Guest guest Posted December 7, 2010 Report Posted December 7, 2010 Dear Pat, Your message have been very helpful. After one year one year on anti-thyroid drug, I feel well for one year. Now it recurred hyperthyroidism and the specialist nurse said once it's back it won't got away and suggested radiodine. I read your last point about the cookware. Can you give me more information on that? I have been using aluminium pressure cooker and rice cooker, and non stick coated pans for frying. Do you mean I should avoid them all together. Your reply would be highly appreciated. Thank you. Donna On 7 December 2010 19:07, <nambucca@...> wrote: Having worked for one of the 1st doctors to give RAI and heard the patients stories and to have married a man who developed Graves /Hyperthyroid age 27 who was bamboozled into the OP age 40 and was told RAI was not safe in anyone under 40 i would from bitter experience say NO NO NO to any such intervention Theres a survey which proved that after RAI 50% of patients became Hypothyroid After 5 years 90% of all patients either RAI or OP became Hypothyroid My husband has suffered the entire gamut of Thyroid Disease and been totally misdiagnosed and mistreated over the course of 40 years Even though he is now on Armour he will never be well and far too much damage has been done to his body Block and replace is a better treatment as far as i can see along with finding a really good Homeopath who genuinely knows how to restore your body Above all do not smoke and do not use Aluminium or non stick coated ( flouride ) cookware Pat Quote
Guest guest Posted December 7, 2010 Report Posted December 7, 2010 Dear Pat, Your message has been very helpful. After one year one year on anti-thyroid drug, I feel well for one year. Now it recurred hyperthyroidism and the specialist nurse said once it's back it won't got away and suggested radiodine. I read your last point about the cookware. Can you give me more information on that? I have been using aluminium pressure cooker and rice cooker, and non stick coated pans for frying. Do you mean I should avoid them all together. Your reply would be highly appreciated. Thank you. Donna Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 Dear Donna I also have Graves and I am also being treated with drugs (carbimazole) and I am told that this is my best hope for remission. My endocrinologist says that whilst RAI and thyroidectomy (operation) are choices that are there if things really become impossible on drugs, he thinks by far the best treatment is on ATDs even if I need to stay on a low dose drug for ten or twenty years, provided I feel well he doesn’t care. He also says it’s a marathon not a sprint. I’m not sure your nurse is right that they can’t get you under control again – perhaps she means that Graves is auto-immune disease so you will always have it in the background, but I’m not sure she’s right that there is no point trying again with drugs. My endo also said he doesn’t care about ‘normal’ blood results – he said only endocrinologists who don’t know what they are doing with Graves are obsessed with ‘normal’ results, he said he is more concerned that I’m healthy, well, feeling good and able to function. So he’s going to run me a little high in the range, or even just over normal range (i.e. showing a ‘hyper’ blood result, technically) because it is most likely that is where I will feel well. I should also say we’ve been trying for almost six months to get me stable, and I have relapsed into ‘hyper’ several times in that time, and he is not concerned about that either, so unless your results are very high (ie you are very toxic and therefore in danger) I would query their advice. I suggest you get a second opinion – I’m sure your specialist nurse is well qualified for a nurse, but you need to speak to an endocrinologist who specialises in Graves Disease. Not just any endocrinologist, but a Thyroid endo, who lives and breathes Graves disease. I’ve seen my endo today and he’s told me that it is a ‘partnership’ between me and him – an equal partnership. He also said, ‘ultimately you get to choose what to do to your body, but I am not going to let you make any life changing choices until I am satisfied that it is you choosing and not your illness’. Graves can make us hasty and sometimes it is our symptoms not our personality that is making choices. Unless it is an emergency, you have plenty of time, do not let them bully you into making a decision you are not ready to make. If you feel well on drugs, maybe they just need to adjust the dose you are on? I also agree with Pat that stopping smoking is the best thing you can do to help yourself. I’d also recommend the book ‘Graves Disease – A Practical Guide’ by Elaine . She also has a website. Take care Your message has been very helpful. After one year one year on anti-thyroid drug, I feel well for one year. Now it recurred hyperthyroidism and the specialist nurse said once it's back it won't got away and suggested radiodine. I am using the Free version of SPAMfighter.SPAMfighter has removed 3222 of my spam emails to date.Do you have a slow PC? Try free scan! Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 Dear , Thank you very much for your invaluable advice. That really helped. I will get the book you recommended. You don't know how much I appreciated it. Best wirhses. Donna On 8 December 2010 15:27, <rebecca@...> wrote: Dear Donna I also have Graves and I am also being treated with drugs (carbimazole) and I am told that this is my best hope for remission. My endocrinologist says that whilst RAI and thyroidectomy (operation) are choices [Ed] Quote
Guest guest Posted December 9, 2010 Report Posted December 9, 2010 Hi Pat I too was given the choice of an op or RAI for graves disease, I opted for the latter. This is the worst decision of my life. The endo told me the RAI would most likely make the thyroid normal again. How wrong she was. For 2 years now I have been ill with severe hypo symptoms. My blood levels are now within the 'normal' range but I certainly am not feeling normal. I have fought for Armour which she will not prescribe, saying it is dangerous, and now she won't see me anymore. You said your husband has the Armour, does your GP prescribe it, as my GP wont because he said it is out of his remit. Does your GP see private patients as I need to know a doctor who will prescribe me it. I am getting desperate now as I have been off work for 6 months now and financially struggling as well as all the physical problems. Sorry about the long miserable letter. Hope you can help Thanks Avril > > Having worked for one of the 1st doctors to give RAI and heard the patients stories > and to have married a man who developed Graves /Hyperthyroid age 27 who was bamboozled into the OP age 40 and was told RAI was not safe in anyone under 40 i would from bitter experience say NO NO NO to any such intervention > > Theres a survey which proved that after RAI 50% of patients became Hypothyroid > > After 5 years 90% of all patients either RAI or OP became Hypothyroid > > > My husband has suffered the entire gamut of Thyroid Disease and been totally misdiagnosed and mistreated over the course of 40 years > > Even though he is now on Armour he will never be well and far too much damage has been done to his body > > Block and replace is a better treatment as far as i can see along with finding a really good Homeopath who genuinely knows how to restore your body > > Above all do not smoke and do not use Aluminium or non stick coated ( flouride ) cookware > > Pat > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 9, 2010 Report Posted December 9, 2010 Hi Donna, I'm also suffering from Graves' disease for the second time and was advised last August to have an operation to remove my thyroid as soon as. I refused the option and I am now on carbimazole only. I can't say I'm feeling 100% as I seem to have gone Hypo and I'm also loosing my hair but I am still hoping that eventually I will be on the right medication. Worth investigating further and finding out all the options before accepting the advices of your specialist nurse. Quote
Guest guest Posted December 9, 2010 Report Posted December 9, 2010 Neither is a good idea .If I knew then what I know now I would not touch the surgery I had ten years ago with a barge pole {and no to RAI] I would certainly keep to the carbimazole but you must be tested regularly I ended up hypo . Best wishes Quote
Guest guest Posted December 9, 2010 Report Posted December 9, 2010 Hi , I wonder why the specialist nurse made radiodine sounded like the best option. Clean and easy, when you go hypo, just take a hormone supplement. She said long term use of carbimazole will cause osteoporosis. I think it's true. The side effect of the carbimazole is suppressing our bone marrow and our calcium level. But no information clarifies at what dose of the drug use would likely to cause osteoporosis. I really look forward to the Practical Guide I ordered to arrive. Donna --- In thyroid treatment , pgelthooft@... : > > Hi Donna, I'm also suffering from Graves' disease for the second time and was advised last August to have an operation to remove my thyroid as soon as. I refused the option and I am now on carbimazole only. I can't say I'm feeling 100% as I seem to have gone Hypo and I'm also loosing my hair but I am still hoping that eventually I will be on the right medication. Worth investigating further and finding out all the options before accepting the advices of your specialist nurse. > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 9, 2010 Report Posted December 9, 2010 Hi Donna, it could be your nurse is right. To be honest I don't know much about radiodine as in my case they advised me the removal of the thyroid rather than radiodine due to my eyes protruding slightly. Apparently radiodine accentuates thyroid eye problems. I'm sure taking carbimazole is not great in the long term but I thought the risk of osteoperosis was more to do with suffering from hypo or hyperthyroidism and the lack of adequate treatment. Best > > > Hi , > > I wonder why the specialist nurse made radiodine sounded like the best option. Clean and easy, when you go hypo, just take a hormone supplement. > fore accepting the advices of your specialist nurse. > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 9, 2010 Report Posted December 9, 2010 On Thu, 09 Dec 2010 15:21:44 -0000, you wrote: > >I am getting desperate now as I have been off work for 6 months now and financially struggling as well as all the physical problems. There is a very good chance that the excess T4 that comes with Graves will cause Reverse T3 (RT3) to be produced. Even after the excess is cleared this RT3 lingers causing receptor blockage and hence resistance to T3. The solution is to get your T4 levels low for a few months by going to T3 only. Have a read through the RT3 site http://thyroid-rt3.com/ Feel free to ask questions after you read through Nick Quote
Guest guest Posted December 9, 2010 Report Posted December 9, 2010 Hi Donna -take time over this .I know there are negatives with any medication - but there ARE different opinions on the use of carbimozole .Instead of the nurse ask one or two pharmacists -they are much more knowledgable and I know Dr P has very definite opinions on this . Surgery always has risks but RAI !!! You need to look in to the health risks with this approach Treatment after either of these is far from perfect so DON'T be rushed it is your future health you need to consider . Best wishes Quote
Guest guest Posted December 9, 2010 Report Posted December 9, 2010 Thank you Nick, will read this. Avy x > > > > >I am getting desperate now as I have been off work for 6 months now and financially struggling as well as all the physical problems. > > There is a very good chance that the excess T4 that comes with Graves > will cause Reverse T3 (RT3) to be produced. > > Even after the excess is cleared this RT3 lingers causing receptor > blockage and hence resistance to T3. > > The solution is to get your T4 levels low for a few months by going to > T3 only. > > Have a read through the RT3 site http://thyroid-rt3.com/ > > Feel free to ask questions after you read through > > Nick > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 10, 2010 Report Posted December 10, 2010 Hi Donna, As the others said...think long and hard over this. For starters you can take carbimazole twice....I did and if you look on the american sites some of them are on it for years! Elaine s site is great as Bec said and you can ask her questions, she always gets back to you. I don't regret surgery but I'm very hypo now, I reacted badly to carb and PTU mostly I think because of bad managment of carb the first time, my liver function went haywire, after that I vomited everytime I took them. If it wasn't for that I'd have hung on to my thyroid and stayed on the pills. I wouldn't have touched RAI with a bargepole though no matter how desperate I was...and I was lol. You obviously did ok on atd's before so don't let them talk you into a quick fix, RAI or surgery won't fix you, it'll just make you hypo, Graves is still wreaking havoc with my eyes and legs, my TRab's still high because I'm so hypo, basically you'll still have Graves even if you have no thyroid. As long as you're monitored regularly on atd's there's no reason not to stay on them. There's lots of info in the files you could look at for more info. Also in America they gauge when they're approaching remission or stopping carb/ptu by measuring TRab, so it'd be well worth asking for it to be tested again to see just what's going on. What were your results,are you back on carb just now or a beta blocker to help with the palps. Good luck Tess > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 10, 2010 Report Posted December 10, 2010 Hi Avril, What are your 'normal' blood levels, are you on thyroxine only, would they prescribe some T3 for you or are they saying that's dangerous too? Idiots!! I'm really hypo now too even though I'm on both T4 and T3,levels get lower every time they test me. When you were hyper was it T3 Toxicosis or high T4? Pat found a study showing ( correct me here if I get this wrong Pat) that folk who had T3 toxicosis need more T3 as we develop a tolerance for it after being hyper for a long time. I was scared to take it at first in case I went crazy hyper again after I had thyroid removed but within weeks I was up at 60mg, now I'm on 100 sometimes 120 and my t3 is only 1.2. Hope you get some help soon. Tess > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 10, 2010 Report Posted December 10, 2010 Hi, Forgot to say, it's not carbimazole that causes osteoporosis, it's their bad management of both hypo and hyper. I've got osteo? lol bone spur in my shoulder which is the start of osteoporosis I think, Also now have rhuematoid arthritis and loads more. As long as carb is monitored and blood is checked for not just thyroid levels but liver function and white blood cells as well, it can cause nuetropenia which lowers white cells and you can't fight off infection...that also happened to me, again because of incomptetance,labs had flagged it on blood results, doctors never seen or failed to look at it. That's why it's important to get copies of your results. Hyper depletes calcium and vit d which causes bone loss and osteoporosis, hypo affects it too though someone with more hypo knowledge than me could maybe help on why. As I said in last post my liver function went up into the 1000's on carb, ast, alp and ggt so they gave me a liver scan as carb had cause problems with liver disorders. I was on 40mg ? can't remember but I'd been on a high dose far too long and was very hypo, dose was lowered and labs went back down. A few months later they were sky high again but that time it was only alp that was up really high but I wasn't on carb then, I'd stopped it! I was told it was down to the unstable swings from hyper/hypo/hyper etc I was probably losing bone mass and they'd do a fragmentation or partition test on it to see whether it was high due to liver or bone. It was bone! They tell you a suppressed Tsh causes osteoporosis as well,( more rubbish) but it's well documented that in graves it can take years for the tsh to come back, my tsh is 0.001 still. There's nothing 'clean and easy' about trying to tell/educate doctors that a suppressed tsh is not always hyperthyroid. When your thyroids gone it's gone and unfortunately she's wrong again ' just taking a hormone replacement' is complete bollox!! Tess > > > Hi , > > I wonder why the specialist nurse made radiodine sounded like the best option. Clean and easy, when you go hypo, just take a hormone supplement. > > She said long term use of carbimazole will cause osteoporosis. I think it's true. The side effect of the carbimazole is suppressing our bone marrow and our calcium level. But no information clarifies at what dose of the drug use would likely to cause osteoporosis. > > I really look forward to the Practical Guide I ordered to arrive. > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2010 Report Posted December 11, 2010 Hi Tess - I was looking up 'funny thyroid function test results' to try to ascertain what could be the reason for your extremely low free T3 considering you are taking such a high dose of T3 and your very suppressed TSH. What came up was non-thyroidal illness - early phase post-treatment for hyperthyroidism - pituitary disease -or congenital TSH deficiency. Not sure where this is leading but there has to be an answer somewhere. Luv - Sheila I was scared to take it at first in case I went crazy hyper again after I had thyroid removed but within weeks I was up at 60mg, now I'm on 100 sometimes 120 and my t3 is only 1.2. Hope you get some help soon. Tess .._,___ Quote
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2010 Report Posted December 11, 2010 Dear Tess, Thanks for your reply. Much appreciated. My result was: TSH < 0.01; FT3; 34.5 and FT4: 42.2. The blood test was taken when I felt the worst three or four weeks ago. I have been on Carbimazole for two week (30mg) now and I can feel my heart rate has slowed. My current state of FT3 and 4 should be slightly slower now. I wasn't prescribed anything for palps. I didn't mind that. When I first had it two year ago, the results were much higher THS: 0.01; T3 >46 and carbimazole brought it down very quickly. Although I felt extremely itch and with a layer of white yeast in my mouth initially but I body got used to it after a while. The symptoms started after an episode of prawn allergy. I told the specialist nurse. She didn't seem to think it's the trigger. She thought it as the stress. I started reading some websites some a natural treatment website recognised the allergy could be one of those possible triggers. I think it make sense because allergy is related to our immune system reacting to allergens. The medical professionals don't seem to care about the cause. I started taking minerals such as calcium, magnesium. selenium and vitamin C. Donna On 11 December 2010 04:27, tess <tessfleming@...> wrote: Hi Donna,As the others said...think long and hard over this. For starters you can take carbimazole twice....I did and if you look on the american sites some of them are onit for years! Elaine s site is great as Bec said and you can ask her questions, she always gets back to you. Tess> [Ed] Quote
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2010 Report Posted December 11, 2010 Hi Tess I should probarly use another title- but just to say I was interested in your mention of bone spurs -I had them on my fingers when hypo but on a decent dose of T3 they seem to have gone. Donna make sure they do very regular blood tests -I became hypo in 6 weeks on carbimazole { by GP's standards not endos ] Make sure you know what number they are aiming for . Some endos seem to think we are fine until the TSH is 10 !!!!!! Best wishes Quote
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2010 Report Posted December 11, 2010 Hi Tess The endo did give me t3 after much complaining from me. After taking t3 for a week I had horrendous pains in my joints, especially my knees. I stopped it for a week and the pains subsided a bit. I started it again and the same happened so i stopped altogether. The last tsh result I had was 2.57. I have actualy just started on the erfa this morning and am just praying this is going to work. Self medicating is absolutely shocking I think, but what else can you do to get better. I feel so let down by those so called medical people in the nhs. Avy x > > Hi Avril, > > What are your 'normal' blood levels, are you on thyroxine only, would they prescribe some T3 for you or are they saying that's dangerous too? Idiots!! > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2010 Report Posted December 11, 2010 Thanks for that Sheila :-) They were talking about looking at pituitary and ? hypothalmus?? a few months ago but with TRab still high seems that the reason for TSH still being suppressed. My bowel is getting the blame, absorption but as you know I'm on liquid T4 and putting the T3 under tongue so God knows where it's going! I was raging at endo's secretary the other day...told me results in range! You can imagine my answer but it sent me on a rant about endo again lol. I jumped the gun though, endo phoned me, apologised about secretary then told me she was looking at research (swoon) and the auto immune side of Graves to see what she could come up with. I had to be patient though as she'd need cut through red tape, she's also going to get together with bowel surgeon (swoon again) to discuss my case. Just had diverticulitis again and partial blockage which is still there...agony. Drinking litres of movicol, fybogel,picolax, 's getting dyna rod out for me :-). Endo also said to be careful as if bowel clears I might get a rush of hormones and could feel a bit hyper again.....never thought I'd say it but bring it on for a day. Asked her if it was rituximab she was looking into....she said 'how do you know about that, you're always one step in front of me' lol. Not ate a bite since Sunday and I'm like a big burst couch :-( or a big fat beached whale that's pregnant with 100 baby whales. At least I'm back on my feet again though...weebles wobble but they don't fall down ;-) Will keep you posted, thanks again. Love Tess x > > Hi Tess - I was looking up 'funny thyroid function test results' to try to > ascertain what could be the reason for your extremely low free T3 > considering you are taking such a high dose of T3 and your very suppressed > TSH. What came up was non-thyroidal illness - early phase post-treatment for > hyperthyroidism - pituitary disease -or congenital TSH deficiency. Not sure > where this is leading but there has to be an answer somewhere. > > Luv - Sheila > > I was scared to take it at first in case I went crazy hyper again after I > had thyroid removed but within weeks I was up at 60mg, now I'm on 100 > sometimes 120 and my t3 is only 1.2. > Hope you get some help soon. > > Tess > > ._,___ > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2010 Report Posted December 11, 2010 OOFT! Poor you, big hugs :-) I went into thyroid storm with T3 of 53,my T4 was never like yours though, highest it went was 22. Glad you can feel it slowing down a bit, just be careful with stress etc over Xmas. I've read about allergy triggers too and sea food's a big one it seems! L Carnitine good for hyper too. I remember that itch, I was covered in a rash too, ask for anti histamine, actually cheaper just buying them...they're allowed with carb :-) Some of the so called professionals don't care about symptoms, treatment as well as the cause...or they don't know and can't be bothered finding out. They'd rather obliterate/remove the thyroid so they can say, that's you just take replacement now!! I was forever fighting with them lol. Did your TSH come back when you were off the carb and felt ok or did it stay suppressed like mine is? Go armed with info to your next appt, anything you want to know just ask. How's your eyes/legs are they affected? Take care Tess > > Thanks for your reply. Much appreciated. > > My result was: TSH < 0.01; FT3; 34.5 and FT4: 42.2. The blood test was > taken when I felt the worst three or four weeks ago. I have been on > Carbimazole for two week (30mg) now and I can feel my heart rate has > slowed. My current state of FT3 and 4 should be slightly slower now. I > wasn't prescribed anything for palps. > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2010 Report Posted December 11, 2010 Hi , I've got wee lumps on my pinkies too at the knuckle,'s got them too, that's good that they might go away. X Ray on shoulder showed narrowed joint space too but I'm seeing physio now...well seen her once then snowed in but have another appt on Tues so hopefully that'll help. I forgot to say that my alk phosphate is up again too....it's vet I need lol. Going off topic again but did you have any bother with vocal chord after they removed your thyroid? I was at speech therapy a couple of weeks ago, she wants me to get some x ray on my swallow, thinks that food particles are getting into my lungs because of paralysed vocal chord and recurrent chest infections, also said chord won't recover properly until my levels are right...Sigh!!! Love Tess > > Hi Tess I should probarly use another title- but just to say I was interested in your mention of bone spurs -I had them on my fingers when hypo but on a decent dose of T3 they seem to have gone. Donna make sure they do very regular blood tests -I became hypo in 6 weeks on carbimazole { by GP's standards not endos ] Make sure you know what number they are aiming for . Some endos seem to think we are fine until the TSH is 10 !!!!!! Best wishes > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2010 Report Posted December 11, 2010 Poor you, Hopefully you'll do better on the erfa:-) Fingers crossed for you. It is shocking the lengths we have to go to just to feel better. The caring profession...yeah right. Thank God for the internet and sites like this. Good luck Tess x > > Hi Tess > > The endo did give me t3 after much complaining from me. After taking t3 for a week I had horrendous pains in my joints, especially my knees. I stopped it for a week and the pains subsided a bit. I started it again and the same happened so i stopped altogether. The last tsh result I had was 2.57. I have actualy just started > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2010 Report Posted December 11, 2010 Hi Tess I've just been reading the bit about the link between hypo -low D3 levels -and osteoarthritis . It was after a bi-lateral hip op that my thyroid packed in completely . I have a bit of secondary arthritis in a couple of my fingers but touch wood no other problems now I take a decent dose of T3 .As for swallowing -My bowels stopped and I couldn't swallow when my thyroid was giving up -I was making a funny noise in my throat but no problem that hasn't improved when on a decent dose of meds .I agree that other Drs are wasting there time if your meds aren't right . .I hope this helps Best wishes Quote
Guest guest Posted December 12, 2010 Report Posted December 12, 2010 Hi Avril Just to chip in with Tess, my endocrinologists exact words when I was with him this Weds were, ‘only endocrinologists who do not know what they are doing with Graves are obsessed with normal blood results’. I’m currently sticking out carbimazole treatment but he’s going to run me high in the normal range or just over normal range as that what my body is used to, and he reckons that is where I will feel well. He said, ‘I don’t care about ‘normal’, I care about how you feel, whether you are healthy, and whether you are functioning’. I appreciate I am lucky to have him but all endocrinologists should be taking this line!! Cheers x Pat found a study showing ( correct me here if I get this wrong Pat) that folk who had T3 toxicosis need more T3 as we develop a tolerance for it after being hyper for a long time. I am using the Free version of SPAMfighter.SPAMfighter has removed 3312 of my spam emails to date.Do you have a slow PC? Try free scan! Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.