Guest guest Posted June 1, 2009 Report Share Posted June 1, 2009 My daughter age 4 has always had an intense reaction to pain! she is not on any protocol. She screamed like all my other babies when she got her immunizations and now shows us if she gets even a little scratch. I know that my neice (she is 15) does NOT react to pain much at all. I guess all our kids are different. Lorene Subject: [DownSyndromeInfoExchange] Changing Minds Protocol/"Normal" Reaction to PainTo: DownSyndromeInfoExchange Date: Monday, June 1, 2009, 3:32 PM My son is 20 months old. We started him on Ginkgo Biloba when he was 13 months old and Prozac when he was 14 months old. We added the Body Bio PC and oil when he was 16 months old. One change I've noticed since starting the protocol is that he now has a "normal" reaction to pain. Allow me to explain what I mean.Here are some examples of our son NOT having a "normal" reaction to pain. When Tristen was born, he was in the NICU for 9 days. During that time my husband and I watched as he was poked and prodded with multiple needles, he had his IV changed 4 times - and he never even flinched, never cried, he acted as though nothing happened. At two weeks old, he had his circumcision done in my OB's office - he didn't cry. Throughout the months, he went for immunization shots and NEVER cried. Before starting the protocol (at 13 months), I took him to the hospital to have a battery of bloodwork drawn. He had 7 vials of blood drawn - his vein stopped giving blood twice and the nurse had to move it all around in his arm trying to find the vein again (made me sick to watch because I have "rolling veins" and this happens to me everytime I have blood drawn - it REALLY hurts). He did not even flinch or attempt to move his arms or legs, never cried, didn't even get upset at being restrained by a second nurse. Both nurses were just amazed that he was so "good." I was just sick inside because I knew that this meant he just wasn't "feeling" things as he should. Throughout his first year I cannot remember a time when he fell over and cried from pain. Even his physical therapist commented many times about him "being tough" because he didn't cry when he bumped his head or fell.Fast forward to today. . . he totally reacts appropriately to pain! He had his blood drawn (just 4 tubes) in April - he screamed, hollered, kicked, turned purple - and it took two people to hold him down while the nurse drew his blood. He had an immunization shot a couple of months ago and threw a fit! He now cries when he gets a bump. The difference we see is night and day. It is as though he had absolutely no sesitivity to pain before starting the protocol and now his pain sensitivity is normal.Has anyone else noticed this in their child?? Just curious. . . .Christy Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 1, 2009 Report Share Posted June 1, 2009 Danny used to have problems with hyposensitivity, especially in his mouth…he used to want to have Peppercorn Ranch dressing on everything he ate..but he was hypersensitive to sounds…he would be hysterical during a thunderstorm, fireworks, couldn’t go to the movies because he couldn’t stand the sound..now he doesn’t like Peppercorn Ranch or any heavily spiced foods..says they are ‘too hot’. Around the same time that that happened, he also became able to tolerate thunderstorms, likes fireworks, and when we went to a movie the other day, he wore his ear protecting headphones at first, then took them off and handed them to me. (he is not on the CM protocol, just NVD, gingko, Omega-3’s)He also was also able to be completely toilet trained at 3 ½….way before he ever started on gingko.. I know that there are many kids w/Ds who don’t take any kind of supplements who are very healthy…Danny was never really healthy until we started him on nvd..I know that there are many parents whose child did not seem to have any good response to nvd, and I believe those parents when they say that it didn’t work for their child….but I also know what parents mean when they say that they notice changes in their kids after starting them on something new….if an infection clears up after putting a child on an antibiotic, the antibiotic is usually given credit for curing the infection…but if changes are noticed after starting a child on a supplement/alternative therapy, many times people are quick to write it off to coincidence or whatever. I truly do think that all of our kids have enough differences that no one approach is going to work exactly the same for every single kid..some kids seem to need something extra in order to reach certain milestones, others don’t. KathyR __ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 1, 2009 Report Share Posted June 1, 2009 you said it all kathyeach kid has only to be compared to themselvesbut we have always to be aware and well informed because some experience mauhelp more than one kidthere is tons of it in this list and that is why i like itso muchamanda was always healthier than my two other daughter without DSand with The cm protocol she became even healthieri am seriously thinking about having The whole family in pc and body bio oili Will start with myself-you do a blood exam TO see what is missing and can compasate with suplements i am sure nutrevene has a similar effect, but we never got to try itPatEnviado de meu iPhoneEm 01/06/2009, às 17:10, "Kathy" escreveu: Danny used to have problems with hyposensitivity, especially in his mouth…he used to want to have Peppercorn Ranch dressing on everything he ate..but he was hypersensitive to sounds…he would be hysterical during a thunderstorm,you fireworks, couldn’t go to the movies because he couldn’t stand the sound..now he doesn’t like Peppercorn Ranch or any heavily spiced foods..says they are ‘too hot’. Around the same time that that happened, he also became able to tolerate thunderstorms, likes fireworks, and when we went to a movie the other day, he wore his ear protecting headphones at first, then took them off and handed them to me. (he is not on the CM protocol, just NVD, gingko, Omega-3’s)He also was also able to be completely toilet trained at 3 ½….way before he ever started on gingko.. I know that there are many kids w/Ds who don’t take any kind of supplements who are very healthy…Danny was never really healthy until we started him on nvd..I know that there are many parents whose child did not seem to have any good response to nvd, and I believe those parents when they say that it didn’t work for their child….but I also  know what parents mean when they say that they notice changes in their kids after starting them on something new….if an infection clears up after putting a child on an antibiotic, the antibiotic is usually given credit for curing the infection…but if changes are noticed after starting a child on a supplement/alternative therapy, many times people are quick to write it off to coincidence or whatever. I truly do think that all of our kids have enough differences that no one approach  is going to work exactly the same for every single kid..some kids seem to need something extra in order to reach certain milestones, others don’t. KathyR   __ Veja quais são os assuntos do momento no Yahoo! + Buscados: Top 10 - Celebridades - Música - Esportes Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 1, 2009 Report Share Posted June 1, 2009 "but I also know what parents mean when they say that they notice changes in their kids after starting them on something new….if an infection clears up after putting a child on an antibiotic, the antibiotic is usually given credit for curing the infection…but if changes are noticed after starting a child on a supplement/alternative therapy, many times people are quick to write it off to coincidence or whatever. I truly do think that all of our kids have enough differences that no one approach is going to work exactly the same for every single kid..some kids seem to need something extra in order to reach certain milestones, others don't." Kathy - Thank you for your comments. I have noticed the same with people "writing off" the positive effects our son is experiencing since starting the protocol. My husband and I are very analytical people. As with any treatment, I don't think that any one thing will work for every0ne. With that said. . . the CMF protocol *IS* working for OUR son. This was just a recent realization looking back at my and the timing of the difference in his pain reaction was quite remarkable to us (looking back over my notes of his appointments). He went from still having NO pain reaction at the appointment where they drew 7 vials of blood-just weeks before starting Prozac- to having a normal pain reaction 1 month after adding Prozac (and continuing to have a normal pain reaction from that time to present). Christy I have not posted any updates here recently about the progress our son is making. >> Danny used to have problems with hyposensitivity, especially in his mouth…he> used to want to have Peppercorn Ranch dressing on everything he ate..but he> was hypersensitive to sounds…he would be hysterical during a thunderstorm,> fireworks, couldn't go to the movies because he couldn't stand the> sound..now he doesn't like Peppercorn Ranch or any heavily spiced> foods..says they are `too hot'. Around the same time that that happened, he> also became able to tolerate thunderstorms, likes fireworks, and when we> went to a movie the other day, he wore his ear protecting headphones at> first, then took them off and handed them to me. (he is not on the CM> protocol, just NVD, gingko, Omega-3's)He also was also able to be completely> toilet trained at 3 ½….way before he ever started on gingko..> > I know that there are many kids w/Ds who don't take any kind of supplements> who are very healthy…Danny was never really healthy until we started him on> nvd..I know that there are many parents whose child did not seem to have any> good response to nvd, and I believe those parents when they say that it> didn't work for their child….but I also know what parents mean when they> say that they notice changes in their kids after starting them on something> new….if an infection clears up after putting a child on an antibiotic, the> antibiotic is usually given credit for curing the infection…but if changes> are noticed after starting a child on a supplement/alternative therapy, many> times people are quick to write it off to coincidence or whatever. I truly> do think that all of our kids have enough differences that no one approach> is going to work exactly the same for every single kid..some kids seem to> need something extra in order to reach certain milestones, others don't.> > KathyR> > > > > > __> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 1, 2009 Report Share Posted June 1, 2009 Dear Christy: We had the same experience with my son (3years 6 months. On Gingko since NOv 2008, Prozac since Feb 2009 and oils etc.). Hardly ever cried before, he had to hit himself really very hard (blood) to cry and he also did not seem to understand when he was yeald at by his brothers etc. Before the protocol, since he was 6 months I used to rub his whole body with different textures (9 times a day) and also rub it with cold (ice) and hot (9 times a day) for months until we saw him react to both, as part of the neurological reorganization program that we followed. He did improve in what he felt, but he still did not react to pain. Now he reacts to physical and emotional pain. The other day as he was going down a step he bent his foot and he said "ouch", in such a casual way, I was impressed, it was a first. Jannette--- Em seg, 1/6/09, kayc0911 escreveu: De: kayc0911 Assunto: [DownSyndromeInfoExchange] Changing Minds Protocol/"Normal" Reaction to PainPara: DownSyndromeInfoExchange Data: Segunda-feira, 1 de Junho de 2009, 16:32 My son is 20 months old. We started him on Ginkgo Biloba when he was 13 months old and Prozac when he was 14 months old. We added the Body Bio PC and oil when he was 16 months old. One change I've noticed since starting the protocol is that he now has a "normal" reaction to pain. Allow me to explain what I mean.Here are some examples of our son NOT having a "normal" reaction to pain. When Tristen was born, he was in the NICU for 9 days. During that time my husband and I watched as he was poked and prodded with multiple needles, he had his IV changed 4 times - and he never even flinched, never cried, he acted as though nothing happened. At two weeks old, he had his circumcision done in my OB's office - he didn't cry. Throughout the months, he went for immunization shots and NEVER cried. Before starting the protocol (at 13 months), I took him to the hospital to have a battery of bloodwork drawn. He had 7 vials of blood drawn - his vein stopped giving blood twice and the nurse had to move it all around in his arm trying to find the vein again (made me sick to watch because I have "rolling veins" and this happens to me everytime I have blood drawn - it REALLY hurts). He did not even flinch or attempt to move his arms or legs, never cried, didn't even get upset at being restrained by a second nurse. Both nurses were just amazed that he was so "good." I was just sick inside because I knew that this meant he just wasn't "feeling" things as he should. Throughout his first year I cannot remember a time when he fell over and cried from pain. Even his physical therapist commented many times about him "being tough" because he didn't cry when he bumped his head or fell.Fast forward to today. . . he totally reacts appropriately to pain! He had his blood drawn (just 4 tubes) in April - he screamed, hollered, kicked, turned purple - and it took two people to hold him down while the nurse drew his blood. He had an immunization shot a couple of months ago and threw a fit! He now cries when he gets a bump. The difference we see is night and day. It is as though he had absolutely no sesitivity to pain before starting the protocol and now his pain sensitivity is normal.Has anyone else noticed this in their child?? Just curious. . . .Christy Veja quais são os assuntos do momento no Yahoo! + Buscados: Top 10 - Celebridades - Música - Esportes Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 1, 2009 Report Share Posted June 1, 2009 Yeah…when I used to tell people that Danny started being healthy for the first time in his life after we started him on nvd, several people told me that he probably just got better on his own…that their child had been sickly until xxx age, then it cleared up..and I believed that it was the case for their child, but Danny had been on a vitamin for his whole life (the doc in the NICU started him on Poly Vi sol when he was 3 months old) but he was always, always sick with something. But within a couple of weeks of being on nvd, he was suddenly healthy. And I KNEW it was because of the nvd, but some other parents acted like I was deluded or making it up. I know that Danny’s speech took a huge upswing within a couple of weeks of starting gingko..again, some naysayers said that it was going to happen anyway, on its own. Since he had been having speech therapy since he was 5 months old with very limited success…gingko was the only new thing we added at the time (he was around 8 ½ yrs old) I *do* give gingko the credit. He went from saying stuff like ‘hamburger, slushy, Mom” to “Mom, I want to go to the library and get a movie and go to Burger King to get a hamburger and a slushy, please.” His articulation was still a problem, but the *ideas* were finally there. He could think of more things to say. KathyR From: DownSyndromeInfoExchange [mailto:DownSyndromeInfoExchange ] On Behalf Of kayc0911 Sent: Monday, June 01, 2009 6:28 PM To: DownSyndromeInfoExchange Subject: [DownSyndromeInfoExchange] Re: Changing Minds Protocol/ " Normal " Reaction to Pain " but I also know what parents mean when they say that they notice changes in their kids after starting them on something new….if an infection clears up after putting a child on an antibiotic, the antibiotic is usually given credit for curing the infection…but if changes are noticed after starting a child on a supplement/alternative therapy, many times people are quick to write it off to coincidence or whatever. I truly do think that all of our kids have enough differences that no one approach is going to work exactly the same for every single kid..some kids seem to need something extra in order to reach certain milestones, others don't. " Kathy - Thank you for your comments. I have noticed the same with people " writing off " the positive effects our son is experiencing since starting the protocol. My husband and I are very analytical people. As with any treatment, I don't think that any one thing will work for every0ne. With that said. . . the CMF protocol *IS* working for OUR son. This was just a recent realization looking back at my and the timing of the difference in his pain reaction was quite remarkable to us (looking back over my notes of his appointments). He went from still having NO pain reaction at the appointment where they drew 7 vials of blood-just weeks before starting Prozac- to having a normal pain reaction 1 month after adding Prozac (and continuing to have a normal pain reaction from that time to present). Christy I have not posted any updates here recently about the progress our son is making. > > Danny used to have problems with hyposensitivity, especially in his mouth…he > used to want to have Peppercorn Ranch dressing on everything he ate..but he > was hypersensitive to sounds…he would be hysterical during a thunderstorm, > fireworks, couldn't go to the movies because he couldn't stand the > sound..now he doesn't like Peppercorn Ranch or any heavily spiced > foods..says they are `too hot'. Around the same time that that happened, he > also became able to tolerate thunderstorms, likes fireworks, and when we > went to a movie the other day, he wore his ear protecting headphones at > first, then took them off and handed them to me. (he is not on the CM > protocol, just NVD, gingko, Omega-3's)He also was also able to be completely > toilet trained at 3 ½….way before he ever started on gingko.. > > I know that there are many kids w/Ds who don't take any kind of supplements > who are very healthy…Danny was never really healthy until we started him on > nvd..I know that there are many parents whose child did not seem to have any > good response to nvd, and I believe those parents when they say that it > didn't work for their child….but I also know what parents mean when they > say that they notice changes in their kids after starting them on something > new….if an infection clears up after putting a child on an antibiotic, the > antibiotic is usually given credit for curing the infection…but if changes > are noticed after starting a child on a supplement/alternative therapy, many > times people are quick to write it off to coincidence or whatever. I truly > do think that all of our kids have enough differences that no one approach > is going to work exactly the same for every single kid..some kids seem to > need something extra in order to reach certain milestones, others don't. > > KathyR > > > > > > __ > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 1, 2009 Report Share Posted June 1, 2009 ….if an infection clears up after putting a child on an antibiotic, the antibiotic is usually given credit for curing the infection…but if changes are noticed after starting a child on a supplement/alternative therapy, many times people are quick to write it off to coincidence or whatever.The only difference is the antibiotics have gone trough rigorous testing and they have proof, there is no proof at the moment that the supplements we are using work or not. Carol in ILMom to , 8 DSMy problem is not how I look. It's how you see me.Join our Down Syndrome information group - http://health. groups.yahoo. com/group/ DownSyndromeInfo Exchange/ http://downsyndromeinfoexchange.blogspot.com/Listen to oldest dd's music http://www.myspace.com/vennamusic ….if an infection clears up after putting a child on an antibiotic, the antibiotic is usually given credit for curing the infection…but if changes are noticed after starting a child on a supplement/alternative therapy, many times people are quick to write it off to coincidence or whatever. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 1, 2009 Report Share Posted June 1, 2009 Yeah, I know…but we can’t totally discount anecdotal evidence. Parents have a pretty good idea whether or not something is working for their child. From: DownSyndromeInfoExchange [mailto:DownSyndromeInfoExchange ] On Behalf Of Carol AnCel Sent: Monday, June 01, 2009 9:44 PM To: DownSyndromeInfoExchange Subject: Re: [DownSyndromeInfoExchange] Changing Minds Protocol/ " Normal " Reaction to Pain ….if an infection clears up after putting a child on an antibiotic, the antibiotic is usually given credit for curing the infection…but if changes are noticed after starting a child on a supplement/alternative therapy, many times people are quick to write it off to coincidence or whatever. The only difference is the antibiotics have gone trough rigorous testing and they have proof, there is no proof at the moment that the supplements we are using work or not. Carol in IL Mom to , 8 DS My problem is not how I look. It's how you see me. Join our Down Syndrome information group - http://health. groups.yahoo. com/group/ DownSyndromeInfo Exchange/ http://downsyndromeinfoexchange.blogspot.com/ Listen to oldest dd's music http://www.myspace.com/vennamusic ….if an infection clears up after putting a child on an antibiotic, the antibiotic is usually given credit for curing the infection…but if changes are noticed after starting a child on a supplement/alternative therapy, many times people are quick to write it off to coincidence or whatever. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 1, 2009 Report Share Posted June 1, 2009 Yes. was very similar. The change also started about the same time. However.. she is NOT on the whole protocol. We do some vitamin therapies Flax seed oil stuff like that. We just started her on Gingko so that was not the factor. I think it may have to do more with an immature nervous system.. that maybe takes a while to " catch up". I am sure the protocol did not hurt that any though. Steph [DownSyndromeInfoExchange] Changing Minds Protocol/"Normal" Reaction to Pain My son is 20 months old. We started him on Ginkgo Biloba when he was 13 months old and Prozac when he was 14 months old. We added the Body Bio PC and oil when he was 16 months old. One change I've noticed since starting the protocol is that he now has a "normal" reaction to pain. Allow me to explain what I mean.Here are some examples of our son NOT having a "normal" reaction to pain. When Tristen was born, he was in the NICU for 9 days. During that time my husband and I watched as he was poked and prodded with multiple needles, he had his IV changed 4 times - and he never even flinched, never cried, he acted as though nothing happened. At two weeks old, he had his circumcision done in my OB's office - he didn't cry. Throughout the months, he went for immunization shots and NEVER cried. Before starting the protocol (at 13 months), I took him to the hospital to have a battery of bloodwork drawn. He had 7 vials of blood drawn - his vein stopped giving blood twice and the nurse had to move it all around in his arm trying to find the vein again (made me sick to watch because I have "rolling veins" and this happens to me everytime I have blood drawn - it REALLY hurts). He did not even flinch or attempt to move his arms or legs, never cried, didn't even get upset at being restrained by a second nurse. Both nurses were just amazed that he was so "good." I was just sick inside because I knew that this meant he just wasn't "feeling" things as he should. Throughout his first year I cannot remember a time when he fell over and cried from pain. Even his physical therapist commented many times about him "being tough" because he didn't cry when he bumped his head or fell.Fast forward to today. . . he totally reacts appropriately to pain! He had his blood drawn (just 4 tubes) in April - he screamed, hollered, kicked, turned purple - and it took two people to hold him down while the nurse drew his blood. He had an immunization shot a couple of months ago and threw a fit! He now cries when he gets a bump. The difference we see is night and day. It is as though he had absolutely no sesitivity to pain before starting the protocol and now his pain sensitivity is normal.Has anyone else noticed this in their child?? Just curious. . . .Christy Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 2, 2009 Report Share Posted June 2, 2009 Pat, Sorry for the confusion! I was commenting on the comparison of supplements to antibiotics. I think it's comparing apples to oranges since anecdotal evidence is not proof and we won't know for sure if this things or not with out the studies. I think anecdotal evidence is a just a place to start the investigation, but not a point on which you could 'hang your hat'. As for prozac- the fuss for me is very simple- I don't like drugs of any kind and do my best to keep her off of them. Prozac has not been tested long term on children with DS. They do have different brain chemistry and so how this is going to affect them is not known. Now add more drugs into the mix and honestly, no one knows what the results or side effects may, or may not be. As I said before, is doing as well, if not better then many on the protocol and I am not willing to experiment on her at this point. If she were having a really difficult time, I am sure I would feel differently. I also noticed on the link that Therese or Marsha had sent, that some of the drugs mimicked physical exercise and a very rich environment... so why not just do the exercise and rich environment, instead of risking the drugs? I do agree we need to be demanding testing and raising money to do so... and that we are doing. How much money have you all raised or donated to the cause? Here in Chicago not ONE DS group is interested in supporting the DSTRF!!!! They are claiming there is not enough money in the 'DS pool' and individuals I guess are very happy to leave their children just as they are with no help to improve their cognition. Now THIS puzzles *me*. Carol in ILMom to , 8 DSMy problem is not how I look. It's how you see me.Join our Down Syndrome information group - http://health. groups.yahoo. com/group/ DownSyndromeInfo Exchange/ http://downsyndromeinfoexchange.blogspot.com/Listen to oldest dd's music http://www.myspace.com/vennamusic Carol, Prozac has gone through rigorous testing for years. It is so well known it is already a generic drug. I really cant see what all the fuss is all about if this is all being made with prescription and strict supervision of doctors. In the past peopleo - including doctors in the DS community were ready and eager to promote drugs like cleregyl and others that later were proved not to work.This is based on drugs that are FDA approved. The only question here is that we dont know what they do together - we are now finding out on our own kids. I think every DS association in the worlsd should have testing the CM protocol as a priority. We are all seeing what it is doing to our kids - very good improvement in quality of life with minor side effects. Isnt that what all the DS groups should be about?I say we should ALL get together and pressure for a clinical trial. If we dont do that, all of us - the ones that are " experimentig " with the protocol and the ones who are only throwing stones at it, we ALL will be co-responsible for any harm it might cause on persosns with DS by watching it happen and being negligent. Lets get more consructive here. Pat De: Carol AnCel Para: DownSyndromeInfoExchange Enviadas: Segunda-feira, 1 de Junho de 2009 21:44:13Assunto: Re: [DownSyndromeInfoExchange] Changing Minds Protocol/ " Normal " Reaction to Pain ….if an infection clears up after putting a child on an antibiotic, the antibiotic is usually given credit for curing the infection…but if changes are noticed after starting a child on a supplement/alternat ive therapy, many times people are quick to write it off to coincidence or whatever.The only difference is the antibiotics have gone trough rigorous testing and they have proof, there is no proof at the moment that the supplements we are using work or not. Carol in ILMom to , 8 DSMy problem is not how I look. It's how you see me.Join our Down Syndrome information group - http://health. groups.yahoo. com/group/ DownSyndromeInfo Exchange/ http://downsyndrome infoexchange. blogspot. com/Listen to oldest dd's music http://www.myspace. com/vennamusic On Mon, Jun 1, 2009 at 4:10 PM, Kathy <Kathy_Rcomcast (DOT) net> wrote: ….if an infection clears up after putting a child on an antibiotic, the antibiotic is usually given credit for curing the infection…but if changes are noticed after starting a child on a supplement/alternat ive therapy, many times people are quick to write it off to coincidence or whatever. Veja quais são os assuntos do momento no Yahoo! + Buscados: Top 10 - Celebridades - Música - Esportes Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 2, 2009 Report Share Posted June 2, 2009 Carol-This statement is true. . .it is true of all supplements we are giving our children (whether they are based on the CMF protocol or others). It is also true of all special diets we put our children on (that is there is no proof that they "work"). As it has been said. . "the proof is in the pudd'in." We have been VERY careful to try and be objective about the CMF protocol. We do NOT want to be giving our son supplements and medicines that are not showing beneficial results. I would just like to add that before we put our son on the CMF protocol, we consulted a Neurodevelopmental Pediatrician (who sees a lot of kids w/Ds). He was VERY skeptical and negative about us starting Tristen on Ginkgo and Prozac, had nothing nice or encouraging to say about it. I found a different doc willing to work with us on the protocol. Four months later, I took Tristen back to see the first Neurodevelopmental Pediatrician (he had been following him since birth, in the NICU). I made sure he read all of Tristen's evaluations during the appointment (PT, OT, DT, ST). All of his evaluations were completed just before his annual review one week before we started him on Ginkgo and one month before we started him on Prozac. I had the ND Pedi compare those evaluations to his more recent evaluations (quarterly update). To make a very long story short, let me summarize his reaction to the difference in Tristen by his comment (my paraphrase of his comment), "I'm cautiously impressed - kids with Ds do not make this much progress. This may just be a 'spurt' in skills after which he will plateau. Time will tell if this is just a 'spurt' in developmental milestones or if it continues then it may be something we can attribute to the protocol. I am very interested in taking a look at him again in another year - let's see where he is then." So no, I do not have concrete proof that the protocol is working for my son - but I feel I do have a little more proof that just my anecdotal stories. I have his evaluations to compare showing he is making GREAT progress. I have his therapists' comments about how incredible he is doing (they do not know he is on the protocol). As the ND Pedi said, time will tell. . . and our son has experienced NO negative side effects after being on Ginkgo and Prozac for six months now (he was 14 months when we started Prozac). Christy > > > ….if an infection clears up after putting a child on an antibiotic, the> > antibiotic is usually given credit for curing the infection…but if changes> > are noticed after starting a child on a supplement/alternative therapy, many> > times people are quick to write it off to coincidence or whatever.> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 2, 2009 Report Share Posted June 2, 2009 "How much money have you all raised or donated to the cause?" Carol - I find you comment above tasteless and sarcastic and not in the spirit or the purpose of this list, as I understand it. Yes, it is commendable that you organize a golf event to raise money. You also mentioned previously that you were going to make a donation when your husband got his Christmas bonus. You need to keep in mind that not everyone is in your fortunate position and that does NOT minimize their contribution to the cause. I would like to quote some scripture from Luke 21: 1-4, "And he looked up, and saw the rich men casting their gifts into the treasury. And he saw also a certain poor widow casting in thither two mites. And he said, Of a truth I say unto you, that this poor widow hath cast in more than they all: For all these have of their abundance cast in unto the offerings of God: but she of her penury hath cast in all the living that she had." I would like to add 6:1-4 where Jesus said, "Take heed that ye do not your alms before men, to be seen of them: otherwise ye have no reward of your Father which is in heaven. Therefore when thou doest thine alms, do not sound a trumet before thee, as the hypocrites do in the synagogues and in the streets, that they may have glory of men. Verily I say unto you, They have their reward. But when thou doest alms, let not thy left hand know what thy right hand doeth: That thine alms may be in secret: and thy Father which seeth in secret himself shall reward thee openly. I quote that to say. . .just because one does not post openly on a listserv about what money he/she raises or donates does not mean that that person is not raising money or donating. Christy > >> >> ….if an infection clears up after putting a child on an antibiotic, the> >> antibiotic is usually given credit for curing the infection…but if changes> >> are noticed after starting a child on a supplement/alternat ive therapy,> >> many times people are quick to write it off to coincidence or whatever.> >> >> >> > ------------------------------> > Veja quais são os assuntos do momento no Yahoo! + Buscados: Top 10<http://br.rd.yahoo.com/mail/taglines/mail/*http://br.maisbuscados.yahoo.com/>-> > Celebridades<http://br.rd.yahoo.com/mail/taglines/mail/*http://br.maisbuscados.yahoo.com/celebridades/>-> > Música<http://br.rd.yahoo.com/mail/taglines/mail/*http://br.maisbuscados.yahoo.com/m%C3%BAsica/>-> > Esportes<http://br.rd.yahoo.com/mail/taglines/mail/*http://br.maisbuscados.yahoo.com/esportes/>> > > >> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 2, 2009 Report Share Posted June 2, 2009 Again, sorry for the confusion. I agree that the proof is in the pudding. I myself use things not proven, but this is not going to be accepted by many nor can any of these protocols be used for the DS community at large with out the studies or scientific proof that it works so that Doctors can prescribe it confidently, isn't that we ultimately want? For a proven treatment that would be available to ALL? No matter your results with the protocol, it will never enough to convince *me* to use it on my child with out the studies, and I know I am not the only one. I am much more willing to try things that don't have any side effects, but I do draw the line with using untested/unproven drugs/combinations with out long term studies, when I can get the same results with out the risks. I certainly do not question that you all are getting great results! I too have seen great results with the ginkgo/diet/oils/exercise/stimulation and believe she would not have made the progress she has with those things! We are in the same book, just different page. :-) Carol in ILMom to , 8 DSMy problem is not how I look. It's how you see me.Join our Down Syndrome information group - http://health. groups.yahoo. com/group/ DownSyndromeInfo Exchange/ http://downsyndromeinfoexchange.blogspot.com/Listen to oldest dd's music http://www.myspace.com/vennamusic Carol-This statement is true. . .it is true of all supplements we are giving our children (whether they are based on the CMF protocol or others). It is also true of all special diets we put our children on (that is there is no proof that they " work " ). As it has been said. . " the proof is in the pudd'in. " We have been VERY careful to try and be objective about the CMF protocol. We do NOT want to be giving our son supplements and medicines that are not showing beneficial results. I would just like to add that before we put our son on the CMF protocol, we consulted a Neurodevelopmental Pediatrician (who sees a lot of kids w/Ds). He was VERY skeptical and negative about us starting Tristen on Ginkgo and Prozac, had nothing nice or encouraging to say about it. I found a different doc willing to work with us on the protocol. Four months later, I took Tristen back to see the first Neurodevelopmental Pediatrician (he had been following him since birth, in the NICU). I made sure he read all of Tristen's evaluations during the appointment (PT, OT, DT, ST). All of his evaluations were completed just before his annual review one week before we started him on Ginkgo and one month before we started him on Prozac. I had the ND Pedi compare those evaluations to his more recent evaluations (quarterly update). To make a very long story short, let me summarize his reaction to the difference in Tristen by his comment (my paraphrase of his comment), " I'm cautiously impressed - kids with Ds do not make this much progress. This may just be a 'spurt' in skills after which he will plateau. Time will tell if this is just a 'spurt' in developmental milestones or if it continues then it may be something we can attribute to the protocol. I am very interested in taking a look at him again in another year - let's see where he is then. " So no, I do not have concrete proof that the protocol is working for my son - but I feel I do have a little more proof that just my anecdotal stories. I have his evaluations to compare showing he is making GREAT progress. I have his therapists' comments about how incredible he is doing (they do not know he is on the protocol). As the ND Pedi said, time will tell. . . and our son has experienced NO negative side effects after being on Ginkgo and Prozac for six months now (he was 14 months when we started Prozac). Christy > > > ….if an infection clears up after putting a child on an antibiotic, the> > antibiotic is usually given credit for curing the infection…but if changes> > are noticed after starting a child on a supplement/alternative therapy, many > > times people are quick to write it off to coincidence or whatever.> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 2, 2009 Report Share Posted June 2, 2009 To be honest...I really do not think one could coorelate this change to the CMP. I think your child just has gotten older and more aware. Most kids react to the blood draws IV's before the actual stick and really have no difference in reaction when the needle stick is made. Nate is pretty good with them and he has gotten worse as he aged. Kids also pick up on the parent response. I think Nate is so good because I am a nurse and I know it doesn't hurt much, he reacts more anticipatory. Most infants do not have much response at all to the needle sticks, etc. I have watched many circs and these kids react to the cold not the circ itself. Nate had his at 2 months of age and was great with it wtihout sedation or anything other than tylenol.....a little older and he would have had problems according to my OB he was at the border age and most kids will tolerate it done till about 2 1/2 months of age. I honestly do not believe the CMF is making the difference in his response. I think you are searching and putting your child too much under a microscope looking for some changes and some are just going to be normal developmental changes. I dislike that those who are on this protocal are making statements that they cannot see why others are not trying their kids on this protocol. Well both my husband and I have an extensive medical background and we just don't " buy " in to it just yet. Not that we won't in the future but medication have side effects and the science is just not there yet to support this yet especially with young child. The first thing in medical shcool you learn is to do not harm. I look at the things children who are around the same age as Nate who are on the potocol and he is doing the same stuff if not more advanced. So you can see why I am not on board yet. I say yet, because I am not opposed to it just not yet for my child. Sherry > > My son is 20 months old. We started him on Ginkgo Biloba when he was 13 > months old and Prozac when he was 14 months old. We added the Body Bio > PC and oil when he was 16 months old. One change I've noticed since > starting the protocol is that he now has a " normal " reaction to pain. > Allow me to explain what I mean. > > Here are some examples of our son NOT having a " normal " reaction to > pain. When Tristen was born, he was in the NICU for 9 days. During that > time my husband and I watched as he was poked and prodded with multiple > needles, he had his IV changed 4 times - and he never even flinched, > never cried, he acted as though nothing happened. At two weeks old, he > had his circumcision done in my OB's office - he didn't cry. Throughout > the months, he went for immunization shots and NEVER cried. Before > starting the protocol (at 13 months), I took him to the hospital to have > a battery of bloodwork drawn. He had 7 vials of blood drawn - his vein > stopped giving blood twice and the nurse had to move it all around in > his arm trying to find the vein again (made me sick to watch because I > have " rolling veins " and this happens to me everytime I have blood drawn > - it REALLY hurts). He did not even flinch or attempt to move his arms > or legs, never cried, didn't even get upset at being restrained by a > second nurse. Both nurses were just amazed that he was so " good. " I was > just sick inside because I knew that this meant he just wasn't " feeling " > things as he should. Throughout his first year I cannot remember a time > when he fell over and cried from pain. Even his physical therapist > commented many times about him " being tough " because he didn't cry when > he bumped his head or fell. > > Fast forward to today. . . he totally reacts appropriately to pain! He > had his blood drawn (just 4 tubes) in April - he screamed, hollered, > kicked, turned purple - and it took two people to hold him down while > the nurse drew his blood. He had an immunization shot a couple of months > ago and threw a fit! He now cries when he gets a bump. The difference we > see is night and day. It is as though he had absolutely no sesitivity to > pain before starting the protocol and now his pain sensitivity is > normal. > > Has anyone else noticed this in their child?? Just curious. . . . > > Christy > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 2, 2009 Report Share Posted June 2, 2009 Sherry- I have to respectfully disagree with your comment, "I honestly do not believe the CMF is making the difference in his response. I think you are searching and putting your child too much under a microscope looking for some changes and some are just going to be normal developmental changes." We have been very careful about our analysis of his progress. We are not basing his progress solely on our stories and observations. We are basing our statements on his progress on his evaluations by his PT, OT, ST, & DT. They are unbiased opinions (they do not know he is on the protocol), and they are showing that he is NOT falling further behind, in fact in some areas he is not only making month for month progress (3 months progress in 3 months time), he is *closing the gap* (making 6.3 months progress in 3 months time in one area). " I dislike that those who are on this protocal are making statements that they cannot see why others are not trying their kids on this protocol. " I totally understand your comment above. I have never made such a statement. In fact, I've said that there are certain unknown risks that potentially could be involved and if you, as a parent, cannot live with those possibel consequences then this protocol is not for you or your family. As for us, our son is 20 months old and has been on Ginkgo, Prozac, and the Body Bio PC and oils for 6 months. He has experienced no negative side effects to date. Christy > >> > My son is 20 months old. We started him on Ginkgo Biloba when he was 13> > months old and Prozac when he was 14 months old. We added the Body Bio> > PC and oil when he was 16 months old. One change I've noticed since> > starting the protocol is that he now has a "normal" reaction to pain.> > Allow me to explain what I mean.> > > > Here are some examples of our son NOT having a "normal" reaction to> > pain. When Tristen was born, he was in the NICU for 9 days. During that> > time my husband and I watched as he was poked and prodded with multiple> > needles, he had his IV changed 4 times - and he never even flinched,> > never cried, he acted as though nothing happened. At two weeks old, he> > had his circumcision done in my OB's office - he didn't cry. Throughout> > the months, he went for immunization shots and NEVER cried. Before> > starting the protocol (at 13 months), I took him to the hospital to have> > a battery of bloodwork drawn. He had 7 vials of blood drawn - his vein> > stopped giving blood twice and the nurse had to move it all around in> > his arm trying to find the vein again (made me sick to watch because I> > have "rolling veins" and this happens to me everytime I have blood drawn> > - it REALLY hurts). He did not even flinch or attempt to move his arms> > or legs, never cried, didn't even get upset at being restrained by a> > second nurse. Both nurses were just amazed that he was so "good." I was> > just sick inside because I knew that this meant he just wasn't "feeling"> > things as he should. Throughout his first year I cannot remember a time> > when he fell over and cried from pain. Even his physical therapist> > commented many times about him "being tough" because he didn't cry when> > he bumped his head or fell.> > > > Fast forward to today. . . he totally reacts appropriately to pain! He> > had his blood drawn (just 4 tubes) in April - he screamed, hollered,> > kicked, turned purple - and it took two people to hold him down while> > the nurse drew his blood. He had an immunization shot a couple of months> > ago and threw a fit! He now cries when he gets a bump. The difference we> > see is night and day. It is as though he had absolutely no sesitivity to> > pain before starting the protocol and now his pain sensitivity is> > normal.> > > > Has anyone else noticed this in their child?? Just curious. . . .> > > > Christy> >> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 2, 2009 Report Share Posted June 2, 2009 This is a very interesting discussion. We've gone around and around before. But everytime I read, "we would do it if we had a proven study". Again, I ask you what type of study would satisfy you? We have 30 years of giving prozac to people- that's the best you are going to get. There is 50 years with ritalin (focalin). Most of the practice of medicine comes from observation not studies. So observations made are absolutely legitimate. You stated: 'the first thing you learn in medical school is do no harm' -this is true. However, all the research indicates that there is severe decline in DS as they age. This is the stark reality coming. And also, I don't think getting to the 2nd grade is enough. I want more for Neal. (and he wasn't going to get to 2nd grade easily). Reality says there are not many with DS that do very well as adults. The paragraph describing DS in medical books is true unless something else is done. We have had a couple of generations that had early intervention, it is not enough. Why would our children turn out any differently? Subject: [DownSyndromeInfoExchange] Re: Changing Minds Protocol/"Normal" Reaction to PainTo: DownSyndromeInfoExchange Date: Tuesday, June 2, 2009, 2:13 PM To be honest...I really do not think one could coorelate this change to the CMP. I think your child just has gotten older and more aware. Most kids react to the blood draws IV's before the actual stick and really have no difference in reaction when the needle stick is made. Nate is pretty good with them and he has gotten worse as he aged. Kids also pick up on the parent response. I think Nate is so good because I am a nurse and I know it doesn't hurt much, he reacts more anticipatory. Most infants do not have much response at all to the needle sticks, etc. I have watched many circs and these kids react to the cold not the circ itself. Nate had his at 2 months of age and was great with it wtihout sedation or anything other than tylenol...... a little older and he would have had problems according to my OB he was at the border age and most kids will tolerate it done till about 2 1/2 months of age. I honestly do not believe the CMF is making the difference in his response. I think you are searching and putting your child too much under a microscope looking for some changes and some are just going to be normal developmental changes.I dislike that those who are on this protocal are making statements that they cannot see why others are not trying their kids on this protocol. Well both my husband and I have an extensive medical background and we just don't "buy" in to it just yet. Not that we won't in the future but medication have side effects and the science is just not there yet to support this yet especially with young child. The first thing in medical shcool you learn is to do not harm. I look at the things children who are around the same age as Nate who are on the potocol and he is doing the same stuff if not more advanced. So you can see why I am not on board yet. I say yet, because I am not opposed to it just not yet for my child.Sherry>> My son is 20 months old. We started him on Ginkgo Biloba when he was 13> months old and Prozac when he was 14 months old. We added the Body Bio> PC and oil when he was 16 months old. One change I've noticed since> starting the protocol is that he now has a "normal" reaction to pain..> Allow me to explain what I mean.> > Here are some examples of our son NOT having a "normal" reaction to> pain. When Tristen was born, he was in the NICU for 9 days. During that> time my husband and I watched as he was poked and prodded with multiple> needles, he had his IV changed 4 times - and he never even flinched,> never cried, he acted as though nothing happened. At two weeks old, he> had his circumcision done in my OB's office - he didn't cry. Throughout> the months, he went for immunization shots and NEVER cried. Before> starting the protocol (at 13 months), I took him to the hospital to have> a battery of bloodwork drawn. He had 7 vials of blood drawn - his vein> stopped giving blood twice and the nurse had to move it all around in> his arm trying to find the vein again (made me sick to watch because I> have "rolling veins" and this happens to me everytime I have blood drawn> - it REALLY hurts). He did not even flinch or attempt to move his arms> or legs, never cried, didn't even get upset at being restrained by a> second nurse. Both nurses were just amazed that he was so "good." I was> just sick inside because I knew that this meant he just wasn't "feeling"> things as he should. Throughout his first year I cannot remember a time> when he fell over and cried from pain. Even his physical therapist> commented many times about him "being tough" because he didn't cry when> he bumped his head or fell.> > Fast forward to today. . . he totally reacts appropriately to pain! He> had his blood drawn (just 4 tubes) in April - he screamed, hollered,> kicked, turned purple - and it took two people to hold him down while> the nurse drew his blood. He had an immunization shot a couple of months> ago and threw a fit! He now cries when he gets a bump. The difference we> see is night and day. It is as though he had absolutely no sesitivity to> pain before starting the protocol and now his pain sensitivity is> normal.> > Has anyone else noticed this in their child?? Just curious. . . ..> > Christy> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 2, 2009 Report Share Posted June 2, 2009 BTW, I just wanted to add that I did not make the realization of Tristen's pain reaction until this week. Yes, I had noticed that he now reacted to pain, but it wasn't until I read a posting by Miriam Kauk at http://einstein-syndrome.com/ where she talked about Deep Pressure techniques that made me look back at my notes and compare them to my calendar of appointments. No, we did not do Deep Pressure with Tristen (this was the first I'd heard of it). However, what got me thinking after reading it was that I remembered back to when Tristen had NO reaction to pain. Reading the article made me look back at my notes of his appointments and accomplishments (I have kept a diary of sorts since he was born) and compare those notes to my appointment calendar. It was then that I discovered the ironic *TIMING* of the change in his ability to react to pain. He still had NO pain reaction just before starting Ginkgo and then we added Prozac. Just one month later, I made notes of where he started reacting to pain - bumps, bruises, shots, etc (whereas my previous notes over the YEAR expressed concern about him having NO reaction to pain when he should have). This was just a realization that I "happened" upon - I would have never looked for it or expected it otherwise. Christy > > >> > > My son is 20 months old. We started him on Ginkgo Biloba when he was> 13> > > months old and Prozac when he was 14 months old. We added the Body> Bio> > > PC and oil when he was 16 months old. One change I've noticed since> > > starting the protocol is that he now has a "normal" reaction to> pain.> > > Allow me to explain what I mean.> > >> > > Here are some examples of our son NOT having a "normal" reaction to> > > pain. When Tristen was born, he was in the NICU for 9 days. During> that> > > time my husband and I watched as he was poked and prodded with> multiple> > > needles, he had his IV changed 4 times - and he never even flinched,> > > never cried, he acted as though nothing happened. At two weeks old,> he> > > had his circumcision done in my OB's office - he didn't cry.> Throughout> > > the months, he went for immunization shots and NEVER cried. Before> > > starting the protocol (at 13 months), I took him to the hospital to> have> > > a battery of bloodwork drawn. He had 7 vials of blood drawn - his> vein> > > stopped giving blood twice and the nurse had to move it all around> in> > > his arm trying to find the vein again (made me sick to watch because> I> > > have "rolling veins" and this happens to me everytime I have blood> drawn> > > - it REALLY hurts). He did not even flinch or attempt to move his> arms> > > or legs, never cried, didn't even get upset at being restrained by a> > > second nurse. Both nurses were just amazed that he was so "good." I> was> > > just sick inside because I knew that this meant he just wasn't> "feeling"> > > things as he should. Throughout his first year I cannot remember a> time> > > when he fell over and cried from pain. Even his physical therapist> > > commented many times about him "being tough" because he didn't cry> when> > > he bumped his head or fell.> > >> > > Fast forward to today. . . he totally reacts appropriately to pain!> He> > > had his blood drawn (just 4 tubes) in April - he screamed, hollered,> > > kicked, turned purple - and it took two people to hold him down> while> > > the nurse drew his blood. He had an immunization shot a couple of> months> > > ago and threw a fit! He now cries when he gets a bump. The> difference we> > > see is night and day. It is as though he had absolutely no> sesitivity to> > > pain before starting the protocol and now his pain sensitivity is> > > normal.> > >> > > Has anyone else noticed this in their child?? Just curious. . . .> > >> > > Christy> > >> >> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 2, 2009 Report Share Posted June 2, 2009 Have these drugs been studied in people w/Ds? What are the long term effects (minimum 2-5 yrs) on the brains of children who were started on Prozac as infants or toddlers? Has the combination of Prozac and Focalin been studied in people with Ds? What are the long term effects (minimum 2-5 yrs) on the brain of the combination? How long do the positive effects last after the drugs are discontinued? Or is the protocol something that will have to be taken for the rest of the person’s life? I want more for Danny, too…I would love for him to be able to progress more quickly than he does right now. BUT..I do worry about the possibility of long term negative effects of the drugs..especially of the combination of drugs in the protocol. And since he is doing ok right now, I just am not willing to use the protocol until it has been proven that the combination of drugs does not have harmful long term effects in people w/Ds. Instead of debating back and forth on this to try to convince the other ‘side’, that what we are doing (or not doing) is the way to go, it would probably be best to for us all to contribute what we can afford to research-because until the studies are done, even excellent results will be seen as anecdotal by the medical/Ds community at large, and you will continue to meet with resistance on the part of the powers that be. Parents need to be able to make their decisions based on what they believe is right and safe for their own kids…not because they are being pressured to jump on the bandwagon before they feel comfortable using the protocol. There was a lot of that with NVD, and it didn’t turn out well..fractured the Ds community, when it really didn’t need to, imo. And I am not saying that is what you are trying to do..you are understandably excited about the results you are seeing..but please understand that some parents are just not ‘pioneers’…and there is nothing wrong with that, imo. KathyR From: DownSyndromeInfoExchange [mailto:DownSyndromeInfoExchange ] On Behalf Of Cody Sent: Tuesday, June 02, 2009 12:40 PM To: DownSyndromeInfoExchange Subject: Re: [DownSyndromeInfoExchange] Re: Changing Minds Protocol/ " Normal " Reaction to Pain This is a very interesting discussion. We've gone around and around before. But everytime I read, " we would do it if we had a proven study " . Again, I ask you what type of study would satisfy you? We have 30 years of giving prozac to people- that's the best you are going to get. There is 50 years with ritalin (focalin). Most of the practice of medicine comes from observation not studies. So observations made are absolutely legitimate. You stated: 'the first thing you learn in medical school is do no harm' -this is true. However, all the research indicates that there is severe decline in DS as they age. This is the stark reality coming. And also, I don't think getting to the 2nd grade is enough. I want more for Neal. (and he wasn't going to get to 2nd grade easily). Reality says there are not many with DS that do very well as adults. The paragraph describing DS in medical books is true unless something else is done. We have had a couple of generations that had early intervention, it is not enough. Why would our children turn out any differently? Subject: [DownSyndromeInfoExchange] Re: Changing Minds Protocol/ " Normal " Reaction to Pain To: DownSyndromeInfoExchange Date: Tuesday, June 2, 2009, 2:13 PM To be honest...I really do not think one could coorelate this change to the CMP. I think your child just has gotten older and more aware. Most kids react to the blood draws IV's before the actual stick and really have no difference in reaction when the needle stick is made. Nate is pretty good with them and he has gotten worse as he aged. Kids also pick up on the parent response. I think Nate is so good because I am a nurse and I know it doesn't hurt much, he reacts more anticipatory. Most infants do not have much response at all to the needle sticks, etc. I have watched many circs and these kids react to the cold not the circ itself. Nate had his at 2 months of age and was great with it wtihout sedation or anything other than tylenol...... a little older and he would have had problems according to my OB he was at the border age and most kids will tolerate it done till about 2 1/2 months of age. I honestly do not believe the CMF is making the difference in his response. I think you are searching and putting your child too much under a microscope looking for some changes and some are just going to be normal developmental changes. I dislike that those who are on this protocal are making statements that they cannot see why others are not trying their kids on this protocol. Well both my husband and I have an extensive medical background and we just don't " buy " in to it just yet. Not that we won't in the future but medication have side effects and the science is just not there yet to support this yet especially with young child. The first thing in medical shcool you learn is to do not harm. I look at the things children who are around the same age as Nate who are on the potocol and he is doing the same stuff if not more advanced. So you can see why I am not on board yet. I say yet, because I am not opposed to it just not yet for my child. Sherry > > My son is 20 months old. We started him on Ginkgo Biloba when he was 13 > months old and Prozac when he was 14 months old. We added the Body Bio > PC and oil when he was 16 months old. One change I've noticed since > starting the protocol is that he now has a " normal " reaction to pain.. > Allow me to explain what I mean. > > Here are some examples of our son NOT having a " normal " reaction to > pain. When Tristen was born, he was in the NICU for 9 days. During that > time my husband and I watched as he was poked and prodded with multiple > needles, he had his IV changed 4 times - and he never even flinched, > never cried, he acted as though nothing happened. At two weeks old, he > had his circumcision done in my OB's office - he didn't cry. Throughout > the months, he went for immunization shots and NEVER cried. Before > starting the protocol (at 13 months), I took him to the hospital to have > a battery of bloodwork drawn. He had 7 vials of blood drawn - his vein > stopped giving blood twice and the nurse had to move it all around in > his arm trying to find the vein again (made me sick to watch because I > have " rolling veins " and this happens to me everytime I have blood drawn > - it REALLY hurts). He did not even flinch or attempt to move his arms > or legs, never cried, didn't even get upset at being restrained by a > second nurse. Both nurses were just amazed that he was so " good. " I was > just sick inside because I knew that this meant he just wasn't " feeling " > things as he should. Throughout his first year I cannot remember a time > when he fell over and cried from pain. Even his physical therapist > commented many times about him " being tough " because he didn't cry when > he bumped his head or fell. > > Fast forward to today. . . he totally reacts appropriately to pain! He > had his blood drawn (just 4 tubes) in April - he screamed, hollered, > kicked, turned purple - and it took two people to hold him down while > the nurse drew his blood. He had an immunization shot a couple of months > ago and threw a fit! He now cries when he gets a bump. The difference we > see is night and day. It is as though he had absolutely no sesitivity to > pain before starting the protocol and now his pain sensitivity is > normal. > > Has anyone else noticed this in their child?? Just curious. . . .. > > Christy > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 2, 2009 Report Share Posted June 2, 2009 Thank you Kathy, I totally agree, though I don't necessarily view parents willing to experiment with their children with out the benefit of long term studies, as 'pioneers'. ;-)Also, there is NO proof at all that the CMP will alter the decline in teens and adults, and not every single person with DS suffers a decline as they age... that from Dr. Chicoine here in Chicago who HAS followed 1000's. Could be the kids on the protocol show declines at the same rate as the un-treated population. The kids using it now, aren't any where near that age as it is. I really disdain scare tactics and insults , whenever I hear them, I typically firm up my orignial assesments. And thank you Sherry for chiming in as well. Carol in ILMom to , 8 DS My problem is not how I look. It's how you see me.Join our Down Syndrome information group - http://health. groups.yahoo. com/group/ DownSyndromeInfo Exchange/http://downsyndromeinfoexchange.blogspot.com/ Listen to oldest dd's music http://www.myspace.com/vennamusic Have these drugs been studied in people w/Ds? What are the long term effects (minimum 2-5 yrs) on the brains of children who were started on Prozac as infants or toddlers? Has the combination of Prozac and Focalin been studied in people with Ds? What are the long term effects (minimum 2-5 yrs) on the brain of the combination? How long do the positive effects last after the drugs are discontinued? Or is the protocol something that will have to be taken for the rest of the person’s life? I want more for Danny, too…I would love for him to be able to progress more quickly than he does right now. BUT..I do worry about the possibility of long term negative effects of the drugs..especially of the combination of drugs in the protocol. And since he is doing ok right now, I just am not willing to use the protocol until it has been proven that the combination of drugs does not have harmful long term effects in people w/Ds. Instead of debating back and forth on this to try to convince the other ‘side’, that what we are doing (or not doing) is the way to go, it would probably be best to for us all to contribute what we can afford to research-because until the studies are done, even excellent results will be seen as anecdotal by the medical/Ds community at large, and you will continue to meet with resistance on the part of the powers that be. Parents need to be able to make their decisions based on what they believe is right and safe for their own kids…not because they are being pressured to jump on the bandwagon before they feel comfortable using the protocol. There was a lot of that with NVD, and it didn’t turn out well..fractured the Ds community, when it really didn’t need to, imo. And I am not saying that is what you are trying to do..you are understandably excited about the results you are seeing..but please understand that some parents are just not ‘pioneers’…and there is nothing wrong with that, imo. KathyR From: DownSyndromeInfoExchange [mailto:DownSyndromeInfoExchange ] On Behalf Of Cody Sent: Tuesday, June 02, 2009 12:40 PM To: DownSyndromeInfoExchange Subject: Re: [DownSyndromeInfoExchange] Re: Changing Minds Protocol/ " Normal " Reaction to Pain This is a very interesting discussion. We've gone around and around before. But everytime I read, " we would do it if we had a proven study " . Again, I ask you what type of study would satisfy you? We have 30 years of giving prozac to people- that's the best you are going to get. There is 50 years with ritalin (focalin). Most of the practice of medicine comes from observation not studies. So observations made are absolutely legitimate. You stated: 'the first thing you learn in medical school is do no harm' -this is true. However, all the research indicates that there is severe decline in DS as they age. This is the stark reality coming. And also, I don't think getting to the 2nd grade is enough. I want more for Neal. (and he wasn't going to get to 2nd grade easily). Reality says there are not many with DS that do very well as adults. The paragraph describing DS in medical books is true unless something else is done. We have had a couple of generations that had early intervention, it is not enough. Why would our children turn out any differently? Subject: [DownSyndromeInfoExchange] Re: Changing Minds Protocol/ " Normal " Reaction to Pain To: DownSyndromeInfoExchange Date: Tuesday, June 2, 2009, 2:13 PM To be honest...I really do not think one could coorelate this change to the CMP. I think your child just has gotten older and more aware. Most kids react to the blood draws IV's before the actual stick and really have no difference in reaction when the needle stick is made. Nate is pretty good with them and he has gotten worse as he aged. Kids also pick up on the parent response. I think Nate is so good because I am a nurse and I know it doesn't hurt much, he reacts more anticipatory. Most infants do not have much response at all to the needle sticks, etc. I have watched many circs and these kids react to the cold not the circ itself. Nate had his at 2 months of age and was great with it wtihout sedation or anything other than tylenol...... a little older and he would have had problems according to my OB he was at the border age and most kids will tolerate it done till about 2 1/2 months of age. I honestly do not believe the CMF is making the difference in his response. I think you are searching and putting your child too much under a microscope looking for some changes and some are just going to be normal developmental changes. I dislike that those who are on this protocal are making statements that they cannot see why others are not trying their kids on this protocol. Well both my husband and I have an extensive medical background and we just don't " buy " in to it just yet. Not that we won't in the future but medication have side effects and the science is just not there yet to support this yet especially with young child. The first thing in medical shcool you learn is to do not harm. I look at the things children who are around the same age as Nate who are on the potocol and he is doing the same stuff if not more advanced. So you can see why I am not on board yet. I say yet, because I am not opposed to it just not yet for my child. Sherry > > My son is 20 months old. We started him on Ginkgo Biloba when he was 13 > months old and Prozac when he was 14 months old. We added the Body Bio > PC and oil when he was 16 months old. One change I've noticed since > starting the protocol is that he now has a " normal " reaction to pain.. > Allow me to explain what I mean. > > Here are some examples of our son NOT having a " normal " reaction to > pain. When Tristen was born, he was in the NICU for 9 days. During that > time my husband and I watched as he was poked and prodded with multiple > needles, he had his IV changed 4 times - and he never even flinched, > never cried, he acted as though nothing happened. At two weeks old, he > had his circumcision done in my OB's office - he didn't cry. Throughout > the months, he went for immunization shots and NEVER cried. Before > starting the protocol (at 13 months), I took him to the hospital to have > a battery of bloodwork drawn. He had 7 vials of blood drawn - his vein > stopped giving blood twice and the nurse had to move it all around in > his arm trying to find the vein again (made me sick to watch because I > have " rolling veins " and this happens to me everytime I have blood drawn > - it REALLY hurts). He did not even flinch or attempt to move his arms > or legs, never cried, didn't even get upset at being restrained by a > second nurse. Both nurses were just amazed that he was so " good. " I was > just sick inside because I knew that this meant he just wasn't " feeling " > things as he should. Throughout his first year I cannot remember a time > when he fell over and cried from pain. Even his physical therapist > commented many times about him " being tough " because he didn't cry when > he bumped his head or fell. > > Fast forward to today. . . he totally reacts appropriately to pain! He > had his blood drawn (just 4 tubes) in April - he screamed, hollered, > kicked, turned purple - and it took two people to hold him down while > the nurse drew his blood. He had an immunization shot a couple of months > ago and threw a fit! He now cries when he gets a bump. The difference we > see is night and day. It is as though he had absolutely no sesitivity to > pain before starting the protocol and now his pain sensitivity is > normal. > > Has anyone else noticed this in their child?? Just curious. . . .. > > Christy > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 2, 2009 Report Share Posted June 2, 2009 This is as ever an interesting discussion. It does go back and forth a bit with the same arguments but good to hear all sides. Its encouraging to hear how so many have hit upon things that work for their kids and even more encouraging that the search is still going on for many other things .We never do give up .:-) I appreciate all the pioneers out there who took the leap , Dixie Dr L , Victor and Standford Sydney and everyone in between. ( by that I mean all you wonderful people on lists everywhere who taught me a lot ) I am thankful so much is out there. I wish there was more and am always on the look out for more. There is a quote out there and I don't know who its by but it goes something like , "I can only see so far because I am standing on the shoulders of giants". That's probably not right but you get my meaning I hope. I feel a bit like that person who can see so far , I am standing on the shoulders of all the giants who have done so much work to date. I am not so lost and do not feel so helpless and there are decisions and options now that were not around 5 10 15 years ago. We are just so spoiled for choice and don't even know it LOL Good huh ???? Sam was making slow progress on just his vits , I did not expect miracles . I always though Vits like NVD were for the long haul and to try to save Sam from the same fate as my mum. He is healthier on them and that is a fact too. Sam has been on Gingko almost 3 years and this has made the biggest difference of all. If I have to take him out of it you can see the difference. He was off it for 3 weeks once and he was just dull and not aware of anything and had completely lost his spark and comprehension. Despite the difficulties I have getting gingko Sam will not be ever taken off of it . I introduced P C from the CMP a few weeks ago and again now we see another HUGE difference in Sam. His speech has come yet again and its there's just so much more of it. He has also developed a worrying addiction to that horrible song Poker Face by Lady Ga ga . His sister put on on his iPod and now he spends his whole time singing " cant read my poker face " Worrying side effect lol but I digress. I am going to introduce Cur cumin next , its the nearest thing I can get to Prozac here . As we get older we do get a bit more likely to err on the side of caution. I know I do. At the same time I want Sam to continue to make progress and I don't want all he has achieved to be stolen from him by Alzheimer's. That disease stole my mother from me and its not getting Sam without a fight!!!! Sam's reaction to physical and emotional pain has always been pretty good , even normal I would say. pretty much like his reaction to bedtime :-) Whatever your take on this whole debate just congratulations on how you got to where you are now !! I bet it has not been easy [DownSyndromeInfoExchange] Re: Changing Minds Protocol/"Normal" Reaction to Pain Sherry- I have to respectfully disagree with your comment, "I honestly do not believe the CMF is making the difference in his response. I think you are searching and putting your child too much under a microscope looking for some changes and some are just going to be normal developmental changes." We have been very careful about our analysis of his progress. We are not basing his progress solely on our stories and observations. We are basing our statements on his progress on his evaluations by his PT, OT, ST, & DT. They are unbiased opinions (they do not know he is on the protocol), and they are showing that he is NOT falling further behind, in fact in some areas he is not only making month for month progress (3 months progress in 3 months time), he is *closing the gap* (making 6.3 months progress in 3 months time in one area). " I dislike that those who are on this protocal are making statements that they cannot see why others are not trying their kids on this protocol. " I totally understand your comment above. I have never made such a statement. In fact, I've said that there are certain unknown risks that potentially could be involved and if you, as a parent, cannot live with those possibel consequences then this protocol is not for you or your family. As for us, our son is 20 months old and has been on Ginkgo, Prozac, and the Body Bio PC and oils for 6 months. He has experienced no negative side effects to date. Christy >> To be honest...I really do not think one could coorelate this change to the CMP. I think your child just has gotten older and more aware. Most kids react to the blood draws IV's before the actual stick and really have no difference in reaction when the needle stick is made. Nate is pretty good with them and he has gotten worse as he aged. Kids also pick up on the parent response. I think Nate is so good because I am a nurse and I know it doesn't hurt much, he reacts more anticipatory. Most infants do not have much response at all to the needle sticks, etc. I have watched many circs and these kids react to the cold not the circ itself. Nate had his at 2 months of age and was great with it wtihout sedation or anything other than tylenol.....a little older and he would have had problems according to my OB he was at the Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 2, 2009 Report Share Posted June 2, 2009 ooops , twice , must be an irish thing , to be sure to be sure :-) sorry !!! [DownSyndromeInfoExchange] Re: Changing Minds Protocol/"Normal" Reaction to Pain Sherry- I have to respectfully disagree with your comment, "I honestly do not believe the CMF is making the difference in his response. I think you are searching and putting your child too much under a microscope looking for some changes and some are just going to be normal developmental changes." We have been very careful about our analysis of his progress. We are not basing his progress solely on our stories and observations. We are basing our statements on his progress on his evaluations by his PT, OT, ST, & DT. They are unbiased opinions (they do not know he is on the protocol), and they are showing that he is NOT falling further behind, in fact in some areas he is not only making month for month progress (3 months progress in 3 months time), he is *closing the gap* (making 6.3 months progress in 3 months time in one area). " I dislike that those who are on this protocal are making statements that they cannot see why others are not trying their kids on this protocol. " I totally understand your comment above. I have never made such a statement. In fact, I've said that there are certain unknown risks that potentially could be involved and if you, as a parent, cannot live with those possibel consequences then this protocol is not for you or your family. As for us, our son is 20 months old and has been on Ginkgo, Prozac, and the Body Bio PC and oils for 6 months. He has experienced no negative side effects to date. Christy >> To be honest...I really do not think one could coorelate this change to the CMP. I think your child just has gotten older and more aware. Most kids react to the blood draws IV's before the actual stick and really have no difference in reaction when the needle stick is made. Nate is pretty good with them and he has gotten worse as he aged. Kids also pick up on the parent response. I think Nate is so good because I am a nurse and I know it doesn't hurt much, he reacts more anticipatory. Most infants do not have much response at all to the needle sticks, etc. I have watched many circs and these kids react to the cold not the circ itself. Nate had his at 2 months of age and was great with it wtihout sedation or anything other than tylenol.....a little older and he would have had problems according to my OB he was at the Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 2, 2009 Report Share Posted June 2, 2009 Dear Sherry: I would have to desagree also. Even though my intention is not to convince anyone to use the protocol or continue arguing for the sake of arguing. It is just that other people's experience have help me a lot and thus I think it is a duty to share my experience. I have 3 boys and 6 nephews (from my sisters) and then a whole bunch from my cousins and I had never seen a newborn baby that did not cry when he was given his first bath, (my other two sons cried like if they were being killed), until my son . He was sleeping the nurse undressed him in an aircondition room, gave him a bath (rubing and turning), and dressed him again without him waking up, to the point that I signaled my startled husband to check if the baby was still alive and he actualy put his finger under 's nose to check if he was breathing. My husband was as chocked as I was! No reaction at all, not even a wink or any movement. Now, I certainly did not imagen this or was looking for things under the microscope at that time, as I am not doing it now either. I simply observe and write down what is happening with my son. As for other kids being developing better than kids on the protocol I can certainly believe that, all kids are different. I met an 11 years old girl with DS that if I closed my eyes and heard her talking I would not imagen that she had DS. Unfortunately this is not the norm. I do know what was happening to my son, who was regressing, even with all the neurological reorganization, Fisotherapy, TO, etc. and was almost diagnosed with autism by a neurologist (I did not make it up!). This was in november 2008 and my son is a totally diferent kid today. His radical changes in behaviour were noticed by his school teacher, who has no idea that this protocol even exists, along with many other people. I do not know if this would have the same effect in other kids but in my son it did. And you just don`t grow out of autistic behaviours! I can perfectly respect whoever wants to try the protocol as much as those who do not but as I do not think it is right for me to push other people to use it, I also do not think it is right to say that it does not work because that has not been proven either, or treat us parents who are using it as ignorants or say that we are making up this things. Regards, Jannette De: Sherry Assunto: [DownSyndromeInfoExchange] Re: Changing Minds Protocol/"Normal" Reaction to PainPara: DownSyndromeInfoExchange Data: Terça-feira, 2 de Junho de 2009, 11:13 To be honest...I really do not think one could coorelate this change to the CMP. I think your child just has gotten older and more aware. Most kids react to the blood draws IV's before the actual stick and really have no difference in reaction when the needle stick is made. Nate is pretty good with them and he has gotten worse as he aged. Kids also pick up on the parent response. I think Nate is so good because I am a nurse and I know it doesn't hurt much, he reacts more anticipatory. Most infants do not have much response at all to the needle sticks, etc. I have watched many circs and these kids react to the cold not the circ itself. Nate had his at 2 months of age and was great with it wtihout sedation or anything other than tylenol...... a little older and he would have had problems according to my OB he was at the border age and most kids will tolerate it done till about 2 1/2 months of age. I honestly do not believe the CMF is making the difference in his response. I think you are searching and putting your child too much under a microscope looking for some changes and some are just going to be normal developmental changes.I dislike that those who are on this protocal are making statements that they cannot see why others are not trying their kids on this protocol. Well both my husband and I have an extensive medical background and we just don't "buy" in to it just yet. Not that we won't in the future but medication have side effects and the science is just not there yet to support this yet especially with young child. The first thing in medical shcool you learn is to do not harm. I look at the things children who are around the same age as Nate who are on the potocol and he is doing the same stuff if not more advanced. So you can see why I am not on board yet. I say yet, because I am not opposed to it just not yet for my child.Sherry>> My son is 20 months old. We started him on Ginkgo Biloba when he was 13> months old and Prozac when he was 14 months old. We added the Body Bio> PC and oil when he was 16 months old. One change I've noticed since> starting the protocol is that he now has a "normal" reaction to pain..> Allow me to explain what I mean.> > Here are some examples of our son NOT having a "normal" reaction to> pain. When Tristen was born, he was in the NICU for 9 days. During that> time my husband and I watched as he was poked and prodded with multiple> needles, he had his IV changed 4 times - and he never even flinched,> never cried, he acted as though nothing happened. At two weeks old, he> had his circumcision done in my OB's office - he didn't cry. Throughout> the months, he went for immunization shots and NEVER cried. Before> starting the protocol (at 13 months), I took him to the hospital to have> a battery of bloodwork drawn. He had 7 vials of blood drawn - his vein> stopped giving blood twice and the nurse had to move it all around in> his arm trying to find the vein again (made me sick to watch because I> have "rolling veins" and this happens to me everytime I have blood drawn> - it REALLY hurts). He did not even flinch or attempt to move his arms> or legs, never cried, didn't even get upset at being restrained by a> second nurse. Both nurses were just amazed that he was so "good." I was> just sick inside because I knew that this meant he just wasn't "feeling"> things as he should. Throughout his first year I cannot remember a time> when he fell over and cried from pain. Even his physical therapist> commented many times about him "being tough" because he didn't cry when> he bumped his head or fell.> > Fast forward to today. . . he totally reacts appropriately to pain! He> had his blood drawn (just 4 tubes) in April - he screamed, hollered,> kicked, turned purple - and it took two people to hold him down while> the nurse drew his blood. He had an immunization shot a couple of months> ago and threw a fit! He now cries when he gets a bump. The difference we> see is night and day. It is as though he had absolutely no sesitivity to> pain before starting the protocol and now his pain sensitivity is> normal.> > Has anyone else noticed this in their child?? Just curious. . . ..> > Christy> Veja quais são os assuntos do momento no Yahoo! + Buscados: Top 10 - Celebridades - Música - Esportes Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 3, 2009 Report Share Posted June 3, 2009 Jannette- It sounds like 's response to pain (I mean, lack of response) was similar to Tristen's. I think in our cases it was virtually nonexistent in every situation. I know that all kids w/Ds present with differing " symptoms " (ie - some need glasses - others do not, some have heart conditions - others do not, etc). I'm glad to hear that is having a similar positive effect after starting the protocol. I'm in the same boat as you in that my intention is not impose my decision on others. I've posted a couple of times that there *could* potentially be unknown risk factors involved and as a parent you have to accept responsibility for them - as with any treatment option you conscent to for any condition. My husband and I feel that we are as informed as we can be at this point and with that moved forward with our decision to pursue this treatment option. We personally have three doctors aware that Tristen (20 months, has been on the protocol for 6 months) is taking Prozac, Ginkgo Biloba, the two Body Bio products. He is not taking Focalin. I read and respect what treatment options others choose for their children. Quite frankly, I've learned a lot over the past 20 months! I do not challenge the claims that others make about the positive effects certain treatments or therapies have had on their child. I read what is written and research the validity for myself. My sole purpose of sharing our experience is for informational purposes. I am glad that this list remains open to discussing alternative treatment options and that it's purpose is to " exchange information " , as the name states. That is how I found out about the CMF protocol, Nutrivene D, useful therapies, and various other helpful supplements. Christy > > > > My son is 20 months old. We started him on Ginkgo Biloba when he was 13 > > months old and Prozac when he was 14 months old. We added the Body Bio > > PC and oil when he was 16 months old. One change I've noticed since > > starting the protocol is that he now has a " normal " reaction to pain. > > Allow me to explain what I mean. > > > > Here are some examples of our son NOT having a " normal " reaction to > > pain. When Tristen was born, he was in the NICU for 9 days. During that > > time my husband and I watched as he was poked and prodded with multiple > > needles, he had his IV changed 4 times - and he never even flinched, > > never cried, he acted as though nothing happened. At two weeks old, he > > had his circumcision done in my OB's office - he didn't cry. Throughout > > the months, he went for immunization shots and NEVER cried. Before > > starting the protocol (at 13 months), I took him to the hospital to have > > a battery of bloodwork drawn. He had 7 vials of blood drawn - his vein > > stopped giving blood twice and the nurse had to move it all around in > > his arm trying to find the vein again (made me sick to watch because I > > have " rolling veins " and this happens to me everytime I have blood drawn > > - it REALLY hurts). He did not even flinch or attempt to move his arms > > or legs, never cried, didn't even get upset at being restrained by a > > second nurse. Both nurses were just amazed that he was so " good. " I was > > just sick inside because I knew that this meant he just wasn't " feeling " > > things as he should. Throughout his first year I cannot remember a time > > when he fell over and cried from pain. Even his physical therapist > > commented many times about him " being tough " because he didn't cry when > > he bumped his head or fell. > > > > Fast forward to today. . . he totally reacts appropriately to pain! He > > had his blood drawn (just 4 tubes) in April - he screamed, hollered, > > kicked, turned purple - and it took two people to hold him down while > > the nurse drew his blood. He had an immunization shot a couple of months > > ago and threw a fit! He now cries when he gets a bump. The difference we > > see is night and day. It is as though he had absolutely no sesitivity to > > pain before starting the protocol and now his pain sensitivity is > > normal. > > > > Has anyone else noticed this in their child?? Just curious. . . . > > > > Christy > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Veja quais são os assuntos do momento no Yahoo! +Buscados > http://br.maisbuscados.yahoo.com > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2009 Report Share Posted June 4, 2009 Thank you for the information. It is very helpful to those who are searching to make the decision. It is very much appreciated. Jules Romero -- [DownSyndromeInfoExchange] Re: Changing Minds Protocol/"Normal" Reaction to Pain Jannette-It sounds like 's response to pain (I mean, lack of response) wassimilar to Tristen's. I think in our cases it was virtually nonexistentin every situation. I know that all kids w/Ds present with differing"symptoms" (ie - some need glasses - others do not, some have heartconditions - others do not, etc). I'm glad to hear that ishaving a similar positive effect after starting the protocol.I'm in the same boat as you in that my intention is not impose mydecision on others. I've posted a couple of times that there *could*potentially be unknown risk factors involved and as a parent you have toaccept responsibility for them - as with any treatment option youconscent to for any condition. My husband and I feel that we are asinformed as we can be at this point and with that moved forward with ourdecision to pursue this treatment option. We personally have threedoctors aware that Tristen (20 months, has been on the protocol for 6months) is taking Prozac, Ginkgo Biloba, the two Body Bio products. Heis not taking Focalin. I read and respect what treatment options otherschoose for their children. Quite frankly, I've learned a lot over thepast 20 months! I do not challenge the claims that others make aboutthe positive effects certain treatments or therapies have had on theirchild. I read what is written and research the validity for myself.My sole purpose of sharing our experience is for informational purposes.I am glad that this list remains open to discussing alternativetreatment options and that it's purpose is to "exchange information", asthe name states. That is how I found out about the CMF protocol,Nutrivene D, useful therapies, and various other helpful supplements.Christy> >> > My son is 20 months old. We started him on Ginkgo Biloba when he was13> > months old and Prozac when he was 14 months old. We added the BodyBio> > PC and oil when he was 16 months old. One change I've noticed since> > starting the protocol is that he now has a "normal" reaction topain.> > Allow me to explain what I mean.> >> > Here are some examples of our son NOT having a "normal" reaction to> > pain. When Tristen was born, he was in the NICU for 9 days. Duringthat> > time my husband and I watched as he was poked and prodded withmultiple> > needles, he had his IV changed 4 times - and he never even flinched,> > never cried, he acted as though nothing happened. At two weeks old,he> > had his circumcision done in my OB's office - he didn't cry.Throughout> > the months, he went for immunization shots and NEVER cried. Before> > starting the protocol (at 13 months), I took him to the hospital tohave> > a battery of bloodwork drawn. He had 7 vials of blood drawn - hisvein> > stopped giving blood twice and the nurse had to move it all aroundin> > his arm trying to find the vein again (made me sick to watch becauseI> > have "rolling veins" and this happens to me everytime I have blooddrawn> > - it REALLY hurts). He did not even flinch or attempt to move hisarms> > or legs, never cried, didn't even get upset at being restrained by a> > second nurse. Both nurses were just amazed that he was so "good." Iwas> > just sick inside because I knew that this meant he just wasn't"feeling"> > things as he should. Throughout his first year I cannot remember atime> > when he fell over and cried from pain. Even his physical therapist> > commented many times about him "being tough" because he didn't crywhen> > he bumped his head or fell.> >> > Fast forward to today. . . he totally reacts appropriately to pain!He> > had his blood drawn (just 4 tubes) in April - he screamed, hollered,> > kicked, turned purple - and it took two people to hold him downwhile> > the nurse drew his blood. He had an immunization shot a couple ofmonths> > ago and threw a fit! He now cries when he gets a bump. Thedifference we> > see is night and day. It is as though he had absolutely nosesitivity to> > pain before starting the protocol and now his pain sensitivity is> > normal.> >> > Has anyone else noticed this in their child?? Just curious. . . .> >> > Christy> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Veja quais são os assuntos do momento no Yahoo! +Buscados> http://br.maisbuscados.yahoo.com> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.