Guest guest Posted June 4, 2007 Report Share Posted June 4, 2007 Hi  My personal experience is don't waste your time. You will just end up frustrated and upset. My GP doesn't know anything about Eleanor's protocol or her results because I know he would have no interest and wouldn't support me.  There is very little in the protocol that would be available on the NHS anyway, so there is no need to tell them because they can't provide any of it for you. It will all have to be funded by you.  I do insist on blood work when I need it, like you, and I think with previous abnormal results you will have no problem getting them to fill in a blood form for you. They will probably do this over the phone and leave the form at the desk for you to collect. You can then nip down to Children's out patients and get them to do the draw for you. But that's as far as it goes for me. I always ask the practice manager to fax or copy the results for me so that I can send them to my DAN or whoever. It's very frustrating and it's wrong, but I find that if I spend time getting upset about the injustice in the system then it takes my focus and energy away from the real issue, i.e. healing my daughter. HTH, Joy Views/opinion - to give Paed/GP copy of Test Results and DAN report Hi Everyone, Please I need your your views/experiences about giving paediatricians /GP's the Report from a DAN and the results from poryphrin, amino acids, and OAT tests. Have you all provided your NHS docs with the results of the tests you've done? What about the proposed treatment - I get the feeling that this may not be a good idea (especially with B12 treatment and chelation). Is it "the less they know, the better" and a BIG risk if we inform them of everything? Our DAN has given us a letter to give our paediatrician requesting for her support with further tests (bloods) for liver function and kidney function as they (NHS) did some bloods a little while ago and some of ds's liver function tests were not in normal range. Then the elevated levels of urinary oxalate marker with an elevated urinary creatinine level and the NHS' recent finding of protein in a recent urine test which could be all attributed to kidney dysfunction and a probable side effect of the medical diet for his epilepsy. The letter also draws attention to the moderate to high level nutritional deficiencies in particular with the amino acids which are affected and can be again, by the restrictive ketogenic diet. Soooo... what do you think our chances of getting their support with these? I would really appreciate your thoughts, advice on this pleeeeasse. thanks, emily Get a FREE AOL Email account with 2GB of storage. Plus, share and store photos and experience exclusively recorded live music Sessions from your favourite artists. Click Here for more information. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2007 Report Share Posted June 4, 2007 Have to agree with that, we dont bother telling the doc's anything and in fact let our paed go, we dont use him anymore when he suggested drugs for my 3 year old! Further, we have had more than enough bloods and urine taken via NHS which to an observant eye, would show that our boy has some major problems, and even when the results come back with an exclamation mark next to them, from the lab, they do nothing. The simply dont want to know and they sure dont want you telling them. If you can get bloods and other tests done for free, by all means, but make sure you dont tell them why you need them, e.g. chelation, etc. Tell them you feel your child is anaemic or some other story before you tell them the real story. Best case scenario is that they will do the bloods and show a modicum of interest. Worst case scenario is you get accused of child abuse for taking " unecessary bloods " like what was intimated to me about our boy/tests. Even those docs who want to help are scared of setting a precedent, particularly with doctors being struck off or scrutinised regularly. They arent willing to jeapardise their careers over our kids. Which is why we have to be so vigilant and informed. > > > Hi > > > > My personal experience is don't waste your time. You will just end up frustrated and upset. My GP doesn't know anything about Eleanor's protocol or her results because I know he would have no interest and wouldn't support me. > > > > There is very little in the protocol that would be available on the NHS anyway, so there is no need to tell them because they can't provide any of it for you. It will all have to be funded by you. > > > > I do insist on blood work when I need it, like you, and I think with previous abnormal results you will have no problem getting them to fill in a blood form for you. They will probably do this over the phone and leave the form at the desk for you to collect. You can then nip down to Children's out patients and get them to do the draw for you. But that's as far as it goes for me. I always ask the practice manager to fax or copy the results for me so that I can send them to my DAN or whoever. > > It's very frustrating and it's wrong, but I find that if I spend time getting upset about the injustice in the system then it takes my focus and energy away from the real issue, i.e. healing my daughter. > > HTH, > Joy > > > Views/opinion - to give Paed/GP copy of Test Results and DAN report > > > > > > > > > Hi Everyone, > > Please I need your your views/experiences about giving paediatricians > /GP's the Report from a DAN and the results from poryphrin, amino acids, > and OAT tests. Have you all provided your NHS docs with the results of > the tests you've done? > > What about the proposed treatment - I get the feeling that this may not > be a good idea (especially with B12 treatment and chelation). Is it > " the less they know, the better " and a BIG risk if we inform them of > everything? > > Our DAN has given us a letter to give our paediatrician requesting for > her support with further tests (bloods) for liver function and kidney > function as they (NHS) did some bloods a little while ago and some of > ds's liver function tests were not in normal range. Then the elevated > levels of urinary oxalate marker with an elevated urinary creatinine > level and the NHS' recent finding of protein in a recent urine test > which could be all attributed to kidney dysfunction and a probable side > effect of the medical diet for his epilepsy. The letter also draws > attention to the moderate to high level nutritional deficiencies in > particular with the amino acids which are affected and can be again, by > the restrictive ketogenic diet. Soooo... what do you think our > chances of getting their support with these? > > I would really appreciate your thoughts, advice on this pleeeeasse. > > thanks, > > emily > > > > > > _____________________________________________________________________ ___ > Get a FREE AOL Email account with 2GB of storage. Plus, share and store photos and experience exclusively recorded live music Sessions from your favourite artists. Find out more at http://info.aol.co.uk/joinnow/?ncid=548. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2007 Report Share Posted June 4, 2007 On the other hand if you can do it without upsetting yourself, you may perform a public education service -- like vicky xx Sally joymroscoe@... wrote: > > Hi > > My personal experience is don't waste your time. You will just end up > frustrated and upset. My GP doesn't know anything about Eleanor's > protocol or her results because I know he would have no interest and > wouldn't support me. > > There is very little in the protocol that would be available on the > NHS anyway, so there is no need to tell them because they can't > provide any of it for you. It will all have to be funded by you. > > I do insist on blood work when I need it, like you, and I think with > previous abnormal results you will have no problem getting them to > fill in a blood form for you. They will probably do this over the > phone and leave the form at the desk for you to collect. You can then > nip down to Children's out patients and get them to do the draw for > you. But that's as far as it goes for me. I always ask the practice > manager to fax or copy the results for me so that I can send them to > my DAN or whoever. > > It's very frustrating and it's wrong, but I find that if I spend time > getting upset about the injustice in the system then it takes my focus > and energy away from the real issue, i.e. healing my daughter. > > HTH, > Joy > > > [Autism-Biomedical- Europe] Views/opinion - to give Paed/GP > copy of Test Results and DAN report > > > Hi Everyone, > > Please I need your your views/experiences about giving paediatricians > /GP's the Report from a DAN and the results from poryphrin, amino acids, > and OAT tests. Have you all provided your NHS docs with the results of > the tests you've done? > > What about the proposed treatment - I get the feeling that this may not > be a good idea (especially with B12 treatment and chelation). Is it > " the less they know, the better " and a BIG risk if we inform them of > everything? > > Our DAN has given us a letter to give our paediatrician requesting for > her support with further tests (bloods) for liver function and kidney > function as they (NHS) did some bloods a little while ago and some of > ds's liver function tests were not in normal range. Then the elevated > levels of urinary oxalate marker with an elevated urinary creatinine > level and the NHS' recent finding of protein in a recent urine test > which could be all attributed to kidney dysfunction and a probable side > effect of the medical diet for his epilepsy. The letter also draws > attention to the moderate to high level nutritional deficiencies in > particular with the amino acids which are affected and can be again, by > the restrictive ketogenic diet. Soooo... what do you think our > chances of getting their support with these? > > I would really appreciate your thoughts, advice on this pleeeeasse. > > thanks, > > emily > > Get a FREE AOL Email account with 2GB of storage. Plus, share and > store photos and experience exclusively recorded live music Sessions > from your favourite artists. Click Here > <http://info.aol.co.uk/joinnow/?ncid=548> for more information. > > ------------------------------------------------------------------------ > > No virus found in this incoming message. > Checked by AVG Free Edition. > Version: 7.5.472 / Virus Database: 269.8.7/830 - Release Date: 03/06/2007 12:47 > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2007 Report Share Posted June 4, 2007 I've always copied everything to Paed and GP. And the NHS still stumps up for a lot of testing for Tom including recent calprothingy test. Our paed is pretty much opposed to biomed but my view is that it's a significant factor in Tom's well being, TOm's her patient and therefore she is obliged to know all about it. We consulted her before we started chelation - she said she wouldn't recommend it but couldn't see how it was harmful. In part we want the powers that be to know what we're doing so they can't kick up but I appreciate that that won't work for all paeds. I just feel easier being honest with everyone, it's not as if we're following quack theories, DAN Is pretty established whether you subscribe to it or not. Our GP finally authorised HBOT one full year after we first asked him! Steph x > > > Hi Everyone, > > Please I need your your views/experiences about giving paediatricians > /GP's the Report from a DAN and the results from poryphrin, amino acids, > and OAT tests. Have you all provided your NHS docs with the results of > the tests you've done? > > What about the proposed treatment - I get the feeling that this may not > be a good idea (especially with B12 treatment and chelation). Is it > " the less they know, the better " and a BIG risk if we inform them of > everything? > > Our DAN has given us a letter to give our paediatrician requesting for > her support with further tests (bloods) for liver function and kidney > function as they (NHS) did some bloods a little while ago and some of > ds's liver function tests were not in normal range. Then the elevated > levels of urinary oxalate marker with an elevated urinary creatinine > level and the NHS' recent finding of protein in a recent urine test > which could be all attributed to kidney dysfunction and a probable side > effect of the medical diet for his epilepsy. The letter also draws > attention to the moderate to high level nutritional deficiencies in > particular with the amino acids which are affected and can be again, by > the restrictive ketogenic diet. Soooo... what do you think our > chances of getting their support with these? > > I would really appreciate your thoughts, advice on this pleeeeasse. > > thanks, > > emily > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2007 Report Share Posted June 4, 2007 You are lucky Steph with your paed. Mine phoned my dr to say if we were doing chelation then she was going to inform the social services because it was a case of child abuse. I lied and said we weren't. Peta-- - In Autism-Biomedical-Europe , " stephaniesirr " wrote: > > I've always copied everything to Paed and GP. And the NHS still > stumps up for a lot of testing for Tom including recent calprothingy > test. Our paed is pretty much opposed to biomed but my view is that > it's a significant factor in Tom's well being, TOm's her patient and > therefore she is obliged to know all about it. > > We consulted her before we started chelation - she said she wouldn't > recommend it but couldn't see how it was harmful. > > In part we want the powers that be to know what we're doing so they > can't kick up but I appreciate that that won't work for all paeds. I > just feel easier being honest with everyone, it's not as if we're > following quack theories, DAN Is pretty established whether you > subscribe to it or not. > > Our GP finally authorised HBOT one full year after we first asked him! > Steph x > > > > > > > Hi Everyone, > > > > Please I need your your views/experiences about giving paediatricians > > /GP's the Report from a DAN and the results from poryphrin, amino acids, > > and OAT tests. Have you all provided your NHS docs with the results of > > the tests you've done? > > > > What about the proposed treatment - I get the feeling that this may not > > be a good idea (especially with B12 treatment and chelation). Is it > > " the less they know, the better " and a BIG risk if we inform them of > > everything? > > > > Our DAN has given us a letter to give our paediatrician requesting for > > her support with further tests (bloods) for liver function and kidney > > function as they (NHS) did some bloods a little while ago and some of > > ds's liver function tests were not in normal range. Then the elevated > > levels of urinary oxalate marker with an elevated urinary creatinine > > level and the NHS' recent finding of protein in a recent urine test > > which could be all attributed to kidney dysfunction and a probable side > > effect of the medical diet for his epilepsy. The letter also draws > > attention to the moderate to high level nutritional deficiencies in > > particular with the amino acids which are affected and can be again, by > > the restrictive ketogenic diet. Soooo... what do you think our > > chances of getting their support with these? > > > > I would really appreciate your thoughts, advice on this pleeeeasse. > > > > thanks, > > > > emily > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2007 Report Share Posted June 4, 2007 No, we put the test results before her and said we've been recommended to do this course of action, is it dangerous? (i.e. before we made up our minds whether to do it or not). We've never gone to the NHS with a fait accompli that was contentious. These social services threats are really interesting because they show bugger all interest when you're fighting to get 4 hours a week of support. Perhaps the short cut is... no, being flippant. Sxx > > > > > > > > > Hi Everyone, > > > > > > Please I need your your views/experiences about giving > paediatricians > > > /GP's the Report from a DAN and the results from poryphrin, amino > acids, > > > and OAT tests. Have you all provided your NHS docs with the > results of > > > the tests you've done? > > > > > > What about the proposed treatment - I get the feeling that this > may not > > > be a good idea (especially with B12 treatment and chelation). > Is it > > > " the less they know, the better " and a BIG risk if we inform them > of > > > everything? > > > > > > Our DAN has given us a letter to give our paediatrician > requesting for > > > her support with further tests (bloods) for liver function and > kidney > > > function as they (NHS) did some bloods a little while ago and > some of > > > ds's liver function tests were not in normal range. Then the > elevated > > > levels of urinary oxalate marker with an elevated urinary > creatinine > > > level and the NHS' recent finding of protein in a recent urine > test > > > which could be all attributed to kidney dysfunction and a > probable side > > > effect of the medical diet for his epilepsy. The letter also > draws > > > attention to the moderate to high level nutritional deficiencies > in > > > particular with the amino acids which are affected and can be > again, by > > > the restrictive ketogenic diet. Soooo... what do you think our > > > chances of getting their support with these? > > > > > > I would really appreciate your thoughts, advice on this > pleeeeasse. > > > > > > thanks, > > > > > > emily > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2007 Report Share Posted June 4, 2007 Also, she's in no way supportive of chelation (which keeps getting typed as collation in her letters and therefore should evade any data capture!!) Sx > > > > > > > > > Hi Everyone, > > > > > > Please I need your your views/experiences about giving > paediatricians > > > /GP's the Report from a DAN and the results from poryphrin, amino > acids, > > > and OAT tests. Have you all provided your NHS docs with the > results of > > > the tests you've done? > > > > > > What about the proposed treatment - I get the feeling that this > may not > > > be a good idea (especially with B12 treatment and chelation). > Is it > > > " the less they know, the better " and a BIG risk if we inform them > of > > > everything? > > > > > > Our DAN has given us a letter to give our paediatrician > requesting for > > > her support with further tests (bloods) for liver function and > kidney > > > function as they (NHS) did some bloods a little while ago and > some of > > > ds's liver function tests were not in normal range. Then the > elevated > > > levels of urinary oxalate marker with an elevated urinary > creatinine > > > level and the NHS' recent finding of protein in a recent urine > test > > > which could be all attributed to kidney dysfunction and a > probable side > > > effect of the medical diet for his epilepsy. The letter also > draws > > > attention to the moderate to high level nutritional deficiencies > in > > > particular with the amino acids which are affected and can be > again, by > > > the restrictive ketogenic diet. Soooo... what do you think our > > > chances of getting their support with these? > > > > > > I would really appreciate your thoughts, advice on this > pleeeeasse. > > > > > > thanks, > > > > > > emily > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 5, 2007 Report Share Posted June 5, 2007 Hi Steph I didn't really mean you were lucky I was just saying that mine is dangerous. She is in charge of child protection and could make our lives miserable so I stay stum. She also couldn't pronounce chelation. Don't you love narrow minded, smug(mine is) paeds?! Peta -- In Autism-Biomedical-Europe , " stephaniesirr " wrote: > > Also, she's in no way supportive of chelation (which keeps getting > typed as collation in her letters and therefore should evade any data > capture!!) > Sx > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Hi Everyone, > > > > > > > > Please I need your your views/experiences about giving > > paediatricians > > > > /GP's the Report from a DAN and the results from poryphrin, amino > > acids, > > > > and OAT tests. Have you all provided your NHS docs with the > > results of > > > > the tests you've done? > > > > > > > > What about the proposed treatment - I get the feeling that this > > may not > > > > be a good idea (especially with B12 treatment and chelation). > > Is it > > > > " the less they know, the better " and a BIG risk if we inform them > > of > > > > everything? > > > > > > > > Our DAN has given us a letter to give our paediatrician > > requesting for > > > > her support with further tests (bloods) for liver function and > > kidney > > > > function as they (NHS) did some bloods a little while ago and > > some of > > > > ds's liver function tests were not in normal range. Then the > > elevated > > > > levels of urinary oxalate marker with an elevated urinary > > creatinine > > > > level and the NHS' recent finding of protein in a recent urine > > test > > > > which could be all attributed to kidney dysfunction and a > > probable side > > > > effect of the medical diet for his epilepsy. The letter also > > draws > > > > attention to the moderate to high level nutritional deficiencies > > in > > > > particular with the amino acids which are affected and can be > > again, by > > > > the restrictive ketogenic diet. Soooo... what do you think our > > > > chances of getting their support with these? > > > > > > > > I would really appreciate your thoughts, advice on this > > pleeeeasse. > > > > > > > > thanks, > > > > > > > > emily > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 5, 2007 Report Share Posted June 5, 2007 Don't worry, I took " lucky " in truly the comparative sense of the word! It's a pretty low bar when it comes to paeds currently. I think that will change. I wish it would hurry up. Steph x > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Hi Everyone, > > > > > > > > > > Please I need your your views/experiences about giving > > > paediatricians > > > > > /GP's the Report from a DAN and the results from poryphrin, > amino > > > acids, > > > > > and OAT tests. Have you all provided your NHS docs with the > > > results of > > > > > the tests you've done? > > > > > > > > > > What about the proposed treatment - I get the feeling that > this > > > may not > > > > > be a good idea (especially with B12 treatment and > chelation). > > > Is it > > > > > " the less they know, the better " and a BIG risk if we inform > them > > > of > > > > > everything? > > > > > > > > > > Our DAN has given us a letter to give our paediatrician > > > requesting for > > > > > her support with further tests (bloods) for liver function > and > > > kidney > > > > > function as they (NHS) did some bloods a little while ago and > > > some of > > > > > ds's liver function tests were not in normal range. Then > the > > > elevated > > > > > levels of urinary oxalate marker with an elevated urinary > > > creatinine > > > > > level and the NHS' recent finding of protein in a recent > urine > > > test > > > > > which could be all attributed to kidney dysfunction and a > > > probable side > > > > > effect of the medical diet for his epilepsy. The letter also > > > draws > > > > > attention to the moderate to high level nutritional > deficiencies > > > in > > > > > particular with the amino acids which are affected and can be > > > again, by > > > > > the restrictive ketogenic diet. Soooo... what do you think > our > > > > > chances of getting their support with these? > > > > > > > > > > I would really appreciate your thoughts, advice on this > > > pleeeeasse. > > > > > > > > > > thanks, > > > > > > > > > > emily > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.