Guest guest Posted December 18, 2009 Report Share Posted December 18, 2009 The best evidence is that probably over 95% of patients take Synthroid [or its generic] only and do well. HOWEVER: Some small percentage of patients continue to report symptoms that can range from mild to pure hell. There seems to be no clearly defined reason why this occurs. Some possibilities are other related or unrelated ailments. One possibility that AFAIK has nothing beyond anecdotal support is that some of those patients with difficulties may have suffered organ damage from lack of treatment for an extended time for an undiagnosed hypo condition; or else from totally inadequate treatment. It may take a long time for this damage to be reversed [if it can be]. The idea behind taking Armour is that it contains T3 as well as T4. Normally your body makes all the T3 it needs from T4; however there is some support [i don't know how much] for the notion that some people cannot convert T4 to T3 and thus can benefit from Armour or some other medication that contains T3. Some patients report almost mirculous results from same. Unfortunately AFAIK there is no evidence from credible studies that can show greater than chance or placebo results for Armour over Synthroid. Treating with other than Synthroid can be a real challenge as many doctors seem to be unaware of any need or that it even exists. There's lots of info on alternative hypothyroidism treatment that ranges from dubious to " no one with an IQ over 13 would even consider this " . Just remember: You have to have T3 or you will die. You can probably make all the T3 you need as long as you have enough T4. Be aware that info you find on the internet and elsewhere could harm or kill you, so be careful. There are no " natural " supplements or procedures that will properly treat hypothyroidism. Be aware of the world view of any person advising you. Mine is from the viewpoint of allopathic medicine and modern science, although I'm neither a doctor nor scientist; and I claim no credentials whatsoever. Luck, .. .. > Posted by: " MC28 " cumocumocumo@... > <mailto:cumocumocumo@...?Subject=%20Re%3ASynthroid%20vs%20Armour> > cumocumocumo <cumocumocumo> > > > Wed Dec 16, 2009 6:56 am (PST) > > > > I've been hearing that I should have my doctor get me off of Synthroid > and put on Armour. The reasoning was that i would have problems the > rest of my life if i continue to just take synthroid. Can anyone help > clarify as to whether or not this is True and perhaps even share a > personal experience? My TSH level is OK but I have been still > experiencing inconsistent energy levels, extreme seasonal allergies > (year long now) and difficulty losing weight. > > Any help you can provide is appreciated. I sometimes feel that i have > no one to turn to for these questions as my DR. hasn't a clue. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 18, 2009 Report Share Posted December 18, 2009 Thanks -I really appreciate you answering my question!   From: <res075oh@...> Subject: Re:Synthroid vs Armour hypothyroidism Date: Thursday, December 17, 2009, 6:25 PM  The best evidence is that probably over 95% of patients take Synthroid [or its generic] only and do well. HOWEVER: Some small percentage of patients continue to report symptoms that can range from mild to pure hell. There seems to be no clearly defined reason why this occurs. Some possibilities are other related or unrelated ailments. One possibility that AFAIK has nothing beyond anecdotal support is that some of those patients with difficulties may have suffered organ damage from lack of treatment for an extended time for an undiagnosed hypo condition; or else from totally inadequate treatment. It may take a long time for this damage to be reversed [if it can be]. The idea behind taking Armour is that it contains T3 as well as T4. Normally your body makes all the T3 it needs from T4; however there is some support [i don't know how much] for the notion that some people cannot convert T4 to T3 and thus can benefit from Armour or some other medication that contains T3. Some patients report almost mirculous results from same. Unfortunately AFAIK there is no evidence from credible studies that can show greater than chance or placebo results for Armour over Synthroid. Treating with other than Synthroid can be a real challenge as many doctors seem to be unaware of any need or that it even exists. There's lots of info on alternative hypothyroidism treatment that ranges from dubious to " no one with an IQ over 13 would even consider this " . Just remember: You have to have T3 or you will die. You can probably make all the T3 you need as long as you have enough T4. Be aware that info you find on the internet and elsewhere could harm or kill you, so be careful. There are no " natural " supplements or procedures that will properly treat hypothyroidism. Be aware of the world view of any person advising you. Mine is from the viewpoint of allopathic medicine and modern science, although I'm neither a doctor nor scientist; and I claim no credentials whatsoever. Luck, .. .. > Posted by: " MC28 " cumocumocumo > <mailto:cumocumocumo?Subject=%20Re% 3ASynthroid% 20vs%20Armour> > cumocumocumo <http://profiles. / cumocumocumo> > > > Wed Dec 16, 2009 6:56 am (PST) > > > > I've been hearing that I should have my doctor get me off of Synthroid > and put on Armour. The reasoning was that i would have problems the > rest of my life if i continue to just take synthroid. Can anyone help > clarify as to whether or not this is True and perhaps even share a > personal experience? My TSH level is OK but I have been still > experiencing inconsistent energy levels, extreme seasonal allergies > (year long now) and difficulty losing weight. > > Any help you can provide is appreciated. I sometimes feel that i have > no one to turn to for these questions as my DR. hasn't a clue. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.