Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Why did you get fat?

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

I was a jock growing up and I lived on a farm, changing irrigation pipe and riding horses. I was a great softball player because that was all that was available in the 50's. I mostly played baseball because my dad was a semi-pro player who didn't want us to run or throw like a girl and I didn't. My coach told me that "I ran too long in one place" and I assume that meant that although I was quick I was not fast. I was very short topping 4' 11" until I had knee replacements a couple years ago. I majored in physical education in college before switching to early childhood education as an adult. My mother was super morbidly obese. The Norwegian side of my family all were thin until the moment that they conceived and then we girls all ballooned up. I never had craves and I never overate and so when I continued to put on weight I was shocked. I researched the DS thanks to my friend and former co-worker, Ellen Rowley, the founder of this group. When I had my physical with Dr, Keshishian he explained to my husband and me that I had the "survivor" gene and that the responsibility for my weight was 15% and the rest was heredity. Could I exercise more? Of course. Am I happy with the 140-150 pound loss? Of course. I never had any emotional issues or hang ups - just ask my MSW husband who spent 20 years counseling people with all kinds of problems. Am I compliant with the requirements of the DS - no sodas, no carbonation, no alcohol, protein first, then veggies, etc., and taking all my supplements as required - you bet! There are many reasons why people gain weight. We all have different stories and reasons. What is your story?

Marla

WA State

DS: 2-9-05

Total bilateral knee replacements: 10-06

TT and brachioplasty: 10-07

thigh lifts: 1-09

Color me Happy!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jo & all,

I absolutely did eat emotionally as a kid. In elementary school I was maybe 10

pounds overweight due to sugar and carb eating out of boredom of being a

latchkey kid and unhappiness of having to live with a stepfamily who hated me.

Mom took my older sis, and i lived with dad, new wife & her 3 older kids who

were mean & hateful. By Jr High my older step bro started molesting me, and I

began a campaign to intentionally become ugly and physically disgusting to him

by getting fat. I realized in my early 20s what I had done but by then I felt I

had no ability to handle unwanted male attention, and I continued to gain 10 lbs

a year until I had DS. Before I had my surgery, I found an excellent counselor

who helped me believe I could handle unwanted male attention by Verbalizing My

Boundaries. I still struggle with being silent and not reacting when im

uncomfortable or in danger. But let me say that when I do stand up for myself,

it feels incredible! It's like a high. Even something as simple as asking the

drunk guy sitting next to me at the rock concert to please maintain his own

space & don't press his thigh against mine. I experienced a wonderful elation

that lasted for days! I stuck up for myself instead of running away or feeling

victimized.

This was my experience. I hope sharing it helps someone else.

Vicki in Roseville

>

> Great question Jo! I had a troubled childhood ...before that I was a normal

skinny, active kid. I started gaining weight around 8 yrs old.  Even though I've

come to terms with why I gained weight I have to acknowledge that what may have

started as a means of comfort, it became a really bad habit!! It's the habits

that are hard to overcome, even when the memories surface, I have to remind

myself that was a long time ago, to love myself NOW!

>

>

>

>

> ________________________________

>

> To: DS_Friends_Keshishian

> Sent: Thu, October 29, 2009 1:41:30 AM

> Subject: Why did you get fat?

>

>  

> I watch The Biggest Loser. I cry at some point during each show. Sometimes I

cry out of joy, sometimes I greive with the contestants. This weeks show seem to

have an extra emotional punch. Jillian (one of the trainers) always pushes to

get the contestant to " deal " with what ever emotional problem has brought them

to become obese. So they can deal with it and quit the behavior that has led to

them becoming obese.

>

> I don't personally feel I have some BIG emotional issue. I think obesity runs

in my family so we are pre=disposed. Add that, to just a " family " way (bad

habits) of eating and over-eating. I was a thin child. So was my brother and

sister. We became obese when we grew up. The same for my parents...aunts,

uncles...Even my own children...thin as kids, obese/overweight as adults. So I

don't think in " MY " case it's EMOTIONAL... but rather bad eating habits combined

with genetics.

>

> How about YOU? Has your obesity been a cloak that protects you? Is there an

underlying reason why you have become obese? Do you love yourself enough to

" allow " yourself to reach a more normal weight?

>

> Hugs

>

> Jo

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thank you for sharing Vicki, I know that it took a lot of courage. Congratulations on the progress you've made, speaking up for yourself and losing weight.

To: DS_Friends_Keshishian Sent: Fri, October 30, 2009 10:03:50 AMSubject: Re: Why did you get fat?

Jo & all,I absolutely did eat emotionally as a kid. In elementary school I was maybe 10 pounds overweight due to sugar and carb eating out of boredom of being a latchkey kid and unhappiness of having to live with a stepfamily who hated me. Mom took my older sis, and i lived with dad, new wife & her 3 older kids who were mean & hateful. By Jr High my older step bro started molesting me, and I began a campaign to intentionally become ugly and physically disgusting to him by getting fat. I realized in my early 20s what I had done but by then I felt I had no ability to handle unwanted male attention, and I continued to gain 10 lbs a year until I had DS. Before I had my surgery, I found an excellent counselor who helped me believe I could handle unwanted male attention by Verbalizing My Boundaries. I still struggle with being silent and not reacting when im uncomfortable or in danger. But let me say that when I do stand up for

myself, it feels incredible! It's like a high. Even something as simple as asking the drunk guy sitting next to me at the rock concert to please maintain his own space & don't press his thigh against mine. I experienced a wonderful elation that lasted for days! I stuck up for myself instead of running away or feeling victimized. This was my experience. I hope sharing it helps someone else. Vicki in Roseville>> Great question Jo! I had a troubled childhood ... before that I was a normal skinny, active kid. I started gaining weight around 8 yrs old. Even though I've come to terms with why I gained weight I have to acknowledge that what may have started as a means of

comfort, it became a really bad habit!! It's the habits that are hard to overcome, even when the memories surface, I have to remind myself that was a long time ago, to love myself NOW! > > > > > ____________ _________ _________ __> From: Jo <moobabies@. ..>> To: DS_Friends_Keshishi anyahoogroups (DOT) com> Sent: Thu, October 29, 2009 1:41:30 AM> Subject: [DS_Friends_ Keshishian] Why did you get fat?> > > I watch The Biggest Loser. I cry at some point during each show. Sometimes I cry out of joy, sometimes I greive with the contestants. This weeks show seem to have an extra emotional punch. Jillian (one of the trainers) always pushes to get the contestant to "deal" with what ever emotional problem has brought them

to become obese. So they can deal with it and quit the behavior that has led to them becoming obese.> > I don't personally feel I have some BIG emotional issue. I think obesity runs in my family so we are pre=disposed. Add that, to just a "family" way (bad habits) of eating and over-eating. I was a thin child. So was my brother and sister. We became obese when we grew up. The same for my parents...aunts, uncles...Even my own children...thin as kids, obese/overweight as adults. So I don't think in "MY" case it's EMOTIONAL... but rather bad eating habits combined with genetics.> > How about YOU? Has your obesity been a cloak that protects you? Is there an underlying reason why you have become obese? Do you love yourself enough to "allow" yourself to reach a more normal weight?> > Hugs> > Jo>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They say " It's not where you start its where you finish, and girl look at you

now! " It sounds like you finished well.. That's an inspiring story.

Vicki

> >

> > Great question Jo! I had a troubled childhood ...before that I was a normal

skinny, active kid. I started gaining weight around 8 yrs old.  Even though I've

come to terms with why I gained weight I have to acknowledge that what may have

started as a means of comfort, it became a really bad habit!! It's the habits

that are hard to overcome, even when the memories surface, I have to remind

myself that was a long time ago, to love myself NOW!

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > ________________________________

> > From: Jo <moobabies@>

> > To: DS_Friends_Keshishian

> > Sent: Thu, October 29, 2009 1:41:30 AM

> > Subject: Why did you get fat?

> >

> >  

> > I watch The Biggest Loser. I cry at some point during each show. Sometimes I

cry out of joy, sometimes I greive with the contestants. This weeks show seem to

have an extra emotional punch. Jillian (one of the trainers) always pushes to

get the contestant to " deal " with what ever emotional problem has brought them

to become obese. So they can deal with it and quit the behavior that has led to

them becoming obese.

> >

> > I don't personally feel I have some BIG emotional issue. I think obesity

runs in my family so we are pre=disposed. Add that, to just a " family " way (bad

habits) of eating and over-eating. I was a thin child. So was my brother and

sister. We became obese when we grew up. The same for my parents...aunts,

uncles...Even my own children...thin as kids, obese/overweight as adults. So I

don't think in " MY " case it's EMOTIONAL... but rather bad eating habits combined

with genetics.

> >

> > How about YOU? Has your obesity been a cloak that protects you? Is there an

underlying reason why you have become obese? Do you love yourself enough to

" allow " yourself to reach a more normal weight?

> >

> > Hugs

> >

> > Jo

> >

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was a binge eater. I ate whatever I wanted, what I wanted.

I started at age 6 and went on from there.

As a matter of fact, I never knew what a craving was till after my DS. Before, I just ate so I never let myself have one.

One thing I miss about being big is anonymity. I was kind of a block of a person who just moved along. People didn't ask me for directions, didn't really look at me. I just was. It's different when you're so much smaller. People come into your personal space. They come closer. I've gotten more used to it, but sometimes I still miss just going my own way.

A.

----------------

Duodenal Switch/Lap -- Drs. Alfons Pomp & Michel Gagner -- New York City

4/4/05: 265 lbs/BMI: 45.6

4/11/05: 256 lbs/BMI: 43.9 (date of surgery)

7/27/08: Gallbladder Removed

10/8/09: 119.2 lbs./BMI: 20.5

My pics: http://www.picturetrail.com/sfx/album/view/20083300

----------------

From: Jo <moobabieshotmail (DOT) com>To: DS_Friends_Keshishi anyahoogroups (DOT) comSent: Thu, October 29, 2009 1:41:30 AMSubject: [DS_Friends_ Keshishian] Why did you get fat? I watch The Biggest Loser. I cry at some point during each show. Sometimes I cry out of joy, sometimes I greive with the contestants. This weeks show seem to have an extra emotional punch. Jillian (one of the trainers) always pushes to get the contestant to

"deal" with what ever emotional problem has brought them to become obese. So they can deal with it and quit the behavior that has led to them becoming obese.I don't personally feel I have some BIG emotional issue. I think obesity runs in my family so we are pre=disposed. Add that, to just a "family" way (bad habits) of eating and over-eating. I was a thin child. So was my brother and sister. We became obese when we grew up. The same for my parents...aunts, uncles...Even my own children...thin as kids, obese/overweight as adults. So I don't think in "MY" case it's EMOTIONAL... but

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This has proven to be a very interesting subject. We are learning more about

each other and taking a moment to reflect on ourselves. We are looking inward

and " owning " our path to obesity. This is good.

Whatever was our individual path was, that led to our obesity, the greatest

thing we have in common is " We did something about it " . YEA US!

Thanks sooooo much for sharing. I hope to hear for more.

Hugs

Jo

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There are probably many reasons, but the emotional ones seem to center around a

childhood spent as a lonely " unparented " kid raised by two alcoholics, who

barely noticed I was there. Not permitted to eat until the parents returned

each night from their daily excursions to the bars, I have very early memories

of sitting on my little chair in the kitchen, staring hungrily into the glass

window on the oven where dinner was being kept on " warm, " and wishing so hard

that they would come home so I could eat. When they eventually would, I would

be so hungry I would gobble everything I could get my hands on or my fork into!

So, I believe, began a lifetime of eating too much, too quickly, and of the

expectancy that food would finally fulfill my longings. I'd like to think that

by age 66 I'd have left that all far behind, but I know I haven't altogether. I

still struggle with those desires to pig out on comfort food or sweets; I doubt

they'll ever be altogether gone. Thanks for asking the question, Jo. The

answers can provide some valuable and thoughtful insight into the complex

emotional relationships we all have with food.

Bellingham, WA

DS 01-15-08

>

> How about YOU? Has your obesity been a cloak that protects you? Is there an

underlying reason why you have become obese? Do you love yourself enough to

" allow " yourself to reach a more normal weight?

>

> Hugs

>

> Jo

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Your story brought tears to my eyes. It is amazing the impact that childhood has

on us.

vicki

> >

> > How about YOU? Has your obesity been a cloak that protects you? Is there

an underlying reason why you have become obese? Do you love yourself enough to

" allow " yourself to reach a more normal weight?

> >

> > Hugs

> >

> > Jo

> >

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

:

Thanks for sharing. I think you bring up an excellent point. I don't really

think any of us ever completely leave our trauma/drama behind. I think we can

distance ourselves a tad but in a heartbeat it can be standing right beside us

again at any second.

What's more important, I think, is that we recognize it and the impact it has

had on our lives, therefore we can hope to deal with it.

Hugs

Jo

++++++++++++++

I'd like to think that by age 66 I'd have left that all far behind, but I know

I haven't altogether.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...