Guest guest Posted January 1, 2007 Report Share Posted January 1, 2007 I have a good friend who is possibly the world's best mother. When she was being interviewed by the social services agency prior to adopting her daughter, she repeatedly made reference to her experience in training dogs as preparation for motherhood. The agency nearly refused her application until a more enlightened member investigated her experience and training (oops, there's that word) in behavior management. My point is that people who react to a word like training should look more deeply into what training really is. I do train my dogs, using sound ABA principles, much as I train my students. I am able to use ABA because I have been trained in applied behavior analysis myself. I just cannot see training as a bad thing or a bad word. R Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2007 Report Share Posted January 2, 2007 I agree completely. Sara Re: Eye Contact Triggers Threat Signals in Autistic Children's Brains I have a good friend who is possibly the world's best mother. When she was being interviewed by the social services agency prior to adopting her daughter, she repeatedly made reference to her experience in training dogs as preparation for motherhood. The agency nearly refused her application until a more enlightened member investigated her experience and training (oops, there's that word) in behavior management. My point is that people who react to a word like training should look more deeply into what training really is. I do train my dogs, using sound ABA principles, much as I train my students. I am able to use ABA because I have been trained in applied behavior analysis myself. I just cannot see training as a bad thing or a bad word.R Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2007 Report Share Posted January 2, 2007 I agree completely. Sara Re: Eye Contact Triggers Threat Signals in Autistic Children's Brains I have a good friend who is possibly the world's best mother. When she was being interviewed by the social services agency prior to adopting her daughter, she repeatedly made reference to her experience in training dogs as preparation for motherhood. The agency nearly refused her application until a more enlightened member investigated her experience and training (oops, there's that word) in behavior management. My point is that people who react to a word like training should look more deeply into what training really is. I do train my dogs, using sound ABA principles, much as I train my students. I am able to use ABA because I have been trained in applied behavior analysis myself. I just cannot see training as a bad thing or a bad word.R Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2007 Report Share Posted January 3, 2007 I've been living with Border Collies for 13 years now. For those of you not familiar with the breed, they're considered probably the smartest dog in the world, bred to run hundreds of miles per day and to do one task--herd, finish the job and never give up. The result is a very smart, quirky, obsessive dog who can spend 20 hours frozen in one place staring at a cat, can be bothered by the slightest noise, obsess over shadows, have rituals before eating, you name it. A smart, often understood, quirky obsessive animal. Dogs are dog and they are not people. However, what I have learned from my border collies, living and training them all these years has helped me beyond anything I can describe when working with my son who is on the spectrum. I've lived with quirks and obsessions and learned how to work around fears, etc. If they start rating dogs on the autism scale, border collies will be at the top of the list. I don't mean to offend anyone, and yes there is a BIG difference between dogs and children, but at the same time, consistency is the key and you need to be very clear with dogs what your requests are and so on. Having a background in training animals or understanding how to mold behavior is incredibly helpful with kids autistic or not! I see nothing wrong with suggesting that training animals has helped a person prepare to be a parent as while it is very different, I take from my experiences with my dogs every day and it has been nothing but helpful. My son is doing great and in a way a lot of it has to do with my understanding of dogs, particularly Border Collies! And just as a side note, we don't do ABA either. > Well,one can only wonder why a social worker would be concerned with a potential parent who compares their preparation and experience in training dogs to raising children . I don't subscribe to the principals of ABA so perhaps that's why I don't take to well to the concept of " training " children but that's a whole other subject.The point I was trying to make regarding this study is that sometimes there are more things that can be learned about autism that don't involve science,blind studies and placebos.I personally have learned more from talking to autistics themselves and hearing from their experiences than I have from any publishings I've ever read. > > Stacey > > From: <luvsbt@...> > Date: 2007/01/01 Mon PM 03:17:11 CST > autism > Subject: Re: Eye Contact Triggers Threat Signals in Autistic Children's Brains > > I have a good friend who is possibly the world's best mother. When shewas being interviewed by the social services agency prior to adoptingher daughter, she repeatedly made reference to her experience intraining dogs as preparation for motherhood. The agency nearly refusedher application until a more enlightened member investigated herexperience and training (oops, there's that word) in behaviormanagement. My point is that people who react to a word like trainingshould look more deeply into what training really is. I do train mydogs, using sound ABA principles, much as I train my students. I amable to use ABA because I have been trained in applied behavioranalysis myself. I just cannot see training as a bad thing ora bad word. > R > > > > > > > __________________________________________________ > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2007 Report Share Posted January 3, 2007 I've been living with Border Collies for 13 years now. For those of you not familiar with the breed, they're considered probably the smartest dog in the world, bred to run hundreds of miles per day and to do one task--herd, finish the job and never give up. The result is a very smart, quirky, obsessive dog who can spend 20 hours frozen in one place staring at a cat, can be bothered by the slightest noise, obsess over shadows, have rituals before eating, you name it. A smart, often understood, quirky obsessive animal. Dogs are dog and they are not people. However, what I have learned from my border collies, living and training them all these years has helped me beyond anything I can describe when working with my son who is on the spectrum. I've lived with quirks and obsessions and learned how to work around fears, etc. If they start rating dogs on the autism scale, border collies will be at the top of the list. I don't mean to offend anyone, and yes there is a BIG difference between dogs and children, but at the same time, consistency is the key and you need to be very clear with dogs what your requests are and so on. Having a background in training animals or understanding how to mold behavior is incredibly helpful with kids autistic or not! I see nothing wrong with suggesting that training animals has helped a person prepare to be a parent as while it is very different, I take from my experiences with my dogs every day and it has been nothing but helpful. My son is doing great and in a way a lot of it has to do with my understanding of dogs, particularly Border Collies! And just as a side note, we don't do ABA either. > Well,one can only wonder why a social worker would be concerned with a potential parent who compares their preparation and experience in training dogs to raising children . I don't subscribe to the principals of ABA so perhaps that's why I don't take to well to the concept of " training " children but that's a whole other subject.The point I was trying to make regarding this study is that sometimes there are more things that can be learned about autism that don't involve science,blind studies and placebos.I personally have learned more from talking to autistics themselves and hearing from their experiences than I have from any publishings I've ever read. > > Stacey > > From: <luvsbt@...> > Date: 2007/01/01 Mon PM 03:17:11 CST > autism > Subject: Re: Eye Contact Triggers Threat Signals in Autistic Children's Brains > > I have a good friend who is possibly the world's best mother. When shewas being interviewed by the social services agency prior to adoptingher daughter, she repeatedly made reference to her experience intraining dogs as preparation for motherhood. The agency nearly refusedher application until a more enlightened member investigated herexperience and training (oops, there's that word) in behaviormanagement. My point is that people who react to a word like trainingshould look more deeply into what training really is. I do train mydogs, using sound ABA principles, much as I train my students. I amable to use ABA because I have been trained in applied behavioranalysis myself. I just cannot see training as a bad thing ora bad word. > R > > > > > > > __________________________________________________ > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.