Guest guest Posted August 9, 2010 Report Posted August 9, 2010 Think very very carefully about this and take more time finding out about the medication and the alternatives.It may settle given more time. I was rushed into surgery and regret it. Now I know more I would have stuck with the medication . Are you on heart medication as well ? Mine was not bad enough for that. Take time over this it is unfair to rush you .Best wishes Quote
Guest guest Posted August 9, 2010 Report Posted August 9, 2010 Hi. As far as I'm aware you can stay on Carbimazole for years if they help you! Can your dose not be lowered yet, what were your last blood results? How long did you take them for last time? 40mg is a high dose to be on for 3months.. I take it they're testing your liver function etc and it's ok? I had the operation in April this yr and for me personally it was the best thing I could've done as I couldn't with the effects of Carb or PTU and was swinging from hyper to hypo on a regular basis and I had Hashis along with Graves disease. Was it endo who told you to go for op or surgeon? I think it's too big a decision to make in one week especially if you're doing ok on atd's. I'd look at all my options before you do anything drastic as you can stay on a maintenance dose for yrs. As I said I don't regret the op for a minute but I'm struggling a bit just now,nothing compared to before but if I could've took the Carbmizole/PTU I would've stayed on that as long as I could. Love Tess > > I have just come back from seeing a consultant who seemed very keen to have me operated. I suffered from Hyperthyroidism 2 years ago and was treated for a year with the block & replace therapy. Unfortunately about 3/4 months ago I started to Quote
Guest guest Posted August 9, 2010 Report Posted August 9, 2010 Read what Dr Peatfield says about treatment for Grave's http://www.tpa-uk.org.uk/surgery_vs_radioiodinetherapy.php http://www.tpa-uk.org.uk/treatment_hyperthyroidism.php http://www.tpa-uk.org.uk/hypert_when_things_go_wrong.php Luv - Sheila I have just come back from seeing a consultant who seemed very keen to have me operated. I suffered from Hyperthyroidism 2 years ago and was treated for a year with the block & replace therapy. Unfortunately about 3/4 months ago I started to feel unwell and eventually was diagnosed again as having Hyperthyroidism. I have been on 40 gr of Cabimazole since mid June and feel much better for it. I was hoping that I could carry on the treatment, stop it and hope for the best but the consultant I saw seemed to expect the worst. I am allegedly on a very high dose of carbimazole which in the long term is very bad for the liver and the level of white blood cells and he advised me very strongly - i.e. to make up my mind this week rather than when I next see him - to have the operation. I am a bit confused about the whole thing and was hoping I could avoid the operation altogether. anyone with an idea? similar experience? many thanks No virus found in this incoming message. Checked by AVG - www.avg.com Version: 8.5.441 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/3059 - Release Date: 08/08/10 17:57:00 Quote
Guest guest Posted August 9, 2010 Report Posted August 9, 2010 Here's a link that says staying on atd's long term gives better chance of remission. Most patients achieve remission within 12-18 months. However, on rare occasions, it can take as long as 20 years. Studies by Yamamoto from the 1980's show that approximately 90 percent of people who stay on ATDs as long as 4 years achieve permanent remission. Read more at Suite101: Hyperthyroid Disorders - free Suite101 course http://www.suite101.com/lesson.cfm/19330/2902/2#ixzz0w8tr3UVz Love Tess > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 10, 2010 Report Posted August 10, 2010 Thank you very much for your reply. No I didn't need to take any heart medication but my blood test showed a very high level of Hyperthyroidism. When you say that now you know more about it you would have stuck to the medication what do you mean? My gut feeling is I don't want to have the operation and I would rather have an alternative but the consultants didn't give me much choice. Eventhough I asked for a second opinion and got it...i.e saw another consultant at the same hospital, she just repeated more slowly what the previous consultant had told me. > > > Think very very carefully about this and take more time finding out about the medication and the alternatives.It may settle given more time. I was rushed into surgery and regret it. Now I know more I would have stuck with the medication . Are you on heart medication as well ? Mine was not bad enough for that. Take time over this it is unfair to rush you .Best wishes > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 10, 2010 Report Posted August 10, 2010 I would ask for a referral to Dr Lynn and be guided by him - considered to be the top thyroid surgeon in the UK. You can see his web site here http://www.endocrinesurgeon.co.uk .. Luv - Sheila Thank you very much for your reply. No I didn't need to take any heart medication but my blood test showed a very high level of Hyperthyroidism. When you say that now you know more about it you would have stuck to the medication what do you mean? My gut feeling is I don't want to have the operation and I would rather have an alternative but the consultants didn't give me much choice. Eventhough I asked for a second opinion and got it...i.e saw another consultant at the same hospital, she just repeated more slowly what the previous consultant had told me. Quote
Guest guest Posted August 10, 2010 Report Posted August 10, 2010 Hi, Have you asked if it is possible for you to have Radio Active Iodine treatment? This is far preferable to having surgery. I had very high thyrotoxicity and needed heart meds as well as the maximum dose of carbimazole and I had also suffered thyroid storm. I was told surgery carried a much higher risk than RAI. I really do think you need to ask them about it beforemaking any decisions. Luv Lynne My gut feeling is I don't want to have the operation Quote
Guest guest Posted August 10, 2010 Report Posted August 10, 2010 Hi Sheila, Many thanks for your suggestion. When you say ask for a referral I assume you mean make an appointment with him on a private basis. I'll have a good look at his website. thanks again. > > I would ask for a referral to Dr Lynn and be guided by him - considered > to be the top thyroid surgeon in the UK. You can see his web site here > http://www.endocrinesurgeon.co.uk . > > Luv - Sheila > > > > > > Thank you very much for your reply. No I didn't need to take any heart > medication but my blood test showed a very high level of Hyperthyroidism. > When you say that now you know more about it you would have stuck to the > medication what do you mean? My gut feeling is I don't want to have the > operation and I would rather have an alternative but the consultants didn't > give me much choice. Eventhough I asked for a second opinion and got > it...i.e saw another consultant at the same hospital, she just repeated more > slowly what the previous consultant had told me. > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 10, 2010 Report Posted August 10, 2010 Hi, they said that my left eye was bulging which indicated thyroid related eye disease and that Radio Active Iodine affects the eyes so that it wasn't such a good idea. I've asked to be refer to an ophtalmologist to double check my eyes. I had not quite noticed it was bulging. now i'm very worried! thanks for your reply. > > Hi, > Have you asked if it is possible for you to have Radio Active Iodine treatment? This is far preferable to having surgery. > I had very high thyrotoxicity and needed heart meds as well as the maximum dose of carbimazole and I had also suffered thyroid storm. I was told surgery carried a much higher risk than RAI. > I really do think you need to ask them about it beforemaking any decisions. > Luv Lynne > > My gut feeling is I don't want to have the operation > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 10, 2010 Report Posted August 10, 2010 Many thanks for the link. > > > Here's a link that says staying on atd's long term gives better chance of remission. > > > Most patients achieve remission within 12-18 months. However, on rare occasions, it can take as long as 20 years. Studies by Yamamoto from the 1980's show that approximately 90 percent of people who stay on ATDs as long as 4 years achieve permanent remission. > > Read more at Suite101: Hyperthyroid Disorders - free Suite101 course http://www.suite101.com/lesson.cfm/19330/2902/2#ixzz0w8tr3UVz > > Love Tess > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 10, 2010 Report Posted August 10, 2010 My husband had the op for Hyperthyroid because he was told very firmly that Radio Active Iodine should never be given to anyone under 40 Also I once worked for one of the 1st doctors to use RAI on Thyroid patients and would never encourage anyone to accept it Also a stuidy was done in which RAI patients ALL became Hypothyroid within 5 years often far sooner whereas generally with surgury it was 10 yrs before pretty much all became Hypo What must be checked prooperly is if you also have Hashimotos running in tandem then nothing should be done because you stand a better chance of becoming Normal The other very vital thing is that after either RAI or Surgury for Hyperthyroid the " normal " range for T4 and TSH is a nonsense because as my husband proved and research in Sweden showed the body is sensitised to extraordinary high levels of T4 and after surgury can never again function on the " normal levels " Pat > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 10, 2010 Report Posted August 10, 2010 Problem here is that each one of us is an individual, and what worked for one doesn't automatically mean it will work for others. All options need to be considered and you need to speak with the real professionals who are the experts in this field. I suggested Dr Lynn because he is NHS and you should ask your GP to refer you to him. However, I don't know the area you live pgelthooft. My sister was operated on as an emergency, she came through it with flying colours, but yes, she went hypothyroid and has been kept alive and well on Armour Thyroid ever since. Luv - Sheila My husband had the op for Hyperthyroid because he was told very firmly that Radio Active Iodine should never be given to anyone under 40 Also I once worked for one of the 1st doctors to use RAI on Thyroid patients and would never encourage anyone to accept it Also a stuidy was done in which RAI patients ALL became Hypothyroid within 5 years often far sooner whereas generally with surgury it was 10 yrs before pretty much all became Hypo What must be checked prooperly is if you also have Hashimotos running in tandem then nothing should be done because you stand a better chance of becoming Normal The other very vital thing is that after either RAI or Surgury for Hyperthyroid the " normal " range for T4 and TSH is a nonsense because as my husband proved and research in Sweden showed the body is sensitised to extraordinary high levels of T4 and after surgury can never again function on the " normal levels " Pat Quote
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Posted August 11, 2010 Hi 'pgelthooft' (have you another name we can address you by?). Auto-immune problems are caused by inappropriate behaviour of the body's immune system. The immune system usually fights off infection but in auto-immune disease it attacks the body's own tissues with auto-antibodies. Thyroid antibodies destroy the thyroid gland completely - it can take a short time or it can take years. At the moment the reason for this is not entirely clear. When an auto-immune attack starts on the thyroid, it responds by producing more of its hormones. At the same time the auto-antibodies attacking the thyroid gland also attack the tissues around the eyes. They probably want to operate and remove your thyroid gland so the antibodies will have nowhere to attack and will go away, and hopefully, will stop attacking the eye tissue. Read the information here and also scroll down to 'Thyroid Ablation' http://www.thyroidmanager.org/Chapter12/Ch-12-2.htm .. Also read the info. here http://www.thyroid-info.com/articles/thyroideye.htm Luv - Sheila Hi, they said that my left eye was bulging which indicated thyroid related eye disease and that Radio Active Iodine affects the eyes so that it wasn't such a good idea. I've asked to be refer to an ophtalmologist to double check my eyes. I had not quite noticed it was bulging. now i'm very worried! thanks for your reply. Quote
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Posted August 11, 2010 You can of course see him privately, or you can ask your GP for a referral within the NHS. Whatever you decide , you should not delay, especially as it now appears your eyes are becoming affected. Luv - Sheila Hi Sheila, Many thanks for your suggestion. When you say ask for a referral I assume you mean make an appointment with him on a private basis. I'll have a good look at his website. thanks again. Quote
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Posted August 11, 2010 Hi Sheila, I was not aware I could ask for a referral via the NHS to a Bupa surgeon. I've already had a referral through the NHS to a King's College consultant here in London and that took ages. Do you think I could go back to the GP and ask to be referred to that particular surgeon? Is that common practice? many thanks, > > > You can of course see him privately, or you can ask your GP for a referral > within the NHS. Whatever you decide , you should not delay, > especially as it now appears your eyes are becoming affected. > > Luv - Sheila [Ed] Quote
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Posted August 11, 2010 Hi Sheila, My name is . Thanks for the detail information. tks > > > Hi 'pgelthooft' (have you another name we can address you by?). Auto-immune > problems are caused by inappropriate behaviour of the body's immune system. > OLD MESSAGE DELETED BY MODERATOR PLEASE TRIM YOUR MESSAGES. THANK YOU Quote
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Posted August 11, 2010 Hi in answer to your question it was carbimazole and I went on to have surgery for a very large goitre . I was brought up in what could be called a " hot spot " -too much natural fluorine in the water. Therefore all my close friends have had a problem -the one who is a doctor refused both radiation and surgery and now has the best health of all of us .{ her thyroid eventually settled taking carbimazole} Your worry about your eyes -have you seen a specalist ? I don,t mean a surgeon . After surgery or radiation you will most likely only see the consultant only once and then back to GP and perhaps an endo . If you have read the items on this website you will find that many of us are not happy with the aftercare in this country. Also there are different opinions on the dangers of carbimazole -read Dr P,s bit. Also I know of one GP { of the older generation } who would give carbimazole a very good try before sending patients to a surgeon . A pharmacist would have much greater knowledge than a surgeon on the danger of any drug -try phoning a couple and get an opinion from them .You might find that there is not as much to worry about as you are being told . Best Wishes Quote
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Posted August 11, 2010 Hi, Betablockers are often given for hyper as they reduce the T4 to T3 conversion which can be excessive in hyper. They are also prescibed for migraine and reducing blood pressure. > thyroid treatment > From: mary36white@...> Date: Mon, 9 Aug 2010 19:02:57 +0000> Subject: Re: thyroid ablation> > > Think very very carefully about this and take more time finding out about the medication and the alternatives.It may settle given more time. I was rushed into surgery and regret it. Now I know more I would have stuck with the medication . Are you on heart medication as well ? Mine was not bad enough for that. Take time over this it is unfair to rush you .Best wishes > > > > ------------------------------------> > TPA is not medically qualified. Consult with a qualified medical practitioner before changing medication.> > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Posted August 11, 2010 Hi, Hardly a proper second opinion when they were in the same dept- you need to see someone at a different hospital for a proper opinion. She wouldn't dare go against the dept boss! > thyroid treatment > From: pgelthooft@...> Date: Tue, 10 Aug 2010 14:56:59 +0000> Subject: Re: thyroid ablation> > Thank you very much for your reply. No I didn't need to take any heart medication but my blood test showed a very high level of Hyperthyroidism. When you say that now you know more about it you would have stuck to the medication what do you mean? My gut feeling is I don't want to have the operation and I would rather have an alternative but the consultants didn't give me much choice. Eventhough I asked for a second opinion and got it...i.e saw another consultant at the same hospital, she just repeated more slowly what the previous consultant had told me.> > >> > > > > ------------------------------------> > TPA is not medically qualified. Consult with a qualified medical practitioner before changing medication.> > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Posted August 11, 2010 Hi Sheila, I have called doctor Lynn and spoke to his secretary. It would appear he doesn't take any referrals from the NHS and he's only doing it on a private basis. I was quoted £350 for a consultation and £8.000 should I need an operation which is a lot of money for me. best regards, > > > > You can of course see him privately, or you can ask your GP for a referral > > within the NHS. Whatever you decide , you should not delay, > > especially as it now appears your eyes are becoming affected. > > > > Luv - Sheila > > > [Ed] > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Posted August 11, 2010 Hi , my gut feeling entirely. I am not too sure how I can go about getting a second opinion on the NHS. whether I can just ask my GP or whether I need to go private which in that case appears to be particularly expensive. Regards > > > Hi, > Hardly a proper second opinion when they were in the same dept- you need to see someone at a different hospital for a proper opinion. She wouldn't dare go against the dept boss! > > > > thyroid treatment > > From: pgelthooft@... > > Date: Tue, 10 Aug 2010 14:56:59 +0000 > > Subject: Re: thyroid ablation > > > > Thank you very much for your reply. No I didn't need to take any heart medication but my blood test showed a very high level of Hyperthyroidism. When you say that now you know more about it you would have stuck to the medication what do you mean? My gut feeling is I don't want to have the operation and I would rather have an alternative but the consultants didn't give me much choice. Eventhough I asked for a second opinion and got it...i.e saw another consultant at the same hospital, she just repeated more slowly what the previous consultant had told me. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > > > TPA is not medically qualified. Consult with a qualified medical practitioner before changing medication. > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Posted August 11, 2010 I thought they were only given in case of anxiety or palpitations. That is why I didn't take them. Regards, > > > Hi, > Betablockers are often given for hyper as they reduce the T4 to T3 conversion which can be excessive in hyper. > > ------------------------------------ > > OLD STUFF DELETED BY MODERATOR.... CAN YOU REMEMBER TO TRIM OFF THE OLD MESSAGES PLEASE..... Quote
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Posted August 11, 2010 Thanks for explaining. My white cell blood count is going down and I guess that is why they advised me the surgery. On the ground that carbimazole is bad for the liver and the white blood cells. It is not quite clear why I am not given a lesser dose of carbimazole now that I'm feeling much better. I can imagine what you mean with regards to the after care and that is also what I am worried about. I spoke to the consultant's secretary yesterday to double check whether she was going to refer me to an opthalmologist (after describing my left eye as having all the signs of graves disease and being enlarged) and the response was it wasn't needed yet. Of course it is good news but now I'm even more confused! regards, > > > Hi in answer to your question it was carbimazole and I went on to have surgery for a very large goitre . I was brought up in what could be called a " hot spot " -too much natural fluorine in the water. Therefore all my close friends have had a problem -the one who is a doctor refused both radiation and surgery and now has the best health of all of us .{ her thyroid eventually settled taking carbimazole} Your worry about your eyes -have you seen a specalist ? I don,t mean a surgeon . After surgery or radiation you will most likely only see the consultant only once and then back to GP and perhaps an endo .. If you have read the items on this website you will find that many of us are not happy with the aftercare in this country. Also there are different opinions on the dangers of carbimazole -read Dr P,s bit. Also I know of one GP { of the older generation } who would give carbimazole a very good try before sending patients to a surgeon . A pharmacist would have much greater knowledge than a surgeon on the danger of any drug -try phoning a couple and get an opinion from them .You might find that there is not as much to worry about as you are being told . Best Wishes > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Posted August 11, 2010 Can Armour still be obtained in Scotland.Sent from my BlackBerry® wireless deviceFrom: "Sheila" <sheila@...>Sender: thyroid treatment Date: Tue, 10 Aug 2010 21:43:37 +0100<thyroid treatment >Reply thyroid treatment Subject: RE: Re: thyroid ablation Problem here is that each one of us is an individual, and whatworked for one doesn't automatically mean it will work for others. All optionsneed to be considered and you need to speak with the real professionals who arethe experts in this field. I suggested Dr Lynn because he is NHS and you shouldask your GP to refer you to him. However, I don't know the area you livepgelthooft.My sister was operated on as an emergency, she came through itwith flying colours, but yes, she went hypothyroid and has been kept alive andwell on Armour Thyroid ever since.Luv- SheilaMy husband had the op for Hyperthyroid becausehe was told very firmly that Radio Active Iodine should never be given toanyone under 40 Also I once worked for one of the 1st doctors to use RAI on Thyroid patientsand would never encourage anyone to accept it Also a stuidy was done in which RAI patients ALL became Hypothyroid within 5years often far sooner whereas generally with surgury it was 10 yrs beforepretty much all became Hypo What must be checked prooperly is if you also have Hashimotos running in tandemthen nothing should be done because you stand a better chance of becomingNormal The other very vital thing is that after either RAI or Surgury for Hyperthyroidthe " normal " range for T4 and TSH is a nonsense because as myhusband proved and research in Sweden showed the body is sensitised toextraordinary high levels of T4 and after surgury can never again function onthe " normal levels " Pat Quote
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Posted August 11, 2010 OoErr! Well, obviously once you are as famous as him, you can charge what you like. Sorry about that . Do you know anything of the reputation of the guys your GP has referred you to. Have you tried typing their name into Google with 'Thyroid Surgeon' and getting up some information about them. If they are well known and lecture or teach or written papers, that will be a good indication that they can be trusted. It's always good to find out as much about such surgeons as you can. Luv - Sheila Hi Sheila, I have called doctor Lynn and spoke to his secretary. It would appear he doesn't take any referrals from the NHS and he's only doing it on a private basis. I was quoted £350 for a consultation and £8.000 should I need an operation which is a lot of money for me. best regards, Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.