Guest guest Posted December 30, 2010 Report Posted December 30, 2010 Hi Indyrose, Most OTC pills claim they are intended to help you lose weight by raising your metabolism (not Alli though which is nasty in different ways). Most do have some kind of stimulant. The stimulant speeds up your heart rate which also acts to speed up your metabolism (like cardio exercise does). So, in theory, yes, they do work. However, while you can stop exercising if you start feeling dizzy or faint because your heart is beating too fast, you cannot yank the "diet" pill out of our system and they can really wreak havoc with your health, including causing heart attacks and death. Also, like cardio, the effect of raising your metabolism is temporary. Your metabolism is up when your heart rate is up. Shortly after you stop exercising, your heart rate and later your metabolism return to their normal rate. Same thing with the pills. You have to keep exercising, or in this case popping pills, to keep your heart rate up and keep your metabolism up. At least with exercise you get tons of benefits in addition to weight loss. With the pills, you gamble and might lose all the benefits. The only way to raise your metabolism so that it stays higher in a healthy way is with strength training. More muscle equals more calorie buring even at rest. Cardio is extremely important for all kinds of reasons too so a balance of the two (plus flexibility training to keep joints supple) is ideal for weight loss and overall health. Exericise is at most 20-30% of the weight loss equation though so a healthy, balanced diet with an emphasis on portion control will do the rest of the job. Also, the stimulants and/or "water pills" might make also you lose weight by making you pee a lot. You're only temporarily losing water that way. It will come back and again, you're only putting extra stress on your kidneys, heart or other vital organs without adding any benefit to your health. I hope that helps! Diet drugs/suppliments Does anyone use these? Are they affective at all? About the only one that my doctor said really worked at all was Alie, and that it had some really nasty consequences. I know most OTC diet pills are caffeine, which I can get from diet pop or coffee. Most say to use them with a diet and exercise -- well, of course, you will see weight-loss results with diet and exercise...Any real-world testimonies?Indyrose Quote
Guest guest Posted December 30, 2010 Report Posted December 30, 2010 I love your response about how you can stop exercise when feeling faint or dizzy but can't yank the chemicals out of your system. Caffeine does come from coffee and tea, I would avoid using soda pop to get caffeine as that doesn't help with weight loss, sugar free soda introduces a whole new set of problems as it triggers your body to react to a perceived increase in blood sugar but then nothing comes, that weakens your pancreas and can put you on the path to diabetes. I don't know if I would go the short cut route when it comes to weight loss, eat home cooked foods, cut back on processed goods, sugars and drink plenty of water to keep things moving properly. Exercise and take it one day at a time to retrain your body on how to react to the foods you are eating.. > > Hi Indyrose, > > Most OTC pills claim they are intended to help you lose weight by raising your metabolism (not Alli though which is nasty in different ways). Most do have some kind of stimulant. The stimulant speeds up your heart rate which also acts to speed up your metabolism (like cardio exercise does). So, in theory, yes, they do work. However, while you can stop exercising if you start feeling dizzy or faint because your heart is beating too fast, you cannot yank the " diet " pill out of our system and they can really wreak havoc with your health, including causing heart attacks and death. Also, like cardio, the effect of raising your metabolism is temporary. Your metabolism is up when your heart rate is up. Shortly after you stop exercising, your heart rate and later your metabolism return to their normal rate. Same thing with the pills. You have to keep exercising, or in this case popping pills, to keep your heart rate up and keep your metabolism up. At least with exercise you get tons of benefits in addition to weight loss. With the pills, you gamble and might lose all the benefits. The only way to raise your metabolism so that it stays higher in a healthy way is with strength training. More muscle equals more calorie buring even at rest. Cardio is extremely important for all kinds of reasons too so a balance of the two (plus flexibility training to keep joints supple) is ideal for weight loss and overall health. Exericise is at most 20-30% of the weight loss equation though so a healthy, balanced diet with an emphasis on portion control will do the rest of the job. > > Also, the stimulants and/or " water pills " might make also you lose weight by making you pee a lot. You're only temporarily losing water that way. It will come back and again, you're only putting extra stress on your kidneys, heart or other vital organs without adding any benefit to your health. > > I hope that helps! > > > > > Diet drugs/suppliments > > > > Does anyone use these? Are they affective at all? About the only one that my doctor said really worked at all was Alie, and that it had some really nasty consequences. I know most OTC diet pills are caffeine, which I can get from diet pop or coffee. Most say to use them with a diet and exercise -- well, of course, you will see weight-loss results with diet and exercise... > > Any real-world testimonies? > > Indyrose > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 30, 2010 Report Posted December 30, 2010 Thanks for the insight here. I've never used them, because I feel they are rather bogus, but what you've said also makes a lot of sense. My son has life-threatening allergies, and has on occasion needed an Epi-pen injection. (BIG stimulant!) He's an athletic teenage in very good condition, and he complained about how bad that made him feel, for hours. (Of course, he prefers breathing, so he tolerates the nasty side affects.) My diet is *somewhat* under control -- I need to watch portion sizes and occasional sugar binges. (Like last night, when DH wasn't feeling well and very grouchy - I hit the chocolates hard then...) But regular diet is low-fat-high-fiber and now I've been adding exercise to that. I was just wondering if it was worth looking into the diet pills, too. Doesn't seem so... Thanks again, Indyrose > > Hi Indyrose, > > Most OTC pills claim they are intended to help you lose weight by raising your metabolism (not Alli though which is nasty in different ways). Most do have some kind of stimulant. The stimulant speeds up your heart rate which also acts to speed up your metabolism (like cardio exercise does). So, in theory, yes, they do work. However, while you can stop exercising if you start feeling dizzy or faint because your heart is beating too fast, you cannot yank the " diet " pill out of our system and they can really wreak havoc with your health, including causing heart attacks and death. Also, like cardio, the effect of raising your metabolism is temporary. Your metabolism is up when your heart rate is up. Shortly after you stop exercising, your heart rate and later your metabolism return to their normal rate. Same thing with the pills. You have to keep exercising, or in this case popping pills, to keep your heart rate up and keep your metabolism up. At least with exercise you get tons of benefits in addition to weight loss. With the pills, you gamble and might lose all the benefits. The only way to raise your metabolism so that it stays higher in a healthy way is with strength training. More muscle equals more calorie buring even at rest. Cardio is extremely important for all kinds of reasons too so a balance of the two (plus flexibility training to keep joints supple) is ideal for weight loss and overall health. Exericise is at most 20-30% of the weight loss equation though so a healthy, balanced diet with an emphasis on portion control will do the rest of the job. > > Also, the stimulants and/or " water pills " might make also you lose weight by making you pee a lot. You're only temporarily losing water that way. It will come back and again, you're only putting extra stress on your kidneys, heart or other vital organs without adding any benefit to your health. > > I hope that helps! > > > > > Diet drugs/suppliments > > > > Does anyone use these? Are they affective at all? About the only one that my doctor said really worked at all was Alie, and that it had some really nasty consequences. I know most OTC diet pills are caffeine, which I can get from diet pop or coffee. Most say to use them with a diet and exercise -- well, of course, you will see weight-loss results with diet and exercise... > > Any real-world testimonies? > > Indyrose > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 30, 2010 Report Posted December 30, 2010 I'm attaching the PowerPoint from my Weight Management and Behavior class last Spring on Weight Loss Medications and Supplements. I have other notes on this chapter on my hard copy that I printed out before class that aren't on this PowerPoint, though, so I'll put them in the email for you. In the section about Medications vs. Supplements, I noted, Meal Replacement Shakes and Bars contain supplements but are not themselves classified as supplements. So, they aren't specifically mentioned in the other slides but the components of them are. In the section on medications I have noted that while not approved for long term use as weight loss drugs, other drugs can be marketed for off label use. Our class only covered the FDA approved drugs, not off label uses for other drugs. In the section on Weight Loss Medications where Sibutramine is mentioned and " Side Effects? " is listed on the slide, I noted high blood pressure and increased heart rate. On the same slide it talks about Orlistat (This is Alli BTW), the Side Effects I noted are diarrhea and leaks. In the section on Ephedrine (Ma Huang), I noted that it acts similarly to Sibutramine but without the selective seratonin reuptake inhibition.On the slide referring to the Ephedrine/Caffeine study, I noted that it had similar results to Sibutramine. On the slide referring to Chitosan, I noted that it is a polysaccaride.On the slide referring to Chromium, I noted that it may not help people without insulin issues. On the slide referring to Conjugated Linoleic Acid, I noted that a University of Iowa research study on pigs showed an increase in lean mass and a decrease in fat mass.Now, after all that, I will say that I personally consume my caffeine in Pepsi form and have taken a CLA supplement with good results. CLA doesn't have the stimulant effect that most other supplements have as it is a naturally occurring fat, so it is considered safe for most populations, even heart patients. Tonya Does anyone use these? Are they affective at all? About the only one that my doctor said really worked at all was Alie, and that it had some really nasty consequences. I know most OTC diet pills are caffeine, which I can get from diet pop or coffee. Most say to use them with a diet and exercise -- well, of course, you will see weight-loss results with diet and exercise... Any real-world testimonies? Indyrose -- Tonyawww.trainingwithtonya.comwww.smellabella.comwww.facebook.com/trainingwithtonya www.twitter.com/trainingwtonya 1 of 1 File(s) Medications and Supplements.pptx Quote
Guest guest Posted December 30, 2010 Report Posted December 30, 2010 The bottom line on the diet pills is there are not shortcuts to good health. I wish there were and I wish chocolate was one of them but, sigh, it ain't. Btw, occasional sugar binges are nothing to worry about, as long as they stay occasional and you're mostly under control they won't be deterrents to overall good health, including healthy weight. They can even promote it! Seriously! You can't be perfect all the time. If you expect yourself to be then you're going to continually disappoint yourself and that disappointment is going to throw you off track way more than an occasional sugar binge will. Splurging/treating yourself from time to time truly does help you stay in control. You'll find even your splurges aren't totally out of control when you allow yourself treats without guilt too! Diet drugs/suppliments> > > > Does anyone use these? Are they affective at all? About the only one that my doctor said really worked at all was Alie, and that it had some really nasty consequences. I know most OTC diet pills are caffeine, which I can get from diet pop or coffee. Most say to use them with a diet and exercise -- well, of course, you will see weight-loss results with diet and exercise...> > Any real-world testimonies?> > Indyrose> Quote
Guest guest Posted December 30, 2010 Report Posted December 30, 2010 Wow, that's a bit of research! I wish I could have seen the complete presentation so to get all the info from it. It sounds like I'm best to just lose weight the " natural " way. Thanks for posting that! Indyrose > > > > > > > Does anyone use these? Are they affective at all? About the only one that > > my doctor said really worked at all was Alie, and that it had some really > > nasty consequences. I know most OTC diet pills are caffeine, which I can get > > from diet pop or coffee. Most say to use them with a diet and exercise -- > > well, of course, you will see weight-loss results with diet and exercise... > > > > Any real-world testimonies? > > > > Indyrose > > > > > > > > > > -- > Tonya > www.trainingwithtonya.com > www.smellabella.com > www.facebook.com/trainingwithtonya > www.twitter.com/trainingwtonya > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 30, 2010 Report Posted December 30, 2010 The natural way is best. Though it may not be the fastest, it is the healthiest AND the most sustainable long-term. I think that is key. If you want to keep the weight off once you lose it, the best way to do that is to lose it in a way that you want to eventually become a lifestyle for you. That way, once the weight is off, you don't have to make any other big changes to keep it off. You just keep doing what you were doing for the most part and it is comfortable and sustainable. You also are less likely to yo-yo and that is much healthier than losing it fast with pills or quick weight loss plans and then gaining it back (often plus more) when you quit the pills or the difficult to keep going with plan. It also helps to have support in your journey from others who are also trying to lose (and maintain) weight. I lost 25 pounds with Weight Watchers and have kept it off for 4 1/2 years (and am now employed as a WW leader, going on 4 years this spring) because the support group atmosphere in the meetings and the accountability with another person weighing me in helps me tremendously. Other people find the support they need in online groups (Sparkpeople is very popular, WW has message boards free to anyone at weightwatchers.com, there are other good sites too) and of course, right here. (who has not been a model WW lately but has managed to maintain her happy weight throughout the holiday challenges anyway, especially with portion control) Re: Diet drugs/suppliments Wow, that's a bit of research! I wish I could have seen the complete presentation so to get all the info from it.It sounds like I'm best to just lose weight the "natural" way.Thanks for posting that!Indyrose> > >> >> > Does anyone use these? Are they affective at all? About the only one that> > my doctor said really worked at all was Alie, and that it had some really> > nasty consequences. I know most OTC diet pills are caffeine, which I can get> > from diet pop or coffee. Most say to use them with a diet and exercise --> > well, of course, you will see weight-loss results with diet and exercise...> >> > Any real-world testimonies?> >> > Indyrose> >> > > >> > > > -- > Tonya> www.trainingwithtonya.com> www.smellabella.com> www.facebook.com/trainingwithtonya> www.twitter.com/trainingwtonya> Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.