARI for publication 39F for more info. He also says when you start a trial of DMG not to confuse the results by simultaneously starting other vitamins, drugs, or other forms of treatment that make it difficult to tease out the effects of DMG. But when time is of the essence, it's hard to wait. R. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 6, 2005 Report Share Posted November 6, 2005 Can I add my experience to this? If you are going to try methyl B12 injections then Dr. Neubrander (the pioneer/expert of this supplement) suggests it be tried alone for 5 weeks. By alone I mean not to take DMG/TMG or folinic acid or FolaPro. The first " WOW " gain we saw in our autistic daughter was when we added methyl B12 injections. I had a feeling she would respond well to this supplement as we tested her MTHFR gene and she had a double SNP there which means her ability to methylate is deficient to nil. For 2 weeks we had her on the " every 3rd day " injection schedule. The first day after the injection we could note a difference in her, but nothing on days 2 and 3. So I spoke with our DAN doc and he agreed I could give the injections everyday without lowering the dosage. (Note that excess vit B12 is excreted, thus no chance of becoming toxic.) On the third day of the daily shots, she went and got her old dusty potty chair, set it up on my bed so she wouldn't miss Elmo, shucked down her panties, and peed in the potty! She has used that potty every day since July without encouragement. I had stopped trying to train her about 6 months before because I could see she just wasn't ready developmentally; she " didn't get it " at all. Needless to say, we were stunned and THRILLED. I can honestly say that the methyl B12 was responsible for that gain. By the way, only about 50% of kids have 1 or 2 SNP's on the MTHFR gene, but Dr. Neubrander says that 85% of kids using methyl B12 injections improve with this supplement. (This is parent reported improvement.) Message being...you don't have to undergo expensive genetic testing and even if you do and it is negative, it is worth a five week trial on methyl B12 injections to see if your child is one of those 85% who benefit. Why NOT try a a biomedical intervention that has 85% of parents reporting improvements in their autistic child's symptoms? Also, for those who can't imagine giving a shot...this needle is smaller than a diabetic needle and is given in the fat, not muscle, of the buttock. I give it when my daughter is asleep and she doesn't notice it. But others get a prescription for EMLA cream and apply that first to numb the area. So please don't discount it for this reason. I just approached it with the mind-set of " if she were a diabetic I would inject her with insulin; since she is a poor methylator I will inject her with methyl B12 " . Lastly, a methyl B12 nasal spray has just been developed. It doesn't have all the numbers supporting the efficacy yet, but that is a route to administer the methylcobalamine which might be easier on the child (and parent). Sorry so long. I am always happy to correspond with others interested in or using the DAN! protocol or biomedical intervention. started chelating using TD-DMPS 2 months ago and we are seeing gains with this treatment, too. She is on various other supplements, but the next big therapy she will undertake is HBOT. I am particulary excited about getting that started as a tiny study presented at the last DAN! conference stated that the most improvements were noted in kids 4 and under. However, I have read that autistic adults are seeing gains as well. The neat thing is that unlike many interventions/therapies this one has a test to measure improvement. There is a test of the brain called SPECT scans which can be done before and after a course of HBOT. These scans have shown improvements in EVERY autistic individual who has employed them. We will do the hypobaric therapy without them as insurance doesn't cover them. But the fact that so many others have seen gains using this therapy makes me feel motivated to try it. Take care, Penni Penni > > > In a message dated 11/5/2005 10:32:30 P.M. Central Standard Time, > mwaybright@c... writes: > > I have a question about DMG. I've been thinking about trying it, but a > friend of mine thought she remembered reading that it was best to try this > later in the protocol. What do you all know about this? > > > I have not read anywhere that DMG should be tried later according to a > specific protocol (not sure which one you're referring to). In the book, > Biological Treatments for Autism & PDD by Shaw, in chapter 9 which is written > by Bernard Rimland of the Autism Research Institute, Dr. Rimland doesn't say > when the best time to start he just writes that for a pre-school aged child > he would start with 1/2 of a 125 mg tablet a day with breakfast for a few > days. Then gradually increase to 1 to 4 tablets a day. We only did 1 tablet per > day the entire time my son was on it. Dr. Rimland suggests if you are just > starting out, to give DMG for 2-3 weeks then add B6/magnesium. He says to write > to ARI for publication 39F for more info. He also says when you start a trial > of DMG not to confuse the results by simultaneously starting other vitamins, > drugs, or other forms of treatment that make it difficult to tease out the > effects of DMG. But when time is of the essence, it's hard to wait. R. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 7, 2005 Report Share Posted November 7, 2005 and Penni: Thanks so much for the info! I'm going to write for that publication on DMG and will seriously consider the Methyl B12 shots. I was hesitant to do those because of the whole shot aspect, but if you REALLY can give the shot while sleeping, we'll have to give it a go. I might do the DMG first though so I can work up the courage for the shots! Thanks again! _____ From: Texas-Autism-Advocacy [mailto:Texas-Autism-Advocacy ] On Behalf Of kgreeceman@... Sent: Sunday, November 06, 2005 10:55 AM To: Texas-Autism-Advocacy Subject: Re: Biomedical Interventions/Discussions for W. In a message dated 11/5/2005 10:32:30 P.M. Central Standard Time, mwaybright@... writes: I have a question about DMG. I've been thinking about trying it, but a friend of mine thought she remembered reading that it was best to try this later in the protocol. What do you all know about this? I have not read anywhere that DMG should be tried later according to a specific protocol (not sure which one you're referring to). In the book, Biological Treatments for Autism & PDD by Shaw, in chapter 9 which is written by Bernard Rimland of the Autism Research Institute, Dr. Rimland doesn't say when the best time to start he just writes that for a pre-school aged child he would start with 1/2 of a 125 mg tablet a day with breakfast for a few days. Then gradually increase to 1 to 4 tablets a day. We only did 1 tablet per day the entire time my son was on it. Dr. Rimland suggests if you are just starting out, to give DMG for 2-3 weeks then add B6/magnesium. He says to write to ARI for publication 39F for more info. He also says when you start a trial of DMG not to confuse the results by simultaneously starting other vitamins, drugs, or other forms of treatment that make it difficult to tease out the effects of DMG. But when time is of the essence, it's hard to wait. R. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 7, 2005 Report Share Posted November 7, 2005 We are using vitamin research sublingual b-12 and it has a cinnamon- cherry flavor and Cody doesn't mind it at all and will hold his tongue up while I put it under there. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 7, 2005 Report Share Posted November 7, 2005 Agreed the shots are no big deal. The needle is really tiny and even without the cream my son will go along willingly. Beware though I think Matt threw some of them away he's getting way sneaky. Down side of chelation and B-12? Wouldn't we all throw away our medicine if that meant we didn't have to take it? Too bad there isn't a sneaky category in the autism rating scale... Trina Re: Biomedical > Interventions/Discussions > for W. > > > > > In a message dated 11/5/2005 10:32:30 P.M. Central > Standard Time, > mwaybright@... writes: > > I have a question about DMG. I've been thinking > about trying it, but a > friend of mine thought she remembered reading that > it was best to try this > later in the protocol. What do you all know about > this? > > > I have not read anywhere that DMG should be tried > later according to a > specific protocol (not sure which one you're > referring to). In the book, > Biological Treatments for Autism & PDD by > Shaw, in chapter 9 which > is written > by Bernard Rimland of the Autism Research Institute, > Dr. Rimland doesn't > say > when the best time to start he just writes that for > a pre-school aged child > > he would start with 1/2 of a 125 mg tablet a day > with breakfast for a few > days. Then gradually increase to 1 to 4 tablets a > day. We only did 1 tablet > per > day the entire time my son was on it. Dr. Rimland > suggests if you are just > starting out, to give DMG for 2-3 weeks then add > B6/magnesium. He says to > write > to ARI for publication 39F for more info. He also > says when you start a > trial > of DMG not to confuse the results by simultaneously > starting other > vitamins, > drugs, or other forms of treatment that make it > difficult to tease out the > effects of DMG. But when time is of the essence, > it's hard to wait. > R. > > > [Non-text portions of this message have been > removed] > > > > Texas Autism Advocacy > www.TexasAutismAdvocacy.org > > Texas Disability Network > Calendar of Events > www.TexasAutismAdvocacy.org > > > > > _____ > > YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS > > > > * Visit your group " Texas-Autism-Advocacy > <http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Texas-Autism-Advocacy> > " on the web. > > * Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 8, 2005 Report Share Posted November 8, 2005 , I hope I don't get a " DUH! " back from you, but...is this methyl B12? For others interested in a sublingual, make sure you obtain METHYL B12--whatever the route. The type most commonly found in health food stores is NOT methyl B12. Dr. Neubrander explained it in a paper like this: Think of your family. Everyone has the same last name, but each individual has a different first name. It is the same with B12. There is CYNCOcobalamine, HYDROXYcobalamine, METHYLcobalamine, and 2 others. The form which is beneficial to autistic kids is methylcobalamine and the others don't provide the same supplementation to the methylation system. Just an FYI for those who didn't know there are different types of B12. Penni > > We are using vitamin research sublingual b-12 and it has a cinnamon- > cherry flavor and Cody doesn't mind it at all and will hold his tongue > up while I put it under there. > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 8, 2005 Report Share Posted November 8, 2005 I am sorry. I should have specified that it is the Methylcobalamin Vitamin B-12. It is 1000mcg per 1 ml. I wouldn't use anything as as they need the cobalt to assumulate the vitamin. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 9, 2005 Report Share Posted November 9, 2005 Penni, After all this discussion on Methyl-B12, I checked my cabinet and found that I still have a bottle of tablets that say " Methylcobalamin B-12 " that we were giving our sons a couple of summers ago during a time when they were taking about 15 different suppplements a day! I got burned out--wasn't seeing tremendous results-- but I am going to start giving the boys this B12 again, but I was wondering how much of a dose you were told to give your child? Our twins are 11 years old--Joe weighs over 100 pounds now, and Ben is probably about 85 pounds or so. I don't know if your child is even close to the size of my boys but I was just curious how much you're giving your child. Thanks, a Re: Biomedical Interventions/Discussions for W. , I hope I don't get a " DUH! " back from you, but...is this methyl B12? For others interested in a sublingual, make sure you obtain METHYL B12--whatever the route. The type most commonly found in health food stores is NOT methyl B12. Dr. Neubrander explained it in a paper like this: Think of your family. Everyone has the same last name, but each individual has a different first name. It is the same with B12. There is CYNCOcobalamine, HYDROXYcobalamine, METHYLcobalamine, and 2 others. The form which is beneficial to autistic kids is methylcobalamine and the others don't provide the same supplementation to the methylation system. Just an FYI for those who didn't know there are different types of B12. Penni > > We are using vitamin research sublingual b-12 and it has a cinnamon- > cherry flavor and Cody doesn't mind it at all and will hold his tongue > up while I put it under there. > > Texas Autism Advocacy www.TexasAutismAdvocacy.org Texas Disability Network Calendar of Events www.TexasAutismAdvocacy.org Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 10, 2005 Report Share Posted November 10, 2005 a, I am going to post here what Dr. Neubrander last stated was his current dosage and delivery schedule for SUBCUTANEOUS methyl B12. I'm not sure if you would give a different amount by mouth (I would think a higher dose) as the absorption would be different from the intestines as opposed to the fatty tissue of the hiney. There is a reason why Dr. Neubrander believes injected is a MUCH superior route for ASD kids...I just can't remember why at the moment! However, depending on a child's age and willingness to comply, shots could be out for some kids. There has just been developed a nasal spray of methyl B12. Folks are talking about it because you avoid the shot aspect and it is absorbed into the tiny blood vessels of the nose, thus avoiding the notoriously messed-up ASD GI tract. However, it is so new I can find no opinion as to efficacy as compared to the subcutaneous route or any parent reports yet of effectiveness. If you or anyone is interested I can find out the price and where it can be ordered from. I believe it is being produced by a compounding pharmacy and would require a prescription. Here's Dr. Neubrander's methyl B12 dosage & delivery schedule: 64.5 mcg/kg once every 3 days to the adipose tissue of the buttocks at an angle severe and horizontal enough to guarantee a " shallow " subcutaneous delivery from a BD 3/10 cc insulin syringe with an 8 mm, 31-gaurge needle (item # 328438 only) and made from a 25 mg/ml methyl-B12 stock solution My daughter was either 50 or 51 pounds when we last calculated dosage and her dose was 1524.135 rounded to 1524 mcg every 3 days. As a side note, we went to daily shots at that dose and have seen great gains. The body excretes excess B12 that it doesn't use and it will not build up within the body. HTH, Penni > > > > We are using vitamin research sublingual b-12 and it has a cinnamon- > > cherry flavor and Cody doesn't mind it at all and will hold his > tongue > > up while I put it under there. > > > > > > > > > > > Texas Autism Advocacy > www.TexasAutismAdvocacy.org > > Texas Disability Network > Calendar of Events > www.TexasAutismAdvocacy.org > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.