Re: kidney pain and EDTA tetra sodium salt

[Guest guest]

My completely non-educated guess on this would be that it's doing it's

job and helping you detox, but it's just overtaxing your kidneys. How

long does it take the pain to go away if you stop the EDTA completely?

If it were me, I'd cut back the dose, by mixing one drop in 8 oz of

water, and then trying 1 oz of that, and see if you get any pain as a

result. If not, work your way up a bit at a time until you get to a

level where it starts to hurt again, then back down a step from there

for your regular dose. Just my 2 cents' worth, YMMV etc.

Marcia on

in Salem, Massachusetts

On Dec 8, 2011, at 3:03 PM, nil wrote:

> Hi all

>

> Doctor prescribed me a supplement containing EDTA tetrasodium

> salt(Sodium edetate), It was for heavy metal detox and mostly used

> for children. Recommended dosage is 3 drops three times a day. I

> started with one drop per day but it gives me kidney pain.I do not

> know what is going on if kidney pain occurs while taking a

> supplement. Why does kidney pain occur?Does it mean it is damaging

> kidneys or what? Pain is not at extreme level. I can handle it but I

> do not wish to damage my kidneys.Would you think I should continue

> taking this supplement while having this kidney pain. Thanks

> nil

>

>

[Guest guest]

nil wrote:

> Doctor prescribed me a supplement containing EDTA tetrasodium salt(Sodium

edetate), It was for heavy metal detox and mostly used for children. Recommended

dosage is 3 drops three times a day. I started with one drop per day but it

gives me kidney pain.I do not know what is going on if kidney pain occurs while

taking a supplement. Why does kidney pain occur?Does it mean it is damaging

kidneys or what? Pain is not at extreme level. I can handle it but I do not wish

to damage my kidneys.Would you think I should continue taking this supplement

while having this kidney pain. Thanks

You should call your doctor and report the problem. How can you expect

people who are not physicians to diagnose what is going on with you?

You are asking people to diagnose you. That is illegal. And you have

no way of knowing for sure whether the pain is actually coming from your

kidneys or some other organ. Pain can be referred.

Jeri <teewinot13@...>

@>--->---->-------------------<----<---<@

Dr. Pall's NO/ONOO- Theory/Treatment Discussion Group:

TenthParadigmSociety

@>----------<---------->-----------------------<----------<----------<@

The Tenth Paradigm - Dr. Pall's Website for CFS/MCS/FM/ETC.:

http://www.thetenthparadigm.org

@>----------<---------->-----------------------<----------<----------<@

MCS-Florida - For All Chemically Sensitive Floridians

MCS-Florida

[Guest guest]

Hi Jeri

If I was able to ask my doctor I would not ask it here.Plus if i did not know it

was kidney pain i would not say that it was kidney pain.Your note made me feel

like i was treated as stupid.

Nil

Re: kidney pain and EDTA tetra sodium salt

nil wrote:

> Doctor prescribed me a supplement containing EDTA tetrasodium salt(Sodium

edetate), It was for heavy metal detox and mostly used for children. Recommended

dosage is 3 drops three times a day. I started with one drop per day but it

gives me kidney pain.I do not know what is going on if kidney pain occurs while

taking a supplement. Why does kidney pain occur?Does it mean it is damaging

kidneys or what? Pain is not at extreme level. I can handle it but I do not wish

to damage my kidneys.Would you think I should continue taking this supplement

while having this kidney pain. Thanks

You should call your doctor and report the problem. How can you expect

people who are not physicians to diagnose what is going on with you?

You are asking people to diagnose you. That is illegal. And you have

no way of knowing for sure whether the pain is actually coming from your

kidneys or some other organ. Pain can be referred.

[Guest guest]

Coffee enemas help the kidneys when detoxing

On Dec 9, 2011, at 2:04 PM, Teewinot wrote:

> nil wrote:

>

> > Doctor prescribed me a supplement containing EDTA tetrasodium salt(Sodium

edetate), It was for heavy metal detox and mostly used for children. Recommended

dosage is 3 drops three times a day. I started with one drop per day but it

gives me kidney pain.I do not know what is going on if kidney pain occurs while

taking a supplement. Why does kidney pain occur?Does it mean it is damaging

kidneys or what? Pain is not at extreme level. I can handle it but I do not wish

to damage my kidneys.Would you think I should continue taking this supplement

while having this kidney pain. Thanks

>

> You should call your doctor and report the problem. How can you expect

> people who are not physicians to diagnose what is going on with you?

> You are asking people to diagnose you. That is illegal. And you have

> no way of knowing for sure whether the pain is actually coming from your

> kidneys or some other organ. Pain can be referred.

>

> Jeri <teewinot13@...>

> @>--->---->-------------------<----<---<@

> Dr. Pall's NO/ONOO- Theory/Treatment Discussion Group:

> TenthParadigmSociety

> @>----------<---------->-----------------------<----------<----------<@

> The Tenth Paradigm - Dr. Pall's Website for CFS/MCS/FM/ETC.:

> http://www.thetenthparadigm.org

> @>----------<---------->-----------------------<----------<----------<@

> MCS-Florida - For All Chemically Sensitive Floridians

> MCS-Florida

>

>

[Guest guest]

I had a lot of kidney pain when using antibiotics

I believed my body was filtering a lot of die off via the kidneys

I used a lot of water to keep them flushing

I also used a formula called kidney activator from natures sunshine

Also coffee enemas helped a lot the explanation for that was coffee enemas help

the liver do it job of filtering better so it takes a load off the kidneys ..

when I used the enema my kidney pain decreased by about fifty percent

also I took time off the antibiotics from time to time to give my kidneys a

break

On Dec 10, 2011, at 1:20 AM, nil wrote:

> Hi Jeri

>

> If I was able to ask my doctor I would not ask it here.Plus if i did not know

it was kidney pain i would not say that it was kidney pain.Your note made me

feel like i was treated as stupid.

> Nil

> Re: kidney pain and EDTA tetra sodium salt

>

> nil wrote:

>

> > Doctor prescribed me a supplement containing EDTA tetrasodium salt(Sodium

edetate), It was for heavy metal detox and mostly used for children. Recommended

dosage is 3 drops three times a day. I started with one drop per day but it

gives me kidney pain.I do not know what is going on if kidney pain occurs while

taking a supplement. Why does kidney pain occur?Does it mean it is damaging

kidneys or what? Pain is not at extreme level. I can handle it but I do not wish

to damage my kidneys.Would you think I should continue taking this supplement

while having this kidney pain. Thanks

>

> You should call your doctor and report the problem. How can you expect

> people who are not physicians to diagnose what is going on with you?

> You are asking people to diagnose you. That is illegal. And you have

> no way of knowing for sure whether the pain is actually coming from your

> kidneys or some other organ. Pain can be referred.

>

>

>

[Guest guest]

Hi, nil.

I recommend that you read this:

http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5508a3.htm

I also recommend that you check with your doctor before taking more of this type

of EDTA.

Best regards,

Rich

>

> Hi all

>

> Doctor prescribed me a supplement containing EDTA tetrasodium salt(Sodium

edetate), It was for heavy metal detox and mostly used for children. Recommended

dosage is 3 drops three times a day. I started with one drop per day but it

gives me kidney pain.I do not know what is going on if kidney pain occurs while

taking a supplement. Why does kidney pain occur?Does it mean it is damaging

kidneys or what? Pain is not at extreme level. I can handle it but I do not wish

to damage my kidneys.Would you think I should continue taking this supplement

while having this kidney pain. Thanks

> nil

>

>

[Guest guest]

EDTA comes in suppository form too -- I wonder if that would be better

tolerated?

I like Solaray Kidney SP-6 formula when my kidneys feel strained. It seems to

help me after having bad reactions to kidney-toxic meds.

Peggy