Who Controls Medical Research in U.S.?

[Guest guest]

http://www.emaxhealth.com/24/5009.html

Is Society Losing Control of The Medical Research Agenda?

Posted by: BMJ on 03-17-2006.

" Medical research depends on funding from the private sector, in particular

from biotechnology and drug companies, but this funding may lead to

conflicts of interest. "

Is society losing control of the medical research agenda? ask experts in a

study published online by the BMJ today (17 March 2006).

Medical research depends on funding from the private sector, in particular

from biotechnology and drug companies, but this funding may lead to

conflicts of interest about the results of medical research.

To measure the potential impact of public funding compared to industry

funding, researchers analysed the affiliations of authors and the funding

sources of the most frequently cited medical research papers from 1994 to

2003. Top-cited papers have a major impact on scientific thinking.

Of the 289 most frequently cited articles, most had at least one author with

a university (76%) or hospital (57%) affiliation.

Government or public funding was most common (60% of articles), followed by

industry (36%). However, the proportion of articles funded by industry

increased over the decade and by 2001, more than 50% of funding came from

industry, surpassing funding from government or public sources.

Sixty five of the 77 top-cited randomised controlled trials received funding

from industry, whereas government and public sources funded only 32 trials.

The proportion of trials funded by industry also increased significantly

over time. Eighteen of the 32 most cited trials published after 1999 were

funded by industry alone.

Participation of academics in influential medical research has remained

strong, despite the perceived crisis in academic medicine, say the authors.

Yet industry funds an increasing proportion of this research, especially

randomised controlled trials, most of which are now funded exclusively by

industry.

They suggest that the role of industry should be scrutinised further. They

also believe that medical research should reflect public needs more closely

and the efforts of all those involved (government, industry, and academia)

should be better coordinated.

--------------------------------------------------------

Sheri Nakken, R.N., MA, Hahnemannian Homeopath

Vaccination Information & Choice Network, Nevada City CA & Wales UK

Vaccines - http://www.nccn.net/~wwithin/vaccine.htm