Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Share Posted August 11, 2010 Hi Jonny, I wondered where you had gone to as you had been a regular contributor to the forum discussions. However, from what you say, I am concerned that you appear to be now dismissing hypothyroidism as a cause for your symptoms and finding other problems that could be an explanation for them. What happened that caused you to go back onto thyroxine when you were doing so amazingly well on Armour Thyroid. I actually copied a note from you when you were doing so well on Armour Thyroid, which I used in my response to the British Thyroid Association's Statement on Armour Thyroid · “I have just tried Armour for a few weeks after being unsuccessfully treated with thyroxine for 2 1/2 years. Unfortunately I ran out of Armour, but for those few weeks my symptoms went, for the first time in years (and I’m only 20 so that's a large proportion of my life). No more muscle aches, joint pain, foggy non-thinking brain, tiredness, depression. Then when I ran out, I started thyroxine again. Now the dreaded symptoms have all come back. I now know how needed Armour is, and think it is verging on negligent that it can't be prescribed to me " . I am amazed that an endocrinologist would tell his patients who had been taking hydrocortisone to stop taking this all at once. It is well known that anybody stopping their hydrocortisone should be warned to do this slowly, slowly decreasing by 2.5mcgs at a time until they are finally off it completely. I am glad to hear it caused no problems in your particular case. How long have you been taking levothyroxine-alone now Jonny? Are you absolutely POSITIVE that your symptoms of lack of concentration, inattentiveness, brain fog, forgetfulness and depression are all attributed to ADHD and not hypothyroidism? Keep us informed regarding any improvement (or not) and let us know what dose of levothyroxine you are taking right now, when was it last increased and what are your latest thyroid function test results. Don't forget to give us the reference range for each test done Jonny. Luv - Sheila Just to let you know...I'm back on thyroxine as found the Armour wasnt really any better. I also was taking hydrocortisol for almost a year but stopped taking it last november.. I stopped suddenly after the endo told me too and actually felt much better from doing this. Last year I was diagnosed with depression by the GP, started taking sertraline which helped a lot. A few months ago i was diagnosed with ADHD inattentive type by a consultant neuropsychiatrist and this has really explained practically my whole life. i was always not concentrating at school, and would forget things a lot...especially if someone told me something. (I still do this now actually) and infact the school reports were used in the decision to diagnose me. ADHD inattentive also explains my tiredness, brain fog, and depression (which I think is secondary to the ADHD because it effects things like socializing and generally makes you feel a bit retarded when you forget things all the time). It quite a recent development to diagnose adults but they are only just realising that adults get it too. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Share Posted August 11, 2010 Hi Sheila, Yes I have stopped thinking that the hypothyroidism is a cause for it now. There is still a small doubt in my mind, but I decided after Trying the Armour for 18 months and hydrocortisone at various doses for about 10 months that I wasn't feeling much better on it. And indeed I actually felt better coming off the HC. I did feel worse when I went from Armour to thyroxine at the time of writing that snippet that you quoted. I think tho that this was actually deo to my body getting used to Armour (lowering its natural T3 production to compensate for that in Armour) and then when I went on thyroxine my body had to start increasing it again. I also think that it could have been partly placebo. Having total belief that a medication would make me feel better I think actually made me feel a bit better on it. But after coming off HC suddenly and feeling better I suddenly though " Maybe I was wrong about all this after all if I was wrong about the HC " . I thought that it would be dangerous for me to come off HC so suddenly, but, with healthy working adrenals, it proved to be fine and my body actually seemed grateful for me coming off it. I think if you don;t need the HC then coming off it is fine. So I then starting thinking " Maybe Im wrong about this whole Armour/thyroxine thing too " . Then when I went onto thyroxine I felt no real difference. Im on 125mg thyroxine now and have been on it since December I think. I havnt had blood results done in a while and can't actually remember the last ones at this dose. I only remember at 150mg I was below the TSH range a bit so the dose was decreased to 125mg. It's possible that my symptoms are from the hypothyroidism instead of ADHD and that extra T3 is need (In the form of Armour for instance). But after trying Armour at various doses and still being unable to go out and socialize or do sports etc from being tired, and then finding that antidepressants gave me more energy and for the first time in years so I could go out drinking with my friends and not get too tired and have to go home, I think that antidepressants have been more successful in treating my symptoms. Also, given that the medical establishement supports the view that it is depression and/or depression responsible for my symptoms and not hypothyroidism, then I am happy to go with this. It is well documented that ADHD/depression can be responsible for all these symptoms, whereas it is not documented that TSH and T4 being in the normal ranges can be responsible (I am talking about studies here, not anecdotal evidence). For now, I am feeling better than I did when taking Armour. I have just stopped the antidepressants and think that (much to my surprise) the depression is not coming back and I have more energy than I did on armour. I am also still waiting for the ADHD medication to start working and when it does and if it effectively treats the ADHD, this should give me more energy too and improve my memory, attention, brain fog and depression. I have decided to no longer take things into my own hands and just let the medical profession decide for me what to do. This is not only logical (I thought to myself that out of all these studies, and all these medical professionals looking at them and deciding the best thing to do, I should beleive them), but has also proved to be much less stressful than trying to take it into my own hands and decide for myself what I should do. Thanks Jonny > > Hi Jonny, I wondered where you had gone to as you had been a regular > contributor to the forum discussions. However, from what you say, I am > concerned that you appear to be now dismissing hypothyroidism as a cause for > your symptoms and finding other problems that could be an explanation for > them. > > What happened that caused you to go back onto thyroxine when you were doing > so amazingly well on Armour Thyroid. I actually copied a note from you when > you were doing so well on Armour Thyroid, which I used in my response to the > British Thyroid Association's Statement on Armour Thyroid > > . " I have just tried Armour for a few weeks after being > unsuccessfully treated with thyroxine for 2 1/2 years. Unfortunately I ran > out of Armour, but for those few weeks my symptoms went, for the first time > in years (and I'm only 20 so that's a large proportion of my life). No more > muscle aches, joint pain, foggy non-thinking brain, tiredness, depression. > Then when I ran out, I started thyroxine again. Now the dreaded symptoms > have all come back. I now know how needed Armour is, and think it is verging > on negligent that it can't be prescribed to me " . > > I am amazed that an endocrinologist would tell his patients who had been > taking hydrocortisone to stop taking this all at once. It is well known that > anybody stopping their hydrocortisone should be warned to do this slowly, > slowly decreasing by 2.5mcgs at a time until they are finally off it > completely. I am glad to hear it caused no problems in your particular case. > > How long have you been taking levothyroxine-alone now Jonny? Are you > absolutely POSITIVE that your symptoms of lack of concentration, > inattentiveness, brain fog, forgetfulness and depression are all attributed > to ADHD and not hypothyroidism? Keep us informed regarding any improvement > (or not) and let us know what dose of levothyroxine you are taking right > now, when was it last increased and what are your latest thyroid function > test results. Don't forget to give us the reference range for each test done > Jonny. > > Luv - Sheila > > > > > Just to let you know...I'm back on thyroxine as found the Armour wasnt > really any better. I also was taking hydrocortisol for almost a year but > stopped taking it last november.. I stopped suddenly after the endo told me > too and actually felt much better from doing this. > > Last year I was diagnosed with depression by the GP, started taking > sertraline which helped a lot. > > A few months ago i was diagnosed with ADHD inattentive type by a consultant > neuropsychiatrist and this has really explained practically my whole life. > > i was always not concentrating at school, and would forget things a > lot...especially if someone told me something. (I still do this now > actually) and infact the school reports were used in the decision to > diagnose me. ADHD inattentive also explains my tiredness, brain fog, and > depression (which I think is secondary to the ADHD because it effects things > like socializing and generally makes you feel a bit retarded when you forget > things all the time). > > > > It quite a recent development to diagnose adults but they are only just > realising that adults get it too. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Share Posted August 11, 2010 Hi Jonnie, Good to hear that you may have found an answer to your problems. my Daughter is ADHD so I know the problems that it can cause- the ADHD help group always explained that there were two sides to the condition- that the quiet, withdrawn children that were failing at school could have the flipside of this condition. My daughters problems were controlloed in large part by attedntion to diet- see the work of Dr. Ben Feingold- and with the addition of evening primrose oil for it's gammalinoleic acid content and zinc supplementation. You may find that this approach helps you too.- after all, if it doesn't, the diet is a still a healthy way to live ,so no harm done. thyroid treatment From: jrshannie@...Date: Wed, 11 Aug 2010 01:25:35 +0000Subject: Diagnosed with ADHD and Depression - explains EVERYTHING Hi guys,I havnt been on this forum for AGES.Just to let you know...I'm back on thyroxine as found the Armour wasnt really any better. I also was taking hydrocortisol for almost a year but stopped taking it last november.. I stopped suddenly after the endo told me too and actually felt much better from doing this.Last year I was diagnosed with depression by the GP, started taking sertraline which helped a lot.A few months ago i was diagnosed with ADHD inattentive type by a consultant neuropsychiatrist and this has really explained practically my whole life.There is ADHD hyperactive which is the one where people have lots of energy and thought buzzing around in their head so talk fast and are generally hard for people to keep up with. It quite a recent development to diagnose adults but they are only just realising that adults get it too. i thought I would mention it on here to see if it could help some people explain things like it did for me.Jonny Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Share Posted August 11, 2010 I hope you will be proved right in your beliefs that putting your health back into the hands of the medical professionals is the way for you to go Jonny. I also hope that your actions do prove to be " logical " . We are here to help if you find at any point in the future, you need help again, should you find your health deteriorating within mainstream guidelines, which I hope it does not. Seriously though Jonny, good luck and I hope you regain total good health in your chosen path. Luv - Sheila I have decided to no longer take things into my own hands and just let the medical profession decide for me what to do. This is not only logical (I thought to myself that out of all these studies, and all these medical professionals looking at them and deciding the best thing to do, I should beleive them), but has also proved to be much less stressful than trying to take it into my own hands and decide for myself what I should do. Thanks Jonny Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Share Posted August 11, 2010 The last person I would personally put my faith in is doctors who are going to give me meds for ADHD, like ritalin. As someone who has all the symptoms you have mentioned, it is very easy to fall into the trap of being medicalised, as shrinks like to do. As for me ADHD is just another symptom that I have. This is more than likely caused by many things, possibly mercury the underlying issue. I also believe that SSRI's messed up my whole endocrine system, as it has been shown to do. The support and understanding that I have personally far outweighs anything I have had from the medical profession, who patronise and condescend my every thought on my health. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Share Posted August 11, 2010 I have to agree 100% . Sheila The last person I would personally put my faith in is doctors who are going to give me meds for ADHD, like ritalin. As someone who has all the symptoms you have mentioned, it is very easy to fall into the trap of being medicalised, as shrinks like to do. As for me ADHD is just another symptom that I have. This is more than likely caused by many things, possibly mercury the underlying issue. I also believe that SSRI's messed up my whole endocrine system, as it has been shown to do. The support and understanding that I have personally far outweighs anything I have had from the medical profession, who patronise and condescend my every thought on my health. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Share Posted August 11, 2010 Hi, I'm de-lurking for this conversation, hope that's okay... I actually think there might be a middle ground. I think there's a large overlap between hypothyroid symptoms and ADHD (whether hyperactive, inattentive or combined). Depression in thyroid patients, I've come to believe, is usually due to inadequate medication, and when SSRIs are prescribed, I think it's usually a mistake and they make things worse. I think perhaps the key is in when the ADHD symptoms started. In childhood? Or later on? This is why they want to use school reports and interviews from family members. If the symptoms didn't surface until adulthood, then I think it's more likely to be thyroid complications than ADHD. For me, they pre-date my thyroid issues. And in fact, I believe when my genetic code triggered Hashimoto's around puberty it actually masked the ADHD enough for everyone around me to feel it was no longer an issue, as I wasn't hyperactive anymore. Well I may have been too physically tired to be hyperactive, but nothing stopped my brain. I only recently discovered that adults can also have ADHD. And for me, at the moment, it's like finding a missing piece. I've been treating for Hashimoto's with varying degrees of success for almost a decade. I keep raising my thyroid meds, but some symptoms remain. I used to take Armour but didn't do well with the formula change. I now take Efra from Canada (I'm American), I take the equivalent of 4 grains. The residual symptoms all *could* be explained by ADHD. It's a possibility. I'm interested enough to check it out and see what happens with stimulants. Either it will work or it won't. I understand the original posters desire to hand it over to a medical professional, in fact, I remember feeling that way too at his age. But I'm older now and I don't feel that it's ever possible to just hand things over. We all know endocrinologists leave quite a bit to be desired, especially for you all in the UK. Specialists in Adult ADHD are similar. The medical " professionals " are just starting to figure it all out. So this means that we, as patients, need to be even more involved in our treatment... that much more in tune with our health. Even more so when the system is stacked against you. Many of the dietary choices that should be made for thyroid patients are the same as those for ADHD patients (restricting processed foods, avoiding gluten, low-carb, watching sugar intake, potentially the same with dairy). Taking a good multi vitamin/mineral, fish oil, vitamin c, etc... good for both. Just as I was once willing to walk away from Synthroid and Levothyroxine in favor of Armour (made a huge difference for me), the same way I was willing to give up gluten to see if it made a difference as well (it did), I'm willing to try a low dose stimulant to see if it may help (but only because my ADHD symptoms existed from childhood). If it doesn't, then it's back to the drawing board. Wouldn't it be nice if there was a one-size-fits-all fix. But that's exactly what's wrong with the approach of the majority of endocrinologists worldwide. We each have these unique systems, we're each a unique puzzle. I wish none of us had to deal with these issues, but we do, and I think we need to be curious enough to explore all the clues to solving our own mysteries. Well it's taken me 2 hours to compose this (thanks ADHD). I hope it makes sense and doesn't offend anyone, as that was not my intention. > > I have to agree 100% . > > Sheila > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Share Posted August 11, 2010 "I think perhaps the key is in when the ADHD symptoms started. In childhood? Or later on? This is why they want to use school reports and interviews from family members. If the symptoms didn't surface until adulthood, then I think it's more likely to be thyroid complications than ADHD."Yes I agree. For me, I was quite hypoeractive as a youngster and my school reports as far back as I have them (7 years old) state that I need to pay attention more and not mess around in class. I remember at school getting told off and recall trying to concentrate but Ended up not paying attention anyway. It wasn't just being "naughty" because I wasn't always talking or exhibiting "naughty" behavior....a lot of the time I would be looking out of the window or looking at posters round the room instead of listening to the teacher.If anyone was not ADHD as a child (inattentive, hyperactive etc ) then it is unlikely that they have ADHD as an adult (unless there was a head injury in which case acquired ADHD is possible). Conversely, if someone had ADHD as a child then they WILL have it as an adult because it is a brain disorder - a lower amount of dopamine in certain areas of the prefrontal cortex so I gather. So what I'm saying is that if someone had symptoms as a child and still has them now, or had a head injusry in their life, then it is quite possible that they have ADHD as an adult and this maybe something that any of you may want to look into if you feel it is possible.I think it is also possible that some of you have symptoms caused by depression, like I did, especially if there have been past experiences that may have caused it or if depression runs in your family, and so you may want to look into this too."For me, they pre-date my thyroid issues. And in fact, I believe when my genetic code triggered Hashimoto's around puberty it actually masked the ADHD enough for everyone around me to feel it was no longer an issue, as I wasn't hyperactive anymore. Well I may have been too physically tired to be hyperactive, but nothing stopped my brain. :)"Yes I think this is very possibly what heppened to me too. i went from being quite hyper and annoying at around 12/13 years old to tired and depressed at about 15/16. I was finally diagnosed at 17 when my thyroid blood results eventually same out of the range.The fact that i felt tired for the 2 years preceding the diagnosis when my thyroid labs were in range does make me think that the ranges need changing to a small, or lower, range. However, at the time my undiagnosed ADHD was causing social problems at school and it's quite possible that the tiredness and depression was due to this. What further supports this is that treating with thyroxine and then Armour, did not improve me, or at least not enough. And also that hypoeractive ADHD is much less common in adults that children, indicating that many hypoeractive ADHD children will turn into inattentive ADHD adults (of which the symptoms are often tiredness, brain fog and secondary depression).I understand that if you felt a great improvement from Armour over thyroxine then this is evidence that the T3 in Armour is needed for you. I can't say I noticed a significant improvement myself so that is why I lost faith in the whole T3 argument.It does seem, however, that extra thyroid hormones produces a better mood anyway, as indicated by this quote I quickly found:"Thyroid tests in blood, such as T3, T4 and TSH, are performed if the cause of euphoria is suspected to be due to hyperthyroidism."So even in the case of seeing an improvement, it is also possible that this is not because of a physiological replacement of the lack of hormone, but rather because of the increase in mood that anyone would get if they supplemented extra thyroid hormone.It's up to you to decide either way, but for me I have left that to the medical profession. Between either the thousands of anecdotal reports from people that think they need extra T3 hormone or the studies and hundreds of thousands of medical professionals with their degrees I will feel safer going with the latter. Even tho there is possibility of conspiracy, I feel that 99.99% of medical professionals have good intentions.It was my belief a year ago that medical professionals are not to be trusted due to being bribed by the pharmaceutical companies. However, I think that researchers at universities would not let their studies be swayed by such things. After all, a researcher is not a highly paid job and so I assume that their passion for their subject outweighs their passion for money.And again, for doctors, a 5 year medical degree, the training required after that and the subsequent demand of such a demanding job would not attract someone that doesn't care about other people's welfare. I have to assume that the evidence there has not been tainted by anyone.It is possible that studies have unfortunately not picked up the truth, and while this is a possibility, one cannot assume that it is true because it is the same for all studies and is an unlikely occurrence. ThanksJonny Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2010 Report Share Posted August 12, 2010 I don't understand why this should make any difference. Even babies can have thyroid problems. Even if the problem is not genetic, they are influenced by the environment in the womb. Miriam > I think perhaps the key is in when the ADHD symptoms started. In childhood? Or later on? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2010 Report Share Posted August 12, 2010 I sincerely hope your trusting nature with the medical profession never lets you down Jonny as it has let down so many. Do you never wonder why we have almost 2000 members and over 3000 hits a week on our web site. I wonder why there are literally hundreds of such thyroid web sites and forums throughout the world with tens of thousands of members, if they all felt happy with their doctors and their treatment ,and knew they were on the road to recovery? I wonder why there are over 250,000 sufferers in the UK alone (and millions world-wide) who are being left to suffer so unnecessarily because they are being denied the thyroid hormone replacement that would give them back their lives. These folk are being failed miserably by the medical profession. We do not deny that there are medical professionals throughout the world who have 100% total dedication, who have great passion to help those suffering, who have, and are doing brilliant research, who have performed fantastic studies, etc , but we have learned that there are many, many doctors who have NO dedication to their profession or their patients, some admitting they were drawn into the profession because of the money. If what you say about the medical professionals is true, then why are we trying to pick up the pieces of broken lives that have been wrecked through sheer ignorance, arrogance and lack of training in helping those with the symptoms of hypothyroidism. I spend hours of my time in trying to deal with hundreds of messages sent from our web site and the forum, and receiving hundreds of telephone calls throughout the years - often from people who are weeping, out of sheer desperation and fear for their future well-being, and yes, many such calls make me weep. Perhaps a day standing in my shoes Jonny might make you less trusting. Many of these victims have been, and continue to be, physically and verbally abused by some of our so called medical professionals. For those reports from people that " think " they need extra T3 hormone, there is research and studies that have been done to prove that many sufferers DO need T3, that the RCP and BTA inexplicably refuse to acknowledge. These are all in our web site, Files, our responses to the many misleading and incorrect statements by the British Thyroid Association and the Royal College of Physicians. I hope your faith in the medical professionals proves good Jonny and that they have now found the true cause for your symptoms and will treat you and give you back normal health at last. Meanwhile, we will continue to pick up the pieces of those who are being denied a proper diagnosis and the choice of treatment, because of doctors fear of losing their career and livelihood should they DARE to diagnose and treat outside of the RCP, BTA guidance. If you really want to know why this is happening, I would highly recommend you read the book " Dirty Medicine by " . From its Back Cover: " Orthodox medical practitioners, pharmaceutical companies and industrial scientists, have organised against alternative and complementary medicine in Europe and America, since the last century. Dirty Medicine traces the history of these campaigns, their proponents and institutions. " In 1987 the Wellcome Foundation, one of Britian's largest multi-national drug companies, obtained a license for the drug Zidovudine, known as AZT. AZT was heralded by the media and marketed by Wellcome as if it was the answer to the AIDS epidemic. Packaged and promoted like any other commodity, public relations companies and advertising agencies hyped AZT from Romania to Uruguay. In 1992 the foundation made nearly £200M profit from the drug. With the marketing of AZT, the campaign against alternative and complementary medicine was suddenly transformed from an academic dispute to a war. Dirty tricks, industrial sabotage and character assassination replaced normal business and scientific practice. Dirty Medicine, is a frightening story of the free market, at war with the powerless. It exposes how, under the guise of government regulation, big business, science and medical orthodoxy defended their products and profits from competition " . Sheila It's up to you to decide either way, but for me I have left that to the medical profession. Between either the thousands of anecdotal reports from people that think they need extra T3 hormone or the studies and hundreds of thousands of medical professionals with their degrees I will feel safer going with the latter. Even tho there is possibility of conspiracy, I feel that 99.99% of medical professionals have good intentions. It was my belief a year ago that medical professionals are not to be trusted due to being bribed by the pharmaceutical companies. However, I think that researchers at universities would not let their studies be swayed by such things. After all, a researcher is not a highly paid job and so I assume that their passion for their subject outweighs their passion for money. And again, for doctors, a 5 year medical degree, the training required after that and the subsequent demand of such a demanding job would not attract someone that doesn't care about other people's welfare. I have to assume that the evidence there has not been tainted by anyone. It is possible that studies have unfortunately not picked up the truth, and while this is a possibility, one cannot assume that it is true because it is the same for all studies and is an unlikely occurrence. Thanks Jonny No virus found in this incoming message. Checked by AVG - www.avg.com Version: 8.5.441 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/3063 - Release Date: 08/10/10 18:34:00 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2010 Report Share Posted August 12, 2010 Hi , you can " de-lurk " any time with information such as this. many thanks for posting it. I have been naughty and left all of your previous message as I think others will want to read it, who missed it yesterday because they were, perhaps elsewhere. Luv - Sheila Hi, I'm de-lurking for this conversation, hope that's okay... I actually think there might be a middle ground. I think there's a large overlap between hypothyroid symptoms and ADHD (whether hyperactive, inattentive or combined). Depression in thyroid patients, I've come to believe, is usually due to inadequate medication, and when SSRIs are prescribed, I think it's usually a mistake and they make things worse. I think perhaps the key is in when the ADHD symptoms started. In childhood? Or later on? This is why they want to use school reports and interviews from family members. If the symptoms didn't surface until adulthood, then I think it's more likely to be thyroid complications than ADHD. For me, they pre-date my thyroid issues. And in fact, I believe when my genetic code triggered Hashimoto's around puberty it actually masked the ADHD enough for everyone around me to feel it was no longer an issue, as I wasn't hyperactive anymore. Well I may have been too physically tired to be hyperactive, but nothing stopped my brain. I only recently discovered that adults can also have ADHD. And for me, at the moment, it's like finding a missing piece. I've been treating for Hashimoto's with varying degrees of success for almost a decade. I keep raising my thyroid meds, but some symptoms remain. I used to take Armour but didn't do well with the formula change. I now take Efra from Canada (I'm American), I take the equivalent of 4 grains. The residual symptoms all *could* be explained by ADHD. It's a possibility. I'm interested enough to check it out and see what happens with stimulants. Either it will work or it won't. I understand the original posters desire to hand it over to a medical professional, in fact, I remember feeling that way too at his age. But I'm older now and I don't feel that it's ever possible to just hand things over. We all know endocrinologists leave quite a bit to be desired, especially for you all in the UK. Specialists in Adult ADHD are similar. The medical " professionals " are just starting to figure it all out. So this means that we, as patients, need to be even more involved in our treatment... that much more in tune with our health. Even more so when the system is stacked against you. Many of the dietary choices that should be made for thyroid patients are the same as those for ADHD patients (restricting processed foods, avoiding gluten, low-carb, watching sugar intake, potentially the same with dairy). Taking a good multi vitamin/mineral, fish oil, vitamin c, etc... good for both. Just as I was once willing to walk away from Synthroid and Levothyroxine in favor of Armour (made a huge difference for me), the same way I was willing to give up gluten to see if it made a difference as well (it did), I'm willing to try a low dose stimulant to see if it may help (but only because my ADHD symptoms existed from childhood). If it doesn't, then it's back to the drawing board. Wouldn't it be nice if there was a one-size-fits-all fix. But that's exactly what's wrong with the approach of the majority of endocrinologists worldwide. We each have these unique systems, we're each a unique puzzle. I wish none of us had to deal with these issues, but we do, and I think we need to be curious enough to explore all the clues to solving our own mysteries. Well it's taken me 2 hours to compose this (thanks ADHD). I hope it makes sense and doesn't offend anyone, as that was not my intention. > > I have to agree 100% . > > Sheila > No virus found in this incoming message. Checked by AVG - www.avg.com Version: 8.5.441 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/3063 - Release Date: 08/10/10 18:34:00 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2010 Report Share Posted August 12, 2010 I'm also diagnosed ADHD & was treated for about 6 months with Concerta XL (Ritalin). This happened after 15 years of complaining of the same symptoms (brain fog, no concentration or motivation) & the GP ignoring my swollen red tongue, & me refusing constant offers of Anti-Depressants, as I insisted there was something physical going on, I accepted his offer to go for CBT. CBT was the biggest pile of crap I have ever encountered, it was embarrassing. Just so lame, a 5-year-old could learn how to do that. anyway, he thought I had some sort of OCD & I was referred to a Clinical physiologist, who gave me questionnaires for my family to fill out. Yes, I fit the bill perfectly, class clown, hyperactive, always in trouble, risk-taker etc… OK, so I accepted the diagnosis, it explained everything (at the time) & I took the Ritalin. Ritalin is very nice, I have to say. Did it help with any of my symptoms? No, did I care? No, I felt nice & chilled. Thankfully, whilst trying to find out more on an American ADHD forum, I came up with a thread speaking of conditions which share symptoms with ADHD. The one that caught my eye was Testosterone Deficiency. I went to my GP & requested a test. After being laughed at I demanded a test & after being told I was " normal " , I demanded the result & found I was 0.6 within the Ref range. That lead me to a whole new world of discovery. I found I was deficient in Cortisol, B12, T4, with sky high TSH etc.. I stopped the Ritalin & now I'm being treated with Testosterone, HC, B12 & Thyroid, I am feeling better than I can ever remember, sleeping better than I ever have & wishing I'd known what I know now 20 years ago! Just my opinion, but I believe ADHD to utter nonsense. I would bet that most ADHD kids would be miraculously better if they A) Got 9 hours sleep a night, removed TV/PC/iPhones etc.. out of their bedrooms & ate a nutritious diet, not consisting of junk food & cola. The Medical establishment & big Pharma likes to come up with these labels & ignore proper holistic (non-profitable) prevention, in favour of the latest expensive pill which merely masks symptoms & keeps the cash coming in. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2010 Report Share Posted August 12, 2010 Hi, There's a bit more to it than that- but I agree with the diet comments- a correct low salycilate and no food additive diet will slow a hyperactive child down- but they still will be more whizzy that their classmates- concentration and focus will still be a lifeong problem- this as a mother of a 28year old hyperactive- who is now working towards an OU degree. > thyroid treatment > From: strummer61@...> Date: Thu, 12 Aug 2010 14:57:18 +0000> Subject: Re: Diagnosed with ADHD and Depression - explains EVERYTHING> > I'm also diagnosed ADHD & was treated for about 6 months with Concerta XL (Ritalin).> > > Just my opinion, but I believe ADHD to utter nonsense. I would bet that most ADHD kids would be miraculously better if they A) Got 9 hours sleep a night, removed TV/PC/iPhones etc.. out of their bedrooms & ate a nutritious diet, not consisting of junk food & cola.> > The Medical establishment & big Pharma likes to come up with these labels & ignore proper holistic (non-profitable) prevention, in favour of the latest expensive pill which merely masks symptoms & keeps the cash coming in.> > > > > ------------------------------------> > TPA is not medically qualified. Consult with a qualified medical practitioner before changing medication.> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2010 Report Share Posted August 12, 2010 Hi Don't you think your daughter's symptoms could be down to the same things that bring you to this forum, IE Thyroid related?? I certainly feel 1000 times better since I've been treated with B12 & Thyroid meds. Afterall, ADHD is diagnosed on a set of behaviour. All of which I believe can either be attributed to Thyroid or cured by good sleep & the right diet. Is she on Ritalin? > > > Hi, > There's a bit more to it than that- but I agree with the diet comments- a correct low salycilate and no food additive diet will slow a hyperactive child down- but they still will be more whizzy that their classmates- concentration and focus will still be a lifeong problem- this as a mother of a 28year old hyperactive- who is now working towards an OU degree. > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2010 Report Share Posted August 12, 2010 Just want to add my two pence worth to this discussion…. or rather what I have read in Mark Starr's book of "Hypothyroidism, Type2" (Quote) ….In a study from the National Institutes of Health published in 1995, attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) was present in 72% of males and 43% of females who were identified with a genetically inherited form of Hypothyroidism. The NID studied 104 affected patients from 42 different families identified between 1976 and 1995….. Medications affecting the central nervous system (the brain and spinal cord) often have the opposite effect upon children that they have on adults. Stimulants such as amphetamines are used to treat hyperactive children with attention deficits. Their hyperactivity and short attention spans frequently improve. The same drugs would make adults more active with shorter attention spans. The short attention span and hyperactivity many children suffer may be due to their low metabolism and fatigues. If symptoms of hypothyroidism and low basal temperature are present, a trial of thyroid hormones in indicated. Thyroid hormone treatment to increase metabolism is a much more physiological and efficacious method than elevating metabolism with amphetamines….. .... The gray matter of our brain's frontal cortex continues to thicken and grow throughout childhood. Its size peaks at about the time of puberty. It appears the brain has some capacity for regeneration and development throughout our lives. The gray matter of the frontal cortex is involved in judgement, organization, planning, initiating attention, and shifting or stoppingattention. The frontal cortex is the command centre of the brain. In 2006, 2.5 million children in America were prescribed antipsychotic medication. Obviously, the earlier the treatment for hypothyroidism begins, the better the chances are for normal cognitive development and psychological well-being... (unquote) Every worth-while book I have ever read on Hypothyroidism states that ADHD is well known as a clinical sign of Hypothyroidism. So why, I wonder (or shouldn't I ?) are patients with diagnosed ADHD not generally checked for, let alone treated for, Hypothyroidism ? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2010 Report Share Posted August 12, 2010 I once shared the same opinion about ADHD as Ian. Then I actually met someone who has it and is not medicated. In reading about it, I learned more about ADHD, as it affects adults, than I'd ever know. It's not *just* about being hyperactive or easily distracted. And everyone who has it does not just consume too much junk food or watch too much TV. Although some do, absolutely. But there's no need to throw the baby out with the bathwater. But this should not turn into an argument as to childhood ADHD diagnoses.So I've been diagnosed with Adult ADHD, does that mean that I will stop monitoring my B12 and my Ferritin levels? Of course not. Does it mean I would stop taking my thyroid meda or stop fighting for everyone to be able to have access to best T3/T4 treatment that works for them, be it Armour, Naturthroid, Efra, or even combos of Synthroid & Cytomel? Absolutely not.ADHD is not diagnosed only on behavioral patterns. It's how your brain works, how you process things. While ADHD may have been a misdiagnosis for Ian, it doesn't negate the possibility of it affecting someone else. 's daughter probably does have ADHD, but if has thyroid problems, then her daughter may well have them now or in future. Then she'd have both, and both deserve to be considered during treatment as well.If I felt that thyroid treatment was the end all be all answer to all my problems I think I'd be just as guilty of rigid thinking as those who claim that thyroid treatment will *not* answer my problems. Or those that cling to the idea that noone needs T3, or those who think Armour alone will answer every thyroid patient's issues while they refuse to consider that adrenal issues could be involved too. There is no one size fits all.Just because a portion of thyroid patients may also have ADHD it doesn't dilute the very legitimate problems that thyroid patients experience, especially in the UK. There's room for all. My experience is not your experience. Yours is not mine. But hopefully we can still be on the journey together.P.S. Congratulations to your daughter working on her degree . I know first hand how difficult that is to do when your brain is all over the place.MicheleHi Don't you think your daughter's symptoms could be down to the same things that bring you to this forum, IE Thyroid related??I certainly feel 1000 times better since I've been treated with B12 & Thyroid meds.Afterall, ADHD is diagnosed on a set of behaviour. All of which I believe can either be attributed to Thyroid or cured by good sleep & the right diet.Is she on Ritalin?>> > Hi,> There's a bit more to it than that- but I agree with the diet comments- a correct low salycilate and no food additive diet will slow a hyperactive child down- but they still will be more whizzy that their classmates- concentration and focus will still be a lifeong problem- this as a mother of a 28year old hyperactive- who is now working towards an OU degree. > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2010 Report Share Posted August 12, 2010 It should also be remembered that ADHD is closely related to the autism syndrome illnesses and there is a strong link with thyroid illness to the autistic spectrum. Lynne Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 13, 2010 Report Share Posted August 13, 2010 With respect , it's diagnosed with a questionaire. " How your brain works, how you process things " is behaviour. Or did they identify yours on a CT Scan? I don't think so. Does Ritalin cure any of these issues? No, just makes you care less. Zoned out. Bit like Anti-depressants, well exactly like. I don't want my symptoms masking, I want to find the cause & treat it. Good luck with your ADHD. I'm only trying to help. I think you'd be better off with B12 jabs & your Throid meds. Good luck! ian ADHD is not diagnosed only on behavioral patterns. It's how your brain works, how you process things. Michele Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 13, 2010 Report Share Posted August 13, 2010 Hello , can you share with us what treatment they are giving you for your ADHD and is it working. Also, how do you differentiate between the symptoms of ADHD and those of thyroid that must be really difficult? Luv - Sheila Just because a portion of thyroid patients may also have ADHD it doesn't dilute the very legitimate problems that thyroid patients experience, especially in the UK. There's room for all. My experience is not your experience. Yours is not mine. But hopefully we can still be on the journey together. Michele Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 14, 2010 Report Share Posted August 14, 2010 Hi jonny, No, I don't believe ritalin would have helped- it works on children as it is a stimulant,which that at that age would have acted as a sedative- not really enough was known 28 years ago so I didn't really want her to be used as a guinea pig when it was obvious that she was overreacting to ordinary meds for normal childhood stuff- mostly due to the azo dyes and preservatives used then- now it's somewhat better ,but you do still see a lot of pink pills etc- I and she always asks if there is an uncoloured version of any med. It was an obvious hyperactive reaction to colours preservatives and salysilates- I could see the change in her coming back from a birthday party- she would be bouncing off the walls and we would have to calm her night terrors for a couple of days until she calmed down- then a day of tears as she was 'hung over' from the reaction. I packed her special lunch boxes for these occasions, but so many mothers thought that 'a little bit of pink cake wouldn't hurt' but one bite was always too much. As teenager she would have got decent A levels had it not been for severe glandular fever which she took 5 years to fully recover from- this is why she is doing an OU degree at her age. She is fit enough to be a qualified life guard and ran a 'race for life' in a respectable time this year. She has had TSH done at intervals when she had low points, but and it always comes back at 1.0 which is optimum. I feel that a decent fresh food diet was the best and most natural option- which in her case calmed her down so her appetite improved- she could sit still long enough to eat properly and thus tired her normally instead of being able to walk for 2 miles at 18months!! It only took a week for her sleep to improve once the diet was strictly enforced- sleeping through the night for the first time at 3 years old. The classic quote from Dr Feingold is'your cant put 20th century food into stone age bodies- we have come so far, but our bodies have not changed. > thyroid treatment > From: strummer61@...> Date: Thu, 12 Aug 2010 16:11:17 +0000> Subject: Re: Diagnosed with ADHD and Depression - explains EVERYTHING> > Hi > > Don't you think your daughter's symptoms could be down to the same things that bring you to this forum, IE Thyroid related??> > I certainly feel 1000 times better since I've been treated with B12 & Thyroid meds.> > Afterall, ADHD is diagnosed on a set of behaviour. All of which I believe can either be attributed to Thyroid or cured by good sleep & the right diet.> > Is she on Ritalin?> > > > > >> > > > Hi,> > There's a bit more to it than that- but I agree with the diet comments- a correct low salycilate and no food additive diet will slow a hyperactive child down- but they still will be more whizzy that their classmates- concentration and focus will still be a lifeong problem- this as a mother of a 28year old hyperactive- who is now working towards an OU degree. > > > > > > > > > ------------------------------------> > TPA is not medically qualified. Consult with a qualified medical practitioner before changing medication.> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 14, 2010 Report Share Posted August 14, 2010 Hi , Thanks for this- I will copy to my daughter. She is very aware of the possibility that she may develop hypo at some stage in her life, but is doing very well at the moment.thyroid treatment From: christina@...Date: Thu, 12 Aug 2010 17:14:37 +0000Subject: Re: Diagnosed with ADHD and Depression - explains EVERYTHING Just want to add my two pence worth to this discussion…. or rather what I have read in Mark Starr's book of "Hypothyroidism, Type2" (Quote) ….In a study from the National Institutes of Health published in 1995, attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) was present in 72% of males and 43% of females who were identified with a genetically inherited form of Hypothyroidism. The NID studied 104 affected patients from 42 different families identified between 1976 and 1995….. Medications affecting the central nervous system (the brain and spinal cord) often have the opposite effect upon children that they have on adults. Stimulants such as amphetamines are used to treat hyperactive children with attention deficits. Their hyperactivity and short attention spans frequently improve. The same drugs would make adults more active with shorter attention spans. The short attention span and hyperactivity many children suffer may be due to their low metabolism and fatigues. If symptoms of hypothyroidism and low basal temperature are present, a trial of thyroid hormones in indicated. Thyroid hormone treatment to increase metabolism is a much more physiological and efficacious method than elevating metabolism with amphetamines….. .... The gray matter of our brain's frontal cortex continues to thicken and grow throughout childhood. Its size peaks at about the time of puberty. It appears the brain has some capacity for regeneration and development throughout our lives. The gray matter of the frontal cortex is involved in judgement, organization, planning, initiating attention, and shifting or stoppingattention. The frontal cortex is the command centre of the brain. In 2006, 2.5 million children in America were prescribed antipsychotic medication. Obviously, the earlier the treatment for hypothyroidism begins, the better the chances are for normal cognitive development and psychological well-being... (unquote) Every worth-while book I have ever read on Hypothyroidism states that ADHD is well known as a clinical sign of Hypothyroidism. So why, I wonder (or shouldn't I ?) are patients with diagnosed ADHD not generally checked for, let alone treated for, Hypothyroidism ? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 14, 2010 Report Share Posted August 14, 2010 Hmm, Shelia's two questions each seemed to generate their own long answers. Sorry. I'm long-winded I know it, but I cant' reign it in. Forgive me and I hop this all helps someone.Hello , can you share with us what treatment they are giving you foryour ADHD and is it workingI'm happy to Shelia. I haven't started anything yet. Right now the Adult ADHD specialist and my GP are coordinating with each other. I have another consult next Wednesday. I can update as I go through the process if you'd like. Let me know.So here's what I've done to prepare for starting ADHD meds. I've gotten fresh bloodwork processed and am at probably my best ever period in my thyroid treatment.I'm actually very excited, as I've not been to the doctor for almost 2 years and have been handling things on my own. I feel better than I have in years, and it's nice to finally have the "proof" in my numbers. I've finally been able to prove to my doctor that allowing me to suppress my TSH lets my FT4 and FT3 stabilize. Hopefully this will help future patients in his care.TSH - <0.01FT4 - 1.0ng/dL (0.8-1.8 range)FT3 - 365 pg/dL (230-420 range)TgAB - <20 (the first time I've not shown positive for them in years)TPO AB - 314 /ml ( my lowest number ever, my highest was 895)I believe my improved antibodies are a direct result of eliminating gluten.My iron and ferritin are in range, but on the low end. I'd like to see them higher still so I'm going back to actively supplementing. I also cook with cast iron.Iron Total - 53 mcg/dL (40-175 range)Iron Binding Capacity - 268 mcg/dL (250-450 range)% saturation - 20% (15-50 range)Ferritin - 76 ng/mL (10-154 range)My B12 has lowered, I'll be watching it, but I'm usually in the upper third of the range or over range without supplementation except for what's in my multi-vitamin.Vitamin B12 - 582 pg/mL (200-1100 range)My vitamin D is pitifully low, as I knew it would be, so I'll be starting supplementation again. I just don't get enough sunlight, despite living in Southern California.And I had an EKG yesterday, all was good.I still need to have my cortisol measured so I can get a baseline pre-ADHD medication.The one aspect that I will be watching most closely will be how any medication I take is interacting with my adrenal system. I think this is probably the biggest challenge. I plan to support my adrenal system naturally while doing the med trail. I've never taken Cortef and don't really want to.. Also, how do you differentiate between thesymptoms of ADHD and those of thyroid that must be really difficult?Luv - SheilaI can only tell you where my thinking is right now. I believe my Hashimoto's kicked in around puberty, as that's when I first started have physical symptoms. I was dx'd with Hashimotos in my early 20s, I became actively involved in my treatment and started researching about my thyroid problems in my late 20s I'm now 37. At this point, I consider myself an expert... on myself :)I have some symptoms that have not changed, they were there before I was diagnosed with Hashis, they were there when I was under-treated, and they're there now that I am adequately treated. I initially thought they were thyroid symptoms. Because I didn't know adults could have ADHD I never considered anything else, and I'm well aware of how un- and under-treated thyroid problems can affect mental health. I was mis-diagnosed as bi-polar at the same time my Hashi's was discovered. It's horrible, but it's a common misdiagnosis. I have experienced crippling depression in my life as well.... turned out that was thyroid related as well. It "magically" disappeared with treatment.What never changed were symptoms like these:The ability to hyper-focus (to the exclusion of all else for 8-10 hours at a time) on things that interest me coupled with the inability to focus on anything that bores me. (I'm so very lucky that my medical treatment interest me!)Being distracted off topic at the drop of a hatStarting projects, but rarely finishing - my world is surrounded by piles of half completed projects.It's very difficult for me to make decisions, it takes me 10 times as long as the average person.I'm impatient, I get frustrated easilyI have difficulty expressing myself and getting my points across because I flood people with too much info.My mind is usually on 10-15 things at once.I can't be on time to save my life, and I'm very poor at estimating time.Now, sure, you could argue that everyone is like that, everyone experiences stuff like that from time to time.But for me, it's my daily life, and it interferes with the progression of my life as well. I can't hold down a real world job, so I work in entertainment. Great that I found something that works for me, but I'm 37 with no retirement, pension, or health benefits. Not so great really.So my internal guide is telling me to try this path. It's the same voice that told me that I needed T3 in addition to T4, and that I should get off gluten, so I'm willing to listen. -MicheleThese are my experiences, and I wouldn't dream of telling anyone else that what worked for me will work for them. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2011 Report Share Posted January 2, 2011 " Does Ritalin cure any of these issues? No, just makes you care less. Zoned out. Bit like Anti-depressants, well exactly like. " It is unfortunate that you felt that ritalin did not help you with your symptoms Ian. But ritalin does help people with their symptoms, not just make people care less. Many people with ADHD find that ritalin does not help them...this is why there are many medications for ADHD (amphetamine based like Adderall, dexedrine, vyvanse or methylphenidate based like ritalin, concerta, focalin, strattera, and perhaps others like provigil and intuiv) ADHD is a complex disorder, like all mental disorders, and there is speculation that the hyperactive type of ADHD and the innatentive type are actually two different disorders (the behaviour of a purely hyperactive type is very different from that of an purely innatentive type, although there are many things they have in common too). When it comes to brain chemicals it's not as simple as " this pill should work " because the brain is so complex that one pill can have different effects in one person than another. This is why there is so much choice of medication, and partly why they are always on the hunt for new ones. " Afterall, ADHD is diagnosed on a set of behaviour. All of which I believe can either be attributed to Thyroid or cured by good sleep & the right diet. " It is true that many hypothyroid symptoms are the same as those for ADHD, and in fact statistically people with hypothyroidism are much more likely to be diagnosed with ADHD and vice versa.... ....NOTE: this indicates a correlative link, not necessarily a causal one...so it COULD indicate that many people with hypothyroidism are diganosed with ADHD but that hypothyroidism is the sole cause of their symptoms. OR it could mean that there is a mutual cause of both (eg. genes that play a role in hypothyroidism also play a role in ADHD). Or a combination of the two. I think that hypothyroidism has many symptoms in common partly because it probably affects the same brain chemicals that are involved in ADHD (dopamine and norepinephrine). Low thyroid hormones will probably lower the output of the brain chemicals and will effectively give someone ADHD or depression which is secondary to hypothyroidism. In THIS case, the cause is hypothyroidism. BUT it is wrong to assume that all cases of ADHD/depression are caused by a hormone problem. Mostly ADHD is simply a genetic problem with the brain...a lower amount of certain brains chemicals. The only way to solve this is to give ADHD medication. Ideally we would be able to permanently correct the mechanism which causes it to be low, so that no medication need to be given every day. But we don't know enough about the brain to do this and so the only way to restore the brain chemicals to a normal level is to use daily medication. A rather rubbish analogy from the top of my head is that we can't fix the fuel leak in a car because we don't know how, so we keep filling the tank up more often. It's not a cure, but it sorts the problem out. As for the existence of ADHD...there is no debate abut this. It is more of a media involvement which has led the public to believe that there is. There is so much evidence to show that ADHD is real. And if the medical profession didnt take other disorders into account while researching ADHD (eg. hormonal disorders like low testosterone or hypothyroidism, or even not getting enough sleep) then it could hardly be counted as research. Overall, I agree with Michele...if you have hormonal disorders then of course treat them. Ian, if my testosterone was close to the edge of the range then I too would want to treat it to make it more normal. BUT please don't assume that ADHD is not real and MUST be due to hormonal causes or even just not enough sleep. Mostly it is due to genetic problems with the brain. I think it is important to look at evidence when diagnosing a medical condition and that is exactly what the medical establishment does. That is why there are journals and studies. We need the evidence to support a diagnosis or treatment because without that we are just guessing. And while personal or anecdotal evidence is a form of evidence, it is not a strong as medical research as it is vulnerable to many errors due to the man variables involved not being controlled. This is why only evidence from rigorous studies is used for diagnosis and treatment, and anecdotal evidence is only used to suggest a POSSIBLE area for further research. To put it bluntly, there IS substantial rigorous evidence for ADHD and its treatment, whereas there is no evidence for the treatment of hypothyroidism with Armour thyroid or hydrocortisone other than anecdotal.. To try and treat certain symptoms with a treatment that there is only anecdotal evidence for, while there is ample, medically recognised, evidence for a different treatment does not make sense. My intention is not to " rock the boat " as it were, but rather to get people to seek a more medically recognised, evidence based diagnosis and treatment that will hopefully work better and ultimately lead them on the road to a healthier and happier life. All the best, Jonny Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2011 Report Share Posted January 2, 2011 "To try and treat certain symptoms with a treatment that there is only anecdotal evidence for, while there is ample, medically recognised, evidence for a different treatment does not make sense." Dear Jonny, I have worked in the drug licensing department of a pharmaceutical company. Drug licenses in most civilised countries are obtained by presenting a toxicological and pharmacological dossier of the product to the Ministry of Health. The trials that back up the claims of these two dossiers may be carried out by the manufacturer, but must be carried out by an independent laboratory. Any independent laboratory that runs drug trials for a product that is likely to compete with a Big Pharma Company's product is going to find itself out of business in no time. In fact the term "independent" means that the laboratory has no direct financial or administrative link with it's clients in Big Pharma. It is a total joke, because Big Pharma supply all the business to these labs and they get to call the shots. No one will ever run trials for Armour because (i) it costs a lot of money (ii) the manufacturers of other products who would lose business if Armour became a recognised treatment, would be able to stop the business of this independent laboratory by withdrawing their custom. This is how good cheap products are kept off the market and new ones that we don't need are kept coming onto the market. This is how Big Pharma gets to control what goes on and which drugs get to be sold, all of this is backed up with written material in the form of trials which masquerades as proof. Ritalin etc, may very well do what it says it does, but do people who have ADHD really get to make an informed choice about their treatment? Finally, because of what I have explained above, it is highly unlikely that lots of good drugs (good that is for patients) will have trials done on them. So iodine, ldn and lots of other drugs already on the market will be held back, because they will only make people better and don't make people rich. What consistutes "proof" is rigged and what is anecdotal seems to me after a stint in the pharmaceutical industry a great deal more reliable than what my doctor has told me about thyroid drugs. MacGilchrist Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2011 Report Share Posted January 3, 2011 Good response , Many thanks. Luv - Sheila " To try and treat certain symptoms with a treatment that there is only anecdotal evidence for, while there is ample, medically recognised, evidence for a different treatment does not make sense. " Dear Jonny, I have worked in the drug licensing department of a pharmaceutical company. Drug licenses in most civilised countries are obtained by presenting a toxicological and pharmacological dossier of the product to the Ministry of Health. The trials that back up the claims of these two dossiers may be carried out by the manufacturer, but must be carried out by an independent laboratory. Any independent laboratory that runs drug trials for a product that is likely to compete with a Big Pharma Company's product is going to find itself out of business in no time. In fact the term " independent " means that the laboratory has no direct financial or administrative link with it's clients in Big Pharma. It is a total joke, because Big Pharma supply all the business to these labs and they get to call the shots. No one will ever run trials for Armour because (i) it costs a lot of money (ii) the manufacturers of other products who would lose business if Armour became a recognised treatment, would be able to stop the business of this independent laboratory by withdrawing their custom. This is how good cheap products are kept off the market and new ones that we don't need are kept coming onto the market. This is how Big Pharma gets to control what goes on and which drugs get to be sold, all of this is backed up with written material in the form of trials which masquerades as proof. Ritalin etc, may very well do what it says it does, but do people who have ADHD really get to make an informed choice about their treatment? Finally, because of what I have explained above, it is highly unlikely that lots of good drugs (good that is for patients) will have trials done on them. So iodine, ldn and lots of other drugs already on the market will be held back, because they will only make people better and don't make people rich. What consistutes " proof " is rigged and what is anecdotal seems to me after a stint in the pharmaceutical industry a great deal more reliable than what my doctor has told me about thyroid drugs. MacGilchrist Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.