Guest guest Posted December 29, 2003 Report Share Posted December 29, 2003 Coryn, Have you seen the videos on the fairly new BLOOD TYPE DIET VIDEO MULTIMEDIA webpage on Dr. D's website? http://www.dadamo.com/media/index.htm The video " The Circle " (a short film about the concepts of the blood type diet) shows the balance between protein, carbs, and fat for each blood type in the form of a pie chart. For O's Dr. D indicates a ratio or 40-40-20. I hope that info helps you and your efforts concerning your sister. Don where did the 1 gram of protein per pound of bodyweight come from? Is that on Dr. D's site?? Thank you!! > > Coryn Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 30, 2003 Report Share Posted December 30, 2003 When in doubt, reread page 57 in ER4YT. Os strive on protein. As far as serving sizes: Meat/Poultry: up to 5 oz 6 to 9 times per week, non secretors 7 to 12 times per week. Rh- increase by 1 to 2 servings. Fish: 3 to 5 serving per week. Rh- increase by 2 servings. Eggs: up to 6 eggs a week. So what does all this mean? THESE ARE GENERAL GUIDELINES per . Remember that the books were not written for you or me personally but for the masses. The recommendations are great starting points however ..But we are all very different with different needs. I'd bet a lot of someone else' $$$ that if you were to see your servings would differ slightly from the ones in the book. As far as the 1 gr per lbs - it originated in the bodybuilding community (not by bodybuilders, but by MDs/PhDs who specialize in sport nutrition). At 140 lbs you do have the need for a minimum amount of calories to maintain. A wild guess would be 1200 to 1400 calories daily. If you consume 77gr of pure protein a day, that gives you little over 300 calories a day. With fat (in nature protein always comes with fat) lets say 500 calories. Even if you were to eat enough greens you will be way behind of what your body will need. So that leaves you with carbs - and most people eat way too many carbs. If we didn't we wouldn't feel ashamed when looking in the mirror naked. People are getting fatter and fatter anywhere you look. And not because they are overeating protein. If you are an athlete then you fall into a totally different category also. Is your sister an O as well? Has her life been stressful? Love http://www.foodforyourblood.com Eggs and menu questions...Attn: Hi , I DO worry about details like that. I want to make sure that I do it right, ya know? I was all happy knowing that I could eat 2 eggs every day and now I find out that I can't...according to Dr. D. My sister has fibromyalsia (sp) and I am trying to set up a diet for her that she can follow. I thought I was doing things ok until I started reading and re-reading. I was stunned to find out that 80% of fibro people of any blood type are non-secretors!! What an amazing fact!! I just want her to get better. She doesn't know that I am doing this...but in doing so, it looks like I am in need of a diet re-vamping too!! So, 1 gr of protein per pound of body weight. According to Dr.D's guidelines, I can have 1-5oz serving of protein twice a day, and one egg. That equals 77 grams of protein. According to you, I should be eating twice that amount. That is why I am confused. Dr. D says one thing (and that is what we are supposed to be following) but then there are the other opinions. I understand that everyone is different and each of us customizes the diet as needed. But from what I am reading, I get 2-5oz portions of protein a day. That's it. And an egg, and some beans once in a while. I can have a couple of slices of bread every day or so and that is some protein, and a handful of nuts every other day or so...that is protein. But it still doesn't come close to the 1 gr per bodyweight deal. Sigh. , where did the 1 gram of protein per pound of bodyweight come from? Is that on Dr. D's site?? Thank you!! Coryn RE: Eggs and menu questions Hi Coryn - just make sure to eat 1 gr of protein per bodyweight every day (from any of the beneficial/neutral sources) and the maximum amount of green leafy veggies. Also about a tablespoon of fat per meal. After that you can have a glass of pineapple juice (about 40 gr of carbs) - you will need 6 oz of meat or 6 eggs to balance it out. Or your fruits (27gr of carbs/each or so). Should not worry about minor details like that. Hope this helps. http://www.foodforyourblood.com Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 1, 2004 Report Share Posted January 1, 2004 In Cook Right he also stresses that he is giving protein guidelines and that it is not possible to break it out by gender, weight, height, etc. He says there that he specificially that he doesn't want to make an exact, exact recommendation on quantity. With that said I realize that some people really like absolutes. Some like them, to be told what to do, just so they can make it easier for themselves. Others like them to put themselves in a special category " I am the perfect follower of this diet and anyone doing less is inferior! " . Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 1, 2004 Report Share Posted January 1, 2004 **With that said I realize that some people really like absolutes. Some like them, to be told what to do, just so they can make it easier for themselves. Others like them to put themselves in a special category " I am the perfect follower of this diet and anyone doing less is inferior! " . ** Golly, I feel insulted somehow!! (I kid.) My goal in all of this is to test what is right for me...to see what others do...and collect opinions one way or the other. It is not to look perfect in anyone's eyes. I want what is right for me and my family. I am a person who likes absolutes when it comes to food, that is true. Absolutes are used in the beginning until it becomes habit. I am on a SEARCH for MY absolutes. It was first about eggs. I LOVE eggs! How many is too many? Can I have 3 a day?? Two?? What about my 9 year old son?? What is OK for him? He loves eggs too! I used to do 2 eggs and 4 egg whites until I was encouraged from this board to eat the whole egg and not throw the yolk away. Ohhhhh...that was a GOOD day!!! Some things are easy. Getting my son to eat protein is not a problem...but how much is enough? Or too much? That is why I asked for people to send me a " sample " meal plan of what they eat in a normal day. (Incidently, I have yet to receive one!) You see?? I have all these protein questions and am trying to sort out what is right. Fruits and vegetables are easy. Grains are easy. Dairy is easy. It's all easy for me except for figuring out how much meat/seafood/poultry and eggs I can have. I read Dr. D's " guidelines " but don't see anywhere that it is OK to step out of that box. And that is confusing me. Because then I have suggesting that I should consume 1 gr of protein per pound of body weight...and I trust too!!! (I like 's plan better!!) But that goes against Dr. D's plan. I mean, if I can fudge on the protein section and eat twice the amount that he suggests, can I fudge on the other areas too and eat more of the other things too?? If I up my protein intake, do I up my veggies and fruits and grains, etc? You may be thinking " Oh, Coryn...don't dwell on it so much and just eat whatever is comfortable for you. " If left to my own devices, I would eat protein 6 times a day. I love meat and fish and poultry....and eggs! But all that would be too much, right? Or would that be acceptable? According to , that would be OK. According to D'Adamo, that would be way too much. I wish I could ask him personally...to know for sure instead of doing the " guessing game " thing. I'll get it figured out eventually. In the mean time, thanks for your patience and not making me feel TOO silly while on my quest. It's a little tough to go out on that limb and ask questions (good ones or dumb ones)but it's a necessary thing. Coryn Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 1, 2004 Report Share Posted January 1, 2004 The best thing you are doing is building your knowledge base. I can see it grow post by post. Eventually you'll have good knowledge to apply and you will better be able to plan your diet as well as the diet of those you care for :-) _____ From: SnipSnip [mailto:SnipSnip@...] Sent: Thursday, January 01, 2004 2:09 PM Subject: Re: Eggs and menu questions...Attn: **With that said I realize that some people really like absolutes. Some like them, to be told what to do, just so they can make it easier for themselves. Others like them to put themselves in a special category " I am the perfect follower of this diet and anyone doing less is inferior! " . ** Golly, I feel insulted somehow!! (I kid.) My goal in all of this is to test what is right for me...to see what others do...and collect opinions one way or the other. It is not to look perfect in anyone's eyes. I want what is right for me and my family. I am a person who likes absolutes when it comes to food, that is true. Absolutes are used in the beginning until it becomes habit. I am on a SEARCH for MY absolutes. It was first about eggs. I LOVE eggs! How many is too many? Can I have 3 a day?? Two?? What about my 9 year old son?? What is OK for him? He loves eggs too! I used to do 2 eggs and 4 egg whites until I was encouraged from this board to eat the whole egg and not throw the yolk away. Ohhhhh...that was a GOOD day!!! Some things are easy. Getting my son to eat protein is not a problem...but how much is enough? Or too much? That is why I asked for people to send me a " sample " meal plan of what they eat in a normal day. (Incidently, I have yet to receive one!) You see?? I have all these protein questions and am trying to sort out what is right. Fruits and vegetables are easy. Grains are easy. Dairy is easy. It's all easy for me except for figuring out how much meat/seafood/poultry and eggs I can have. I read Dr. D's " guidelines " but don't see anywhere that it is OK to step out of that box. And that is confusing me. Because then I have suggesting that I should consume 1 gr of protein per pound of body weight...and I trust too!!! (I like 's plan better!!) But that goes against Dr. D's plan. I mean, if I can fudge on the protein section and eat twice the amount that he suggests, can I fudge on the other areas too and eat more of the other things too?? If I up my protein intake, do I up my veggies and fruits and grains, etc? You may be thinking " Oh, Coryn...don't dwell on it so much and just eat whatever is comfortable for you. " If left to my own devices, I would eat protein 6 times a day. I love meat and fish and poultry....and eggs! But all that would be too much, right? Or would that be acceptable? According to , that would be OK. According to D'Adamo, that would be way too much. I wish I could ask him personally...to know for sure instead of doing the " guessing game " thing. I'll get it figured out eventually. In the mean time, thanks for your patience and not making me feel TOO silly while on my quest. It's a little tough to go out on that limb and ask questions (good ones or dumb ones)but it's a necessary thing. Coryn Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 1, 2004 Report Share Posted January 1, 2004 Giving absolutes is tough and could be considered illegal. You need to take the guidelines and find out what is absolute for you. 10 people in this group will be doing great on 10 different food schedules. You are the only one that will know what is best for you. As you adjust your diet and learn to listen to your body it will fall into place. But be open to continual adjustments. As you age, grow, change, etc... so will your diet have to change to be optimal for you. Life is a process - this is life Happy New Year to All KM SnipSnip <SnipSnip@...> wrote: **With that said I realize that some people really like absolutes. Some like them, to be told what to do, just so they can make it easier for themselves. Others like them to put themselves in a special category " I am the perfect follower of this diet and anyone doing less is inferior! " . ** Golly, I feel insulted somehow!! (I kid.) My goal in all of this is to test what is right for me...to see what others do...and collect opinions one way or the other. It is not to look perfect in anyone's eyes. I want what is right for me and my family. I am a person who likes absolutes when it comes to food, that is true. Absolutes are used in the beginning until it becomes habit. I am on a SEARCH for MY absolutes. It was first about eggs. I LOVE eggs! How many is too many? Can I have 3 a day?? Two?? What about my 9 year old son?? What is OK for him? He loves eggs too! I used to do 2 eggs and 4 egg whites until I was encouraged from this board to eat the whole egg and not throw the yolk away. Ohhhhh...that was a GOOD day!!! Some things are easy. Getting my son to eat protein is not a problem...but how much is enough? Or too much? That is why I asked for people to send me a " sample " meal plan of what they eat in a normal day. (Incidently, I have yet to receive one!) You see?? I have all these protein questions and am trying to sort out what is right. Fruits and vegetables are easy. Grains are easy. Dairy is easy. It's all easy for me except for figuring out how much meat/seafood/poultry and eggs I can have. I read Dr. D's " guidelines " but don't see anywhere that it is OK to step out of that box. And that is confusing me. Because then I have suggesting that I should consume 1 gr of protein per pound of body weight...and I trust too!!! (I like 's plan better!!) But that goes against Dr. D's plan. I mean, if I can fudge on the protein section and eat twice the amount that he suggests, can I fudge on the other areas too and eat more of the other things too?? If I up my protein intake, do I up my veggies and fruits and grains, etc? You may be thinking " Oh, Coryn...don't dwell on it so much and just eat whatever is comfortable for you. " If left to my own devices, I would eat protein 6 times a day. I love meat and fish and poultry....and eggs! But all that would be too much, right? Or would that be acceptable? According to , that would be OK. According to D'Adamo, that would be way too much. I wish I could ask him personally...to know for sure instead of doing the " guessing game " thing. I'll get it figured out eventually. In the mean time, thanks for your patience and not making me feel TOO silly while on my quest. It's a little tough to go out on that limb and ask questions (good ones or dumb ones)but it's a necessary thing. Coryn Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 1, 2004 Report Share Posted January 1, 2004 **Giving absolutes is tough and could be considered illegal.** What??? Illegal?? What??? **10 people in this group will be doing great on 10 different food schedules.** Well. of COURSE I don't think that everyone is doing the same thing. But it never hurts to ask how much is too much. And not knowing how much is too much can be detrimental to my health. I understand that Dr. D's gives portion recommendations and that those are not set in stone. I could eat 3 eggs, a chicken breast, a huge piece of meat and fish or seafood all in the same day...most cooked with olive oil. And that is not what he recommends. All I am wondering is if that is OK...that's all. Bottom line is I need to win the lottery and hire a chef and hand him/her the books and say " Make it so, #1 " ~she says in her best voice.~ Until then, I need to fend for myself. I just don't want to eat too much fat or cholesterol and drop dead because I'm not educated on what is too much when it comes to this Blood Type Eating way of life. Of course, maybe I am asking a question that can't be answered. I guess I will just do whatever and if I drop dead, then I will know I was doing it wrong! Happy New Year and the best of health, happiness and love to you all. Coryn Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 1, 2004 Report Share Posted January 1, 2004 I think the thought of illegal comes from the possibility of someone taking advice and then blaming the advice for some result. We live in a very litigious society so it could be considered a matter of judgment, but certainly not against the law. :-) _____ From: Coryn [mailto:SnipSnip@...] Sent: Thursday, January 01, 2004 7:46 PM Subject: Re: Eggs and menu questions...Attn: **Giving absolutes is tough and could be considered illegal.** What??? Illegal?? What??? **10 people in this group will be doing great on 10 different food schedules.** Well. of COURSE I don't think that everyone is doing the same thing. But it never hurts to ask how much is too much. And not knowing how much is too much can be detrimental to my health. I understand that Dr. D's gives portion recommendations and that those are not set in stone. I could eat 3 eggs, a chicken breast, a huge piece of meat and fish or seafood all in the same day...most cooked with olive oil. And that is not what he recommends. All I am wondering is if that is OK...that's all. Bottom line is I need to win the lottery and hire a chef and hand him/her the books and say " Make it so, #1 " ~she says in her best voice.~ Until then, I need to fend for myself. I just don't want to eat too much fat or cholesterol and drop dead because I'm not educated on what is too much when it comes to this Blood Type Eating way of life. Of course, maybe I am asking a question that can't be answered. I guess I will just do whatever and if I drop dead, then I will know I was doing it wrong! Happy New Year and the best of health, happiness and love to you all. Coryn Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2004 Report Share Posted January 2, 2004 In a message dated 1/1/2004 7:10:52 PM Eastern Standard Time, kathymatthews@... writes: > You are the only one that will know what is best for you. As you adjust > your diet and learn to listen to your body it will fall into place. Well said Kathy. Coryn, I think you're used to following other diets that say, " do this exactly this way and this diet will work. " much as I have over the years. Read through Dr Ds answers to FAQs on his website and you'll see over and over where he discusses his diet as a guideline for you to fine tune. Remember that this diet is about better health and that weight loss is a byproduct. It is a journey of discovery for what your body needs to be healthy and only you can determine that. Whether you follow rigid guidelines or not your body will eventually detox and start telling you what it needs. Do what makes you feel best for now. You'll eventually get to the same place anyway. It'll be amazing how easy it will become. Max Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2004 Report Share Posted January 2, 2004 In a message dated 1/1/2004 9:14:49 PM Eastern Standard Time, tomwilson64@... writes: > We live in a very > litigious society so it could be considered a matter of judgment, but > certainly not against the law. :-) > Unless someone buys coffee from you and spills it on themselves. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2004 Report Share Posted January 2, 2004 In a message dated 1/2/2004 1:58:13 PM Eastern Standard Time, SnipSnip@... writes: > I have never been on a " diet " before. But I ate the " high carb, low fat " > way for ever. I did too and it worked too until I started having pains deep in my body trunk and it felt like my organs were moving around. That was the end of the food pyramid for Max. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2004 Report Share Posted January 2, 2004 In a message dated 1/2/2004 1:58:13 PM Eastern Standard Time, SnipSnip@... writes: > I'm going to go for a walk today. It's supposed to snow and I love walking > in the snow. It's so unseasonably warm here that my outside plants are still blooming and I actually had to water them. I sent a picture to my relatives who are ankle deep in snow just to be a shit. The lawn better not start growing or I will be mad. We need at least one good frost or we'll have bugs the size of birds next year. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2004 Report Share Posted January 2, 2004 Re: Eggs and menu questions...Attn: **Coryn, I think you're used to following other diets that say, " do this exactly this way and this diet will work. " ** I have never been on a " diet " before. But I ate the " high carb, low fat " way for ever. That's what " they " told the world to do. Then I went to the doctor and my blood was messed up. Triglyceride ratios all off and such. He looked me square in the eye and said " you go home and eat MEAT/FAT " . So I did. I lost 10 pounds in 2 weeks!! I went back in 3 months for a re-check and everything was OK except my hdl cholesterol was low still. But total cholesterol was 124 at first and then went to 150. Last time I had it checked was 4 years ago and it was still the same. That is another reason why the BTD has been relatively easy for me. It's NOT a diet...it's a way of life. And it is a way of life that made sense to me the first time through the first book. I'm going to go for a walk today. It's supposed to snow and I love walking in the snow. Coryn Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2004 Report Share Posted January 2, 2004 It's unseasonably warm here also. We have only had a dusting of snow so far. The grass is as green as anything and the temperatures have been in the mid 40's, tomorrow is supposed to be 52 and rain. But I am definitely not complaining. I am going to try to get more vigorous about the ER diet starting now. I have been slipping and sliding all over the place lately, especially over the holidays but I have continued to read everyone's posts. Regards, Sharon (Ontario) Canada Re: Eggs and menu questions...Attn: > In a message dated 1/2/2004 1:58:13 PM Eastern Standard Time, > SnipSnip@... writes: > > > I'm going to go for a walk today. It's supposed to snow and I love walking > > in the snow. > > It's so unseasonably warm here that my outside plants are still blooming and > I actually had to water them. I sent a picture to my relatives who are ankle > deep in snow just to be a shit. The lawn better not start growing or I will > be mad. We need at least one good frost or we'll have bugs the size of birds > next year. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 4, 2004 Report Share Posted January 4, 2004 <<<<<I just don't want to eat too much fat or cholesterol and drop dead because I'm not educated on what is too much>>>>> Chances are that will not happen. Now however eating too many starches will pretty much guarantee it for you as an O. The amount of macro nutrients that are needed also depend on what shape you want to accomplish. When I train hard I eat around 300 gr to 350 gr of protein. And I am an A. As an O having 1 gr per lb of protein is no big deal. Love http://www.foodforyourblood.com Re: Eggs and menu questions...Attn: **Giving absolutes is tough and could be considered illegal.** What??? Illegal?? What??? **10 people in this group will be doing great on 10 different food schedules.** Well. of COURSE I don't think that everyone is doing the same thing. But it never hurts to ask how much is too much. And not knowing how much is too much can be detrimental to my health. I understand that Dr. D's gives portion recommendations and that those are not set in stone. I could eat 3 eggs, a chicken breast, a huge piece of meat and fish or seafood all in the same day...most cooked with olive oil. And that is not what he recommends. All I am wondering is if that is OK...that's all. Bottom line is I need to win the lottery and hire a chef and hand him/her the books and say " Make it so, #1 " ~she says in her best voice.~ Until then, I need to fend for myself. I just don't want to eat too much fat or cholesterol and drop dead because I'm not educated on what is too much when it comes to this Blood Type Eating way of life. Of course, maybe I am asking a question that can't be answered. I guess I will just do whatever and if I drop dead, then I will know I was doing it wrong! Happy New Year and the best of health, happiness and love to you all. Coryn Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 6, 2004 Report Share Posted January 6, 2004 Coryn - for the next 3 days write down for me all the carbs you will consume. Just what it was and how much of it you had. I'll figure out the rest. As an O you only increase your protein. As far as your son - forget about portions he is growing and needs nourishment. Feed him often. Look! Almost half of the population is overweight. Os make up around 47% or so of the people. You do the math. Os WILL LOOSE WEIGHT BY EATING HIGH PROTEIN. (I am not saying that the 50% overweight population is all the Os) Do you know what I never see here? Post about being concerned over too much carbs that you guys consume. I wish I was an O! The diet it so easy and basic, yet I see so many struggling with the protein issue. I have no idea why. http://www.foodforyourblood.com Re: Eggs and menu questions...Attn: **With that said I realize that some people really like absolutes. Some like them, to be told what to do, just so they can make it easier for themselves. Others like them to put themselves in a special category " I am the perfect follower of this diet and anyone doing less is inferior! " . ** Golly, I feel insulted somehow!! (I kid.) My goal in all of this is to test what is right for me...to see what others do...and collect opinions one way or the other. It is not to look perfect in anyone's eyes. I want what is right for me and my family. I am a person who likes absolutes when it comes to food, that is true. Absolutes are used in the beginning until it becomes habit. I am on a SEARCH for MY absolutes. It was first about eggs. I LOVE eggs! How many is too many? Can I have 3 a day?? Two?? What about my 9 year old son?? What is OK for him? He loves eggs too! I used to do 2 eggs and 4 egg whites until I was encouraged from this board to eat the whole egg and not throw the yolk away. Ohhhhh...that was a GOOD day!!! Some things are easy. Getting my son to eat protein is not a problem...but how much is enough? Or too much? That is why I asked for people to send me a " sample " meal plan of what they eat in a normal day. (Incidently, I have yet to receive one!) You see?? I have all these protein questions and am trying to sort out what is right. Fruits and vegetables are easy. Grains are easy. Dairy is easy. It's all easy for me except for figuring out how much meat/seafood/poultry and eggs I can have. I read Dr. D's " guidelines " but don't see anywhere that it is OK to step out of that box. And that is confusing me. Because then I have suggesting that I should consume 1 gr of protein per pound of body weight...and I trust too!!! (I like 's plan better!!) But that goes against Dr. D's plan. I mean, if I can fudge on the protein section and eat twice the amount that he suggests, can I fudge on the other areas too and eat more of the other things too?? If I up my protein intake, do I up my veggies and fruits and grains, etc? You may be thinking " Oh, Coryn...don't dwell on it so much and just eat whatever is comfortable for you. " If left to my own devices, I would eat protein 6 times a day. I love meat and fish and poultry....and eggs! But all that would be too much, right? Or would that be acceptable? According to , that would be OK. According to D'Adamo, that would be way too much. I wish I could ask him personally...to know for sure instead of doing the " guessing game " thing. I'll get it figured out eventually. In the mean time, thanks for your patience and not making me feel TOO silly while on my quest. It's a little tough to go out on that limb and ask questions (good ones or dumb ones)but it's a necessary thing. Coryn Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.