Re: Ogino and Knaus in 1930

[Guest guest]

Dear , I have a copy of the talk given by Fr. Z ("Progress of NFP in the World Today", FLA International Seminar, Tokyo, Sept 26, 1978, A Reader in Natural Family Planning, report on international conferences No. 1 second edition, edited by Fr. Z and published by Rev. P Marx, HLI). Will this give insight about what you are looking for? Regards." F. Kippley" wrote: Some years ago I learned from the late and great Fr. Zimmerman about the discussion between Ogino and Knaus that was

apparently resolved by Ogino's publication in a German journal in February 1930. I have the name and date of the journal article, but I can't find Fr. Z's treatment of the discussion between these two pioneers. Does anyone on the list have it or know where it can be found? F Kippley"Sex and the Marriage Covenant" (Ignatius, 2005)"Natural Family Planning: The Question-Answer Book" an ebook at www.NFPandmore.org __________________________________________________

[Guest guest]

Dear , I wrote the wrong reference on Fr. Z. Sorry.Godofredo Ditan wrote: Dear , I have a copy of the talk given by Fr. Z ("Progress of NFP in the World Today", FLA International Seminar, Tokyo, Sept 26, 1978, A Reader in Natural Family Planning, report on international conferences No. 1 second edition, edited by Fr. Z and published by Rev. P Marx, HLI). Will this give insight about what you are looking for? Regards." F. Kippley" <jfkippleyfuse (DOT) net> wrote: Some years ago I learned from the late and great Fr. Zimmerman about the discussion between Ogino and Knaus that was apparently resolved by Ogino's publication in a German journal in February 1930. I have the name and date of the journal article, but I can't find Fr. Z's treatment of the discussion between these two pioneers. Does anyone on the list have it or know where it can be found? F Kippley"Sex and the Marriage Covenant" (Ignatius, 2005)"Natural Family Planning: The Question-Answer Book" an ebook at www.NFPandmore.org __________________________________________________

[Guest guest]

Thanks very much, but I have already found what I was looking for. See my message to the List dated November 6. Again, thanks for your offer. Kippley

Re: Ogino and Knaus in 1930

Dear , I wrote the wrong reference on Fr. Z. Sorry.Godofredo Ditan <ditanfred> wrote:

Dear , I have a copy of the talk given by Fr. Z ("Progress of NFP in the World Today", FLA International Seminar, Tokyo, Sept 26, 1978, A Reader in Natural Family Planning, report on international conferences No. 1 second edition, edited by Fr. Z and published by Rev. P Marx, HLI). Will this give insight about what you are looking for? Regards." F. Kippley" <jfkippleyfuse (DOT) net> wrote:

Some years ago I learned from the late and great Fr. Zimmerman about the discussion between Ogino and Knaus that was apparently resolved by Ogino's publication in a German journal in February 1930. I have the name and date of the journal article, but I can't find Fr. Z's treatment of the discussion between these two pioneers. Does anyone on the list have it or know where it can be found?

F Kippley"Sex and the Marriage Covenant" (Ignatius, 2005)"Natural Family Planning: The Question-Answer Book" an ebook at www.NFPandmore.org

__________________________________________________