a's Banning -- her statement

[Guest guest]

From a (with her permission to post here) -- she did not resign...

I would like to state that I have been banned from the Marshall

Protocol website where I used to be a moderator. I have no further

connection with this website or with Dr. Trevor Marshall.

I was banned because I expressed concern for a patient who had been

vomiting three days, had elevated kidney tests, and needed IV fluids.

This patient's doctor had stated these things. When I encouraged this

patient to follow the doctor's directions, and that minocycline and

Benicar both can affect kidney function, my post was deleted.

When I protested the deletion of my cautionary message I was banned.

Dr. Marshall wrote me the following warning:

" There is no way that any of us should be talking in such a manner

such as might induce a mother to believe that IV fluids are either

necessary or desirable. "

I replied on this:

" I did not suggest IV fluids. Her doctor called her and left a

message on her answering machine to BRING HIM IN FOR IV FLUIDS. I

suggested she do that NOW. This boy had extreme vomiting for three

days, elevated markers for kidney malfunction which had existed in

the past, and needed electrolytes. He remained so dizzy he could not

stand. I gave this woman NO advice her doctors had not already given

her…Yet my post was the one deleted. "

I am still on the Marshall Protocol and had encouraging conversations

with doctors at the Chicago conference. I will be writing an article

on this for the Wisconsin CFIDS organization that should come out in

May of this year. I also will be posting some observations about the

protocol that should be of use to patients on the protocol.

I feel that in order to protect myself and other patients I must

distance myself from the MP website. I find that I frequently

disagree with the advice given there, and several of my posts have

been deleted in the past because of this.

I hear it has been posted at the MP website that they will not

discuss why I was banned " to protect my privacy. " The information I

have stated above is the reason I was banned. I am not trying to

protect my privacy. They are trying to hide the reason why I was

banned.

a Carnes

--- In infections , " Ken " <ken@l...>

wrote:

>

> There is the appearance of dishonesty by " Admin "

>

> http://marshallprotocol.com/forum11/2426.html

>

> Posted: Wed Mar 16th, 2005 09:03

> a has resigned from the MP site.

>

> Out of respect for Ms. Carnes, any further information will remain

> private.

>

> This topic is now being closed.

>

> Thank you,

>

> Board Staff