Re: FW:Lyme disease: A Look Beyond Antibiotics

[Guest guest]

Pam posted:

> Lyme disease: A Look Beyond Antibiotics

> Dietrich K. Klinghardt, MD, PhD 1/7/05

I commented on this one when it was posted previously a few days

ago.

I would just add that the reference to the Marshall Protocol, and

repitition of unsubstantiated claims about 1,25-D as though they

were facts, tells me this is someone who does not always scrutinize

carefully what he's pitching as important medical information.

I'm not dismissing the whole article, but I would advise it be read

with a large cannister of salt within arm's reach.

There is a difference between being thorough and being gullible - a

difference that is likely to involve large sums of money, time and

grief.

Maybe the MP thing is an atypical lapse, but I wouldn't bank on it.

I think a lot of these guys will scrutinize something just enough to

see if they're likely to embarass themselves by promoting it. As

long as there's a veneer of credibility, they add it to the list

of 'essential treatment components.'

By the looks of this, any patient of this doctor who has the

misfortune to have her 1,25-D tested on the wrong day in her

menstrual cycle will wind up compelled to endure a year on the

Marshall Protocol. Are we sure Klinghardt isn't everyone's favorite

RN in drag?

[Guest guest]

>

> Pam posted:

>

> > Lyme disease: A Look Beyond Antibiotics

> > Dietrich K. Klinghardt, MD, PhD 1/7/05

>

Hi

I didn't write about Klinghardt must have been somebody else though

I have read the article. One thing I know about him and mercury

poisoning is that he uses chlorella which by no way has been proved

to move mercury out of the brain so therefore it is likely to be

inefective for mercury chelation.

As far as I know only 3 substances have been proved to cross the

blood brain barrier with regard to mercury, DMSA, DMPS and alpha

lipoic acid. Therefore if he is so wrong about mercury chelation he

might well be wrong about a lot of other things he writes, I don't

know.

Pam

[Guest guest]

Argh, no, it was P. Dalton who posted it. My blinking brain turned

it into Pam. My apologies!

> >

> > Pam posted:

> >

> > > Lyme disease: A Look Beyond Antibiotics

> > > Dietrich K. Klinghardt, MD, PhD 1/7/05

> >

>

> Hi

>

> I didn't write about Klinghardt must have been somebody else

though

> I have read the article. One thing I know about him and mercury

> poisoning is that he uses chlorella which by no way has been

proved

> to move mercury out of the brain so therefore it is likely to be

> inefective for mercury chelation.

>

> As far as I know only 3 substances have been proved to cross the

> blood brain barrier with regard to mercury, DMSA, DMPS and alpha

> lipoic acid. Therefore if he is so wrong about mercury chelation

he

> might well be wrong about a lot of other things he writes, I don't

> know.

>

> Pam