Guest guest Posted July 24, 2006 Report Share Posted July 24, 2006 Tony, there have been quite a few studies regarding the efficacy of inhaling the higher concentrations of salt and it has been proven with CF patients who have bronch and other bronch patients that using the saline (6 to 7% is common here ) will reduce the number of hospitalisations. During a recent hospitalisation I was inhaling it four times a day and that seemed to help get up the muck. If you google hypertonic and CF there is heaps of info.I think most people are incredulous that something so cheap and easy can do good...the drug cos.,of course are not promoting it. I have mine made up by the local chemist for less than $A2 for 500ml. I have heard that in Britain the little sachets of solution cost the health scheme 5 pounds each...value adding eh? Cheers Carole Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 25, 2006 Report Share Posted July 25, 2006 Thanks for that Carole! I only posted because of the similarity in the written form between .9% and 9%. I did emphasise that I did not know which was the correct concentration! I am also aware that homeopathy uses dilutions which are undetectable and they obviously work for some people - including Queen II of England! Whichever dilution salt is used in, my wife thinks it is the answer to a lot of problems. We live and learn! Tony hypertonic saline > Tony, there have been quite a few studies regarding the efficacy of > inhaling the higher concentrations of salt and it has been proven with > CF patients who have bronch and other bronch patients that using the > saline (6 to 7% is common here ) will reduce the number of > hospitalisations. During a recent hospitalisation I was inhaling it > four times a day and that seemed to help get up the muck. If you > google hypertonic and CF there is heaps of info.I think most people > are incredulous that something so cheap and easy can do good...the > drug cos.,of course are not promoting it. I have mine made up by the > local chemist for less than $A2 for 500ml. I have heard that in > Britain the little sachets of solution cost the health scheme 5 pounds > each...value adding eh? Cheers Carole > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 25, 2006 Report Share Posted July 25, 2006 Sandy when you say ORDINARY saline do you mean 'normal saline, the .9% dilution? I don't know who told you the hypertonic is dangerous in nebulizers (if I read you correctly?) but I have been nebbing the 7% solution under medical supervision for yonks and it is great. The only real concern is if you have reactive airways and it may cause spasms which is why they reccommend that it be taken under supervision for the first time or ventolin used before. I do not have a problem with this.-Cheers Carole- In bronchiectasis , " sandy taylor " wrote: > > Hypertonic saline is a much stronger not diluted saline,. > With nebulisers saline isn,t dangerous, but you must only use the ORDINARY > saline. > It is sometimes used in ventilators, but that must be under strict > supervision. > In nebs, 2-4 ml is the most common dose, and 2 for kids. > can be used 4 hrly( norm) but no harm done if the need to assist with > muccous break up, and assisting ventolin to do its work more easily. > Sandy > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 25, 2006 Report Share Posted July 25, 2006 Tony, good on your wife! As for the homeopathy, my theory as to why that works is that these people are healthy to begin with and 'time heals all wounds! " Someone once told me if I prayed I would not have bronch...yeah right!...I'll just get up off my calloused knees and go have a cough lol. Cheers Carole > > Thanks for that Carole! I only posted because of the similarity in the > written form between .9% and 9%. I did emphasise that I did not know which > was the correct concentration! I am also aware that homeopathy uses > dilutions which are undetectable and they obviously work for some people - > including Queen II of England! Whichever dilution salt is used > in, my wife thinks it is the answer to a lot of problems. We live and learn! > Tony > hypertonic saline > > > > Tony, there have been quite a few studies regarding the efficacy of > > inhaling the higher concentrations of salt and it has been proven with > > CF patients who have bronch and other bronch patients that using the > > saline (6 to 7% is common here ) will reduce the number of > > hospitalisations. During a recent hospitalisation I was inhaling it > > four times a day and that seemed to help get up the muck. If you > > google hypertonic and CF there is heaps of info.I think most people > > are incredulous that something so cheap and easy can do good...the > > drug cos.,of course are not promoting it. I have mine made up by the > > local chemist for less than $A2 for 500ml. I have heard that in > > Britain the little sachets of solution cost the health scheme 5 pounds > > each...value adding eh? Cheers Carole > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 25, 2006 Report Share Posted July 25, 2006 When I used hypertonic saline during a hospitalisation about 7 years ago it did give me a very sore throat and was hard on my lungs. I actually started to get worse. My doctor took me off it. I am aware that some of people with cystic fibrosis also ran into difficulties with hypertonic saline, as it was causing them chest problems. I have asthma; many with CF also have asthma and perhaps are lungs simply can not tolerate hypertonic saline due to asthma. I am sure it can help a majority of people with CF and bronchiectasis as studies have shown. As with most every treatment, it can cause problems for some. Hugs:0) --- Carole wrote: > Sandy when you say ORDINARY saline do you mean > 'normal saline, the .9% > dilution? I don't know who told you the hypertonic > is dangerous in > nebulizers (if I read you correctly?) e-mail:maryholt12@... or lungsformary@... Pre-Lung Transplant Journey - For updates please visit my carepage and leave a message. Thank you!:0) carepages.com name:maryelizabethholt ) " Miracles happen with love..... " ..... Please support your local children's hospital.... and " Give with all your might! " http://iwkfoundation.org/ )Visit.... Children's Miracle Network.... http://www.cmn.org/ ) " I don't give in, I don't give up, and I don't take no for an answer. " ~Doris ~ __________________________________________________ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 26, 2006 Report Share Posted July 26, 2006 Hello, This is from Los Angeles. I recently saw a doctor at UCLA who is much more receptive than my previous pulmonologist (which is great!). During the first visit she determined updated chest ct scan, pulm function study and sputum cultures were needed. I talked to her about the hypertonic saline and she said that the only thing it does is make you cough -- which is the point, right? Well, that and to clear the congestion. She ordered the hypertonic saline for me, but the pharamacy has yet to process the prescription. I need to follow-up. I just wanted to vent a little, because I hear good things in this Group about the hypertonic saline and would like to try it. But the response and lack of encouragement from my doctor about the saline took the wind out of my sails for a bit. I was both happy and disconcerted after seeing my doctor (recently had my 2nd visit). All my exercising is paying off (I try to get to the gym regularly and have recently taken up cycling). My pulmonary function study shows that my FEV1 volume HAS NOT diminished over the last 5 years! It would have been great to see actual improvement, but I didn't lose any ground, so I'm thankful for that. I hope everyone is doing well today. Kind regards, Tony Lundy wrote: Thanks for that Carole! I only posted because of the similarity in the written form between .9% and 9%. I did emphasise that I did not know which was the correct concentration! I am also aware that homeopathy uses dilutions which are undetectable and they obviously work for some people - including Queen II of England! Whichever dilution salt is used in, my wife thinks it is the answer to a lot of problems. We live and learn! Tony hypertonic saline> Tony, there have been quite a few studies regarding the efficacy of> inhaling the higher concentrations of salt and it has been proven with> CF patients who have bronch and other bronch patients that using the> saline (6 to 7% is common here ) will reduce the number of> hospitalisations. During a recent hospitalisation I was inhaling it> four times a day and that seemed to help get up the muck. If you> google hypertonic and CF there is heaps of info.I think most people> are incredulous that something so cheap and easy can do good...the> drug cos.,of course are not promoting it. I have mine made up by the> local chemist for less than $A2 for 500ml. I have heard that in> Britain the little sachets of solution cost the health scheme 5 pounds> each...value adding eh? Cheers Carole>>>>>>>> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 26, 2006 Report Share Posted July 26, 2006 Hi in Los Angeles, I hope that my post did not take the wind out of anyone's sales. Hypertonic saline was just not a good treatment for me, but can help others. Sometimes, I type without using my brain! I am sorry that you pulmonologist sounded a bit negative towards the saline. It is worthwhile to try. When possible first dose or two should be taken if possible in an outpatient clinic or doctor's office. The reason for this advice is it can trigger as asthma attack in some people. At least this was my experience. Everyone is different however and I agree with you that hypertonic saline is a worthwhile treatment. Many of my CF friends (on computer) have said it works well for them and helps clear their lungs. Your right, coughing and clearing our lungs so they don't build up secretions that lead to infections ... well, that's a very good thing. Sometimes doctors are negative towards various treatments or ideas, but it does not mean these treatments/ideas are a bad thing or useless. Its just that doctors can sometimes develop their hard-to-break-through attitudes; until they can see something work and prove it with their " own " set of tests, well you get the picture!) Congratulations on going to the gym and on your PFTs. Do try the saline. If I could use hypertonic saline, I would, because it is a big help to many people with bronch and CF. Interestingly, with all this talk of saline ... essentially salt water... I find ocean air can be helpful for my lungs. We often escape the heat permeating in the Valley by heading towards the shoreline. Cooler ocean air is much easier on my breathing. Best Wishes and Hugs:0) Liz in Nova Scotia, Canada e-mail:maryholt12@... or lungsformary@... Pre-Lung Transplant Journey - For updates please visit my carepage and leave a message. Thank you!:0) carepages.com name:maryelizabethholt ) " Miracles happen with love..... " ..... Please support your local children's hospital.... and " Give with all your might! " http://iwkfoundation.org/ )Visit.... Children's Miracle Network.... http://www.cmn.org/ ) " I don't give in, I don't give up, and I don't take no for an answer. " ~Doris ~ __________________________________________________ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 27, 2006 Report Share Posted July 27, 2006 Hi in Nova Scotia, Thank you for your message and encouragement. I was expressing (more like venting) about how I felt after seeing my doctor. To let you know I wasn't responding to anything you may have posted. Thanks again for your thoughts and I now need to follow-up with the pharmacy. Hope you're having a good day. in L.A. Holt wrote: Hi in Los Angeles,I hope that my post did not take the wind out ofanyone's sales. Hypertonic saline was just not a goodtreatment for me, but can help others. Sometimes, Itype without using my brain! I am sorry that youpulmonologist sounded a bit negative towards thesaline. It is worthwhile to try. When possible firstdose or two should be taken if possible in anoutpatient clinic or doctor's office. The reason forthis advice is it can trigger as asthma attack in somepeople. At least this was my experience. Everyone isdifferent however and I agree with you that hypertonicsaline is a worthwhile treatment. Many of my CFfriends (on computer) have said it works well for themand helps clear their lungs. Your right, coughing andclearing our lungs so they don't build up secretionsthat lead to infections ... well, that's a very goodthing.Sometimes doctors are negative towards varioustreatments or ideas, but it does not mean thesetreatments/ideas are a bad thing or useless. Its justthat doctors can sometimes develop theirhard-to-break-through attitudes; until they can seesomething work and prove it with their "own" set oftests, well you get the picture!)Congratulations on going to the gym and on your PFTs. Do try the saline. If I could use hypertonic saline, Iwould, because it is a big help to many people withbronch and CF. Interestingly, with all this talk ofsaline ... essentially salt water... I find ocean aircan be helpful for my lungs. We often escape the heatpermeating in the Valley by heading towards theshoreline. Cooler ocean air is much easier on mybreathing.Best Wishes and Hugs:0) Liz in Nova Scotia, Canadae-mail:maryholt12yahoo (DOT) ca or lungsformaryyahoo (DOT) caPre-Lung Transplant Journey - For updates please visit my carepage and leave a message. Thank you!:0)carepages.com name:maryelizabethholt:o) "Miracles happen with love....." ..... Please support your local children's hospital.... and "Give with all your might!" http://iwkfoundation.org/ )Visit.... Children's Miracle Network.... http://www.cmn.org/ )"I don't give in, I don't give up, and I don't take no for an answer."~Doris ~__________________________________________________ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 27, 2006 Report Share Posted July 27, 2006 Hi in LA, I posted a lot about saline on my website and have been getting a lot of positive feedback from people all over the world who are healthier by following the regime I recommend. Saline does a LOT MORE than make you cough. I remember when I was a kid bathing my grazed knees often in warm salt water to KILL THE GERMS as my mother often said. I does the same in the lungs, kills the bugs, stops the moulds, softens the mucus. After decades of western inhaled drugs, cortisone, antifungals like VFEND and Itraconizole, blood products (intragam), and hell knows what else, I am now free of everything except a daily dose of ventolin. This is mixed with saline and inhaled through my Omron NEU22 nebuliser which goes with me everywhere. I use saline in it and 'bathe' my lungs frequently. I have NOT HAD a chest infection in 2006. My peak flow has improved from, 325 to 475. I ride my bike 50 miles a week at least, and ballroom dance at least 10 hours. My website has more info http://www.muston.com/html/health.html Good luck on the beach in Australia. > Hi in Los Angeles, > > I hope that my post did not take the wind out of > anyone's sales. Hypertonic saline was just not a good > treatment for me, but can help others. Sometimes, I > type without using my brain! I am sorry that you > pulmonologist sounded a bit negative towards the > saline. It is worthwhile to try. When possible first > dose or two should be taken if possible in an > outpatient clinic or doctor's office. The reason for > this advice is it can trigger as asthma attack in some > people. At least this was my experience. Everyone is > different however and I agree with you that hypertonic > saline is a worthwhile treatment. Many of my CF > friends (on computer) have said it works well for them > and helps clear their lungs. Your right, coughing and > clearing our lungs so they don't build up secretions > that lead to infections ... well, that's a very good > thing. > > Sometimes doctors are negative towards various > treatments or ideas, but it does not mean these > treatments/ideas are a bad thing or useless. Its just > that doctors can sometimes develop their > hard-to-break-through attitudes; until they can see > something work and prove it with their " own " set of > tests, well you get the picture!) > > Congratulations on going to the gym and on your PFTs. > > Do try the saline. If I could use hypertonic saline, I > would, because it is a big help to many people with > bronch and CF. Interestingly, with all this talk of > saline ... essentially salt water... I find ocean air > can be helpful for my lungs. We often escape the heat > permeating in the Valley by heading towards the > shoreline. Cooler ocean air is much easier on my > breathing. > > Best Wishes and Hugs:0) > Liz in Nova Scotia, Canada > > e-mail:maryholt12@... or lungsformary@... > > Pre-Lung Transplant Journey - For updates please visit my carepage and leave a message. Thank you!:0) > carepages.com name:maryelizabethholt > > ) " Miracles happen with love..... " ..... Please support your local children's hospital.... and " Give with all your might! " > http://iwkfoundation.org/ > )Visit.... Children's Miracle Network.... http://www.cmn.org/ ) > > " I don't give in, I don't give up, and I don't take no for an answer. " > ~Doris ~ > > __________________________________________________ > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.