RE: MARSHA

[Guest guest]

Hi Pia

Im not Marsha, but my wife had EST (its called ECT over here in

Australia) for Post Natal Depression/Psychosis, as far as my experience goes as

a bystander, this treatment is:

1) Temporary

2) An alternative when the

body is not responding to drugs (and back to one – temporary relief from a

constant unbearable depressive state)

3) Has short term and long

term memory loss (to quiet an extent)

It might well jolt us happy, but I wouldn’t want to try it personally to

see if it fixes 4S, unless I was in a deep depressive state that I could not

get out of.

Just my thoughts from my wife’s experience and what she has told me, not

sure she would do it again.

Neil

-----Original

Message-----

From: Soundsensitivity

[mailto:Soundsensitivity ]On

Behalf Of Pia Levensteins

Sent: Thursday, September 27, 2007

11:19 PM

To:

soundsensitivity

Subject: MARSHA

Marsha, has

anyone looked into electro shock therapy?

I read an article in THE VILLAGE VOICE and it has come

a long way in helping depression so maybe a little jolt

can rewire our sensitivity!!! OR MAKE IT WORSE??

PIA

To: Soundsensitivity

From: judytk

Date: Thu, 27 Sep 2007 06:06:34 -0700

Subject: Re: Re: Past trauma related to sound sensitivity?????

There have been no traumatic events in my childhood;

thus, there is no past trauma associated with my 4s.

There is the possibility that people are born with a

pre-disposition for 4s, and a traumatic event is the

precipitating factor for its realization [for some

people].

Judy

--- orinlouis <orinlouis>

wrote:

> 1 million trillion percent!

>

> Many here feel differently, which could mean they

> got theirs another way.

>

> Or maybe nobody's on the right track.

>

> Nah, it's PTSD all the way.

>

>

__________________________________________________________

Shape Yahoo! in your own image. Join our Network Research Panel today! http://surveylink.yahoo.com/gmrs/yahoo_panel_invite.asp

?a=7

Explore the

seven wonders of the world Learn more!

[Guest guest]

Thanks Neil!

To: Soundsensitivity From: neilholmes@...Date: Fri, 28 Sep 2007 00:08:34 +1000Subject: RE: MARSHA

Hi Pia

Im not Marsha, but my wife had EST (its called ECT over here in Australia) for Post Natal Depression/Psychosis, as far as my experience goes as a bystander, this treatment is:

1) Temporary

2) An alternative when the body is not responding to drugs (and back to one – temporary relief from a constant unbearable depressive state)

3) Has short term and long term memory loss (to quiet an extent)

It might well jolt us happy, but I wouldn’t want to try it personally to see if it fixes 4S, unless I was in a deep depressive state that I could not get out of.

Just my thoughts from my wife’s experience and what she has told me, not sure she would do it again.

Neil

Re: Re: Past trauma related to sound sensitivity?????

There have been no traumatic events in my childhood;thus, there is no past trauma associated with my 4s.There is the possibility that people are born with apre-disposition for 4s, and a traumatic event is theprecipitating factor for its realization [for somepeople].Judy--- orinlouis <orinlouis> wrote:> 1 million trillion percent! > > Many here feel differently, which could mean they> got theirs another way.> > Or maybe nobody's on the right track.> > Nah, it's PTSD all the way.> > __________________________________________________________Shape Yahoo! in your own image. Join our Network Research Panel today! http://surveylink.yahoo.com/gmrs/yahoo_panel_invite.asp ?a=7

Explore the seven wonders of the world Learn more!

Discover the new Windows Vista Learn more!