Guest guest Posted November 24, 2003 Report Share Posted November 24, 2003 I really don't like to get into political debates (or politics related debates), but I agree with you guys that should never become the PM of India. One aspect is her Italian origin. The second aspect - why is it necessary for the Congress to hang on to the Nehru-Gandhi dynasty for leadership. Surely they have other better leaders? Ravin '82 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 25, 2003 Report Share Posted November 25, 2003 Dear Dr.Goel, I appreciate your correct analysis of this complex matter in the historical perspective. may represent the feudal congress culture but even moderate and non-extremist (read secular)knows in the heart of his heart that is just not the likely choice for PM of this country. Why do we limit the choice of PM ? India is a huge country with lot of contenders , family rule of Nehruvian era will not work in the present era of rapid communication and volatile sentiments. VK Gupta 1976 AKHAND---BHARAT > It is absolutely untrue notion that British-empire united India as a nation. > > Dear Ashok,When British left India,there were more than 500 small kingdoms within the nation covering > more than 40 percent of land.British were taking heavy taxes from these Rajas and Nawabs and allowing > them limited rights,it was more like HAFTA--VASOOLI. When they left India they also made these kings free > and they were free to either join India or Pakistan or remain Independent. After British left India these > kingdoms were not small hindrance but a very big problem. we all know that it was only Sardar Patel,who > handled this matter very nicely. Nehru was given the responsibility to handle Kashmir governed by Raja Hari > Singh and we know what a mess he made about Kashmir issue. we know that Nehru was also a Kashmiri > Pundit and so he had personal interests there and was against Raja.Raja Hari Singh wanted to be with India > But Nehru helped the dissident Sekh Abdulla, A Muslim leader and all politics took place. Muslim being in > majority were made against Raja and we know what happened after that. Actually British with the help > of lady mountbetan and Nehru had made all the arrangement to see India disintegrating very soon requiring > them again but did not know the strength of its public. > > Dear Ashok,Indian Sub-continent,Supt-Sindhu region was united nation from earliest days of civilization, > moreover it was a true democracy in those earlier times with perfect Panchayati-Raj system in Janapads > and Nagars.Very soon southern region was united with it by efforts of Muni August and RAMA . > Ashok,how do you forget, it was one empire during times of auryas[ ASHOKA] and Guptas. Only after > starting of foreign invasion it disintegrated. > > > ---------- Dear Munish, Dear Ashok, please don't worry, will never become PM of India.We need you more > than this lady,please never think about, even in dreams,to cut ties with India. > > is a good lady but in a democracy to represent public,leader should be true representative. can > not be compared with Rabri or Uma or jailalitha. Question of good or bad, able or not comes next, first is to > represent the masses. Rabri is representative of typical Indian woman,who only follows husband's wish without > arguing anything else.Laloo asked her to become CM,she became CM,tomorrow if Laloo will ask her to leave > and go to kitchen ,she will do that in a minute.We know that she is not CM of Bihar but a proxy of Laloo Yadav, > And nobody can doubt the capabilities of Laloo Yadav. > > just poses to be true Indian lady but she fails miserably every time,it is not easy to pose what you are not > actually,only saying,----MAINE KONSI MARYADA TODI,does not work. Only keeping great names like Gandhi or > Bose is not sufficient.Everybody understand the difference between true and fake names. > > > Gauri Shankar Goel > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 30, 2003 Report Share Posted November 30, 2003 dear dr vk gupta i agree sonia is not the only choice for becomming PM of this country acan't we find a suitable person amongst so many? i came to know a startling fact why she should not become PM. it was during last war that all the pilots of our airlines were asked to report for war duty and fly the war planes but sonia ran away with her husband to italy eventhough her mother in-law was PM Now why she should be PM Dilip Gupta 1981 On Tue, 25 Nov 2003 Dr.V.K.Gupta wrote : >Dear Dr.Goel, >I appreciate your correct analysis of this complex matter in the historical >perspective. may represent the feudal congress culture but even >moderate and non-extremist (read secular)knows in the heart of his heart >that is just not the likely choice for PM of this country. >Why do we limit the choice of PM ? >India is a huge country with lot of contenders , family rule of Nehruvian >era will not work in the present era of rapid communication and volatile >sentiments. >VK Gupta >1976 > AKHAND---BHARAT > > > > It is absolutely untrue notion that British-empire united India >as a nation. > > > > Dear Ashok,When British left India,there were more than 500 small >kingdoms within the nation covering > > more than 40 percent of land.British were taking heavy taxes from these >Rajas and Nawabs and allowing > > them limited rights,it was more like HAFTA--VASOOLI. When they left India >they also made these kings free > > and they were free to either join India or Pakistan or remain Independent. >After British left India these > > kingdoms were not small hindrance but a very big problem. we all know that >it was only Sardar Patel,who > > handled this matter very nicely. Nehru was given the responsibility to >handle Kashmir governed by Raja Hari > > Singh and we know what a mess he made about Kashmir issue. we know that >Nehru was also a Kashmiri > > Pundit and so he had personal interests there and was against Raja.Raja >Hari Singh wanted to be with India > > But Nehru helped the dissident Sekh Abdulla, A Muslim leader and all >politics took place. Muslim being in > > majority were made against Raja and we know what happened after that. >Actually British with the help > > of lady mountbetan and Nehru had made all the arrangement to see India >disintegrating very soon requiring > > them again but did not know the strength of its public. > > > > Dear Ashok,Indian Sub-continent,Supt-Sindhu region was united nation > from earliest days of civilization, > > moreover it was a true democracy in those earlier times with perfect >Panchayati-Raj system in Janapads > > and Nagars.Very soon southern region was united with it by efforts of Muni >August and RAMA . > > Ashok,how do you forget, it was one empire during times of >auryas[ ASHOKA] and Guptas. Only after > > starting of foreign invasion it disintegrated. > > > > > > ---------- Dear Munish, Dear Ashok, please don't worry, will never >become PM of India.We need you more > > than this lady,please never think about, even in dreams,to cut ties with >India. > > > > is a good lady but in a democracy to represent public,leader >should be true representative. can > > not be compared with Rabri or Uma or jailalitha. Question of good or bad, >able or not comes next, first is to > > represent the masses. Rabri is representative of typical Indian woman,who >only follows husband's wish without > > arguing anything else.Laloo asked her to become CM,she became CM,tomorrow >if Laloo will ask her to leave > > and go to kitchen ,she will do that in a minute.We know that she is not CM >of Bihar but a proxy of Laloo Yadav, > > And nobody can doubt the capabilities of Laloo Yadav. > > > > just poses to be true Indian lady but she fails miserably every >time,it is not easy to pose what you are not > > actually,only saying,----MAINE KONSI MARYADA TODI,does not work. Only >keeping great names like Gandhi or > > Bose is not sufficient.Everybody understand the difference between true >and fake names. > > > > > > Gauri Shankar Goel > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.