Guest guest Posted May 22, 2006 Report Share Posted May 22, 2006 Hello everyone, Some of you may receive this a few times as I am cross-posting it on a few different groups. My appologies to those that may read it three or four time...) is just finishing up first grade and our IEP meeting to plan for next year will be on Thursday. I already know that her HI is increasing her time with and I will be asking for speech services to include at least one session individually. I'm also pretty sure which teacher we will get next year. It may sound like I know what's going on and how to get it. Well, after looking back at this year I realize that would probably benefit from having an aide in the classroom. I know that some of you refer to this as a paraprofessional. This was our first year in this district and they are very " aggressive " in their teaching. This may great for a small class, or where many of the students are at a higher level of achievement, but that is no longer the case in our growing (rapidly) town. 's first grade class had 26 children in it. They say there was an aide, but she was shared between the three first grade classes and I don't think she every really worked with the kids, at least this is what I get from the HI and . They don't have a volunteer program at our school (don't even get me started on that) so there wasn't anyone to help the teacher when/if the students were having difficulites. Some of you might remember that the personel at the school feel quite strongly that 's " issues " this year were stemming from a lack of attention or ADHD. Although some of it may have been, I'm sure that more of it had to do with her hearing loss. I could cite several examples, but I won't bore you. (We are getting her evaluated this summer for ADHD, so we will hopefully have an answer before school begins in the fall). Anyways the reason I want a aide for is not because I want someone to hold her hand. That would be bad for her because she would take advantage of the situation. What I would like an aide to do is to make sure that when she begins to work on an assignment, that is on the right track. That she understands what is being asked of her. She also needs some additional help with sentence structuring. I didn't realize how large a writing component there was in first grade and I know it will be more in second grade. It's not that she can't do the work, it's just that she needs a few more prompts to get it done correctly. IT was becoming very obvious to me that the teacher either didn't have the time to do this, or thought that should be able to do this alone. On another note, it should be interesting to see what they do in gym for second grade. You may remember me telling you that they put all first grade classes together for gym. That means 79 children in a gym at one time with two teachers. I'm not sure if got anything out of gym this year, but also I wonder if she'll be expected to " learn " more in gym next year and not be able to due to the circumstances. So does this request seem reasonable? Anyone want to share pointers on how I get this? I've casually dropped this into conversations with her team as I could, but I usually got back " Oh that might not be good for her...she'd become too dependent " or " hmmmmm, interesting " . Debbie, mom to , 6, moderate SNHL and , 3, hearing Some men see things as they are and ask why. Others dream things that never were and ask why not. G.B Shaw --------------------------------- Yahoo! Messenger with Voice. Make PC-to-Phone Calls to the US (and 30+ countries) for 2¢/min or less. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2006 Report Share Posted May 22, 2006 79 children with 2 teachers in a gym sounds UNLAWFUL to me--please check your state's laws on that. I don't think that would work here in NC. Best of luck, Robin T. > > Hello everyone, > Some of you may receive this a few times as I am cross-posting it on > a few different groups. My appologies to those that may read it three or > four time...) > > is just finishing up first grade and our IEP meeting to plan > for next year will be on Thursday. I already know that her HI is increasing > her time with and I will be asking for speech services to include at > least one session individually. I'm also pretty sure which teacher we will > get next year. It may sound like I know what's going on and how to get it. > Well, after looking back at this year I realize that would probably > benefit from having an aide in the classroom. I know that some of you refer > to this as a paraprofessional. This was our first year in this district and > they are very " aggressive " in their teaching. This may great for a small > class, or where many of the students are at a higher level of achievement, > but that is no longer the case in our growing (rapidly) town. 's > first grade class had 26 children in it. They say there was an aide, but > she was shared between the three first grade classes and I don't think she > every > really worked with the kids, at least this is what I get from the HI and > . They don't have a volunteer program at our school (don't even get > me started on that) so there wasn't anyone to help the teacher when/if the > students were having difficulites. > Some of you might remember that the personel at the school feel quite > strongly that 's " issues " this year were stemming from a lack of > attention or ADHD. Although some of it may have been, I'm sure that more of > it had to do with her hearing loss. I could cite several examples, but I > won't bore you. (We are getting her evaluated this summer for ADHD, so we > will hopefully have an answer before school begins in the fall). Anyways > the reason I want a aide for is not because I want someone to hold > her hand. That would be bad for her because she would take advantage of the > situation. What I would like an aide to do is to make sure that when she > begins to work on an assignment, that is on the right track. That > she understands what is being asked of her. She also needs some additional > help with sentence structuring. I didn't realize how large a writing > component there was in first grade and I know it will be more in second > grade. It's not that she > can't do the work, it's just that she needs a few more prompts to get it > done correctly. IT was becoming very obvious to me that the teacher either > didn't have the time to do this, or thought that should be able to do > this alone. > On another note, it should be interesting to see what they do in gym > for second grade. You may remember me telling you that they put all first > grade classes together for gym. That means 79 children in a gym at one time > with two teachers. I'm not sure if got anything out of gym this > year, but also I wonder if she'll be expected to " learn " more in gym next > year and not be able to due to the circumstances. > > So does this request seem reasonable? Anyone want to share pointers on > how I get this? I've casually dropped this into conversations with her team > as I could, but I usually got back " Oh that might not be good for > her...she'd become too dependent " or " hmmmmm, interesting " . > > > Debbie, mom to , 6, moderate SNHL and , 3, hearing > > > > > Some men see things as they are and ask why. Others dream things that > never were and ask why not. G.B Shaw > > > > > > > > --------------------------------- > Yahoo! Messenger with Voice. Make PC-to-Phone Calls to the US (and 30+ > countries) for 2¢/min or less. > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2006 Report Share Posted May 22, 2006 I wonder if a parapro would come out of special ed funds. If so, it might be something the people in the actual school could take advantage of to have a full time aide NOT paid out of their funding. So it might be something the people in your actual school might be willing to get behind. Remind me if Nichole had an FM this past year. With a large class that would be even more necessary. Is the HI willing to be proactive about the " attention " concerns and tell them how this is related to hearing?? Sounds like they need a good dose of Carol Flexer - " we medicate children who can't listen!! " Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2006 Report Share Posted May 22, 2006 Debbie wrote: Anyways the reason I want a aide for is not because I want someone to hold her hand. That would be bad for her because she would take advantage of the situation. What I would like an aide to do is to make sure that when she begins to work on an assignment, that is on the right track. That she understands what is being asked of her. She also needs some additional help with sentence structuring. I didn't realize how large a writing component there was in first grade and I know it will be more in second grade. It's not that she can't do the work, it's just that she needs a few more prompts to get it done correctly. IT was becoming very obvious to me that the teacher either didn't have the time to do this, or thought that should be able to do this alone. So does this request seem reasonable? Anyone want to share pointers on how I get this? I've casually dropped this into conversations with her team as I could, but I usually got back " Oh that might not be good for her...she'd become too dependent " or " hmmmmm, interesting " . *** Debbie, this is exactly the type of " inclusion " services will be getting next year, based on the fact that he flunked the school district " standard writing test " for his grade level by one point (out of 20) this year. The teacher coming in to help will be there 2 to 3 hours a week solely for him (at a minimum), but she'll be coming to help other children in the room as well, so he'll actually get more time with her. really struggles with word-finding, and she's going to concentrate on helping him develop a method to organize his thoughts so that they translate well into a written document. She's also going to help him with breaking up his week-long workplan (the list of works he needs to complete *at a minimum* during a given week) into a set of daily goals that is easier for him to manage, and she's going to keep an eye on him while she's in the room with other students to make sure that he's actually on task (instead of spacing out). We're hoping that having this, combined with his speech therapy, will help him to overcome the language hurdles that he has right now - and we're also hoping that he'll be able to wean himself from her presence within the next couple of years. I hope this helps. Kris Mom to (7 y.o., Profound/Complete SNL, Left Ear) and Ethan (6 y.o., hearing) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2006 Report Share Posted May 23, 2006 < > I think you're going to need to come up with a longer list of things the aide will need to do. We just had Neal's IEP and the thing I was most worried about was that they would take his aide away. I do want her gone eventually because I want him to handle things on his own, but the transition from K to 1st is a big one, and for a kid with transition issues already, I thought it would be plain foolish to start without her. They approved her full day through November in the end (after tossing around the idea of having her come just for recess and transitions), and we will reconvene then to decide on the rest of the year. I think you might benefit from playing up the ADHD concerns. Even if you don't agree with them, they have said it is causing her problems, so going from an angle that you know they already agree with seems like a good start. Talk about how you are concerned with her attention and plan to have her evaluated over the summer. Tell them that you don't think she will be able to handle 2nd grade with her attention issues combined with the hearing impairment unless she has an aide. She needs someone there to get her focused or redirect her as needed, and to make sure she has heard the directions. If she has transition issues that cause behavior problems by any chance, then talk about how she really needs an aid to help her through those times. Neal's aide does sensory diet exercises and such with him to get him back on track after recess for example. Mention that you don't want to take up all of the teacher's time and make the other kids lose teacher attention. My husband said last year and this year at the IEP meeting that he wanted an aide for Neal more for the teacher than for Neal.. He said he didn't want the teacher spending 90% of her time on dealing with Neal (My husband is a 2nd grade teacher at Neal's school), and for some reason, both times that seemed to make a light click in the team members' heads. If you can get this year's teacher on board for the need, that would be great. If she would be willing to say that had taken up a disproportionate amount of her time and that having an aide would benefit both , the teacher and the other students, that would be helpful. What Neal's teacher said this year was that there were many time when she didn't need Neal's aide, but that when she did need her, there was no way she could have done it without her. That was pretty truthful and helpful. Rhonda Savage Mom to Audrey, 9, hearing; and Neal, 6 1/2, CII at 2.9 years " Hard does not mean impossible. " Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2006 Report Share Posted May 23, 2006 Hi there, Yes, had an FM system this year. She's had it since she was in preschool. I'm not sure how proactive the HI will/can be. She's been working with since started preschool at 3 years old. She has seen how much better has gotten over the years in her ability to not bounce around constantly, but she feels that maybe there is something else there too. What I think is odd is that I had expressed this concern to her preschool teacher and the HI a few years ago and they all said that it was " enthusiasim for life " that kept her so happy and active. Even last year, it never really came up. But this year we are back in our home district and now everyone wants to say that it's ADHD or ADD. They don't see how the hearing loss can affect her. There was an example the other day that her HI related to me. As the HI brought back to class, asked her teacher where the kids were. Her teacher replied that they were at recess. started out the door and then asked again where the kids were. Her teacher once again replied that they were outside at recess. So went out with the kids. The teacher then looked at the HI and said, " See, she just doesn't pay attention " . The HI looked at her and told her " No, that's not what it is. Usually when and I come back to class, the class is in music. Today you told her recess. She heard you, but she didn't understand why there was a change, so she asked for clarification " . As the HI was telling me this I was screaming inside! Since there are only 2 teaching days left, I'm not even going to waste my time setting her teacher straight (something I thought I had done a few times this year). But I definately want to make sure that this kind of stuff doesn't happen next year. Sooooo, what Carol Flexer book is that from? Debbie, mom to , 6, moderate SNHL and , 3, hearing pcknott@... wrote: Is the HI willing to be proactive about the " attention " concerns and tell them how this is related to hearing?? Sounds like they need a good dose of Carol Flexer - " we medicate children who can't listen!! " Some men see things as they are and ask why. Others dream things that never were and ask why not. G.B Shaw --------------------------------- Yahoo! Messenger with Voice. PC-to-Phone calls for ridiculously low rates. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2006 Report Share Posted May 23, 2006 Kris, This would be the ideal situation for . We don't have a standard writing test in first grade (or at least I'm not aware of it), but based on the grades that has gotten in language related things, I'm sure she wouldn't have passed it. Maybe I can see if they have someone like this that can fill this need. Thanks for sharing. Debbie EskiLvr eskilvr@...> wrote: Debbie, this is exactly the type of " inclusion " services will be getting next year, based on the fact that he flunked the school district " standard writing test " for his grade level by one point (out of 20) this year. The teacher coming in to help will be there 2 to 3 hours a week solely for him (at a minimum), but she'll be coming to help other children in the room as well, so he'll actually get more time with her. really struggles with word-finding, and she's going to concentrate on helping him develop a method to organize his thoughts so that they translate well into a written document. She's also going to help him with breaking up his week-long workplan (the list of works he needs to complete *at a minimum* during a given week) into a set of daily goals that is easier for him to manage, and she's going to keep an eye on him while she's in the room with other students to make sure that he's actually on task (instead of spacing out). We're hoping that having this, combined with his speech therapy, will help him to overcome the language hurdles that he has right now - and we're also hoping that he'll be able to wean himself from her presence within the next couple of years. Some men see things as they are and ask why. Others dream things that never were and ask why not. G.B Shaw --------------------------------- Sneak preview the all-new Yahoo.com. It's not radically different. Just radically better. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 24, 2006 Report Share Posted May 24, 2006 Debbie, it sounds like a very typical situation. They know how an ADHD kid acts and there are a lot of similarities between not hearing what's going on and not paying attention to whats going on. It's like they look at it through the lens of what they know and don't " think outside the box " because they don't know anything about how deaf/hoh kids act. I can't think of the article, but I know I have seen this in print, And I know I have heard Carol Flexer say this every time I've heard her speak - there is actually a chart with the comparison. I would probably start with the Facilitating hearing and Listening book and then look at book she wrote with Carl Smaldino on FM/soundfield in the classroom. Or maybe do a search for her articles. I don't think it is in a medical article, I'm pretty sure it is geared to teachers. Sounds like your teachers dont' get it. I've had some success in using tapes that mimic the hearing loss, I have one that mimics hearing loss through hearing aids and play it aloud for teachers. Have gotten FMs for several kids this way. I also come to IEP meetings with a tape of cafeteria noise and play it at about 65 dB and they always want it turned off - duh! That's what our kids are trying to hear through in their classrooms. Hearing is INVISIBLE and like Harry Potter in his invisibility cloak, it can be seen but only by the trained eye. Unfortunately more parents than teachers have this trained eye. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 29, 2006 Report Share Posted May 29, 2006 In a message dated 5/22/2006 9:48:28 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time, eskilvr@... writes: .... this is exactly the type of " inclusion " services will be getting next year, Sorry to be delayed in getting to emails -- work has been a touch overwhelming and I'm stealing a bit of time on a holiday to read my non-business email! (ever pronounce the word business phonetically? Busy-ness ... it defines life lately, LOL) Ian was placed into the inclusion classes first as an inclusion child and later a non-inclusion student. When he was one of the regular kids, it was slightly breaking the rules because Ian is classified and that upped the number of " classified " kids in the room and there is a legal ratio of classified/regular students that must be met. But the teachers knew Ian and knew that he did not require the academic/support services that the other classified kids did. So, given his specific disability, he was counted as one of the " regular " kids. The types of visual reinforcement that are used in the inclusion classes were perfect for Ian as a D/HOH kid. For instance, there was more work written onto the board instead of presented orally requiring heavier note taking. There was more repetition and clarification of instructions ... many teaching strategies that are a positive for a D/HOH kid. Plus, since he was not struggling with the academic content, he was able to work with some of the kids who were, and that helped both his self esteem and his own understanding of the subjects. There is no reason that a D/HOH child can't be placed into an inclusion class as one of the inclusion kids as well. Here in NY, there is a second teacher (Spec Ed) or aide in the room at all times to help the classified kids. She is the one to help as the kids if they're struggling, adjusts their workloads to meet their individual needs. It sounds like an inclusion class setting might be a good place for . The aide/SpecEd would not be sitting qt her elbow like a nursemaid, but working with many of the kids in the room when they needed help. Inclusion classrooms here have about 1/3 of the kids as classified (for a variety of reasons) and the rest of the kids are just plain old students. When Ian was in these classes, they were not " dumbed down " at all, simply run differently covering the same content. A very good setting for our D/HOH child to get the reinforcement he needed without having an aide assigned to him. Being in the inclusion room with the added Spec Ed support does NOT replace the services of a TOD. They should work together to address a D/HOH child's needs. Unfortunately, for us, that did not work well. The Spec Ed teacher disliked the very presence of a TOD and felt it was a personal criticism of her. She could/would not understand the need for a TOD yet she was not capable of addressing Ian's needs. It was an awkward situation. So while Ian did wonderfully in the inclusion room, he did not do well with SpecEd services. After Ian was transferred to a 504 plan, he continued to be placed in the inclusion class settings until the end of middle school and it worked beautifully for him. It was an appropriate LRE with just the right amount of support. Best -- Jill Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.