Re: Confusion re Vitamin C and iodine supplementation??

[Guest guest]

It also says they alternated that 3 gm Vit C with

the Iodine every other day. One day vit C, the

next day Iodine. No conflict.

Bethann

" The greatest enemy of knowledge is not

ignorance...it is the illusion of knowledge "

~ Hawking

whiting.mary@... wrote:

>

>

> In the free iodine book at http://f1.grp. fs.com/ v1/wK-AS8KpTgVyt

> 80nmPztVesP0mBwp YGinb06U6I2XOBKy kjI9wzderzIRYsbA IJzzpuCzYVOXhXub

> uNO9o3TvnbaEJor- XtZl6YXKw9QImnT7 eE0bXpIBAdu/ 90%20Miscellaneo

> us%20Information /iodine_book_ 03_30_08. pdf

>

<http://f1.grp.fs.com/v1/wK-AS8KpTgVyt80nmPztVesP0mBwpYGinb06U6I2XOBKykjI9w\

zderzIRYsbAIJzzpuCzYVOXhXubuNO9o3TvnbaEJor-XtZl6YXKw9QImnT7eE0bXpIBAdu/90%20Misc\

ellaneous%20Information/iodine_book_03_30_08.pdf>

> it lists Vitamin C in the foods to be limited when taking iodine - yet

> I'm sure I've read elsewhere that you should be taking 3g Vitamin C to

> assist iodine?? Any comments?

>

>

[Guest guest]

Doesn't that imply a conflict, otherwise they could be taken together?

Warm regards,

Joan

> >

> >

> > In the free iodine book at http://f1.grp. fs.com/ v1/wK-AS8KpTgVyt

> > 80nmPztVesP0mBwp YGinb06U6I2XOBKy kjI9wzderzIRYsbA IJzzpuCzYVOXhXub

> > uNO9o3TvnbaEJor- XtZl6YXKw9QImnT7 eE0bXpIBAdu/ 90%20Miscellaneo

> > us%20Information /iodine_book_ 03_30_08. pdf

> >

<http://f1.grp.fs.com/v1/wK-AS8KpTgVyt80nmPztVesP0mBwpYGinb06U6I2XOBKykjI9w\

zderzIRYsbAIJzzpuCzYVOXhXubuNO9o3TvnbaEJor-XtZl6YXKw9QImnT7eE0bXpIBAdu/90%20Misc\

ellaneous%20Information/iodine_book_03_30_08.pdf>

> > it lists Vitamin C in the foods to be limited when taking iodine - yet

> > I'm sure I've read elsewhere that you should be taking 3g Vitamin C to

> > assist iodine?? Any comments?

> >

> >

>

[Guest guest]

Yes, it implies conflict, and how to avoid the

conflict, that's why they did the vitamin C and

Iodine on alternating days. There is no conflict

if it's done that way. LOL

I think I was replying to someone wanting to know

about taking Vit C and Iodine together, LMAO, but

I've read so many emails since then I don't

remember the post I was responding to.

Bethann

" The greatest enemy of knowledge is not

ignorance...it is the illusion of knowledge "

~ Hawking

coloredoctave wrote:

>

>

> Doesn't that imply a conflict, otherwise they could be taken together?

>

> Warm regards,

> Joan

>

>

> > >

> > >

> > > In the free iodine book at http://f1.grp. fs.com/

> v1/wK-AS8KpTgVyt

> > > 80nmPztVesP0mBwp YGinb06U6I2XOBKy kjI9wzderzIRYsbA IJzzpuCzYVOXhXub

> > > uNO9o3TvnbaEJor- XtZl6YXKw9QImnT7 eE0bXpIBAdu/ 90%20Miscellaneo

> > > us%20Information /iodine_book_ 03_30_08. pdf

> > > <http://f1.grp. fs.com/ v1/wK-AS8KpTgVyt 80nmPztVesP0mBwp

> YGinb06U6I2XOBKy kjI9wzderzIRYsbA IJzzpuCzYVOXhXub uNO9o3TvnbaEJor-

> XtZl6YXKw9QImnT7 eE0bXpIBAdu/ 90%20Miscellaneo us%20Information

> /iodine_book_ 03_30_08. pdf

>

<http://f1.grp.fs.com/v1/wK-AS8KpTgVyt80nmPztVesP0mBwpYGinb06U6I2XOBKykjI9w\

zderzIRYsbAIJzzpuCzYVOXhXubuNO9o3TvnbaEJor-XtZl6YXKw9QImnT7eE0bXpIBAdu/90%20Misc\

ellaneous%20Information/iodine_book_03_30_08.pdf>>

> > > it lists Vitamin C in the foods to be limited when taking iodine - yet

> > > I'm sure I've read elsewhere that you should be taking 3g Vitamin C to

> > > assist iodine?? Any comments?

> > >

> > >

> >

>

>

[Guest guest]

Well the problem to start with is to question the source. I can't get the

link to the source to work so I have no idea what it is or whether to trust

it. However, Steph's husband takes his Vit C along with his Iodoral every

day and as she has related, he overcame his Hashi's after a year on the

protocol. So I think Dr. Brownstein's advice is the one to trust, ergo,

take the Vit C every day in divided doses and take the iodine every day as

well.

--

>Yes, it implies conflict, and how to avoid the

>conflict, that's why they did the vitamin C and

>Iodine on alternating days. There is no conflict

>if it's done that way. LOL

>

>I think I was replying to someone wanting to know

>about taking Vit C and Iodine together, LMAO, but

>I've read so many emails since then I don't

>remember the post I was responding to.

>

>Bethann

~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~

--A.J. Muste

[Guest guest]

Well if you look in the ebook that I gave the link

to, and that is in the list files, I believe it

was Dr Brownstein that did the Vit C every other

day. I don't care how people take it really

*shrug*, I'm not trying to tell anyone how they

should or shouldn't be taking vitamin C. I just

replied with what I read in that ebook, and having

info from people that know about chemical

reactions. Someone asked and I replied with what I

know. How anyone takes their Vit C, and when, is

up to them.

Bethann

" The greatest enemy of knowledge is not

ignorance...it is the illusion of knowledge "

~ Hawking

Baker wrote:

>

>

> Well the problem to start with is to question the source. I can't get the

> link to the source to work so I have no idea what it is or whether to trust

> it. However, Steph's husband takes his Vit C along with his Iodoral every

> day and as she has related, he overcame his Hashi's after a year on the

> protocol. So I think Dr. Brownstein's advice is the one to trust, ergo,

> take the Vit C every day in divided doses and take the iodine every day as

> well.

>

> --

>

> >Yes, it implies conflict, and how to avoid the

> >conflict, that's why they did the vitamin C and

> >Iodine on alternating days. There is no conflict

> >if it's done that way. LOL

> >

> >I think I was replying to someone wanting to know

> >about taking Vit C and Iodine together, LMAO, but

> >I've read so many emails since then I don't

> >remember the post I was responding to.

> >

> >Bethann

>

> ~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~

> --A.J. Muste

>

>

[Guest guest]

Oh ok. I have Dr B's iodine book and I never found any info about

alternating, I just saw the daily requirements. --

At 03:46 PM 2/22/2010, you wrote:

>Well if you look in the ebook that I gave the link

>to, and that is in the list files, I believe it

>was Dr Brownstein that did the Vit C every other

>day. I don't care how people take it really

>*shrug*, I'm not trying to tell anyone how they

>should or shouldn't be taking vitamin C. I just

>replied with what I read in that ebook, and having

>info from people that know about chemical

>reactions. Someone asked and I replied with what I

>know. How anyone takes their Vit C, and when, is

>up to them.

>

>Bethann

>

> " The greatest enemy of knowledge is not

>ignorance...it is the illusion of knowledge "

>~ Hawking

>

> Baker wrote:

> >

> >

> > Well the problem to start with is to question the source. I can't get the

> > link to the source to work so I have no idea what it is or whether to trust

> > it. However, Steph's husband takes his Vit C along with his Iodoral every

> > day and as she has related, he overcame his Hashi's after a year on the

> > protocol. So I think Dr. Brownstein's advice is the one to trust, ergo,

> > take the Vit C every day in divided doses and take the iodine every day as

> > well.

> >

> > --

~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~

--A.J. Muste

[Guest guest]

He doesn't recommend alternation. He recommends daily.

Steph

Re: Re: Confusion re Vitamin C and iodine supplementation??

Oh ok. I have Dr B's iodine book and I never found any info about alternating, I just saw the daily requirements. --At 03:46 PM 2/22/2010, you wrote:>Well if you look in the ebook that I gave the link>to, and that is in the list files, I believe it>was Dr Brownstein that did the Vit C every other>day. I don't care how people take it really>*shrug*, I'm not trying to tell anyone how they>should or shouldn't be taking vitamin C. I just>replied with what I read in that ebook, and having>info from people that know about chemical>reactions. Someone asked and I replied with what I>know. How anyone takes their Vit C, and when, is>up to them.>>Bethann>>"The greatest enemy of knowledge is not>ignorance...it is the illusion of knowledge">~ Hawking>> Baker wrote:> >> >> > Well the problem to start with is to question the source. I can't get the> > link to the source to work so I have no idea what it is or whether to trust> > it. However, Steph's husband takes his Vit C along with his Iodoral every> > day and as she has related, he overcame his Hashi's after a year on the> > protocol. So I think Dr. Brownstein's advice is the one to trust, ergo,> > take the Vit C every day in divided doses and take the iodine every day as> > well.> >> > --~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~--A.J. Muste

[Guest guest]

There's a part in the book; # 10 on page 40, that

talks about a case report by Dr. Brownstein and

Dr. Abraham about a woman who responded to 3gm of

vitamin C alternated with Iodine every other day.

I didn't say Dr Brownstein recommended it. Like

I said, it was just an observation about what is

in the book, not a suggestion about how anyone

should, or shouldn't, take Vit C.

Bethann

" The greatest enemy of knowledge is not

ignorance...it is the illusion of knowledge "

~ Hawking

ladybugsandbees wrote:

> He doesn't recommend alternation. He recommends daily.

>

> Steph

[Guest guest]

Book #10?

Re: Re: Confusion re Vitamin C and iodine

supplementation??

> There's a part in the book; # 10 on page 40, that

> talks about a case report by Dr. Brownstein and

> Dr. Abraham about a woman who responded to 3gm of

> vitamin C alternated with Iodine every other day.

> I didn't say Dr Brownstein recommended it. Like

> I said, it was just an observation about what is

> in the book, not a suggestion about how anyone

> should, or shouldn't, take Vit C.

>

> Bethann

>

> " The greatest enemy of knowledge is not

> ignorance...it is the illusion of knowledge "

> ~ Hawking

>

> ladybugsandbees wrote:

>> He doesn't recommend alternation. He recommends daily.

>>

>> Steph

>

>

> ------------------------------------

>

> All off topic posts should go to the IodineOT group

> IodineOT/

>

>

> Commonly asked questions: http://tinyurl.com/yhnds5e

[Guest guest]

Yeah, the one I posted the link to a few days ago,

that's in the list files. Heck, I just had the

file open. Hold on a second, I'll find the name.

" Iodine Remedies Secrets From the Sea " . It's got a

strange kind of layout. On page 40, # 10 is what

the paragraph is labeled in the PDF I have.

Bethann

" The greatest enemy of knowledge is not

ignorance...it is the illusion of knowledge "

~ Hawking

ladybugsandbees wrote:

> Book #10?

[Guest guest]

I took that as meaning 3 mg of vit C daily for three months. With iodine taken

on alternate days. Vit C daily and iodine every other day. ~

> > Book #10?

>

[Guest guest]

Try to mix some Vitamin C with Lugol, You'll see by yourself the reaction. Vit C

is a powerfull oxydant. It turns Iodine into Iodide. As our body need both

iodine and iodide, It is preferable to take Vitamin C some time after the

ingestion of Lugol to avoid that reaction. It is a simple and know reacton in

chemistry.

I read the same observation from I don't remember exactly Who it was, Dr

Browstein? Dr ? Dr Guy Abraham? or Walter Last?

http://www.newton.dep.anl.gov/askasci/chem00/chem00880.htm

> > > > Book #10?

> > >

> >

>

[Guest guest]

In Secret of the Sea you can read too

" If Iodine in Lugol's or another liquid is reduces to iodide, the yellow color

of iodine will disappear becaude iodide is white. "

This is the reaction a was taking to you about. The Why it is maybe not advise

to take Lugol and Vitamin C at the SAME time if you don't want to see your

Lugol( iodine and Iodide) end up only into an iodide solution

http://tinyurl.com/nsquvd

> > > > Book #10?

> > >

> >

>

[Guest guest]

I have seen the reaction here at home in a glass of water, but my question

was and is, how do we know that's what happens in the stomach, with the

acids and etc? Because I agree with Steph that if we still lived in a

world in which it was possible to get our nutrients from our diet, it would

all be mixed up in our stomachs. So this is why I wonder so much about all

the instructions for separation. And, I worry that we make it so difficult

to comply with the protocol that it paralyzes people and they can't

participate. my thoughts.

--

>Try to mix some Vitamin C with Lugol, You'll see by yourself the reaction.

>Vit C is a powerfull oxydant. It turns Iodine into Iodide. As our body

>need both iodine and iodide, It is preferable to take Vitamin C some time

>after the ingestion of Lugol to avoid that reaction. It is a simple and

>know reacton in chemistry.

>I read the same observation from I don't remember exactly Who it was, Dr

>Browstein? Dr ? Dr Guy Abraham? or Walter Last?

>

>http://www.newton.dep.anl.gov/askasci/chem00/chem00880.htm

>

>

>

> >

> > I don't think this is totally true. Because I have been taking them

> together as does Dr Brownstein for years. You have to think about how

> God designed us. Our nutrients were supposed to come from food. There

> weren't rules about what we can and cannot eat together. I think this

> whole " combining " of natural things gets out of hand.

> >

> > Steph

~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~

--A.J. Muste

[Guest guest]

But the body is a far more complex thing than the mixing of two substances. Lots of things that happen in the lab cannot be repeated in the human body and vice versa. So what it always comes down to is what works for each one of us. We need both iodine and vitamin C to avoid either would be dangerous to our health. Perhaps taking them at different times would be ideal but we have absolutely no evidence to that effect in the human body itself, people who take them together and separately are both having success with the protocol.

Engtovo

From: Poff

Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 3:11 PM

iodine

Subject: Re: Confusion re Vitamin C and iodine supplementation??

Try to mix some Vitamin C with Lugol, You'll see by yourself the reaction. Vit C is a powerfull oxydant. It turns Iodine into Iodide. As our body need both iodine and iodide, It is preferable to take Vitamin C some time after the ingestion of Lugol to avoid that reaction. It is a simple and know reacton in chemistry. I read the same observation from I don't remember exactly Who it was, Dr Browstein? Dr ? Dr Guy Abraham? or Walter Last?http://www.newton.dep.anl.gov/askasci/chem00/chem00880.htm--- In iodine , "ladybugsandbees" <ladybugsandbees@...> wrote:>> I don't think this is totally true. Because I have been taking them together as does Dr Brownstein for years. You have to think about how God designed us. Our nutrients were supposed to come from food. There weren't rules about what we can and cannot eat together. I think this whole "combining" of natural things gets out of hand.> > Steph> > > Re: Confusion re Vitamin C and iodine supplementation??> > > > Don't see need to alternate vit C and Lugol. Just don't take them together. Vit C is an oxidizer. It will iodize the iodine in the lugol into Iodide, then losing the full property of lugol. You.ll end up only with iodide> > Little experiment: to a drop of lugol add a tiny bit of vitamine C powder. The Lugol will turn White, > > Poff> > > > > > Book #10?> > >> >>