Guest guest Posted May 8, 2002 Report Posted May 8, 2002 Gill I wish you all the very best in your new venture it sounds very exciting. It is heart wrenching to leave behind something into which you have put so much of yourself and frightening to be standing on the edge of the diving board and preparing to launch into something of the unknown. However doing new things and meeting new people facing new challenges and finding creative solutions is a very exhilarating way to live life. Gill I would never have described you as an 'ordinary practitioner' and I feel sure that you wont be ordinary in Faithworks. Very good luck for the future and I hope you will keep in touch. >From: Gill Newell <GC.Newell@...> >Reply- > " ' ' " < > >Subject: goodbye >Date: Wed, 8 May 2002 15:05:50 +0100 > >Dear Colleagues > >I'm writing to let you know that I have decided to leave health visiting >and the NHS. This has been the hardest decision I've ever made. I'm >moving into the voluntary sector, where I will be involved in a new >national project called Faithworks, a christian project which aims to >enable faith groups/churches to identify community needs and to provide >good quality services to fill the gaps, and to work in partnership with >other agencies. Still health visiting but by another name...? > >I have greatly valued the support and encouragement from Senate and I feel >very privileged to have participated. I know that Senate will continue to >inspire, guide and empower ordinary practitioners like me; I hope you go >from strength to strength! > >Best wishes > >Gill Newell _________________________________________________________________ Chat with friends online, try MSN Messenger: http://messenger.msn.com Quote
Guest guest Posted May 8, 2002 Report Posted May 8, 2002 Dear Gill, Good luck in your new venture. Does this goodbye meant that you are going to unsubscribe? We will be sorry to loose you if it does. You could still keep in touch. I am sad that you couldn't stay in health visiting and do what you are going to do for Faithworks. Is this a reflection on the state of health visiting or on the vision of Faithworks or a mixture of both. I really wish you well Gill and hope that the job is all that you would want it to be. I agree with it does sound exciting. Best wishes, goodbye > Dear Colleagues > > I'm writing to let you know that I have decided to leave health visiting > and the NHS. This has been the hardest decision I've ever made. I'm > moving into the voluntary sector, where I will be involved in a new > national project called Faithworks, a christian project which aims to > enable faith groups/churches to identify community needs and to provide > good quality services to fill the gaps, and to work in partnership with > other agencies. Still health visiting but by another name...? > > I have greatly valued the support and encouragement from Senate and I feel > very privileged to have participated. I know that Senate will continue to > inspire, guide and empower ordinary practitioners like me; I hope you go > from strength to strength! > > Best wishes > > Gill Newell > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted May 13, 2002 Report Posted May 13, 2002 Yes, Gill, I would echo what the others have said: good luck with your new venture which sounds exciting. Yes, it is sad when (extra)-ordinary practitioners like yourself feel that the only way to use health visiting skills, work in a health visiting way and keep their ideals and principles intact is to go to another post that is not called health visiting. Please don't leave Senate: keep us posted with your activities! I am currently very interested in the idea of 'health visiting' being undertaken by health visitors outside the NHS, by people whose role is called something else and would love to hear more once you have got started. best wishes Gill Newell wrote: >Dear Colleagues > >I'm writing to let you know that I have decided to leave health visiting >and the NHS. This has been the hardest decision I've ever made. I'm >moving into the voluntary sector, where I will be involved in a new >national project called Faithworks, a christian project which aims to >enable faith groups/churches to identify community needs and to provide >good quality services to fill the gaps, and to work in partnership with >other agencies. Still health visiting but by another name...? > >I have greatly valued the support and encouragement from Senate and I feel >very privileged to have participated. I know that Senate will continue to >inspire, guide and empower ordinary practitioners like me; I hope you go >from strength to strength! > >Best wishes > >Gill Newell > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted May 14, 2002 Report Posted May 14, 2002 Gill, I haven't forgotten your help with your sharing the questionnaire that you sent to hv in your area and will feedback to you as and when we have something less thatn very draft (what is your individual email address?). Good luck in your new role but, as I was told when a student " once a health visitor always a health visitor " and I feel that is true - on my personal experience. TOity On Mon, 13 May 2002 22:39:20 +0100 Cowley <sarah@...> wrote: > Yes, Gill, I would echo what the others have said: good luck with your > new venture which sounds exciting. Yes, it is sad when (extra)-ordinary > practitioners like yourself feel that the only way to use health > visiting skills, work in a health visiting way and keep their ideals and > principles intact is to go to another post that is not called health > visiting. > > Please don't leave Senate: keep us posted with your activities! > > I am currently very interested in the idea of 'health visiting' being > undertaken by health visitors outside the NHS, by people whose role is > called something else and would love to hear more once you have got > started. best wishes > > > > > > Gill Newell wrote: > > >Dear Colleagues > > > >I'm writing to let you know that I have decided to leave > health visiting >and the NHS. This has been the hardest > decision I've ever made. I'm >moving into the voluntary > sector, where I will be involved in a new >national project > called Faithworks, a christian project which aims to > >enable faith groups/churches to identify community needs > and to provide >good quality services to fill the gaps, and > to work in partnership with >other agencies. Still health > visiting but by another name...? > > >I have greatly valued the support and encouragement from > Senate and I feel >very privileged to have participated. > I know that Senate will continue to >inspire, guide and > empower ordinary practitioners like me; I hope you go >from > strength to strength! > > >Best wishes > > >Gill Newell > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted May 26, 2002 Report Posted May 26, 2002 goodbye All best wishes for courage in your new venture Gill Marjorie Talbot St Clements Oxford > Dear Colleagues > > I'm writing to let you know that I have decided to leave health visiting > and the NHS. This has been the hardest decision I've ever made. I'm > moving into the voluntary sector, where I will be involved in a new > national project called Faithworks, a christian project which aims to > enable faith groups/churches to identify community needs and to provide > good quality services to fill the gaps, and to work in partnership with > other agencies. Still health visiting but by another name...? > > I have greatly valued the support and encouragement from Senate and I feel > very privileged to have participated. I know that Senate will continue to > inspire, guide and empower ordinary practitioners like me; I hope you go > from strength to strength! > > Best wishes > > Gill Newell > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2003 Report Posted September 18, 2003 I guess I missed all the fuss since I tend to blow past some subjects that don't grab my interest. But you might consider that there are many many people on this list that may be helpful to you or that could use your ideas that may not have been part of whatever upset you. It would be a shame to sign off just because of the comments of one person. Gaylen Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2003 Report Posted September 18, 2003 I guess I missed all the fuss since I tend to blow past some subjects that don't grab my interest. But you might consider that there are many many people on this list that may be helpful to you or that could use your ideas that may not have been part of whatever upset you. It would be a shame to sign off just because of the comments of one person. Gaylen Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2003 Report Posted September 18, 2003 -I don't think YOU are the one who should be going!!! We in the autism community NEED teachers like you!! I'm ashamed of this type of behavior and there is NO excuse for it. -- In Autism Treatment , " teacher_n_texas78 " <kmcmillan78@h...> wrote: > As if being yelled at and dealt with in a rude manner wasn't enough. I > recieved an email at my private email address from Ronnie. Lets just > say it wasn't a friendly greeting. After reading it I am saying goodbye > to this group. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2003 Report Posted September 18, 2003 -I don't think YOU are the one who should be going!!! We in the autism community NEED teachers like you!! I'm ashamed of this type of behavior and there is NO excuse for it. -- In Autism Treatment , " teacher_n_texas78 " <kmcmillan78@h...> wrote: > As if being yelled at and dealt with in a rude manner wasn't enough. I > recieved an email at my private email address from Ronnie. Lets just > say it wasn't a friendly greeting. After reading it I am saying goodbye > to this group. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2003 Report Posted September 18, 2003 -I don't think YOU are the one who should be going!!! We in the autism community NEED teachers like you!! I'm ashamed of this type of behavior and there is NO excuse for it. -- In Autism Treatment , " teacher_n_texas78 " <kmcmillan78@h...> wrote: > As if being yelled at and dealt with in a rude manner wasn't enough. I > recieved an email at my private email address from Ronnie. Lets just > say it wasn't a friendly greeting. After reading it I am saying goodbye > to this group. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2003 Report Posted September 18, 2003 Please forgive me, but I wrote personally incase you had already unsubscribed. I'm sorry for your decision. Ronnie's comments were not representative of all our opinions. From what I know of Guppy, the list owner, she will censure Ronnie for her actions. I hope you'll consider rejoining the list. If not, please keep my address. I'd be happy to exchange ideas and views on " our " kids anytime. My son is 9 and I don't know a lot about the older children's issues, but are learning. Thanks for your time, Tonya Hettler Texas Rep, Unlocking Autism http://www.unlockingautism.org Federation of Families Technical Liaison for the Texas Panhandle http://www.txffcmh.org Goodbye As if being yelled at and dealt with in a rude manner wasn't enough. I recieved an email at my private email address from Ronnie. Lets just say it wasn't a friendly greeting. After reading it I am saying goodbye to this group. Unlocking Autism www.UnlockingAutism.org Autism-Awareness-Action Worldwide internet group for parents who have a child with AUTISM. Schafer Autism Report News and information on Autism To Subscribe http://home.sprynet.com/~schafer/index.html Healing Autism: No Finer Cause on the Planet Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2003 Report Posted September 18, 2003 Please forgive me, but I wrote personally incase you had already unsubscribed. I'm sorry for your decision. Ronnie's comments were not representative of all our opinions. From what I know of Guppy, the list owner, she will censure Ronnie for her actions. I hope you'll consider rejoining the list. If not, please keep my address. I'd be happy to exchange ideas and views on " our " kids anytime. My son is 9 and I don't know a lot about the older children's issues, but are learning. Thanks for your time, Tonya Hettler Texas Rep, Unlocking Autism http://www.unlockingautism.org Federation of Families Technical Liaison for the Texas Panhandle http://www.txffcmh.org Goodbye As if being yelled at and dealt with in a rude manner wasn't enough. I recieved an email at my private email address from Ronnie. Lets just say it wasn't a friendly greeting. After reading it I am saying goodbye to this group. Unlocking Autism www.UnlockingAutism.org Autism-Awareness-Action Worldwide internet group for parents who have a child with AUTISM. Schafer Autism Report News and information on Autism To Subscribe http://home.sprynet.com/~schafer/index.html Healing Autism: No Finer Cause on the Planet Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2003 Report Posted September 18, 2003 I second Connie's thoughts--we parents really need teachers like you. Thank you so much for taking the time to attempt to learn more. I sincerely hope that you will reconsider and, stay on with us. My twins, Ben & Joe, would be lucky to have a dedicated teacher such as yourself. Sure we get testy at times--that is a by-product of an autism spectrum disorder, but we always look out for one another, and that includes educators who want to learn more so they can help to provide our children and loved ones with an appropriate education. If that's not enough, if you agree to stay-----I'll wash your car the next time I'm in San !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! My best. Peacefully, Jeff Sell 1st Vice Chairman--Autism Society of America Chair--ASA Government Relations Committee www.autism-society.org 832-731-3145 www.jzslaw.com JZSell@... Re: Goodbye -I don't think YOU are the one who should be going!!! We in the autism community NEED teachers like you!! I'm ashamed of this type of behavior and there is NO excuse for it. -- In Autism Treatment , " teacher_n_texas78 " <kmcmillan78@h...> wrote: > As if being yelled at and dealt with in a rude manner wasn't enough. I > recieved an email at my private email address from Ronnie. Lets just > say it wasn't a friendly greeting. After reading it I am saying goodbye > to this group. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2003 Report Posted September 18, 2003 I second Connie's thoughts--we parents really need teachers like you. Thank you so much for taking the time to attempt to learn more. I sincerely hope that you will reconsider and, stay on with us. My twins, Ben & Joe, would be lucky to have a dedicated teacher such as yourself. Sure we get testy at times--that is a by-product of an autism spectrum disorder, but we always look out for one another, and that includes educators who want to learn more so they can help to provide our children and loved ones with an appropriate education. If that's not enough, if you agree to stay-----I'll wash your car the next time I'm in San !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! My best. Peacefully, Jeff Sell 1st Vice Chairman--Autism Society of America Chair--ASA Government Relations Committee www.autism-society.org 832-731-3145 www.jzslaw.com JZSell@... Re: Goodbye -I don't think YOU are the one who should be going!!! We in the autism community NEED teachers like you!! I'm ashamed of this type of behavior and there is NO excuse for it. -- In Autism Treatment , " teacher_n_texas78 " <kmcmillan78@h...> wrote: > As if being yelled at and dealt with in a rude manner wasn't enough. I > recieved an email at my private email address from Ronnie. Lets just > say it wasn't a friendly greeting. After reading it I am saying goodbye > to this group. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2003 Report Posted September 18, 2003 I don't understand why this teacher is so upset over Ronnie's comments. When she wrote this email blasting her student's parents...she had to expect that some parents would get defensive. I really don't think Ronnie set out to alienate the teacher. I think she was just trying to help the teacher see the parents point of view. I for one would be very offened if my son's teacher insisted I try the gfcf diet and to put my child on meds. That is a personal decision for my family and my family alone to make. How can a teacher even think to criticize me for not going the route she thinks is " right " . Some parents simply can not put their children on the diet for many reasons. This diet is expensive, time consuming, and extremely difficult. I put my son on the diet for almost a year and we were all miserable and it didn't do a thing for us. My other kids suffered because of the gfcf diet as well. They ended up having to eat anywhere from the laundry room to the backyard so that my son with autism will not try to snatch their non gfcf snacks. I know that this teacher is just trying to help...but don't you think it's going a little overboard to threaten to leave a group because of one parent that had differeing ideas? Chris > > As if being yelled at and dealt with in a rude manner wasn't > enough. I > > recieved an email at my private email address from Ronnie. Lets > just > > say it wasn't a friendly greeting. After reading it I am saying > goodbye > > to this group. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2003 Report Posted September 18, 2003 I don't understand why this teacher is so upset over Ronnie's comments. When she wrote this email blasting her student's parents...she had to expect that some parents would get defensive. I really don't think Ronnie set out to alienate the teacher. I think she was just trying to help the teacher see the parents point of view. I for one would be very offened if my son's teacher insisted I try the gfcf diet and to put my child on meds. That is a personal decision for my family and my family alone to make. How can a teacher even think to criticize me for not going the route she thinks is " right " . Some parents simply can not put their children on the diet for many reasons. This diet is expensive, time consuming, and extremely difficult. I put my son on the diet for almost a year and we were all miserable and it didn't do a thing for us. My other kids suffered because of the gfcf diet as well. They ended up having to eat anywhere from the laundry room to the backyard so that my son with autism will not try to snatch their non gfcf snacks. I know that this teacher is just trying to help...but don't you think it's going a little overboard to threaten to leave a group because of one parent that had differeing ideas? Chris > > As if being yelled at and dealt with in a rude manner wasn't > enough. I > > recieved an email at my private email address from Ronnie. Lets > just > > say it wasn't a friendly greeting. After reading it I am saying > goodbye > > to this group. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2003 Report Posted September 18, 2003 I was surprise to hear e the teacher had resigned from the group after reading her last post and she sounded sad and frustrated I emailed her individually to be positive and supportive but I guess my e-mail wasn't the only one she got. Largely the response she has gotten from the list has mainly been positive and I am sorry to see her go- hopefully she will reconsider. I too think it is helpful to get a different opinnion because sometimes I can get tunnel vision. I'll keep her in my thoughts Jeneane Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2003 Report Posted September 18, 2003 I was surprise to hear e the teacher had resigned from the group after reading her last post and she sounded sad and frustrated I emailed her individually to be positive and supportive but I guess my e-mail wasn't the only one she got. Largely the response she has gotten from the list has mainly been positive and I am sorry to see her go- hopefully she will reconsider. I too think it is helpful to get a different opinnion because sometimes I can get tunnel vision. I'll keep her in my thoughts Jeneane Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2003 Report Posted September 18, 2003 Chris: I'm just trying to be a peacemaker and let folks know that discussion is always welcome from apparently differing points of view. We're all in this darn autism boat together. I always appreciate constructive dialogue. So often, we parents get caught up in " preaching to the choir " on so many of the list serves these days. While that isn't bad in and of itself, it just doesn't produce solutions to the problems we deal with on a daily basis. I have always been under the impression that all points of view are welcome. That has been 's intent from day one of this list. I hope it stays that way. My best. Peacefully, Jeff Sell Z. Sell, P.C. 4309 Yoakum Blvd. 2nd Floor Houston, Texas 77006 713-654-7776 713-654-7789 (fax) 832-731-3145 (cell) JZSell@... www.JZSLAW.com Re: Goodbye I don't understand why this teacher is so upset over Ronnie's comments. When she wrote this email blasting her student's parents...she had to expect that some parents would get defensive. I really don't think Ronnie set out to alienate the teacher. I think she was just trying to help the teacher see the parents point of view. I for one would be very offened if my son's teacher insisted I try the gfcf diet and to put my child on meds. That is a personal decision for my family and my family alone to make. How can a teacher even think to criticize me for not going the route she thinks is " right " . Some parents simply can not put their children on the diet for many reasons. This diet is expensive, time consuming, and extremely difficult. I put my son on the diet for almost a year and we were all miserable and it didn't do a thing for us. My other kids suffered because of the gfcf diet as well. They ended up having to eat anywhere from the laundry room to the backyard so that my son with autism will not try to snatch their non gfcf snacks. I know that this teacher is just trying to help...but don't you think it's going a little overboard to threaten to leave a group because of one parent that had differeing ideas? Chris > > As if being yelled at and dealt with in a rude manner wasn't > enough. I > > recieved an email at my private email address from Ronnie. Lets > just > > say it wasn't a friendly greeting. After reading it I am saying > goodbye > > to this group. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2003 Report Posted September 18, 2003 Chris: I'm just trying to be a peacemaker and let folks know that discussion is always welcome from apparently differing points of view. We're all in this darn autism boat together. I always appreciate constructive dialogue. So often, we parents get caught up in " preaching to the choir " on so many of the list serves these days. While that isn't bad in and of itself, it just doesn't produce solutions to the problems we deal with on a daily basis. I have always been under the impression that all points of view are welcome. That has been 's intent from day one of this list. I hope it stays that way. My best. Peacefully, Jeff Sell Z. Sell, P.C. 4309 Yoakum Blvd. 2nd Floor Houston, Texas 77006 713-654-7776 713-654-7789 (fax) 832-731-3145 (cell) JZSell@... www.JZSLAW.com Re: Goodbye I don't understand why this teacher is so upset over Ronnie's comments. When she wrote this email blasting her student's parents...she had to expect that some parents would get defensive. I really don't think Ronnie set out to alienate the teacher. I think she was just trying to help the teacher see the parents point of view. I for one would be very offened if my son's teacher insisted I try the gfcf diet and to put my child on meds. That is a personal decision for my family and my family alone to make. How can a teacher even think to criticize me for not going the route she thinks is " right " . Some parents simply can not put their children on the diet for many reasons. This diet is expensive, time consuming, and extremely difficult. I put my son on the diet for almost a year and we were all miserable and it didn't do a thing for us. My other kids suffered because of the gfcf diet as well. They ended up having to eat anywhere from the laundry room to the backyard so that my son with autism will not try to snatch their non gfcf snacks. I know that this teacher is just trying to help...but don't you think it's going a little overboard to threaten to leave a group because of one parent that had differeing ideas? Chris > > As if being yelled at and dealt with in a rude manner wasn't > enough. I > > recieved an email at my private email address from Ronnie. Lets > just > > say it wasn't a friendly greeting. After reading it I am saying > goodbye > > to this group. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2003 Report Posted September 18, 2003 I think one reason parents become frustrated is the knee jerk assumption by some school staff that if the child is having a bad day, it must be either medication related or something happening at home. Very seldom is the event that occurred really analyzed to determine what happened and why the response occurred. Without carefully assessing the situation too often the antecedents are missed and the leap to consequences occurs. The only correlation I can offer would be to consider that your child (substitute pet if you don't have kids) is ill. The symptoms are vague, but you know something is wrong. You talk to a nurse in the doctor's office and she says she has only been working there are a few months and has never heard of anything like you are describing. She recommends a few things, but you are uncomfortable. You make an appointment to go see the doctor who saw your child last year and who you are comfortable with. When you get there you find your usual doctor is out of the office, but his associate will see your child. After examining your child the new doctor tells you that this is only his second year as a pediatrician and he's never seen this problem before, but he writes you a prescription. You leave, but are apprehensive about the treatment because you don't have a relationship with this person yet. You call back and the nurse tells you that he is a doctor and you should trust him. Some people will feel good about getting the prescription filled as they assume anyone who gets through med school should be able to handle this. Some people might wait and try to run it by their usual physician first or call a friend to ask advice. Others may be angry because they don't feel the problem was handled properly. It really doesn't matter whether it's your child, cat or washing machine, many people need to feel good about the person handling the problem. With new teachers often every year and kids that don't come home telling you every detail of their school day, it's often hard to trust people until they have proven themselves trustworthy. Relationships have to be built over time and teachers need to understand that parents have a lot on their plate. I have never met a parent who thought " Gee, I think I'll take my kid off medication so I can really mess up his behavior at school " . If a parent is making med changes and there are problems at school because of it, a teacher can call a meeting and talk about their concerns face to face. Also, parents of kids with autism, just like all people in every other situation in life, come to the table with different personalities, strengths, weaknesses, stresses and past experiences. The best years my son has had at school were those where we had very open relationships with the staff, met frequently and where my concerns and ideas were encouraged and given equal weight to those of the staff. Getting on a list like this can certainly help a teacher learn more about autism, but it cannot replace meeting with and developing a relationship with that family. There are no cookie cutter treatments for autism and to assume a GFCF diet is a necessary intervention for all kids with autism is incorrect. And certainly the older the child and more negative your school experiences have been, the more frustrated you become. Even when things are going pretty well, the whole special ed experience can be draining, not to mention all we do at home and worrying about what happens when we aren't around anymore-which begins to feel more imminent as you approach 50 and your child is shaving. Getting your feelings hurt when people don't agree with you is part of life, but it's important to be able to buck up and deal with that especially in jobs like teaching. You'll never agree with everyone and it's not realistic to expect it. Jill On Thursday, September 18, 2003, at 11:30 AM, christina95132 wrote: > > I don't understand why this teacher is so upset over Ronnie's > comments. When she wrote this email blasting her student's > parents...she had to expect that some parents would get defensive. I > really don't think Ronnie set out to alienate the teacher. I think > she was just trying to help the teacher see the parents point of > view. I for one would be very offened if my son's teacher insisted I > try the gfcf diet and to put my child on meds. That is a personal > decision for my family and my family alone to make. How can a teacher > even think to criticize me for not going the route she thinks > is " right " . Some parents simply can not put their children on the > diet for many reasons. This diet is expensive, time consuming, and > extremely difficult. I put my son on the diet for almost a year and > we were all miserable and it didn't do a thing for us. My other kids > suffered because of the gfcf diet as well. They ended up having to > eat anywhere from the laundry room to the backyard so that my son > with autism will not try to snatch their non gfcf snacks. I know that > this teacher is just trying to help...but don't you think it's going > a little overboard to threaten to leave a group because of one parent > that had differeing ideas? > > Chris Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2003 Report Posted September 18, 2003 I think one reason parents become frustrated is the knee jerk assumption by some school staff that if the child is having a bad day, it must be either medication related or something happening at home. Very seldom is the event that occurred really analyzed to determine what happened and why the response occurred. Without carefully assessing the situation too often the antecedents are missed and the leap to consequences occurs. The only correlation I can offer would be to consider that your child (substitute pet if you don't have kids) is ill. The symptoms are vague, but you know something is wrong. You talk to a nurse in the doctor's office and she says she has only been working there are a few months and has never heard of anything like you are describing. She recommends a few things, but you are uncomfortable. You make an appointment to go see the doctor who saw your child last year and who you are comfortable with. When you get there you find your usual doctor is out of the office, but his associate will see your child. After examining your child the new doctor tells you that this is only his second year as a pediatrician and he's never seen this problem before, but he writes you a prescription. You leave, but are apprehensive about the treatment because you don't have a relationship with this person yet. You call back and the nurse tells you that he is a doctor and you should trust him. Some people will feel good about getting the prescription filled as they assume anyone who gets through med school should be able to handle this. Some people might wait and try to run it by their usual physician first or call a friend to ask advice. Others may be angry because they don't feel the problem was handled properly. It really doesn't matter whether it's your child, cat or washing machine, many people need to feel good about the person handling the problem. With new teachers often every year and kids that don't come home telling you every detail of their school day, it's often hard to trust people until they have proven themselves trustworthy. Relationships have to be built over time and teachers need to understand that parents have a lot on their plate. I have never met a parent who thought " Gee, I think I'll take my kid off medication so I can really mess up his behavior at school " . If a parent is making med changes and there are problems at school because of it, a teacher can call a meeting and talk about their concerns face to face. Also, parents of kids with autism, just like all people in every other situation in life, come to the table with different personalities, strengths, weaknesses, stresses and past experiences. The best years my son has had at school were those where we had very open relationships with the staff, met frequently and where my concerns and ideas were encouraged and given equal weight to those of the staff. Getting on a list like this can certainly help a teacher learn more about autism, but it cannot replace meeting with and developing a relationship with that family. There are no cookie cutter treatments for autism and to assume a GFCF diet is a necessary intervention for all kids with autism is incorrect. And certainly the older the child and more negative your school experiences have been, the more frustrated you become. Even when things are going pretty well, the whole special ed experience can be draining, not to mention all we do at home and worrying about what happens when we aren't around anymore-which begins to feel more imminent as you approach 50 and your child is shaving. Getting your feelings hurt when people don't agree with you is part of life, but it's important to be able to buck up and deal with that especially in jobs like teaching. You'll never agree with everyone and it's not realistic to expect it. Jill On Thursday, September 18, 2003, at 11:30 AM, christina95132 wrote: > > I don't understand why this teacher is so upset over Ronnie's > comments. When she wrote this email blasting her student's > parents...she had to expect that some parents would get defensive. I > really don't think Ronnie set out to alienate the teacher. I think > she was just trying to help the teacher see the parents point of > view. I for one would be very offened if my son's teacher insisted I > try the gfcf diet and to put my child on meds. That is a personal > decision for my family and my family alone to make. How can a teacher > even think to criticize me for not going the route she thinks > is " right " . Some parents simply can not put their children on the > diet for many reasons. This diet is expensive, time consuming, and > extremely difficult. I put my son on the diet for almost a year and > we were all miserable and it didn't do a thing for us. My other kids > suffered because of the gfcf diet as well. They ended up having to > eat anywhere from the laundry room to the backyard so that my son > with autism will not try to snatch their non gfcf snacks. I know that > this teacher is just trying to help...but don't you think it's going > a little overboard to threaten to leave a group because of one parent > that had differeing ideas? > > Chris Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2003 Report Posted September 18, 2003 I agree Jill Levine Re: Re: Goodbye I think one reason parents become frustrated is the knee jerk assumption by some school staff that if the child is having a bad day, it must be either medication related or something happening at home. Very seldom is the event that occurred really analyzed to determine what happened and why the response occurred. Without carefully assessing the situation too often the antecedents are missed and the leap to consequences occurs. The only correlation I can offer would be to consider that your child (substitute pet if you don't have kids) is ill. The symptoms are vague, but you know something is wrong. You talk to a nurse in the doctor's office and she says she has only been working there are a few months and has never heard of anything like you are describing. She recommends a few things, but you are uncomfortable. You make an appointment to go see the doctor who saw your child last year and who you are comfortable with. When you get there you find your usual doctor is out of the office, but his associate will see your child. After examining your child the new doctor tells you that this is only his second year as a pediatrician and he's never seen this problem before, but he writes you a prescription. You leave, but are apprehensive about the treatment because you don't have a relationship with this person yet. You call back and the nurse tells you that he is a doctor and you should trust him. Some people will feel good about getting the prescription filled as they assume anyone who gets through med school should be able to handle this. Some people might wait and try to run it by their usual physician first or call a friend to ask advice. Others may be angry because they don't feel the problem was handled properly. It really doesn't matter whether it's your child, cat or washing machine, many people need to feel good about the person handling the problem. With new teachers often every year and kids that don't come home telling you every detail of their school day, it's often hard to trust people until they have proven themselves trustworthy. Relationships have to be built over time and teachers need to understand that parents have a lot on their plate. I have never met a parent who thought " Gee, I think I'll take my kid off medication so I can really mess up his behavior at school " . If a parent is making med changes and there are problems at school because of it, a teacher can call a meeting and talk about their concerns face to face. Also, parents of kids with autism, just like all people in every other situation in life, come to the table with different personalities, strengths, weaknesses, stresses and past experiences. The best years my son has had at school were those where we had very open relationships with the staff, met frequently and where my concerns and ideas were encouraged and given equal weight to those of the staff. Getting on a list like this can certainly help a teacher learn more about autism, but it cannot replace meeting with and developing a relationship with that family. There are no cookie cutter treatments for autism and to assume a GFCF diet is a necessary intervention for all kids with autism is incorrect. And certainly the older the child and more negative your school experiences have been, the more frustrated you become. Even when things are going pretty well, the whole special ed experience can be draining, not to mention all we do at home and worrying about what happens when we aren't around anymore-which begins to feel more imminent as you approach 50 and your child is shaving. Getting your feelings hurt when people don't agree with you is part of life, but it's important to be able to buck up and deal with that especially in jobs like teaching. You'll never agree with everyone and it's not realistic to expect it. Jill On Thursday, September 18, 2003, at 11:30 AM, christina95132 wrote: > > I don't understand why this teacher is so upset over Ronnie's > comments. When she wrote this email blasting her student's > parents...she had to expect that some parents would get defensive. I > really don't think Ronnie set out to alienate the teacher. I think she > was just trying to help the teacher see the parents point of view. I > for one would be very offened if my son's teacher insisted I try the > gfcf diet and to put my child on meds. That is a personal decision for > my family and my family alone to make. How can a teacher even think to > criticize me for not going the route she thinks is " right " . Some > parents simply can not put their children on the diet for many > reasons. This diet is expensive, time consuming, and extremely > difficult. I put my son on the diet for almost a year and we were all > miserable and it didn't do a thing for us. My other kids suffered > because of the gfcf diet as well. They ended up having to eat anywhere > from the laundry room to the backyard so that my son with autism will > not try to snatch their non gfcf snacks. I know that this teacher is > just trying to help...but don't you think it's going a little > overboard to threaten to leave a group because of one parent that had > differeing ideas? > > Chris Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2003 Report Posted September 18, 2003 I agree Jill Levine Re: Re: Goodbye I think one reason parents become frustrated is the knee jerk assumption by some school staff that if the child is having a bad day, it must be either medication related or something happening at home. Very seldom is the event that occurred really analyzed to determine what happened and why the response occurred. Without carefully assessing the situation too often the antecedents are missed and the leap to consequences occurs. The only correlation I can offer would be to consider that your child (substitute pet if you don't have kids) is ill. The symptoms are vague, but you know something is wrong. You talk to a nurse in the doctor's office and she says she has only been working there are a few months and has never heard of anything like you are describing. She recommends a few things, but you are uncomfortable. You make an appointment to go see the doctor who saw your child last year and who you are comfortable with. When you get there you find your usual doctor is out of the office, but his associate will see your child. After examining your child the new doctor tells you that this is only his second year as a pediatrician and he's never seen this problem before, but he writes you a prescription. You leave, but are apprehensive about the treatment because you don't have a relationship with this person yet. You call back and the nurse tells you that he is a doctor and you should trust him. Some people will feel good about getting the prescription filled as they assume anyone who gets through med school should be able to handle this. Some people might wait and try to run it by their usual physician first or call a friend to ask advice. Others may be angry because they don't feel the problem was handled properly. It really doesn't matter whether it's your child, cat or washing machine, many people need to feel good about the person handling the problem. With new teachers often every year and kids that don't come home telling you every detail of their school day, it's often hard to trust people until they have proven themselves trustworthy. Relationships have to be built over time and teachers need to understand that parents have a lot on their plate. I have never met a parent who thought " Gee, I think I'll take my kid off medication so I can really mess up his behavior at school " . If a parent is making med changes and there are problems at school because of it, a teacher can call a meeting and talk about their concerns face to face. Also, parents of kids with autism, just like all people in every other situation in life, come to the table with different personalities, strengths, weaknesses, stresses and past experiences. The best years my son has had at school were those where we had very open relationships with the staff, met frequently and where my concerns and ideas were encouraged and given equal weight to those of the staff. Getting on a list like this can certainly help a teacher learn more about autism, but it cannot replace meeting with and developing a relationship with that family. There are no cookie cutter treatments for autism and to assume a GFCF diet is a necessary intervention for all kids with autism is incorrect. And certainly the older the child and more negative your school experiences have been, the more frustrated you become. Even when things are going pretty well, the whole special ed experience can be draining, not to mention all we do at home and worrying about what happens when we aren't around anymore-which begins to feel more imminent as you approach 50 and your child is shaving. Getting your feelings hurt when people don't agree with you is part of life, but it's important to be able to buck up and deal with that especially in jobs like teaching. You'll never agree with everyone and it's not realistic to expect it. Jill On Thursday, September 18, 2003, at 11:30 AM, christina95132 wrote: > > I don't understand why this teacher is so upset over Ronnie's > comments. When she wrote this email blasting her student's > parents...she had to expect that some parents would get defensive. I > really don't think Ronnie set out to alienate the teacher. I think she > was just trying to help the teacher see the parents point of view. I > for one would be very offened if my son's teacher insisted I try the > gfcf diet and to put my child on meds. That is a personal decision for > my family and my family alone to make. How can a teacher even think to > criticize me for not going the route she thinks is " right " . Some > parents simply can not put their children on the diet for many > reasons. This diet is expensive, time consuming, and extremely > difficult. I put my son on the diet for almost a year and we were all > miserable and it didn't do a thing for us. My other kids suffered > because of the gfcf diet as well. They ended up having to eat anywhere > from the laundry room to the backyard so that my son with autism will > not try to snatch their non gfcf snacks. I know that this teacher is > just trying to help...but don't you think it's going a little > overboard to threaten to leave a group because of one parent that had > differeing ideas? > > Chris Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2003 Report Posted September 18, 2003 How can we hope to establish a dialogue with teachers if we only drive them away? I too sent e encourage e-mails privately hoping that would smooth over any hurt feelings. It's just another reminder that we can't put " teachers " or " parents " or " kids with autism " in a group and make assumptions. I think we're all so sleep deprived, we forget how stressed out we really are. --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.489 / Virus Database: 288 - Release Date: 6/10/03 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.